Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

23 March 2009 · Parliamentary control session (questions to the President of the Government)

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions on the one-year anniversary of his legislature, addressing Spain's commitments to the Foral Community of Navarra in March 2009.
Main themes
Spain-Navarra relations, infrastructure investment, high-speed rail agreement, renewable energy, Itoiz Dam and Navarra Canal, tax and financial agreements, IRENA headquarters proposal, institutional cooperation, road infrastructure, Pamplona airport modernization
Duration
~51 min
94th percentile
Words
6,163
94th percentile
Sentences
222
91st percentile
Readability
45
50th percentile
Grade
13.3
59th percentile
Syntax
3.29
81st percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
42nd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 47%43%
  • Economic 26%24%
  • Ceremonial 14%13%
  • Geopolitical 7%6%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Environmental 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 9%

222 sentences in 106 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Francisco Javier Tuñón, from the Mixed Parliamentary Group

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Tuñón.- Welcome, Mr. President of the Government. A year has passed since your inauguration as President of the Government in this Legislature, and for that reason, I would like you to assess the relations between the Government of Spain and the Government of the Foral Community of Navarra. At the same time, I am going to make a proposal that, if you allow me, I will develop in the reply turn, for Navarra to be the headquarters of the International Renewable Energy Agency. I will make that proposal.

The question is formulated in the following terms: what is the President's assessment of the degree of compliance of the commitments of the Government of Spain with the Foral Community of Navarra?

President.- Mr. Tuñón, the Government positively values the relationship it maintains with the Government of the Foral Community of Navarra. There has been a willingness to collaborate that has been reflected in a very high number of agreements and joint actions. I will highlight some briefly.

In November 2007, we reached an agreement on tax and financial matters regarding the Economic Agreement of Navarra, which has served to determine the framework for the contributions that the State and the Community should make. In addition, there has been a significant boost to the Itoiz Dam project and the Navarra Canal, a project that, as you know, involves an investment of more than one billion euros, financed 70 percent by the Government of Spain. At the beginning of this March, we have definitively put this reservoir into operation with the inauguration of its hydroelectric plant, which has been a good example of effective institutional cooperation between both Governments.

The same can be said about the great engineering work of the Navarra Canal; a vital infrastructure for that land, to transform almost sixty thousand hectares of dry land into irrigated land. More than three hundred million euros have already been invested in this work, and to date, half of its 177 kilometers have been constructed.

In the area of infrastructure, there has been a 90 percent increase compared to the previous Legislature.

We also contribute, as Your Lordship knows, to the development of renewable energies, where Navarra enjoys national and international recognition.

We are fulfilling commitments, and in addition, we have opened new projects. Thus, the Ministry of Development has just signed an agreement with the Foral Community for both Administrations to proceed with the construction of various road connections; among them, I want to highlight the connection of the Santiago de Compostela Highway with the A-68, a project with a budget of 93 million euros. Likewise, we are betting on the modernization of the Pamplona airport.

And regarding the arrival of High-Speed Rail to Navarra, which I suppose is also implicit in your question, I must tell you that the will of the Government of Spain is to reach an agreement with the Foral Community as soon as possible. I hope that this agreement does not take more than a month so that we can jointly carry out this large-scale project of great economic and social importance for the Community of Navarra.

In short, Your Lordship, in this brief summary, I give a positive assessment of the relationship with the Government of the Foral Community of Navarra from the Government of Spain.

Mr. Tuñón.- I hope that these words will help to channel these good relations that have also been maintained in the future.

The truth is that the question implicitly included the High-Speed Train. You know it; there is no need to be a fortune teller.

In principle, if you keep your word that this agreement will be signed in a month, I believe that we will all be highly satisfied. I think it is a matter of political wear that leads us nowhere. I have always been in favor of not using this issue as a weapon, but the truth is that commitments are meant to be fulfilled.

This is a topic I already raised in the first appearance I had; I asked the Minister of Development, and you know that the Senate recently approved this motion from all Groups requesting the signing of the Agreement, so I am glad that things are going well.

