Press conference of the President of the Government after the meeting of the European Council

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

19 March 2009 · Press conference after the meeting of the European Council

Context
Zapatero addressed press following the March 2009 European Council meeting in Brussels, summarizing decisions on economic recovery and energy policy.
Main themes
European economic recovery, EU financial crisis response, Spain's Plan E, credit access and liquidity, energy infrastructure projects, climate change policy, G-20 summit coordination, Lisbon Strategy reforms, EU budget allocation, Spain-France energy interconnections
Duration
~36 min
88th percentile
Words
4,307
88th percentile
Sentences
161
83rd percentile
Readability
45
48th percentile
Grade
13.6
63rd percentile
Syntax
3.29
82nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
13th percentile

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

161 sentences in 79 paragraphs

President.- Good afternoon. As you all know, this European Council has focused on economy, mainly. It has corroborated Europe's willingness to carry out a common action, with the outmost efficiency and firmness in order to face the difficulties issuing from the international economic situation.

This European Council, as you all know, has dealt with two main issues: on the one hand, the analysis of the economic situation and, on the other hand, the questions concerning energy and climatic change.

In December we adopted the European Plan for Economic Recovery, which contains the recovery plans set up by all the member countries; in the case of Spain, this plan is called Plan E, Economy and Employment Stimulation Plan. These plans entail a joint effort that amounts to four hundred and thousand million Euros, 3.3% of the EU Gross Domestic Product.

All European Governments have realised that the financial situation keeps having serious problems, as well as its impact upon real economy and citizens.

The European Governments are sure that the effectiveness of this ambitious Plan for Economic Recovery will yield results and that the measures it contemplates will surely contribute to bring the economic recession to an end and to enhance the expectations of economic recovery in our countries.

During the next European Council, in June, we will assess the measures adopted as state plans last December and also the EU measures, which are proving to be efficient, as they are starting to be applied to real economy, right now, over the last few weeks in March.

As for Spain, I must say that, according to the Government, things have improved slightly as far as credit access in the case of companies is concerned; things have improved slightly even in spite of the situation, which is characterised by serious difficulties, but they have improved as compared to the general situation two months ago.

Besides, the credit lines of the Official Credit Institute are progressively increasing. Right now we have already carried out 77,500 transactions for companies and citizens and the ICO line aimed at improvement the liquidity of companies in order to finance working capital, which is surely enough the main problem of companies, has already financed more than twelve thousand small and medium sized companies and it has already started to gain speed, as more transactions are being carried out. Small and medium-sized companies know that there are better expectations for the ICO lines, although - let me insist on this - there is still a lot to do in order to go back to normality.

Besides, I would also like to point out that the decrease of the Euribor, which is under 1.9%, brings relief to household economy, as family income is increasing, which will surely favour the expectations of consumption recovery.

As you all know, during this Council we had to allocate five thousand million Euros provided by the European Union for its recovery plan, in order to support the recovery plans implemented by the Member States; five thousand million Euros financed with money from the European budget for 2009 and 2010. This has been allocated to energy projects and, thus, as for our country, the amount totals to 340 million Euros, which will be financed by the European Union.

We are talking about the electric interconnection between France and Spain, which, as you all know, will double the existing interconnection capacity in the Central-European electric market and which, as you all know too, contributes, specially, to increasing the availability of electricity in Catalonia.

Besides, the European Union has also financed another project, namely, the construction of a carbon capture and storage plant in El Bierzo, Leon, which is something I am particularly pleased about. As you all know, this will be an essential step forward in our capacity to use carbon, a fossil source of energy, in a clean way, and carbon is considerably abundant in Spain, especially in Northern Spain.

The third project that has received financing is the construction of the gas interconnection between Spain and France in order to improve energy safety in Europe.

Besides, the European Council has corroborated the relevance of moving on and enhancing the structural reforms contemplated n the Lisbon Strategy. One of the aims of the Spanish Presidency next year will be the promotion of these reforms in order to enhance economic recovery and to increase the growth and employment creation capacity.

