- Context
- Zapatero addressed the ABC-Deloitte-Vocento Forum in Spain in October 2007, reviewing his government's legislative record ahead of upcoming general elections.
- Main themes
- Economic growth and prosperity, job creation, gender equality in employment, Spain's global standing, democratic strengthening, legislature achievements, social rights and opportunities, per capita income convergence with EU, Spain's political trajectory
- Duration
- ~121 min
- Words
- 14,534
- Sentences
- 451
- Readability
- 43
- Grade
- 15.1
- Syntax
- 3.37
- Vocabulary
- 2.05
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other451 sentences in 210 paragraphs
I would like to thank ABC, Deloitte and Vocento for their invitation to share these moments with you, to be given the chance to express my ideas and to attend the debate that I think is going to be stimulating. Besides, I feel that Mr. Jose Antonio Zarzalejos wants to step in. I think that in fact that one is going to be the most interesting part this afternoon.
It is in order to express my gratitude that I would like to remind you of something that has already been mentioned before, during the initial interventions. This is the second time that I attend this Forum as President of the Government. I did it five months after having been invested as President of the Government and I am doing it now, five months before the general elections; today, exactly the same day that I was invested President of the Government three years ago.
While I was in the opposition I also attended this Forum twice, as leader of the opposition and, thus, it seems that destiny has made a rule out of it and attending this Forum, at least twice each Legislature, has become a sort of compromise for me with ABC. I attended it twice as leader of the opposition and I have attended it twice as President of the Government and I am committed, dear Jose Antonio, to be here again in the next Legislature, twice, as President of the Government.
I would like to start by reviewing the meaning of this Legislature - if we can have a look at it from a distance - of this political period, for Spain; starting with the objectives of the investiture in the electoral programme, which I will refer to very briefly and which represented the essence of a political project of change towards a better Spain and with which I asked citizens to vote for me. Five lines had to do with prosperity, in the first place; in the second place, with the extension of rights and opportunities and with the advances towards equality among the Spanish citizens, especially among men and women; the third point supported a stronger democracy; the fourth one was a priority towards the preparation of the future of Spain and the fifth one represented the position of Spain in the world, the intention to be respected by the great powers and to be appreciated by the emerging countries and by the weakest ones, as this is the most convenient position for Spain, from the historical and from the political, economical and cultural points of view.
Thus, I will start by briefly mentioning the implications of the creation of richness and of Spanish economy during this period, from the point of view of prosperity.
By this time, it must be an undeniable fact that we are living, that we have been living a period of great economic growth since 2004. This is a fact, to such an extent that our country can claim for the first time that: in the last few years we have grown more than the seven biggest industrial powers in the world; we have grown more than the United States, Japan, Italy, Canada, France, Germany and the United Kingdom during this Legislature. This has made it possible for us to augment our real richness in 265,000 million Euros, which is as if in three years and something we had achieved or incorporated Denmark - that is, the Gross Domestic Product of Denmark - to our country, economically speaking.
We are now the eighth economic world power and we have increased our per capita income. Thus, we have almost attained the per capita income of the European Union; we are in a good condition, for the first time ever since the beginning of our democracy, to surpass the per capita income of one of the strongest countries, a friend, which I hope will be a good competitor as well: Italy; and with regards to other great parameters concerning the economic evolution of the prosperity of a country, we have also achieved some results -and let me say this modestly but with satisfaction-which may be defined as outstanding, for a country that is among the eight big powers and that has created more jobs in the last three and a half years is an outstanding country.
We have created more jobs than any other country, more than the United States, Japan, Germany, Italy, France and the United Kingdom, and we are going to create one million more jobs than the amount demanded by the leader of the opposition during the investiture debate, when he said that Spain should, at least, generate two million jobs. Well, by the end of the Legislature there will be three million new jobs.
Thus, this Legislature will be, mainly, the Legislature of employment, of work. During this period, it has been the Spanish workers who have obtained more benefits as, in fact, they are the ones that guarantee our future; besides, work has become each time more balanced and has acquired each time more potential for stability. More balanced because more than 50 per cent of the jobs created during this Legislature are carried out by women, they have been created for women and, as a consequence of the social agreements established with the businessmen and the unions, the high percentage of temporary jobs in our country has been brought to a halt and has started to diminish: since the labour agreement was signed, nearly one million jobs that used to be temporary jobs have become stable jobs.
To sum up, a unique economic growth as compared to any of the big powers during this period: 3.6 per cent in 2005; 3.9 per cent in 2006 and we hope to finish this year near 3.8 per cent too; more job creation than any of the big powers and, what's even more important, because this influences directly the management of public accounts, as this is the balance that we are going to present Spanish citizens with: we have supported budgetary stability as an essential element of our economic policy and we have supported the reorientation of public expenditure. At the same time, we have dealt with historical problems in the public sector and we have fulfilled our compromise to reduce the Income Tax and the Corporate Income Tax.
I have the satisfaction to be the President of the first Government of Spain that ever since the beginning of our democracy has achieved a surplus in the public accounts and, besides, this has been done during each and every single financial year in which we have had to present the budgets at the Parliament for them to be approved of.
I would like to point out that we are the only great country with a biggest surplus in its public accounts. I would like to remind you of the fact that in 2006 our surplus reached 1.8 per cent of the Gross Domestic Product and that we intend to finish 2007 with a similar surplus.
Therefore, budgetary stability is a sign of identity of our governing system and it reflects the efficiency, austerity and success of the reorientation of public expenditure. We have reorientated public expenditure. The figures show where our efforts have concentrated, in terms of the investment priorities for our country for, whereas the general expenditure corresponding to the General State Budget and, in particular, to the General State Administration, have augmented 26 per cent during this period; the productive expenditure leads the increase of the expenditure. The productive expenditure of Research plus Development plus Innovation has increased 137 per cent.
I would just like to give this data, not in terms of percentages, but in real terms: when we entered the Government, the expenditure, the investment in R+D+i amounted to 2,900 million Euros; the budget for 2008 increases these figures to 6,700 million Euros. This represents a real technological revolution in our Research plus Development plus Innovation system, which is the essential factor that is changing the evolution of productivity in our country; a country that has started to grow in a very favourable way and that, given the strong investment in equipment goods during the last few years, represents a guarantee of economic growth for the future.
The second great priority as far as expenditure reorientation is concerned has been the human capital, the education. We have applied an increase of 63 per cent in those things that depend on the Central Government, which has been mainly devoted to children education, grants and support during the Obligatory Secondary Education in order to fight school failure or school abandonment, which has already started to diminish. We have already reduced the rate in two points - and I am talking of Spain in general - and this is an essential purpose for our country: increasing the percentage of young people with an education degree apart from the one obtained after the obligatory education period. It is there that we are risking, to a great extent, the competitiveness and capacity of our economy taking the future into account.
Infrastructures are the third section of the expenditure items that have experienced a greater increase during this period. This is making it possible for us to undertake an ambitious Strategic Plan concerning Transport Infrastructures, a plan that is a novelty in this country for two main reasons: firstly, because it focuses on railways for the first time in many years, in almost one century; as part of public investment on Transport infrastructure, more than 40 per cent of the Plan and of the investments have been devoted to railways, especially in the case of High Speed Rails; and, secondly, because it surpasses the traditional condition of infrastructures in our country, which has implied a radial conception, and emphasizes a network conception in order to link all the points of the territory and favour economy beyond the meaning of a radial conception.
I would like to give you one piece of data, which I keep repeating but which shows, quite clearly, the evolution of this country: in less than three years we are going to be the country with more kilometres of High Speed Rails in the world; in less than three years we are going to be the country with more kilometres of double carriageway in Europe and we are going to have the country with the best transport and communication infrastructures as compared to the other great powers.
