Press conference of the President of the Government after the meeting of the European Council

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

16 December 2008 · Press conference after the meeting of the European Council

Context
Zapatero addressed a press conference following the December 2008 European Council meeting in Brussels, summarizing key outcomes under France's EU presidency.
Main themes
European Council outcomes, French presidency of Sarkozy, European economic recovery plan, financial crisis response, Treaty of Lisbon and Ireland ratification, energy and climate change package, greenhouse gas emissions reduction, Eurogroup coordination, European Investment Bank, employment support, Stability and Growth Pact
Duration
~59 min
96th percentile
Words
7,052
96th percentile
Sentences
220
91st percentile
Readability
39
33rd percentile
Grade
15.6
81st percentile
Syntax
3.42
90th percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
15th percentile

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

220 sentences in 99 paragraphs

President .- Good morning. I would like to comment on the contents of this European Council, which is the last one under French Presidency, under the presidency of President Sarkozy, and has been a success, just as all his actions. Under this Presidency the European Union has been more united than ever and now it is stronger.

I would like to go through the initiatives implemented and the results obtained under the French Presidency since the dialogue with the Mediterranean through the Union for the Mediterranean was resumed; the coordinated, quick reaction against the financial crisis, through the agreement attained by the Eurogroup last 12 October, then the initiative implemented during the Washington Summit, followed by the promotion - together with the Commission- of a Plan for the Reactivation of Economy, which was finally approved of during this Council, together with the agreement on energy and climatic change.

Besides, this council has also dealt with the Treaty of Lisbon, which has recovered its potential through an agreement subscribed by all the countries taking part in this Council, an agreement that allows us to face facts and keep up our hopes for the implementation of the Treaty of Lisbon, which, as you all know, is an essential element for the future and the efficiency of the European Union, for the European Union to become more articulate and to keep progressing and adapting to the new times and to its new dimensions.

Thus, I would like to congratulate the French Presidency and, in particular, President Sarkozy.

As you all know, the Council's agenda this time included three main issues; three transcendental issues, namely, the approval of the set of economic measures to face the financial crisis and, in particular, the economic crisis - which was a consequence of the financial crisis -, then, Ireland's ratification of the Treaty of Lisbon and, finally, the approval of the set of measures on energy in order to face climatic change.

As to the Plan on Economic Measures, I would like to point out the fact that Europe keeps acting in a coordinated way in order to face the current difficult economic situation: thus, last October, the Eurogroup decided to carry out a coordinated action in order to unblock the financial system; last November, the Washington Summit was carried out and now, on December, we have approved of the European Plan for the Recovery of Economy, in consonance with the suggestions put forward at the Washington summit last 15 November.

The European Council has decided that the budgetary efforts will match the proposal of the European Commission, totalling two hundred and thousand million Euros, that is to say, 1.5% of the European Gross Domestic Product. The Member States, as you all know, are living different situations and, logically enough, there has been some flexibility in order to make up for this.

Still, the Council has established a set of common guidelines concerning the actions that must be undertaken: thus, in the first place, supporting the demands of economy, a provisional immediate support focussed on specific activities; in the second place, these economic measures may materialise either through greater public expenditure, or through tax reductions and also transfers and aids for families or for the less-favoured sectors - namely, the vehicle or the construction sectors. The Lisbon Strategy will be the strategic reference for these extraordinary, complementary, provisional investments intended to improve the general situation of Spanish economy.

Besides, as you all know, the European Commission will invest five million Euros more in energy infrastructures, research, innovation --specially to promote the wide band-and in energy efficiency.

Besides, we will also promote employment through the European Social Fund and through the European Globalisation Adjustment Fund. Moreover, the European Investment Bank will provide one thousand million Euros to finance investment projects.

All these actions will be implemented respecting the ongoing budgetary stability agreements and using the flexible margin of manoeuvre offered by the Stability and Growth Pact. We have also approved of a more favourable contexts for companies through the flexibilisation of the public aids' system.