Moreover, the European Council has established a common position for the EU countries that will be taking part in the London G-20 Summit next 1 and 2 April. I think that this common position is especially relevant for - in order to undertake the reform of the international financial system - it is very positive for all EU countries to propose and defend a common position as far as the regulation, supervision and reform of the International Monetary Fund are concerned, and also as far as the other measures that will be discussed and adopted during the G-20 Summit in London are concerned.

As you all know, the Council has decided to back up the increase of resources of the International Monetary Fund, which will reach 75,000 million Euros with the contribution of the EU countries, in order to make up for any problems in the balance of payments in the world; 75,000 million Euros that the EU countries will provide the International Monetary Fund with in order to face the situations derived from this crisis and which are a voluntary contribution, as you all know.

Besides, the European Council that will be held next June will establish the new supervision system concerning the EU financial system, which, surely enough, will serve to make up for the current crisis and to ensure a future characterised by greater confidence and guarantees as far as the financial system is concerned.

As to climatic change, the European Union has proved, once more, its willingness to lead the international fight against this phenomenon and today's Council has analysed the different elements that must form part of the common European position during the Summit in Copenhagen, next December.

Finally, with regards to the EU neighbourhood policy, the Council has set up the process of Eastern Partnership. It has approved of a Declaration for the creation of this Partnership during the next Summit of Heads of Government and Heads of State, in May, which will be intended to strengthen the bonds with the Eastern Europe from the EU, including the 27 EU members.

These are the main issues the Council, this spring Council, this economic Council, has dealt with, a Council that has corroborated something that - in my opinion - is an essential reaction of the EU against the economic crisis, namely, the fact that we are attaining progressively more agreements, we defend more common positions, we make more shared decisions, and this European common policy against the economic crisis and in favour of economic recovery and employment is still the main axis and the main proposal of the European Union.

Journalist.- President, yesterday, the Minister of Defence announced the withdrawal of the Spanish troops from Kosovo. I would like to ask you, in the first place, a few questions that have remained unanswered. Why does the Government decide to withdraw from Kosovo right now? The Minister explained that the mission was over. The Spanish mission forms part of a global NATO mission and we wonder why Spain has decided that we are over in Kosovo considering that the NATO mission has not concluded yet.

Then, does this have something to do with the independence process in Kosovo? And, what can you say about the criticism of the PP, which agrees and thinks that the withdrawal of the Spanish troops is a coherent decision, yet, is wondering what Obama will think about this fact?

President.- To start with, the withdrawal of the Spanish troops from Kosovo is a logical, expected thing and we all know it would have to happen at some point. It has happened now, but it could have happened two months ago or in two months' time.

We have concluded a mission for stability and safety in the Balkans. Our soldiers have been there for ten years, working with devotion and efficiency and they are honestly appreciated by the population in that area. Thus, I would like to pay a tribute, in the first place, to those soldiers who have been there and, in particular, to those who have died there.

One year ago, Kosovo issued a unilateral declaration of independence and, as you all know, Spain did not recognise it. Thus, our presence there didn't make that much sense any longer, even less now that the area has progressively gained stability.

Then, let me say that -logically enough- our withdrawal will take place favouring or enhancing the operational reorganisation. Thus, we have set a four or five-month period in order to do so with our allies, with the NATO.

As to the criticism of the PP, they keep criticising things even when they agree, and, thus, well... I'm glad that they agree, which is something they had already said some time ago, some months ago. But I will not give way to controversy for we agree about this. We have already many points of disagreement and controversy with the PP.

We made the logical decision, we did what we had to do and, moreover, we did it in a reasonable moment. Things are fine, everything is calm. We have not recognised Kosovo's independence and the transition, given the important role played by our troops, is going to be carried out in a natural way and with the outmost coordination with the allies and with the NATO.

