Press conference of the President of the Government after his meeting with the President of the People's Party

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

13 October 2008

Context
Zapatero addressed press after meeting opposition leader Rajoy on 13 October 2008 to outline government measures responding to the global financial crisis.
Main themes
International financial crisis response, Spanish financial system stability, asset-purchase fund, European coordination, transparency and public accountability, structural economic reforms, Pact of Toledo, Social Security system, cross-party dialogue, welfare state future
Duration
~49 min
94th percentile
Words
5,869
94th percentile
Sentences
202
89th percentile
Readability
47
54th percentile
Grade
13.4
61st percentile
Syntax
3.28
80th percentile
Vocabulary
1.97
7th percentile

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

202 sentences in 83 paragraphs

President .- Good afternoon.

I would like to inform you about the contents of today's meeting with Mr. Rajoy. I will make a previous evaluation and then I will explain the contents.

I think that this has been a useful, positive meeting. I have informed Mr. Rajoy about the analysis concerning the situation of the international financial situation and the analysis of our financial system and I have also informed him about the action plan implemented by the Government; a plan that, as you all know, should be agreed on and coordinated with the European Union, for, this way, it will be more useful to face this international crisis, a crisis that also affects the whole of Europe.

I have also informed him about the last two measures adopted by the Eurogroup, two measures that have resulted in two Royal Decrees. One of them, as you all know, is aimed at creating an asset-purchase fund in order to buy assets from Spanish financial entities and promote the financing of these entities; and the second one is intended to regulate the guarantees concerning the new debt of financial entities until next 31 December 2009 and for a period of up to five years.

I have informed him about the criteria of the Government and I have offered him all the necessary mechanisms to guarantee the maximum transparency, rigour and, of course, the maximum control with regards to these two types of actions; and more in particular with regards to the asset-purchase fund.

I have also informed him about two main compromises in this sense: to start with, the first one, the one concerning the contents of the Royal Decrees concerning development, whereby the different matters relating the limits, price and purchase model will be included, will be sent to the People's Party before being approved of; secondly, as a general idea, which has been welcomed by Mr. Rajoy - so I think -, we are going to try to get the Bank of Spain involved as the main institution in order to implement the asset-purchase fund, for this action is rather innovative as far as the Crown is concerned. As you already know, the fund totals to thirty thousand million Euros and this amount might be expanded to fifty thousand million Euros.

In my opinion, there has been a receptive atmosphere during the meeting. We agreed about the fact that we are facing a highly exceptional action. For, even though this is an action that the whole of Europe shares, it is highly exceptional from the point of view of the Government and it must be carried out with the outmost guarantees, control and transparency, because we are dealing with a considerable amount of public resources.

This was what we commented on with regards to the recently adopted measures to support and buttress the Spanish financial system, as you all know.

Apart from this, I have presented him with the two proposals for the People's Party concerning the economy of our country, the future of the Welfare State and other essential aspects.

First, I have proposed to create a round table formed by representatives of the Government and of the main party in the opposition in order to implement a series of structural reforms, the reforms the Government has already announced, the reforms the Government is working on, the reforms the Government is promoting, the reforms that affect the services' sector, the employment regulation in the transport sectors, etc.

To sum up, a round table aimed at dealing with what we call structural reforms. Mr. Rajoy has accepted my proposal and, of course, we will try to implement it as soon as possible. It has to do with the future of our economy, with the improvement of competitiveness and with the need for changes in our economy, which has become rather obvious lately.

Secondly, I have offered Mr. Rajoy the possibility to summon the Pact of Toledo in order to move on as far as this pact is concerned. I did this a few days ago, when I held a meeting with the unions and with the president of the businessmen organisations, in the context of social dialogue. I intend to summon this pact in fifteen days so that it may start working as soon as possible with businessmen and with the unions.

And then there is the question of the Social Security system, an area of interest - of general interest - for our country and for the future of social welfare y our country. In 1994, the Pact of Toledo yielded very positive results, which made it possible for our Social Security system to become more sustainable and to gather more resources. This let us move on and keep improving the pensions and now we would like to do something else for our future, for the future of our pensions and also for the future of our Social Security system. This will surely instil great calm and a positive message into our social protection system, into our basic social protection system.