Besides, the Council has channelled the economic situation of financial markets and it has established that it is necessary to keep on working in order to adopt the necessary measures so that the measures implemented so far to instil the financial system with liquidity may have the results intended making credit available both for companies and families.

The second essential issue dealt with by this Council was the set of measures on climatic change and energy. We are happy for we have reached an agreement this time, and you know it wasn't easy, on energy and climatic change. This agreement includes the necessary measures so that our greenhouse gas emissions may reduce by 20% and so that 20% of our energy consumption may come from renewable sources by 2010. This is an essential measure to fight climatic change in the world. And let me stress that it is thanks to this agreement that Europe become s a leader and an example for the implementation of a global agreement on emission reduction, the most ambitious and the widest agreement ever, even more than the one established through the Kyoto Protocol.

The use of renewable energies and bio fuels is a good thing for Spain, for it lays the foundations for the reduction of our energy dependence in the long term. And let me stress the fact that the environmental goals and our industrial development and competitiveness are compatible thanks to this agreement.

Thus, and in order to avoid a loss of competitiveness in the European firms - versus those of non-EU countries where no emission-reduction requisites are to be met - we have agreed on granting free emission permits to those industrial sectors that have higher export rates and also to those whose costs would increase considerably as a result of the agreement.

This set of measures on energy and climatic change is going to demand a great effort from all countries, from all companies and from all citizens, but we are convinced that the economic costs would be higher, by far, if we did not implement the necessary reduction measures proposed.

Thus, this is an economic-oriented agreement, and also an agreement with an environmental, ethical goal; a fair agreement, for it involves the balanced distribution of the economic efforts among the Member States.

Besides, the agreement is a great chance for Spanish renewable energy and bio fuel industry to develop. This is an area in which our companies have become world leaders thanks to the promotion of competitiveness and innovation and, these will be surely enough two main factors.

As to the Treaty of Lisbon, the Council has corroborated that it is an essential legal frame for the future of the Union, so that Europe may work with greater efficiency and democracy. Thus, we have designed an "action plan" to make up for the situation generated after Ireland's No vote.

The Council and Ireland have reached an agreement whereby this country undertakes to resume the ratification process so that the Treaty may come into force before the current period is over. The Member States have accepted the Irish proposals concerning the preservation of its special regime in questions such as neutrality, Corporate Taxes and abortion.

Similarly, the Council has accepted Ireland's proposal to keep one Commissar per Member State, which, as you all know, is also satisfactory for other States. This is an essential move in the ratification process.

Spain has always considered the ratification an essential issue and, thus, we are glad to have reached an agreement; and today's agreement must culminate with the implementation of this new legal frame for Europe by the end of 2009.

We are also satisfied about the fact that the council has made a decision concerning the European Parliament. As you all know, as a consequence of the Treaty of Lisbon and of the institutional reorganisation, the composition of the European Parliament had been extended, and this benefited in particular Spain, for we gained four more seats. Of course, this would not materialise until the Treaty of Lisbon comes into force and, since the European election is going to take place next June, we have proposed that this point should be taken into account and that once the Treaty of Lisbon enters into force - by the end of 2009 or in 2010 - this situation may be corrected and Spain may have the four additional Deputies as stated in the Treaty of Lisbon, in spite of the fact that the European election will take place before the Treaty of Lisbon is fully ratified. Thus, the deadline is 2010, that is to say, soon after the elections for the European Parliament, which, as you all know, will take place in June 2009.

To conclude, the Council has also dealt with several issues concerning Foreign Safety and Defence Policies. Thus, on the one hand, it has assumed the conclusions and suggestions concerning the competences of the Union for the Mediterranean - including, as you all know, the decision to locate the Headquarters of the Secretariat in Barcelona - put forward by the Ministerial Meeting in Marseille. It has also encouraged the elaboration of the so-called Eastern Partnership Initiative, which is the result of the Eastern dimension of the European neighbourhood policy.

