Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

8 June 2009 · Parliamentary control session (Sesión de control al Gobierno)

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions during a control session in June 2009, addressing Spain's proposed Sustainable Economy Law and the need to shift away from real estate-driven growth.
Main themes
Sustainable economy law, economic model transformation, real estate sector reform, workforce retraining, innovation and technology investment, financial system regulation, education and training, trade deficit, renewable energy, regional cooperation, mortgage reform
Duration
~48 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,772
93rd percentile
Sentences
193
88th percentile
Readability
40
36th percentile
Grade
14.4
71st percentile
Syntax
3.43
91st percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
50th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 42%42%
  • Institutional 24%24%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Geopolitical 10%10%
  • Social 10%10%
  • Environmental 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

193 sentences in 93 paragraphs

Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, it seems that everyone is quite convinced that it is necessary to change the growth model. At the very least, there is an awareness that the party is over and that we must consider whether we want to be in the G-20 on our own merits in a more solid economy.

In the past State of the Nation Debate, you announced a law for a sustainable economy that is to be like the "Big Bang" of the new model, and although you linked it to a fund of twenty billion euros, there is a certain incredulity that a law alone will suffice to change deeply rooted behaviors. One only needs to see how, so far, the measures against the crisis do not herald a new economy. The effects of the four hundred euros and the subsidies to banks, cars, and a myriad of minor municipal works do not seem to be indicative of a productive change.

The lack of examples and specifics on how a law can guide us towards another economy has generated skepticism and distrust, if not ridicule, comparing it to Soviet and Francoist planning.

It seems clear that the structure of the Spanish GDP must align with that of the main European countries where, to begin with, the participation of the real estate sector is much lower. But if it is said "less bricks and more computers," it is to be assumed that there is an intention to transfer part of the workforce from this sector to others with higher added value.

The problem is that the sector that has led the Spanish economic boom, the real estate sector, is not characterized by the training of a large part of its workers. This is a problem that I suppose the Law must address: how to retrain part of this sector towards emerging ones?

In any case, as long as speculation in real estate and the ease of creating urban business are not curtailed, we are ready. Will the Law prevent urban metastases? It does not seem reasonable that a town of one thousand or three thousand inhabitants can sponsor real estate operations of tens of thousands of homes. Will the carpetovetónicos "pelotazos" be eradicated?

We must put an end to the scandalous impact of land value on housing prices. We should dare to consider establishing maximum sale prices on land designated for residential or industrial use.

The Law, therefore, should make it difficult to obtain profits from bricks and facilitate them from computers; but in the last twelve years, construction has accounted for up to 50 percent of all bank credit. It will also be necessary to establish mechanisms to prevent the financial system from accumulating so much credit in a single sector, as well as to end the irrationality of the fact that the value of mortgages is not covered by the value of the property that supports it, and we must abolish the perpetual mortgage chain by establishing a maximum duration of fifteen or twenty years for a mortgage on a first home.

Mr. President, while it is necessary to put obstacles to capital's affection for the real estate sector, public and private investment in science, technology, and innovation must yield returns to be attractive to capital.

The trade deficit is the other great anomaly of the Spanish economy. We must generate patents and exports of high added value. It is true that there are green shoots in the Spanish scientific or technological system, that there are many competitive companies in renewable energy or infrastructure, but all this is still not enough to play in the Champions League. So there will be no choice but to study, because this "let them invent" mentality will have to be repealed if we want an economy led by knowledge, innovation, and renewable energies.

If we want to catch up with Europe in average wages, we will have to agree on a large educational and training program at all levels, from school to university, vocational training, and lifelong learning.

Mr. President, in the 1980s, a painful industrial reconversion had to be undertaken: blast furnaces, mines, and shipyards were sacrificed for the sake of future growth. Now we face a challenge of equal or greater significance. A change in the economic model will require great determination and a significant collective effort.

Transitioning from laying bricks to connecting chips is not easy, as the Mexicans say. It is essential to reach an agreement with employers and unions, but at the same time also with the Autonomous Communities, because many of the decisions will be social and political at the same time, and it would be good to avoid futile disagreements.

Mr. President, from the Catalan Progress Alliance, we have always advocated for a reconversion of the economy. We fully agree that after the crisis, it should not remain the same as the one that led us into it. That is why we announce our willingness to contribute, within our means, to ensure that the Law truly signifies the beginning of economic change. I hope, therefore, that you will provide us with specifics on what the Law will mean for unions, for workers, and for Autonomous Communities; ultimately, for the common citizen.