Mr. President, in five minutes I hope you have sufficient arguments to accept the proposal I am making, and I will make it quite reasoned.

I will start, in principle, by giving you some compliments in these times, like those that the golden eagle carries in its beak, a symbol of renewable wind energy; the eagle that carries joys in its wings and loves in its heart. And I will congratulate you from Navarra, as an autonomous senator, for your support six years ago for renewable energies and for leading, along with Germany and Denmark, the International Renewable Energy Agency, IRENA, recently created in Berlin in January 2009, with 75 signing countries; in general, countries that are supportive, pacifist, and advanced ecologists, or poor developing countries. The big ones are not there yet, but they will come.

This Agency is a self-sustaining seed of the future and will survive other types of Agencies; it will survive OPEC, because one day oil will run out, and it will survive the International Atomic Energy Agency, the energy of the future whose time has already passed.

In June 2009, the location of this IRENA headquarters will be decided. This shared global headquarters and sub-headquarters for Southern Europe, Africa, and America could be in Spain, and especially in Navarra. Spain has all kinds of reasons to obtain this headquarters. If we succeed, Navarra and the twenty-three municipalities adjacent to the Las Bardenas Military Training Area, recently renewed for twenty years, would be happy to have their efforts recognized by bringing the International Renewable Energy Agency to our land.

I want the effort that Navarra has made to renew the Las Bardenas Military Training Area for twenty years to be recognized. The training area has a local dimension that affects twenty-three adjacent municipalities, which have signed the rental contract for the Training Area; but it also has an autonomous dimension, regarding environmental impact and risk cost, and it also has an international dimension as it is the only training area used by NATO on European soil.

If the adjacent municipalities have voluntarily and collectively assumed the extension of the agreement on the Training Area, we request an international recognition and a symbolic compensation: a shared headquarters of the International Renewable Energy Agency.

From Navarra, we enthusiastically offer to obtain this headquarters, especially in Pamplona. Ideally, it would be in the Ebro Valley and shared with Zaragoza and Vitoria. In this "Ebrópolis" or "Eópolis" corridor, as coined by my friend Mario Gaviria, the equivalent in renewable energies to Silicon Valley, is the largest concentration of technologists, research centers, industrial companies manufacturing wind turbines, wind farms, and solar thermal power plants.

From Navarra, we would warmly welcome all those who wish to come, especially from Africa and America, to learn from our experience. That is why Navarra and the Ebro Valley are a good headquarters for people from the rest of the planet to come and transmit our technological and social knowledge in renewable energies. Navarra has also been replacing its universalist missionary tradition, which spread Christianity and the Spanish language in America and Africa, and has generated the new missionaries of the 21st century: hundreds of engineers and technologists who are creating wind turbine factories, wind farms, and solar thermal power plants in China, Mexico, Chile, and the United States. They are the new wind missionaries.

Moreover, the Foral Community has sufficient merits. Navarra is a pioneering and leading region in the world in renewable energies -- you have recognized it -- a sector that was promoted from the public sector. Twenty-five years ago, the first company in this sector was created. In 1994, the first wind farms were promoted in Navarra, and currently, this sector is a strategic sector for Navarra, along with the automotive and agri-food industries.

In Navarra, 65 percent of electricity consumption comes from wind energy, and by 2010 it will rise to 75 percent. The sector represents 5 percent of the GDP in Navarra: 88 dedicated companies that provide direct or indirect employment to more than eight thousand people; a sector that expects to create five thousand jobs in two years. Here, the National Renewable Energy Center (CNER) was born, precisely promoted by the State, with two hundred professionals working at the highest level, and the Integrated Training Center in Renewable Energies (CENIFER).

Minister Garmendia, as you have recognized, last week in Congress acknowledged that Navarra is the best example of commitment to renewable energies in Spain. Navarra is the first region in Europe in self-maintenance of renewable energy per square kilometer and per thousand inhabitants, and Navarra could be the first self-sustainable region in food and energy in the next twenty years.

Therefore, we make ourselves available to you to bring a shared IRENA headquarters to Spain and Pamplona. We will be generous in personal and economic effort, as we have always been.

