Interview with the President of the Government on the program "I Have a Question for You," from Televisión Española.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

26 March 2007 · "I Have a Question for You" programme, Televisión Española · Televisión Española studios

Context
Zapatero participated in a live televised Q&A on Spanish public television in March 2007, answering questions from 100 citizens on terrorism and governance.
Main themes
ETA terrorism and peace process, anti-terrorist policy limits, De Juana Chaos case, dialogue with terrorists, citizen trust in government, rule of law, IRA peace process comparison, social rights and economic progress, democratic debate, government accountability
Duration
~132 min
99th percentile
Words
15,801
99th percentile
Sentences
599
99th percentile
Readability
52
69th percentile
Grade
12.4
50th percentile
Syntax
3.30
82nd percentile
Vocabulary
1.98
9th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

599 sentences in 232 paragraphs

Lorenzo Milá.- Thank you very much, Mr. President, on behalf of Radiotelevisión Española, for accepting this invitation to participate in this unprecedented format.

President.- Good evening.

L. Milá.- Never before has a Prime Minister, or generally a relevant political leader, faced questions from one hundred citizens live on television in our country. Tonight we will have ninety minutes and we will try to allow as many questions as possible to be asked. For that, we have asked them to be concise and brief in their questions, and we ask the same of you: to make an effort to be succinct.

President.- I will make the utmost effort, although you know that it is not easy for politicians.

L. Milá.- It is not easy. Those subordinate clauses that tend to sneak in… but we ask you to make an effort.

They have the opportunity, and I hope they take it, to ask a question live to the Prime Minister, and I hope you take your opportunity to speak directly to the citizens.

P.- Before I ask my question, let me give you a bit of context. I have lived, unfortunately, like many Spaniards, with the presence of ETA in my life, since I was five years old when I had to go to school with an escort. I didn’t quite understand why my father, when I was little, would crouch down to check the underside of the car, and when I finally understood, I spent a year and a half not wanting to get in the car with him. So, I don’t understand how a Government and a President whom I trusted at the polls can sit down with murderers to dialogue about who knows what, because I don’t believe that peace can be discussed with weapons. I don’t understand why the Government I trusted prioritizes the interests of an individual, a murderer like De Juana Chaos, and an individual like Otegi, over the interests of the citizens.

I don’t know why it doesn’t listen to the citizens; I don’t know if you think that with this speech I am getting too close to your opposition; but I can tell you that I am a voter of the Socialist Party and I feel therefore outraged, deceived, and ashamed that my President, whom I have trusted, negotiates and yields to the blackmail of murderers.

My question is whether your Government has set any limits in anti-terrorist policy and whether you do not think it has gotten out of hand.

President.- First of all, I appreciate the trust you placed in the Socialist Party in the last elections, and I want to make a general observation. Your question has been of a general nature, although you have cited some specific cases, which I find relevant.

Spain is a country with a very promising future. We are experiencing great economic growth, with significant job creation, with the possibility of expanding social rights; we are a country that lives democracy and has had thirty magnificent years, and we only, only, have one serious problem that the duty of the Prime Minister, as it has been for all Prime Ministers, is to put an end to, which is the terrorism of ETA.

In the face of ETA terrorism, a Government must prevent, combat, and try to end the violence of ETA. And, as has happened in many processes of organizations of this nature, in many other places we have just seen what happened in Ireland with the end of IRA terrorism, a process that lasted ten years, there is a possibility that this end can come through dialogue; a dialogue in which the Government has maintained firmness, the Law, and the Rule of Law. The only possible dialogue to end ETA is for them to lay down their arms, to end the violence, and for those who claim to defend ideas to do so democratically, with words and never with violence.

Therefore, after nearly forty years, because we have been fighting this throughout democracy, all parties and all Spanish society, my duty is to try to end this scourge, which is the only serious scourge we have in Spain.

P.- If you had the opportunity to meet, for example, in a bar with a group of ordinary citizens who have just finished their workday and are engaged in a debate about politics, talking about their problems, their day-to-day lives, how would you explain to that group of workers that a person who has killed twenty-five people and threatened judges is not in prison?

President.- For the explanation, it is important that we have the data of a situation and of an absolutely exceptional case, which is the case of De Juana Chaos. De Juana Chaos served his sentence according to the current legislation, which came from Francoism, for the twenty-five murders he committed and, subsequently, was charged and sentenced for a crime of threats to three years: final resolution of the Supreme Court.

He had served a year and a half of his sentence, and he had a year and a half left, during which, according to our penitentiary system, a good part of the inmates who serve that sentence have some penitentiary regime that is not strictly being incarcerated twenty-four hours a day, and he was on a hunger strike, as we all know, throwing, it is true, a challenge.

The responsibility, always within the Law, in the decision we have made to keep De Juana Chaos in a penitentiary regime in which he is certainly neither free nor dead, because he was at risk, we understand is the one that best aligns with the general interests. The obligation of a Government is to assess all elements, to do so responsibly, and, of course, to also think about the security of the State.

P.- Precisely since the release of De Juana Chaos, in the media we have seen how the opposition has cited dead victims of terrorism, has raised the GAL again, and your party, the Government, has responded with deaths from the Iraq war and has talked about the deaths of terrorists released during the PP legislature. My question is when the Government and the opposition are going to stop politicizing the dead and victims of terrorism and the Iraq war, and will have a debate and political forms worthy of all citizens.

President.- It is my main desire. For there to be a more relaxed political climate, with less tension, we all must contribute; certainly, the Government, and I take on my part, to contribute to making the climate more serene and that on some issues, such as the fight against terrorism, we are united. That is what the Spanish people want and it is the best for the anti-terrorist struggle.

Certainly, I can say one thing, which I believe everyone here and those watching me at home can perfectly attest to: I was the leader of the opposition for four years and the first time I went to see President Aznar, when I was elected Secretary General of the Socialist Party, at La Moncloa I told him some things, but regarding terrorism I said: "nothing would make me happier than to see the end of ETA with you as Prime Minister and me as leader of the opposition. In this matter, you have a blank check; I will support all your anti-terrorist policy." And I fulfilled that, all Spaniards know it well, and the Popular Party knows it. I never asked in Parliament, I never criticized the Government; I always supported him, because for me the fight against terrorism is outside of party politics and must be a policy of all parties united.

I regret and feel that in this Legislature, practically from the beginning, even having had a first stage of more than three years in which there was no fatal victim of ETA, the opposition has focused its strategic attitude on ETA terrorism. In my opinion, it is a mistake, it is not good for anyone or anything, and my desire, which I have tried on many occasions, is that with the Popular Party, which is the only party that does not support the Government in such a difficult task, as everyone can understand, which is to fight against ETA and against terrorism; the Popular Party should have a different attitude.

I will continue to try, but in a democracy, each party acts freely, each political leader has their priorities. Mine was to give full support to the Government in the fight against ETA when I was in opposition, and I regret that it is not so at this historical moment.

P.- Mr. President, as a mother, I would tell you that I find the disqualifications among politicians to be disproportionate. The question would be: are you aware of the damage you are doing to our children and what it can generate?

President.- I believe we have a country that enjoys enviable democratic health, in which there is great pluralism, in which there is freedom of expression, and in which, moreover, we are fortunate to have a generation of young people and adolescents who will have more opportunities than practically the generations since we have had democracy, since the transition and of course since the previous regime. But I believe we can make distinctions here.

Honestly, both in my time in opposition and now, much more in my time as Prime Minister, I always try to maintain decorum. To defend my ideas, yes, but without insulting, without disqualifying, without exaggerating. I believe that is a democratic obligation, because, moreover, I am convinced that those who have deep ideas and clear principles do not need to insult or disqualify. We may disagree. Surely in this room, as happens in Spanish society and among parties, there are different and plural opinions; but we all have, from my point of view, the duty to do so with respect, calm, and serenity.

I completely agree with you that the best example, from those of us who represent citizens, for our young people but for society in general, is that we have the respect and tolerance to listen to the adversary, to refute or contradict them with arguments, never with insults and disqualifications.

P.- We are in a studio where I believe the three structural elements of a Welfare State are represented: politicians, the society represented by the one hundred citizens, and the media. Our assessment of these three elements is that we have incompetent and corrupt politicians, we have a disarticulated and disconnected society, and the media are demagogic and conditioned.

