Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

13 October 2008 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero addressed the Spanish parliament on October 13, 2008, responding to questions about the government's strategy to combat the global financial crisis and protect jobs.
Main themes
Employment protection, financial system liquidity, economic crisis response, coordinated European measures, stock market recovery, mortgage relief, Euribor decline, corporate layoffs, social dialogue, structural economic reform, confidence in financial system
Duration
~48 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,715
93rd percentile
Sentences
208
90th percentile
Readability
48
58th percentile
Grade
12.6
52nd percentile
Syntax
3.35
86th percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
22nd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 70%68%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Institutional 9%9%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

208 sentences in 86 paragraphs

Mr. President, now the only thing we ask is that these measures that have been taken and that have been positive reach where this liquidity needs to go: that it reaches companies and that it reaches citizens, to consumers; that this liquidity allows companies to maintain their investment, allows the continuity of these companies and the jobs they create, by financing their working capital, and also that it reaches citizens so that they can have the necessary credits to acquire vehicles, if they need them, so that people who can take on a mortgage at this time can also have mortgages, and, in any case, that the economy is stimulated.

Mr. President, today’s press gave us very good news: the stock markets have reacted appropriately and positively, with an increase of almost 11 percent in the IBEX, to the two trillion that Europe is putting into the system. But there were also two bad news items, Mr. President: there was the news of the ERE at Nissan, which threatened an ERE of 1,760 layoffs, and there was also the news of a possible ERE at Seat, which could affect 4,700 workers.

Now, Mr. President, the priority, the great challenge of this crisis, is employment and my question, Mr. President, is very clear: how does the Government plan to tackle this challenge and how will the Government defend jobs?

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Vilajoana, for your question. I must say that I agree with many of the things you have said and I only want to introduce some nuance into your reflection.

To what extent was the Government aware of the economic situation that I requested to appear in the Plenary precisely in September, and to talk about the economy has few precedents in our parliamentary tradition for the President of the Government to do so.

Second, the Government has always been aware that the fundamental problem of stagnation and the poor economic outlook in all developed countries, and unfortunately increasingly also in the so-called emerging countries, has to do with a lack of liquidity and a lack of functioning of the financial system that, of course, has an extraordinarily serious impact on the economy; on companies and on the entire economic system.

As has been demonstrated, which was the thesis maintained by the Government of Spain, the only measures that could change the situation, mark a turning point, and give rise to a moment of inflection were coordinated and strong measures. It is not enough for one country, as has been demonstrated, to announce plans or actions for the financial system; it has been useful when the entire euro area plus Great Britain, which represent 88 percent of the GDP of Europe, have put in place a powerful support plan for the financial system to ensure the economy functions.

It is true that yesterday there was good news and today there is also good news. The markets continue to respond favorably. There is another good piece of news: the Euribor has been falling for three days, which is especially needed by people committed to mortgages, and also that inflation is showing very good progress and is expected to continue to do so by the end of the year.

I also agree with Mr. Vilajoana that the fundamental problem of this situation is the impact on employment in our economy, an impact that, logically, we will only see recover when economic activity recovers globally. Jobs are created when the economy grows and when companies have objectives, new investments and not a situation of difficulty and lack of horizons, as they currently have.

To achieve this, what do we need to do? First, we need to restore confidence in the financial system; without confidence in the financial system, we will not recover economic activity and the steps taken, especially on Sunday, have been, in my opinion, decisive; second, we must act on all fronts in the internal sphere, strictly in the labor area to correct, mitigate and intensify the fight against unemployment through social dialogue, with measures from social dialogue: vocational training, active employment policies, and unemployment protection; and, in the general economic sphere, with structural reform measures that lead us to a more competitive economy when the cycle improves.

But I want to draw Your Excellency's attention to one fact. It has been said a lot that we had the problem of an excessive real estate sector, that our economy is more or less competitive… And all the European economies, Your Excellency, that do not have a real estate sector? Economies even with the most advanced sectors in R&D are in a situation of recession and blockage of their financial system. Look at Denmark or some other countries that we know are extraordinarily powerful as innovative economies.

Therefore, let us properly situate the focus or the etiology of the problem and we will know how to provide a response that should not divert us from doing the things we need to do in our country.