The structural reforms and the Pact of Toledo and the Social Security system are the two great questions I have commented on with Mr. Rajoy, because these issues are a matter of concern for our country, a matter of collective concern, something we should start to work on today, thinking of tomorrow. Similarly, I have undertaken a compromise with social agents, businessmen and unions to work with the greatest collaboration spirit and to reach as many agreements as possible, from cooperation, sharing that very spirit, and I would like to reach this cooperation with the political parties, in particular, with the party in the opposition. These are highly interesting matters, matters of general interest, matters that of a national scope, and I am responsible for these matters and I intend to reach the greatest agreement.

We have also talked about other economic issues concerning a shorter time span, an accounting year, in fact, issues concerning the Budgets; for, as you all know, we disagree about this matter. The debate about the Budgets will take place soon and it will serve to clarify our positions. You already know our stance, namely, that the Budgets should include social investments, investments in infrastructures, investments in research, Development and Innovation. We can keep making this effort with regards to social policies and we are going to do it.

If someone wants to reduce expenditure in the Budgets, if someone wants to restrict the Budgets as is said in such cases - although I would not recommend this -, I think that this person should say which items should be eliminated and which items should be restricted, because preaching the reduction of expenditure does not mean anything. We have specific items, we have specified the amounts per item and, thus, it is necessary to specify whether it should be the salaries of public servants that should be reduced, or whether it should be the minimum pensions that should not be increased or whether it should be the scholarships that should remain the same, or aid for dependence. This will surely be debated next week during the Budget debate.

Thus, to conclude, I think that we have reached an understanding to a great extent, with regards to the most transcendental measures concerning the financial system, the compromises I have just mentioned; and we have agreed to work together on two great questions: structural reforms and Pact of Toledo, with all the political parties and, in particular, with businessmen and with the unions.

Journalist .- You asked Mariano Rajoy to support, without conditions, your measures to fight crisis without conditions and I would like to know whether Mr. Rajoy has supported you without conditions or whether he has made any objections. Otherwise, what has the President of the PP objected?

President .- I have always said that supporting our financial system was a matter of State, a matter of general concern. And a matter of general concern demands a supportive political attitude and the willingness to support. I think that a few days ago he said: and then, if we want to, we can talk about the details. We have dealt with specific issues, details and development issues, and I think that we might reach an understanding. The most important thing is to keep up this willingness.

It is important, both for our financial system and for our country as a whole, to get the widest parliamentary support for those two Royal Decrees; two decrees that establish that the State will provide guarantees amounting up to one hundred thousand million Euros until next 31 December; two decrees that establish the creation of an asset-purchase fund, aimed at buying assets from Spanish financial entities and endowed with up to fifty thousand million Euros. I think that it is my duty to do this, for this is also a positive message and it instils confidence.

I have done my best to attain these results and I have perceived a rather positive attitude on Mr. Rajoy's side, and I hope that this will be talked over next Monday afternoon, during the debate to approve of the Royal Decrees that will take place at the Parliament.

Journalist .- Mr. President, I would like to know whether you could tell us in what way has changed the People's Party, for only three days ago they were saying that the measures that the Government was implementing were good for nothing and were not adequate for Spain, and now, two days later, you say that you have come to an understanding with the leader of the opposition.

Then, I would like to know whether, apart from the economic measures, you have talked about some other issues, such as, for example, the renewal of the Constitutional Tribunal.

President.- The thing is that I have heard many spokesmen of the People's Party talk about the Royal Decrees and about the different measures. I have even heard someone say that I was the bankers' President. Yet, such things, some of which are taken to absurd extremes, can be heard during a debate between different parties...

They have said a lot of things, but the most important thing is to carry them out. This meeting has been the most important thing as well as the clarification, the words of Mr. Rajoy: "I would like a model with the greatest parliamentary control and transparency". I have told to him: this is easy, because, obviously enough, the Government is highly interested in keeping the maximum control and transparency, even more so given the nature of this task. Thus, I can undertake a compromise in this sense. We have been talking about the Bank of Spain and we think that this institution offers maximum security and solvency.

Thus, I think that we have moved on and I don't pay so much attention to the things that have been said so far.

