Press conference of the President of the Government after the meeting of the Council of Ministers.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

27 August 2009 · Press conference after the meeting of the Council of Ministers

Context
Zapatero held a post-Council of Ministers press conference in late August 2009, updating journalists on ETA counterterrorism operations and Spain's economic situation.
Main themes
Fight against ETA terrorism, anti-terrorist operations and arrests, economic crisis and recovery, government policy updates, ETA arsenal seizures, Spain-France security cooperation, Basque Country governance, GDP contraction and recovery outlook, employment recovery, rule of law
Duration
~78 min
97th percentile
Words
9,328
97th percentile
Sentences
306
95th percentile
Readability
39
34th percentile
Grade
15.3
78th percentile
Syntax
3.41
90th percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
30th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

306 sentences in 132 paragraphs

President.- I appear before you to fulfill the commitment to hold a press conference at each session on the balance, the situation, and the horizon of government action. On this occasion, this press conference takes place in the last part of August. I initially planned to do it in the last days of July, but the circumstances of the terrorist attacks led me to wait for this moment as more appropriate, after the celebration of the last Council of Ministers in July.

I want to begin this initial intervention by referring to the fight against terrorism in what we have experienced so far in 2009.

In this year, 2009, the terrorist group has murdered three public servants: police officer Eduardo Antonio Puelles García and two civil guards, Carlos Saínz de Tejada and Diego Salvá Lezaún. To them, my remembrance, and to their families, once again my support and affection.

As you know, during this period, so far this year, 62 members of the terrorist group ETA have been arrested; 25 of them in France. All of them are responsible for the forgery apparatus, the military apparatus, and information. This has demonstrated the progressive dismantling of the head of ETA carried out in recent months.

You know that when, after an attack, we proclaim emphatically and forcefully that its authors will be arrested, tried, and imprisoned, we do not do so as an expression of rage, nor even of pain, but to show an inflexible determination that ultimately becomes an evident fact: that the Police, the Civil Guard, and collaboration with France, the State Security Forces and Corps, arrest terrorists. They are arresting more terrorists each time, and they are arresting those who are engaged in terrorist activity earlier each time.

Along with the arrests, this month has seen the discovery of numerous arsenals of explosives and weapons from ETA. In particular, in recent days, up to fourteen caches have been discovered, in which more than seven hundred kilos of explosives, thirty handguns, a submachine gun, twenty-four containers in different stages of preparation to be used as limpet bombs, abundant ammunition, documentation, and computer and electronic material have been found, which constitutes, possibly, the largest material blow to ETA in recent years.

I want to reiterate my congratulations to the National Police for this last major operation regarding the results of the seizure of ETA material.

With this deactivation of a good part of ETA's arsenal, we have managed to deactivate the possibilities of causing harm, of inflicting pain, that those arsenals contained, but I must remind you that ETA still retains its capacity and will to kill. Therefore, we will not rest or falter for a single moment. We will continue to weaken ETA on all fronts and with the support of all democrats.

I want to thank all political and social forces for the support they have been providing to the government's anti-terrorist policy; support that makes us stronger; support that, along with collaboration with France, ensures that the rule of law will undoubtedly win the battle against violence and terror.

That gratitude has a special mention. That recognition of the contribution to the fight against terrorism, in the delegitimization of ETA's terrorism, that special gratitude is to the government of Patxi López, which is exemplarily leading the fight for freedom and against terror, the fight to end spaces of impunity and to extend social and democratic awareness of isolation and delegitimization of any type of violent action; in short, of ETA.

But, as you well know, during the last months, the bulk of the government's action has been focused on the fight against the economic crisis.

According to the latest data available, both from the evolution of the international economy and from the evolution of the Spanish economy, we can say that the acute phase of the crisis has already passed, but we still have to make a great collective effort so that recovery begins as soon as possible, so that it is based on solid foundations for the future and allows us to recover employment, which is the great objective, the main objective, of the government and Spanish society.

The growth figures in our country for the second quarter have just been made public. The contraction, in a negative phase, of recession, as we are, has been significantly lower than that recorded in the first quarter of the year. We have also learned in recent days that countries like France or Germany have recorded positive growth in the second quarter of this year. I must remind you that these are economies that began to record declines in GDP in the second quarter of 2008, that is, one quarter earlier than Spain did, and that their accumulated declines have been greater than ours. But the good data, which we hope will consolidate as recovery in France and Germany, is good news for the Spanish economy due to our connection, especially regarding the external sector, with these two countries.

We are, therefore, facing signs that the worst of the economic recession has passed, that the worst of job destruction and recession is behind us; but we will still have difficult months ahead until we see economic recovery and difficult months in employment until we can confirm the recovery of jobs. We must not forget that the financial indicators, the crisis, the recession that the world is experiencing, has its origin in a serious crisis of the financial system, have evolved favorably, and that must represent a solid foundation for economic recovery.

But I must insist: this does not mean that recovery will be immediate and, even more importantly, we must ensure that recovery is based on solid foundations to improve and to introduce the necessary reforms in our growth model, a growth model that, based on an excess in certain activities in the past, has resulted in a very high level of unemployment at the time of the economic recession, of the severe economic recession, which has destroyed nearly or around 1,300,000 jobs in the last year. That is a lot of unemployment in a very short time, and for that reason, we must ensure that recovery, the recovery model, results in a pattern of more sustainable economic growth, fundamentally from the point of view of job maintainability.

