Press conference of the President of the Government after his meeting with Lehendakari Ibarretxe.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

15 October 2007 · Press conference after meeting with Lehendakari Ibarretxe

Context
Zapatero held a press conference on 15 October 2007 after meeting Basque President Ibarretxe to reject his proposed popular consultation as unconstitutional.
Main themes
Constitutional legality, Basque self-determination, Ibarretxe Plan, popular consultations and referendums, state authority, Basque political plurality, combating political violence, Socialist Party position, institutional dialogue, autonomous community competencies
Duration
~19 min
64th percentile
Words
2,298
64th percentile
Sentences
84
54th percentile
Readability
51
66th percentile
Grade
12.8
54th percentile
Syntax
3.45
92nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
41st percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

84 sentences in 39 paragraphs

President.- I wanted to provide you with information about the development of the meeting I held with the Lehendakari, after having listened to him attentively and after having conveyed what the principles and opinions are regarding the proposal he made in the Basque Parliament and which he explained to me today in the meeting we just had.

I told the Basque Lehendakari that political proposals, whatever their nature, in this country, in Spain, only have one path, which is that of legality and the Constitution. Therefore, I made it very clear to him that any popular consultation in this country can only be initiated or authorized by the State, through the Government or through the Cortes Generales. That is what our legal framework dictates. Consequently, I reminded him of the competencies that a Lehendakari, an autonomous President, has, and the competencies that the Government of Spain, the State bodies, have; in his case, the Cortes Generales.

At its core, I have the impression that we are facing a kind of second part, with different characteristics, of what was the Ibarretxe Plan-1. It is a reconstructed second part, and I must reiterate that the fate of this second part will be the same as that of the Ibarretxe Plan-1, that is, it will not be accepted, approved, or implemented.

From there, I emphasized to the Lehendakari that the fundamental objective of democracy, of citizenship, of Basque society, of the entire Spanish society, and of the political forces is, without a doubt, to combat and eradicate violence and terror, and, furthermore, to seek the best understanding among the political forces in Euskadi; an understanding that, by the very nature of Basque society, requires that it be an understanding from the plurality of the different options that exist in the Basque Country; that this is the path that must be taken; that on this path, the attitude, as always, of collaboration from the Socialist Party of Euskadi will be present, but that, evidently, on the path of attempting a route that has no legal foundation and that does not have, moreover, a minimum basic political backing to attempt to change anything, it will have the opposition of the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party and the Socialist Party of Euskadi.

This is the summary. I believe that, as things are very clear, I do not need to elaborate further, and I can, of course, answer your questions.

Q.- President, the Lehendakari has just said, regarding what you said about legality, that his proposal is legal because it fits within the Constitution, because Article 149 refers to referendums, not consultations. That on one side.

On the other hand, he said that, whether people like it or not, his proposal has the majority of the Basque Parliament and, therefore, he rejected the two arguments you provided just yesterday.

He has also asked for respect even for his person. He criticized that he has sometimes been slighted, in some way, regarding his proposal.

President.- Respect always, just like the institutional dialogue that must take place and just like the political dialogue; but each one in the position they hold. Mine is very clear, very firm, and very determined.

I must say, to reiterate once again, that the so-called popular consultations by way of referendum that our legal framework contemplates must always be authorized by the State, through the Government. This is the case at the local level and in all instances, regardless of the linkage or legal value they may have. And apart from that, we have all the instruments of direct participation: the referendum contemplated in the Constitution, consultative, in Article 92; the referendum for the reform of the Constitution or the referendum for the ratification of Statutes and, in its day, for the impetus of the birth of Autonomous Communities.

But that is the principle. It is as clear as water, and it must be clear that no type of consultation can be called, even if it does not have, I insist, or did not have binding value. Therefore, what cannot be done, will not be done, and will not happen.

Q.- You still had the question about the majority of the Parliament pending.

President.- Yes, it is true that it is a majority of the Parliament, but it is true that it is a narrow majority. Given the social composition and the plurality of identities in the Basque Country, everything advises that this majority should be a transversal, broad majority that includes the different sensitivities that coexist around identity in the Basque Country.

Q.- President, Mr. Ibarretxe has made it clear that for him today's meeting is the opening of a process. We do not know exactly what process it is. Do you share that vision or do you think this meeting is the first and last?

President.- The truth is that I am not surprised that he states that, because he has been talking about the same thing since 2001. Therefore, we are already in the seventh year, and I do not know if he will have the will and tenacity to remain in the same position for more years.

I reiterate it, I have always reiterated it, and today also to all the Basque political forces: the Government I preside over is always willing to dialogue, but here there is only one path, which is that of legality and the Constitution. Therefore, any modification of self-government only has one route, which is the reform of the current Statute, in this case, called the Statute of Guernica, which, by the way, has been an enormously positive experience for self-government, for the economic development of Euskadi, and for the recognition of the identity that the Basque people have.

Q.- President, there are two things that the Lehendakari has also said that I wanted to have your opinion on. First, he said that if the Government has spoken with ETA and with Batasuna about these issues, why not speak with him.

Secondly, he also used the Catalonia Statute as a precedent, which does not require, regarding popular consultations, that the authorization of the central Government be necessary.

Finally, I would like to ask you, once the meeting today has taken place and you have told him "no," based on what you have told us, if you can now tell the citizens what the Government will do if the Lehendakari continues forward, as he just said a moment ago.

