Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

27 March 2007 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions during a government control session in Spain's Congress on March 27, 2007, addressing Basque Economic Concert concerns and Catalan airport management.
Main themes
Basque Economic Concert, foral autonomy, parliamentary control session, Basque self-government, legislative reform, political trust and credibility, tax autonomy of Foral Councils, airport management model in Catalonia
Duration
~21 min
67th percentile
Words
2,490
67th percentile
Sentences
76
50th percentile
Readability
45
49th percentile
Grade
14.3
70th percentile
Syntax
3.49
94th percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
29th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 75%75%
  • Economic 14%14%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

76 sentences in 39 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josu Iñaki Erkoreka, of the Basque Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Erkoreka.- Mr. President of the Government, I will not take a single second of my allotted time explaining the dangers that threaten the Economic Concert. I know that you are aware of them because, among other things, I personally had the opportunity to explain them to you not long ago.

What I would like to express is my personal discontent and that of my entire Parliamentary Group regarding your decision to reject the amendments we presented against the Organic Law Project of the Constitutional Court with the aim of safeguarding the Economic Concert, and especially the fact that this decision was made after nine long months of intense and what we believed to be fruitful negotiations. That is why I pose the question that appears on the agenda: How do you propose to address the defense of the Basque Economic Concert from the progressive erosion it is undergoing?

President.- Mr. Erkoreka, I want to reiterate that the Government respects and protects the historical rights of the foral territories and, of course, that respect and protection extends to the Economic Concert as the highest expression of forality guaranteed in the Constitution, which has subsequently developed mainly in the Statute of Autonomy of the Basque Country, in the Law of the Concert itself, and in the successive agreements on the Basque Country's Quota.

In each of those norms and agreements, the progressive increase of the tax autonomy of the Foral Councils has been a constant; I believe you are well aware of this. And the Government has been faithfully complying with the current Law of 2002 in coordination with the Foral Administrations. To that end, as you know, the creation of bodies, working groups, and the adoption of common procedures has been promoted.

I regret the disagreement and the position maintained by the Basque Nationalist Group in the legislative process to which you have referred, but, as you know, the position of the Government and the Socialist Group is that it was neither the time nor the place to address that issue.

Mr. Erkoreka.- Mr. President, I regret to disagree with you. It was the time and it was the place. Precisely for that reason, I would like to send you the clearest possible message.

You see, safeguarding the Economic Concert is not an anecdotal, secondary, or irrelevant claim for my Parliamentary Group; it is a top-priority demand. So much so that we are willing to elevate it as a parameter of your credibility, as an indicator of your political and personal reliability, because if you are not capable of supporting a legislative reform of a simple Organic Law in order to remove the Economic Concert from this provoked litigation that is clearly emptying it of content, there is little to expect from your willingness to explore and address a profound reform of Basque self-government based on the Additional Provision and the possibilities offered by the historical rights recognized in that Provision.

As you well know, the fundamental historical right that underpins the Additional Provision of the constitutional norm is the Economic Concert, and if we do not operate, if we do not function, with responsibility to cover and safeguard the Economic Concert, there is little to expect from what we can do with everything else.

That is why, Mr. President, we believe it is the time to prove that you deserve our trust, and I hope you do not disappoint us.

President.- Mr. Erkoreka, I reiterate that I regret your position; I understand it, because it has been an initiative you have maintained repeatedly, but which, in the opinion of the Government and the Socialist Group, was not, as I have said, the time or the place.

That does not mean that we do not have many points of agreement in the substance of the proposal, and surely, sooner rather than later, we will address it and provide a solution, because that is the will of the majority Group and the Government. I am convinced that we will do so through dialogue and, of course, also understanding and respecting the nuances or disagreements that may exist, as has characterized the attitude of your Group always with the Government and with the Socialist Group, which I certainly want to thank you for.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Joan Herrera, of the Parliamentary Group of United Left-Initiative for Catalonia Greens

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Herrera.- Mr. President, last week more than a thousand people representing the economic world gathered to call for a change in the airport management model. For many months, all political forces in Catalonia, including Mr. Piqué -- it is also true that he says it in Catalonia and not here -- have asked for a change in the airport management model. The question is not only what your opinion is, but what you are going to do, because we understand that you have an opportunity, the opportunity of the bilateral Commission on April 16; a bilateral Commission in which infrastructure will be discussed and a bilateral Commission in which you must do something more, say something new.

Democracy is listening, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, and what we expect is that you have listened well, that you listen well to the demand of Catalan society and that you move forward, betting, ultimately, on a new airport management model. That is why we ask you not only what you think, but what you are going to do, following that demonstration from last week.

President.- Mr. Herrera, I want to express my respect, of course, for what was the event held regarding the situation of the El Prat airport, the future of El Prat, the importance it has for the economy of Catalonia, for the economic opening of Catalonia; not only for Catalonia, but for a good part of the whole of Spain, and that undoubtedly shows the vitality and interest of Catalan society in its own future, as has traditionally been the case.

I can assure you that the Government shares that interest and that will for the El Prat airport to continue in a permanent improvement and that it has ahead the necessary modification in what is the airport management model to satisfy what is, without a doubt, a widely held sentiment among the political forces in Catalonia and in the whole of society.

I want to remind you that we are making a great effort with El Prat, an investment of three billion euros; that it has a great potential ahead, and that there are already facts, such as the opening of the third runway, the control center in Gavá, and the new control tower. We are planning an airport to have a capacity of up to 55 million people starting at the end of 2008, doubling the current capacity. And, of course, we also want to resolve the access and communication infrastructures of the airport.