As you know, we launched a counter-cyclical plan, a plan in response to the crisis, known as the Plan E, a Plan to Stimulate the Economy and Employment, which has yielded results to mitigate the severe impact of the economic recession and its effect on employment; to alleviate in the construction sector, because with the Local Fund, four hundred thousand jobs have been created or maintained; to alleviate the difficulty and strangulation of credit because with more than ten billion euros from the ICO lines so far this year, financing has been provided to SMEs, self-employed individuals, and families, totaling 260,000 SMEs, families, and self-employed individuals, to mention just the most significant examples of that Plan. I could recall the Support Plan for the Automobile, but you already know it.

I want to emphasize, however, that throughout the process, in the entire period, difficult and hard, of the economic recession, there has been an irrenounceable objective of the government, an objective that we always maintain, and that is to preserve social cohesion, social protection, and the welfare state. Therefore, the government has maintained its commitment in social policy, in pensions, in minimum wage, in the extension of the Dependency Law, and, of course and above all, in the protection of individuals and families against the eventuality of unemployment; protection against unemployment that, as you know, the government has decided to increase.

The last Council of Ministers approved a measure to extend unemployment protection for those individuals who have exhausted their contributory benefit or assistance protection, a measure linked to a training activity to facilitate employability, a measure that has never been taken in democracy, never; that is to say, it is the measure that extends unemployment protection more than we have had at any time during the democratic period, a measure of a benefit of 420 euros for six months with training, to help individuals and families, of course regarding their situation and their income, but above all to help them find employment again.

As you know, the date of entry into force of this measure has been a subject of debate. Whenever a measure that implies a benefit, a right to a created situation, is to be applied, it is debatable when that entry into force can occur. I already stated a few days ago that the government wanted social consensus on the entry into force of the right to the new unemployment benefit, to the benefit of 420 euros, and we will do so. Through dialogue with the unions and dialogue with the Parliamentary Groups, we will establish the date of entry into force. Therefore, the government reiterates that it is open to modifying it so that it can benefit more people.

Furthermore, I must draw attention to the real, objective fact of the difficulty in assessing how many people will be able to receive this benefit, how many will apply for it, and how many people will therefore be within the scope of the Law. Surely any estimate made, regardless of the date we set for the entry into force of the right to the benefit, will be an estimate that must be taken with great caution, at least based on the data we have at this moment.

But, as I was saying, alongside social protection, social cohesion, as an irrenounceable objective, as a basic objective, to navigate this severe economic recession, the government is firmly committed to this new growth model. To this end, I want to announce to you what the instruments, the measures, that we are going to implement will be.

The main objective will be the Sustainable Economy Law and, of course, the Budgets for 2010.

The Sustainable Economy Law aims to incentivize this new growth model, but I must remind you that there are reforms underway that we must complete, that are in Parliament and that are broad reforms for the Spanish economy: the transposition of the European Services Directive, the Retail Trade Law, the reform of the electricity sector, or the entire Plan to reduce administrative burdens that the government is developing.

Alongside these reforms, the Sustainable Economy Law will be, as I said, the incentive for this new model, a model that must generate confidence in consumers and private investors. This Law will have five fundamental elements that the government is working on:

First, the Law will introduce principles of good economic regulation, with the goal of creating a stable and predictable regulatory framework, with a low level of administrative burdens, greater transparency, and an incorporation of principles that will guide the reform of the sectoral regulatory bodies that the government has committed to.

Second, it will support business dynamism and competitiveness, streamlining the creation of companies and betting on their internationalization, also streamlining public procurement and enhancing the use of public-private collaboration mechanisms, not only in transport infrastructure but also in environmental, energy, or technological areas.

Third, reforms of educational structures and their linkage to the productive system will be proposed so that human capital and training are an essential pillar of the productive system; that is to say, the entire program of reform of Vocational Training.

Fourth, there will be a set of fiscal incentives, both structural and temporary, where, in addition to those already announced in the past State of the Nation Debate for the housing market and the maintenance of employment in SMEs, incentives for business activities in research, technological development, and innovation will be reinforced.

Finally, as you already know, two Funds will be established to promote investment in projects that respond to the principles of the Law: private investment projects in the Fund that will be managed by the ICO, for a volume of twenty billion euros available to private initiative, and another, to promote public investment, also for projects of technological renewal, with five billion and managed by local entities.

Alongside the Sustainable Economy Law, the Budgets for 2010. What is the fundamental objective? Economic recovery, the reduction of non-productive public spending, and preparing our public finances to place the deficit below 3 percent in 2012, to comply with the requirements of the European Commission regarding the Stability Pact.

The Budget Law will be the normative vehicle where the government will explicitly state its fiscal policy, a fiscal policy that, just as we have been doing in recent years, will be guided by the principles of fiscal moderation and the utility of fiscal policy for economic recovery.