President.- I reiterate what represents constitutional doctrine, legality, which is unequivocal: popular consultations by way of referendum, at the local level or at the autonomous level, require authorization, therefore the will, of the State, acceptance through the Government and, in the case of a consultative referendum, with the authorization also of the Cortes Generales, which, logically, is an instrument that has been used on more than one occasion for popular consultations, for referendums that have a general character.

Secondly, I am not going to enter into any of the assessments he has made about the difficult and hard task of seeking the end of violence in the peace process. I say this because I usually do not like to enter into assessments that simply represent a nonsense. I simply reiterate that, in the face of any proposal in this country from an autonomous President, from a Lehendakari, whom I respect, or from any other institution or any other body, only the Constitution and legality can be applied. That is the only possible path. Everything else will have the same fate that the proposal he has been making for seven years has had, in my opinion, now reformulated. I believe that experience should already serve for something.

I hope that over time there will be reflection, dialogue, and understanding that in democracy there is only one path, which is legality, respect for the Constitution, for the norms, for the rules of the game; furthermore, a path that is advisable to travel with broad consensus.

Q.- President, if Mr. Ibarretxe does not reflect, as you say, over time, do you have a plan B or...?

President.- I simply have the strength to evoke what has happened up to this point. I insist, this has been going on since the year 2000 and has been formulated in 2001, 2003, and in 2005, when we had another moment of debate in Parliament. In democracy, things are like this: the force of the Law, the force of reason, the force of Law, and the force of the rules of the game always prevail; always. It is true that one can persist in proposals that have no open path or possibility of opening, but they also have the possibility of rectifying and changing. And that is what, logically, I would like to happen and that, of course, the Basque political forces also participate in, seeking the maximum possible consensus.

Q.- Ibarretxe has said that for his part he does not consider this issue settled in any way, and you have spoken to him about legality. Is Ibarretxe listening to you? Do you think Ibarretxe listens to you in the meetings you have already had?

President.- I can assure you that yes, with interest and respect. I have done so since the first day I became President of the Government. I have had several meetings with Lehendakari Ibarretxe and have maintained an institutional relationship of respect and collaboration with the Basque Government, which has translated into important agreements. Certainly, from the Government I preside over, that attitude remains, but when we disagree, as is the case with this proposal, we disagree. We disagreed when the Ibarretxe Plan, when the Political Statute, and what happens in democracy happened: we dialogue, we debate, and we vote by those who have the competencies to vote and decide. It is that simple.

Therefore, yes, of course I listen to him, and moreover with interest, because I believe it is my duty, and, of course, because I always seek to have more areas of agreement than of dissent or confrontation.

Q.- But does Ibarretxe listen to you?

President.- I believe so.

Q.- You said yesterday that you were not very clear about what Ibarretxe intended to ask the Basque people. I wanted to know if today you have clarified that a bit more.

Aside from this and aside from the referendum that Mr. Ibarretxe proposes, I wanted to know if, in your opinion, there is anything to negotiate between the President of the Government and the Lehendakari.

President.- There are always things to negotiate, and, moreover, with the autonomy regime of the Basque Country, there are some singular ones that are of great importance, which we have negotiated, by the way, recently, such as the renewal of the Cupo, and, of course, everything that affects self-government, the area of institutional cooperation, which is an area of work that, of course, affects and matters a lot to the citizens of Euskadi, but also to all citizens of this country and to the institutions.

I have listened to him attentively, especially regarding what could be an iter or a path he has developed. I have also listened to him, because he summarized it in the press conference, regarding what would be the plenary session in June in the Basque Parliament, the hypothetical consultation in October, then a negotiation process and a referendum in 2010. I understand that it can be difficult at times, because it is complex. It is complex, it is long, and in that sense, honestly, I believe we need more time for... The Lehendakari needs a little time for reflection and dialogue, and of course, in that task, I will continue to be committed, because I believe it is also useful in democracy.

Q.- I have listened to you today, and I do not believe, and this is not the first time, to evoke the example of the first Ibarretxe Plan as it was halted in the Cortes Generales, in Congress. However, the formula that the Lehendakari proposes this time evades the Spanish Parliament. I would like to know if you believe that the response to that initiative from Mr. Ibarretxe should also be given by the Cortes, specifically the Congress of Deputies.

President.- I see that the question highlights the complexity that this new version of the Ibarretxe Plan entails, because, indeed, if that consultation were to take place, the agreement would logically have to go through Parliament, because we would be talking about a Political Statute or a new Statute in the version we already know from the first Ibarretxe Plan.

Therefore, it does not seek to evade anything, because I can assure you that in democracy no one evades the Law. In the Rule of Law, no one evades the Law. It may be formulated in one way, reformulated, but no one is going to evade it, neither the Law, nor the Constitution, nor what the rules of the game mean.

I believe that this is a principle that has prevailed, as could not be otherwise, in these twenty-five years and that will continue to mark, governing, our collective life and our relationship as a State and its linkages or relationships with the Autonomous Communities.

I have invited Lehendakari Ibarretxe to dialogue with the Basque political forces and to ensure that any proposal he wishes to present in the Basque Parliament or before the entire State institutions is a proposal that has the straight path, the path of legality, the path of constitutionality, and, of course, that has the broadest possible consensus. And the Lehendakari knows very well that this Government has always had a principle open to dialogue. The limit of dialogue is clear: it is respect for the Constitution, for the Law, and for the Rule of Law.

Thank you very much.