And we have also commented on the Constitutional Court. We have decided to wait a few more days in order to continue analysing the progress of the process and our own criteria. This has not been the main issue and, therefore, there no news in this regard.

Journalist .- Mr. President, given the present situation, the general economic crisis, I would like to know whether the Pact of Toledo is going to be summoned in order to make up for the risks the Spanish pension system might be facing.

President .- In fact, no. The thing is that this is one of the issues we did not talk about. We should have set it forth, but this demands the engagement of the unions and of the businessmen organisations, in particular, and they must agree about a new stage of the Pact of Toledo, to put it this way. Therefore, the last day I held a meeting with them I asked them whether they agreed or not, because it was important for us, from the parliamentary point of view, to get the Pact of Toledo going.

I think that this is an attempt to get some work done in advance and this is what we should do if we are to behave in a responsible way. Our Social Security system is in very good condition, with nearly seventy thousand million Euros in the Reserve Fund; our Social Security system has a surplus, in spite of such a complex year from the economic point of view, and this is what makes it possible for us to increase the minimum pensions; but a responsible leader must think of the future of the Social Security system in fifteen years' time. I think that it is possible to promote that new stage of the Pact of Toledo in order to bring stability and tranquillity to the Social Security system. I say that it is possible now because the unions and the businessmen have agreed to do this and because the People's Party has agreed to do this, for this had also been commented on in the past. I think that there is still a long way to go for us and I also think that we can reach a wide agreement in order to renew the criteria concerning our Social Security system.

Journalist .- Mr. President, since you said a while ago that this financial rescue plan is a very exceptional action and since the economic crisis is also a very exceptional, serious situation - and although I am more interested in your opinion -, haven't you or Mr. Rajoy considered the possibility to appear before the media together in order to give the public opinion the impression that the Government and the opposition are together against this crisis?

President .- The truth is we haven't. I haven't even considered that possibility. The main virtue or strength of democracy is the fact that the rules of dialectics between the Government and the opposition, the rules of dialogue between the Government and the opposition are really useful in all kinds of situations. And when it comes to economic matters too, as happens in all European countries.

It is good to reach as many agreements as possible and to set up as many chances for dialogue as possible, that's true. Absolutely true. In fact, think that, it is with regards to the main issues, to the main national issues, to the most important issues, that I should make an effort in order to propitiate agreement, because I consider that the two Royal Decrees intended to support our financial system - two royal decrees that have been designed to cover our needs for a few years - demand a considerable amount of public resources in order to cover those guarantees or compromises. I think that the fact that this has brought about the agreement between the two main parties is extraordinarily positive, at least; I wish more parties will agree with us too.

As to the public Social Security system, it is necessary to consolidate it with the cooperation of the two main political parties. And as to the structural reforms, it is also possible. Surely enough, we agree about certain particular aspects; and we disagree about certain others. I am particularly interested in one issue, namely, the rules concerning the supervision of the regulating bodies and the debate that is starting to take place now concerning the supervision of financial entities due to the crisis. And in this sense, we must reach an agreement, because this legislation and these rules are going to last and they should not depend on the changes in the Government to such an extent.

Then, logically enough, there are other issues, daily issues or rather yearly issues that are more likely to come up more frequently in the dialogue between the Government and the opposition; but, for me, it is very important for those Royal Decrees to achieve the widest parliamentary support. They are important for the country, they are important for citizens, because that means that all the political parties are determined to use the initiatives at hand in order to support and buttress the financial system. This is very important for the financial system and also for small enterprises, it is very important abroad and I think that this way we are reacting as a nation.

Journalist .- Mr. President, two questions. Should we then understand that the thirty thousand million asset-purchase fund is going to be controlled by the Bank of Spain and not by the Official Credit Institute, as the PP had said, nor by the Commission announced by President Solbes a few days ago, which was a sort of solution in between? Should we take it this is how things are going to be?

And in the second place, when you talk about the transparency measures, that is, measures for the parliament to control the destiny of that money, do you mean the Financial Commission will receive updated information about the asset purchase or do you mean that a specific Commission will be appointed, as the PP proposed?