President.- Mr. Tuñón, I want to publicly acknowledge the effort of Navarra, and especially of the affected municipalities, for their attitude regarding the Las Bardenas Military Training Area.

Likewise, I reiterate the recognition, pride, and satisfaction for what Navarra has achieved as a pioneer and leader in renewable energies with the full support of the Government of Spain. Without a doubt, there lies the future, and undoubtedly, the change in the economic model that will help to overcome the crisis and recover economies in general, and the Spanish economy in particular, largely depends on the new energy model that we are trying to implement, where Navarra is part and has a fundamental role.

And I welcome, as it could not be otherwise, with the utmost interest the proposal you have just made regarding the International Agency, which, as you have recalled, is the result of the impetus, among others, from our country to undertake that energy change that will undoubtedly be the prelude, the engine, that drives the change to a different economic growth. I welcome it with the utmost interest and, of course, I will keep you informed of the evolution of the expectations regarding the International Energy Agency.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Pío García-Escudero, from the Popular Parliamentary Group

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. García-Escudero.- Does the President of the Government consider that his current ministerial cabinet is the most suitable to face the economic crisis?

President.- Mr. García-Escudero, the Government has been working fundamentally, almost exclusively, on the fight against the economic crisis with a set of measures oriented from the general interest, from work, from seriousness, and from the social commitments that this Government has expressed before the citizens and, of course, before the Chamber.

As Your Lordship knows, because we have already spoken on some occasions, that policy of fighting against the crisis and gaining as much time as possible to provoke economic recovery and the recovery of employment constitutes an unprecedented fiscal effort by a Government in facing a crisis in our country and, moreover, it is one of the greatest efforts of all developed countries, as the International Monetary Fund has just pointed out.

I will briefly recall the essential lines of our action, of that plan to fight against the economic crisis and the loss of employment.

An important injection of public investment. We are starting this month with around 33 billion euros in public works, 30,000 public works, particularly at the municipal level, and also state investments, which we hope will have a positive impact on the evolution of employment.

Likewise, as you know, the Council of Ministers has just analyzed and approved last Friday the Support Plan for the competitiveness of the automotive sector, with aid, just for competitiveness, of eight hundred million euros, as the major industrial sector that is going through the most difficulties and needs specific support.

In the same way, to date, since January 1, with the reinforcement of the Lines of the Official Credit Institute to face the serious credit and liquidity crisis, the Government has facilitated that 77,500 companies and citizens have already benefited, up to this moment, from ICO credits, making use of more than 2.1 billion euros of the 40 billion we have available for the whole year to try to counteract that situation.

I will tell you that in some specific cases, to cite one of the Lines that have generated the most interest and demand, the Liquidity Line, 1.1 billion euros have already been financed to 12,500 SMEs and self-employed workers. This means that there is an average of 180 operations daily and that, fortunately, the evolution is somewhat more favorable, slightly more favorable, in the expectations of credit for SMEs and self-employed workers, although there are still many difficulties.

In addition to that, as Your Lordship knows, we have launched a new line of support for the liquidity of companies amounting to six billion euros.

And all of this while working in the field of social dialogue, introducing modifications to our labor legislation and new bonuses to promote job retention and to encourage new hiring, because, without a doubt, this is the fundamental problem we have.

Furthermore, as I mentioned initially, we are maintaining our commitments in social policy, increasing pensions, increasing the Minimum Interprofessional Wage, increasing scholarships, increasing housing assistance, and maintaining and strengthening social protection, because we understand that in the crisis and in the exit from the crisis, those who should pay the least are the workers who, evidently, are those who have not caused it. In this, the entire team, the whole Government, is working with, logically, the utmost interest and striving to do things in the service of the general interest.

Mr. García-Escudero.- Why will people see it differently, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero?

People see paralysis as the word that best describes the situation in Spain today. They see paralysis in the economy, an economy that is in recession as it has not been known for fifteen years, an economy that is dangerously regressing.