Therefore, I am going to make a request and a question. The request is: Mr. President, we need to believe in politicians and we have the responsibility, I believe, to leave our children and grandchildren a dignified and better society; therefore, it is your responsibility.

And the question is: do you believe that the current model of doing politics is obsolete? The reflection is: we have a model and it is Bachelet, in Chile, with great results, and she is a woman. Do you believe that new models of doing politics should be initiated, to innovate politics? Lastly, are you aware of the competencies that a leader of a party like yours and a leader of Spanish society requires to somehow change the current political life and, therefore, enable the stability and sustainability of a Welfare State?

President.- I am absolutely convinced that political life, which ultimately is the expression of what a society is, just like parties, requires permanent reforms and changes.

Allow me to say that this model today is a significant reform in what it represents that, for the first time, a Prime Minister answers questions from citizens, directly, freely, as you are asking, on public television; public television that historically was a television at the service of the Government in power and that now, in this time, has undergone a reform by which the Director is elected by Parliament, in this case there has been agreement, consensus, from all parties, including the Popular Party; there are some consensuses, let’s not exaggerate, because there are, of course, and where freedom, plurality, and, of course, independence of professionals is breathed.

That strengthens democracy, because today democracy demands, above all, transparency, it demands that citizens have the best information and that, of course, political representatives, and in this case the Government and not to mention the Prime Minister, are subject to permanent control.

But allow me to conclude with a reflection: the political system in our country has had a very beneficial result for Spanish society. We have thirty years that are the best thirty years in the history of Spain, since we achieved the transition, democracy, the Constitution, and an economic progress that was unimaginable. Today we are a reference for many countries, even with this political tension, which exists, which is exaggerated and which I believe we would all like to see decrease.

Look at what happened in 2006: Spain was the country that grew the most economically of all the major industrialized countries. We grew more than Germany, France, Italy, England, the United States, Japan, or Canada. We were, in 2006, the country that created the most jobs, 3.5 percent, almost half of all jobs in the European Union. We are, fortunately, able to make laws that expand the Welfare State, which is an essential objective for me, such as the Law on Personal Autonomy or the Dependency Law, which we approved this year and which will transform the lives of many elderly people, many people who cannot take care of themselves, and many families; or the Equality Law between men and women, which came into force very recently and which expands rights for women, making us a more modern society.

In this, we are a reference in many countries, and political parties, which are an expression of citizenship, have logically contributed to this. During this time, a social majority pushed for a change of government in March 2004, and we are having all these possibilities to change things and improve the overall life of citizens.

In politics, one must always be open to criticism, to defend one's ideas, and the political system is always improvable. For me, a fundamental improvement, and you alluded to it at the beginning, is the participation of women in public life, in social life, in economic life, and in the general life of a country. I remember that I created and have a government with as many ministers as ministers, that we have approved the Equality Law, which will mean that in all political institutions and in eight years in the major boards of directors of large companies, there must be equality between men and women.

These are changes, reforms, and innovations that improve society, but they will also improve democracy.

L. Milá.- Mr. President, we will try from the beginning to accommodate all possible questions.

President.- I was already thinking that you were taking too long to tell me.

L. Milá.- We will all make that effort.

Q.- In line with what you were commenting on regarding the Equality Law for women and that in your government there are the same number of women as men, do you not think that this is really limiting the presence of fully qualified individuals or that our representatives, both politically and on boards of directors, are not the most prepared people? As a citizen, why should I be represented by 50 percent women and 50 percent men? Perhaps I prefer to be represented by people who are more qualified, regardless of their gender.

President.- I know that this position is held by some voices, but reality shows that if there are no positive measures to ensure that the presence of women is comparable to that of men in political representation or economic representation, that does not happen naturally. There are qualified individuals of both sexes, and the most evident proof is that the number of university graduates currently exceeds that of male graduates.

But I will give you a piece of information that many people may not know: in the boards of directors of large companies in this country, women do not reach 3 percent. What happens? Are there no capable and competent female executives to be on the boards of companies? Of course there are, but tradition, what is tradition, the predominant dominance of men in many areas of social life, has made that not natural and that mechanisms and measures must be introduced.

I can tell you about my party's experience. In my party, we started with quotas: 25 percent. There was debate at the beginning, but if that had not started with quotas, we would not be today with a government where there are as many men as women, and, of course, capable, in my opinion, almost more capable than they are, because that is my usual observation.

These are measures that will undoubtedly improve the country and that transform, that open opportunities to scenarios, to places, where doors have normally been closed to women. Of course, also in business, because the Equality Law imposes equality plans on companies with more than 250 workers, which must be negotiated by agreement with the unions to ensure that there is no discrimination of any kind.

Why do women earn 20 percent less than men for equal work in this country? We must put an end to that. It is an inequality resulting from a long-standing tradition of what has been a very macho society in this country, where women have been relegated to what we know for so many decades. I believe that laws like the Equality Law for Men and Women will take a definitive step so that in all areas, starting with the family, where responsibilities for burdens, children, and what it means to be a father or mother must be shared equally, the law includes a paternity leave of fifteen days, which we will extend to four weeks over the next six years; in schools, in workplaces, in companies, in municipalities, and in society in general, women and men must be on equal footing.

Q.- I had two questions to ask you. The first relates a bit to politics and drugs. Perhaps it is a bit..., but I see it that way. That is to say, those who enter politics, like those who enter drugs, find it difficult to want to leave.

The second question is that at the moment you are giving figures about how we have grown in percentage, what we have done, where we are going... Okay, I used to earn 200,000 pesetas and now I earn 1,200 euros, and it feels to me as if I were earning 100,000 pesetas. You will say that things are going well, but I believe we are doing quite worse. That is all.

President.- I respect, of course, your personal circumstance, but the objective data is what it is, and it is known and endorsed by all institutions. Look, in what we have had so far in this legislature, 2,300,000 jobs have been created, if you allow me, and I hope that by the end of the legislature in these four years we will exceed three million jobs. Economic growth is not stated by the government; it is stated by official statistics, the European Commission, and the OECD, which has been the highest of all major developed countries: 3.9 percent. We have had the opportunity to implement social policies, for example, in terms of pensions, and to raise minimum pensions in these three years, which affect three million pensioners, by nearly 30 percent. In three years, we have raised minimum pensions the same amount as in the previous eight years, as we have raised the Minimum Interprofessional Wage, which was practically frozen and has had an increase of 20 to 25 percent.

In short, the country's outlook is clearly one of progress, economic improvement, and more possibilities for social protection, both in pension systems and in the new law, which I just mentioned, on personal autonomy.

Regarding drugs, all drugs are bad, and it is true that politics for those of us, like me, who have had ideas since we were very young, a vocation and a conviction of what it means to care for your country, I can assure you that there is nothing one can feel prouder of than being the president of your country, of Spain, of my country. It is an immense pride that one must owe every day.

I have a very optimistic view of Spain, and so do others outside. In recent days, these last weeks, there have been several reports in the foreign press and even a survey that asked which is the preferred country in the European Union among workers and executives to go work. It was Spain. It is a feeling, for me, of deep pride, and I am convinced that this path of economic, social progress, and job creation will continue.

L. Milá.- Mr. President, there is no way to have any credibility with the hundred citizens, because you are not paying any attention to me. It cannot be. It cannot be explained everything that has been done in three years in the first minutes of the program. We have many minutes.

President.- I warn you that I have explained very little.

Q.- I wanted to insist that, as I said, for example, with the euro, I left home with five thousand pesetas and got through the week; now I leave with fifty or sixty euros and I cannot manage, and my salary, personally mine and I suppose that of almost everyone, has not increased in that proportion. That is to say, statistically, which is what you handle, we are doing great, but on the street, at street level, we are not doing great. You are getting down here to answer our questions, but how much does a coffee cost on the street? Can you answer me?

President.- Yes. Eighty cents, approximately.

Q.- No. That was in the times of almost grandfather Pachi. Today, no.

President.- It depends.

Q.- As a widow and mother of a son, unemployed and due to my age, given the low amount of both pensions, it is impossible to live. My question, Mr. President, is whether it would be fairer to provide assistance to Spaniards like us than to that granted to undocumented immigrants.