Thus, the determining factor for the economic growth, in my opinion, is the calm horizon in front of us.
The Spanish economy has become a reference, employment creation has become a reference and the public account management has become a reference. Thus, I think that we may feel satisfied. Businessmen and the unions have contributed to this decisively. Businessmen in this country are good entrepreneurs, innovative and surprising in many sectors around the world due to their technological capacity and to the way they do things in sectors such as construction, in sectors such as energy, in the automotive sector and in many others; each time with a higher technological value and, therefore, with a higher added value. The best proof for this is that, during 2006, we were the third country in the Organisation for Economy Cooperation and Development with more investments abroad, which shows in the fact that we are being awarded the tenders in areas that demand such a high technological level.
Just consider the significance of changes: we took up IZAR, the public shipyard company, in bankruptcy, with great debts because it had been very badly managed, and now Navantia is about to produce benefits, with guaranteed contracts from now to 2015; besides, Navantia has also been adjudged in Australia one of the most important contracts for the construction of vessels and frigates in the last few years, which guarantees the future stability of a company that has undergone so many historical difficulties. And I feel very glad about Ferrol and Cadiz.
That is the objective scenario. I was saying that I would like to thank both businessmen and unions because, to a great extent, these achievements are due to their responsible, committed attitude.
This has been a Legislature of social peace. There have been less strikes in this Legislature than ever since the beginning of our democracy, with the establishment of twenty social agreements between businessmen, unions and the Government, as, for instance, the agreement concerning employment, or the agreement concerning the reform of the Social Security system, in order to guarantee the sustainability of pensions in the future and many other agreements.
This reform of the Social Security system has complemented the management policy in the area of public accounts, which is so transcendental; and it throws an outstanding balance, for our Social Security Reserve Fund will have increased from 15,000 million Euros - when we entered the Government - to 52,000 million Euros in 2008, by the end of the Legislature. And all that, as you know, in a time in which a great effort has been made in order to augment the minimum pensions of three million pension holders whose pensions are still low in our country.
Thus, our economic growth has not been matched by any of the great countries; our employment creation rates have not been matched by the rates of any of the great countries; we have achieved a surplus in public accounts and we have reduced the debt - which, by the way, I had not mentioned yet - from 46 per cent of the Gross Domestic Product to 35 per cent of the Gross Domestic Product, which is what we intend to achieve, guaranteeing financing in the future, establishing a horizon of tax reduction as the most favourable element in our economy; and all this in a frame of tax reduction and social peace.
Just let me refer to the convenience of feeling proud about this. And, since patriotism is trendy lately, I would like to say that we can be proud of our economic, social and labour patriotism. I also think that the best way to build our country, to build Spain, to structure it, to strengthen and enrich it is to create more jobs and establish more rights for the families.
Rights. A liberal, progressist vision of society, which I mentioned during the electoral campaign and during the investiture speech, demands the establishment of a new frame for civil rights, for individual freedom. To sum up, one of the main assets of democratic societies is defined by the spread of rights and public freedom: political rights, the most traditional individual rights, democratic rights and civil and social rights.
During this stage we have emphasized the spread of those individual rights and public freedoms. Laws such as the Equality Act for men and women, the Act for the recognition of marriage between homosexuals, the facilitation of divorce or separation procedures represent a clear tendency towards modernity, towards sensibleness and progressist liberalism which, by the way, is usually a factor of prosperity and openness in a democratic society.
More specifically, during this period we have focused on making an effort in order to strengthen our Welfare State. The greatest achievement in the last twenty years, as compared to many other countries, might have been the fact that we have forged a Welfare State in order to attain social cohesion, which has experienced great advances and few regressions, with our public health system; with our National Health System, which is one of the best in the world considering the relation between the services granted and the global costs of the system; with an educational system that guarantees compulsory, free education until the children are sixteen years old and with a public pension system, a system that facilitates a horizon to confront the eventual abandonment of one's job due to age or due to other reasons, a horizon of security both for those who have paid taxes and for those who have not and, of course, also a horizon to provide a complement or aid those who have paid very little.
With regards to the extension of this Welfare State, let me emphasize two issues that have been a priority for this Government in the social area and that, at the same time, are an incentive for economic activities, productiveness and prosperity in general.
On the one hand, the fourth mainstay of the Welfare State with the Act to favour the personal autonomy of dependent persons, which in a few years will incorporate a social expenditure of fourteen thousand million Euros and which will be a guarantee for both families and individuals. The State, the central Government, in cooperation with the Autonomous Regions, by means of different instruments, will guarantee the aid to those persons who cannot take care of themselves and to handicapped persons.
On the other hand, the second question I wanted to refer to was the aid for families, which is a social area that has traditionally been quite forgotten in our country. It includes subsidies per birth, per children born and, of course, the harmonization of work and family life. For this reason, the Income tax has improved considerably the aids per children, thus -next Thursday at the Congress of Deputies-we will approve of a subsidy per children born that will amount to 2,500 Euros. This is why we have made such a great emphasis on the harmonisation of work and family life, by means of the Equality Act for men and women, which introduces veritable, deep changes, extends rights, provides those women who want to have a child with guarantees and facilitates the commitment of men, by means of the paternity right, to share the responsibility of having a child.
By the way, since the data are very positive, I would like to point out that this Act that facilitates agreements in favour of equality is already starting to be applied with great success in many companies in this country, especially in great firms that have assumed their responsibility in the establishment of equality between men and women and, of course, in the implications of carrying out the greatest efforts in order to guarantee such equality.
In developing the Welfare State we have also emphasized one of the greatest social problems, which is the access to a house in a country in which housing is not just a concern, a need and a permanent demand, but also a factor of investment given the inherent characteristics of the social history of our country.
As you know, during this period in the Government we have had two objective factors: in the first place, housing prices have decelerated and, in the second place, we have made up for the decrease in the number of social houses, which started to be built again one year later, placing their number back in eighty thousand per year in order to facilitate the access to a house. And during this last stage we have implemented several measures in order to promote rentals.
During the last few weeks, several elements in the public debate have generated concern about the future of the real estate sector, of the construction sector, as a consequence of the financial turbulences originated, as you know, by the well-known "subprime" mortgages in the United States and, logically enough, by their possible consequences on economy in real terms; in particular, on Spanish economy after the reduction in the previsions of economic growth that we are witnessing.
I would like to say a couple of things in this regard: the first one is that the Spanish economy and the Spanish financial system are in a strong position. Economy is strong due to the data I have just mentioned and, in particular, due to the condition of our public accounts, due to the good health of our public accounts, which makes it possible for us to react as if there had been a deceleration beyond the previsions, beyond the reasonable expectations; and, the second one, as I said, is the good health of financial institutions.
This makes me consider the convenience of carrying out a public reflection and share it with the main protagonists of the system or of this sector. The reflection consists in considering the fact that, from the point of view of the Government, the strength of the economic system makes it advisable for financial institutions, for credit entities, to be ready to keep up a reasonable credit level for the economy of our country - while keeping at the same time the security principle that has given such good results in the whole system -, in particular, in the real estate sector, the construction sector, which, let me remind you, represents 5 or 6 per cent of the Gross Domestic Product of our country, as compared to the 68 per cent rate of services, 18 per cent of industry and half of the sector of non-residential construction, but public works, civil works, etc., etc.
But it seems convenient for liquidity turbulences not to affect credit availability excessively, which will make it possible for us to keep up that growth horizon with regards to what has been considered a quite evident fact during for more than one year. That is to say, with regards to the deceleration of the construction sector, which in spite of this still needs a permanent, continuous activity in our country; because the number of houses that are currently being built and that will be built in the future in Spain amounts to approximately five hundred and thousand.