President.- Mr. Bonet, we share the need to advance in the development of a more sustainable economy in the medium and long term. I largely agree with your analysis. In recent years, we have had, in the vigorous growth of the Spanish economy, an excess of growth based on the real estate sector.

I simply want to introduce a nuance, but it is true that the most innovative sectors, the most productive sectors, to which your Lordship has referred, have also experienced favorable growth that places us in a reasonable potential to ensure that our economy has, in general, a more sustainable growth.

This is why since 2004 we have made an effort to lay the foundations for a change in the growth model; for example, we have tripled public investment in Research, Development, and Innovation; that is why we have boosted clean energies, allocating over 6.3 billion euros in aid to promote renewable energy; that is why we have promoted the Information Society with the Avanza and Avanza 2 Plans, the first of which has mobilized more than nine billion euros and the second has started for the period 2009-2012 with 1.5 billion.

During the last Legislature, this sector, the Communication Technologies sector, grew in our country at rates close to 10 percent annually. Its activity exceeded one hundred billion euros, employing more than 350,000 workers, by the way, with a high percentage of stable employment, which is also the case, at around 80 percent, in employment in the renewable energy sector.

Therefore, it is not by chance, Your Lordship, that companies in our country are at the forefront of European companies that have broadband or that we are leading internationally in renewable energy companies.

We have also made a strong commitment during this time to promote rental housing as an alternative to buying and to the excessive support and fiscal stimulus for home ownership, which has generated excess demand, a real estate bubble, and, moreover, has not facilitated access for citizens, because the price of housing has doubled in the last ten years.

Likewise, we have significantly increased support for protected housing and have launched a Land Law to prevent the multiple urban abuses that are often linked, by the way, to corruption phenomena, as we see day by day.

The international crisis and its impact on Spain have precipitated the adjustment of the real estate sector, generated a significant loss of employment, and now compel us to accelerate the path of reforms for a new growth pattern. This is the Government's proposal, a proposal that seeks to stimulate a high added value economy and greater productivity and dynamism in the emerging sectors that create more jobs, better jobs, and contribute more Gross Domestic Product to the growth of our economy.

We are also going to normalize the real estate sector so that it occupies the place it deserves in this country, no more and no less, and divert part of the resources that have gone to residential housing so that that part of resources is directed to other sectors of the economy. To this end, we are going to launch two financing instruments, stimulus, not dirigisme: financing for companies through a fund of twenty billion euros for investments in sustainable economy projects and another local fund, of five billion euros, so that municipalities can also contribute significantly to stimulating productive activities in the sectors of technology, savings, energy efficiency, environmental renewal, sustainable tourism, etc., etc.

Since the date of the Debate you referred to in your question, we have already approved new initiatives, such as the 2000 E Plan, to boost and renew the automotive sector, or the expansion of the Tourism Renove to promote its reactivation and sustainability, a plan that, by the way, is being a great success. And we are already working on the Sustainable Economy Law, which I announced to the Chamber. At the same time, we are working in social dialogue to facilitate the application of that Law within companies and thus proceed to adapt our business world to what that more sustainable, more innovative, and more productive economy should be.

The Law will focus on the following axes: the adoption of temporary measures to mitigate the effects of the crisis and improve the foundations for recovery, with special attention to improving the protection of the most vulnerable groups affected by unemployment and preventing the loss of the business fabric.

Among the strategic actions that favor a more favorable environment for a sustainable economy, the Law will articulate measures to rationalize the future development of the real estate sector; to promote productivity based on knowledge and innovation; environmental sustainability measures in relation to energy savings and renewable energies, fiscal measures, and budgetary measures; all directed in the same orientation.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Jordi Vilajoana, of the Catalan Parliamentary Group of Convergència i Unió

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Vilajoana.- Mr. President of the Government, after an electoral campaign that some editorials have described as "the worst electoral campaign in democracy, mediocre, obtuse, absurd," or another editorial that said "the most disjointed and absurd campaign that Spain has experienced since the Restoration of 1874," the reality, Mr. President, is that the two major parties, the Popular Party and the PSOE, have continued their particular battle, talking about planes, bodyguards, the Abortion Law, the morning-after pill, possible cases of corruption, and, of course, the elimination of Spanish in Catalonia. All these issues are very far from Europe and we fear that, moreover, they are also very far from the citizens.

