Press conference of the President of the Government after the European Council.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

16 June 2005 · European Council press conference

Context
Zapatero held a press conference following the June 2005 European Council, reporting on the EU Constitutional Treaty impasse and failed budget negotiations for 2007-2013.
Main themes
EU Constitutional Treaty ratification, Financial Perspectives 2007-2013, period of reflection on EU constitution, EU budget negotiations, Spain's national interests, Luxembourg Presidency, British Presidency, Common Agricultural Policy reform, European enlargement, French and Dutch referenda outcomes
Duration
~31 min
84th percentile
Words
3,762
84th percentile
Sentences
110
67th percentile
Readability
41
37th percentile
Grade
16.0
83rd percentile
Syntax
3.51
94th percentile
Vocabulary
1.99
9th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

110 sentences in 53 paragraphs

President.- I will report on the development of this European Council, which had, as you well know, two basic, more relevant points on the agenda: to analyze what happened after the referenda held in France and the Netherlands on the Constitutional Treaty and, secondly, to analyze and try to reach an agreement on the Financial Perspectives for the period 2007-2013, that is, on the Budget of the European Union.

In relation to the Constitutional Treaty, after a broad debate that took place yesterday, today the Council has adopted an agreement that can be summarized in three points: first, to ratify the willingness to advance in what it means and represents a European Union, taking into account that it faces an ambitious challenge, which is to establish a Constitutional Treaty, and in this process that has begun, ten countries have so far ratified the Constitutional Treaty and two countries have held referenda with a negative outcome.

Based on that circumstance, there is a consensus in the Council whereby it is established — and this is the second important consideration — a period of reflection, of broad debate, until June 2006, through which we seek to intensify the approach, the meaning, of what the project of the European Union and the Constitutional Treaty represent to the societies of the Union countries.

Thirdly, it is considered that the ratification process can and should continue based on the circumstances of each country, as logically it could not be otherwise.

We have convened to conduct a new analysis in the first half of 2006, as I mentioned earlier, to evaluate the moment in which the European Constitutional Treaty will find itself, where, without a doubt, there will be new ratification processes, new decisions, and therefore, the corresponding evaluation.

All of this necessarily entails a process of extending the timeline we had set for the European Constitutional Treaty; but the will of the Council, expressed in these terms and based on the circumstances experienced after the referenda in France and the Netherlands, is a will for Europe to equip itself with the Constitutional Treaty.

Secondly, as you know, the Council also had on the agenda the attempt to reach an agreement on the Financial Perspectives, on the Union's Budget for the period 2007-2013. That agreement has not been possible. Despite multiple efforts and despite the prior work carried out by the Luxembourg Presidency, the necessary and sufficient consensus to decide the Union's Budgets from 2007 to 2013 has not been found.

We have to try again, as is logical; we have time and we must have the sufficient will so that, in the necessary time, the Financial Perspectives for 2007 to 2013 can maintain the functioning and spirit of the Union, of enlargement, and of the policies that European societies require.

I want to tell you that Spain has maintained a constructive attitude and a defense of national interest, of defending the interests of our country. That position, which has always been and is open to dialogue, has led us not to support the last proposal made by the Presidency of the Council; not to support it, but at the same time to express our willingness to maintain the negotiating and dialogue position.

You know that there has been in that proposal some specific consideration for our country and I want to thank all the effort of work that has been done in the negotiating process by all the people from the Presidency of the Council, the Government of Spain, and the Spanish delegation in the European Union.

You know that this last proposal has also not received the support of various countries and that there has been a parallel debate throughout the process regarding the Financial Perspectives on the need, expressed by several members of the Union, to propose a reform of the structure of expenditure, a reform of the philosophy, of the principles, and therefore, of the composition of expenditure. That reform, perhaps necessary in the future, is still very premature to propose today based on what are the agreements we have maintained so far, which are still in force, in some very important aspects, such as the Common Agricultural Policy, and in other determining elements of the composition of expenditure. Spain believes that in the future it will be possible to address a reform but that today it is premature.

Now the new Presidency, the British Presidency, has the task of trying to reach an agreement on the Financial Perspectives. We hope and wish that it succeeds in this task. On the part of the Government of Spain, we will continue to maintain the two principles that I have just outlined: constructive will and defense of the interests of our country.