As to European safety and defence policies, the Council has approved of a Declaration that includes the main principles of these policies for the next few years. It has also updated the European Safety Strategy elaborated back in 2003, recognising the existence of old and new threats, and establishing a goal for the next few years, namely, endowing the European Union with the capacity to mobilise up to sixty thousand soldiers. This will allow the European Union to carry out simultaneous civil and military operations outside its territory in order to face any future crises.

The Council has also set up another goal whereby the European Union would play a more active, efficient role with regards to great international safety issues, namely, the fight against terrorism, the increase of weapons of mass destruction, organised crime and cybernetic attacks.

As to the situation in Congo, the Ministers of Foreign Affairs had the chance to listen to the report of the High Representative for the Common Foreign and Security Policy, Javier Solana, who will travel next Monday to New York in order to meet the General UN Secretary and get an insight into the needs of the United Nations. Once Javier Solana informs about the results of that meeting, the European Union will decided on the best way to cooperate with the United Nations in this country in order to help it overcome the difficult situation it is going through.

Thus, this European Council has been a chance to establish agreements and to get results, and it has served to overcome two important challenges: the recovery of the Treaty of Lisbon, as an attempt to facilitate its implementation, and the agreement on energy and climatic change. Therefore, we should make a positive, a very positive assessment.

Journalist .- Mr. President, I will ask something about this last issue you have been commenting on, about Congo; I would like to know whether or not Spain would be in favour of sending troops to this country under the auspices of the UN and whether or not part of those troops would be formed by Spanish soldiers, given that, as the Minister of Defence said a few days ago at the Parliament, we have surpassed the limit of Spanish soldiers abroad.

And, another question that is not related to this Council, I would like to know whether you could tell us something about the way in which the Government would dissolve the twenty four Municipalities governed by ANV.

President .- As to the question of Congo, I have just explained that this matter depends on Javier Solana, after the Summit with the General UN Secretary, and then the EU members should elaborate a proposal. I think that as soon as we know what that proposal is about we will say something as to the EU actuation and intervention possibilities in Congo.

But let me add that this has nothing to do with the words of the Minister of Defence, which were a mere reference to the update of the Law on Defence as far as our participation in missions abroad is concerned, missions that, logically enough, follow the guidelines of the United Nations and are approved of and supported by the Parliament.

This figure, seven thousand soldiers, is not new; this is the operative capacity of our country. This is not a political decision, but a transfer of the technical capacity of our Army at present. It has nothing to do with future missions or with possible expansions. I just wanted to stress this fact.

As to ANV, I would like to say a couple of things: in the first place, the task carried out by the Government and by the State Security Forces and the cooperation with France are already producing successful results in the fight against ETA, which is under constant vigilance, and important members of the group have also been arrested. Besides, we are sure that we are going to keep working positively and obtaining such good results in the near future. All the political forces and, in my opinion, all citizens, can see and assume this, for it is our aim.

The Government has implemented a strategy to reduce ETA's operational capacity and to reduce the social support and comprehension it receives, and we are obtaining good results as a consequence of this strategy, I insist.

I have asked all the political parties more than once for maximum cooperation - for I deem it essential. This cooperation means that the management of anti-terrorist policies, of the defence of freedom, safety and the constitutional organisation depends on the Government. I would like this cooperation, which has been a reasonable demand from the beginning of this Legislature, to keep on progressing and I would like partisan attitudes on the side of political parties - and I am thinking of the PP now -, Municipalities and circumstances to be dropped.

I can tell the public opinion, I can tell citizens that the government knows what it is doing and it will act when necessary, according to the Law. I just demand cooperation , for citizens would like us not to turn the fight against terrorism into the scenario of partisan, unilateral initiatives, because what citizens want and what the fight against terrorism needs is unity, common sense and understanding. I think that I can say this, given the data I have just commented on.