Journalist.- President, it seems that the extraordinary Meeting of next 7 May in Prague has been cancelled. It was going to deal with employment. Why has it been cancelled and who has proposed its cancelation? Then, as for the G-20, the London meeting will take place in just two weeks' time but there is still disagreement with Obama's Government concerning the priorities to bring the economic crisis to an end.

President.- As to the first question, the Summit on employment has changed in format. Let's say it is going to be attended by the Troika, the Commission and the social interlocutors and several Heads of State and government proposed this considering this way it could be more positive - operatively speaking - as far as the aims of the Summit of employment are concerned; and especially considering that we will soon be attending another Summit in June, some time before the G-20 Summit in London.

I think that the commission has an interest in focusing on the answer to the economic crisis and to the problems concerning employment derived from it, and in turning it into one of the main tasks of the EU, and this is extraordinarily positive; and it is also particularly interested in making this come true, as I could see this yesterday during the meeting I, Prime Minister of Sweden and the social interlocutors attended, a meeting characterised by the highest participation of both unions and employers' organisations.

I think that operativeness is the most logical reason for this change in format.

As for the proposal, it was put forward by a few persons, as I have already said. President Sarkozy, in the first place, and also other Presidents or Heads of Government.

As far as the G-20 meeting is concerned, it is true, that sort of disagreement exists. I think that there will not be any disagreement during the G-20 Summit, and I think that the G-20 Summit is going to mark the definitive stage of the reform of the international financial system. This will surely be a transcendental landmark in history. We must change the financial system, which must become more strict, and must operate according to an efficient regulation, to a more active supervision that may do away with tax havens, and I am sure that this actuation plan will be backed up by the G-20 countries and by the United States and Europe, of course.

Besides, the G-20 Summit will analyse and assess the evolution of the expectations of the economic situation and the reaction implemented. Europe has met the agreement reached during the G-20 Summit held in Washington on 20 November, where all Governments were demanded to make an effort in order to enhance demand, a strong fiscal contribution. We did it and we did it in a coordinated way, and this should be our goal.

But the underlying question is: should we make more efforts and more plans? I think that, right now, we must assess the results and the effects of the plans that have been implemented so far, whose measures - I insist - are now starting to reach the economic reality, because all decision-making processes take some time to yield tangible results.

We should evaluate the economic situation and the expectations once the plans have been fully developed; but, right now, I think we should just keep making a great effort, which is something that we have already done from Europe, from the Government of Spain, in particular, with this great fiscal contribution, in order to enhance investments so as to favour demand in our economies.

Journalist.- President, back to Kosovo, I would like to know whether Spain has been rebuked by any of the NATO members, in Brussels, as, so it seems, last night, during the supper, a few Ministers of Foreign Affairs criticised this decision. Could you tell us whether this was so?

And, something completely unrelated to this, do you think that during the next NATO meeting in Strasburg the United States will put forward a petition demanding more troops in Afghanistan?

President.- As for the second question, I will not say anything before we see the results of the next NATO meeting.

Let me tell you that I haven't received any direct criticism about the decision concerning Kosovo, because - I insist - our position was well-known. We have had many debates about Kosovo in the European Union. Our allies and our European partners know that we have never recognised the unilateral declaration of independence by Kosovo and we have just been coherent and, besides, we have announced our decision after a reasonable time; it was announced yesterday by the Minister of Defence; and we have also given a reasonable time for the definitive withdrawal so as to guarantee operativeness in the area.

So, there is nothing else to say.

Journalist.- President, a question about regional financing, if I may. The Generalitat has turned down the last proposal we have learnt about. I would like to know whether the Government might improve this proposal. Would you meet President Montilla in order to solve this situation? Are you going to hold a meeting? Do you think that agreement is possible without Catalonia, as Councillor Castells said? Is there a deadline for these negotiations to be considered a failure?

