Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

24 May 2010 · Parliamentary control session (Sesión de control al Gobierno)

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions on the functioning of Spain's State of Autonomies amid the 2010 economic crisis during a congressional control session.
Main themes
State of Autonomies reform, economic crisis response, fiscal deficit reduction, decentralization and cooperation, autonomous communities competencies, public spending management, labor and financial reform, savings banks reform, welfare state sustainability, political class credibility, territorial model of Spain
Duration
~48 min
94th percentile
Words
5,796
94th percentile
Sentences
180
86th percentile
Readability
36
28th percentile
Grade
15.6
80th percentile
Syntax
3.57
96th percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
52nd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 50%50%
  • Economic 22%22%
  • Ceremonial 15%15%
  • Social 11%11%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

180 sentences in 90 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. José María Mur, of the Mixed Parliamentary Group

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Mur.- Now that it seems we have all accepted that we are in crisis, fundamentally economic, although in my opinion not only economic, we are concerned about the consequences of this crisis: unemployment, public deficit in all Administrations, the crisis of confidence abroad and in the markets, difficulties in the financial system, the low valuation of the political class and the Administrations, etc., etc.

But I believe it would be good for us to now investigate not only the consequences but also the causes that have brought us here, because otherwise we run the risk of placing all the blame on the institutions, on politicians, and, of course, on the State of Autonomies.

Some of us, Mr. President, are very concerned about the critical climate towards the territorial model of Spain. It is as if a new centralism, which arises not only from Madrid, is going to solve all the problems we have in this country. It is true, and let us accept that not everything has been done well, that there have been excesses, dysfunctions, duplicities, and inefficiencies. It is not possible, for example, Mr. President, that there are more ministries now, in a decentralized State, than when the State was openly centralist.

We read and hear criticisms every day such as "how are we going to solve the problem with regulatory dispersion, market fragmentation, the gigantism of the Administrations with more than three million civil servants, little effectiveness, excessive cost, lack of competitiveness in a globalized world...". And you, Mr. President of the Government, are the President of a very decentralized State and must take measures; in fact, you are continuously taking them.

But to the intrinsic difficulties of these measures, we must add that in this complex State, whose Government you preside over, the execution of the most important spending policies, the production of goods and services, and the welfare state policies such as education, health, and dependency, must be executed by the Autonomous Communities. They have been transferred, Mr. President.

And you must immediately address issues such as labor reform; financial reform, especially regarding Savings Banks, with their impact on the Autonomous Communities; controlling the deficit in all Public Administrations; increasing production and improving competitiveness; reforming education and justice, etc. Many issues that you must address without delay.

That is why I wanted to know what measures you believe, what reforms, need to be made for the State of Autonomies to function in this crisis situation.

President.- I will try to be as concrete as possible, because it is true that in your initial intervention you have raised a number of very broad topics that exceed the possibilities of what a parliamentary question is.

I will tell you that the State of Autonomies has played an extraordinarily positive role in the consolidation of democracy, in self-government, in political decentralization, and ultimately, in bringing the management of public services closer to citizens and also in recognizing the plurality of our country.

I believe we have reached a high degree of self-government, we have reasonably developed the model of autonomous financing, and we have opened a path, which needs to be completed, of cooperation and participation of the Autonomous Communities in the overall state tasks.

That is to say, we have completed the phase of self-government and we must enter a phase of cooperation so that the entire system and model functions much better; certainly, in all areas that have to do, of course, with the management of public resources, with public spending, as the majority of public spending in this country is in the hands of the Autonomous Communities, while the Government of Spain and these Chambers have fundamental competencies for the regulation of the economy, for the approval of the Budgets, and therefore, for the good health of public accounts.

I express my conviction that both the Autonomous Communities and Local Corporations currently have an attitude of loyal cooperation for that objective, which is fundamental in overcoming the crisis, the serious economic crisis, which is the reduction of the deficit, the cleaning up of our public accounts, which helps and contributes to recovery and sustainable economic growth. This has been the case in the Fiscal and Financial Policy Council; I hope it will be in the next Fiscal and Financial Policy Council that we will have to apply the measures that the Government decided last week, and it is also the case in those budget adjustment measures, in the reduction of expenses, that the Government has promoted, which we have seen today that the Town Halls have also decided to extend to Local Corporations; that they will do and are doing, without a doubt, the Autonomous Communities, and, of course, also the entire set of Administrations.