People see fear in the financial system, with the large banks and the CECA calling for urgent measures to prevent dramatic situations that could arise.

People see paralysis in our productive system. Look, today fewer than half the number of companies are being created compared to a year ago, and more than three times as many are being destroyed.

People see a slowdown in consumption, which is leading us to a situation of deflation that has not been known for many years.

People see an absence of employment policies. We are nearing four million unemployed, and just a year ago you were promising full employment.

People see stagnation in social dialogue, with employers and unions increasingly distanced. And you, the one in the photo, the one who has the obligation to lead and promote it, are neither here nor expected.

People see paralysis in social policies because, while you announce plans and plans that are increasingly empty, the number of Spaniards crossing the poverty line is skyrocketing.

There is paralysis here, in Parliament, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero. You veto the parliamentary debate on the economic proposals of the Popular Party because you are afraid of losing votes, and on top of that, you continue to accuse us of not presenting measures.

You do not dare to send Bills to the Cortes. Do you know how many are being processed here today, in the Senate, a year after the elections? Not a single one, something unprecedented in thirty years of democracy.

People see paralysis in your Government and your Vice President, disheveled, scolding the Undersecretaries. The largest Government, the one with the most Departments and the most advisors in thirteen years; the most expensive Government in Europe, according to "The Economist," is paralyzed, with half the Ministers hiding and the other half trying to hide. Paralyzed, laugh and ask them while waiting for dismissal and playing English hide-and-seek: hands still, feet still. And they have only been in office for a year, a year.

There is defeatism in the Minister of Economy, who only opens his mouth to ask for retirement or to make such lapidary statements as the last one: "there has been no deception or error by the Government, but a poorly assessed economic evolution." Take that!

There is confusion with the Minister of Labor, a stone guest in the social disagreement and who only moves to hide at the beginning of each month when the unemployment figures are published.

There is astonishment with the Minister of Industry, who has been searching for the philosopher's stone for a long time and has not found a single correct measure.

There are failed ministries like the Ministry of Education, which, by the way, just received a blow from the Supreme Court; or the Ministry of Research, fighting with the Ministry of Industry over space competencies, while more and more students are on the streets against the Bologna Plan.

There is a total void in absolutely dispensable ministries, like the Ministry of Housing or the Ministry of Equality, which in times of crisis are a true waste.

And with these materials, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, you think you can pull Spain out of the crisis and create jobs. But the worst part is that there is paralysis in you as well, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, who only moves to unnecessarily anger Mr. Obama and our NATO allies by the way you have announced the withdrawal of our troops from Kosovo.

Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, you have shown that you are capable of anything to distract attention and to ensure that the real problems that concern Spaniards, which are unemployment and the economic crisis, are not discussed. What a spectacle your Government is giving these days on this issue! What a shame!

And, meanwhile, the enormous gravity of this moment; the "desolate panorama," as Nobel Prize winner Krugman described it; the "national emergency," as Felipe González said a few days ago, are crying out for a strong Government, with the capacity to work, with ideas, with initiatives, and a President who leads, who makes decisions, who faces situations and who gives confidence. And you are offering today the exact opposite: a lot of immobility, a lot of resignation, and that eternal circular thinking of your usual clichés, because you are already boring us with the guarantee of social rights, while unemployment continues to rise and more and more families are struggling. You are already boring us hiding behind a social dialogue that does not exist, because you are incapable of leading or promoting it. You are already boring us promising structural reforms that never arrive and selling plans and plans without results, you seem like a man-advertisement.

Now, that said, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, you always fix everything with the magic word: "you will not make 'decretazos'." Do you not remember when you enthusiastically supported the "decretazos" of 1988 and 1992, when you were just a simple backbench MP?

Get over it, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero; get over it once and for all and you will live more peacefully. Get over it and look much further than the famous Plan E, the one you gave to Nobel Prize winner Krugman the other day, who must still be astonished. Listen to him, since he is a Nobel Prize winner, since you do not want to listen to us.