We are on the good way to reduce ETA's capacity, to reduce the capacity of terrorism and to bring violence to an end. And I make a general calling for cooperation, among other things, considering the legitimacy of the Socialist Party in this sense, for it has always worked in this direction.

Journalist .- Mr. President, I have a couple of questions, the first one is rather technical. Since last June, I know that many Spanish regions feel uncomfortable about the fact that the requisites applied by the European Commission to grant the Structural Funds concerning the Financial Prospects - both the Berlin prospects and the new ones, specially, the 2006 Regulations - are the reason why certain funds that should have been received are not being paid. And I know that certain budgetary reductions are going to be implemented, not due to specific problems, but because the administrative requisites established by the Commission are not fully met or cannot be met. Thus, I would like to know whether the decisions approved of during this Summit in order to encourage the payments from the European Fund for Regional Development, European Social Fund, are going to affect this situation somehow.

The second question has to do with the question of Ireland and the institutional reform, for, after the great efforts carried out during the 90's and by the beginning of the current decade in order to implement a specific institutional organisation, whose main point was the two-thirds of the Commission; how can it be justified for a country to say no and laying waste those efforts?

President.- The last question has a rather evident answer, for, if one single country says no, the Treaty of Lisbon cannot come into force. These are our rules.

Thus, we must do our best to make all countries agree, as we have always done, whenever the European Union has tried to implement any normative changes, and the Commission will have to make an effort so as to reach efficiency and agility proposing a composition in which all the member states are going to have one representative. This is going to demand a more innovating organisation and a more innovating attitude from the Commission, for it to be efficient.

And this is not a hindrance to the operation of the Commission, although it will be formed by many members. It will make things more complicate but, surely enough, the most important thing is the implementation of the Lisbon Treaty, because the institutional structure and the global contents of the Treaty serve to facilitate, improve and develop the European Union, its efficiency and a more democratic vision of Europe.

As to the first question, the different conclusions -and this was the main issue during the discussions on the economic situation held last night, during the supper-are aimed at turning fund availability and the availability of complementary investments on the side of the European Union and on the side of the Commission and the Member States into an essential matter, enhancing its agility, swiftness and urgent implementation. We are well aware of this. Thus, for instance, the Government of Spain has included an item endowed with eleven thousand million Euros for public investments in its plan to reactivate economy, an investment that will be implemented through the most agile, swiftest procedure contemplated by our laws, namely, providing the Municipalities with eight thousand million Euros so that they may develop productive investment projects amounting to five million Euros maximum, and create employment so as to reach the maximum administrative agility and efficiency according to our laws.

Thus, the Commission is already following the Council's mandate in this sense. The Commission expressed yesterday its proneness to enhance the efficiency of those investment processes and, of course, as far as European funds are concerned.

Journalist .- Mr. President, I would like to know whether, apart from the petition put forward by this Summit for the different financial entities to provide families and small and medium size enterprises with credits, the Spanish Government is going to implement any extraordinary measures so as to achieve this goal. Besides, I would also like to know whether you have had the chance to talk to your Greek colleague about the conflicts in Greece, which have extended to certain Spanish cities, and whether you think that these conflicts could intensify in our country.

President .- As to the second question, yes, I have briefly commented on the situation in Greece with Prime Minister Caramanlis. He has told me that he was sure that things were going to come back to normal soon and, of course, I hope that may happen as soon as possible.

As to the extension of these conflicts, I don't think it will take place.

As to the first question, we have already implemented a few extraordinary measures, as I explained yesterday to the Spanish businessmen. One of them consists in the endowment of ten thousand million Euros for small and medium size enterprises to finance their working capital. This money will be available after next 23 December at the different financial entities, and it will depend on the Official Credit Institute.

This is no longer a matter of making financial entities provide indirect credits through the measures we have already implemented; this is rather a matter of carrying out an urgent action, a special action implemented by the Government and totalling ten thousand million Euros for the working capital, and we have also implemented more urgent actions by modifying the traditional financing channels for the Small and Medium Size Enterprises through the Official Credit Institute; because now up to 40% of that credit can be used for something different from investments in new projects and it can now be used for complementary tasks, to cover other needs that serve to complete those investments. Thus, we have already implemented extraordinary measures.