In short, we have completed a phase of self-government, a phase of autonomous financing, and we need to walk a path in favor of cooperation, participation, and co-responsibility in all public affairs.

Mr. Mur.- Mr. President of the Government, for a convinced person, like this senator speaking to you, of the correctness of the autonomous model and the positive nature of the experience of the last thirty years, it is concerning that, due to the new realities that have occurred in Spanish society, integration into Europe, and the new economic model that will arise from the crisis, we are unable to consolidate the State of Autonomies.

Therefore, it is possible that we need to reflect while we act. That was the reason that led this senator last year, specifically on June 9, 2009, to present an interpellation to the Government, addressed by the Third Vice President and Minister of Territorial Policy, on the deepening and development of the State of Autonomies; a year ago. From that interpellation arose a motion, which was amended by all the Groups in this Chamber, with great collaboration, which I greatly appreciated, and was approved by consensus; a motion, Mr. President, which, almost certainly, as happens with all, has not gone beyond the text of the Senate Bulletin, has it? Because it has practically not been fulfilled at all. It is not that a motion will solve things, but you know that in politics, foresight and anticipation are fundamental.

We must anticipate events and have forecasts made for when the moment arrives, because our autonomous system, Mr. President, and you know it is not simple; it requires multiple balances and good legal engineering. It cannot be improvised. A culture of power is also needed that involves respect for diversity and acceptance of unity, and loyalty and collaboration between institutions. Cooperation and coordination between the Autonomous Communities and the Government of Spain. This is a plural State and this is a complex State. The model we practice from Aragón can be, to some extent, an example.

Therefore, Mr. President, you have instruments to address the problems; what I do not know is whether you will have time. That is why you should take advantage of this Chamber, take advantage of this Senate, to make a good diagnosis of reality, with calmness, with rigor, and with the collaboration of all. Promote here a pact among all political forces and public institutions, both central and autonomous. This is the house of the territories and the Autonomous Communities. A pact with the Presidents of the Autonomous Communities, with all the Presidents of the Autonomous Communities, who are the legitimate representatives of territorial power.

Others have done it, even in federal States. You know that the German federal State has made far-reaching reforms, even constitutional reforms that were unthinkable a few years ago.

Mr. President, I wish you good luck and I hope you get to the root of the problems because, otherwise, they will not be solved and it may be too late next year.

President.- Thank you, Mr. Mur. Of course, I appreciate your idea and your suggestion, which aligns with one of the lines of work I have tried to maintain in these years, which is to call for participation and co-responsibility. That is why I launched the Conference of Presidents, which we have held in the Senate; an institution that for the first time has been put into operation in our country, which should serve as a space for major agreements, for collaboration and for cooperation, which has had results in matters of immigration and health, and which I would have liked to have had more results; undoubtedly.

The horizon we have ahead of us, the hard and difficult task we have ahead of us, especially in overcoming the crisis and in what affects the reduction of public spending, will require great collaboration and great cooperation. It would be very positive and very favorable for there to be major political agreements around that idea in this Chamber and among all political forces. I think it is an absolutely necessary idea and, of course, the Government will work for it with all its might.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Pío García-Escudero, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. García-Escudero.- Why does the President of the Government claim that his announced social cuts will guarantee a more solid growth?

President.- Mr. García-Escudero, it is not only the President of the Government who claims this. All international organizations and all the Governments of the euro area assert that it is essential to advance --that is the decision we made at the beginning of May-- the reduction of the public deficit so that in the future, in the medium term, the growth of the economies of the euro area, of Europe in general, and of course of Spain, is a more solid and sustainable growth. It is a conclusion accepted by all Governments and by international organizations, and in that endeavor, all the Governments of the euro area are engaged because, as you well know, twenty-five out of twenty-seven countries have an excessive deficit, some more than others, logically, and we are committed and obliged to reduce that deficit.

Mr. García-Escudero.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, where is the one who five months ago was going to teach Europe how to get out of the crisis? Where is the great protector of social rights? Where is the great benefactor of pensioners, the one from Rodiezmo? Where is the one who would never raise civil servants' salaries, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero? Where do your ideological reasons stand, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero? Because I am looking at you and I do not recognize you.

Who is this Rodríguez Zapatero now who, with the fury of a convert, announces a cut in civil servants' salaries and a freeze on pensions through a "decretazo" that is the largest cut of social rights in the history of democracy?