I must remind you that we are in Spain at the moment of the lowest tax pressure since 1995; that the Government I lead has lowered taxes, reducing the Corporate Tax by five points and has now concretely proposed a reduction of the Corporate Tax for SMEs that create or maintain jobs; that the Government I lead has lowered personal income tax and introduced a deduction, the famous four hundred euros; that the Government I lead has eliminated the Wealth Tax, which directly affects the middle classes, as sometimes reference is made to the middle classes. It is the first Government to eliminate the Wealth Tax and the first Government to lower the Corporate Tax by five points.

These are the facts, and therefore, in terms of tax pressure, we are now seven points below the European Union, and on more than one occasion you will have heard me say that tax pressure or fiscal policy, which is one of the instruments the Government has, must respond to the economic situation.

Therefore, we will present the Budget Law, but I already anticipate that my intention is to preserve and maintain fiscal moderation in what affects companies; moreover, in Corporate Tax we will have that proposal for reduction that I have indicated, and in what affects taxation related to work, logically, to stimulate employment.

Consequently, adjustments, or changes, or revisions, or increases, will be limited and/or temporary, preserving that principle of fiscal moderation, which I believe is a good principle in general to demand that the State functions as well as possible and to, in this case, also facilitate economic reactivation, all while keeping in mind that we are at a moment of low tax pressure, comparatively with our trajectory and comparatively with the European Union.

I am in favor of tax pressure and I am in favor of making public management as efficient as possible, and, of course, of preserving, within what is fiscal moderation, the necessary funding for social cohesion, for the Welfare State, which is a great achievement of Spanish democracy.

Alongside the Sustainable Economy Law and the Budget Law, the Government intends to carry out three dialogue processes. The first of these is social dialogue. I want to announce that the Government will convene social interlocutors during the first half of September to inform, dialogue, and debate about the content of the Sustainable Economy Law, about this great law of economic impetus, of economic initiative.

You know that for me social dialogue is a fundamental, strategic element of Government policy. It has been since 2004 and it will continue to be. And I hope there will be the best disposition on the part of social organizations, employers, and unions, to address the Sustainable Economy Law.

And, as you also know, to situate and address political dialogue, on September 9 I will appear again before the Congress of Deputies to inform and debate about the evolution of the economic situation, and also to inform about the general lines of this Sustainable Economy Law.

In political dialogue, I will highlight two offers of agreements with which we want to begin this period, which are two essential topics for the Spanish economy and also for that perspective of reforms: the Government wants to conclude a great political agreement on education and for this, the Minister of Education, who has been working in this direction, will convene the various political forces, starting with the Popular Party; and the second thematic area of dialogue that we want to prioritize is energy policy.

As you know, the Government has committed to presenting in Parliament the energy horizon until 2020. The Ministry of Industry will initiate a dialogue process with the political forces, starting with the Popular Party, to seek an agreement on the energy horizon, on the energy mix, on energy policy until 2020, which, as you know, is the date that the European Union has set for all of us as a reference to achieve that 20 percent of renewable energies and the reduction of greenhouse gases.

Therefore, I repeat, social dialogue around the Sustainable Economy Law and political dialogue for economic reforms in two specific fields, essential for Spain, education and energy. We will start with the Popular Party, but logically we will have a dialogue that incorporates and convenes all political forces.

Regarding foreign policy, I must say that this period has, as could not be otherwise, a clear prominence, which is the Spanish Presidency of the European Union, which will begin on January 1 and will cover the entire first half of 2010. It is an important Presidency for Spain and for Europe, because it will coincide, presumably, with the entry into force of a new Treaty, a new impetus for the governance of Europe and, above all, because it will coincide with a period in which economic recovery must begin to be felt throughout the European Union and, of course, in our countries.

It will also be a Presidency with a marked external emphasis to reinforce and underscore the role of the European Union in the international concert. Hence, we have a broad agenda of Summits, all of them significant; bilateral Summits, for example with the United States, with Morocco, with Russia, with Mexico, with Canada, and with Japan, and of course multilateral Summits, especially those that are of great interest to Spain, those related to Latin America and the Caribbean, and the Union for the Mediterranean Summit.

This semester will also be very intense in one of the objectives that the Government has set as a priority, in which we have worked a lot, and that is our participation in the G-20 Summit in Pittsburgh on September 24 and 25. You know that we already participated in the first G-20 Summit in the face of the crisis, in Washington; in the second, in London, and now in Pittsburgh, which consolidates and strengthens Spain's role in the international order.

Finally, I want to refer to an issue that undoubtedly raises concern among Spanish citizens and citizens around the world, which is the H1N1 flu.

The H1N1 flu constitutes the first pandemic of the 21st century and against it, the Government has launched a policy based on the following principles:

- First principle, transparency, coordination, and collaboration: transparency before the citizens and before the Autonomous Communities, which have so many competences in health matters; coordination and collaboration in the internal and international spheres; in the international sphere with the World Health Organization and with the European Union, and, internally, with the Autonomous Communities that, I emphasize, have been collaborating satisfactorily in the face of this pandemic,

- Secondly, the second principle, that the actions, guidelines, behaviors, responses, are being adopted according to verified scientific evidence and the proposals of professional organizations and scientific societies. Hence the great importance of the Scientific Committee created for this purpose, with which I met in July and hence the great importance of the entire research program that the Government is promoting regarding the H1N1 flu with the support of the Ministry of Science and Innovation.