Therefore, we are leaders in economic growth, leaders in employment creation and leaders in the management of public accounts, which, as you all can see, makes it necessary for me to refer to two facts: the first one is that we made an adequate planning; we established the adequate guidelines; we structured the objectives adequately; we knew where we wanted to get and we had clear goals; and the second one is that there has been a very good management. And it is the Vice President for economic matters, Mr. Pedro Solbes, who is directly and significantly responsible for it; and no one will be surprised at my praising him, for he has achieved an ongoing success, and a moderate one too, with regards to the growth previsions, and he has also kept up his word to achieve a surplus in public accounts.
And I say that he has gathered an ongoing success, because it has been the International Monetary Fund and the European Commission who have made a mistake concerning Spanish economy. I must state that the International Monetary Fund has made a great mistake with regards to the growth previsions for 2005, 2006 and 2007, yet, the Vice President for economic matters succeeded moderately when he said that we would have a positive growth and, what is more important, an each time healthier one, because industry and services, as well as construction and internal demands are progressively becoming more relevant - though to a lesser extent - as a consequence of the increase in productivity, which is the result of the efforts in Research, Development and Innovation.
I would finally like to refer to the economic and social task and this will take me to the issue of the construction of democracy, which has to do with the management of Radiotelevision Española, of the public radio station and TV.
When we entered the Government, the debt reached already one billion pesetas, approximately, maybe a bit more; an unbearable situation. As you might have heard me say at some point, a country cannot waste money to keep up a public TV which, in the end, is just used to broadcast the Government's news. This happens in big and small media but, more often, in big ones, in the public radio and TV; it used to happen, and quite noticeably too.
Thus, the SEPI (State Society for Industrial Stake) and the Vice President for economic affairs, with the collaboration of the unions, have faced an exemplary process of reorganisation of public radio and TV in order to rationalize the expenditure. At the same time we are going to reduce publicity and, thus, we are moving forward and turning our public radio and TV into a public service, mainly, and depriving them from an excessive commercial, competitive interest, beyond the reasonable limits that are necessary in order to keep them up.
We have rationalised and reorganised public TV and, at the same time, I think that we have attained one of the most expected democratic advances in the last thirty years: a public television for all, independent or as independent as possible and characterised by plurality in the way to broadcast information.
As you all know, the new President of the Corporation, as a result of the reform, was elected by consensus, also for the first time in the history of democracy, at the Parliament; and I think that all citizens appreciate and value the change that has taken place in the Television Española, which is not a partisan television any more, but a television that belongs to all the parties, to the whole society; a television that takes into account a greater plurality.
At the same time, in order to strengthen democracy during this Legislature, we have carried out an intense process to reform the State and the Autonomous Regions, through the reform of the Statutes of Autonomy and through innovation in certain areas in order to achieve the general governability of the State. Thus, for example, we have enhanced the participation of Autonomous Regions in the Councils of Ministers of the European Union, the creation of the Conference of Presidents, or a greater intensification of Sector Conferences and of the cooperation agreements between the central Government and the Autonomous Regions.
A lot has been said about the reform of the Statutes of Autonomy, a lot of debate has been going on, it has had great political relevance, it has also had great emotional relevance, and I would just like to say a couple of things in this regard.
Firstly, as a country, we should make an extraordinarily positive assessment of the State of Autonomies, of self-government, of political decentralization and, if I may say so, mainly of the decentralization of public expenditure; because that is mainly what the Autonomous Regions have. Among the different models of compound States, among the different types of federal State or of regional State or of autonomic State, whatever we may call it, that can be mentioned, the Spanish autonomic State is one of the most successful ones. Without increasing Public Expenditure with regards to our richness and with our Gross Domestic Product, our system has made it possible to approach power and decision-making processes to citizens, it has made it possible to achieve a better management in many areas and it has made it possible to develop the Autonomous Regions or to enhance the development of those regions whose historical development has been more difficult, which is for me even more relevant.
The balance is very clear: an approach between the richest Autonomous Regions, the ones with a higher Gross Domestic Product and those with less richness, with a lower Gross Domestic Product. This shows that the DNA of the autonomic State lays in the cohesion principle to a great extent as opposed to the Centralist State.
Approaching the decision-making process to citizens demanded a reform, so that the different things that have changed over the last few years, since we established the State of Autonomies, could also approach the regional Governments and, therefore, citizens. This is the case, for instance, of new technologies, immigration, environment preservation, especially in the case of our coastline, of everything concerning Labour Inspection, and of many other public services that have been proved to be better managed, more efficient and closer to citizens now.
These statutory reforms are already in force. There is still something that needs to be done, but the reform model is already in force. We are applying these reforms to the transfer of competences in the areas of environment, immigration and water management, as in the case of Andalusia and other Autonomous Regions. I can assure you that, once everything is operative - all the reforms of the Autonomic Statutes - we will witness favourable results concerning economic growth and energies in the different territories, in the management of new public affairs; and all will be closer to citizens and, besides, the State will keep its strength. I will refer to this in a while, during the last part of my intervention.
I am sorry that the reforms of the Statutes have not been backed by a full consensus, that is to say, in all cases. They have obtained a full consensus in most cases, not in the case of the Statute of Catalonia, and I am sorry about it. I think that the consensus between the two main parties, the consensus of all parties would have been desirable also in the case of the Statute of Catalonia. By the time the Statute becomes fully operative, I hereby announce that all the mistrust, the suspicion and the prophecies will crumble down, and that will speak for itself.
And I am also sorry that the debate issued from the Reform of the Statute of Catalonia was taken to the plane of feelings, to the plane of identities. And excesses were committed by all, which may make it difficult to establish the meaning of the need of a single Catalonia leading the economic growth and leading innovation, which is what most of the Spanish citizens want, I think: a self-confident Catalonia and a Catalonia that is not closed up in itself, because most Spanish citizens want to share its strength, which is the strength of us all.
I was telling you that, apart from carrying out the reform of the Statutes of Autonomy, we have strengthened the State. I know that there are some people for whom these things have sometimes been difficult to understand, maybe because one sometimes approaches such things from a reductionist perspective, with a slight myopia. But I must say that the fact that the competence of the Autonomous Regions, their self-governing capacity, have grown does not at all mean that the State Government does not have or does not increase its competences, duties and obligations in many other fields. Fields that, as those who work in the world of business know, are innovated, transformed and it is necessary to intervene in areas that needed no intervention before.
How could this country know, only fifteen years ago, that the State would need to build a powerful Administration in the area of immigration! No one knew this, no one had planned it; but the truth is that, when we entered the Government, we noticed that we needed to strengthen, extraordinarily, the Administration with regards to immigration, as well as the political action in the area of immigration.
Why am I telling you that the State is stronger now? The State is stronger because we have extended, in the first place, the citizenship rights and the social rights thanks to the equality principle; in the second place, because the General State Budget is, mainly, a Budget that favours cohesion. I would like to underline that during this period the Regions that have experienced a greater growth have been Asturias, Galicia, Andalusia or Cantabria, and this makes the State stronger because that unites and structures the State.
But we have also strengthened the State because the State Security Forces and Bodies in our country have eight thousand members more, and the number will raise to forty thousand, in brief, after the incorporation of the last public employment offer; and because our Army, whose strength has increased thanks to the public general Act of Parliament on Defence, with the Troops and Navy Act, with constant investments for its modernization, have passed from 115,000 to 121,000 in this period. The Army plays a brilliant role in all the different places to which it is sent by the Spanish Parliament on peace missions, their retributions have increased 25 per cent during this period, which represents the biggest salary increase of the public sector. We have implemented the recovery of our Army, which was on the decline as far as the number of troops is concerned, in particular thanks to the Troops and Navy Act. This Act propitiates the incorporation of our soldiers to other activities, to other public jobs.