Because here, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, there must be a political impostor: either the Rodríguez Zapatero of before or the Rodríguez Zapatero of now. Probably, it is the Rodríguez Zapatero of now, the one who with a funeral face asks for sacrifices but does not ask for forgiveness.

Because, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, the five million unemployed, the civil servants, the pensioners, the families, the SMEs, is nobody in Spain making sacrifices? Because, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, the fact that today we are the greatest concern for the euro and for Europe; that today we are a country shamefully tutored and subjected to the surveillance of the IMF and Europe; that today we are a country that leads unemployment in the world, although, according to you, the bars are full and the unemployed drive BMWs; that today we have a deficit that is alarming; that today it costs us more and more money to place the debt; of all this, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, the only responsible and the only guilty one is you.

Your "decretazo" is the consequence of your continuous and costly improvisations, contradictions, rectifications, and whims. And you have said it, not long ago: the latest, that of the Town Halls today. But your "decretazo" is also the consequence of your lack of courage to tackle the structural reforms that our country has needed for a long time, because they have been essential for a long time.

Today you have been reduced to a scapegoat, overwhelmed by the situation, forced to hastily adopt all the impositions that come from the European Union and from Obama, on one side, and those that come from your party and the unions, on the other.

Have you thought, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, that just by not having done the famous Plan E, you would have saved sixteen billion euros and that today this "zapaterazo" would have been unnecessary?

How are you going to explain to civil servants, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, that you are going to cut their salaries while maintaining five useless ministries and hundreds of advisors, who are perfectly dispensable? How are you going to explain to pensioners that you are going to freeze their pensions while increasing subsidies to the unions?

And now you come with the latest improvisation to satisfy the congregation, which is the tax increase on the richest, when everyone knows that a tax increase will burden the middle classes and savings, because you do not dare to raise taxes on the richest. And on July 1, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, there will be a new increase in electricity prices and an increase in VAT; for everyone, not for the richest.

Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, what have you done in the last two weeks? A horse therapy without anesthesia for the weakest. For what? To achieve what? More crisis and more unemployment after the summer. Because you have not yet presented, and time is passing, a single useful measure to stimulate the economy and create jobs.

Do you believe, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, that with so much improvisation you will earn the trust of the International Monetary Fund and Europe? Do you think that this will stop the feeling of insecurity that currently exists in Spain? What can outsiders think about the future of our economy when it turns out that the two largest items in the Budget, amounting to eighty billion euros, are allocated to pay unemployment benefits and to pay interest on the debt? This way, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, you cannot grow; this way, you cannot create jobs, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero.

What can outsiders think of a government, the most expensive in Europe, that is mired in absolute schizophrenia, where its President dedicates himself to disavowing the First Vice President with the salary cut for civil servants and the Second Vice President with the tax increase?

Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, in just two weeks you have liquidated the Toledo Pact, the Public Function Table, the Stability Law for Pensions, and the Dependency Law, and you have once again demonstrated that you are incapable, absolutely incapable, of rigorously facing the seriousness of a situation that is dramatic, according to Mr. Campa, or catastrophic, according to Mr. Blanco.

You have had to suffer the embarrassment of having to retract what has been your demagogic discourse for six years.

Today, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, you and your government are absolutely incapable of promoting and managing the structural reforms that Spain needs. Today you and your government are only offering the image of a boxer who is groggy and throwing punches in the air.

Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, you are no longer in a position to lead anything. You have already more than demonstrated your incapacity. This legislature, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, is as exhausted as you and your government. Stop being an obstacle to getting out of the crisis and, if you have any political dignity left, immediately call for elections so that the Spanish people can decide about their future.

President.- Mr. García-Escudero, I appreciate your constructive intervention. It has been a true exercise of responsibility towards a country for a group that aspires to govern Spain again.

I will tell you: I do recognize you, I recognize you perfectly. It is the same policy every day for several years: "no," "never," "ever," to anything that could be positive, responsible, and constructive for our country. "No," "never," "ever."

Allow me, since you have evoked Rodiezmo and social policy, to tell you something. From 2004 to today, social spending in Spain has increased by 50 percent under the government I preside over, and the reduction affecting social items in the Royal Decree Law we have approved represents 1.5 percent of the total social spending led by the government and 0.5 percent of the total social spending in the country.

It is true that "no," "never," "ever," not even to listen, which is the first condition of a democrat; the first, as the group listens to your intervention respectfully.