President.- I just gave a piece of information about pensions that is eloquent, right? And I want to reinforce it, if you allow me. Approximately, we spend 89 billion euros a year on pensions for just over eight million pensioners. When we came to government, the expenditure was 66 billion, and we have made a very large effort to increase minimum pensions, which affect three million pensioners, by 30 percent.

Is that pension still low? Undoubtedly, but we have raised it in three years the same amount as it had been raised in previous years, and since we have a Social Security system that is in very good health, because we have a surplus this year, we have had the largest surplus in the Social Security system of all European countries, eleven billion euros, we have a fund in Social Security that will reach forty billion euros, to guarantee future pensions, we will continue to improve and raise, always reasonably, especially the minimum pensions of the system, which are obviously retirement and widow's pensions. I want to say, in addition, that, obviously, this will be progressively accompanied, it is already starting as a consequence of the country having gained much progress with pensions that are higher than what many people still enjoy today, because the contribution bases have been much higher.

But these are the data, I repeat: 88 billion euros each year for more than eight million pensioners; we have concentrated the effort on the three million pensioners who had the lowest pension, and fortunately, we have a horizon of stability in the Social Security system.

Q.- My question is directed at the construction workers' collective. As we well know, the construction trade is one of the toughest and has the highest severity in accidents, and it has been a long time since a reduction in the retirement age from 65 to 60 years has been requested. What is your criterion on this issue?

My question is about the self-employed. We consider ourselves completely unprotected. There are many Spaniards who are self-employed, and for us, being sick is a luxury. I find myself with depression, which is why I often have to take sick leave, and I have to continue paying Social Security the same, I have to pay half of what they pay me. So, tell me how one can live on such a low amount. When I am on sick leave, I have to continue paying almost half of what is paid, and at the time of retirement, with whatever you have to pay for housing or mortgage, you will tell me what is left for us to live.

Then, if you allow me, Mr. Zapatero, I ask you to commit the State to provide public nurseries so that families with children who have to work do not have to pay those outrageous amounts that they pay in nurseries.

President.- I will answer both at the same time.

Regarding the first, of course, I consider that work in construction is one of the toughest that exists in our country, along with others that are well known, such as work at sea or in mining, which I also know well from my land. The trend regarding retirement is not precisely to shorten the retirement age; however, I believe that there may be groups and sectors, logically, where an individual consideration can be made. In fact, we have in this country a significant number of workers from different sectors who retire at much younger ages than the 65 years represented.

Self-employed. I believe there is good news, which you surely know, which is positive and will happen soon, because in a few months, surely before summer, the Statute of the Rights of the Self-Employed will come into force. It is a Statute that has been negotiated with all self-employed organizations; it establishes new rights, both in the area of Social Security, as well as contributions, as well as various types of permits; it facilitates the hiring of children in self-employed businesses; it provides assistance in certain situations for hiring people when the self-employed person, who is the vast majority, cannot perform their work; and it also allows, under certain circumstances, what can be a cessation of activity for the self-employed. This is about to arrive, because the Law of the Statute of the Self-Employed, which includes rights that self-employed individuals have never had, I insist, will be in force surely before May.

Why have we done this? Because I agree with you, self-employed individuals were in a situation of little protection, little support, and little encouragement. There are already three million self-employed individuals in Spain, and moreover, it is a figure that is growing, and of course, they must have rights that they did not have until now, so that they can carry out that entrepreneurial initiative; fortunately, they will have them.

L. Milá.- Let's keep the pace. I want you to make a special effort. Reflections are always important, but we need questions, to the point. We will also ask the President twenty-three times to get to the point.

Q.- The second question I had asked was regarding nurseries, which is also very important.

President.- This country is making an effort, I say "is making," because it is not only the Government that does it, through the central Government, through the Budgets, but also the Autonomous Communities to cover a glaring deficit we had, which is early childhood education, both for the first stage, from zero to three, and from three to six years. Today, fortunately, for three to six years, it can practically be said that education is guaranteed free of charge for all, and the effort must be concentrated from zero to three years. I can tell you that in the Budgets we have approved in these years, and which fundamentally is money that goes to the Autonomous Communities to develop that policy, because education in its management, as you know, is transferred, that money has doubled.

Certainly, in the educational system, from my point of view, the great objective we have as a country for the coming years is education... If I were asked for a priority, "name just one," I would say education, because that will guarantee our progress. We have to make an effort to increase the number of years of training and education for young people, so that that education starts as early as possible, early childhood education, and, of course, improve quality. Here we have a very important challenge and a challenge as a country.

Q.- My question is related to maternity leave here in Spain, and I would like to know why maternity leave is not equated with the rest of the European countries, as in some it can last up to a year.

President.- There are various models of maternity leave in different European countries, but I can also give you good news, which you surely know, because the Equality Law between Men and Women is already in force, has reinforced rights for, of course, the protection of maternity, for what is the incentive for maternity, for the workers of this country and also extending rights to them.

For example, until now, until the entry into force of the Law, there were just over fifty thousand female workers who, as they had not contributed enough, as they had contributed very little, did not have certain rights derived from maternity; the Law provides for a specific subsidy so that no woman who is working is unable to have that right. For example, the Law provides for the possibility that the time, up to a year, that women can use for breastfeeding can be accumulated, which would practically mean an extension of four weeks of maternity leave. And, for example, the Equality Law provides that during the time that parents can choose a leave for children, for two years, the contribution to the system is 100 percent.

That is to say, a whole series of new rights of extension and protection, which includes, for example, flexibility in working hours that did not exist before and that will also mean that many women will have more possibilities, more facilities, for that task and also for them. With paternity leave, we are also, well, I no longer believe we are obliged, and for that we must recognize by law rights such as the right to paternity.

Therefore, we are making progress and the change in the Law is very important. In fact, I can say that it is the first law in which we have had that feeling; it was being debated in Parliament in recent days for final approval, and we had many calls in Moncloa, in the Ministry of Labor, and in Parliament from many people, women but also from many men, asking when it would come into force. We had to rush to get it published in the BOE, because there was a great demand to be able to enjoy those new rights that, without a doubt, will improve the lives of women, what is the task of paternity and maternity, and that will encourage having a child in this country not to be a burden, a huge difficulty, to reconcile work with family.

Q.- I wanted to ask you if you could give a solution to today's youth so that with a thousand euros a month we can buy a flat.

Housing, as we all know, is a problem that affects many young people in this country. Prices are rising every day, and interest rates are too. Many of us have to be working multiple jobs to be able to achieve our goal without reaching it. I don't know if any measures are planned to solve the problem.

Related to this, when and how does the Government plan to take measures so that I can buy a house?

President.- If I said earlier that the great priority of our country for the coming years, as a Government task and as a collective task, is education, the extension of education, there is no doubt that the social problem with the greatest demand is housing.

I want to give a very brief explanation of how I found things when I arrived at the Government, what we have done, and the immediate prospects we have.

First, when we arrived at the Government, the price of housing was growing by 19 percent, and now it is growing by 9 percent; therefore, growth has been reduced by 50 percent.

Second, when we arrived at the Government, the total money that the State dedicated to helping with the purchase or rental of housing was 3.3 billion euros, and now it is at 6.8 billion euros. We have doubled it, and I want to remind you that it is more than one trillion of the old pesetas, which contains the plan that goes from 2005 to 2008. This benefits seven hundred thousand families; that is to say, from 2005 to 2008, seven hundred thousand families will have public assistance to buy or rent.

I am convinced that we must bet much more on rental, because 53 percent of that volume of the Housing Plan, which is then managed by the Autonomous Communities, are the protected homes that are built in the municipalities, and it is the money that the central Government makes available, 53 percent goes to rental. We have taken many measures in favor of rental.

And at this moment, a new Land Law is in Parliament, a Land Law that adopts measures in favor of protected housing and against land speculation. Why? Because we require municipalities to reserve 30 percent of the land for protected housing and because we change what was the expectation of land value.

Consequently, we are making a great effort, but I am aware that we have to do much more, especially thinking of young people, of the "mileuristas," many of whom are betting on rental. We have just launched a plan to build ten thousand homes for young people in Spanish universities; we are going to soon launch a plan for the construction, in a first phase, of twenty thousand rental homes for young people in which the Government will finance, with the municipalities, 50 percent, for rents of 200 or 240 euros... In short, we are mobilizing a significant volume of resources and something that is also, I believe, noteworthy, and that is that the public land of the State, such as, for example, Madrid, with the famous Campamento Operation, the Government is handing over to have more possible protected homes to Communities and Municipalities.