Thus, with regards to the public sector, this Government has been the one that has decided to increase the number of policemen, civil guards, Army troops and Justice Administration workers, passing from twenty two thousand to twenty five thousand members. There are one thousand judges and public prosecutors now and, curiously enough, or at the same time, we have reduced the weight of the General State Administration, the number of civil officers, in one thousand workers. Our country needed more security and we have carried out the greatest public calls for tenders ever, as far as Policemen and Civil Guards are concerned, and we have increased the number of our Army troops and at the same time we have modernized them.
Let me tell you that this is what strengthening the State means, this is maintaining security and, of course, this is the best proof that increasing self-government is perfectly compatible with a State that maintains its strength, its weight and its cohesion capacity; this Government means the capacity to spread both rights and freedoms.
As far as the strengthening of democracy is concerned, I would like to refer to the fight against terrorism.
Democracy has walked a long way, it has carried out a long fight against terrorism, against violence - a blot on society - which has torn us apart for so long, which has taken away so many lives and has frustrated so many hopes. During this period, from the very first day, we have tried to prevent and fight terrorism, attempting to put an end to it; expressing the deepest wish of Spanish society, the deepest wish and, of course, the main duty of a Government that suffers the consequences of such a disgrace in our country.
In this long fight between democracy and terror we have gone through different scenarios, different stages. During this period we have lived a cease-fire and a process of dialogue which has not attained the objective that the vast majority of the Spanish society would have liked to attain, the end of violence. Thus, once more, this means that in spite of the different opportunities during the democracy, those who defend and practice violence and terror are radically unable to do anything different from violence, anything different from justifying or defending it.
Given this situation, as I have claimed on several occasions, the State is strong enough so as to face the threat and the blackmail of the terrorist group. We would like to face this threat with the greatest unity and the maximum consensus possible among the political forces, and I think that the serene vision provided by time and perspective will let us assess, and I will not anticipate how, the period that we have gone through and the effects of the main objective for all Spanish democrats - that is, the end of violence, the end of terrorism, and at the same time, of course, protect the lives and freedoms of citizens.
I will end by briefly referring to the future. As I said at the beginning, the future is education, research, modernity, competitiveness and a completely European country in the international context, and at the same time a country that may be able to provide a reference and to be a reference in other continents. Of course, also in Latin America, where our economic, political and cultural presence is a State duty for any Government; but also in other continents, nowadays more than ever. Spain has been historically absent from Asia and Africa. It is there that we are focusing our greatest efforts, the more intense efforts of this period, not just for economic reasons, but also for cultural, political and security reasons - especially in the case of Africa - and of course in Asia for economic, cultural and political reasons.
Spain has a capacity for cultural dialogue with Latin America, with Africa and also, increasingly, with Asia, and it is a singular European country due to the power it exerts on other areas of the world, because we can be very European and, at the same time, we can be one of the countries with the greatest capacity to attract other countries and other continents towards the European values and the European way of life. Given all this, Spain must carry out a very close policy defending the United Nations, defending international legality, defending peace, defending the Objectives of the Millennium. Thus, we have tripled the aid for development during this period and the aid to support the defence against climatic change carried out by the International Community.
In this context of evolution of our country in the economic and social areas, no one should wonder if I conclude with an emphatic assertion: Spain can be and is going to be part of the main group of the great powers of the world in the 21 st century, at the economic, social and cultural levels.
As far as culture is concerned, just one reflection before concluding: Spain, through its more powerful cultural expression, that is, the Spanish language, is breaking all the records and growing as any other culture, as any other language; and we, the Government of Spain, are contributing to this decisively. One of the management features that we can boast about with great satisfaction is the fact that during this period we have opened twenty four centres of the Cervantes Institute, the great flagship of the Spanish language in the world, in order to meet the growing demand, the amazing demand in some continents, to learn Spanish; twenty four new centres of the Cervantes Institute versus four during the previous Legislature.
This is the best way to believe in one's country, to strengthen Spain, to strengthen our identity, our language, what we represent and the deeply-rooted culture behind our people and our culture in the world and, therefore, before all the inhabitants of the Earth.
Thank you very much.
DEBATE WITH THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Jose Antonio Zarzalejos .- Thank you very much for your intervention, President, an intervention that has been so wide and detailed. I would like to thank you once more, just as the editor-in-chief of "ABC", for being here in such a significant date for you, three and a half years after your investiture.
I must also thank Mr. Blanco, Mr. Jose Blanco, for his effort, which has also been important to have you here today, his good actuation, his great actuation.
I wonder, President, whether you have time for the debate. I thank you for this because, if I may, I would like to ask you about the political part of your speech; that is, you have given several data, but there is a sort of background to all that which perhaps could also be detailed, for it is interesting.
I will start with the most immediate issue. Tomorrow you are going to meet the President of the Basque Government, Lehendakari Ibarretxe. You say that the statutory reforms have served to provide Spain with more cohesion, but he has a proposal for a political agreement. You have already said that you are going to answer no, initially; but I would like to know: how are you going to stop him from carrying out, next 25 th of October 2008, a public consultation that might become the ratification of the agreement that he says he would like to set up with you; a public consultation that may even and surely enough give way to a more or less hidden self-determination, just like the plan he presented at the Congress, if you are the President of the Government by then?
President .- Thank you very much for thanking me, as you have already done in the initial interventions. There was something I did not say during my first intervention and I am going to say it now; when I was here five months after having been elected President of the Government I made the same effort that I am going to make now in order to convince "ABC". I think that it is objective, but I must admit that perhaps I was not very lucky, considering the editorial line that I have been able to follow, as a reader who feels great respect for a newspaper with such a vast tradition as "ABC". But today I have also made up my mind to convince the editorial line of "ABC", I am here in the same mood, with the same willingness and, of course, with the same answers that, in political terms, I gave here three years ago.
Spanish democracy is very strong. Our constitutional system has proved to work virtuously and nobody in this country, including the President of the Government in the first place and then, of course, the Lehendakari or the President of any other Autonomous Region, can do anything for which he has not been enabled by the Law. As simple as that. And just as I cannot appoint the members of the Basque Government, the Lehendakari cannot summon citizens to any public consultation because such consultations are very clearly regulated by the Constitution: there are consultations or referendums as a consequence of the reforms of the Statutes and there is also something called consultative referendum, which is established in article 92 of the Constitution, and can only be carried out on the initiative of the President of the Government, exclusively, and must be authorised by the Parliament.
Thus, as to what Lehendakari Ibarretxe has put forward, I do not even consider it a proposal in formal terms. It may be an idea, but not a proposal. Therefore, no consultation or initiative decision is being made or will be made in this country if it does not respect the constitutional legality and, of course, the statutory legality.
And I will also add that: tomorrow, I will tell Lehendakari Ibarretxe, in a friendly, correct way - for I think this is how things should be done in a democracy, for it always helps, whereas the contrary is always harmful, a different attitude - that before trying to establish the new agreement he has been talking about for seven years, between the Basque Country and the Spanish State, he should establish an agreement between the Basque citizens; because apart from the fact that it does not respect legality, for which I do not consider it a formal proposal, this initiative has also been unilateral and it has not taken into account the plurality of the Basque society.