President .- The thing is that the creation of a specific Commission doesn't make any sense, because that's in fact the job of the Financial Commission, among other things; sometimes, concerning specific, less relevant matters and some other times concerning matters of major relevance, such as this one. I think that the members of the Financial Commission will be responsible enough so as to exert the necessary parliamentary control, and I have told Mr. Rajoy that we are going to make our best in order to achieve maximum transparency with maximum diligence, and this management operation, as everyone can surely imagine considering the scope of the actions that are going to be implemented, will involve a lot of work.

As to the Bank of Spain, we would like the Bank of Spain to play an essential role, but this should be determined through the corresponding regulations; an essential role, I say, with regards to the management of the fund, in particular. We think that this institution - as I have just said - is fully solvent, it knows our financial system very well and it has a reputation in this area, a reputation it has kept up under different Governments in our country.

As to the Official Credit Institute, it has been commented on many an occasion, but the Official Credit Institute has its own aims and its own dimension. It is formed by a relatively low number of public servants and it cannot carry out any tasks resembling those performed by banks or define the tasks that should be carried out in order to assess the assets and the criteria. This is quite evident.

I think that the Bank of Spain should play a relevant role, as well as the Treasury, because, in the end, it is the Treasury that is accepts the responsibility and provides the guarantees and the State resources in order to purchase these assets; but I think that the Bank of Spain can play an essential role. And if this proves to be satisfactory for the PP, so much the better.

Journalist .- As to the committee for structural reforms, I would like to ask you whether you could explain a bit further the contents of the programme; that is to say, whether the issues debated will have to do with the liberalisation of services, with the introduction of greater controls in the financial system, as you have just suggested, or whether you are going to deal with issues such as the liberalisation of the labour market, that is, the flexibilisation of certain measures, measures such as dismissal.

I would also like to ask you, with regards to tomorrow's meeting with the Spokesmen of the different parties, and in particular, with regards to the spokesman of Convergència i Unió, whether or not you'd be prone to negotiate a parallel plan for economic action in order to attain a wider parliamentary support for the 2009 Budgets; for I think this is one of the proposals or one of the conditions set by CiU in order to give an positive vote to the Budget.

President .- As to the latter, I'd rather wait and listen to Mr. Duran, because I am not exactly acquainted with the terms of their conditions. Otherwise I would be improvising and I don't want to do that.

As to the structural reforms, they include everything you've mentioned in your question, in particular, the supervision, regulation and the different reform specifications concerning the services' sector. The labour market involves social dialogue, that's quite evident. Anyway, should the PP have any proposal to make, we will be glad to listen to it, at least.

Journalist .- Mr. President, considering the importance you attach to getting the Congress' support for these two Royal Decrees, has Mariano Rajoy confirmed his either positive vote or his abstention, or whether he is going to vote against or in favour?

President .- I think that the moves of the People's Party should be announced by Mr. Rajoy. I think this is a rather logical thing, out of respect. I have already said that I have seen a receptive attitude on his side, and it has seemed to me that understanding and agreement are possible, and in my opinion this is highly important. But it is Mr. Rajoy that must speak on behalf of the PP. Just imagine...

Journalist.- Two questions. This afternoon, Pio Garcia-Escudero, at the Senate, has reproached you for not having regulated these measures through Royal Decrees, which would have made it possible for the People's Party to introduce amendments. Has this been commented on during your conversation with Mr. Rajoy?

Then, has Mr. Rajoy reproached you for having implemented these measures without holding previous conversations or without setting up a previous dialogue with the PP, just as he has been doing over the last few days?

Finally, if I may, as to the Constitutional Court, would it be possible to reach an agreement by eliminating one of the names, taking into account that none of the candidates proposed by the People's Party is an adequate candidate according to the Socialist Party? I refer to Mr. Hernando and Mr. Lopez.

President .- No such questions have been put forward with regards to the procedure concerning any such Bill Draft. We need the Royal Decrees. All countries have implemented urgent measures, because the situation of the financial system is going through a very delicate period, because it is facing high risks. Thus, I think that this can be understood, and I think that Mr. Rajoy can understand this too.

As to the elaboration of the Royal Decrees, I am going to say something I hope you will understand. We have reached mutual understanding. I understand the fact that the leader of the opposition must play his role and ask for in-detail information, in spite of the fact that I have already phoned him on a couple of occasions in order to inform him about the plans that were being designed by Europe; and he has also understood that our Government cannot come to Madrid and ask the opposition to give its own opinion, for this is what happens in the case of the different Governments that are facing this situation and must make important decisions in just one week end.