Mr. Vilajoana.- Mr. President, I am pleased to share this diagnosis that employment is the priority at this time for your Government and it is for this Group.

Mr. President, in the last forty-eight hours you were in Europe in very positive dialogue, let it be clear; we are very satisfied with what happened this weekend in Europe. But you met with President Sarkozy and Chancellor Merkel. Sarkozy, as reported in the press, spoke with the President of Renault and Nissan, Mr. Ghosn, and told him: "please, Renault cars must be manufactured in France." I ask you, Mr. President, did you talk to Sarkozy about this issue? Renault is in Spain, it is in Valladolid, and Nissan is in Barcelona. I believe it is essential that at this time the European Union also works in this direction, and this is a bit the line when I raised the need…

That is, it is very good that in the 2009 Budget the resources allocated to unemployment benefits increase by 24 percent; very positive, Mr. President. But, on the other hand, we are concerned that the resources allocated to active employment policies are reduced by 1.3 percent. Where am I going, President? I agree with social dialogue, which also needs a certain calendar and priority objectives, which we do not have or this senator does not know, Mr. President; it is essential that you have that, that it carries a calendar and that it carries priorities. But it is fundamental to preserve jobs and in this sense active employment policies must be combined with passive employment policies. In this sense, the right balance is the solution.

On the other hand, we must make a very important effort. It is true that in times of crisis it is difficult to create new jobs, but we believe in this economy, we believe in small and medium-sized enterprises. In Spain, in this country, there are small and medium-sized companies that are exporting and that this economic model that we must build is already being built.

We fundamentally believe that this country will be able to get out of this situation; but we would like, Mr. President, that, just as we have properly focused on the issue of liquidity and the issue of ensuring the financial system, we now need to make a special effort on the part of your Government to find solutions to resolve the other major issue we will have, which will also affect us very clearly in 2009, which is employment.

I ask you, Mr. President, to make a special effort in this direction and that this dialogue with Europe also leads us to seek solutions in this line of how we achieve that Seat, which is a multinational but is located in Spain, and that Renault, which is a multinational but is located in Spain, maintain their productions; that Volkswagen does not reduce production in Pamplona and that, therefore, we maintain employment as the maximum priority of this Government.

President.- Mr. Vilajoana, it is worth remembering that the problems facing the automotive sector are closely related to the drop in demand, fundamentally, in Europe, because our production is exported approximately 80 percent. So, it affects less what is…

I can tell you—I am glad you asked the question—that, indeed, I was talking with President Sarkozy about Renault. We have set ourselves a deadline of three weeks to work together and try to find a response that can satisfy both countries. Of course, it has also been a priority concern in these days, apart from the issue of the financial system and the response.

I also agree that one of the tasks we have ahead of us, and which also has very positive signs, because the data this year has been very favorable, is to strengthen the export capacity of our economy. I believe we will end the year with very favorable export data and, therefore, that field in which more and more small and medium-sized enterprises are entering is fundamental as a source of maintaining activity, fundamentally in countries, let’s say, not mature for our exports, such as the euro area or the European Union.

The data showing improvement in those exports that are occurring this year in a more significant way are precisely in countries that are not in the European Union zone. There we have a good source of activity, just as the Government will be in monitoring, in dialogue, and in support of all industrial sectors that may currently be facing difficulties, starting with the automotive sector. I can assure you of that.

And, of course, we will respond and inform about all the actions we carry out, just as we will about social dialogue, which I believe is a fundamental lever to address the part of active employment and unemployment for our society.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Carles Josep Bonet, of the Catalan Progress Entente Parliamentary Group

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Bonet.- The question will address the necessary change of the Spanish economic model.

Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, there is no doubt that we are facing a crisis that has its origin in the United States, but it is a fact that it has burst the Spanish real estate bubble. We may have a banking system free of toxins, but the issue is that the economy has grown led by the real estate sector. The data from the National Institute of Statistics, excuse me, what was I thinking?, is clear: it turns out that from 1995 to 2007 construction grew by 273 percent, double that of services and triple that of industry; an economy of continuous booms where the financial sector has been at its service. During this same period, credit to construction has risen from 20 to 50 percent.

