Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

17 March 2009 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions on the elimination of Spain's Wealth Tax and its implications for regional financing during a March 2009 control session.
Main themes
Abolition of wealth tax, regional financing and compensation, tax reform debate, fiscal deficit and economic crisis, redistributive tax policy, autonomous communities funding, progressivity and tax justice, disposable income and economic reactivation
Duration
~20 min
66th percentile
Words
2,408
66th percentile
Sentences
96
61st percentile
Readability
39
34th percentile
Grade
13.7
64th percentile
Syntax
2.97
44th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
27th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 40%40%
  • Institutional 33%33%
  • Ceremonial 16%16%
  • Social 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

96 sentences in 42 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Francisco Jesús Jorquera, from the Mixed Parliamentary Group

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Jorquera.- Mr. President of the Government, what measures does the Government plan to adopt to compensate for the elimination of the Wealth Tax in light of the impact it has on the equity of the financial system and on regional financing?

President.- Mr. Jorquera, as you know, this Chamber, by a large majority, abolished the obligation to pay the Wealth Tax last December, and we did so because the Tax has ceased to fulfill the objectives for which it was introduced. In the thirty years of its existence, this tax has stopped being a tax on wealth and has become a burden on the savings of middle-income citizens. It was enough for a citizen to have, in addition to their primary residence, a normal home, some savings for retirement, or an inherited property worth one hundred thousand euros for them to have to pay the tax on income that had already been taxed throughout the fiscal period.

Regarding the redistributive capacity of tax policy, a value in which we agree, the Tax had become distorted, as it taxed year after year the same assets that had already contributed to that redistribution through other taxes.

The same conclusion has been reached by practically all European countries that have been abolishing this tax. This measure will benefit one million citizens this year, those who are more transparent with the Public Treasury, by the way, who will have greater disposable income, which in the current situation will undoubtedly benefit society as a whole.

As for the regional compensation for the abolition carried out, I would remind you that the Law approved in December itself establishes the commitment of loyalty to the financing of Autonomous Communities. Therefore, I confirm that this year the decrease in income resulting from the Autonomous Communities will be compensated, so the elimination of the tax will have no negative effect on them.

Mr. Jorquera.- I do not intend to reopen any debate with the formulation of this question; I simply want to draw your attention to the following aspects:

First, with the abolition of this tax, the Autonomous Communities will stop receiving around 1.8 billion euros, for the moment. The compensation mechanisms have not yet been specified, and there has been no progress in the reform of the regional financing system.

Second, your Government forecasts a deficit for this fiscal year of 5.8 percent of GDP, while tax revenue is decreasing, a deficit forecast that many observers consider excessively optimistic. And while this is happening, there are voices in your Government that claim that your Government's margin to face the crisis is running out.

We believe that this is not true, that the margin is not running out, that it is necessary to mobilize vast public resources to reactivate the economy and ensure social coverage, and this also affects the Autonomous Communities since essential social policies and services depend on them to operate in this context. To enable this, we believe it is necessary to review fiscal policies.

You know that in the Spanish State there is no objective problem of excessive tax pressure, which is one of the lowest in the countries around us. The problem is that it is poorly distributed and rests, above all, on labor income. From our point of view, it is necessary to undertake a debate now for a tax reform that ensures greater revenue capacity and a tax reform that is based on principles of justice and progressivity, and that contributes to reactivating consumption and reducing the tax burden on the less affluent sectors.

The personal income tax must be reformed so that new deductions are promoted in the lower income brackets and a higher tax rate is applied to higher incomes; the VAT must be reformed so that rates on essential goods and services are reduced, while increasing them on luxury products; and a tax on large fortunes must be created.

Crisis policies are not neutral, and for them to be effective from an economic point of view and fair from a social point of view, it is necessary to move beyond old recipes, and even the United States and the United Kingdom are doing so...

President.- Sticking to the content of your question, because there is no room now for a debate on our tax model, which we would logically be willing to have at the appropriate time, I simply want to say and reiterate that the Autonomous Communities will see their income decrease compensated. This Tax was received by the Autonomous Communities around June, and we will comply so that they also have the compensation in due time. And, of course, we hope that we can reach an agreement on the new model of regional financing that also improves the financial capacity of the Autonomous Communities, while we will make the greatest effort to contain...

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Joan Ridao, from the Parliamentary Group of Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya-United Left-Initiative for Catalonia Greens

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Ridao.- I take it that the question is reproduced in the terms known to the President of the Government: does the President of the Government believe he has sufficient parliamentary support as a result of the new political situation created following the recent elections in Euskadi and Galicia?

President.- I can tell you regarding your question, Mr. Ridao, that the Government will work, as it has worked this year and as it worked in the last Legislature, to carry forward in this Chamber a progressive agreement for the extension of rights and freedoms, for the extension of social policies, for support for employment, and, of course, also for a foreign policy that places Spain in advanced positions in the world in the fight against poverty and in meeting the objectives around the fight against climate change.

My opinion is that in this Chamber there are sufficient Groups to reach agreements around a political project of these characteristics which, on the other hand, has broad support with the 169 deputies that the Socialist Group has, representing eleven million citizens, which should be a sufficient basis to reach those agreements that, with the utmost willingness to dialogue, the Socialist Group, first of all, and the Government will carry forward in the coming times.

Mr. Ridao.- Mr. President, like in the old pirate movies, you are at the end of the plank where they are threatening you with a spike and about to fall into the shark-infested sea. And all this because of your bad judgment, Mr. President, because you could be the President who, having started better, ends worse.