Certainly, the Government is at the disposal of that dialogue process to address what is the future management model of the El Prat airport from the perspective that the central Government has always understood, and that is a comprehensive vision of our airport system, of what AENA represents and, of course, the possibility that this is compatible with the aspirations of a good part of Catalan society.

Mr. Herrera.- Mr. President, the problem is not the investments; the problem is that you propose a new management model. I told you, and you have said it many times: governing is listening, and listening means, in this case, not that we are explained the investments, but that the debate is addressed and that it is addressed by proposing on April 16 a new airport management model where autonomy prevails. That means a model different from the one we have in Spain; a model like the one they have all over the planet or in all of Europe.

That is why, what do we ask of you? Not only to share the reflection but to share precisely the proposal. To share is to decide, and to decide means to start walking, and to start walking with a more effective, more European airport management model, and therefore, different from the one you propose today.

Here I tell you, Mr. President, that you have two options; that is our point of view. You have two options: you can continue hand in hand with an unusual model like the one we have today in Spain, hand in hand with AENA, even hand in hand with the Minister of Development, or you can bet, Mr. President, on a reasonable management model, where autonomy prevails and where leadership is exercised from proximity. That is what the citizens are asking for.

If you want, we can talk about it. We can talk about it over coffee, which costs seventy cents in the Congress cafeteria and much more at the El Prat airport. But what we want is not just to talk, but to decide, and to decide we want you to simply propose a new proposal, a new management model on April 16.

President.- Mr. Herrera, you will agree with me that investments are decisive for the future of El Prat. Of course, I listen to Catalan society, to the political forces in Catalonia, and we will have time, we are going to have time, to work in that dialogue and see changes in the airport management model and, specifically, in El Prat. That is my commitment.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, the facts that motivate this question are as follows: in March 2004, the High Court of Justice of the Basque Country, following an accusation from the Prosecutor's Office, sentenced Otegi to fifteen months in prison for the crime of glorifying terrorism; later, the Supreme Court annulled the sentence because it accepted a recusal against one of the judges and ordered that the trial be repeated. To general surprise, the Prosecutor did everything possible to prevent the trial from being held; he requested several postponements. Later, the Attorney General of the State, who has said that a political channel must be sought for the abertzale left -- he says -- to run in the elections, hinted that the Prosecutor would withdraw the accusation; then, the Prosecutor withdrew the accusation and did so after Mr. Otegi failed to appear in court and they had to go look for him on a plane paid for by the Spanish taxpayer because the judge wanted him to appear. Later, the Prosecutor acted in such a way during the hearing that the defense attorney for Mr. Otegi did not even have to intervene.

The question I ask you seems to me to be a matter of pure common sense, Mr. President: why did the Prosecutor request that the trial be postponed, why did he interrogate Mr. Otegi as he did, and why did he withdraw the accusation when there was no legal reason to advise it? I would ask you to answer these questions, which are questions made from a democratic point of view, with a logic that seems to me to be unassailable.

President.- From the point of view of common sense, I would have to make a clarification: from a legal standpoint, it is the Prosecutor who has the competence in each case to maintain or withdraw an accusation; it is neither you nor me. Therefore, I believe that the best way to contribute, certainly from the Government, but also, from my point of view, from the opposition, to what is the functioning of the Rule of Law is to respect the decisions of judges and prosecutors who act within the margin of the autonomy of the Law according to their loyal and informed understanding.

And I want to tell you, Mr. Rajoy, that they are prosecutors, some of them, specifically the one who has had responsibility in this case, with a long tradition in the National Court of a very high number of accusations for alleged terrorism or collaboration. I have respect for all prosecutors, and I believe you should do the same.

Mr. Rajoy.- The problem, Mr. President of the Government, is that I have no relationship with the Prosecutor, and you do, because Article 8 of the Statute of the Prosecutor's Office states that "the Government may request the Attorney General to promote before the Courts the pertinent actions in defense of the public interest." You do the exact opposite. The Prosecutor's actions have been lamentable; he has given Mr. Otegi preferential treatment and has not defended the Law, but a political interest.

I am very sorry, Mr. President, but I have to tell you one thing: you did not want Otegi to go to prison, just as you wanted De Juana Chaos to be released from it. The sentencing court said that it had to acquit Otegi because, although there were reasons and arguments to convict him, it did not do so because the Prosecutor requested the acquittal.

My duty is to demand accountability from you because, just as you have to govern, I have the obligation to control the Government. I fulfill my obligation, and you do not. You do not defend the general interest; you defend another, which in this case is that of Mr. Otegi. And I regret to say it this way because it is the truth.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, I regret to have to tell you that the Government has neither given an instruction nor has it been interested in the procedure to which you refer in this question. The Government respects the actions of the Public Prosecutor's Office, of all the prosecutors who day by day formulate accusations, or withdraw them, or request penalties in the criminal proceedings they deem appropriate.

From the point of view of political responsibility, Mr. Rajoy, you cannot cast doubt on the honesty of a long-standing prosecutor, who freely evaluates and judges their actions, unless in your experience in government different things happened with the Attorney General's Office, but that is not the case at this moment.

Therefore, I must appeal to you, Mr. Rajoy, to take responsibility, to respect the functioning of the rule of law, to judges and prosecutors, and to not say, because it is false and a lie, false and a lie, that the Government has influenced any action of the Prosecutor. As things in politics must be, in public debate, as they must be, either you prove that this is the case or, simply, it is false and does not correspond to the truth.

Be responsible and respect judges and prosecutors, because you will respect the rule of law in the way that citizens have decided.