But I acknowledge that there is a lot of demand, that there are many difficulties, and that, therefore, we must continue to strongly bet on increasing protected housing.

Q.- I wanted to say that with everything you have said, I still cannot buy a flat, although I thank you.

President.- I thank you for thanking me, and I thank you because, logically, I understand your situation, and I hope and wish that you can have the possibility, like many others, because the seven hundred thousand families I have indicated here are all real families who will have the possibility, who are having... There are already 440,000 who have bought or are renting with public assistance since 2005; 440,000. And, of course, practically 80 percent of what the state Housing Plan means is aimed at young people.

But I hope that you can also have the possibility, perhaps, in some of the rental homes. And I just mentioned that we are going to launch that plan: homes of 45 square meters, first phase with 20,000 financed at 50 percent by the State; this is new.

Q.- I wanted to know why the youth of this country feels so insecure regarding the issue of job precariousness. One trains, studies, and then enters the labor market and finds "garbage contracts" and garbage salaries. You remember that three years ago thousands of young people supported you with their vote, and since you are now taking stock of these three years, we only ask you, I don't know if you remember, "Zapatero, don't fail us." Do you think you are failing us?

President.- The truth is that you should say that, right? It would not be objective if I said it.

L. Milá.- What do you think?

President.- Simply. Come on, cheer up.

Q.- Regarding the youth issue, I see that not much has been done, honestly.

President.- Now I am going to explain something to you.

Job precariousness is, without a doubt, and as you have called it, "garbage contracts," one of the worst features of our labor market; but I want to remind you, because you probably know it, that last year we signed an agreement for labor stability between unions, employers, and the Government; employers and unions, by the way, and workers in general, who contribute in an exemplary manner in this country to what is economic progress and job creation.

That agreement for the reform of the labor market, which includes a set of measures to incentivize stable hiring, is yielding very good results. I will tell you that since it came into force, in the last period, there have been practically one and a half million indefinite contracts and that there have been seven hundred thousand fixed or stable contracts; a good part, conversion of precarious contracts into stable contracts thanks to bonuses and aids that the Government puts on the table in the Social Security system.

The trend, therefore, is clearly towards increasing stable hiring, indefinite hiring. We still have a high percentage, and the latest data from the Labor Situation Survey is 31 percent. It mainly affects young people, but we have started to lower the trend from the 34 percent we were at not long ago thanks to that labor agreement.

Surely there are workers here, there are self-employed, I don't know if there are any employers; but everyone will understand that in the labor market, either we make reforms, changes, with great social agreements, as we have had in this Legislature, where we have had twenty, so that employers get involved, as they are the ones who hire, because they have many aids, because they will save a lot of money by hiring young people, by hiring women, by hiring people with disabilities, which is undoubtedly the hiring that has the most help... We will agree that if all the decisive actors, such as companies, unions, and the Government, work in the same direction, we will reduce those figures.

L. Milá.- President, allow me to ask a question here. It’s a novelty.

President.- This was not planned.

L. Milá.- No, but this contribution is important. Does it hurt you when a person says to you, "I remember 'Zapatero, don't fail us' and I have the impression that you have failed me"?

President.- No, I think it is the healthy exercise of democracy. Surely, you have not had the opportunity to explain everything that "don't fail us" could represent. I have it absolutely internalized, engraved, that night. It was emotional, although it was also painful, because the tragedy of March 11 was very close; but I know very well what young people thought. Above all, the "don't fail us" I have always interpreted, first of all, as having a president who tells them the truth about things, who explains to them, who does not lie to them and who does not deceive them. That is, for me, the basic feeling of "don't fail us" and that, as far as possible, I fulfill my word.

The "don't fail us" for me that night, to a large extent, was what had happened with the Iraq war and what the majority feeling of young people and the Spanish population was. To a large extent, I also remember that the first decision I made as President of the Government was to withdraw the troops from Iraq. The "don't fail us" has been that for me, and I try, logically, to fulfill and tell the truth.

Q.- Really, I have heard about employment policy, about what was done with the unemployed, and I feel like I am in the lottery: it hits some, but it never hits me. What plan do you have for people over forty years old, what forecasts do you have, and if ever, when courses are given, will the demand be valued to truly have a job and not just month-long jobs? That was my question.

President.- You are very right, because one of the areas in which the labor market functions with more reluctance, with more difficulties, is for people who are in that age of 45 or older. It is true that employers have a great incentive for hiring those people of that age, but it is no less true that that segment or that part of the population has more difficulties.

The only way to respond to that is by trying to make training a continuous activity for a person throughout their working life, even during periods of unemployment, which, on the other hand, are usually periods covered by the unemployment system, because today, in a world, as we know, very competitive, and despite the many aids to stimulate the hiring of young people, women, long-term unemployed, of a certain age, training is fundamental. Hence, I invoked Education so much.

What I wish is for you to have luck in the next one, but I do tell you that, if there is something that is evident, it is that we are at a very important moment of job creation. Fortunately, to recall the previous question, a considerable amount of stable employment is also being created at this moment.

We must be fully aware of how economic growth is going and how job creation is progressing, especially because, to continue maintaining this pace of job creation and economic growth, we will have to keep making efforts.

It is true that there is something extraordinarily positive in Spanish society, and that is that it is a society eager to work, with a will to work; a positive society, a society in which, when you have that, there is a lot of confidence in each of us and, of course, in the future of this country.

Q.- I am a volunteer at the Murcian Association for Support of Abused Children. I am not going to ask you any questions tonight; a girl is going to ask you. That girl is named Carmen, she is fourteen years old, and she was a victim of child sexual abuse by her father. She tells me to tell you that she had a very hard time, that the three years she has been involved in the Justice system have been suffering the unspeakable—she tells me in other words—that every time the psychologists told her she had to forget, the Judge would call her back shortly after and ask her how it had been, and that she had to go to Justice repeatedly to say what happened to her and that she wanted to forget. She says that if she had known, she might not have filed the complaint. It is very serious.

So, the question that she and I ask you is: why is there a Court for juvenile offenders, and for child victims, there is no Court with prepared experts to treat them? That is the question we want to ask you.

President.- Certainly, the question you convey to me, which reflects such a hard, painful, and difficult case, has an answer that must also be very close and personal.

I do not know the details, logically, of the entire process, of the whole case, nor the actions that the Judge may have taken. In general, we must have confidence in how judges do things and that, in the face of such a sensitive, delicate, and difficult case, they are willing to make the least painful experience possible for a minor, for a person, like the one you asked me about. I will simply tell you that, of course, I am willing to take an interest in that particular case, beyond the fact that we undoubtedly have an important task to do in modernizing and streamlining our justice system in service of citizens, their freedoms, and their rights.

Q.- Allow me, it is not the specific case of this case. Over the twelve years I have been dealing with this, I have gone through many cases, and there are many children suffering like this. That is why I insist, my question is: why are there Courts with prepared experts for juvenile offenders and nothing is foreseen or said about child victims? Why do these children have to go, because I have accompanied them, to an adult Court, with a judge dedicated to adults, which also depends on their sensitivity, but of course all of them are adults? I have looked for a defender, a lawyer, for these children when they have no resources, and there are no lawyers for these children; it is for the offender, but for the children, no. Why are the Courts prepared for adults and not for children?

That is what I want to convey to you. The example has been one, an example of many; but my insistence is that the Courts must be prepared for the victims, and the victims, in these cases, need expert people.

President.- I completely agree. In fact, we have made some legislative reforms to improve the position of crime victims, in general; not to mention the position of victims of a crime committed by a minor in cases of abuse.

I absolutely agree that there must be teams; that we must reinforce, of course, all that is the task of assistance, I insist, and I want, in any case, to congratulate you. I take note of the reflection. Without knowing the specific case, which surely has some circumstances, I take note of the reflection and congratulate you for the social work you do, because I find it commendable.

Q.- I have been an abused woman for a very long time, and I have felt completely unprotected. It seems to me that something is wrong; I don’t know, the figures speak for themselves, in the Law of protection against gender violence. I have, for example, a pending trial with my ex for two and a half years, and I still have no news from anywhere. The question is whether you plan to modify anything and if there are any therapies in prisons so that, when these aggressors are released, the story does not repeat itself. That is the problem, because many times it is useless for them to spend two years in prison only for them to commit another mistake when they get out.