As to the attitudes of the financial entities that, as all citizens know, have obtained an extraordinary financial support from the different Governments, I will just say a couple of things: in the first place, this was one of the main issues during last night's supper and I would say that there was unanimous concern about it. In this regard, I asked both the Commission and the European Central Bank -and Mr. Trichet was there too-to propose, to think of new formulae to speed up and guarantee credit liquidity, the liquidity all Governments have contributed to considerably, for families and companies.

I must also say that real economy, companies need liquidity urgently, but the financial measures were implemented just a few weeks ago and, thus, we must be confident that credit availability will improve progressively. And let me remind you of the fact that we have already carry out two auctions: the first one, as you will surely remember, this auction had more modest results as far as financial asset purchase was concerned; and the second one, the one held the day before yesterday, was an utter success because almost all the money provided by the Government in order to buy assets was used and it was attended by more than thirty entities.

This must be progressively implemented, just as the rest of the measures adopted by the European Central Bank so far. Let's say that some of the goals have been a success; for instance, the decrease of the Euribor. Since the Eurogroup and the European Central Bank implemented their respective measures, the Euribor has decreased progressively, and this has brought about a great relief , from the financial point of view, both for families and companies. In particular, for families in our country because, as everyone knows, mortgages take the Euribor as a reference and mortgage renewal is now going to bring about a reduction of the mortgage fees.

The Government is working on this situation, supporting the financial entities. A few days ago, the Vice President of Economy held a meeting with the financial entities, which explained their situation and put forward their arguments; but we will keep supporting financial entities, making them reach a commitment to provide credit according to the rules of market economy, of course. We cannot ask a bank to give credits without minimum guarantees, because, otherwise, we would surely give way to greater problems in the medium term, but we are going to make demands.

I insist that I asked the Commission and the European Central Bank to think of possible formulae to guarantee greater liquidity and credit circulation after having provided financial entities with support. I think that we need more time, even though I am aware of the urgent current needs and I think that liquidity will be recovered and improved.

Journalist .- Mr. President, the reduction of taxes is one of the measures foreseen in the reactivation plan, apart from public investments, and it is already being carried out in several European countries. Spain is going to eliminate the Property Increment Tax and, yet, the reduction of the VAT applied to the labour force in certain products is also being discussed. It seems that there is no agreement on this. I do not know Spain's position in this sense, is Spain going to defend its application? And, will any measures be implemented at the national level? For, the PP has demanded the reduction of the Corporate Tax, but it seems that this solution has been ruled out so far.

Besides, today the Council of Ministers has approved of a set of measures to defend the development of human rights. This week, the Minister of Foreign Affairs spoke before the Congress of Deputies about an issue concerning Human Rights, namely, the transfer of prisoners to Guantanamo. The Minister confirmed that the Government of José María Aznar made a decision in this sense, a decision that was included in an agreement of the Atlantic Council, in a resolution of the United Nations and in an agreement of the European Council. Considering the explanation provided by the Minister of Foreign Affairs, we need to know whether your Government would have made the same decision in those circumstances.

President .- As to the first question, the Government of Spain has implemented different fiscal measures that have resulted in the reduction of twenty thousand million Euros in 2008 and 2009, that is, two points of our Gross Domestic Product: we have reduced the Income Tax by four hundred Euros, through several normative changes. It seems strange to me to hear you say that we do not want to reduce the Corporate Tax, for we have already reduced it; we have reduced it by five points in this Legislature... And then there is the question of the anticipated VAT returns. A fiscal reduction that amounts to twenty thousand million Euros in 2008 and 2009, including the Property Increment Tax, which will come into force by 2009.

These fiscal reductions are direct measures intended to help companies and families improve their economic availability and capacity, their income.