If this serious imbalance is added to the large external deficit, which in these same years has gone from being practically zero to reaching 11 percent of GDP, the diagnosis is clear: Spain has lived beyond its means.

Surely for all that has happened there is not a single culprit; we are all sinners. (Mr. Rajoy said the other day that he had learned to be quiet. I don’t know if you…) For some time now, we have all been proclaiming, and also in this Chamber, the need to free ourselves from this model that has had shameful and vulgar episodes, I would say; but they have been ritual declarations because deep down we did not believe it would burst. International reports, such as "The Economist" in April of last year, warned us and we thought they were doomsayers or envious.

Mr. President, there is no doubt that now the immediate challenge is to regain confidence; confidence in politics. People perceive that we are facing a very serious problem, so coarse declarations are unnecessary; they only cloud and discredit politics. Now is the time for truthful and responsible politics, it is time for politics to lead the economy and not the other way around. The recovery of this confidence must be the first concern and for that we all must contribute something.

But there is another challenge, Mr. President, perhaps not as urgent but equally important, and that is to ensure that when we emerge from the crisis, the economy goes in another direction. Today in this hemicycle they will ask you for guarantees that the planned aid reaches citizens and SMEs. I completely agree, they are not unnecessary, although I suppose the Government and the Governments of the European Union will not be naive in not putting safeguards; but, in addition to this, there should also be certain guarantees that all the measures announced do not lead to repeating the same economic model.

The party is over, we will all pay for it, and, according to experts, in the end we will all be 30 percent poorer. But this urban planning binge cannot be repeated. Relaunching the economy, yes, but not the same economy.

The change will not be easy and there are already pressures to continue as before. The Association of Promoters is already pushing to reactivate the sector as before. Even the Minister of Housing is already saying that it is crucial for financial institutions to bet on the future of real estate companies again. The Federation of Municipalities is already calling for a large construction plan offering the construction of hundreds of thousands of homes. But what do we intend? To go back to the same thing? To build a new Seseña, a new Marbella?

A long time ago, in the Entesa, we have been presenting parliamentary initiatives on this issue. We have asked you questions, Mr. President, and a motion on R&D+i that contributed to a Conference of Presidents, etc. If now fifty billion are going to be allocated to buy assets and another one hundred billion in guarantees, why don’t we allocate something to redefine the model?

Mr. President, since the 1980s, the dogma has been established that industry should not be subsidized; a dogma adopted by the liquidation of the obsolete industries of the INI, not the INE. Agreed, industry must be competitive, but banks and construction companies must be too. If we cannot help the former, we should not help the latter either. It is very easy, too easy, to create urban business: one line more over there, another one more up, on a plan, "et voilà." As long as it is this easy, there is unfair competition between construction and industry.

It has been said that the crisis was confined to construction, but industrial production fell by 9.5 percent in June of this year compared to the same month last year, the largest drop since April 1993; a decline even worse than that of construction and which confirms the suspicion that industry has had no choice but to lag behind.

In the Entesa, Mr. President, as a Catalan group that we are, we fully embrace the industrial tradition of Catalonia; a tradition but a reality. Catalonia represents 26 percent of the industrial output of Spain, a weight that has been maintained despite these years of urban boom that monopolized investment. It is an industry of small and medium-sized enterprises, but many are also linked to large companies, such as SEAT or Nissan among others, which are now facing difficulties. And now, in this crisis, they also deserve to be helped.

I am finishing, Mr. President. It is not that we want to resurrect Catalan protectionism in the Cortes, but if banks and construction companies are protected, industry can also be helped. Is there not a comparative grievance between the refusal at the time to help textiles, or footwear, or metallurgy, and yes, on the other hand, rescuing Banking or large real estate companies now?

Mr. President, there is no doubt that today we are already in an intervened economy and now, since we are going to intervene, we can also plan, and this is the time to plan a new economy, so that credit is directed to finance a balanced economy, to ensure there is a balance between the structure of GDP, between construction, services, and industry, comparable to that of the countries around us, and to a realistic external deficit with our real wealth. Don’t you think so, Mr. President?

President.- Mr. Bonet, it is true that we live in times when classic ideological parameters may be under some revision. We have seen how governments with very liberal labels have revealed themselves to be the most interventionist, even in a sector like the financial sector, and this can logically provoke a certain perplexity and a revision of all the principles that have been defended by political families.