I would also like to say, in order to finish with this question, that the Basque society, the vast majority of the Basque society, wants two things; and that willingness, of course, falls on the part of the Government of Spain and, of course, on the part of the Socialist Party of the Basque Country: firstly, the end of the horror of terrorism and secondly a plural, transversal political agreement in order to provide the Basque self-government with stability and security; for it has already achieved a great level of self-government. We can discuss about self-government, but we will never discuss about anything outside the Constitution or any attempt to outdo the Constitution.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- Let me, President, ask you about this issue too, why is it now that Lehendakari Ibarretxe puts forward this agreement anew? Is it because the so-called peace process has failed, because Mr. Josu Jon Imaz has decided to quit the presidency of Euskadi Buru Batzar, because he must substitute the radical stance of Batasuna or because he wants to present his candidature for the elections? Why now, right in this moment and not before? It is a diagnosis, but I am asking you to make this diagnosis.
President .- I must say, in the first place, that to be honest with regards to the meaning of the Plan Ibarretxe, the Lehendakari has always had in mind this idea of the consultation. It is true that he has kept it, say, in the closet, on certain occasions, while on other occasions he has put it forward explicitly and emphatically, and almost excessively often too; but he has always kept it up. Even when the so-called Political Statute or Plan Ibarretxe was rejected at the Parliament, he came back to the Basque Country, he dissolved the Basque Parliament and the elections were carried out; he kept the idea of a consultation up during that electoral campaign and then he withdrew it.
Why is he coming back with it again if he knows that he has no chance? In my opinion this has a lot to do with the elections and with the person who is going to be the candidate of the Basque Nationalist Party; for this is a party with which the Government is of course having, and wants to keep having, a good democratic dialogue, a good political relationship. In fact, this is how the presidency of Mr. Josu Jon Imaz was and this is how we wish it to be with the future presidency voted for by the members of the Basque Nationalist Party too.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- Mr. President, I am going to ask you something which is quite difficult to ask.
If the 25 th of October 2008 the Lehendakari said that, whatever might happen and since there was no way out, if he achieved an agreement he would ratify it by means of a public consultation and, if there was no agreement, he would also carry out a public consultation so as to be enabled to establish certain unilateral measures; if he would summon and carry out the consultation, would the Government use the legitimate force of the State in order to prevent it?
President .- The thing is far more simple: I do not know why you are always so interested in comparing the strength. It is Law that is strong. The Law is strong, democracy is strong, the State is strong.
The Lehendakari knows that he cannot summon a public consultation and he who cannot does not have the instruments, he simply does not have them and, therefore, he cannot do it and he who cannot do it, will not do it. Once we have said this, we are talking about October next year. Someone has talked about a tremendous political voltage. Many things may happen in one year! Among other things, there will be general elections by the middle of March and, of course, a debate at the Basque Parliament and, who knows, maybe elections at the Basque Country.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- In advance?
President .- Who knows! I am not going to ask for them but the Lehendakari must reflect upon the steps that he may take from now on.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- Anyway, we have the article number 155 of the Constitution, isn't it?
President .- Yes, of course, it is there.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- Can it be used in order to suspend an autonomy that is not meeting its duties towards the State?
President .- I insist: as President of the Government, it is my obligation... I know the State means very well, I know the Government and the meaning of the Judiciary, and I can tell you that this initiative is not feasible; I would like to emphasize this, it is not at all viable. Thus, under no circumstances will it be necessary to apply any extraordinary measure, should this hypothesis take place, which is not going to happen; any extraordinary measure, I can assure you this. I guarantee it.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- Mr. President, in this context and to close the Basque issue, taking into account that neither the Communist Party of the Basque Lands, nor Basque Nationalist Action have condemned the last terrorist blasts of ETA, not only the one at the T-4, but the subsequent ones, is the Government considering a process of illegalization? Has it considered the possibility of setting it up, because he is actively legitimized to do so?
President .- The Government must act according to the Law and with prudence, when it comes to a possible illegalization of a political party. The Government, through the Prosecutor's Department and through the State Security Forces and Bodies, gathers information and that information, together with the evolution of the events will, in its turn, bring about a decision-making process that, of course, has not been put forward yet.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- Mr. President, do you believe in the alternative use of the Law? That is, do you believe that Batasuna is now committing a crime whereas it was not committing a crime while the peace process was on?
President .- I believe in the Rule of Law and the Rule of Law implies, mainly, the respect of the decisions of the independent Judiciary Power, even in the case of the President of the Government. Respect for the decisions of all the judges, in this case I am referring to the judges of the National Assembly, because those are the ones that usually make decisions as far as terrorism is concerned and I have respected them from the first day I became President of the Government. I hereby invite all curious persons to go to a newspaper archive so that they may get some assessment concerning my decisions with regards to a judicial decision.
Therefore, I respect the decisions that have been made. I have an idea of what Jose Antonio Zarzalejos is about, but it is my duty to respect the actuation of justice.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- Mr. President, has the Government substituted the General State Prosecutor during the process of peace with ETA or afterwards, so that he might choose whether to formulate his accusations or not?
President .- The Government respects, deeply, the autonomy of the General State Prosecutor's Office and it acts in compliance with that Law, with its Statute, the Fiscal Statute; and the Government gives instructions on crime policy.
I am going to tell you the instructions concerning criminal policy that I have personally asked for by the beginning of his mandate to the General State Fiscal: prosecution, as active as ever, and the fact that the Prosecutor Office has been provided with as many means as possible in three different areas: first, gender violence against women; second, accidents at work and third, car crashes.
But the Government does not intervene in the particular cases in which the Prosecutor's Office acts and I can assure you that, as in the case of the decisions of judges, I may contemplate some of them in a way and some others differently; but always from a position of respect.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- The thing is that, certain contradictory events have taken place and some people who have been accused by the Prosecutor were not accused a few months ago. That is why I was asking you, to find out whether the Prosecutor's Office might be acting with or without instructions.
As to the Statute of Catalonia, Mr. President, and we have listened to you carefully when you were talking about the cohesion principle, there are several data that must be considered and that make it difficult to maintain what you have been saying about cohesion.
The Statute of Catalonia was not supported by Republican Left of Catalonia (Esquerra Republicana de Cataluña), only 48 per cent of the census voted, seven appeals of unconstitutionality have been put forward and they must be dealt with; this gave way to a crisis in the Socialist Party of Catalonia (PSC), an emulation effect and another crisis in Convergence and Union (CiU) and we found out this morning that a Catalan newspaper, namely, "El Periódico de Cataluña", opens up with an interview in which it claims that most Catalan citizens, six out of ten, are in favour of the public consultation for self-determination. Considering this and the demands by Convergence and Union (CiU) of a confederated State, beyond Mr. Carod, has this reform been worth it? Wasn't the previous Statute, the Sau Statute, more legitimate than the current one?
President .- If we consider the representatives of the political forces, Republican Left did not support the original Statute, neither did Alianza Popular, which is the antecedent of the People's Party - and this becomes more evident each time. Thus, the political forces that were present at the Autonomy Stature of Catalonia were the same that approved of it now.
What I mean is that we are not facing a new Statute, we are facing a reform of the Statute of Catalonia and reforming the Autonomy Statutes means complying with the Constitution, from which the Autonomy Statutes derive; for, just as the Statute of the Basque Country or the Basque Lehendakari himself is a consequence of the Constitution, the Statute of Catalonia issues from the Constitution. It cannot be understood without the meaning of the constitutional principle, the constitutional limits and the constitutional possibilities.