I said it yesterday: not many Prime Ministers have provided first hand information in person, not that I know. By the way, I haven't done this with Mr. Rajoy only, but also with Mr. Duran i Lleida, that very Sunday, when I spoke to him.

This is how things work. I understand that he must demand a previous analysis of these matters and he also understands that in such situations, when you form part of Europe and you have to make such decisions, you must work this way, he understands this because he has also been in the Government, of course.

As to the Constitutional Court, no, we haven't dealt with that, and I am not going to deal with it now. We have just said that the process was going on. I said that, in my opinion, we had to comment on the proposal of the Constitutional Court and talk it over, for there was an ongoing debate; and we have decided to wait a few days and then resume our conversation.

Journalist .- Mr. President, when talking about the Budgets, you have mentioned certain disagreements. I wonder whether such disagreements can be overcome or not, whether you have any certainty that the People's Party is neither going to support the Budgets nor is it going to abstain, whether Mr. Rajoy mentioned abstention or a positive vote - although this possibility has already been left aside - and whether or not you talked about the possible abstention of UPN, Unión del Pueblo Navarro.

Then, a matter of current interest, if I may. Minister Moratinos said today that you will visit Cuba following the invitation of the Cuban Minister of Foreign Affairs. I would like to know whether or not this is so, whether this visit is going to take place during 2009, as the head of the Spanish diplomats said.

President .- As to the last question, let me see, yes, this proposal exists. This project exists and we shall see whether it comes true in the end and how.

We haven't talked about UPN, of course. I have tried to hold a relaxed meeting, and, besides, I like to be respectful. I haven' said anything about UPN over the last few weeks because I think that when the members of a family disagree about something their opinion must be deeply respected.

I have just said that with regards to the Budgets we haven't reached any understanding, say. We know were each other stands. In fact, it is a sort of tradition for the party in the opposition to oppose the Budgets put forward by the Government and I think that this tradition, say, exists despite of the budgets proposed. This is a usual habitude in our system and in parliamentary systems in general.

I think that given the current situation, the main party in the opposition should have considered the convenience of that support, regardless of such tradition; still, it is something that falls within their duties. The thing is that with regards to other questions we have come to an understanding but with regards to this one, to the support for our Budgets, we haven't come any closer.

Journalist.- Does this mean that the Government has found a formula to guarantee that the resources provided now will reach families and small and medium enterprises or does the PP renounce to such guarantees?

President .- We have been considering two different levels. We must consider the question of legality, transparency and tranquillity concerning the management of the fund and the guarantees. I think that this is a good position to keep in the Rule of Law.

In fact, I defend this position, both from the Government and from the opposition. It is a matter of searching for an instrument, an organism or an institution with the capacity to carry out such tasks and, of course, also with the necessary honesty and reputation to do it. The Bank of Spain has these characteristics and it will have to play an essential managerial role with regards to these actions, because it is the Treasury that is directly involved in them, and we are going to find out a formula to achieve the maximum transparency and legality.

Maximum legality, maximum solvency, maximum transparency and a greater parliamentary information; I have undertaken to reach this during my conversation with Mr. Rajoy. And then there is the political situation we have lived over the last few days, the debate about whether this is intended to support banks or to support companies and families. This is intended to support the whole country, because this is essential for our national economy. If our financial system does not work, our economy cannot work, the economy of our companies cannot work, citizens cannot keep saving and the families cannot keep investing their resources. And if our companies cannot work, we cannot keep up and create more employment.

This is intended to support the country, our citizens, the resources of our citizens, their revenues and their jobs, and it is also intended to support companies, to make up for their financial needs and their investment projects. Over the last few weeks, we heard businessmen say that there were no liquidity. We have heard this word thousands of times and that means that there weren't enough financial resources to support the daily activity of our companies and to design investment plans and this holds our companies back.

Thus, let me tell you that this debate is not a genuine debate. This is the necessary, essential way to support the whole country. Besides, the Government is going to enhance and boost up the usefulness of the resources lent to the companies, be it small, medium or big companies, and the same goes for those resources provided for families and citizens. You can be sure that we are going to make it, and you'll learn how soon.