I must tell you, however, that I am not in favor of planning. I believe there are sufficiently clear examples to demonstrate that it is a model that does not work. I am in favor of defending the public, of defending a functioning state; a state that energizes private activity, that allows society to create wealth, but a state that guarantees, controls, regulates, and supervises what represents economic activity, especially the financial system.

Therefore, I would like to make a clarification that links a bit with the question posed by the spokesperson of Convergència i Unió, because I have a certain concern about how we dimension or misinterpret the angle of our view when analyzing the keys to the Spanish economy, its recovery, and what has happened in these years.

The residential construction sector contributes 9.4 percent to GDP; therefore, ninety-something percent, 91 percent of the economy, are services, industry, and agriculture. That is to say, we must dimension it. Neither has the Spanish economy grown due to construction, nor is residential construction the cause of the problems currently faced by the automotive sector, which is related to a crisis of automobile demand and generalized consumption in all developed countries. Otherwise, we will not situate the reality of things.

Residential construction will continue in our country and will continue to be higher than in other countries, because very few countries in our European environment have a population growth like ours and a demand for household formation like Spain, which is one of the causes that explains the strong pull of the real estate sector, which experienced excessive figures in 2004, 2005, 2006, and 2007, with 600 or 700,000 homes started, which will fall to around 300,000, but in a normal situation, at least around 400,000 due to the formation of households that occur, it is logical that they are built in Spain.

Therefore, let us place things in their proper terms.

But it is true that our economy, and it has been an objective of the Government I preside over, needs an injection of innovation and competitiveness. We thought this from day one, and that is why we have made the greatest effort in increasing investment in R&D+i that any government has made in the democratic period: we went from 2.9 billion euros to 7.678 billion. And we have important technological sectors with great international competitiveness, we have good technology companies and sectors, such as renewable energies or biotechnology, that compete with the most advanced countries.

Furthermore, to improve that economic model we need to improve education, especially the enrollment rates of young people up to eighteen years old. Therefore, the effort to implement educational laws is fundamental.

We need to continue maintaining a strong pace of investment in physical capital, and that is why we launched the Strategic Transport Infrastructure Plan and we will maintain, even in this situation, in 2009 an investment of 7 percent in infrastructure.

That is why we need to continue investing more in R&D+i, as we will do in the 2009 Budget, maintaining a 7 percent increase.

An essential issue for our competitiveness and for the improvement of our model is the reform of Vocational Training, and all members of this Chamber know it. It is the priority objective at this moment of social dialogue. It must be done with employers, unions, and Autonomous Communities, and we are working there in an absolutely intense manner.

Finally, I will tell you, Mr. Bonet, that we are not going to be 30 percent poorer; I can assure you of that. We are going to have a period of economic difficulty, where it will be hard for us to grow; but this country is strong, solid, and we will recover the capacity for growth in a reasonable time, as well as for job creation. We will not lose that wealth you speak of, fortunately for all.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Pío García-Escudero, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. García-Escudero.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, the main problem that Spain has today is unemployment, and that is why I would ask you to be a little more precise and tell me what measures your Government is going to take to stop the growing destruction of jobs that exists today in Spain.

President.- Mr. García-Escudero, I will make a clarification on the issue of unemployment, which is the line of your question, the content of your question.

In the year 2000, which was a good economic year, as we all know -- you remember it perfectly, it was the year of "Spain is doing well" -- there was a 13.7 percent unemployment rate in our country. At that time, the active population of Spain was 18,200,000 people. At this moment, in a situation of, as the International Monetary Fund has said, global recession worldwide, we are with three points less in the unemployment rate than in the year 2000 and 4,600,000 more people willing to work; I repeat, 4,600,000 more people willing to work, because we have a great growth in the active population. Therefore, I simply give you the data to place things in their proper terms. Moreover, we have the most extensive unemployment protection system we have had throughout the democratic period.

Is this any argument of consolation, any justification? Absolutely not, because I agree with Your Lordship that the primary concern of society and the Government is employment. So much so that in the last Legislature, in a favorable economic moment, we were able to collaborate with society to create 2,800,000 jobs and place the unemployment rate at the lowest level in history: at 8.6 percent.

