Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

16 December 2008 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions from Joan Ridao on autonomous community financing reform during a December 2008 congressional control session in Spain.
Main themes
Autonomous community financing reform, Catalonia fiscal policy, Esquerra Republicana political relations, parliamentary accountability, regional fiscal equity, education and health funding, government deadlines and trust, coalition politics
Duration
~14 min
49th percentile
Words
1,708
49th percentile
Sentences
65
43rd percentile
Readability
52
69th percentile
Grade
11.9
44th percentile
Syntax
3.29
81st percentile
Vocabulary
2.29
72nd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 66%63%
  • Economic 18%17%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

65 sentences in 32 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Joan Ridao, of the Parliamentary Group of Esquerra Republicana-Izquierda Unida-Iniciativa per Catalunya Verds

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Ridao.- I take the liberty of reproducing the question in its terms: having reached the end of the year, what does the Government have to explain about the future model of autonomous financing?

President.- Mr. Ridao, as you well know, and in compliance with the electoral program and the investiture speech, the Government, through the Ministry of Economy and Finance, approved a first document on the reform of autonomous financing in July, which was presented at the Council of Fiscal and Financial Policy and has led to a broad debate.

From there, the Government, along with the Ministry of Economy and Finance, has been conducting a phase of consultations, exchanges of opinions, and listening to all the Autonomous Communities, a phase that is about to conclude. At that moment, that is, in the coming days or weeks, the Government will make public a new document on the reform of financing for the Autonomous Communities, which we want to agree upon as quickly as possible, harmonizing, satisfying the compliance with regulatory prescriptions, and also achieving a more harmonious, more equitable system, with more fiscal responsibility, where all Autonomous Communities improve their resources to meet the priority needs of Education and Health.

Mr. Ridao.- Mr. President, last week, in this same control session, looking intently at these benches, with a perfectly studied pose, you reproached Mr. Rajoy for supporting the veto of Esquerra in the Senate.

Aside from the fact that you know perfectly well that our veto, like that of CiU or that of Iniciativa, was a Catalan veto, a territorial veto, to denounce your repeated failures in financing, and that the PP's vote was a tactical vote to erode the Government, but in no case an ideological vote. You took advantage of the circumstance to try to emulate the PP in politically excommunicating us, which I must say we found regrettable, among other things, because I suppose it was a fleeting episode of amnesia, because you forgot that until a few hours before, Esquerra was negotiating with you, and that in 2004 we invested you as President of the Government.

But, in any case, what truly keeps us awake at night and seems intolerable is your attitude towards financing. Your record with Catalonia is full of failures. All Catalan parties, including the PSC, have bitten into the apple of deception at some point.

You told us yesterday that there is time for an agreement, and now you speak of a few days, even weeks. You say this, who, by the way, has not met any deadlines, and it is not that we are in times of discounts, but that our clock has simply stopped.

The content is very important at this point, and the how much is almost more important than the when, but let me tell you that the forms are also important; they are the essence of democracy.

We want to be, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, optimistic. If there has been no money until now, I believe there will be; if there has been for the Town Halls and for the Banks, there will also be for the Autonomous Communities; but, in any case, let me tell you not to foist anything on us. Let me tell you not to try to cover a hole with any patch. You are a seasoned specialist in this type of acrobatics at the last second of the extension.

Let me finally say that the agreement must be a good agreement, and if it is not a good agreement, we will not sign it, of course. We have repeatedly said that a no agreement is better than a bad agreement, and, above all, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, do not stretch the rope any further. Do not stretch the rope any further, and above all, do not abuse our patience any more, because it is not infinite.

President.- Mr. Ridao, I respect that justifications are sought. Today we have learned a new concept of what a vote is: there is tactical vote, ideological vote, political vote... there is vote. Mr. Ridao, there is a vote, and the vote has been expressed, and each one does so based on the interests they have at any given moment. I know that it bothers you that the Popular Party voted for you, but that is what happened, Mr. Ridao; that is what happened.

I am very grateful for the vote that your Group gave me in the investiture. You will never have heard from this Government or from me any reproach regarding the initials of what your political formation represents; yes, logically, sometimes about the things it does.

