Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

20 March 2007 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions during a government control session in the Spanish Congress on March 20, 2007, addressing Wealth Tax reform and regional issues.
Main themes
Wealth Tax reform, autonomous communities fiscal competence, tax system in Spain, European comparison of wealth taxes, savings and capital flight, parliamentary oversight, economic growth and fiscal policy, regional financing dialogue
Duration
~19 min
62nd percentile
Words
2,232
62nd percentile
Sentences
64
42nd percentile
Readability
32
19th percentile
Grade
17.3
91st percentile
Syntax
3.53
95th percentile
Vocabulary
2.28
68th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 45%45%
  • Economic 41%41%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

64 sentences in 37 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josep Antoni Duran i Lleida, of the Catalan Parliamentary Group of Convergència i Unió

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Duran.- Mr. President of the Government, Article 31.1 of the Constitution clearly states that taxes levied on the income of Spaniards shall never be confiscatory in nature. In the opinion of this Parliamentary Group and, of course, of experts in economics, the Wealth Tax today has a confiscatory character. Consequently, I would like to know, Mr. President, whether this Government, as has been hinted at by some members of it, intends to annul or abolish this tax during this legislature.

President.- Mr. Duran, as Your Lordship knows and as the Second Vice President of the Government and Minister of Economy has already indicated, the Executive is currently studying the possible reform of this tax with the idea of reinforcing its original character. I want to remind you that, in any case, it is a tax ceded to the Autonomous Communities. The law regulating the current system of autonomous financing attributes to them normative competence regarding the exempt minimum, the tax rate or tariff, and deductions and bonuses on the quota, which must be compatible with the state ones and applied subsequently to them.

Therefore, the ultimate parameters of this tax figure are ultimately determined by the decisions of the Autonomous Communities, which have the possibility of giving it greater or lesser importance from a revenue perspective.

As I have just informed you, the Government is studying, especially based on what is happening in other countries in our European Union environment, a thorough reform of the Wealth Tax. We are in the study phase, and once that study is completed, we will take the next step, which will logically, as is institutionally appropriate, be dialogue with the Autonomous Communities.

Mr. Duran.- The proof that you are studying it is that it is a state tax, yes, certainly, ceded to the Autonomous Communities; but, to the extent that it were abolished at the state level, the principle of loyalty should be applied, and therefore, remit the corresponding revenues that the Autonomous Communities would cease to receive.

But we are talking about something that affects the savings of families, we are talking about something that affects and mortgages the economy of this country itself, and we are talking about something that you know as well as I do, or even better, that no longer exists in the rest of Europe. In recent years it has been abolished in Germany, Denmark, Austria, the Netherlands, last year in Luxembourg and Finland. There are only three countries, Sweden, Spain, and France, but both France and Sweden are considering that debate, and the Economic Commission of the French Parliamentary Assembly has concluded that the rate should be reduced, at least.

This Parliamentary Group insists. This is a tax that does not have the meaning it had originally. It should have had and should have a strict central purpose. Today it is not so; today, I reiterate, it taxes and frustrates the capacity of the very wealth, causes relocations of wealth, is one of the conclusions of the Economic Commission of the French Assembly, and consequently, to the extent that one day the economic sign of our country may turn, which we have always maintained is based, to use the redundancy, basically on the growth of construction and on internal consumption, it is advisable to revive, it is advisable to inject, into our economy and, of course, it would be, as this Parliamentary Group requests, the abolition of the Wealth Tax, Mr. President.

President.- I want to inform you that the Government, as is logical, must conduct an in-depth study of the possible impact of a reform of the Wealth Tax both on the general tax system and on the financing system, and it must be a determining element when it comes to the reform we intend to carry out.

I want to reiterate that the Government is in the study phase. I can share some of the aspects that have been analyzed and that have been communicated regarding the meaning today and the meaning in the past of the Wealth Tax; but, logically, we want to take our time to see the impact and scope that this reform may have.

In any case, I do want to remind you that, beyond your position, it is this Government that is taking the initiative to provide a solution to the current situation and to the real validity of the Wealth Tax.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Agustí Cerdà, of the Parliamentary Group of Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Cerdà.- Mr. President, on December 20, you committed to this spokesperson to promote El Prat Airport as the second center for intercontinental connections of the Spanish State. On March 1, during your visit to Barcelona, you reiterated that commitment and also announced that the State Government would take into account the opinion of the Generalitat in the process of awarding the new South Terminal. From Esquerra, we denounce that we cannot accept that the criteria for awarding the new Terminal be defined unilaterally by the Board of Directors of AENA.

Mr. President, Esquerra Republicana urges you to ensure that the award is agreed upon with the Generalitat of Catalunya and is carried out with knowledge of the future commitments of the different alliances, betting on intercontinental connection flights with interesting frequencies and schedules, reinforcing the role of Barcelona Airport as an operations center, contributing to the development of air cargo, enhancing the strategic areas of Asia and the Euro-Mediterranean region, and balancing the volume of business and tourism travel.

For all these reasons, Mr. President, I ask you the following question: how do you plan to concretize the commitment made on March 1 in Barcelona, in the sense that you will take into account the opinion of the Generalitat in the process of awarding the South Terminal of El Prat Airport?

