Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

22 November 2005 · Parliamentary control session (sesión de control)

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions on railway pricing disparities and the Euro-Mediterranean Summit during a November 2005 congressional control session in Spain.
Main themes
High-speed rail equality, railway tariff fairness, infrastructure modernization, Lleida-Zaragoza-Madrid line, Euro-Mediterranean Conference Barcelona, regional grievances, transport investment, Spain-Catalonia-Aragon relations, neighborhood policy, terrorism and immigration
Duration
~18 min
61st percentile
Words
2,195
61st percentile
Sentences
79
52nd percentile
Readability
40
35th percentile
Grade
14.0
67th percentile
Syntax
3.42
91st percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
51st percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 34%33%
  • Institutional 28%27%
  • Economic 21%20%
  • Geopolitical 9%9%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

79 sentences in 41 paragraphs

RESPONSE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT TO THE QUESTION RAISED BY MR. JOAN PUIGCERCÓS, OF THE PARLIAMENTARY GROUP OF ESQUERRA REPUBLICANA DE CATALUNYA

---------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Puigcercós.- Mr. President of the Government, what measures does the Government intend to undertake to ensure equal conditions for all users of railways and high-speed trains? Users of the Lleida-Zaragoza-Madrid line recently discovered, with the inauguration of the Madrid-Toledo train, the differences that existed. In times when equality and solidarity among all citizens of the State are preached and sometimes demanded from various platforms, we have discovered that a journey of 75 kilometers costs eight euros --the Madrid-Toledo-- that is, 1.6 euros for every ten kilometers, and with a pass for fifty trips, it is reduced to 0.48 euros for every ten kilometers. Curiously, the Madrid-Zaragoza-Lleida route costs 56 euros for 470 kilometers, that is, 1.18 euros for every ten kilometers. A significant difference when considering the pass.

We sincerely believe that there are prices at two speeds; moreover, two speeds because, in addition, after the botched job, the absurdity, and the calamity of Mr. Álvarez-Cascos' journey on the Madrid-Zaragoza-Lleida stretch, it is not only a problem of prices; it is also a problem of speed. It was promised that the high-speed train between Madrid-Zaragoza-Lleida would have a top speed of 350 kilometers, and it turns out we are at 200.

In addition to going slower and being more expensive, it rains on wet ground, because we have recently read in the media that if the speed performance were improved, the fare for users of the Madrid-Lleida route, passing through Zaragoza, would increase.

Different institutions and users from Aragón and Catalonia, specifically from Lleida, have gathered in Huesca to demand equal treatment. We sincerely believe that intervention is necessary here, that a fair treatment for all citizens using the railway must be guaranteed. The regions of Lleida have suffered a grievance, and we sincerely believe that in these times, no grievance should go unanswered. Trains of low quality, like the Manresa-Lleida; a highway, the National II, without doubling and for many years paying tolls. We sincerely believe that now is a good time to guarantee equality for railway and AVE users.

President.- As you know, the Government is implementing an ambitious plan to modernize the infrastructure of this country, especially railway infrastructure and, very specifically, what represents a great boost to High Speed. From the current one thousand kilometers of High Speed, we will move to ten thousand kilometers. By way of example, I will tell you that in the last three months, the Ministry of Development has awarded or tendered works worth 2.9 billion euros. This will mean that all provincial capitals will have direct access to these lines and 90 percent of the population will be located less than fifty kilometers from a station on this network.

Railway infrastructure, and especially High Speed, once completed in its various stretches, must offer similar performances and thereby provide similar conditions of use, services, punctuality, safety, versatility, and price.

I want to express my understanding of what the dissatisfaction stemming from inadequate planning and execution of the High-Speed Train Line from Madrid to Lleida represents. This is representing for this Government a significant investment effort to correct many deficiencies.

And, of course, I want to express to you, Mr. Puigcercós, and I want to express to the Chamber that, from those comparable offers and performances, the Government is committed to designing a versatile tariff system that aims for the similarity of economic conditions and all types for its users throughout the national territory.

RESPONSE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT TO THE QUESTION RAISED BY MR. JOSEP ANTONI DURÁN I LLEIDA, OF THE PARLIAMENTARY GROUP CATALÁN DE CONVERGÉNCIA I UNIÓ

---------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Durán i Lleida.- Aside from the ups and downs of daily politics, the Chamber knows that this weekend the Euromediterranean Conference is being held in Barcelona. I would like to know the Government's objectives for that Summit but at the same time, if you allow me, Mr. President, Ladies and Gentlemen, I would also like to explain what considerations our Parliamentary Group has regarding it.

First of all, Convergència i Unió wishes that it is not simply a commemoration of the ten years of the Barcelona Process, but that it is genuinely a relaunch of Euromediterranean policy.

Secondly, it wishes that this policy is not viewed as a regional policy, but really as a global policy. In that area, there are global problems, such as terrorism and immigration, and they must be considered as such.

We wish, and we express this to the Government, that the neighborhood policy designed in the European Union does not replace the Barcelona Agreements, but rather complements or reinforces them in any case.

We also wish to be aware of the importance of the free trade area with the countries on the other side of the Mediterranean. I am not an apostle of liberalism, but undoubtedly, it is essential to ensure the competitiveness and capacity of that area to ultimately be a forum and a framework for progress and the generation of economic resources.

In that context, I believe that it is necessary to defend, Mr. President, the need for the integration of the South-South Market, which is one of the shortcomings when assessing these ten years of the Barcelona Process.

This Parliamentary Group also understands that among the objectives, we must add those that this very morning the Foreign Affairs Commission approved, at the initiative precisely of the Socialist Group, with some transnational amendment from Convergència i Unió or Esquerra Republicana.