President.- You are raising one of the problems that has had and has the most social impact and, more importantly, on which there is a great collective awareness of absolute rejection of criminal machismo.

It is true that this has gone from being a private problem for years—of course, there was abuse against women, and we have lived through times when we even saw in the newspapers that they talked about crimes of passion—to being a public, collective problem of responsibility, in which, of course, public authorities, but the whole of society, which is doing a lot, must maintain an active, firm, and constant struggle.

I believe we have maintained a very active commitment. I committed that the first Law I would bring to Parliament would be the Comprehensive Law against Gender Violence, and we did so. This Law has resulted in the expansion, without a doubt, of the margin of protection in which, as a consequence of all that is the social response, the number of complaints has increased considerably, and the number of Courts has increased considerably, which are currently around eighty and another five hundred compatible dedicated to what is gender violence.

We have just established in each province, in each Delegation, a specific unit for what represents the protection of women who are abused; we have extended preventive methods, such as direct communication with people who are at risk or who have a protection order, and we have doubled the number of Police and Civil Guard personnel.

It is true that the figures of women murdered today—we have had the last one of this year, which has already reached sixteen—have remained stable. It is a long-term task, but we have made the Law with the support of all feminist organizations and with the support of the unions. It was a law voted unanimously and will yield all its fruits. Despite the fact that we have the same number of women murdered, which has practically remained stable, there are many more women protected and helped; helped with resources from the Social Security itself so that they can have, logically, assistance.

Q.- I would like to ask you, as someone affected, about the new Dependency Law. Will there be as many obstacles as in other laws? That was my question.

President.- I said earlier that the Dependency Law was the strongest and most important social advance that we will experience in many years.

Today, we all in this country see it as natural that we have public healthcare, that we are all assisted free of charge, that all our children can receive free education, and that everyone, absolutely everyone, who has worked more or less, has the right to a pension when they reach retirement age. Well, now we are going to have a country where people with disabilities or who cannot take care of themselves will have public support coverage.

It is a public support coverage that will be deployed from this year, 2007, to 2015; that will require a great financial effort; that, in short, will guarantee—because the Law is already in force—a new citizenship right, in this case of a social nature: the right for no one to be alone, the right for a person to have, within the multiple range, depending on their disability and how they are in the circumstances to take care of themselves, from tele-assistance to day centers, to what represents care places and residences, to what represents the payment of a caregiver by the State, by the Government; a caregiver, who at this moment for people with disabilities or elderly people who cannot take care of themselves, are usually women, normally. Well, now we are going to have the possibility that the family that has a disabled person, a dependent person, can have a caregiver who will contribute to Social Security, who will have a salary, and, in addition, the Law will generate three hundred thousand jobs.

Logically, as always, there will be a series of benefits depending on the characteristics of each person, which will logically be much greater when there is a high level of dependency or when there is a much more serious circumstance; but which we estimate will attend to approximately more than 1,200,000 people that there may be.

It will be a great effort, but this is another reason we can feel very proud of: that we are capable of having a country that cannot leave anyone, neither to live alone nor, less so, to die alone, and for a family that is the one that always has to make the effort when they have a person with a disability or a person with severe dependency.

Q.- I am an immigrant and I have been here in Spain for seventeen years. You talk a lot about illegal immigration, but here in Spain, there are also many legal immigrants. I have been here, in Spain, as I said, for seventeen years, and I have many compatriots who have been here for about the same time as I have, and as an African community, we work and contribute to the well-being of Spanish society. We fulfill our obligation, what the State establishes. We still do not have the right to vote for those who have to govern us. We want to know, living here, contributing, doing everything right, why we cannot have the right to choose the person who will lead us?

I am also an immigrant; I am Ukrainian, I have been in Spain for four years, and I have my papers in order; but I want to speak on behalf of Ukrainian workers who have been here for two or three years and are left without papers. Mr. President, we want to know if there will be a new extraordinary law on the legalization of foreigners, and if not, how can they regularize their situation without leaving Spain?

President.- Regarding the first question, the right to vote in general elections, in elections for Parliament, is linked to nationality in all countries and, of course, to Spanish nationality in this case.

I am in favor of immigrants, people who come to work, to live, to develop a life project, having rights and duties in our society. Today we have a very significant number of immigrants in Spain; they are contributing very clearly to economic growth, and I enter into the response to the question from our Ukrainian friend: the Government has carried out a regularization of six hundred thousand workers who were in illegal conditions. When we came to power, we found hundreds of thousands of workers who were not contributing to Social Security, therefore, not contributing to the wealth of the country, without rights, and employers also failing to meet their obligations.

We carried out a regularization process that was always linked to the employment contract, as the papers, the residence permit, must be linked to the employment contract. There is no provision for a new general regularization, but I do remind you that the Law and the Immigration Regulation provide for singular situations through which the necessary permits can be obtained. However, always linked to the employment contract, because illegal work is unacceptable in an advanced society, in a democratic society. First, it is profoundly harmful to those who are working illegally, and then it is very immoral for the employer who is hiring illegally without having the legal requirements of Social Security, unemployment… As it should be.

This country, which has a clear expectation of job creation, if it needs people from other countries, foreign immigrant people, must do so through legality. We have had and have suffered, as surely we all remember, last year very intensely, during the summer, the arrival of the famous cayucos that came from Sub-Saharan Africa, which is very heartbreaking what happens there, the misery, hunger, and poverty that exist in those countries, and who are willing to risk their lives crossing the Atlantic in a boat of those characteristics.

We have had to make a significant deployment in the countries of Sub-Saharan Africa with political and diplomatic means to prevent them from trying to come, and for those who may come, because there are many sectors in this country (construction, domestic workers, a significant part of the hospitality industry) where the work is done especially by immigrants... But employers who need it should do so through a job contract offer, in a regular manner. That is the way.

Q.- A very brief question, Mr. President. In my case, I also have two children, I have children who were born here and I do not understand, being born here, in Spain, why they do not have Spanish nationality. We have been dealing with paperwork for two years and so far we have nothing. And you see, my children were born here and know no other culture, only Spanish.

President.- If they were born here, it is normal for them to obtain it. I acknowledge that this has been one of the issues that, by the way, we have debated many times in the Council of Ministers, where this topic has come up on several occasions as a problem of agility in everything that represents the process of obtaining Spanish nationality because, as a consequence of legislative modifications, the possibility of obtaining Spanish nationality has been greatly expanded, especially for family descendants of emigrants in Latin America, and there is a very intense and difficult management volume for it to come out in the times it should. But I trust that, if the rights are as such, your children will be Spanish.

Q.- I would like to ask you, now that the topic is immigration, about a question that arises for me. Over the last two years, we have seen an increase in the arrival of cayucos and pateras, as you mentioned, to the Spanish coasts, perhaps due to the pull effect of an Immigration Law that came into force. The Canary Islands are the most affected by this problem, and in Fuerteventura is the largest Immigration Detention Center in Spain. It is customary, the usual practice is to send planes full of these immigrants, of Sub-Saharans, to the Mediterranean coast, where there are other detention centers, such as in Valencia, Barcelona, Madrid, or, in my particular case, to Murcia.

The question would be: when they arrive in Murcia, for example, they can be seen around the airport wandering freely, often barefoot, in inhumane conditions. I believe this may be due to a lack of coordination between the central government and the regional government. What do you think about this and what will be done on this issue?

President.- I am well aware of the issues surrounding what has been illegal migratory pressure through the cayucos and from the Canaries, as we referred to a moment ago. I want to say, however, that in the first three months of this year there has been a reduction of more than 50 percent in the arrival of cayucos and, therefore, of illegal immigrants to the Canaries. One only has to see that today practically the centers have very few immigrants in the Canaries, when we had a moment of saturation during the summer, and that is thanks to European cooperation, to the cooperation of the countries of Sub-Saharan Africa, and to the effort made by our Civil Guard and our means there to control, prevent, and intercept the arrival of cayucos to the Canaries.