In this context, fiscal reductions on indirect taxes, leaving aside the complexity of the European system in this sense as we have seen in this Council, can just be measures aimed at promoting saving, rather than consumption. Thus, in fact, right now, once the Government of Spain has already implemented a fiscal reduction that amounts to twenty thousand million Euros, the measures agreed on and promoted are the increase of public productive investments, which will amount to 33,000 million Euros next year: 22,000 million Euros contemplated in the Budgets, the increase of ordinary investments in infrastructures and environment, plus 11,000 million Euros through the Extraordinary Investment Plan: eight thousand million Euros for Municipalities and three thousand million Euros invested by the Government. That makes 33,000 million Euros more, that is to say, more than three points, 3.3 points, of our Gross Domestic Product. This is, in my opinion, the main goal.

As to the question about whether my Government would have reacted in a similar way to a demand of the Government of President Bush concerning the conflict of the CIA flights; that is easy. I think that the Government of President Bush would have never considered the possibility to ask my Government to act in such a way, to accept such actions, and that is rather evident. I am not going to go into any background issues, yet, since my first decision as President of the Government was withdrawing from Iraq, should the Administration of President Bush have considered the possibility to make any such petition, you can already imagine my reaction. They would have never considered any such possibilities, and the Government of Spain would have never considered it a positive petition and, thus, we would have never accepted it.

Journalist .- In the first place, as to Guantánamo, although this does not have anything to do with it, the Portuguese Government has proposed for European countries to admit prisoners with "clean" files, so to say. I would like to know whether you have commented on this, what you think about this proposal and whether Spain would admit any prisoners. In the second place, I would like to ask something about the Basque Country. You commented on the fact that the fight against terrorism should not damage pluralism and I would like to ask you whether you said so because you think that someone is already trying to damage pluralism or because you think that during the next elections for the Basque Parliament there should be candidates with a similar mentality to that of ANV. I would like you to explain this.

And, if I may, another question. I think that former ETA prisoners have organised an event that will be taking place tomorrow in order to talk about the situation in prison. I would like to ask you whether you think that the group is trying to dissuade possible dissidents or rebels.

President .- As to Guantánamo, I have already said it more than once: Guantánamo should have never been created. It is the worst of examples: the worst of examples for a country with a great democracy, in the United States, and the worst of examples for the world.

The possibility to close Guantánamo and to promote the cooperation of EU countries has not been considered. But I would like to say that I hope it is closed as soon as possible and that it may serve to dissuade any democracy from creating something similar to Guantánamo.

As to what I said a few days ago during the conference at the Centre for Constitutional Studies, I think that everyone shares it. Besides, when it comes to the fight against terrorism, we only think of the fight against ETA in our country, perhaps, and it is rather understandable, but I made a general statement about the fight against terrorism, and I wasn't just talking about respecting pluralism, but about respecting the Constitution and the Rule of Law. It was a declaration of principles that must be subscribed by all democrats for it has nothing to do with particular situations or with particular places and times.

If we consider the conference in general and if we come to think about it, we can see that this is its main idea. the question was whether the Constitution has been a good instrument to fight the enemies of freedom, to fight terrorism and to fight violence, and the answer is yes, it has always been and it still is, and, thus, it is not necessary to expand normative frames any further, neither in this sense, nor in the area of the fight against international terrorism.

Finally, I've only heard about the other question in a news broadcast this morning. I know nothing about the scope and contents of this declaration about ETA's prisoners and, thus, I must be prudent. The Government will make an assessment in due time, if it takes place.

Journalist .- You have congratulated Nicolas Sarkozy during the last Summit. During the press conference you said that he hopes to have proved that Europe needs a strong President and not just a president for six months. I would like to know whether you share this model.

President .- I have already said it and I think I have provided data: the balance of the European Presidency carried out by Nicolas Sarkozy has been successful and he has proved a capacity to act and to hold the initiative, in the first place and he has behaved as a leader. This has been a strong Presidency, yes, and this is good, mainly when facing difficult situations.