Therefore, our main objective and concern is to maintain employment and create jobs. Your Lordship knows very well that this fundamentally depends on economic activity: when there is strong economic activity, jobs are created in Spain, as in all countries; when there is stagnant, negative economic activity, as we are in at this moment, unfortunately, jobs are destroyed.

We must act on active and passive employment policies. We are doing so, if I may, I believe in the area that can yield the most favorable results: with employers and unions; with the Government we design alternatives, seek responses, implement projects, and attend to specific sectors.

I believe this is the best method, and for that method and for that path to mitigate the increase in unemployment and to prepare the country to recover the capacity to create jobs as soon as possible, the Government is pouring all its budgetary, political, and legal resources, always from consensus with employers and unions. And, if possible -- I know it is not easy -- also in dialogue with your party, as I will try to do shortly with Mr. Rajoy, it would certainly be extraordinarily positive and enriching for me.

Mr. García-Escudero.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, to put things in context, in 1996 there was a 23 percent unemployment rate, a 23 percent, and, to also put things in context, just seven months ago, during the electoral campaign, you promised that we would have full employment in this Legislature. You said there was no economic crisis, and you said our financial system was in the "Champions League"; just seven months ago.

Of course, one thing is to preach and another thing is to deliver, and the problem is that today in Spain we have a crisis that we are experiencing with much greater severity than the rest of Europe, including the French and Italians, because in Spain today one hundred thousand jobs are being destroyed each month, which is not happening in the rest of Europe, and the financial situation we have is just as delicate as in the rest of Europe, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero. It is a crisis that is severely affecting our real economy, our productive model, and that has a tremendous social impact because, unfortunately, today -- as I told you before -- after many years, the main problem that Spain is facing is unemployment.

Today there are in Spain, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, 2,600,000 unemployed; 600,000 more than a year ago, a 30 percent increase compared to a year ago. We have gone from 8 percent to 11 percent in just one year.

We have the dubious honor, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, of being at the forefront of Europe in total unemployment rate, in female unemployment, in youth unemployment, and in job destruction per year. There are already more than 550,000 Spanish families, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, who have all their members unemployed. It is true that unemployment started in construction, but it is also true that it has quickly spread to all sectors of the economy, mainly to industry and services.

All this, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, are objective, real, and tangible data. Just as, as you said before, Spain was doing well in the year 2000, what I can tell you now, and it is also tangible and objective, is that Spaniards are living much worse than five years ago.

We think it is very good, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, that you increase the guarantee of bank deposits to one hundred thousand euros, but we are much more concerned about those millions of Spanish families who are eating away their savings day by day due to rising prices, due to rising mortgages, or due to job loss.

Because, you see, in just one year, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, defaults by families and companies have increased by 90 percent, because there is no money to pay debts. Mortgage delinquency and credit card debts have increased dramatically, because there is no money to pay debts. The auctions of foreclosed homes have tripled in just two years, because there is no money to pay mortgages. The sales of VPO homes are either not covered, or the awardees have to give up their homes because they do not have credit to face the mortgage. Car sales, which we talked about earlier, have dropped in September in Spain by 34 percent and, interestingly, and it is very indicative, in the same month in France, sales increased by 8 percent.

Here in Spain, taxes continue to rise, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero. The price of a barrel of oil has halved, and that does not reflect in the price of gasoline. They are going to take away the famous four hundred euros in the Income Tax next year because they are not going to deflate the rate.

You spoke about Social Security. It has lost 470,000 affiliates just in the month of September.

Seventy-seven percent of Spaniards confess that they have reduced their spending on clothing, footwear, appliances, and leisure. What is the consequence? Closure of industries, closure of businesses, more unemployment.

It turns out that the dining rooms of Caritas are serving more than double the number of people compared to last year, just in the first half of this year, because there is more poverty.

That is why I ask you today, because it is my duty, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, what are you and your Government doing to stop this tremendous destruction of jobs? What are you going to do so that as many people as there are right now can meet their mortgage payments? What are you going to do to prevent the closure, which is happening, of so many small and medium-sized enterprises? How are you going to reactivate consumption, which is currently paralyzed?

