Press conference of the President of the Government after his meeting with business and financial leaders.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

25 March 2011 · Meeting with business and financial leaders

Context
Zapatero held a press conference on 25 March 2011 after meeting Spain's top forty companies and CEOE president to discuss economic reforms and recovery.
Main themes
Spanish economy recovery, fiscal consolidation and reforms, labor market flexibility, collective bargaining reform, business competitiveness, internationalization and exports, energy policy and tariff deficit, financial system stability, savings banks reform, competition in professional services, commercial hours liberalization, ICEX reform
Duration
~25 min
75th percentile
Words
2,998
75th percentile
Sentences
118
71st percentile
Readability
44
45th percentile
Grade
13.4
61st percentile
Syntax
3.20
73rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
11th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

118 sentences in 44 paragraphs

President.- Good afternoon. I wish to inform you of the content of the meeting we held today with the forty most important companies in the country, as well as with the president of the CEOE representing the entire business sector.

You know that this meeting is a continuation, a committed continuation, of the meeting I had three months ago with all the companies to assess the evolution of the situation of the Spanish economy in the exit from the crisis, the essential stability of the financial system that we were working on, and the necessary consolidation of fiscal policies, as well as the reforms that we have been carrying out in recent months, the result of social agreement, such as the pension reform or the reform of the financial system that you know is in full process, underway.

There have been some conclusions of great relevance:

- First, in the opinion of the vast majority, if not all, of those present at the meeting, the situation of stability of the Spanish economy in the markets has clearly improved since November. The differential cost of financing for the Spanish economy is one hundred basis points, and that figure generates confidence.

- The second conclusion is that this has been the result of the reforms and decisions that have been made, difficult reforms and decisions, to address the basic problems of the Spanish economy: decisions within the framework of reducing spending, decisions within the framework of labor reform, and decisions regarding the reform of the financial system, especially of the savings banks; decisions that you are well aware of.

- The third conclusion is that we cannot let our guard down. This is a conclusion that I fully share with the business leaders of this country. And there are some essential aspects that we currently have underway, new reforms, new changes, that are of great significance.

Undoubtedly, our labor framework has been present in the vast majority of interventions, a labor framework that must be more flexible to gain competitiveness for the entire economy and businesses. And within that more flexible framework, the negotiation process that currently exists between employers and unions regarding collective bargaining and some other issues is of fundamental importance.

The president of the CEOE has informed us about how the process is going and the willingness for profound changes in our model of collective bargaining and, ultimately, in the labor model. The Government supports this dialogue process and hopes that an agreement will be reached this month, because in this month of April we need to approve the Draft Law that reforms collective bargaining.

Another fundamental issue that has emerged, and on which we must continue to work and make reforms, is the internationalization of the Spanish economy, of businesses. We are seeing very good export data. Our companies demonstrate that they are competitive, with a 25 percent increase in exports in January, and we must consolidate this recovery. Making our economy structurally export-oriented will be the best index of competitiveness. To do this, we need to facilitate that export process, supporting it more. I have announced to you that next Friday the Council of Ministers will carry out a reform of ICEX to make it a more agile, more flexible organization with greater capacity to support companies abroad.

And we must contribute to all the reforms that make us competitive in costs, not only in the labor field but also in the energy sector. With this, I move to the next crucial point of the debate, one of the four or five major topics that have been raised, which is energy policy.

As you know, we have approved a Royal Decree Law to establish a framework that would largely address the problem of the tariff deficit and provide a horizon of stability; but we must continue working, and this country must engage in a collective reflection on an energy policy that guarantees medium-term competitiveness for our companies, especially in the electricity sector, so that they do not have a cost disadvantage here that seriously affects their possibilities abroad.

As major topics, the last one that has been addressed is related to improving the competitiveness of our economy from two perspectives. The first is improving competition in some areas. Opening up more competition in the economy means providing more opportunities for the economy, generating more economic activity, and therefore more employment. There are two areas that have been raised on which the Government intends to act: one you already know, which is professional services, where we need to remove rigidities and allow for broader activity in the professional services sector; the other, commercial hours, has also been on the table. It is one of the factors that limits competition and, therefore, economic growth.

Within the overall reflection on competitiveness aspects, I will finally refer to what perhaps occupies, what must occupy, the fundamental position, and you will quickly understand why I have referred to it last, which is training: general training in our country, the educational system, the improvement of universities, and, specifically, vocational training. There is something that is neither an opinion nor a forecast; it is almost an axiom. There is an axiom in the labor market: training is what leads to employability. The more training and continuous training, the more opportunities and greater guarantee of being able to have a job and a higher quality job.