Regarding the record, I believe that a little modesty should lead us all to say that it is the citizens who judge that. They have judged it in the general elections, and they have certainly judged it clearly in Catalonia, and I am glad that that majority progressive vote has been confirmed in that Autonomous Community. I am sure you also find it well given, moreover, the Government of which you are part in Catalonia.

But if commitments are judged by what citizens say, I believe we have reasonably fulfilled our commitments with Catalonia and we will reasonably fulfill our commitments with Catalonia and with Spain to create a good system of autonomous financing for all Communities. We want to do it well, not hastily; well and for everyone.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- The 2009 Budgets are outdated and surpassed by reality, as Mr. Solbes has said, who is no ordinary person, and that is why we voted no, and everyone agrees on this.

I remind you, Mr. President, that this is the most important instrument you have to fight against the economic crisis and unemployment. But, in addition, you are going to approve these Budgets with the support of a political party that thinks like everyone else and says so; that is, thinks like Mr. Solbes. That said, they vote for them and they vote for them because they achieve two things: the transfer of R&D and the establishment of a minimum retirement age for the Ertzaintza.

I ask you how these Budgets benefit the general interest, I ask you if the transfer of R&D is made in accordance with the general interest or for another reason, and if others have the right to this same transfer. And I ask you if the decision regarding the Ertzaintza is made for the general interest or for another reason, and if others, for example, the Mossos de Esquadra, have the same right or if it is necessary for either Convergència i Unió or Esquerra Republicana to support your Budgets to achieve the same that you have given to the Ertzaintza.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, as you know, and I have indicated on some occasions, the Budgets have two basic objectives: first, to boost the productive economy through investment in infrastructure and in R&D that increase, respectively, by 7.5 percent and 6.7 percent; second objective: the Budgets guarantee and reinforce social protection. Why? Because they raise low pensions by 6 percent, just like scholarships; dependency spending, by 33 percent and the housing aid budget, by 16 percent. That is to say, because they represent a great social advance.

Those are the two main objectives of the Budget, which for us are useful for 2009. And I will tell you that the agreements we reach with other Parliamentary Groups in this Chamber occur under exactly the same terms as those you reached in 1996, 1997, 1998, and 1999, except that at that time, perhaps, it was for the general interest and now, for other interests.

Have a little coherence and seriousness, and a little less hypocrisy, Mr. Rajoy.

Mr. Rajoy.- It is evident that Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero has not answered me because he cannot.

Look at what the Minister of Science and Technology said: "The transfer is the path to fragmentation. The transfer is not profitable for Euskadi. The funds received by the Basque Country will be higher, Minister—if the transfer is not made. The financing and solvency schemes of the State have difficulties competing in the international sphere." Is this what the Minister said true?

In the case of the Ertzaintza, I asked: Are the Mossos de Esquadra of worse condition or do those Parliamentary Groups have to vote for your Budgets for them to be treated equally?

Mr. President of the Government, here the general interest has not been taken into account, neither when drafting the Budget, which no one believes in, nor when adopting the transfer of R&D, which your Minister denied, nor when making decisions about the Ertzaintza, a matter to which you also denied and referred to the Toledo Pact.

What we have witnessed here, for you to have some Budgets approved that are worthless, is a colossal capitulation. That is what has happened.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, you may be unaware, but the Basque Autonomous Police has a system, until this moment when it is going to change, unequal because it has no procedure or formula, neither for second activity nor for early retirement starting at sixty years, unlike other Police forces. Therefore, it starts from an unequal situation, yes, and it is advisable that you know it.

Certainly, if you are very interested in talking about the policy of R&D, about what this transfer has meant, you can ask the Minister.

Finally, I will tell you, Mr. Rajoy, that I think it is advisable for you to leave the pants you referred to and apply a little more common sense, coherence, and rigor, because you agreed on four Budgets with CiU, with PNV, and with Coalición Canaria, and you agreed to apply Article 150.2, which you now say is the worst thing that can exist in the autonomous regime. Yes, you applied a transfer under Article 150.2 while governing with nationalist parties. And now, when we make agreements, it is disastrous for the general interest. It is not credible.