As to the political point of view? From the political point of view, I think that we also must have a bit of calm. I think that in the debate concerning the Statute of Catalonia there were three aspects, there was a mixture of three aspects, and some of them have provoked situations that should have never happened. For it is true that we are going to need a joint effort of serenity and calm, which is a democratic virtue, because it is the best way to express the ideas and to carry out public debates.
The problem with regards to the Statute of Catalonia and its reform is that during the political debate and during the debate among the citizens, the feelings were more powerful than the issue under discussion itself on many occasions and it was difficult to make an effort to explain things during the debate.
In the second place, there has been a factor that is sometimes difficult to defend, and that is the need for Catalonia to see an effort to increase the investments, especially in the area of infrastructures, which, according to the objective data of the last ten or fifteen years, has proved really necessary for Catalonia.
And in the third place, the effects of the Statute itself, of the debate concerning the Statute and of the configuration of the majority that had passed that Statute together with the Government of the Generalitat were also influential. Of course, it had substantial effects and, of course, it caused a certain dislike with regards to the meaning of the political process, in particular, at a certain point of the reform of the Statute of Catalonia.
We should not be worried about the instruments of appeal before the Constitutional Court, which form part of the system, of the Rule of Law; and such appeals affect the laws. This Statute has a specific relevance, but the Constitutional Court will establish those aspects that, similarly, from my point of view, are present in other Statutes, such as the Statute of Andalusia, where no unconstitutionality appeals have been presented. There are many precepts that are practically the same if we compare the new Statute and the reform of the Statute of Catalonia and the reform of the Statute of Andalusia, for which no appeal has been presented at the Constitutional Court.
But, I insist, we need time to get political calm and we need time to see the results of the legislature of the Statute of Catalonia, of its application to this new Government of Catalonia and also, of course, to the result of the general elections of next March in Catalonia. But it is evident that we all would have preferred to get better results with regards to certain things concerning the reform of the Autonomy Statute of Catalonia.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- Anyway, calm for us, but also for them, right?
President .- Calm in general, serenity. I talked a few days ago about a serene Spain, which is the priority. In Catalan it is even more, it is the so-called seny , it is…
J. A. Zarzalejos .- The thing is, President, that it is difficult to deny the fact that the territorial question in Spain has been opened up again, considering what is happening in the Basque Country on the one hand, and what is happening in Catalonia on the other hand, when, at least apparently, we all believed that it was already closed with the Constitution of 1978. And, what's more, there is a full and absolute autonomy in the Basque Country, even as far as financing is concerned. Today, another Catalan newspaper, "La Vanguardia" in this case, opened its edition comparing the income of both Regions, in favour of the Basque Country. We thought that this Statute was also going to calm this down, but each time more demands are made, and now a clearly confederated State is being demanded. Don't you admit this either or do you think that this is an excessive interpretation of the events?
President .- I can admit that there is a territorial debate in our country if you admit that such a debate has always existed.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- Yes. Of course I admit it. That is obvious.
President .- We have heard lately "Ibarretxe is back" and the thing is that Mr. Ibarretxe has been back since 2001. That is to say, ten years after Mr. Jose Maria Aznar won the general elections with absolute majority. It was at the Club Siglo XXI where he talked about a consultation for the first time, a consultation, by the way, whose aim is not really clear, an undefined consultation…
J. A. Zarzalejos .- But he is going to tell you tomorrow, that for sure.
President .- I do not know. I hope so. At least, I hope I will make my best to understand him.
Then, and I remember this moment very well, this stage in which the Declaration of Barcelona took place; and it was there that Convergence and Union (CiU), the Basque Nationalist Party (PNV) and the Galician Nationalist Block (BNG) got together in order to subscribe a declaration that was also considered a declaration of confederalism and plurinationalism at that time. The manager of "ABC" will surely remember it, for he is usually quite concerned about these general matters concerning the Spanish territories.
And it is true that we have undergone a process of Statutory reforms; but the Statutory reforms formed part of the electoral programme of the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party. The proposal has not been put forward exclusively by each Autonomous Region, instead, it formed part of our political programme because we understand that it is convenient and necessary to go deeper into self-government, which so successful and positive results has produced in our country. And now we have Mr. Ibarretxe's proposal, which, I insist, is not at all viable.
But, beyond that, I will make a reflection, maybe with a wider perspective. It is true that particular identities co-exist in our country, in Catalonia, in the Basque Country and in Galicia there is a particular, very strong identity which is closely linked to the existence of a particular language, co-official languages in those territories but languages of Spain after all. I feel them as languages of Spain and that deserves a reflection on our side too.
The recognition of that feeling of identity, which is accompanied by a feeling of self-government willingness, of strong self-government, and which is also accompanied by a feeling of respect and cultural recognition of such identities is the task of the State, in order to provide it with cohesion; and one day, with regards to the extended opinion that they are asking each time for more, we should bring forward an objective balance and establish who has benefitted from the State of Autonomies, I insist once more, and, from my point of view it has benefitted those who had to be benefitted: it has benefitted the Autonomous Regions and the regions with less richness, with less growth.
This is the result of decentralization and of the model of autonomic financing that we have been living in during all these years. For the next Legislature we are going to discuss about the change in the model of autonomic financing and it is there that we will observe strange alliances, for each Autonomous Region will be defending the interests of its territory. I am sure that certain positions, apart from those of the People's Party (PP) and of the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party (PSOE), will coincide.
But this is the best period of our territorial coexistence. Never before the last thirty years, not in the last three, four, seven or eight years; never before the last twenty five or thirty years have we been able to live in freedom and political plurality, that is to say, in democracy. And never before the last twenty five years have we been able to make Spain coexist with each and every single identity in the country.
If we are able, if we apply more rationality and if no one, from any position, tries to spur territorial confrontation; if instead we bring comprehension and dialogue and we try not to spur something that could be easily spurred, then we will be able to coexist better each time, and I think that this is what the vast majority of our citizens want because, in fact, the answer to some of the thesis of certain Catalan political forces or the answer to the initiative of Lehendakari Ibarretxe, the most extreme answer, as is usually said, or the exaggerated one, placing the different political parties in a tense situation, is a negative, sterile answer. And I emphasize this, negative and sterile.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- But, Mr. President, if this coexistence must be like this and if we all respect the autonomic symbols, why is it that from certain autonomies the symbols of the State and of the nation are not respected? I refer, for instance, to the flag, both in Catalonia and in the Basque Country. Or how is it possible that in the Basque Country there are still streets and squares or monuments devoted to members of ETA, to murderers that have been condemned for very serious crimes, and still nothing happens? That is, how can the strength of democracy be proved in such a situation?
President .- That would be a good question for all the democratic period, isn't it?
J. A. Zarzalejos .- That is right.
President .- And I do not know if you asked this to other Presidents of the Government.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- I have. I remember that I did not ask Mr. Suarez, but I asked Mr. Gonzalez, Mr. Aznar and you.
President .- Consider this with regards to the flag, to the monarchy and to the question of the street names. I am going to leave the matter of the streets aside…
J. A. Zarzalejos .- But that is a serious matter.
President .- …because it cannot be compared to anything. This is a matter I would like to leave aside, the question of the streets devoted to ETA prisoners for, surely enough, its treatment should form part of our process to reform the Act on Terrorism Victims. We are thinking about it. This is a legal reform that requires a wide consensus, this one too, mostly this one.
I am surprised by the issue of the flag. Rather than the flag, and, of course, the Government is highly interested in having the flag of Spain, which is our flag, waving everywhere; and the Government of Spain also feels obliged and convinced of the need to respect the flags and the signs of identity of the different Autonomous Regions. Thus, what surprises me more is that something that is protagonised by a minority and that has been treated with prudence during the last twenty five years by the great political parties in this country, the ones that are or may be at the Government, is no longer treated like that.