Q.- Mr. President, I wanted to know if, in your opinion, European leaders have realized that after the failure to reach an agreement on the Financial Perspectives, the image we can convey to citizens is of the most selfish face of the European Union.

President.- Europe is built with, at this moment, twenty-five countries and at this moment we had before us an agenda as important as the Financial Perspectives for seven years, 2007-2013, and it could not be done at the first attempt. I want to remind you that the Constitutional Treaty also went through an intense process. It was not at the first attempt; an agreement was reached at the second, and now we have difficulties in the ratification process, although I hope it will be overcome.

As is easy to understand, this was also the first Financial Perspective that addressed a Europe of twenty-five. In my opinion, without a doubt, this has been the essential problem: that it was the first time we had to address a new reality, a very different reality, in the shaping and distribution of the Budget of the European Union.

But the European Union has the strength and institutional solidity to call again, as is planned, because we have, I insist, time ahead — I want to remind you that the Perspectives come into force from 2007 to 2013 — to reach an agreement.

Q.- I wanted to ask you, Mr. President, after not reaching an agreement on the first attempt, what this could mean for Spain, considering that our country, due to the so-called statistical effect, with each passing month or year we will be more disadvantaged, because we will be richer.

President.- The truth is that we have very positive economic growth, not so much that each month that passes produces a change in the statistical rules. I believe we have a reasonable time ahead so that the parameters we know today, which mark a very different evolution from that of the year 2000, when the last Perspectives were approved, do not affect what they can represent for the interests of our country, which, I insist, we will defend with constructive will and, without a doubt, it will be easier to conclude an agreement if the general climate is one of consensus. I can state, and it will surely be stated in the different press conferences — I have just expressed that there have been several countries that have not supported the last proposal of the Presidency — that the general climate was not of the minimum necessary consensus and perhaps the method of approaching the negotiation can be decisive.

In my opinion, I believe that the method has to improve, can improve, and must improve; the method and a capacity to incorporate many of the elements that have been present in the debate on what can be, even, the most favorable position to have greater spending on Research, Development, and Innovation, a position that, of course, our country can subscribe to at some point if in that philosophy it also incorporates what is a policy or a spirit of cohesion.

Q.- President, after all we have heard these days about the great willingness, the proximity of an agreement, that we were very close to an agreement, about how successive proposals were well received, this last-minute change — last-minute change because at nine-thirty the language we were hearing was not the same — of reaching the rejection of the proposal has certainly caused me some surprise.

So, what I would ask you or wonder is whether there are really objective reasons inherent to the negotiation for us to end up siding with the United Kingdom, which has completely different positions regarding the conception of the budgetary model and of the richer countries, or if internal political reasons have also influenced, especially to protect the Government from any criticism that it has not sufficiently defended the interests.

President.- My task is to protect the country. Spain has, indeed, today a situation characterized by a process of economic growth, a notable increase in per capita income, which entails a significant change in our role in the European Union. I have made this explicit on many occasions and, of course, it is a role that we will gradually adopt. We have received a lot and in this horizon of 2007-2013 we will receive less, because we are much richer; but that process must have a minimum graduality and, above all, it must respond to the expectations and needs of our country in those areas where we still need a clearer effort of cohesion and advancement, which is Research, Development, and Innovation.

I have just mentioned that the method also influences and I sincerely believe that, beyond the fact that I have noted that there was some irreducible position that would not allow consensus with the starting positions of some countries, the method, in my opinion, must also change in the negotiation to reach a consensus and an agreement, nothing more and nothing less, than the Financial Perspectives.

But, when several countries have not been in that position of consensus, for different reasons, undoubtedly, something has failed; something has failed. And I reiterate that my constructive position has been until the last hour, until the last hour of the session that the Council has just held and, of course, it remains from today in the new attempt that the British Presidency must make.

Q.- I would like to know what method you would consider most appropriate for carrying out this negotiation and also to specify a little what the elements are that have led Spain to reject this last proposal from the Presidency, considering that, apparently, it offered four years in the collection of the Cohesion Funds.