Structural reforms in education, the labor market, corporate taxation, the productive system, the energy model are urgent... Do it now, stop trusting everything to "it will clear up," to propaganda and luck. Then do not be surprised if you have less and less parliamentary support. If no one wants to be an accomplice to your disaster anymore.

Thank goodness that more and more Spaniards, as has just been demonstrated in Galicia, are convinced that, at last, the flower has changed its rabel and that very soon all of this will begin to be overcome and not precisely in your hands, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero.

President.- Mr. García-Escudero, the only thing that is quite evident from your intervention is one thing... well, better two. The first, that you have an absolute void, and your party, because you have not made a single proposal, idea, or suggestion of what economic and social policy should be. An absolute void.

In reality, it is not that you have a void; the problem is that your proposals for economic and social policy, the ones you really like, the ones you would try to carry out, you are not able to say them publicly. That is the problem, yes. You are not able to say what you would do every time you talk about labor reform and what that term translates into, and you are able to say, as I believe your spokesperson on economic matters from the party's Executive or in Congress, Mr. Montoro, did yesterday, that he conditioned support for the measures that are or will be necessary to sustain and strengthen our financial system, which are the savings of Spaniards and the loans and interests of companies, on the Government withdrawing the project for new autonomous financing, doing, by the way, a great favor to the Autonomous Communities of all political colors that need more funding to improve education and healthcare.

That is your way of contributing to solving the problems that affect everyone and all Governments, and Governments of different colors, through blackmail without caring whether the financial system needs more support and without caring whether the Autonomous Communities need to improve their financing; simply seeking, as has been demonstrated in your intervention, to entangle and disqualify, but never to cooperate and never to propose. That is the Popular Party and that is what you have done this afternoon.

I see, Mr. García-Escudero, that you do not like it, because I have reminded you of the "decretazo" before. Yes, it is that the "decretazo" was done by the Government of the Popular Party, yes, and this Government that I preside has made social laws to improve social protection and the rights of workers, or laws like the Equality Law between men and women, which is why you do not like there to be a Ministry of Equality, because you do not like equality.

I will finish now. And regarding foreign policy and troops, I have no objection to having all the debates with you and your Group, but I simply tell you: have a little shame after you sent troops to Iraq against international legality and against the United Nations. Have you...

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Joseba Zubía, from the Parliamentary Group of Basque Nationalist Senators

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Zubía.- Do you consider that the Government has already completed the political change that Your Lordship announced in Parliament after the general elections of 2004?

President.- Mr. Zubía, I have seen that you have received applause from the ranks of the Popular Party, which is quite interesting.

Mr. Zubía, as you well know, every political project has stages. In 2004, the Socialist Party received the majority support of the citizens to carry out a political project of change in foreign policy, of change in social policy, of change in management and attitude towards democracy, and of change also in the vision of Spain and the governability of Spain.

In the last Legislature, we made changes, reforms, advances, laws, and a different policy towards the world. That project, in that first stage, again obtained the trust and support of the citizens to carry out a new stage of change in this Legislature, which is what the Government is committed to; change addressing, first of all, the economic crisis, but making this country advance in the field of citizens' rights, in the field of social policies, in the field of its opening to the world, and in the field of peaceful and inclusive coexistence among the different nationalities and peoples that comprise it.

Mr. Zubía.- Mr. President of the Government, on April 15, 2004, in the debate on your investiture, Your Lordship said that the Socialist Party had received the majority mandate from the Spaniards to form a Government and that this decision had been the expression of an unstoppable collective desire: the will for change. You added: "I also know that the will for change of the Spaniards is pregnant with demands, that there is above all a demand for respect for promises, that citizens demand of us politicians that we be faithful to our promises." And you concluded by assuring: "this demand is for me the most pressing, the most obligatory. I will honor the word given."

Those were indeed moments of hope, and we were, moreover, in need of it. We had to give you credit, and we did, but we warned that the announced change had to be materialized; that the words sounded very good, but that subsequent actions were also needed; that it would be regrettable if the new spirit were broken because you did not dare to abandon the followership policy of the Popular Party that your party had been carrying out in recent years, and that the credit that you had at that time and that we recognized with excitement could not be "sine die," but would have an expiration date.