President.- Mr. Cerdà, I reiterate today that the Government has a full commitment to the development of Barcelona Airport and with actions. That commitment and the significant investment that is being made to ensure that Barcelona Airport ranks ninth among European airports is the result of that great investment effort; more than three billion, which has already allowed the operation of the third runway, the control center in Gavá, and the new control tower. There are one hundred projects underway, 55 different companies involved, and an average of 2,450 people working on the works, which will allow El Prat to have a capacity of more than 55 million travelers per year; practically double the current capacity.

The responsibility for the decision on the management of Barcelona Airport lies with the State, through AENA, as is known; but, of course, I renew and reaffirm the commitment that the Government has through the Ministry of Development to ensure that consensus presides over the actions in which Your Lordship is interested; consensus, the search for consensus.

We are convinced that this will be a path that will strengthen the future of El Prat Airport and will provide all the possibilities that this great engine of economic growth and development for Catalonia represents, much more so after the investments that are currently underway. Logically, the decision must be oriented to maximize the growth potential of the Airport and to create all the conditions for it to consolidate as a hub that allows operators to grow and develop their operations without restrictions.

Mr. Cerdà.- Mr. President, I did not ask you about the investments, which I already know about, but about the awarding of the South Terminal. As you know, more than 130 business, academic, and professional entities will hold an event tomorrow in Barcelona in defense of an intercontinental airport with individualized management.

From Esquerra, we ask you that the State Government listen to this outcry from Catalan civil society, as the economy of 21st century Catalonia cannot afford the luxury of having decisions about such an important infrastructure for our country continue to be made unilaterally more than six hundred kilometers away from the meeting point, Barcelona Airport.

For all these reasons, Mr. President, we urge you to accept the active participation and not just as a mere observer of the Generalitat de Catalunya in the process of awarding the South Terminal, and to foresee the possibility of reconsidering the distribution of spaces in the new Terminal in case the aforementioned criteria are not met, as AENA already did with T-4 in Barajas.

President.- I reiterate to you, active participation of the Generalitat, yes, and consensus, the search for consensus, by those who have the legally established responsibility for the awarding of the South Terminal. But allow me to say that, if we are, and the Catalan society, which I know values greatly what El Prat represents, is in this situation to have a great airport with a great projection for Catalonia, it is because we are making an investment of more than three billion euros in El Prat by the national government, with a clear commitment to the development and progress of Catalonia.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- The previous anti-terrorist policy put ETA in a position of extreme weakness; you changed it. Since then, among other things, the following has happened: Batasuna, dissolved by the courts, holds press conferences every day; it acts like a normal party; it appears on television more than democratic parties; it meets with its party, with the PSOE; it receives a lamentable preferential treatment from the Prosecutor's Office, and now it announces that it will run in the elections and publicly presents its candidates.

I want to say and I want to ask you if you are going to allow it to run and if you are doing anything to prevent it.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, it is evident that the Government is going to do what it is obliged to do, which is to comply with the Law and enforce the Law; and, of course, through the units that in this case have the primary responsibility to ensure that all candidacies that wish to present themselves strictly respect the Law; that is, the State Legal Service, the Ministry of the Interior, and the Attorney General's Office. We are going to comply with the Law on Political Parties to the letter.

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, what is happening here is very concerning and it is no longer time for ambiguities. You have not acted in the case of the Communist Party of the Basque Lands; neither the Prosecutor nor the State Attorney's Office did so. This party, on its website, boasts of its support for ETA and has recently not condemned the terrorist attack by ETA in Barajas.

You talk to me about the Prosecutor's Office, but the Prosecutor's Office is doing everything possible and impossible to delay the trials of the Batasuna leader, Otegi, and to avoid new convictions. I tell you that Mr. Otegi has preferential treatment compared to the rest of Spanish citizens, and there has been an event in recent days that is certainly shocking: the Prosecutor of the National Court has questioned the impartiality of the National Court tribunal, and Otegi uses that argument to his advantage. And now the umpteenth scandal could occur if the Prosecutor withdraws the charges after the farce that has occurred today.

You talk to me about the Minister of the Interior, but the Ministry of the Interior, instead of investigating these candidacies that are being presented in the Basque Country, is dedicated to investigating the actions of the Popular Party when it was in government.

You, Mr. President, after what happened with De Juana Chaos, are desperately imploring a message from ETA that allows you to justify what no one understands: that a terrorist organization, without ceasing to be one, is going to the elections. It took a long time and a lot of effort to keep it out of municipal institutions; if they return, the only responsible will be you.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, I am not surprised that you have no respect for the autonomy and function of the Attorney General's Office, of the Prosecutor's Office in general, and I am not surprised because you have already demonstrated the respect you have even for the Supreme Court when it issues rulings in cases related to terrorism, as in the case of De Juana Chaos.

I want to tell you that with this, you have asked me sixteen questions since the beginning of the Legislature about ETA and terrorism; sixteen questions about ETA and none about health, no questions about pensions, no questions about the disabled, no questions about research, no questions about climate change, to give some examples...

It seems after this trajectory, of asking every week about ETA and terrorism, that you can only oppose with anti-terrorist policy, precisely in what you should not oppose the Government of Spain, as has happened since the beginning of democracy.

Do you know what I'm telling you? Do you know what I think? That opposing only with ETA, with the anti-terrorist policy, besides being irresponsible, is a perfectly useless opposition for the citizens.