On Sunday, 15,760,000 citizens, 46 percent of the census, voted in Spain. The PP, the Popular Party, won the elections with a 3.7 percent increase, with about 600,000 votes ahead. I find it significant, Mr. President, to point out that in Catalonia, participation was the lowest in the history of European elections, at 37.5 percent. The Socialist Party won the elections, losing a little more than 200,000 votes, and Convergència i Unió was the only party that gained votes; specifically, 62,000.

Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, you argued on Sunday that the possible electoral outcome was linked to the economic crisis situation. The reality, Mr. President, is also that Sarkozy and Merkel are presiding over countries with a very complex economic situation, and they have won the elections.

The Popular Group asserts itself as the first force in the new Europarliament; the Socialist Group, the socialist family, loses about sixty deputies; the group, let’s say, of the non-attached grows to triple with far-right euro-skeptics and radical leftists; ecologists grow and liberals drop a bit.

With the exception of the statements by the Secretary of Organization, Mrs. Leire Pajín, on June 3, where she spoke of a planetary historic moment that we did not know exactly what she was referring to, we finally discovered that this fact was that you presided over Europe and Obama presided, as always, over the United States, in the campaign no one has said what the priorities of the President of the Government, of you, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, will be before the upcoming European Presidency in the first half of 2010, and that is why I ask you today: in light of the results of this Sunday’s elections and the composition of this Chamber, what will be your Government's priorities?

President.- Allow me to say, Mr. Vilajoana, that I am surprised by your question because the objective is the Spanish Presidency of the European Union, to which you have dedicated exactly the last five seconds of your introduction. I have seen that you have echoed what you criticized, because you have made a whole account of campaign issues to then make an assessment, which I respect, and an analysis of the elections.

But I imagine that what truly interests Your Honor is the subject of the question, the Spanish Presidency of the European Union, to which I have referred, and in respect to that superior interest that I assume you have, I will focus on my question.

As you know, the first priority of the Spanish Presidency must be, if the Lisbon Treaty is ratified, the implementation of the new institutional framework of the European Union, which will require a great effort to make the European Union a more effective, more agile institution that, among other things, stimulates citizen participation in the elections to the European Parliament, a Parliament that will gain much power in the new institutional framework.

Secondly, the Spanish Presidency will work to find, in concert with all Governments, new proposals aimed at economic recovery, which we hope will have a clear horizon in the first half of 2010 across the European Union and also in Spain.

I believe this is the great priority of the Union. The first, as the Spanish Presidency, in any case, is an obligation to manage the entry into force of the Lisbon Treaty and to put its functioning into operation; the second great priority is economic recovery.

Therefore, within this section of economic recovery, it is of great importance that, under the Spanish Presidency, the renewal of the well-known Lisbon Strategy has been anticipated, which will give significant content to everything that affects innovation, knowledge, and social Europe to face and stimulate recovery.

Thirdly, we value as one of our great objectives of the Presidency of the Union that the European Union plays a relevant role on the international stage. To this end, it will pay special attention to the different Summits that will be held during the semester and that will highlight the global weight of the European Union and its priority objectives.

There are three fundamental Summits: the Transatlantic Summit, which will undoubtedly deepen relations with the United States of America; the Summit with Latin America, which will represent a special recognition for a region to which a shared history and culture bind us so deeply and which can have special relevance during this period, because we are in a position to make definitive progress towards achieving some of the association agreements between regions of Latin America and the European Union that, as Your Honor knows, have been negotiated for some time; and the third Summit is the Summit with neighboring Mediterranean countries, to which Spain gives priority attention, of which the recent decision regarding the location of the Secretariat in the city of Barcelona is the best example.

It seems reasonable that, under the Spanish Presidency of the European Union, the gaze to the South of our borders is a priority gaze and that the Mediterranean area occupies a central place for the development of what is the Mediterranean Union and, of course, of the Secretariat's headquarters in the city of Barcelona.

In addition, Spain will pay special attention to the social effects of the process of community integration and to the renewal of a social policy that complements an activity of the European Union, which is often seen as a Union more concerned with the single market, more focused only on economic integration, than on social issues. To this end, we will work intensively to ensure success at the tripartite social Summit, which we hope will strengthen the role of employers and trade unions throughout the Union, and which we appreciate as an essential instrument in social dialogue.