Well, Mr. President, five years have passed since then, five years already, Mr. President, more than enough time to take stock of what has changed so far by your Government following that mandate you said you received and that commitment you expressed as an obligatory demand.

I will therefore allow myself, Mr. President, to take a brief stroll through some of the areas of action of the Government where change was especially awaited but, if it has occurred, I need you to make it explicit, because no matter how much I have searched for it, I have not been able to find it.

It is evident that I am not referring to the economic area, where the change is visible, and I advance that I will not refer to that new change, the change in Euskadi, which Your Lordship says you have set as one of your priority objectives for this Legislature. We will have time to talk about this last change in the future.

I will refer, first of all, to the area of what we could call deepening a model of the State that respects the culture of guarantees. What has been, Mr. President, the public action developed by your Government and what measures have been implemented in these five years to deepen democracy? More specifically, what has been done to repair the serious fissures produced in that principle, which is clearly in crisis, that is the separation of powers? And what has been done, Mr. President, with that exceptional legislation that has been approved under the pretext of terrorism and that severely violates fundamental rights and public freedoms?

It is indisputable that a democratic State must fight with all the means at its disposal against the threat posed by terrorism, but admit with me, Mr. President, that challenges like this, as important as they are, should never be addressed from the perspective of curtailing freedoms and a restrictive interpretation of democracy. However, we sadly see that a law, such as the Political Parties Law, which represents a general breach of fundamental rights and which I would dare to say is incompatible with democracy itself, remains in force in its entirety and exactly as it was approved.

A second area I want to refer to is Justice, a Justice that is also in crisis and in which, being lenient, I will tell you that nothing has changed. It continues to be a great forgotten, it still does not adapt to a State defined as autonomous, it is more politicized than ever, with an evident intrusion into the political sphere and rulings from the highest judicial instances that are adopted based on the composition of the Chambers and not on the substance of what is being judged.

Where do those words of the then Minister of Justice, Mr. López Aguilar, remain, Mr. President, who said, in his first appearance as such, the following: "I reaffirm that the Government of José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero wants to develop a political project of change that in matters of Justice must be secure, responsible, and calm. We desire a change in the measure that it is a Government that symbolizes a democratic alternation and, therefore, starts from a political time that wants to undertake innovative impulses"?

Innovative impulses and a change that is secure, responsible, and calm. You will tell me, Mr. President, where those innovative impulses are today and what has materialized from that change that is calm, if by calm it was meant something synonymous with slow, I can attest that it is indeed being so.

A third and final area I will focus on is the model of the State, a State of Autonomies, also undoubtedly in crisis.

In crisis because, with the non-compliance and the miserly interpretations made by the Government and the jurisprudence of the Courts, it has become a system that, in the case of Euskadi, does not respond in the least to the expectations created at the time of the approval of the Statute.

In crisis also because here we are still, Mr. President, with a Senate that continues to address its reform, despite the fact that it was also announced and despite the fact that the recently appointed Minister of Justice wrote something very recently with which I absolutely agree. He said: "this reform of the Senate is urgent and cannot wait any longer, as our system will continue to limp while the Senate does not become a Chamber of territorial representation." Well, I fear, Mr. President, that we have a limp for a long time.

And in crisis also, Mr. President, because that Constitutional Court, which is considered the ultimate guarantor of the system thanks to its regulatory norm, maintains an absolutely unequal institutional position of the state and autonomous Government, in addition to the fact that its magistrates, no matter how much it is adorned, are appointed by the two major state parties through institutions they control with their majorities. There must be a reason why neither of these two parties wants to lose their weight. The best proof of all this is the lamentable spectacle they are providing us by not even being able to agree to renew it.

And do not tell me at this point, Mr. President, that this renewal, or the reform of the Senate, or the same reform of Justice, is not possible due to the refusal or lack of involvement of the first opposition party because, as far as I know, this is the same party that you are so eager to turn into a travel companion for that new goal you have set, which is the change in Euskadi. Well, what do you want me to say? Have a good trip and someday tell me about it.