I will tell you that, to talk about social policy, this group and the government I preside over feel fully legitimate to talk about pensions, because with this government, minimum pensions, which is the most equitable policy, have increased by 49 percent in the last five years, which is the largest increase in the entire period of democracy in Spain, making an unprecedented effort of solidarity with very low pensions. But you, in eight years, in a time of prosperity, made it so that minimum pensions in this country did not gain a single euro of purchasing power; and with us, a 25 percent increase.

Social policy is remembering and being sensitive to those who have the least income and the least wealth in our country, for example, those who earn the Minimum Interprofessional Wage, which has seen an increase of 37 percent under this government, while during your eight years in government, the Minimum Interprofessional Wage was frozen without any gain in purchasing power.

Social policy is having the commitment, responsibility, and decision to create a Dependency Law that aims to support and help people who cannot fend for themselves, who have more problems. And to make a reduction or rationalization of spending on dependency, which amounts to four billion euros, of which two billion are from the central government, zero when we came to power, and a Dependency Law; to make a rationalization, there first has to be a Dependency Law that this government has created for the first time to extend a decisive social policy.

Social policy is generating equality of opportunities and, therefore, under our government, scholarships in our country have seen how the resources we allocate to equality of opportunities have doubled, how the income to qualify for a scholarship has improved, and some of them have multiplied by ten.

Social policy is assuming the commitment and responsibility, as this government has done, to give priority support to those who suffer the most from the consequences in a situation of serious economic crisis, like the one we have, such as the unemployed. That is why we have extended unemployment protection to reach 80 percent of the unemployed with a benefit and have established a new unemployment benefit of 426 euros for those who are without benefits for six months.

Social policy is making a policy to promote public housing, which we have increased by 50 percent, and establishing assistance to young people, a basic income for emancipation for their rent, which benefits two hundred thousand young people with two hundred euros a month. That is social policy.

And social policy is providing the Autonomous Communities with more resources for the management of health care, and between the agreement of 2005 in the Conference of Presidents and the agreement of the new financing model, we have put in the hands of the Autonomous Communities fifteen billion euros more for the management of public health care, which is one of the great bastions of the Welfare State that we want to preserve, that we want to develop and improve.

Therefore, ladies and gentlemen, that is social policy. A 50 percent increase in social spending and now, a reduction of 1.5 percent; that is it.

And we have, as I was saying, to make an effort now to reduce the deficit to return to having sustainable economic growth. All, absolutely all, European governments are doing it, and the only party, and this is indeed the exception in this serious crisis, that belongs to the political family to which you belong throughout Europe that opposes and is criticizing the reduction of the deficit is the Popular Party of Spain. The only party, due to its lack of responsibility.

And, if there was any doubt left --I appreciate your sincerity--, you made it very clear in the final part of your intervention: you are not concerned about the crisis, nor unemployment, nor the future of Spain; you are concerned about the elections. You said it: you are concerned about the elections. That is what worries you: the elections. The conclusion of your question.

And I will tell you one thing: you lost in 2004, you lost in 2008, and you will lose the next general elections.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Joseba Zubía, of the Parliamentary Group of Nationalist Senators

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Zubía.- Mr. President, in this calm procedure in which we find ourselves, although you may not believe it, this time it is not about statutory development and pending transfers to Euskadi; it does relate to statutory clauses, but the topic is quite different.

As you know, as of today, there is a Bill in full parliamentary procedure in this Chamber that modifies the Law on Auditing Accounts, the Law on the Securities Market, and the consolidated text of the Law on Public Limited Companies for its adaptation to community regulations; a Bill with a very specific objective and a perfectly defined content that, with the text sent by the Government in view, nothing suggested that it could cause excessive turbulence.

However, an amendment presented by the Socialist Parliamentary Group in Congress ultimately allowed for the incorporation in that Chamber, in the fifth final provision, of a modification of section 2 of article 105 of the consolidated text of the Law on Public Limited Companies; a modification that has nothing to do with the objective and content of the Bill, but that also alters the regulation and the applicable regime in a matter that is not precisely minor or peaceful.

We are talking, Mr. President, of nothing less than the elimination of statutory clauses limiting the maximum votes to be cast in listed companies, something that I would like to know what relation it has with the activity of auditing accounts and auditors, but that sneaks in and your Parliamentary Group in Congress has tried to justify it by solemnly stating that such elimination has long been a persistent demand, both from the majority commercial doctrine and from corporate practice.