President.- Let me tell you a couple of things. I will not talk about rumours, because, obviously enough, it makes no sense; and I am not going to talk about extra-official positions either. I keep frequent contacts with President Montilla and I can tell you that we are progressing in order to reach an agreement on regional financing, and the Government would like this agreement to be reached in a reasonable time, and, right now, of course, we must wait until the new Government in Galicia is constituted, out of institutional respect. We need this time to set up any of the established mechanisms before a reform of the regional financing model is implemented, and, thus, we must summon the Council for Fiscal and Financial Policy.

The Government keeps negotiating and it will keep negotiating with the different Autonomous Regions, and I have undertaken to reach a good agreement concerning regional financing. But I will not recognise any figures or rumours.

Journalist.- Back to Kosovo, even though you say there is nothing more to say about it, yesterday, the General Secretary of the NATO, De Hoop Scheffer, said that in his opinion, Spain should have made this decision with the allies and not unilaterally. I would like to know what you think of this piece of criticism.

When you say that all our allies know it, was it because there had been a previous communiqué or message informing that Spain was going to make the decision announced yesterday?

President.- As to the second question, yes, of course. I have said it before, and the Minister of Defence has explained it too.

As to the words of the General Secretary of the NATO, it is Spain that must decide whether or not to withdraw its troops from a given place, just as it would be in the case of Great Britain or of any other country. In the NATO -of course- things work according to the contribution of each different member country to the different missions. Not all countries take part in the missions buttressed by the NATO and not all of them take part in the different missions to the same extent.

Therefore, this is the answer. Of course, this is how commitments are undertaken, this is how decisions are made; as to the rest, it would make no sense from the point of view of operativeness.

But, let me insist, Spain has observed its compromise with stability in the Balkans by far, and this is what is most important; our soldiers, our Army, have made a great effort, with a great support of the different political parties and, as usual, from legality. Honest, the other statements do not deserve my attention, although I respect them, just as Spain's decisions should be respected, because it is Spanish soldiers that are contributing to the NATO.

Journalist.- President, during the last meeting of the European Council, Chancellor Merkel said that she expected to reach an agreement with the United States in a negotiation, soon, about the fiscal unbalance derived from the current economic crisis. It seems that the commission will soon put forward its conception. I would like to ask you what would be the most reasonable period - in your opinion- to resume budget balance.

President.- The ones considered by the Commission from the point of view of the fiscal efforts. In two years. I think that the strongest compromises from the point of view of fiscal expenditure, will take place in 2009 and 2010. Our main aim is for these compromises - as far as Spain is concerned - to be fewer in 2010 as compared to 2009; and in 2011 we should have resumed recovery or approaching the Stability Agreement.

Journalist.- President, you say that the new formula of the Summit on unemployment is going to be more operative, but it seems that you are lessening the relevance of the problem. Yesterday, the Minister of Labour asked Europe to make a greater effort against unemployment. Perhaps you think that Europe has paid attention to the Spanish petition.

President.- We must keep this in mind. The Plan for Economic Recovery set up by the European Union, a plan which is endowed with three hundred and thousand million Euros, focuses on employment, for employment is the consequence of an economic activity. Thus, this is the only perspective.

The plan to support the financial system is also aimed at keeping up the economic activity. If the financial system does not work, and if economy and the different companies do not work, we lose jobs and not new jobs are created. Thus, everything has to do with employment, in the end.

Let's say that this Summit will be special due to the participation of the social organisations, that is, due to the social dialogue. So far, social dialogue in the European Union takes place before each economic Summit and it has now acquired a higher category, it has been strengthened and it has been provided with greater relevance. Of course, Spain is highly satisfied with this because social dialogue is one of the most positive features of the economic and social evolution in our country over the last few decades.

Thus, we are implementing measures concerning employment, due to rather different reasons. Economy is the pillar of employment, of the development of economy and of economic creation. Now, social agents are asked to play a more active role and to get more involved and, of course, during the Spanish Presidency, we will make a special effort so that the representatives of the businessmen organisations and of the different unions may be heard and have more relevance and so that they may take part in the different issues that will form part of the agenda of the summit during the Spanish EU Presidency; issues that will also have a lot to do with economy, of course.