This Parliamentary Group understands, and I want to remind you, that just yesterday this Chamber approved an initiative to take into account the rights of women in particular, considering also, as recommended by the UNDP reports from the United Nations, women as a driving force for economic progress in that area.

Furthermore, I believe, Mr. President, that it must be made clear in that assembly that respect for human rights is fundamental. From there, we can discuss models of democracy.

However, if something has failed during these years, it is that there has not been a permanent follow-up of Mediterranean policy. Therefore, our Group proposes, knowing that it is not something that can be resolved overnight, nor that it can be definitively agreed upon in Barcelona, that the Government commits, and I would like to know your position, to create a Permanent General Secretariat for the Mediterranean, as has been done at the Ibero-American level, to ensure continuity and effectiveness of the agreements that will be adopted in the Barcelona Process for the future and, in addition, that the Government commits that the headquarters, when possible, which must start through the procedure, will be the city of Barcelona.

President.- Indeed, the Summit that we will hold in Barcelona on the 27th and 28th of November represents an attempt to politically and economically revitalize the Barcelona Process, inaugurated precisely under Spanish Presidency in 1995. We are convinced that both the Declaration approved by the Summit and, more importantly, the work plan for the next five years will confirm and deepen the political and economic commitments of the 1995 Declaration, expanding to specific areas of great importance, such as immigration, Interior and Justice, with the priority objective of promoting democracy, human rights, social cohesion, the free market, and above all, the participation of women in educational, social, and labor life.

In this sense, we will concretely support the objective of creating a large Euromed free trade area by 2010; the creation of a sufficiently funded neighborhood financial instrument by the European Union; the continuity of the European Investment Bank's facility for the Southern Mediterranean, as well as the opening of new specific lines of credit for the private sector.

And I can confirm to Mr. Durán, responding to his concern, that the Government of Spain will defend a new institutionalization in what represents the Barcelona Process and the relationship between the European Union and the Mediterranean. We are convinced that a new structure, a General Secretariat, a specific responsible person for the management, development, application, and promotion of these integration policies between Europe and the Mediterranean to overcome the gap of economic and social development would undoubtedly be a decisive and determining lever.

Therefore, you can count on my commitment to defend that, and I am convinced that this initial defense will pave the way for what will represent a new impetus, from the perspective of an institutional structure, for the Euromediterranean area.

RESPONSE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT TO THE QUESTION RAISED BY MR. MARIANO RAJOY, OF THE POPULAR PARLIAMENTARY GROUP

---------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President of the Government, I ask you about a capital issue: the education of Spanish children and young people. Today, no one doubts, neither parents, nor teachers, nor students, that the LOGSE has been very negative for our educational system.

The previous Government approved a law, the Quality Law, which represented a step in the right direction. You repealed it upon taking office and announced a new Law and a social pact for Education. There was no such pact. The Law received nearly two thousand amendments in the State School Council, the Council of State in its opinion said that it might have been more advisable to apply the Quality Law, and just a few days ago, more than a million people, mostly parents and young people, anxious and concerned, took to the streets. It was one of the most important demonstrations in our modern history.

Mr. President, you like to talk a lot about dialogue. I have offered you, and I reiterate it now, a Pact for Education, but a serious and genuine pact. I believe that the Spanish people would appreciate it, and I would like you to set aside tactics and strategies for once and try to reach an agreement on this capital issue for everyone.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, the Government is committed to improving education and to the social cohesion of our country.

Every educational reform has led to demonstrations in our country. That is not new; what is new is that the President of the Government has respected the demonstrators, has called them, and has sat down to dialogue and negotiate with them, unlike what happened on other occasions.

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, you met with the conveners, and as usual, you committed to nothing. But then you met with another part of the educational sector that did not convene the demonstration, and some of those people told you that an educational pact would be desirable.

I want to say that, as the debate is developing in the Cortes, things are going very badly, Mr. President. A working group that lasted two hours, more than a thousand amendments presented by the Parliamentary Groups, and only 37 were accepted, all from the Socialist Party. Now they want to liquidate the debate in the Commission in two days. The Popular Party has presented 120 amendments, and none have been accepted.

Mr. President, we are talking about the future of the Spanish people, we are talking about the prestige of Spain, about opportunities in a global world that is going to be very difficult, and we are talking about a topic that is basic and capital for the competitiveness of our economy, and not only for a better knowledge of individuals.

I am willing to talk to you. You have the habit and are determined to isolate the Popular Party; you like to say those things about "they are alone." I believe you should make an effort to forget a little about politics, strategy, and tactics; to have a little patriotism, so that once and for all, the general interest prevails when it comes to a topic that concerns, Mr. President, and you cannot make a law against millions and millions of Spaniards. You cannot act against so many people at once, Mr. President of the Government.

And I am willing to talk to you about this issue of Education and, by the way, also about the issue...

President.- Mr. Rajoy, our educational system has made tremendous progress in these thirty years of democracy and is so solid that it has not been affected by such null Education Ministers as you, who occupied that portfolio for fifteen months, and the mark is so nonexistent that almost no one remembers that you were Minister of Education. Even when I listen to you, and I also read some things, I believe you have forgotten that you were Minister of Education of the Government of Spain.

I want to tell you: our education needs to improve, it has problems; our teachers and students have great potential. And from here I say to you: yes to a school pact, yes to a pact that improves all education, yes to a pact that strengthens public education, yes to a pact that defends and guarantees Religion for those who want it as a subject, but only for those who want it.

Let’s be clear: if it is about marginalizing public school or imposing Religion, look for someone else. Not me.