Journalist.- Just two further questions. When you talk about enhancing the role of the Bank of Spain as far as supervision is concerned, perhaps you are thinking of turning it into a supervising conglomerate including the supervision tasks carrying out by the CNMV, the agency in charge of supervising the Spanish Stock Market, or by the General Directorate of the Treasury at present.

And I would like to know whether the reforms committee formed by representatives of the Government and of the PP is going to set any limits, at first. I am thinking, for example, about the question of the Pact of Toledo, about the expansion of the salary scales in the case of pensions or other complementary systems are going to be enhanced.

President .- As to the last question, let me tell you that we cannot anticipate things. We will summon the Pact of Toledo first, and we know how it works. The different parties will present their proposals (the Government, the parties, the unions and the businessmen organisations) and then we will try to set up a great agreement for this new period of the Pact of Toledo. We shall see all this in due time.

When I refer to the Bank of Spain, I am not referring to supervision, I am referring to management. Journalist.- Mr. President, with regards to this issue, if the Bank of Spain is not going to be in charge of supervision, but of management , who is going to supervise all this, or is supervision just going to be carried out when the quarterly reports are sent to the Parliament, to the Financial Commission?

Then, yesterday you were setting certain limits concerning the Budgets, limits that had to do with social investments and infrastructures. Does this mean that the rest of the items are subject to great changes?

Finally, a question about the future: if the second article of the Royal Decree approved of yesterday had to be enforced, an article that foresees the partial nationalisation of banks, if necessary, would you ask them to control or set a limit for the salaries of directors?

President .- The thing is that some of these questions are way beyond facts and they really reflect the personality of those who ask them, in fact. Article 2 of the Royal Decree does not contemplate any nationalisation hypothesis; it contemplates the possibility to recapitalise companies, should it be necessary, and the participation of the State would be minor, provisional and highly specific, given the nature and strength of our system; this is what we can reasonably think right now, considering the data we have.

Of course, I would like to say a couple of things with regards to this hypothesis. Obviously enough, this must become a main issue if there has been a poor management and, in general, I think that we, citizens, think that prudence is always good when it comes to salaries - even in the case of directives, even in sectors such as the financial sector, which require high specialisation and high engagement levels.

As to the first question, the question about supervision and control, it is the Parliament that exerts control, the political control of the tasks carried out by the Government and by the fund. We just want the Bank of Spain - which meets a series of requirements, such as solvency, honesty, knowledge, accredited competence - to play an essential role as far as management is concerned. Of course, this supervision will affect financial entities, not the Government of the public institutions. The public institutions undergo two types of controls: a political, parliamentary control and the legality control, exerted, if necessary, by Courts, and then the internal control exerted by the General State Intervention, the Treasury Counsels, etc.

Thus, the supervisor, that is, the Bank of Spain, is in charge of supervising financial entities. By the way, in the case of Spain, our central bank has done things very well, and it has even become a model. But, as we all know, the supervision rules are going to be reformed, we have to work with the People's Party too in order to implement this reform. Besides, it would be good for this reform to have a European character and a European scope.

Each country has its own supervision rules and, of course, given the situation we have lived, it would be extremely positive to have more common rules or as common as possible.

Journalist .- I just have a couple of doubts about what you have just said. In the first place, as to the round table for structural reforms, I would like to ask you whether tomorrow, when you hold a meeting with the spokesmen of the other political parties, are you going to propose them to join this round table or is this just something concerning the PSOE and the PP.

In the second place as to the Constitutional Tribunal, if I got it right, you have agreed to hold another personal meeting in order to solve this question, or are you going to leave to your spokesmen?

President .- It might be done in different ways. Both speaking on the phone - and as you all know Mr. Rajoy and I speak on the phone from time to time - or through the representatives of the Government and of the opposition. We have not established a model, but we have decided to talk it over in a few days' time and I will react in due time.

The round table is for the Government and for the People's Party. If we obtain results with regards to specific issues, if we reach agreements, we will take them to the Parliament and everyone will take part in it; but I think that it is rather reasonable for the Government and the main party in the opposition to start debating these matters.

Thank you very much.