That is the most surprising thing because, when the debate on the presence of flags in certain autonomic or local institutions started out, I asked for a full dossier containing the events of the last ten years with regards to this question and it is evident that it has been present in some places, just a few, fortunately, and it has been difficult to have the Spanish flag waving there, as it should. But I can assure you that any political forces used this in order to criticise the Government, not even one of the biggest mass media turned this into a big national issue.
There was prudence and good sense and I appeal to prudence and good sense because we all know what we are talking about and we all know that it is very negative to discuss about the flag and even more negative to discuss about the Head of the State. And I will not argue with those who are content with our flag and with the positive characteristics of our monarchy, just like you and me.
The only thing I can say as President of the Government is that in this period as Head of the Government, the monarchy has been fully, absolutely backed by all the institutions, as contemplated in the constitution, and I would like to add the following: the Head of the State, the parliamentary monarchy that forms part of the constitutional agreement, is very strong from the institutional, political and social point of view. We can claim and feel proud about it that our Monarchy is more accepted as compared to other parliamentary monarchies in the international arena.
And, thus, if the fact that a very small minority shows an offensive attitude, as usual, besides - as usual, well, as from time to time - against the representation of the Head of the State, the King, is turned into a public debate, maybe it is because some do not have anything to discuss about or because some others do not have anything to discuss about. But I think that it is simply sad. I must say it bluntly, it is very sad, because these are important things in a democracy and we have never discussed them and the best proof for it is that this debate that has risen as a consequence of the burning those photocopies or images of the King. I tell it to you now: it is going to last little time because when there is nothing to talk about, things do not last. This usually happens in public life and, as the Monarchy is fully supported and backed, it is going to keep up and maintain the strength.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- All right, Mr. President. You have defined that as a sort of cold, and I agree with you and I think that most citizens do too, for the Monarchy is a very strong institution. But there are contradictory facts in this assessment too. For instance, the fact that the Monarch goes out in the street vindicating the Institution or the Monarchy, or the fact that a newspaper such as "Le Figaro" a few days ago wrote "Juan Carlos I defends the Spanish monarchy". Beyond our personal considerations, there are other persons and even the Monarch himself that have seen it rather differently. Thus, the question is: Do you discard the possibility that something new is starting out?
President. - Of course. Besides, I will add that the speech in which the King underlines the positive side of the thirty years of the Spanish parliamentary monarchy is a quite usual speech during his interventions, and I know this quite well because I know his speeches. It is a habitual speech. Thus, have a look at the different occasions in which the King has said so. He says so in all his speeches. And it is normal for this to appear in some international newspapers, given the great repercussion of the actions of fifty or one hundred violent persons in the national mass media, and given the importance it has been given in certain political areas.
I simply say one thing: if there are 350 deputies from different Parliamentary Groups at the Parliament, this debate does not exist. There has been an amendment which, by the way, passed unnoticed at the Congress and then, at the Senate, acquired the category of great risk, and this amendment concerned the Military Career, proposed by a group, Republican Left of Catalonia, with regards to the Leadership of the Army; it was voted and it did not pass and that was it. This is something that not one single important party has considered, or is considering it or can reach it.
Thus, no basis for a debate, it is the responsibility of those who use that debate and the actions of a minority, and the absolute strength of the Head of State and of the Parliamentary Monarchy prevails, thanks to the fact that this is what citizens want. We should never forget, right!: in democracy citizens want to and know that this system has provided the country with stability, progress, freedom and democracy, and, of course, they back it and support its undoubted continuity.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- Mr. President, you have a tendency, a logical tendency in the case of a President of the Government, to re-dimension this type of questions. You have also said that the hissing, when you were hissed at during the National Day, is typical. Don't you want your public image before all citizens to be a reference, say, a stronger, intimate, deeper or more perceptible defence of this common symbols, which includes the national flag, apart from the fact that one hundred or two hundred people have hissed at you and you say that this is something typical?
President .- Or even five hundred and thousand.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- I do not know. The truth is that I have no idea. I think that they were very few, anyway, and that is a bad behaviour.
President .- They were quite a lot.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- Besides, it is a bad behaviour, as we all, here, can see.
But, don't you think that you have resigned to have a weak image with regards to the defence of those values while you are claiming that the hissing is traditional?
President .- The hissing took place the 12th of October, I said it was typical because it was the third time that it was taking place in a different circumstance. It is true that you could understand it once you saw some of the flags - I saw it on TV later on, because I had not seen it live, because it happened in that specific moment -, and you could see them and the way you could see them.
What is more important to me is the fact that people have the right to applaud and disapprove of something. I have always been extremely respectful with freedom of expression and with the expression of citizens. We are in a pluralist system and people have the right to applaud and to hiss at you. But I want to make this clear: I felt sorry at that time for the fact that such attitudes were taking place during the homage to the soldiers that had died defending our flag with their relatives of the soldiers there. I was sorry about the relatives, in the first place, about their fellow soldiers whom I had had the chance to meet during this period at the Presidency of the Government, whom we may feel proud of. If there is something that I can claim after my experience as Head of the Government, it is the fact that our Army, our soldiers are first-class, devoted soldiers.
And I would like to add: each one is different. I said before that the way I understand the democratic behaviour and the relationship with the others, with citizens, is filled with austerity, with normality. I have never liked excesses, and I like them even less when talking about my own country, which is what I love the most, after my family. Why? Because I have always thought that the best patriot is the one who shows it with his work, just as so many citizens, meeting his duties, his responsibilities, and not showing off or boasting.
My experience, not as a President but as a normal person has shown me that those who are more valuable at all levels (intellectual, scientific, cultural, moral…) do not usually boast; do not usually consider themselves the best scientifics, or the best writers, or the best democrats or, of course, the best patriots or the most Spanish ones. My experience has shown me that those who are better, more cultivated and who meet the obligations towards their country better do not usually boast, they just do it and share it.
This is the way I understand and feel things. I think that democracy must be accompanied by a certain austerity and calmness and not by those arguments that turn out to be rather false in the long term.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- Mr. President, precisely for that reason, because you are talking about calm, serenity, reason and common sense, it is necessary to reflect quite a lot about the motivations before putting forwards a Law on Historical Memory, wondering whether it is necessary or not and how far should such a Law on Historical Memory reach, whether or not it should comprise the reprehensible events that took place between 1931 and 1936…
President .- I was expecting that question…
J. A. Zarzalejos .- Sure, but it is a normal thing for me to ask …besides, whether it was necessary for this instrument of historical memory to be implanted by means of a Law and not just through a mere declaration; and whether after thirty years of democracy, eighteen under the rule of the Socialist Party, that is to say, of the left wing of this country; under the rule of socialists and nationalists in Catalonia and under the rule of nationalists in the Basque Country, that is to say, under the rule of antifranquists, it is possible to question the relevance of the historical memory in this moment, in this calm, in this serenity and in this sensibleness that is necessary for the first aspect of your conference, that is, for the development of prosperity.
President .- The Law, which is not called Law on Historical Memory - let's call things by their names, because it is good to do it in order to place them in the debate - it is mainly a Law to recognise the rights, so that some people may feel in peace, because there are some people that are not in peace. They feel great unrest because their suffering, their experiences have not been recognized, I mean, from the economic point of view, from the moral point of view and, of course, from the point of view of something so elementary as the possibility to know where was buried one of your relatives, who may have been buried in a common grave.