Therefore, all the reform we are carrying out in vocational training is urgent, and for this reason, I have asked the large companies in this country and the CEOE for an additional commitment in the area of training. They provide training, but they can and must make an additional commitment in terms of training for employment. I have asked them to jointly approve a program for the implementation of thirty thousand scholarships for young people who need qualification; at least thirty thousand scholarships, where large companies, which have shown great receptivity, will collaborate immediately, and of course, the entire set of companies through the CEOE.

The president of Telefónica, Mr. Alierta, will coordinate the working group with the Ministry of Economy and Finance to implement this program as quickly as possible. I insist, thirty thousand scholarships for an internship period of at least six months in companies, which will, of course, be compatible with theoretical training. It is aimed, I insist, at the younger population that most urgently needs to qualify. There has even been some direct commitment, and Banco Santander, Mr. Botín, has committed two thousand scholarships for young people in the context of this program.

Final assessment, conclusion: like the first meeting, extraordinarily useful. It represents a collective update on how the process of recovery and consolidation of our economic stability is taking place, and on the changes that the Spanish economy demands. For this reason, I have committed again to the companies that in three months we will again have this balance meeting on the initiatives and measures we have underway, those we have evaluated, and of course the program regarding the scholarships that I have just outlined, because, while it is true that today we can be more at ease, more secure, and more confident about our economic stability, it is no less true that we still have a huge task ahead of us, which is to consolidate and strengthen economic growth to create employment.

In the medium term, this is the essential issue. A few months ago it was the reduction of the deficit; a few months before that, the financial system, and today, in the medium term, for the Spanish economy and for our capabilities, it is undoubtedly that the reforms culminate, that they are profound, and that they are made quickly to improve expectations, and that this produces economic growth and, as soon as possible, job creation.

Q.- President, from your words, I understood that you felt that the business leaders support the measures, the reforms, that you have taken up to this point. I do not know if they have asked you to undertake any further reforms.

Regarding the specific case of commercial hours, I would like to know what they have requested from you and how far the Government is willing to go.

President.- Global assessment? The business leaders, as I said before, agree, first, that there is an improvement in the situation, and second, that we must complete the ongoing reforms --I have already said this-- especially collective bargaining and, of course, everything that affects fiscal consolidation and the future guarantee of spending control. As sectoral aspects, I have reiterated that there has been a very high number of interventions on energy policy. I just pointed out a moment ago that we must reflect, just as on other aspects, on the need to boost industry, as I mentioned, the internationalization of the economy, etc. But as major topics, at this moment, collective bargaining.

Commercial hours is another topic that we need to work on. Especially, as I said earlier, I believe that improving capacities and possibilities and being flexible in tourist areas is quite reasonable, and we want to immediately talk with the political forces, because we understand that this is a topic that favors competition and promotes economic activity.

Q.- I wanted to ask you, and I just pointed it out now, about the energy policy issue, which you said is one of the most debated aspects in the meeting. Could you elaborate a bit more on this debate?

President.- The debate can be summarized in the following terms. We need to lower energy costs in our country. We cannot continue with a growth rate of energy costs. We need to lower energy costs, and we need the model in the electricity system that we have had and that we are now trying to change in the medium term, which is the model of deferring the real cost of electricity, to be absorbed. This is what we know as the tariff deficit.

Along with this, in the energy mix, we need to evaluate two things: one, the installed capacity, that is, what installed capacity we have to produce energy, and the cost. We are addressing this with the measures I have already mentioned, among others, some of which have been difficult for any government to adopt, and we have had to make a significant increase in the electricity tariff.

But we cannot objectively say that we have a horizon in which we guarantee that stability of energy costs, or that we reduce them. We need to do more. Many things have been done, but more needs to be done. This is my opinion and also the opinion that was expressed at the table today.

Q.- President, I have two questions. One is about the energy issue. I would like to know if this collective reflection will include political parties and if there will be a special table to study what can be done in this regard.

Then, regarding the set of measures in general and this new reform plan, some of them have a deadline to start, which will be in the coming months, and I would like to know if all this conditions the political calendar; that is, do you believe that this is not the appropriate time to make political announcements that could introduce instability into the economy?

President.- Of course, energy policy is a policy that should enjoy the maximum possible dialogue and consensus. In fact, we are trying. There are sufficient instances in the parliamentary sphere for that debate, and there have been agreements regarding the energy mix. As you know, we have been courting the Popular Party for a long time to make a great energy pact. You know that the Popular Party is not easy on these matters, but we must continue.