Can you still claim, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, that the Budgets you have presented will get us out of the crisis? Let’s be realistic, isn’t it better to withdraw them and redo them, with greater rigor in the forecasts, as the International Monetary Fund is telling us, and with greater austerity in public spending, as the International Monetary Fund is telling us?

Or is part of your employment policy to increase the number of advisors, useless Ministries, and propaganda expenses? Or is part of your austerity policy also to increase the expenses that Aznar had in 2004 in Moncloa by 77.5 percent for next year?

Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, as Mr. Vilajoana was telling you earlier, and I repeat it: what are you waiting for to truly implement active employment policies instead of reducing budget allocations for job creation, as you do in your Budgets? Or are you going to wait for the forecasts of the International Monetary Fund to come true and for us to reach 15 percent unemployment, as they are telling us, for next year?

Do not limit yourself, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, to injecting 150 billion euros into the financial system; that is fine, but do not stop there. Because not only… And also through the decree, as you like to say; let’s not make a Bill, lest the opposition, which you have marginalized as always, come up with ideas or amendments.

You must admit, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, that Parliament should control that huge amount of money, because it is a huge amount of money, through a transparency commission, so that this money truly reaches where it needs to go: to small and medium-sized enterprises and families, so that they can access credit, so that jobs can be created, not just to bail out the Banks.

You must prevent, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, that the payers of this tremendous public debt that is going to be created, this indebtedness, are not always the same, the citizens, and, as always, through a tax increase.

I tell you, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, take it seriously. Truly adopt active employment policies and stop circling around the issue of unemployment. It is very serious. Now, if you want, you can blame us, and if you want, you can blame the International Monetary Fund. That will please your congregation, but it will not get anyone out of unemployment nor will it help anyone pay their mortgage.

And I say it again: we are willing to give you our support, but also listen to the proposals made by the Popular Party. We have been trying to help you for many months by making effective proposals, and you have been rejecting all the proposals that come from the Popular Party for many months. If you continue to do so, you will certainly not achieve that we become complicit in the failure you are having in employment policies.

President.- Mr. García-Escudero, it is true, all Spaniards know that they think of nothing but supporting me. They see it day by day and have seen it over these five years with your opposition attitude on all issues, even the most sensitive for Spain. They think of nothing else.

I can invite you to make a consideration, if we can have a debate that is objective and rational; a debate in which we place ourselves, for example, in the electoral campaign to which you referred. Do you think that in March, in the months of February or March, when we held the electoral campaign, there was any analyst, any media outlet, or any Government that predicted the near collapse of the financial system, that predicted the most serious crisis of the international financial system since the Great Depression of 1929?

Do you say yes? So, did all of you predict that the most important American banks would fail, would be nationalized, that the major European banks and the British, German banks, a good part of them, would fail? But to what extent can you play such a hypocritical game in the electoral political debate to say yes? To what extent? If you knew that the most serious moment for the international financial system was coming, how is it possible that your candidate, Mr. Rajoy, proposed and said that he would create 2,200,000 jobs in this Legislature and that the economy would grow by more than 2 percent?

You now have a problem, a serious problem, in the political debate: that for almost a year you have been defending and telling Spaniards that the economic problems, whether they evolved with more or less difficulties or more quickly, were only Spain's and were the fault of this Government, and now you have found that all your argument has collapsed because it has been seen that the problems came from the United States, were more serious than we thought, and have spread to the whole world, unfortunately, because it is going to cost us to get out of this situation.

Finally, we can agree on the data, on some of the ones you have given. I have not disputed what unemployment was in 1996, I have not disputed it, nor what it was in 2000. And I tell you, and I have recognized it on some occasions, I know it will be impossible for you to recognize anything, that I did not receive a bad economic inheritance. I have said it in Parliament, in the Congress of Deputies, because for me in politics honesty and truth also matter, and I hope they matter for everyone.

But there is one thing in which we are indeed different, Mr. García-Escudero, and in which I certainly do not feel close at all: it is in social insensitivity, because you, yes, when there were problems in the labor market, made a "decretazo" to take away rights from workers and we have increased unemployment protection; you froze the Minimum Wage and we have increased it, and you froze minimum pensions and we have raised them. You do not have that sensitivity nor do you have the credibility to talk about families; we do because we have demonstrated it.