- And, thirdly, anticipatory measures in which we will not spare efforts or economic resources to preserve the tranquility and health of all citizens. In fact, today the Council of Ministers has approved the application of the Contingency Fund, an extraordinary credit of 333 million euros to address the cost of the resources that we will need to deploy for the H1N1 flu.

Following the recommendations of experts, vaccination of 40 percent of the population has been planned, around sixteen million Spaniards, and we will have the vaccines at the same time as all European countries, once, logically, they have the appropriate authorization from the European Medicines Agency. We will also have fifteen million antiviral treatments, a quantity that we consider sufficient based on the indications of the World Health Organization and the health authorities of the European Union. Six million of those antiviral treatments are in the hands of the Government of Spain as a strategic reserve to support the Autonomous Communities in the face of any eventuality.

We have reasons to send a message of tranquility to the citizens of our country, because our health system, our health system, is a great system and is prepared to face situations like this; secondly, because all decisions have been made, and will be made in the future, in coordination with the Autonomous Communities to ensure equal application throughout the national territory; thirdly, because these are decisions based on scientific evidence and the recommendations of the World Health Organization.

Spaniards, I reiterate, must know that we have a great National Health System, with means to face this situation and, above all, and I want to highlight this particularly, with magnificent professionals in the field of health, with magnificent professionals in primary care centers, in hospitals, in the network of hospitals, and, of course, in the field of research.

I want to thank in a very special way all the collaboration that professional organizations (collegiate, research, associations..., all that wealth of thought, science, and professionalism that we have in our country in the field of health) are providing to the Government and the Autonomous Communities to face this pandemic.

Tranquility, we have the means to prevent what the evolution may be in the fall, transparency, coordination with the Autonomous Communities and, of course, following the guidelines and recommendations of the World Health Organization and the European Union.

I feared it would be long, but I thought it was all quite necessary.

Q.- A clarification on the issue of taxes. When some members of the Government have talked about increasing tax pressure to guarantee state revenues, are you thinking of a progressive increase in personal income tax or in other financial products such as these variable capital companies that have a lower tax burden? I would like you to clarify this for us. I ask you this because personal income tax is mainly paid by salaried workers and middle classes, and it is basically where the previous reduction was directed.

Secondly, I would like an opinion from the President of the Government on the debate that has taken place this summer, mainly fostered by employers and some economic circles, about the need for salaried workers to lower their salaries. There has been talk of a 1 percent reduction in collective agreements for next year. I would like to know your opinion on this.

President.- Regarding the first question, I have said that the reforms or changes that may occur in fiscal policy will be in the Budget Law, a Budget Law that, as you well know, must be approved by Parliament; but I have established some principles: first, the principle of fiscal moderation; second, fiscal policy must respond to the needs of economic recovery and to the economic situation.

When we had an inflation rate of 5 percent and when the Euribor and the cost of mortgages were rising, the Government took the measure of the four hundred euros, which was one of the few measures available to alleviate somewhat the greater pressure that families had on their disposable income. Today, fortunately, the situation has changed radically because the Euribor is at historic lows and the evolution regarding mortgages, and therefore family income for many families, is the opposite.

Therefore, all fiscal policy must take into account, based on certain principles, the economic situation and within those principles I have stated, one, that the Government considers that the activity of companies and income from work must be preserved because, indeed, to a large extent, the majority of the Personal Income Tax is the result of the tax on the income of salaried workers, and it must be preserved; and, of course, as I said, that of companies.

With this, what do I want to say? With this I want to say, and it is what I wanted to say earlier, moderation in fiscal matters, moderation. There will be some adjustment, there will be some change, some revision, some upward and some downward, because they are instruments; but in any case they will be limited and in some cases temporary. Of course, always attending to the criteria of progressivity and preserving the so-called middle class and workers; but limited because I defend, and it is consistent with the policy I have pursued, fiscal moderation, which is possible while maintaining a Welfare State.

I believe that part of the debate is mistaken; that is to say, state revenues, in both good times and difficult times, like now, depend fundamentally on economic activity: if there is economic growth, revenues evolve favorably; if there is an economic recession, revenues evolve negatively. Is that clear? If you have a period of economic growth, as we have had, and strong revenues, you can, and it is advisable, to lower the tax burden, to reduce taxes, as we have done. If you have a period of severe economic recession and falling revenues, having to meet significant expenses, especially for social protection, it is logical that you cannot pursue the same policy, that you have to adopt a policy with some nuance, a different policy, but always within a principle of fiscal moderation.

Our tax system's foundations are basically established. There may be changes, increases or decreases in some tax figures; but, in any case, they are limited and, to a large extent, temporary. This is what I want to make clear. Of course, I am not going to tell you today... I think it is a bit premature, and we must wait for the specifics of the Budget Law.

Regarding salaries, what I wish is for there to be an agreement in the negotiation of the pending agreements for this year and for next year; that there is an agreement between employers and unions, that they dialogue. Therefore, since this is a strictly bilateral area between the two of them, it does not seem that the Government should comment on it. I will say that we must align the economic situation with the salary policies that, in some cases, in some proposals I have heard in these days of August, are excessive.