As such an argument, no matter how emphatically it is stated, does not correspond at all with reality, and I do not find the scant contributions that your Lordships have made on this matter sufficient, as they have merely pointed out that this is a commitment of the Socialist Party's electoral program, which is why I take the liberty of asking you this question: what are the reasons, the authentic, the true ones, that have led your government to bet on and defend the modification of section 2 of article 105 of the consolidated text of the Law on Public Limited Companies?

President.- Mr. Zubía, the true reasons why the government has promoted the elimination of the protections in listed companies are those that appear in the electoral program with which the Socialist Party ran in the general elections of March 2008. Specifically, in point 1.8 of our electoral program, it could be read: "our commitments in corporate governance are aimed at enhancing the role of the General Meeting and greater protection for small shareholders. To this end, we socialists commit to eliminating statutory restrictions on the exercise of voting rights."

The protection that is now intended to be eliminated was introduced into our law, as Mr. Zubía will well remember, in the 1950s; but the significant changes that have occurred in the management of companies, in capital markets, and in the globalization of the economy have rendered it simply obsolete.

And these are, specifically, the reasons that advise the reform: one, to make our capital market more attractive by recovering the proportionality between the committed investment and voting rights, which seems quite reasonable; to introduce greater economic logic in the relationships between shareholders, as protections constitute an exception to the rule of one share-one vote, restrict the rights of effective investors, and, of course, are a factor that does not stimulate investment in listed companies; to reinforce the property rights and equal treatment of all shareholders; to eliminate contradictions in our law, such as the coexistence of these protections with the more recent regulations that call for active participation in voting by collective investment institutions, and to provide greater coherence to the rules on the exercise of voting, as there is no justification for company executives to accumulate unlimited votes by delegation while the voting rights of investors in the same company are restricted.

This cannot be sustained, Mr. Zubía, objectively, and we know that it happens and we know that it has consequences in many aspects: in the management of the company, in the capacity for opening a company, etc., etc.

Furthermore, the adopted reform aligns with a modernizing movement of Company Law that seeks to increase the legitimacy of managers in listed companies; managers who, in all areas, especially in this stage in financial companies, see that there is a process of regulation and a process of greater control because, in the end, they bear the great responsibility for the future of a company. And it responds, both to the position of a good part of the commercial doctrine and to the recommendations of the Unified Code of Good Governance of listed companies from 2006.

In short, Your Honor, it is up to governments to update and promote the improvement of economic regulation and create more favorable and equitable conditions to attract investors. That is what we have done by removing the restrictions on voting rights in listed companies, in addition to fulfilling an electoral commitment.

Mr. Zubía.- Mr. President, let us take this step by step. Your Honor must know that the limitations on voting rights were born as defensive and statutory measures against hostile takeovers, and that a second function they serve is to protect minority shareholders from de facto control acquisitions without a takeover bid.

There are flagrant cases — I will not name names — in which, formally, without reaching the thresholds required to formulate a takeover bid, control is obtained through selective purchases; but, since there is no takeover bid, the rest of the shareholders receive no benefit and, in fact, are subjected to a new controller.

That said, Mr. President, it is also necessary to make it clear that there is no Community Directive that establishes or even simply recommends the removal of such voting limitations. The Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council of April 21, 2004, concerning takeover bids, even in a limiting case such as a takeover bid, establishes an optional regime, under which the listed companies themselves, by agreement of their General Meeting, can decide whether to neutralize — this is the technical term used — that is, render ineffective, among others, the restrictions on voting rights provided for in their statutes. In short, it is left to the company's option.

To this end, in 2007, the Securities Market Law was amended by introducing Article 60 ter, titled "Optional Neutralization Measures," in which the indicated criterion is applied; that is, it will be the General Meeting of Shareholders that decides whether to render it ineffective or not.

On the other hand, most European countries apply this regime, and only Germany and Italy have excluded limitations on voting rights. Therefore, it is difficult to argue that this is a norm that advances in that direction in the majority of commercial legal systems.

Moreover, with the exclusion that is now being proposed, it is forgotten that the commission appointed by the Ministry of Justice to draft the preliminary draft of the consolidated text of the Capital Companies Act last January, just four months ago, delivered its text and, specifically, in Article 188.4 it states that "in the public limited company, the statutes may generally set the maximum number of votes that a single shareholder or companies belonging to the same group may cast"; that is, the possibility of establishing such limitations is maintained.