Besides, he has met the deadlines. He is exerts leadership and meets the goals, although some said that this Council, for instance, would go on for ages before reaching an agreement about the set of measures concerning energy and climatic change, he has a political capacity to facilitate consensus and to make participants respect the procedures and meet the deadlines, which, in my opinion, also transmits an image of strength and efficiency.

He has done it well and I agree with him when he says that Europe needs a strong Presidency once the Treaty of Lisbon comes into force. We are twenty seven countries, we are twenty seven Heads of State and Government and ruling over such reality demands strength, as everyone can surely understand. Journalist.- Just two weeks before the year is over -I imagine you already know what I am going to ask you , I would like to know…

President .- In fact, I don't…

Journalist. - …whether you still keep up your commitment, your compromise with President Montilla to get to a definitive agreement as far as the new regional financing model is concerned before the end of the year. Besides, I would like to ask you whether you think that this agreement could be ready before next Thursday, for the Congress will vote the new General State Budgets again next Thursday, or whether you think that these two issues, namely, the State Budgets and the new model of regional financing, have nothing to do.

President .- There will be an agreement on regional financing and it will be a good one for the whole regional system and for the different Autonomous Regions, because this agreement is based upon a central idea, as it will serve to improve the financial resources of all the Autonomous Regions and this improvement will be intended to enhance Welfare, education and health care. The agreement on regional financing is important because thanks to it the Autonomous Regions, which are in charge of education and health care, will have more resources to make greater investments and improve the quality of our schooling system and to preserve, keep up and improve our National Health Care System.

We will reach an agreement soon. I can't give you an exact date, but it will be soon.

The agreement on regional financing forms part of the electoral programme and of the programme put forward during my investiture. There is nothing more than that, which has, of course, very strong political implications. The other questions are completely redundant and worthless, but this is one of the most important issues of this Legislature and if we can make it and have it ready during the first part of the Legislature, it will be a great success.

Right now, the Government has four great goals: the Spanish Economy and Employment Stimulation Plan, the fight against terrorism, the Spanish EU Presidency - and the countdown has started today, for there is just one year to go for it - and the agreement on regional financing, which involves the improvement of education and health care. Thus, these area the four great issues, the four great priorities.

If we make it, if we establish an agreement on regional financing as soon as possible, before the end of the year, we will be satisfied, of course, considering that such an agreement takes a lot of work: Council on Fiscal and Financial Policy, the modification of the Law on the financing of the Autonomous Regions, etc. This agreement will have to be implemented in different stages and through different processes.

Journalist.- I would like to ask you about another compromise undertaken by you two weeks ago at the Congress of Deputies, for you asked the European Commission to open up the file of the Spanish shipyards. I would like to know whether you have made any moves in this sense on this occasion.

President.- Yes, we have been working on that lately because this is a good moment to raise this subject. As soon as we have any news, and we have none so far, we will inform people about them; but the thing is that the Commission is open to all those initiatives intended to propitiate the reactivation of economy and it is also open to the initiatives put forward by Spain.

Journalist .- Changing subject, I would like to know something, what are your expectations about tomorrow's match between Barcelona and Madrid?

These two cities are encouraging confrontation with more or less surprising statements. Thus, Lluis Llach said that "in a moment of political decay in Catalonia, beating the Real Madrid would be a good medicine".

President .- I fact, I have nothing to say about that. I just hope it is a good match, just as all football fans. The Madrid-Barcelona matches have always been a good chance to see good soccer. Both teams have really good players. And do not ask me more about it for you already know which one I support and I want to be prudent and respectful. Good luck for all and I hope fans will have fun.