Likewise, we will give priority attention to initiatives aimed at incorporating into the community acquis all kinds of policies aimed at making the principle of equality of citizens within the European Union effective.

In short, we have an intense and ambitious agenda for the Spanish Presidency of the Union. It will be an active Presidency, with political content and decisions, with a clear European and pro-European identity. And I am fully convinced that your political group and all political groups will work to ensure that the Spanish Presidency of the European Union, which will begin on January 1, 2010, is a great success.

Mr. Vilajoana.- Mr. President, I spoke to you about elections because in my question these priorities were clearly stated, but I mentioned this within the context of the elections last Sunday, of the results obtained. Why? Because this positioned a new Parliament. You have every right not to make an assessment of these elections; you are within your rights. I believe you did, and I think this was part of the question I was asking you.

Regarding these priorities, we clearly share many aspects that you have raised. We also believe in our Group that strengthening Europe is one of the great priorities we have, and these elections demonstrate the need to strengthen this Europe, which generates general disinterest across Europe. In Catalonia, we voted 37 percent, but Great Britain also voted 37 percent, as did the Netherlands and others... Therefore, we have a clear need to strengthen this Europe.

We are in total agreement, and in this Chamber, we have often spoken with you about the economic crisis, that it is another great priority for Europe.

And then I thank you very much for this Mediterranean outlook. I believe this is fundamental; that is to say, in Europe we must build Europe, but, evidently, we must defend local interests, and I understand that the Mediterranean is our great interest. We believe that in this new economy, this new economic model that you propose, Mr. President, the Mediterranean must be a great protagonist. The Mediterranean should be somewhat the beach where this great production, which will come from Asia, arrives.

And here, Mr. President, which is where I wanted to emphasize more, we need something that was indeed discussed during the campaign and to which you have somehow committed: to generate the Mediterranean Corridor. In this Corridor is 40 percent of the Spanish GDP. What do we need? We have great ports in this Mediterranean area: in Valencia, in Barcelona, and in Tarragona. What do we need? Trains, railways, so that these products that arrive at the ports can be placed in Europe. And here this railway, which starts in Algeciras and ends in Hamburg, passing through Málaga, Murcia, Alicante, Valencia, Barcelona, the border, and Montpellier, is essential. And I would like, Mr. President, for you to commit again to this fact.

Second topic, very important. You, in 2004, and I know there will be people here... even some representative of the Popular Group has said that what I am about to say now is nonsense; I will say this nonsense, in the investiture session, you committed to Esquerra Republicana to defend Catalan in Europe. You have done it, it has improved, we are in Europe, but we are not at the level we would like to be.

We, and those of us who have Catalan as our mother tongue, consider that Catalan is a language spoken by ten million Europeans, and what we simply seek is for Catalan to have the same strength as Gaelic, which is spoken by seventy thousand; Maltese, which is spoken by two hundred thousand; or Norwegian, or Danish, etc.

I would ask you, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, seriously, that this be another topic to put on your agenda and that somehow it be possible to advance in a field, I repeat, that some people consider nonsense, but there are people who consider this important.

That said, you have raised topics on which we would stand by your side, and you know this well, but we understand that this Presidency must be a double opportunity for two very important aspects: one, to reinforce this Europe, which really did not come out sufficiently reinforced in these elections; and, in addition, also to defend these local interests, which are legitimate, as the Danes do or as the French do, which is to defend this new economy that we must build, in which we understand that the Mediterranean must be the great protagonist.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Vilajoana, for the specificity of the topics that seem to awaken more interest from Your Honor.

I appreciate that there is recognition of what the strategy regarding the Mediterranean means as a priority, the gaze to the South of the European Union under the Spanish Presidency. It is the result of a whole project and a coherent policy that has led us to achieve that the Secretariat for the Mediterranean is located in Barcelona. Moreover, I know that this brings you special satisfaction, no less than that which it brings me, I can assure you openly. It therefore responds to a coherent policy.

Secondly, you refer to Catalan. For me, it is evident, and I do not know if for any member of this Chamber, it is not a minor issue. In coherence with this, I must also remind you that the Government I preside opened the door for Catalan, like the other co-official languages, to be used and utilized in European institutions. There have been various agreements with European institutions; this co-official language has already been used in Councils of Ministers, and we have advanced as far as we could in negotiations with European institutions. It has been an important step.