President.- Indeed, the effort that was made by the proposal of four years of the Cohesion Fund, to maintain it for a significant amount, is not only what represents the whole of what we call the Financial Perspectives; we must also evaluate the payments that each country must make based on how the negotiation was going with other countries. From that perspective, from the point of view of the reduction of the leap we inevitably have to take in terms of loss of funds, it was, from my point of view, excessive. Therefore, I believed and believe that this proposal was not reasonable within, I insist, the effort that the Government of my country is willing to make.

Therefore, the proposal must be analyzed as a whole, taking into account the contributions that each country must make and the contributions to the Funds it receives.

In addition, secondly, as I mentioned earlier, there is an important factor for us, which is the need to introduce some element that facilitates cohesion in those expenditure items related to Research, Development, and Innovation. We will continue to work, logically, towards those objectives.

What method? We have been several weeks in the process of dialogue and negotiation, and I believe that during that time there should have been a more reliable acknowledgment by the Presidency of what the clear, firm positions of the different countries were, because surely more progress could have been made in the work we have developed.

Q.- President, you have mentioned several countries. Without seeking to assign blame or responsibility, I would like to know, when looking for an explanation for this lack of agreement, if you believe it can be associated with some countries and even some leaders, because I suppose the personal factor has been quite important in the negotiation.

President.- I have been President of the Government for a year and two months, I have already had several European Councils where important negotiation processes have taken place (European Constitutional Treaty, Stability Pact, and now Financial Perspectives) and I can assure you that the circumstances do not resemble each other and that the positions of some leaders or some countries do not normally respond to pre-established parameters, but depend on the positions that each country or each political leader may have based on their conception of a Constitutional Treaty or, in this case, of the Financial Perspectives. Therefore, there are times when the coincidences of some countries with others are not the same as in another subsequent debate.

It is true that this is one of the most complicated debates and one of the most difficult decisions there is, and on this occasion it was especially complicated, because we had to adopt the Budget for 2007 to 2013 with twenty-five countries and with many countries making an effort to finance what is known as enlargement, as we usually say. I believe that this will require the broadest reflection period we have been able to have leading up to this European Council, and surely the debate we have had this evening, already with the lack of agreement on the table and in everyone's mind, can be useful to shed light on the way to reach an agreement, which I wish and hope will happen as soon as possible.

Q.- Mr. President, you mentioned that one of the main problems for the Spanish position was the contribution -- I presume that Spain was being asked for a much greater contribution than you intended -- and also that the funds being allocated for R&D&I were insufficient. I would like to know if you could specify more about what was being asked of Spain and how much the European Union was willing to grant Spain in that regard.

On the other hand, regarding the reform of the Common Agricultural Policy, I would like to know your assessment of why France did not stand in solidarity with Spain on this issue, which also affects the French.

President.- France and Spain, on the issue of the reform of the Common Agricultural Policy, have maintained a coinciding position. We believe that this is not the time for a reform of the Common Agricultural Policy. I want to remind you that the Common Agricultural Policy is one of the policies that provides the most funds to Spain, and we are one of the countries that receives the most aid based on the Common Agricultural Policy.

In a negotiation process, establishing unmovable, fixed, or stable figures does not seem to me to be an appropriate response at this moment. It has to be seen as a whole: a whole of the effort that all countries are willing to make and a whole of considerations around the amount, without a doubt. You already know that we had a goal, and that goal is to have a net balance, that is, to receive aid until 2013, and that we had a clear objective at the same time: that the reduction of aid be as progressive as possible and, likewise, to propose an increase, a special consideration, regarding Research, Development, and Innovation.

The proposal ultimately put forward by the Presidency did not respond to a satisfactory overall framework. I expressed, even at the last Council meeting, that I was willing to continue dialoguing. There were other countries that did not, that said that time was up. Spain was willing to continue dialoguing; but some other countries were in favor of ending today with the scenario you already know: with the lack of agreement, the lack of consensus, and therefore, the call for a next time in search of that agreement.

Q.- You previously said that we still have time for economic parameters not to affect Spanish interests. When will those economic parameters start to affect Spain's interests?

On the other hand, I believe that the text agreed upon by the Council on the Constitution makes no reference to the fact that the text of the Treaty is non-negotiable. I would like you to confirm that point and to know Spain's opinion.