What I wish to convey is that I am aware, and the Government is aware, that we must continue working on energy policy and on the decisions and future options for this country. Economic actors know this, companies know this, and the Government must be the first to lead this reflection.

We have taken measures that have alleviated situations that could have been more serious, but there is still… By the way, it is not only a problem of our country. Let’s say that energy policy is today at the center, and has been for years, of the major issues in many countries, especially in countries that have a high energy dependency, as is well known in Spain. In all countries with high energy dependency, energy is a central issue that requires a lot of work and, of course, if there is, a lot of consensus.

Regarding the calendar, there has been a consensus in all the voices that have spoken --I think I dare say that 98 percent or 99 percent of those who were at the meeting spoke-- and it is about the urgency and depth of the reforms, both those that have already been undertaken or are very advanced, as well as those that we currently have in the decisive phase for their approval, and I can assure you that the calendar…

Economic measures and reforms are not conditioned by any other circumstance. I have said it on some occasions: the economic crisis, the severe international economic and financial crisis, has created a difficult situation in our country, and above any other circumstance are the decisions that need to be made and that we have made—many of them, I do not need to reiterate, are not popular, not precisely popular—essential for our country and that will bear fruit. When we see the path of economic growth, job creation, the reduction of our economy's debt, greater productivity, greater competitiveness, and greater export capacity, we will know and remember that they were the result of two or three very difficult years, of difficult measures.

There is no other element that conditions the political calendar, which must always be secondary to what this country still has to do and has ahead of it.

Q.- A couple of questions, Mr. President. First, I would like to know if the plan you announced to encourage the emergence of undeclared employment was also part of the topics discussed in the meeting and if you received any concerns from business owners regarding this issue.

Regarding collective bargaining, I would also like to ask if you received any message from business owners about the need for changes in the wage-setting model in collective bargaining.

President.- Regarding collective bargaining, as I have said, there has been a report from the president of the CEOE, Juan Rosell, which has been a thorough report, reasonably hopeful regarding the possibility of an agreement and that this agreement implies changes in the right direction. This has meant that the specific topic of aspects of collective bargaining has not been one of the most prominent topics after Mr. Rosell's intervention.

On the other hand, the comments that have been made have been favorable to the plan for the regularization of undeclared employment, which, as you know, the Government, specifically the Ministry of Labor, will present to the social agents for approval during this month of April.

Q.- Mr. President, I heard a couple of criticisms this morning about this meeting from small and medium-sized business owners, who say that you never meet with them, that you only meet with large companies, and they are also job creators. Do you plan to meet with them at some point or how do you respond to them?

There have also been criticisms from the leader of the Popular Party, Mariano Rajoy, today in Toledo. He just said that the measures you outlined yesterday in Brussels are not credible because in two weeks, more or less, you will change them again. I would like you to assess those criticisms.

President.- I doubt that he has dedicated much time to their content; I am referring to Mr. Rajoy. Therefore, as he almost always pronounces, regardless of what happens, against it, whether he has read it or whatever the measure is, well... I am even surprised by the question because it is not news. You usually ask about things that are more newsworthy or novel. But I understand that it is logical to ask about what the leader of the opposition says.

Regarding small and medium-sized enterprises, the meeting with large companies has a fundamental objective: they represent a very important part of the GDP and have a particular responsibility. This meeting, above all, is to listen. The Government listens to large companies, but the Government asks large companies. It asks them for commitment, responsibility, and trust, and, in particular, today we asked them for something concrete in terms of training: the plan for thirty thousand initial scholarships to create more opportunities for young people with lower qualifications. We also proposed another program, significantly for SMEs. It is a program for them to extend their training capacity to their auxiliary companies, with support and incentives from the Government. And it has also been very well received.

So, SMEs have been present in the meeting, in favor of them. But I insist, of course, the Government, the Vice President, and I myself meet with SMEs as often as necessary, as I have always met when I have met with the CEOE.

But this meeting has that particularity. It is a meeting in which we listen, the Government listens, and it is very useful for us. Keep in mind that the companies that are in the world are there, and those companies today conveyed to us what they hear from their investors around the world when they meet with them, what they think, and how that confidence has improved. It is a very broad representation. That is very useful for the Government, but moreover, the Government asks them for commitment and responsibility. And we must ask that of the strongest, the large ones.

Thank you very much.