A great part of the Law recognizes rights, closes a chain of decision made through laws, and also Budgetary laws, which has progressively embodied the recognition for those persons and which makes certain declarations and suggests certain things to the Public Administrations: declarations concerning the illegitimacy of those resolutions whereby, due to political, ideological, syndical or religious reasons, the Law points out, they unfairly condemned. I wonder whether democrat citizens assume it as legitimate, from the point of view of democratic values, for someone to be condemned for political, religious, syndical or ideological reasons. I honestly think that we all could assume that no one would admit such a thing at all.
Therefore, in my opinion, bringing calm, peace to those who suffered and have not attained recognition is an action that issues from the philosophy and from the deep sense of the Transition and of harmony.
This Law does not reproach anything to anyone. There are no names or surnames, except for the regime of General Franco, the authoritative regime of General Franco. There are no reproaches.
I think that the maturity of a country, its degree of harmony and its high capacity to co-exist - as is our case - is shown if it respects the recognition of those who suffered during the Civil War, during the Dictatorship, just as I respect, deeply, the beatification of the five hundred religious martyrs that is going to be carried out by the Vatican. I respect it deeply.
What's more, there is a very unusual circumstance, maybe, concerning the way we think, and I would like everyone to think like this: the person who has put forward the Law proposed the Socialist Group and is going to defend the so-called Law on Historical Memory is also going to attend the beatification at the Vatican, because the great-uncle of this person is also going to be beatified.
I feel proud that this is going to happen and I respect deeply those who remember, one way or the other, in this case through worship, those who died, those who suffered, the victims. But there were also many other victims; and they have not been fully recognised, during the Dictatorship, of course; instead, they suffered, just like many others, but they were not fully recognised during the Transition.
Thus, this is not intended to open up anything; it tries to bring peace to some people who were not in peace and affirms democratic values as, for instance, the symbols, where the Public Administrations are asked to eliminate the symbols of exaltation of rebellion or war, not memories, because a wrong interpretation has been carried out. Of course it is possible to remember.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- Gravestones, for instance.
President .- Exactly. That is not exaltation in my opinion; it is just memories, it is just remembering. It is remembering, keeping up memories, paying homage to memories either of the relatives or, as in this case, of a religious congregation. We must respect this.
But do we agree, as a country that it is no good to praise the military rebellion and the Civil War? I think we do agree. That is what the law says. Do we agree that this country is highly mature and has a great degree of political coexistence, which allows us to deal with these matters in a natural way? Just like the person that will put forward the Law on Historical Memory, who will go to the Vatican and who will also defend this Law from the tribune. Of course we agree. That is our great achievement and that is the great achievement we are going to leave for the future generations.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- I am going to finish, Mr. President. I would like to ask you many other questions, but there is no time.
President .- You have asked quite a few.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- Why do you think that the video on Education for Citizenship made by the Socialist Youth of Spain has been good and useful for the debate?
President .- Because, beyond its results, which are merely anecdotic, I had not seen it, but when I saw it I thought it was so extravagant... I think that Spanish politics nowadays lacks distance, serenity, as I said, calm, and a different approach to things. I think whatever may serve to introduce such factor is positive.
Yet, I would like to say, with regards to the debate concerning the Education for Citizenship, that it is possible to deal with this subject a bit more seriously using more serious words, and better still if it is done during a debate, at the parliament or any other moment, and I would gladly attend it, because this is something that I cannot understand, the opposition against the Education for Citizenship. To sum up, incorporating the Education for Citizenship is a patriotic act, because Education for Citizenship implies the transmission to teenagers of the values of the Constitution, of freedom, of democracy, of Spain, of the Head of State and of our identity as a nation.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- Mr. President, is the Government going to refuse two of the Magistrates of the Constitutional Court?
President .- That decision depends on the Office of the State Attorney which should firstly inform from the legal point of view and, then, the Government will make a decision.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- Thus, you will not make a decision until you receive the report from the Office of the State Attorney?
President .- Exactly.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- Mr. President, are we coming to the end of an economic cycle? Because, you have just told the credit entities that they can keep granting credits, which means that they are retaining the credits, that they are restricting the credits and you are encouraging them to give credits, without fear, right?
President .- I must confess that some businessmen have asked me to do this. Last August there was a moment of turbulences in the markets as a consequence of the crises of the "subprime" mortgages which, logically enough, has raised the expectation of the economy at a worldwide level and, in particular, in the case of the credit institutions. This is how I would see the situation, but there is no sign of economic recession or problems on the medium term.
International economy has sound foundations. International economy is going through one of the best moments, the Spanish economy has sound foundations in its great parameters, the European economy has reasonably good foundations, thus, it this moment of expectation, in which we must wait and see what is going on in many markets and financial institutions will be overcome.
In my opinion, each day the situation becomes a bit more relaxed and that will make it possible for us to carry out a reactivation, although in fact, judging by the evolution of the Stocks Market in the last few days and in the last few weeks, it does not seem that we are going to have many problems in order to achieve a climate of full confidence again.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- One last question, which you are not going to answer: who are the wizards that visit La Moncloa? Do not tell me that you have not read it.
President .- I haven't.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- You haven't read it?
President .- Wizards visiting La Moncloa? In La Moncloa I can tell you the order…
J. A. Zarzalejos .- Do not tell me that you do not read the declarations of the Delegate Advisor of the first communication group of this country.
President .- Oh! That…
J. A. Zarzalejos .- There are not witches or visitors.
President .- Many different persons visit La Moncloa habitually. Those who visit La Moncloa more often are usually businessmen, because we have institutional events or work events for businessmen; but I can tell you that I will not comment anything on the assessment carried out by my friend Juan Luis Cebrian.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- The elections, next 2 nd or 9 th of March? You are not going to answer to my question.
President .- Yes, I can tell you that the elections are going to be next 2 nd or 9 th of March. That is quite a lot, isn't it?
J. A. Zarzalejos .- Ms. Maria Teresa Fernandez de la Vega, the first Vice President, will she present her candidature for Valencia?
President .- She will talk about it soon.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- She will talk soon?
President .- Yes.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- One last question, and be honest, Mr. President. Did you order to use the "photoshop" in the photograph in which you appear running in a beach in the South of Spain, as if you were levitating and without leaving any marks upon the wet sand, or didn't you order it?
President .- That's it. It is a real photo, as real as life itself. This question was posed to me a few days ago during a programme in Tele-5 and one of the bodyguards who was running with me was there too, it was his turn that day to be at the programme, and when we came out of it he said to me: "I have been about to raise my hand and say: I was there running with him". So…
J. A. Zarzalejos .- Thus, there was not "photoshop"?
President .- No, not at all.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- You mean that you are fit, you have not put up weight.
President .- I try to do some exercise. I do not compete; I simply try to keep myself as healthy as possible, for I think this is always desirable, regardless of the circumstances, and even more in my case, given my position and my work. But no, I do not run a lot and I do not run to compete with anyone, I want this to be clear.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- Except with Mr. Rajoy, I suppose, right?
President .- I have said on many occasions that I have a good relationship with Mr. Rajoy. He sometimes criticizes me hard; but I have a good relationship with him, I have always had it, each time we have met, each time we have talked, each time we have eaten and each time we have had dinner.
I think that we will reach a very enriching point at the political level if we are able to be opponents in the full sense of the word and to keep a kind relationship, a good mood and if we are able to avoid personal discrediting. I always try to achieve this, sometimes I have to make an effort in order to hold myself back; but I think that this is very good for democracy and also for the citizens.
I am going to compete with him and I know that he is a difficult rival. I went through this four years ago and, therefore, I know that he is a difficult rival and I respect him deeply as a rival in the elections.
J. A. Zarzalejos .- Then call him and reach an understanding, for the sake of Spain.
Thank you very much, President.
President .- Thank you very much.