Q.- Mr. President, you have spoken of social dialogue, but you have focused on the Sustainable Economy Law. I wanted to know if you will try to restore that dialogue that was broken before the summer due to your disagreements with employers, with the business association.

President.- It is true that we were seeking an agreement that involved a whole series of measures, largely from the Government, and that all of them were supportive, incentivizing, positive, for, first of all, the employers, for the CEOE, which was the interlocutor, and also for the workers' organizations. That agreement was not finalized, we could not reach it, mainly because the CEOE wanted to discuss labor reform in terms that, for the unions, especially, but to a large extent also for the Government, did not allow for the conclusion of an agreement.

Does that mean we cannot talk about a whole series of important issues for the Spanish economy? No. We must talk, and if we can reach agreements or understandings, all the better. The Sustainable Economy Law, as you will have noticed from the principles I have anticipated it will contain, addresses all important issues, and I hope that dialogue is feasible in that area that the Government wants to preserve. Can we talk about other things later? The Government is always willing, but the CEOE and the unions know very well what the possible field is to reach an agreement. The lack of agreement on the objective we had, as I have just demonstrated, does not mean at all that the Government does not take measures, does not continue with initiatives, does not propose reforms, or does not establish new areas for agreement and dialogue.

Q.- In your offer or in your various offers for dialogue, I have missed a reference to a meeting with the leader of the opposition that you had committed to with a cadence similar to these appearances. Throughout the summer, there have been a series of accusations from leaders of the Popular Party that the Government was using state resources to spy on them, which have not been substantiated with evidence, and I wanted to know if there is a cause-effect relationship. In any case, what do you think of these types of accusations that have circulated throughout August and have captured public attention?

President.- Well, that they are from August. I hope that things start in this political course, thinking, dialoguing, and working together in the search for economic recovery and the improvement of our economic foundations. I have proposed social dialogue, through the Sustainable Economy Law, to unions and employers; I propose a specific political dialogue, very particularly with the Popular Party, in Education and Energy, which are pillars of our economic future; and, as you know, and I now reiterate, the Sustainable Economy Law must also involve the agreement of the Autonomous Communities in its development, and for that reason, we will have a Conference of Presidents for that purpose.

We are going to start working with the utmost responsibility, and I hope that everyone will rise to the occasion.

Q.- Mr. President, in light of the great pact on Education, can you tell us what the Minister will take to the political parties, because this great pact has been talked about for years and there has never been anything concrete?

And I was just going to ask you about the Conference of Presidents, and you mentioned it in your last response. I don't know if there is already a date and what you intend to bring to that meeting.

President.- First of all, I believe that prudence advises that it should be the political interlocutors, the political parties, who know firsthand, first, the content project of what an agreement in the field of education could be. The Ministry of Education, as I have just told you, has prepared it, has been working on its content this August, and the Minister will begin this task as a priority in the coming weeks. The political parties will know it, and logically, the entire public opinion will know it.

I understand that it is a fundamental, essential agreement because, to a large extent, Spain's economic future depends on progress in educational matters in Spain, and education in Spain will progress better with political and social agreement. This is a reflection shared by an immense majority of citizens, and that is why we are committed to it.

Conference of Presidents: we do not yet have a fixed date. The Sustainable Economy Law will be a central issue, but the Third Vice President will dialogue with all the Autonomous Communities so that the agenda of that Conference of Presidents can have the maximum consensus, because we want to hold a Conference for consensus, for agreement, also in the area of economic reactivation.

Q.- I wanted to ask you about one of the issues that has lingered at the end of the summer, which has been the issue of the Statute of Catalonia. Some parties have raised the possibility of recovering competencies through Article 150.2 in the event that the Constitutional Court issues an unfavorable ruling on the Statute. I wanted to ask you, in that sense, for a statement.

A second question. Speaking of the Popular Party, it has been another of the recurring themes throughout the summer, the systematic criticism of the partisan and sectarian use, according to the Popular Party and Rajoy himself, of state instruments in monitoring leaders and members of the PP in matters of corruption or alleged corruption. I wanted to ask you also, in this regard, for a statement on these two issues that have been circulating all summer.

President.- Regarding the first issue, I believe that a principle of calm must be introduced because I think that the ruling on the Statute of Catalonia has not yet been issued, and therefore, any assessment seems to me should be exercised with all prudence. Let us wait for the Constitutional Court's ruling on the Statute of Catalonia, which we will, of course, respect, to make the appropriate assessments, and that principle should generally apply.

Secondly, I have already expressed my views on the things we have heard this August. In my opinion, things were quite clear the other day in the Permanent Deputation that took place in Congress, and I insist: responsibility in what should be the functioning of the democratic institutions of the country and, of course, an appeal for us to concentrate our collective work on dialogue about the very important issues that Spain has, such as economic reactivation, education, and energy, which I have just named. To dialogue to work and to work for the country.

Q.- I deduce from a response you gave earlier that you do not plan to meet with the leader of the opposition. I would like to clarify that. That, first of all.

Secondly, regarding the Statute, do you share the concerns expressed by the Catalan political forces regarding the ruling? Would you be in favor of any measure, even amending the Constitution, to ensure compliance?