Journalist .- Back to the question of human rights, a matter on which the Government is currently working, you have also mentioned the reform of the Law on Religious Freedom. The Government has commented on the possibility of applying it with greater determination from 2009 onwards and with the maximum consensus. Yet, the People's Party said -in fact, Federico Trillo, member of the Opus Dei, has said so- that the Government is interfering with individual and collective freedom and that, of course, it won't support this. I don't know whether the Government is going to reform this Law even without the support of the People's Party. Could you comment on this and say whether this would lead to a truly lay State?

President .- In fact, it would be more surprising to hear the People's Party - represented by Trillo or by any other - say that it is going to approve a reform proposed by my Government. The PP opposes all the liberal reforms aimed at catching up with the progress of time, be it at the legal level or at any other level, or at the level of rights and freedom, as is the case of Religious Freedom, because this party is highly conservative and it doesn't want things to change, for it thinks that things are the same as twenty five years ago.

Of course, the Law on Religious Freedom can be improved, and we are going to improve it.

As to the question of laicism, sometimes you get surprises. I have seen some headlines going "The lay attack of the Government in this Legislature". But we are in a non-denominational State and, moreover, as compared to any other State, even to any other EU State, for instance, it is characterised by the fact that it is highly favourable to the Catholic Church, in particular, according to the Constitution, which states that the Government and the Catholic Church should have a special relationship.

We are a moderate non-denominational State and, each time they refer to laicism as if it was a sort of risk, or even a threat, they are proving that they do not understand the meaning of laicism; which means, simply, democracy.

Democracy equals - almost - a lay, non-denominational vision, because among equal citizens in a democracy characterised by freedom all options can co-exist. The State must be neutral and guarantee freedom for all, and it should never impose any doctrines or give a specific doctrine a pre-eminent position. But this will surely cease to be a matter for discussion in one more generation in our country. I think that we should have already closed this debate time ago, but we will probably have to wait for one more generation to pass.

Journalist .- Mr. President, as to ANV, I haven't quite understood your explanation about whether the Government's actions with regards to the Municipalities governed by ANV are going to be carried out following the Provisions on the Regime of Municipalities or whether it will be carried out according to the reform of those Provisions; that is, whether you are already working on it or whether you are going to wait for a legal reform to be made at the Congress.

Then, another unrelated question. This morning, Prime Minister Gordon Brown has not confirmed explicitly whether or not Spain is going to attend the next G-20 Summit in London. I would like to know whether you have talked about this with him or not and whether you are still confident about our participation.

President .- Yes, I am confident about our participation just as I did before the Washington Summit.

As to your question about ANV, the Government can follow the Provisions concerning the Regime of Municipalities and it is considering the possibility to establish a new, more operative, useful context so as to try to preserve the goals we must attain, for no one, no public institution - be it a political party or a Municipality - should collaborate or cooperate in any way with a terrorist group.

And let me tell you that things must do properly, taking into account the competences of our Courts and also the facts and actions carried out by the different agents. The Government will do things well and in due time so that those initiatives intended to reduce connivance or cooperation with terrorist groups, in this case, ETA, are not prevented by any legal hindrance, as this is for me an essential priority according to what I have said on many occasions about the fact that the fight against terrorism, the fight against the enemies of freedom must be characterised by the firmest principles of democratic strength, by the most democratic principles, from the most respectful principles with democratic legality and with the values we must preserve.

If we are to preserve freedom, equality and political pluralism and the main values of the democratic legal system, we must face violent actions with a firm attitude of freedom, defending the Rule of Law and political pluralism so that the strength of the State, the authority of the State and the legitimacy of the State may become unchallenged both at the legal and at the social levels.

You should not get surprised at this idea, which is the one I always defend when it comes to the fight against international terrorism, exactly the same. This is why I acted the way I did time ago, when certain circumstances that have also been mentioned here took place.

But I can tell you that the Government has a strategy, we have the orientation and the means to reduce ETA's capacity progressively, to weaken the world of violence day by day and to weaken those that are looking forward to ETA's recovery. Facts speak for themselves and, I insist, facts will keep on being smashing.

Thank you very much