President.- Regarding the second question, I will tell you that the clear will is that the Constitutional Treaty is the one we have, the one ratified by ten countries, and the one we want to be ratified in the terms required and provided for by the annex of the Declaration. There was not a single voice from any country that spoke of a possibility of reforming the Treaty.

Regarding the first point, it is true that lately I have had some inclination to make forecasts about the evolution of economic data; but I sincerely believe that we cannot make a prediction of when the growth of our country and the growth of per capita income in some regions may reach the limits that would imply moving from one situation to another. But it does not seem to be a horizon in the immediate future.

Q.- Mr. President, you mentioned that one of the elements that motivated Spain's rejection of the Presidency's proposal was that the reduction of the net balance was excessive. I wanted to know if the last effort of the new European partners to accept a cut in their aid could have helped improve the position of Spain and the other countries that rejected the final offer.

President.- Yes; in my case, yes. In the case of Spain, yes. The attitude of those countries, without a doubt, as I explained a moment ago, facilitated my expression of willingness to continue dialoguing and negotiating from the meeting of the Council we had this evening. It has been done on other occasions. But, I insist, there were some countries that said that time was up. They did not open any door to that possibility. Spain did open it and we considered that an effort could have been made, that the effort would have been interesting.

In the case of Spain, I believe that with more negotiation time we could have had a reasonable scenario. But we all have to be aware, absolutely all of us, that there were a number of countries that I believe it was practically impossible, from the first minute to the last, to reach an agreement on this Financial Perspectives scheme.

Q.- The President of the Council, who is a man with a certain charm, has just said that he is going to Canada and the United States to explain to President Bush the vigor and strength of Europe. I would like to ask you for a broader reflection. You say that something has failed in this Council. I believe that many things have been failing for some time in this Europe. What credibility, what exciting element, can this Europe have, unable to reach a clear agreement on its Constitutional Treaty and unable to reach an agreement on the budgetary aspect, in the Financial Perspectives?

On the other hand, Mr. President, how can the immediate future of Europe be affected, given that it seems very clear in this Council that there are two models, one more market-oriented and the other more social, the weakness of the Franco-German axis? How can that weakness affect the immediate future of Europe and your internal position in Spain?

President.- I believe we need to have a bit of perspective. Whenever we are on a day when an important issue does not reach an agreement in the European Union, it seems that we have an almost unsolvable problem ahead of us. Let us put things in perspective in the process of the European Union, both in the agreements on the Treaties and in the agreements on the budgets or Financial Perspectives.

There have been moments of greater ease in reaching consensus and moments of less ease in reaching consensus; but the journey has been extraordinarily positive up to this point, extraordinarily positive, not only because Europe has lived in peace and economic union, which has facilitated growth for all countries and employment for the vast majority of countries. And now we have a new European reality, which is a Europe of twenty-five, and that takes time to forge. I believe we need to have that vision as a main element.

If you allow me, I believe that at the heart of the problems in the Constitutional Treaty and the problems in these Financial Perspectives is that process of construction, of definitive advancement, of what is a Europe of twenty-five, a Europe of practically twenty-seven, with Romania and Bulgaria.

Just as if at the next Council meeting we reach an agreement on Financial Perspectives, it would not be fair to headline "Europe is reborn" or "Europe shines." Let us put things in their proper terms and with perspective.

I insist, the balance is very positive and it is true that Juncker's sharpness has led him to make that reflection, especially considering the meetings he has tomorrow. But the reflection I have already made on some occasions I reiterate today: Europe is peace, freedom, and democracy. It must be increasingly an economic engine, a motor of economic growth and employment, and we continue to observe something that is significant in itself: many countries want to be part of the European Union and within the European Union, of course, everyone wants to continue and, of course, as is the case in a democratic and logical environment, there are different ideological positions on the future and on the economic and social model of the European Union.

I do not believe that this debate is negative; undoubtedly, it will be an enriching debate. And at this moment, regarding the economic perspective, in my opinion, it must be necessary, because Europe as a whole must and can grow more economically, Europe must create more jobs, and Europe must be much stronger in its technological and innovation potential. Spain today grows more than the European average, creates much more employment than the European average; but we want and it is in our interest that the entire European Union grows more and creates more jobs.

Thank you very much.