Furthermore, Mr. President, if this regulatory modification were to obey confessable reasons, it does not seem that the method chosen to carry it out is the most correct. Note that it has not been done openly, that we are facing something that was not included in the original Bill, the one approved by your Government, but rather it is introduced stealthily, via amendment and at the very end of its processing in the Congress of Deputies; a Bill that, to make matters worse, has no relation, as I said before, to this suppression subsequently incorporated. So much so, Mr. President, that in the explanatory memorandum of the Bill, there is not even the slightest mention of its existence. Nothing is said about the modification of this subsection 2 of Article 105, as if it did not exist, although as of today it does exist, Mr. President.

I am finishing, Mr. President. Since there are no confessable reasons that justify this modification, we must resort to generic arguments such as "we are fulfilling the electoral program of the Socialist Party," "we are modernizing the functioning of companies," "without a doubt, it will benefit them," or "it is a persistent demand of the majority commercial doctrine and corporate practice," when everyone knows that the reality is quite different: that this is a decision made under persistent pressure from specific companies and individuals, responding to particular and individual economic and political interests, and that it has well-known beneficiaries.

Look, Mr. President, if the issue is clear that some media have even referred to this modification as the "brick amendment," and I do not think it necessary to explain to you why.

In short, the reasons behind this reform are not what is said, but what is kept silent. Think about it, Mr. President, lest one day, and not too far off, you regret the step taken. Moreover, we are all still in time. Tomorrow, precisely tomorrow, the committee that will reform the Bill will be established in this Chamber, the day after the Commission will issue its opinion, and, presumably, on June 9, the last parliamentary procedure will take place in a plenary session. There are amendments regarding this presented by several Parliamentary Groups; therefore, there are ways to restore the agreement, and if there is will, this is still possible. Think about it, Mr. President.

President.- Mr. Zubía, I can assure you that, from my point of view, there is no confessable reason for you to oppose the change of this regulation and, therefore, it is fair that you claim the same honest position defending one thesis as opposed to the other. The rest is simply a judgment of intentions that, in parliamentary debate and in a debate of this nature, indicates the weakness of the arguments.

When someone has few arguments on the substance, they invoke that there are confessable elements. In a debate that is public, where many people from the economic or scientific field have spoken, it is a topic that has been debated for a long time and is as confessable as the fact that we included it in the Socialist Party's program and that we have incorporated it in an amendment, with light and shorthand, before all Parliamentary Groups and before all Members.

Therefore, Mr. Zubía, you can say "I do not agree with your thesis," and I deeply respect that; but do not tell me that there are confessable elements, just as I will not tell you, nor has it crossed my mind, that there are any in your position defending, instead of the brick, another sector that can produce certain political or social energies.

But, having said that, you have warned about the position of the European Union and, however, you have not recalled the Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council of July 11, 2007, which expressly states: "Holders of shares with voting rights must be able to exercise these rights, as they are reflected in the purchase price of the shares. Furthermore, effective control by shareholders is an essential requirement for good corporate governance and must therefore be facilitated and promoted." Therefore, there is indeed a positioning, a direction, from the European Union.

I will also tell you that in Comparative Law the only trend, the only one, from a majority position in favor of protections is to eliminate this type of protection. There is, as you have recalled, in Germany and Italy, and also some time ago in one of the countries that usually sets the reference in this matter, which is the United States, as you well know. There is no doubt that this trend will be the majority.

I must tell you, Mr. Zubía, that I find your position contradictory in asking that this matter not be regulated by law, but rather left to the decision of the shareholders of each company, when precisely the protection prevents a part of the shareholders from voting and expressing themselves on the advisability of such restrictions. Therefore, either there is a law that allows those shareholders to express themselves, or, as we have seen and as we know, the exercise of the right to assert the shares they hold is not allowed, and, of course, participation in the management bodies of the company.

Mr. Zubía, the reform will make investment in Spanish companies more attractive. Moreover, the protection, the supposed protection, does not guarantee the presence or participation of operations, as we have experienced in some companies, for their takeover. It will guarantee the proportionality between the volume of investment and the rights associated with it, and will make managers more accountable, as they must have the backing of the true shareholders, those who have committed their investment. It seems quite reasonable and quite positive for the functioning of commercial companies.

Consequently, Mr. Zubía, beyond specific situations, we are here to make policies and laws of a general nature, and I believe this is a law in the right direction, and I hope that one day your Group will recognize it.

Thank you.