President.- It is already going into hypotheses and conjectures. I will not assess any evaluation of something that has not occurred. It seems quite evident to me. When it occurs, we will assess the ruling and evaluate the assessments; but, in the meantime, it does not seem reasonable because we would be in a game that leads nowhere.

And, of course, from there, you can imagine that the issue of constitutional reform has not even crossed anyone's mind, especially knowing what it represents and what a constitutional reform requires in terms of majorities.

Regarding the first issue, you have made a deduction that seems a bit legitimate, but perhaps hasty. I do not rule out having a meeting with the leader of the opposition, and we will see if the conditions are right. You know that my will is always to promote that dialogue and that I am the President of the Government who has called a leader of the opposition the most times. I believe I do not want to lose that record; I will maintain it, and therefore, it is within what is possible and also probable for the coming weeks.

Q.- Minister Carme Chacón has been accused of incurring a conflict of interest by participating in the approval of the Royal Decree Law on paid DTT in the Council of Ministers on August 13. I wanted to know what your assessment of this is and whether the Minister will attend to ratify the Law when it is voted on in Congress.

President.- I suppose so. I assume there will be no inconvenience or incompatibility. That is my opinion, although I do not know the content of the complaint you refer to.

Q.- Mr. President, I wanted to ask you about social dialogue. I wanted to know if the Government absolutely rules out undertaking any type of labor reform until we are out of the crisis?

Then, that offer that was on paper, and that disappeared, of a 0.5 percent reduction in contributions, is that also totally ruled out, given the current circumstances?

Finally, I wanted to know if you could clarify a couple of things for us. First, is there an economic memory for the payment of the 420 euros, or will the result be universal, without budgetary limitation? Secondly, you said that we are seven points below the European Union in tax pressure; would moderation allow for a convergence towards the European Union of two points, for example?

President.- No. I do not consider the two-point adjustment necessary. When a benefit is established as a subjective right with a series of conditions and requirements, that benefit must logically be provided to all individuals who are in that situation and who request it. Therefore, it will cost what the total number of people represents, from the perspective of both the number and the committed expenditure, which, as you know, is 420 euros every six months.

Yes, we find it interesting for the Government to check how many applications will be made, and I believe that not only for the Government but for the entire country. This will be an important data point, regardless of the date we set. It is evident, and I think that from my words the other day and today it can be inferred, that the date will be pushed back; it will have a retroactive character. We will see where. A parliamentary and social agreement must be reached for that purpose; but, in any case, it will be interesting to know the number of people. But, as we are talking about a right and a benefit, all individuals who meet those requirements will, of course, receive the benefit. That is the least we could expect!

Regarding the contents of the offers in social dialogue, that is, regarding labor reform, to reduce workers' rights or to make a transfer of income from companies to workers, there is no context because the unions, of course, do not agree, and because, furthermore, the Government believes that this is not the way. It is evident. However, it is always possible to study measures in the labor field that favor stability, as we did in the 2006 Agreement, because the great challenge of our labor market is to reduce temporality. What happens is that, until now, whenever labor reform has been discussed, even if only by approximation, from a distance, the CEOE, I believe it is legitimate, logically wants to introduce a reduction in the cost of dismissal, a modification regarding procedures, regarding judicialization, etc., etc., and that does not seem likely to prosper.

Regarding contributions? It is not, as I have mentioned, on the agenda. It was part of that social dialogue, and, in principle, the Government maintains its policy of preserving Social Security, the stability of the system.

P.- President, I have two questions about the H1N1 flu. I wanted to know if you could be a little more specific. When you explained that an extraordinary credit of 333 million euros was approved today, I wanted to know if that will be for the Autonomous Communities and also for the private healthcare sector. Can you clarify this matter a bit better?

The second issue in this regard. Yesterday, the governments of the United Kingdom and France confirmed that the vaccines have arrived in their territory, and I wanted to know if you can tell us if they are already in Spain.

President.- I can confirm that we are going to start the vaccination process and we will have the vaccines at the same time as the European countries. I can commit to and guarantee that, and it will never be before the appropriate authorization for the vaccine is produced and, logically, the absolute guarantees of the vaccine. That is what I can guarantee, and I will not refer to what other countries have said. We guarantee that, which is quite logical to understand, because we all have the availability of resources, the will, and the appropriate orders, and we are waiting for the clinical trials of the vaccine to yield their results.

Therefore, there will be no problem, and I want to emphasize this, neither in when nor in how many vaccines; no problem for Spain or for the Spanish people. It is an absolute guarantee. The government gives an absolute guarantee while always respecting the recommendations of WHO experts regarding the population to be preserved with vaccination and all the preventive measures that must be taken for the proper functioning of public services and for the greatest possible prevention in the educational and school sphere. You know that there will be a meeting in the coming days between the Minister of Health and the Minister of Education that will culminate with parents and teachers to establish all the behavioral guidelines and all the protocols.

As we complete this task of having the entire prevention agenda, the perfectly structured map, with Autonomous Communities, with the educational sector, and with public services to guarantee the functioning of these public services, I intend to convene a monitoring committee of the different affected ministries to conduct a general review of all the measures we are applying and that we have to take, a good part of which depend on the agreement with the Autonomous Communities and with social sectors, professional sectors, and the educational world.