Journalist.- President, sorry to insist on the Kosovo issue, but, why couldn't Spain wait to the ministerial meeting of the allies in order to talk about this question, after ten years?

And a second question. Yesterday, Minister Kouchner suggested that Spain and other countries were going to send civil guards to Afghanistan in order to train the Afghan safety forces. Could you corroborate this?

And a third question, yesterday, the European People's Party elected Durao Barroso as its candidate for the new commission. Does the Spanish Government agree with this decision?

President.- I agree with Durao Barroso, not with the European People's Party, for these are different things.

I won't tell you anything new because I already expressed my support to the continuity of President Durao Barroso in Madrid, some time ago, for ,he has been a good President as far as Spain's interests are concerned and also from the point of view of the performance of the Commission, in my opinion. This is what I wanted to say.

As for Afghanistan, it is true, France has proposed an initiative, an idea in this sense; but, so far, this is just an idea and, thus, it would be too soon to say whether a common mission is going to be undertaken by several European countries in Afghanistan with the Police or with the Civil Guard to train the Afghan Police. It is too soon and, then, it is also too soon to say whether or not our country would be taking part in it.

As for the first question, I can repeat the same. I think that the General Secretary of the NATO was informed about this decision, as it had to be, as well as the main allies, and I think that we should not assess formal aspects, which have been strictly and rigorously observed, as far as this decision is concerned.

Journalist.- President, a while ago, when you talked about financing, you said that the data published yesterday were rumours, but it was Saura who announced them and they were confirmed by the Ministry of economy: 1,200 million Euros in 2009, 1,600 in 2010 and 2,000 in 2011.

President.- Well, I haven't heard the Vice President and Minister of Economy say so…

Journalist.- He might have been there, but Madrid did not corroborate it.

President.- Yes, yes; I have just seen a newswire: "Moncloa…"

Journalist.- The Ministry of Economy.

President.- I must say that no one has enough power to say whether these will be the figures or not, for we are still taking part in a dialogue process.

Journalist.- Thus, can the figures be improved?

President.- I will not talk about any of the figures published so far, please, because, otherwise this would not be a negotiation process with Catalonia and with the rest of the Autonomous Regions.

Thus, until the Government summons the Council for Fiscal and Financial Policy once the new model is ready - for it will be the basis for sending the reform of the LOFCA (Law on Regional Financing) to the Parliament -, let me just say that all these figures may be an approximation or may prove an interest, but they are not valid. Thus, we will have to wait until the Government summons the Council for Fiscal and Financial Policy, which will not happen until the new Government in Galicia has been constituted, out of institutional respect, of course.

Thus, we will hear different figures over the next few weeks, but…

Journalist.- Afghanistan. You used the fact that Spain is the eighth most powerful country as an argument in order to enter the G-20 and you made it. I would like to know whether - since we are the eighth most powerful country - we should and we can undertake an even deeper commitment with safety in Afghanistan.

President.- Spain - I have explained this on many an occasion - is strongly committed with Afghanistan and this commitment has involved a high cost as far as casualties are concerned, a very high cost. We are committed with Afghanistan, just as we did in Lebanon, just as we did in Kosovo or just as we did in other missions carried out under the auspices of the United Nations, and we are one of the countries that are constantly behaving in an exemplary way as far as commitment is concerned, given our economic and political relevance at an international level; be it in Afghanistan or in anywhere else.

The Ministers of Foreign Affairs are constantly thinking of the situation in Afghanistan and about the most adequate strategies for the future, in order to consolidate stability and the Government in Afghanistan, the democratically elected Government, because there will soon be an election there. And they don't focus on safety only, they also think about politics. And, so far, our contribution has always been highly appreciated and, of course, at a great cost.

Thank you very much.