When we have had those moments of saturation, it is true that there has been collaboration from many Autonomous Communities, not all, but well..., I want to say that from many Autonomous Communities so that not all were in the centers of the Canaries because it was a very strong pressure in those detention centers, although we strive, logically, to ensure they receive the greatest humanitarian and personal attention.

Normally, those who take care of the immigrants who have gone to certain places on the Peninsula are Non-Governmental Organizations that we have in this country, extraordinary ones. Certainly, the Red Cross plays a role, with immigrants in the Canaries and everywhere, which I want to highlight here, because it is spectacular.

Normally, NGOs take charge. This is something that from the Ministry of Labor we have tried to practice even in times of greatest migratory pressure. They take charge through various measures, by providing what can be shelters, what can be apartments; that they are socially in a dignified situation, although there always has to be, logically, and there may be some cases where that does not happen. But that is the mechanism we have to function.

L. Milá.- I am going to skip the script because I am going to ask a question that perhaps our citizens do not know, because they have been practically locked up all day. I am talking about that new party, Mr. President, that has been registered today in the Ministry of the Interior to participate in the upcoming municipal elections in May. Many of us wonder if this is a ploy by Batasuna to be able to present itself in those elections. Perhaps you do not know about this.

President.- Today they have registered a party in the Ministry of the Interior, which is where it must be registered. The Ministry of the Interior has made a first reading of the promoters, the name, and the statutes of that party, and has considered that there are indications of illegality. Therefore, in accordance with the Law of Political Parties, it has been referred to the Attorney General and the State Attorney to inform and articulate everything established by the Law of Political Parties because, if it is an illegal party, it cannot be a party and much less present itself for elections. I want to reiterate it here today: no one is going to present themselves for the upcoming municipal and regional elections, which are taking place in many Communities, if they do not comply with the Law of Political Parties to the letter.

Q.- First question. I thank you for giving us the opportunity to all be here, speaking directly with you. You gave us the opportunity and we appreciate it. I wanted to talk to you about rural areas, the rural nuclei, in Asturias, which are totally depopulating; to see what solution they could have. Asturias, in general, the region, we consider is becoming, between retirees and early retirees, a dormitory region. I wanted to see what solution could be had for that.

Second question. Those of us who live and work in the rural environment are very concerned or see with concern, in line with what my colleague has said, how the population is aging, how there is no generational change, how schools are closing because there are no children. For every farmer who joins agricultural activity, four farmers leave. These are figures from La Rioja, which in other parts of Spain are even worse. So, I would like to ask you if you consider the funds allocated for rural development sufficient to maintain the socio-economic fabric of our towns. Do you not think there is a lot of discourse and little real support for agricultural activity?

And taking advantage of this, because perhaps they will not let me return to La Rioja if I do not ask you the question, La Rioja, like other wine regions in Spain, is concerned about the issue, you know, of the Wine Law or the Draft Bill. How is the issue of the Draft Bill? We know that it has been withdrawn. Will it be released after the elections? Will it not come out during the entire Legislature?

Third question. Regarding the sugar beet sector, I am a farmer from Castilla y León, and you, along with the European Union, have liberalized the sugar market. This is going to have tremendous consequences for the cultivation of sugar beet, but if we stop cultivating beet to seek other alternatives, such as the cultivation of potatoes or vegetables, we are going to ruin this other sector that is already very degraded. The specific question is: what can be done with the cultivation of sugar beet so that it does not disappear and, on the other hand, so that it does not have a domino effect on these other crops that are vital for this area of Spain?

President.- Rural nuclei, Asturias and Castilla y León, which is my land; therefore, three topics on which I want to make some considerations.

First, we have lived in recent years, like all societies that are progressing, creating jobs and advancing, a process of population concentration in urban areas. I am a firm supporter of defending the rural environment and, moreover, I believe that, even if only 20 percent of the population is currently in rural areas in Spain, they have exactly the same rights as those who live in cities.

Are there aids? There are aids from the European Union. They are insufficient and that is why we are going to approve this month, we are going to take to Parliament, a Rural Development Law to establish various actions in which the equipment and services are equal in urban areas as in rural areas.

The agricultural sector has been losing weight, as is normal in all countries, but I believe it must be in a permanent process of innovation, of gaining competitiveness. Now we have an important space, which is everything that represents bioenergy and biotanol. There is a great future there, because that is renewable energy, with cereals, with soybeans, and that is going to have a great future.

From the point of view of sugar beet, which affects much of Castilla y León and León in particular, as you know well, there has been a reform in Europe that has been agreed upon with all agricultural organizations and that will mean a reduction in production. But those who want, who have the will to stay in the sugar beet sector, will undoubtedly have a guaranteed future; and those who estimate, because there are very important aids if they abandon the activity, will have significant support. Certainly, I am fully convinced that the agricultural sector in our country must gain profitability and that it must gain, in what it represents for the producer, more added value.

Regarding Asturias, I believe that it is true that Asturias has had some years of certain depression; however, we have had a recent stage in which there is already more economic growth, more job creation, and more industry. We are close to having a factor of such change, as will be the arrival of High Speed, which is currently crossing Pajares; there is a major expansion of the Port of Musel, which will also mean a focus of attraction for industries; and, of course, I have a somewhat more optimistic view of what the whole of Asturias can be, although in the rural area we will have to make many efforts, because they are also decisive for preserving the environment.

Q.- The youth is totally leaving, they are going wherever they can. They have to go out to look for work here, in Madrid, or in London or wherever they can, except in Asturias. Everything is coming to an end.

President.- There is everything. Jobs are also being created for young people in Asturias. It is true that, I insist, it has gone through a process, because it was a very industrialized region, with an industry that has lost all capacity to have presence, like mining, which has been greatly reduced, and all the heavy steel industry, which has also been greatly reduced, and there has had to be a significant effort for alternatives. But I believe that, with all the new infrastructures that are going to arrive in Asturias and with the expansion of the Port of Musel, there will be more opportunities for the establishment of companies, for job creation and, therefore, for young people not all, surely there will be some who even want to go work elsewhere; in this we have to take a more flexible view so they can stay in Asturias.

Q.- Throughout the program, you have expressed your satisfaction and pride in the economic development, in the growth and well-being that has been achieved. I can concede that to some extent it is true, but there are also other data. Perhaps the mirror in which you look is not the right one. There are many social policies directed at society, but not at those who remain on the margins.

There are figures that speak of eight million people in Spain living below the relative poverty thresholds. Apart from that, beyond the statistics, in any large Spanish city we can find homeless people sleeping on the streets, entire families spending the night in ATMs, in squares. There is shantytown living. And that exists. And there are 50,000 homeless people in Spain. The specific question would be: when will the eradication of absolute poverty, of extreme poverty, be a matter of State?

President.- I believe you have asked a question with great social sensitivity. It is true that all the data we have been unpacking tonight point to an evolution of economic progress in Spain. That is not incompatible with the fact that we have social pockets of marginalization, of social exclusion, which must, logically, be addressed as a priority, and, of course, in a task that requires resources, that requires social sensitivity and that also requires commitment.

But I take note of your proposal and we will take, logically, the measures... Surely you will hear me talk more about social exclusion, although they are becoming fewer, surely, in our society: less shantytown living, less marginalization. It exists, but it exists, it is evident, and therefore we must do everything possible to eradicate it.

P.- I am a citizen of Navarre and, moreover, I am Spanish. So, the reason for my concern I believe is quite evident. We are worried. You want to dialogue with Mr. Otegi and Otegi demands Navarre. Is it for sale? Are they going to sell it? The specific question would be: does the Socialist Party of Navarre intend to reach an agreement with Nafarroa Bai and the Communist Party of the Basque Lands? Yes or no?

Second question. We have heard you say on various occasions that Navarre will be what the Navarrese want, and that implies a referendum or at least a popular consultation. Is this consultation going to take place now or will it be postponed until the Government of Navarre changes?

President.- Since the two are coincident, I will be very clear and very specific.

Of course, the Navarrese are, have been since we have democracy, freedom, and Constitution, and will be what they want. They have a regime of Improvement, as it is known. Certainly, any phantom fabrication that may have occurred around Navarre is absolutely and radically false. Do you hear me well? Absolutely and radically false. Navarre has the regime it has and, of course, the institutions it has will continue to have. Any citizen can raise whatever they want, but, of course, it is not in the Socialist Party's proposal.