However, any initiative you come up with or any proposal, within the framework of the governance of the European Union, we are willing to study.

Thirdly, I reiterate the Government's commitment: under the Spanish Presidency of the European Union, the Mediterranean Corridor, which is a great priority, will be incorporated into the priority European networks for economic development, of course also for this area.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Pío García-Escudero, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. García-Escudero.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, blessed are the eyes that see you.

You are not going to make an assessment of the elections today, but I will, because it would not be understood otherwise when only forty-eight hours have passed. And I will also talk at length about my question.

Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, the result the other day shows that you have lost the trust of the Spanish people; I have told you this many times, but it was confirmed the other day. And the loss of more than seven points compared to the Popular Party since the last general elections, in just over a year, is the price you have had to pay when you were misleading then by saying that we were heading towards full employment and that, moreover, there was no crisis in Spain.

Your poor management of the crisis, the more than four million unemployed, the closure of thousands of companies, and the uncontrolled increase in public spending have caused you to lose the elections. And it is not valid to say, and they have already told you, that in these elections it was taken advantage of to punish Governments across Europe due to the economic crisis. In Germany and France, where center-right governs, it has not been so; in Great Britain, Portugal, and Spain, where socialists govern, it has been so. And acknowledge that socialism failed last Sunday across Europe.

If I were you, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, I would engage in a reflection exercise and practice humility. I would acknowledge the failure of your economic policy and address, without further delay, a whole process of reforms: in education, in the labor market, in fiscal policy, in the productive system, in the energy model... Because that is the message that the Spanish people transmitted to you last Sunday, and that is the message you should heed.

But life goes on, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, and you will have heard about the energy model. You know, as I do, that energy is an essential element for our economic development; you know, as I do, that today in Spain we have an energy model that is not perfect; that we have a worrying external dependency rate of 81 percent, when the European average is 53 percent; that what we import—oil, gas, coal—besides being expensive, is polluting. And that, despite the 9.25 percent drop in the last year due to the economic crisis, electricity demand in Spain has grown by 90 percent since 1995, well above the pace of the rest of Europe and, of course, well above the real growth of our economy. And this, and you know or should know, dangerously harms our competitiveness.

Spain today faces an energy challenge that is crucial for our future, a triple challenge: first, to ensure the necessary energy supply for our growth expectations, reducing that great external dependency we have and promoting domestic sources; second, to substantially improve energy savings and efficiency to enhance our competitiveness; and third, to advance towards a sustainable energy model in environmental and economic terms, that is, to diversify, reduce CO2 emissions, and ensure that we have competitive costs.

Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, the reform of the energy model is essential to avoid strangling our development and, moreover, it can serve to partially reactivate our economy, which is currently mired in a deep crisis. All of this would justify that all political groups and social and economic agents come together to define as soon as possible what our energy model should be for the coming decades. For this, work is being done in Congress, at the proposal of our Group and supported by the entire Chamber, in a study subcommittee, because we, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, believe that this is the right path and that ambiguity, indefiniteness, or ideological simplifications are the least suitable for addressing this issue.

That is why the ceremony of confusion regarding the future of the Santa María de Garoña plant, which is being dedicated by your Government and your party, is not understood. Prominent members of your party in recent days have spoken in favor of closing the plant, and prominent members of your party in recent days have spoken in favor of the plant's continuity; your Group in Congress has voted against the closure, but, however, your party in the Basque Country is calling for the closure of the plant, and a socialist foundation has just issued a report stating that they want the closure of all nuclear plants.

That is not serious, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero. We are talking about a sector that is strategic and a debate that requires a minimum of intellectual rigor and not outdated ideological speeches typical of the 1970s.

The question should be whether Garoña and the other plants currently in operation meet the technical and safety conditions to continue operating. And if the Nuclear Safety Council has said that Garoña does meet them, it is not understood why anyone would flirt with the possible idea of closing it.

That is why it is so important, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, that today you, as President of the Government, clear up doubts and uncertainties; that you clarify what the future of the Santa María de Garoña plant will be and that you are consistent, because it makes no sense that we are importing energy from France, 78 percent of which is nuclear, and that the energy we are buying is being produced in a nuclear plant that is less than a hundred kilometers from the Pyrenees.

That is why it is not understood, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, that what turns out to be good for the United States, for Great Britain, for Germany, or for France can be bad for Spain. Spain is currently at the tail end of Europe in meeting the commitments of Kyoto, and it would be very difficult to approach those objectives if we close Garoña today and in the future close the rest of the nuclear plants.