Regarding the 333 million, the reference from the Council of Ministers will be more detailed, but, logically, above all, it is for the availability of purchasing vaccines, antivirals, and everything that will represent the expenditure that, as you know, comes from the resources of citizens through taxes. But the reference from the Council of Ministers will be more detailed.

P.- President, yesterday we learned, upon knowing the structure of GDP for the second quarter, that while productivity per employee has grown quite a bit, basically due to the drop in employment, the remuneration of employees has still grown above it. In part, and this is an analysis I had to make because the official data does not provide it, I believe that the salary increases of civil servants have a decisive influence on this discrepancy. I would like to ask you specifically if any salary measures will be taken for next year regarding civil servants, such as freezing, moderation, or adjustment to the CPI with which we end the year. That on one side.

Also yesterday we saw in the same document that, despite the fact that construction has indeed been the small cataclysm or what we all have in mind as a small cataclysm this year, the industry has fallen exactly double that of construction. I would like to know what reflection you can lead us to make on this issue because, quantitatively and qualitatively, of course, the industry is much more in the Spanish economy than construction.

President.- If the data you provide were so and were confirmed regarding salary evolution and the influence that the remuneration evolution of public employees has had on it, I suppose this is good news for public employees; for anyone who is a public employee, surely, if that is the case.

The government has maintained a principle of dialogue and concertation with public employees regarding remuneration and the various aspects of public function organization, and it will maintain it. As you know, the First Vice President, who after the last reshuffle has the responsibility for public function, is in a dialogue process with the representatives of public employees to reach an agreement, within which, logically, the remuneration issue will be present, but not only the remuneration issue.

We will let the dialogue unfold. I have great confidence in public employees; I have great confidence. They have known, know, and will know how to accompany the country in the economic situation, and there will not be an attitude of imposition from the government, no. I am convinced that with dialogue we will reach a positive and fruitful result.

Industry and construction. It is true that construction, from a temporal sequence perspective, in previous quarters had fallen much more sharply, and in industry, we must bear in mind that there is a part of the industry, which is probably the most affected, that depends on construction; the part of the industry that depends on construction. These are the industrial sectors that are suffering the most from the crisis, and therefore, there is a direct relationship. To the extent that we recover construction in the broad sense, not only in terms of housing construction, residential activity, there is a part of the industry that will recover, such as the cement industry, the white goods industry… in short, an important industry in Spain that is, and I am very aware, suffering in a special way from the crisis.

P.- President, you also spoke about foreign policy and referred to the Spanish Presidency of the European Union in the next semester. You mentioned the different summits that will take place; for example, the EU-Latin America-Caribbean Summit, and in this context, as you know, the Andean Community is pending the signing of a series of multilateral agreements on free trade. Peru and Colombia have requested today, on the sidelines of the Andean Community, due to the different speeds in the Andean countries. I wanted to know, in this framework, if Spain will ratify or specify concrete support for this request.

President.- Spain wishes that under the Spanish Presidency of the European Union we reach the conclusion of various agreements in trade matters between the European Union and regional areas. One of them is the Andean Community, and we would like it to be the entire Andean Community. We would like it to be done in that spirit, and we know that there is a singular situation with some countries, particularly with Peru. Spain always listens to Peru with the utmost sensitivity. We will work to ensure that there can be a concertation for that agreement with the European Union that is so beneficial for the entire Andean Community, including Peru, just as we will work to conclude with Central America and with other regional spaces in that area that is so close and dear to us.

P.- I wanted to ask you about Opel. Is Spain willing to provide financial assistance to General Motors if it retains Opel, and if so, what amount would it be willing to contribute?

President.- The truth is that the Government of Spain is closely monitoring and is willing to support the various alternatives that may exist for Opel and General Motors in Spain; but we must be prudent and much more regarding the amount. In any case, it must respond to viability, renewal, and competitiveness plans; but you know that the entire automotive sector is a sector of decided support from the Government and also, logically, the brand you are asking me about.

P.- President, I have several questions of an economic nature. First, I wanted to ask you about your participation in the G-20 Summit and whether you will support the Franco-German proposal to establish some system of limits on bank executives' bonuses, and if you have communicated in this regard with your colleagues.

Secondly, I wanted to return to fiscal policy. First, in the question about the two points of tax pressure, it is not clear to me whether you do not see it necessary to reach a two-point increase or do not see it necessary to limit yourself to a two-point increase. I also wanted to ask you, given that fiscal policy responds to the situation, if the Government is considering eliminating some measures that were taken in the past, such as the refund of the four hundred euros precisely or other social benefits such as the aid for birth and adoption.

President.- We return to the game with the two points, which is a game already… Two points of tax pressure is on GDP and depends a lot on how GDP evolves, as is natural. What I wanted to say with the two points is that I thought it was not necessary at this moment to consider a two-point increase in tax pressure, regardless of the evolution with GDP.

I have spoken of the principle of fiscal moderation. There will be some measure that implies a limited, and possibly temporary, increase, and there will also be measures of incentives, tax reductions, as I have said in matters of Corporate Tax for what affects R&D, etc., etc.

Therefore, it is not a principle merely to try to collect more or less, because, I insist, that will depend on economic growth; it is about making a more instrumental policy.