Regarding the elections and after the elections, I must say that what the Socialist Party aspires to is to win the elections in Navarre with our candidate. That is what the Socialist Party of Navarre aspires to. And what surprises me on many occasions is to hear the candidate, President of Navarre, of the UPN, who says that if we have..., that we are questioning Navarre, only to immediately say that he wants to be with us, when he is making a permanent grievance.

Is there any reform planned? No. Is there any Law in Parliament? No. Is there any Bill in the Parliament of Navarre or here? No. Therefore, let’s go to the facts and not to what is said.

P.- Have you already told Mr. Otegi?

President.- I do not speak with Mr. Otegi and, of course, the people who speak with Mr. Otegi do so only for one objective: to reject violence and do everything in their power to end what represents the terror of ETA and have the courage and bravery, which is what that illegal organization, Batasuna, must have, to do politics exclusively with democratic methods, with words and with ideas, those they want to defend; but never looking the other way, nor sheltering the drama of violence. Violence has no place, and I am fully convinced that the day will come when we will see the end of terrorism and, of course, peace.

P.- Is that why the Prosecutor also did not speak with Otegi on the day of the trial? Does he think the same as you, that there is no need to talk to Otegi?

President.- We return to the beginning of what the questions can be. We must have, and of course the President of the Government the most, a permanent respect for what is the action of judges and prosecutors, who act subject to the Law and who interpret and apply, according to their loyal knowledge and understanding, the Law. The prosecutors who have acted in the case you mention are the same ones who in many trials, and everyone has seen it, are formulating accusations of many years of conviction, of imprisonment, against what can be people or activities that have to do with the proximity, in a direct or indirect way, of the illegalized Batasuna or ETA. But we must respect, truly.

P.- Don’t you understand that when you say we must respect the judges and prosecutors, we understand that we are not respected?

President.- But we must enforce the rule of law among all of us. One can agree with a judge's decision and with a prosecutor's decision. What we must have the absolute guarantee of is that they act within the Law. It is our system, it is the Constitution. And there will be decisions I should not comment on as President of the Government and respect for those we like more or less. You have, obviously, all the freedom to express yourself, but we must respect them because they act in accordance with the Law. They may be right or wrong, but they act with their criteria in defense of the Law.

P.- I wanted to ask you. I would like to know if your colleagues from the Socialist Party of Euskadi and the Socialist Party of Navarre intend to join in the short or medium term a party table to reach some kind of agreement and, above all, if your party intends to respect the agreement that may be reached there or, on the contrary, will exercise some kind of blocking minority.

President.- I have said it many times: first, peace, and then, politics. There can be no political objective, no negotiation or political agreement that is subject to the condition of an expectation of maintaining violence.

We all know that Euskadi is a plural society. What is, from my point of view, the most convenient for the Basque Country? Undoubtedly, an agreement of the vast majority of political forces about its future. That is what the Socialist Party of Euskadi has been working on, and it has been working with a degree of courage and, in many cases, of misunderstanding, because, as you well know, it is a party, the socialist comrades of Euskadi, that has many victims of terrorism, who have suffered it, who suffer it and who want to use the best of themselves to end that scourge of terrorism.

Peace, politics, agreement, coexistence, and future, that is what the Basque Country needs.

P.- It is evident that we citizens are respecting the decisions of the prosecutors and judges. What happens is that the laws, as they are, in the situation we find ourselves, do not serve us, because, then, if some people, like Mr. De Juana or Otegi, are granted what they want, have you not thought about changing the Law, the Penal Code, so that this does not happen in future occasions?

President.- I said before that the De Juana case was exceptional and that it has a whole history. Now it could not happen. Why? Because the Penal Code has already been changed. It was changed in 1995 and was changed in the last Legislature for full compliance with sentences.

The problem with the De Juana case is that the sentence he had for the murders he committed was under the Penal Code of 1973, from the dictatorship, which had much lighter sentences, and those were the sentences he served with sentence reductions, as is known. He served 18 or 19 years of sentence, and we could not now change the Law so that he served more time because that would be going against the Constitution; it would violate an essential principle, which is that of the non-retroactivity of penal or sanctioning laws.

Therefore, that would not happen today regarding the volume of sentence compliance; it happened as a consequence of previous legislation, and we must respect the Law.

I perfectly understand many people who may have been surprised and, even, who do not clearly share what has been the decision regarding the De Juana case. But I want to insist: it has been exceptional as a consequence of a whole legislative process of sentence compliance, which we have taken, out of a sense of responsibility, within the Law, and I understand that it cannot be shared. But I can surely ask that they understand that the President of the Government has elements to decide what may be best for the whole, best for all of us, best for the future.

P.- My question is directed to a somewhat different topic, which is the deterioration we are observing of the environment as a consequence of the corruption of some Town Halls. Every day we learn that trees have been cut down, that golf courses are going to be built, that we do not have water, in areas and fields protected, even, by the Community. What measures could the Government take, considering that there are already transfers made, to control the corruption of these Town Halls that are leaving us without the environment?

President.- Corruption in general, and particularly urban corruption, which has had many known and striking cases in recent months and in the last two years, is absolutely intolerable. It is intolerable that anyone in a public office, who must be there to defend and serve the general interests, can corrupt themselves for personal interest.

But I will tell you that against urban corruption, the Attorney General's Office and the Government have been acting with great firmness. How many years had we known what was happening, for example, in Marbella, which has been, to the misfortune of the citizens of Marbella, the greatest example of urban corruption? Well, it has been this Government that has dissolved the Town Hall of Marbella and who, through the Attorney's Office, has taken many of the people who had responsibility to the Courts. All the cases that are coming out are actions, either from the Money Laundering Service, or from the Attorney's Office, which has a special section in the fight against urban corruption.

In the Land Law, which we are currently debating in Parliament, there is a requirement that urban developments have the guarantee of services such as water because, evidently, that implies an impossibility of reasonable urban planning.

We must preserve the environment, not only because of what it represents in the great debate on climate change, but because for this country, which has and enjoys a great natural environment, with so many coasts, with so many landscapes, with so many national parks, that is a factor of wealth, of balance, and, of course, of what must be an orderly society. But we are acting very strongly against urban corruption and we will continue to do so, regardless of the party. And I can say that there have been cases from all parties, and when a councilor from the Socialist Party appears, it produces much more indignation for me that they may have incurred in that scourge that is corruption.

P.- First question. My question is about 11-M. That day the PSOE took a step forward compared to the Government. I would like to ask you if you know where that knowledge came from, let’s say, that was more than the Government itself.

Second question. My question is related to the victims of terrorism, because there have been few questions asked about them. There are many victims of terrorism from other countries, those who have unfortunately suffered, for example, from the T-4, and the compensations have been given to those people much earlier and Spanish nationality to all their families, which seems all respectful, I do not doubt that; but we also have to look at the victims of 11-M, many of whom have not yet received their compensations. I don’t know if you understood me, but that is more or less the question.

President.- The two are related. I must say that the Socialist Party, if we remember those dramatic days well, made only one pronouncement, I made it, on the morning of the 11th. After having heard the Government saying that the authorship of the attack was ETA, I went out to condemn ETA as the author of the attack; I attended the demonstration, like thousands and thousands, and tens of thousands, of citizens who attended in Madrid, called by the Government of Mr. Aznar, I went to their side, and I maintained a silence during those days; we suspended, of course, the entire campaign.

I do not know if the majority of citizens think that at those moments we were being told what was being learned from the investigation. The truth is that with the time that has passed, with the trial underway, which we must respect and wait for it to occur, it seems quite evident what the origin is and who are responsible for the largest terrorist attack we have had in our country, which we suffered in several stations in Madrid.

Regarding the other question, I am absolutely convinced that the Ministry of the Interior and the Office of the Victims have the utmost diligence for the payment of all compensations; it does not matter whether they are victims as a result of ETA terrorism and, of course, of 11-M, who also have very active associations. I believe that the majority have been paid. There may be some case that has some legal doubt; but I am absolutely sure that the vast majority have received the compensations, which is the least we can do for those families, and all the social assistance that has been possible, of course also to those who were victims of the very serious T-4 attack, to two Ecuadorian nationals.

P.- My question is very specific. The Attorney General of the International Criminal Court in The Hague is studying whether to prosecute Tony Blair and George Bush for the invasion of Iraq. If that list includes José María Aznar, would you give the order for him to be arrested and handed over to international laws?