In the last Legislature, you started accompanied and ended alone, and those who were there went from hope to the deepest disappointment. You broke, and you know it, many vases with your scorched earth policy, with your yes to everything policy, only to end up systematically failing and burying plural Spain. What is the result? The Statute, the peace process, your allies, burned, and those who are in this Chamber now carry a little sign that says "no trust here, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero."

In the current Legislature, the variable geometry, the doors continue to close on you, and moreover, your credibility is at a minimum, Mr. President. You want to face the crisis alone, you want to do it without reforms, you want to do it improvising, with headlines, and the recent elections in Euskadi and Galicia have left you without oxygen in this Chamber, as has been recently seen.

But here is the relevant point: if at the beginning of the current Legislature Catalonia was the problem, now it can be the solution again, Mr. President. Like all Presidents of the Government in the last 150 years of modern Spain, you have to look towards Catalonia and political Catalanism. And I want to tell you in that sense that the Catalan folder is more open than ever and accumulates grievances and delays, Mr. President: Cercanías de Renfe, El Prat Airport, and, above all, regional financing.

Regarding regional financing, I want to tell you to fulfill your obligations with Catalonia, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, fulfill the Statute, reach a good agreement, and do so as quickly as possible, because I fear that if you do not, you will be left without any kind of lifeline.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Ridao, for your presentation, which has had a clarifying final part.

I simply want to make a reflection. You referred to the last Legislature and then made a judgment on the behaviors of some and others, and on the positions. I refer to what the citizens have said at the polls, which is that this party and this Socialist Group were endorsed with more votes and more seats. I will not make any assessment of what happened to the other Groups, but I believe that this exercise, at least, of moderation in analysis should be in the mouth of a spokesperson for a democratic and progressive party like yours.

Secondly, from there, place yourself in the terms of a political project. If it is a progressive political project and if it is a political project that defends, as this one has defended, plural Spain, there will be possibilities for understanding. If the problem lies in other types of issues regarding electoral expectations or what has happened electorally to one and the other, there will be more difficulties. But always looking at the general interest and putting the long-term lights, undoubtedly, one works more positively for everyone and also for each of the Groups, and not the short-term lights.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, from the Popular Parliamentary Group

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- You have said in this Chamber, and I agree, that the best thermometer to measure the effectiveness of economic policy is employment. Well, when we are not even a year into the Legislature, 1,200,000 jobs have been destroyed in Spain, and we have double the unemployment rate of the European Union.

Many people are asking you for a change in your economic policy: we have asked you; recently, the President of the Generalitat has asked you, and even a Nobel Prize winner who must have been astonished when you handed him the E Plan just a few days ago here in Madrid.

The question I want to ask you is whether you are going to change your economic policy, whether you are going to change your economic team, or whether you believe that the effectiveness of your economic team and your economic policy is so well established that it makes no sense to proceed with any change.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, I believe we have already debated this issue on some occasion. The Government has faced the economic recession, the economic crisis that the whole world is experiencing, although you may not like to hear it, with a set of measures aimed, first of all, at supporting families, supporting the unemployed, and maintaining social protection. We have not given only an economic response to the crisis; we are providing a social response, which you never care about and to which you never referred.

Secondly, we are facing in this period the most difficult part of the crisis, and therefore, our measures have been aimed at alleviating financing difficulties and combating job destruction. A good part of those measures are starting to have their effects from this moment on. And, once the world economy and the financial system recover a minimum of normality, we will be in a position to implement new economic policy measures to prepare and relaunch the Spanish economy and job creation. And I hope that also, or at least in this case, we can count on the collaboration of your political group.

Mr. Rajoy.- You have a problem: that no one believes you and no one wants to be with you because it is not profitable for anyone, nor for the general interests. You have another problem: that your measures do not work. You have a third problem: that you are incapable of accepting the suggestions that the rest of us make, and just a few days ago, nine Propositions of Law from the Popular Parliamentary Group were vetoed here, a veto in an unprecedented act in this Chamber. And you have another small problem: that you do not attend to what we have been asking for a year, which is the following: austerity; change the budgetary and fiscal policy.

Look, in reforms: labor reform? You have done nothing. Educational? Nothing. Market unity? Nothing. Justice? Nothing. Pensions? Nothing. Water? Nothing. Energy policy? Nothing. That said, you have talked about social policy.

The only significant economic measure you have taken in these years has been what happened with Endesa: a Spanish private company becomes an Italian public one, someone takes more than a billion in capital gains, the largest dividend in the history of Spain is shared between two, and Endesa's investments are reduced, giving consumers a huge slap in the face. That is your social policy.

Mr. President of the Government, you are putting us in an impossible situation. Do not forget, neither you nor, what is worse, the Spanish economy can withstand more than half a year like this.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, rest assured that I will not refer to what your problems are, because what matters to me and what matters to the Spanish people is how many solutions we can move forward together. And that is what I want to raise in this Chamber.

Consequently, you will find it agreeable that there is this willingness to engage in dialogue. You have referred to the effectiveness of the measures we have taken. Allow me to give you some data: to support financing for companies, there are already 77,500 companies and citizens who have received ICO Lines. Specifically, the liquidity lines have already financed 1.1 billion for 12,000 small and medium-sized enterprises so far this year. Or I will remind you that this month, 33,000 public works are being launched to generate employment.

From there, I will tell you that in social policy, this Government has increased pensions, the minimum wage, dependency support, and more housing assistance, and has not resorted to "decrees," as you have, against workers.