Tell me, could we afford an even higher electricity bill if we close plants that in Spain are producing only 18 percent of our electricity?

I believe that, for this reason, it would be sensible to address the issue from the perspective of technical and safety requirements, rather than engaging in easy politics for the gallery. And this commitment, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, is perfectly compatible with renewable energies, and this commitment, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, must be realistic and possible, because we cannot ask renewables for more than they can provide. It is just as unsustainable to disregard the green as it is to try to paint everything green.

Nuclear energy and renewables are perfectly compatible, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero; the rest are artificial rhetorics. Not to mention, your admired Obama advocates for renewables, but also states that nuclear energy is essential. Proof of this is that he has just authorized the extension of the life of two nuclear plants that are in exactly the same situation as Santa María de Garoña.

That is why, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, the decision must be under what conditions we are willing to accept nuclear energy and in an energy model that is viable and balanced. Global considerations and energy considerations must take precedence over ideological debates, and objective data over irrational clichés.

If that is the case, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, you will find us there to reach a state agreement and to address the necessary reforms, because our economic development over the next thirty years is at stake and we cannot continue to delay it.

Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, are you going to close the Santa María de Garoña plant?

President.- Mr. García-Escudero, I am also glad to see you; moreover, to see you where you are sitting. I say this because I hope that the elections on Sunday do not create an illusion. The only evident thing is that you are still sitting where you are. I want to say this so that we have things clear.

Then, I am surprised that you speak of the elections, which you have won, in such a sour tone. It seems that even when you win, you are not happy, which causes me a certain perplexity.

The difference, Mr. García-Escudero, since you have brought up this topic, is that we, when the results are not very good, good, or regular, whatever they may be, always accept them very well; we do not look for excuses from our rivals. I say this because the precedents are notable. In any case, I hope you enjoy the results.

Regarding the specific question, the Socialist Party ran in the last elections with a commitment regarding energy: on the one hand, to ensure the sufficiency of supply, as is logical, and, secondly, to opt for an energy model based on savings, environmental protection, and the promotion of renewable and clean energies. This fundamental commitment was accompanied by another equally clear one regarding nuclear energy: the orderly closure of plants as they reach the end of their useful life, as long as the sufficiency of supply to citizens and businesses is guaranteed. This is what the electoral program of the Socialist Party states, with which we obtained the majority support.

Regarding Garoña, its useful life cycle has been fulfilled, in principle; it will be fulfilled in two years, to be more precise: in 2011, the forty years for which it was designed. This fact paves the way to decide on its future in the terms I have referred to, and we will do so. This is the position of the Socialist Party and this is the position of the Government.

My first commitment is to fulfill, whenever possible, logically, the commitments made to citizens, in this and in all cases; but I also always defend that democracy is respect for procedures, and there is one provided for in our regulations, in our legal system. In nuclear matters, the Nuclear Safety Council has been entrusted with certain functions for these cases, which it has fulfilled in recent days, as is known.

As you will know, last Friday the Council sent a report on the Santa María de Garoña nuclear plant, a report that addresses the request for renewal of the operating authorization of the nuclear plant for the period 2009-2019. A ten-year extension has been requested.

Once received, the Government has one month to analyze it and pronounce on it. The Government has already begun that analysis and will pronounce motivatedly, as is logical, in a timely manner and without delaying its decision for any reason unrelated; that is, before July 5, which is when we are legally required to do so. And it will take into account the following variables for its pronouncement:

First of all, obviously, the safety of the nuclear plant, and even more so considering that it is a so-called "first generation" plant, which began construction in the 1960s. It will undoubtedly be necessary to consider in this regard the technical considerations of the Nuclear Safety Council's report on the current state of the plant and on the conditions for a possible renewal of its operation.

Second, the security of energy supply, taking into account what Garoña contributes to the overall electrical system, which, for your Lordships to know, is exactly 1.4 percent of the total electricity in our country. Therefore, the objective is to guarantee the supply of electrical energy to citizens.

And the third criterion, the general criterion of support for so-called clean and less costly energies as an alternative to nuclear plants that reach the end of their useful life.

With these criteria, and respecting the procedure that logically must be followed, the Government will pronounce itself while seeking to maintain its electoral commitment, its programmatic and investiture commitment, as I have just referred to.

Thank you very much.