President.- Everyone knows what I think about the Iraq war. I believe that the four years that have passed have proven right those of us who thought it was a poorly focused war, apart from being illegal, that would bring nothing but more instability, thousands and thousands of deaths, a destroyed country, and a situation of almost civil war confrontation. Therefore, everyone knows that I think that and that I have maintained a very coherent line on this matter.

With the same coherence and the same firmness, I tell you that I am not in favor, at all, of there being an indictment and responsibility for former President Aznar for what was his position regarding the war. I am not, at all.

P.- First, I want to tell you that you have a great dialectical waist and that you have used statistics and numbers in many of your answers. I will also try to make my twist and do a little of the same.

President.- That's how it starts, huh!

P.- As for the fact that we are in an enviable moment of democracy, I am not entirely in favor, because there are certain things in the Constitution that could be changed, like the question I am going to raise. Three thousand square meters built for the house of Prince Felipe, four hundred thousand euros annually for the maintenance of the house, and a wedding that cost the Government nine million euros are an example of how the Monarchy and Prince Felipe are in a privileged situation. There is a Catalan expression that says "panxa contenta," which means "happy belly." In fact, I declare myself anti-monarchist and republican.

So, the question would be: do you not think that the Monarchy no longer has a reason to exist in Spain? Do you not think that Spaniards should be able to decide whether we want royalty or not? Do you not think that we should have the right to self-determination of peoples, regardless of what the Constitution says?

President.- I believe that your intervention is a good example of the fact that we have an absolutely democratic country, with a wide freedom of expression. Everyone can defend their ideas, respecting those of others and within the framework established by the Constitution.

To go to the specific question, in our country, when the Constitution was voted on in 1978, Spanish citizens established a form of government that is a parliamentary monarchy, a constitutional monarchy; which, from my point of view, has been a very positive factor in the entire transition and democratic consolidation; and that the King and the Royal Family fulfill their constitutional role very adequately. Certainly, from that perspective, respecting any option and knowing that there are many republican systems and monarchical systems in the world, which is an option, and you can have yours, I believe that for our country it has been very positive and I am convinced that it will be in the future.

P.- What I think, if I may continue, is that many years have passed since 1976 and we should have the opportunity, the new generations, to vote on this, to say what we think about this issue. That is what I think: that we should have a new opportunity to decide. And, I insist, I think that to represent the country as the Kings or Prince Felipe do, etc., Rubalcaba, for example, could do it perfectly, or much better; just to name someone.

President.- I do not know if everyone would agree, although everyone knows that I have great affection and admiration for Rubalcaba.

What do I want to say? That, evidently, the political parties, which are the ones who mediate with the citizens, can make their proposals regarding the form of government and regarding anything else. It is simply that at this moment I am confident that there is a very large majority in Parliament that will not consider that issue, because, moreover, it constitutionally represents one of the essential, master pieces of everything that the constitutional consensus represents.

Certainly, what I can also add from my experience as President of the Government, which logically has a very direct relationship with the King, the Head of State, is that we can feel proud of his work, of his role and of what the admiration for what this new monarchy established in Spain after the democratic transition and the Constitution represents in the world.

P.- First question. I am addressing you to ask why citizens have to go to public health and, to be attended to, we have to go to the public system, while foreigners have the possibility of being attended to better and faster than us, and Spaniards are left aside. Do you not think we have the same rights?

Second question. It is a pleasure to come to live in Spain and I am not surprised that so many people come because, of course, life is so good and everything is so perfect and everything works so well, except for education, but they are working on it. So, of course, my questions were about the new Law; for example, will it take into account the great diversity of students, will there be a quality control of that Law itself and will it be financially equipped to be developed, not like previous ones? Ultimately, I do not know. I was also surprised that they are studying introducing police in schools, instead of putting more teachers or more social educators.

L. Milá.- These are two significant issues, health and education. They would really warrant another program.

President.- I believe that Spaniards have healthcare, we have a health system that we have built with great effort, which has international recognition rates and which, of course, attends to Spaniards, certainly with the same preference and not in a secondary rank in relation to people coming from other countries with which we have established agreements for assistance and healthcare. That is the starting point.

Education. The Organic Law of Education has an economic memory that is being strictly adhered to. The Organic Law of Education represents a commitment to extend education, tackle the problem of failure, and fight for quality. I believe in an educational system in which we make the maximum effort so that no child is left behind and drops out of the system. That is why we have implemented an important support and reinforcement program, which is reaching a thousand schools. We need, as I said before, to extend education further.

There is, it is true, a plan, not in schools, but in the surrounding areas of schools, where the Police have the mission of preserving what can be drug trafficking and consumption, because I believe that is also a task that has nothing to do with or approaches the educational, pedagogical task, and where, of course, the more teachers and social support we have, the better our educational system will be.

But the problems, I will finish now, of our educational system with a teacher, this we can surely debate, come precisely from the fact that we have had several generations that unfortunately could not have more education, could not reach a level of education. At this moment, from 25 to 34 years old, we are at a 67 percent post-compulsory education and we need to reach, according to the European Union, 85 by 2010. That enormous effort must be made, because each additional year a person has of education or training will surely result in a 10 percent higher salary throughout their life and, without a doubt, the country will have the guarantee of its economic growth and progress.

Many things need to be improved in Education.

L. Milá.- Many things are also left unsaid, but we do not want to leave out any Autonomous Community. We do not have a representative from Ceuta, but we do from Melilla.

P.- Despite the subsidies we have in our City, a family from Melilla with two children, who wants to travel to Málaga or Almería by boat and with their car to spend their vacation, needs 439 euros; if they do it by plane, 646 euros. If that family is not a resident, it costs them 50 percent more. All this must be added to the fact that it is not always easy to get tickets, since on weekends and during peak dates this becomes very difficult. In practice, this makes it a situation of almost isolation. And the question is how a Government or Governments do not look at this situation, since a part of the national territory that is less than 180 kilometers from the Peninsula is in this situation.

President.- I am very glad that there is a question about non-peninsular Spain. Let us not forget that we have the Canary Islands, although they have come up in the debate, and Ceuta and Melilla.

I believe that this Government has looked more than previous ones at Ceuta and Melilla. I have been the first President of the Government to officially visit Ceuta and Melilla, and, in addition, I must say that I am immensely grateful for the affection and welcome I received. We have increased the transport subsidy for residents from 33 to 50 percent, just like in the Canary Islands, just like in the Balearic Islands; from 33 to 50 percent. Is it still expensive? I have no doubt because you have given the data and they are very clear.

We will have to continue making an effort, but we have covered that stretch from 33 to 50 percent, as we are, and you surely know, making significant investments in Melilla in educational centers, in hospitals, in what is the desalination plant… I have a follow-up because I know what the sentiment of Ceuta and Melilla is, that they want to feel close to the institutions, to the Government, and because there is a very deep feeling of what Spain and this country are. That is why I was there and had the opportunity to understand the problems well.

We will continue to make the effort, although, of course, I recognize that it is expensive.

L. Milá.- President. Thank you very much. It is eleven-thirty, we have been here for two hours.

President.- Have you run out of questions?

L. Milá.- Many questions have been left out. I believe it could have gone on for another two hours. I am very sorry that this happened; we already knew it could happen.

President.- I can make you an offer: since you have had the kindness and made the effort to come here, and since there are questions that have gone unanswered, I invite all of you to ask them at Moncloa so that we can continue the conversation, certainly as a thank you for the effort you have made to contribute to this program so that the freedom, plurality, and right to information of citizens, who are the true protagonists, those who hold the destiny of a country in their hands, have been present.

L. Milá.- We thank you very much for the two hours you have stood and for your answers, and to them for the effort they have made to be here today and to synthesize their interventions, and then the frustration they will have for not being able to ask them.

President.- How many have we attended to?

L. Milá.- I do not know the exact number, but it has been quite a few. But many have been left out. I regret it enormously. I understand the frustration, but you already know that the President of the Government has offered it: you have the possibility to send them to Moncloa for him to respond. I believe that almost fifty questions have been asked. 42 questions.

We will leave it here for today, but "I have a question for you" is a new format that starts today and in mid-April we will receive here the leader of the opposition, the leader of the Popular Party, Mariano Rajoy.