Time, Mr. President, does not allow for more, but I believe it has allowed me to convey to you in a clear manner that in the areas I have referred to, which are not precisely minor, that touted change I do not see materialized. So much so that I believe, even having reached this moment, that I have asked the wrong initial question. The correct question would have been to ask you, not whether the Government considers that the political change announced in 2004 has already been completed, but when it plans to initiate it.

In any case, and I conclude, now for real, Mr. President, it would be good if you remembered from time to time your words: "citizens demand that we politicians be faithful to our promises. I will honor the word given." Although five years have passed, Mr. President, you can still try.

President.- Mr. Zubía, I appreciate your tone and your narration. It is true that you have incurred in some implicit contradiction. You have recalled on two occasions to honor the word given, and one of the most serious criticisms you have made is the policy regarding the Political Parties Law and the application of that Political Parties Law. I have done nothing but honor the word given: I voted for the Political Parties Law at the time and always committed to maintaining the Political Parties Law and applying it with respect to the Courts. Therefore, it seems to me that you have incurred in a serious contradiction. I have honored the word given.

By the way, since you have placed special emphasis on this issue, I must tell you that the breach in democracy is not the Political Parties Law; the breach is assassination, extortion, and violence. That is what breaks democracy. What is radically incompatible with democracy is violence. The Political Parties Law is compatible with democracy; moreover, democracy has the right to defend itself so that no one can use its institutions in the service of violence. No one can do that. Democracy has the right, and we should have, from that perspective, all the parties that have a deep democratic tradition, that defend democracy, like yours, a more serene and shared reflection, beyond the electoral vicissitudes, which are usually circumstantial.

Yes, Your Honor, we have made changes in the management of the understanding of the model of the State. The best proof is that, for example, with the Basque Government, the Government I preside over has reached countless agreements: renewal of the Concert, agreements in infrastructure matters..., and we have maintained a scrupulous respect for self-government, supported self-government, and we have maintained a position against proposals that exceeded self-government, such as the plans that Mr. Ibarretxe repeatedly presented to us. We have been coherent and have honored the word given, sometimes with misunderstandings.

You have used a formula to define what happened five years ago in relation to your attitude of the Basque Nationalist Party. You have been clever. You said that you gave credit to the Government or to the President of the Government who at that time obtained the majority of the Chamber. It is true, credit, yes; support they never gave me, because they never voted for the investiture. They did so with Mr. Aznar, curiously.

Therefore, it should not surprise you, since you have a long experience of agreements with the Popular Party, that now the Socialist Party of Euskadi can understand itself there with the Popular Party. It should not produce you so much surprise.

What I do believe we can agree on is that... I can be criticized for many things, and surely with reason, but for following the Popular Party, I honestly believe that no one can criticize me in this Chamber or in the country as a whole. I am sure it will be difficult for that to convince the citizens.

In any case, Mr. Zubía, I wish that your Group at least recognizes some things regarding democratic reforms and changes in the management of plural Spain. There has been a very, very intense reduction of conflict. We have experienced an advance and a time of reforms of the Statutes within the Constitution, and I have also tried to make this Chamber one that dignifies, that has more content and that has more role. The best proof is the control sessions to which for the first time, like the one we have today, a President of the Government is subjected so that someone can tell him, by the way, that he hides, when a President of the Government comes here for the first time to respond with a broader time to the questions posed by the spokespeople of the opposition.

Finally, Mr. Zubía, we share the need to reform this Chamber and we share the urgent need to proceed with the renewal of the Constitutional Court. As you well know, these are not acts of government; as you well know, they are processes of agreement between political groups and, of course, the socialist political group has every will. I hope we can shorten the deadlines and proceed with the renewal of the Constitutional Court.

I agree with you that we have a long way to go and work on the improvement and modernization of Justice, and also that we can finally illuminate this Chamber as a Chamber of territorial representation.

In any case, my attitude towards your Group will always be one of respect, of course, and of gratitude in all the matters, which have already been many, in which you have collaborated and supported the Government.

Thank you very much.