Regarding the two specific questions, maternity aid is a social policy that falls within that chapter considered by the Government of social protection, social welfare, in this case, aid for childbirth. Consequently, we will preserve it. There is not the slightest possibility, the minimum horizon, of changing the 2,500 euros.

Four hundred euros. It was a measure to respond to the situation of rising prices and the rise of the Euribor and mortgages; to alleviate. Therefore, here we have more margin, which will also depend on the scenario and parliamentary dialogue. As I said a moment ago, we will wait for the Budget Law.

P.- President, you announced an extraordinary Council of Ministers on October 9 in the Canary Islands, which is expected to approve the Canary Islands Plan to boost the economy of the Islands. Did you take advantage of your stay in the archipelago this summer to…

President.- Yes, in Lanzarote. I believe everyone is already aware.

P.- …meet with the President of the Canary Islands. I wanted to know, in this regard, if there is agreement between the two of you regarding the diagnosis and treatment of the crisis in the Islands, which, as you know, has seven points above the average in relation to unemployment. For example, yesterday the President of the Canary Islands again called for the elimination of air taxes to incentivize tourism, and in this regard, I wanted to know if this Plan is a matter of exclusive responsibility of your Government or is there, shall we say, a consensus with the Government of the Canary Islands to activate this entire Plan.

President.- I have already had two meetings with the President of the Canary Islands where the dialogue has focused on the Strategy for the Canary Islands that the Government wants to approve in that extraordinary Council of Ministers in the Canary Islands on October 9, and there are many common points. The Strategy will contemplate: commitments from the Government of Spain, commitments from the State, for the Canary Islands for the coming years, articulated, some, in direct actions from the Government and others, through agreements with the Government of the Canary Islands; agreements that we already have, such as the Roads Agreement or the Employment Agreement, but extending the commitment over time, and other aspects that will be the subject of an Agreement. In addition, it will incorporate some criteria that will open the dialogue process for the reform of the Special Tax Regime of the Canary Islands and also all the opportunities of the archipelago, of the Autonomous Community of the Canary Islands, in relation to the external projection of Spain and the Canary Islands in the economic sphere.

What is my commitment to the President of the Canary Islands? The commitment is that by the middle of this month I will send him a project, which can be an advanced program, of the document that we want to take to the Council of Ministers of the Canary Islands. Consequently, it will be a process of dialogue and concertation with the leadership of the Government of Spain of that Strategy for the Canary Islands.

P.- President, I would like you to specify some of the reasons that justify the urgent approval of the Pay DTT Law.

President.- So that we do not fall behind. The most important European countries are already with the Pay DTT; in April 2010, the analog blackout occurs, and this is a stimulus element for the industry sector and the content sector, and, in addition, it was a commitment of the Government, because we had told all operators that we would approve it this year.

The channel is not to waste time and to do it with the instrument that the Government has when it wants to do something that should not be delayed and there is a legal requirement. If it is not delayed, it is because there is urgency, and if there is a legal requirement, the conclusion is a Royal Decree Law. It is quite well established. From there, I understand that it will benefit everyone, and time will tell us.

P.- In light of the questions about the Catalan Statute, I wanted to ask you about what has occurred so far, which are the statements from some leaders. Specifically, I wanted to know your assessment regarding the statements of a member of your party, the deputy spokesperson of the PSC in the Parliament, Carmen Figueras, who says that the Constitutional Court is not a competent or legitimate body to issue a ruling on the Statute of Catalonia.

And following up on the previous question about paid DTT, I also wanted to ask about the accusation made by the Popular Party, which says that this Law has been approved to benefit their friends at Mediapro. I wanted to know what you have to say about that.

President.- First of all, I have said that any statement that has been made about something that is not yet real, which is the ruling, we must approach with all caution. I limit myself to reproducing the fundamental points of what our functioning as a rule of law and as a democratic system is. Let us respect the task, the work, of the Constitutional Court, which will issue a ruling and then everyone will have the right to express their opinion, and we will all have the obligation to respect that ruling.

Let us not anticipate because it is a debate that leads nowhere, only to unnecessary wear and tear. It is really unnecessary to have a debate about something that may happen, which is a hypothesis, that is said. So many times that is not the case that I ask that we do not have a debate prematurely. Let us have the debate when it occurs, if it occurs.

As for what the Popular Party says, I do not believe that any or almost none of the measures or decisions adopted by the Government have the sympathy of the Popular Party. The only thing I can tell you is that the Government has made reforms throughout the communication sector guided by three principles that are being fulfilled: one, more plurality and there are more media in the television sector; modernization, the DTT, and plurality and public service for the Public Entity. Today we have television that I believe can be affirmed is more plural and more independent than there has been in the democratic period; and, two, we are going to have a public television fully of public service, with the disappearance of commercial advertising and income from commercial advertising so that it is only public service.

Therefore, we are more plural, there is more plurality, thus more richness, there is more independence in the public sector and there is more modernization. Furthermore, we have almost always attended to the requests of the sector: when there was a willingness to merge, the door has been opened; when there has been a willingness to change from closed to open, the door has been opened. In other words, we have been sensitive to the sector, modernizers in favor of plurality and independence, and these are indisputable facts for the benefit of the country; of the nation, of course.

Thank you very much.