Speech and dialogue of the President of the Government at the breakfast organized by Nueva Economía Fórum.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

16 January 2007 · Breakfast organized by Nueva Economía Fórum

Context
Zapatero addressed the Nueva Economía Fórum breakfast in January 2007, reflecting on Spain's current situation and anti-terrorist policy following a deadly ETA attack.
Main themes
ETA terrorism and anti-terrorist policy, democratic consensus against terrorism, Spain's future prospects and prosperity, rule of law and security forces, dialogue and peace process, political unity, social progress and economic well-being, territorial integration, solidarity with victims
Duration
~93 min
98th percentile
Words
11,151
98th percentile
Sentences
403
97th percentile
Readability
44
45th percentile
Grade
13.9
66th percentile
Syntax
3.24
77th percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
28th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 37%35%
  • Economic 22%20%
  • Geopolitical 18%17%
  • Social 12%11%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Environmental 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

403 sentences in 168 paragraphs

I want to thank, first of all, the New Economy Forum and José Luis Rodríguez for the invitation he has extended to me to speak before all of you. My presence is the result of the tenacity with which my fellow countryman usually carries out his work, with which he has managed to turn this forum into a continuous reference for plural information. For this reason, I want to sincerely congratulate him.

This morning, I intend to share some reflections on the moment that Spain is currently experiencing and on future prospects; a future for which I can tell you we are excellently prepared; a future that is full of opportunities, which we must seize to definitively place our country among the most prosperous, socially advanced, better integrated territorially, more committed to peace, and more supportive in the world.

We would all have wished, you will understand that no one more than I, that this appearance had not been tinged with the pain and frustration felt by Spanish society as a consequence of the terrorist attack that on the 30th took the lives of Diego Armando Estacio and Carlos Alonso Palate; two Ecuadorian citizens who worked with us and who deserved a future in peace that ETA has deprived them of.

Once again, I reiterate the pain and solidarity of the Government, of myself, and of all Spaniards, which we extend to their families, friends, and fellow citizens.

Only 36 hours have passed since the debate on anti-terrorist policy concluded in the Congress of Deputies. Therefore, please allow me not to insist too much on a matter that now requires, above all, work and on which it is not advisable to speak more than is necessary, and to do so when appropriate, in a tone that we can all share among the political forces, social organizations, and the entire citizenry. Yes, I do want, however, to recall some essential points of the response that we must articulate in the face of the challenge that the terrorists have posed to all of us once again.

The Spanish have the right to live in peace, and their Government has the obligation to try to ensure that this right becomes a reality. It must do so by resorting to all available means, in accordance with the law and the principles of the rule of law. This explains why, always, and also now, we have acted by enhancing the action of the security forces, the action of Justice, and international cooperation. But this also explains why, always, and also now, we have explored the possibilities of dialogue aimed at fostering the abandonment of violence, the acceptance of integration into democratic life, and the understanding that there is no political price to pay, but rather political proposals that can be defended according to the rules of democracy; pathways also aimed at convincing that if these conditions are accepted, Spanish society will be just, but it will be generous.

It must act in any case, and always, upholding legality and using the instruments of the rule of law, and above all, it must rise to the occasion of a society that has mobilized to articulate and demand a powerful and united democratic response that makes it clear to the terrorists that we will never pay a political price for their disappearance, and that they have no alternative but to put an end to violence.

To this end, I proposed the day before yesterday to work towards achieving a great democratic consensus against terrorism, uniting all democratic parties, and I announced that in the coming days I will convene a meeting of the Monitoring Commission of the Anti-Terrorist Pact, signed in its day by the Socialist Party and the Popular Party, to assess the situation and discuss the objectives of that great democratic consensus. For the same purpose, the Government, through the Minister of the Interior, will maintain a forum for dialogue with all parliamentary political forces to present our assessment, listen to their viewpoints and proposals, and jointly strengthen the mechanisms of the anti-terrorist strategy.

I trust that these initiatives will yield the results that society expects, that the Spanish demand of us. I can assure you that I will put all my effort and best disposition into achieving them. Ending violence is, without a doubt, a strategic priority for Spanish society.

Allow me to reflect at this moment: in truth, it is the only serious problem that persists in Spain after the success of our thirty years of democracy, of great social progress, economic well-being, openness to the world, and exemplary consolidation of our democracy, thanks, above all, to a calm, civic, and mature people as it is so well established.

The political action of the Government is directed and will continue to be directed in the remaining year of the Legislature to implement or intensify policies that bring more wealth and well-being to citizens, that better prepare their future, that offer more opportunities to young people, and that protect those who need it most; policies that integrate while increasing the capacity for self-government; policies that compensate for territorial opportunities and are highly committed to ethical values, which are predominantly felt by Spaniards.

It is for the development of these policies that I mentioned at the beginning of my speech that we are in an excellent starting position at this moment.

2006 has been an excellent year in economic and social aspects, and 2007 will also be. It will be a year with which this legislature of changes will practically conclude, from which Spain will emerge clearly in better conditions than it entered.

It will emerge with a larger population and greater economic capacity; with more physical, human, and technological resources; with full technical employment in many parts of our country; with many more stable jobs, because in this Legislature more than three million jobs will be created, and with a per capita income at the average of the European Union.

It will emerge by implementing the most decisive welfare policies for increasingly broader sectors of the population, because, friends, in 2006 much well-being has been generated and distributed; a growth close to 4 percent; a significant reduction in inflation; less public debt; public accounts in surplus; intense job creation and continuous contributions to the Social Security reserve.

2006, viewed in aggregate terms, is surely the brightest year, in economic terms, of the entire democratic period.

In 2007 we will continue to grow, at least, around 3.5 percent of our Gross Domestic Product, and the impressions that the Government has of how the year has started confirm that the trend of reducing unemployment is accelerating, that job creation is intensifying, and that permanent hiring is also evolving favorably.

We are clearly growing above the European average, with better performance in the external sector thanks to the recovery of exports, which will particularly benefit the industrial sector. In 2006 we achieved the highest surplus in our history, which will be around 1.6 percent of Gross Domestic Product. In 2007 we expect to exceed 1 percent surplus again, and with all this, confidence in our economy will grow even more.

We will further reduce debt, by more than three points in relation to GDP, and we are already more than thirty points below the average debt of the Economic and Monetary Union. We are thus relieving future generations of burdens and allowing for tax cuts for today's youth and tomorrow's taxpayers.

We will continue to contribute reserves to Social Security, close to 7 billion euros, and by the end of 2007 the Fund will exceed 42 billion euros, three times what it was when the Legislature began, which demonstrates the good health of our Social Security system. We will thus have a Fund equivalent to 4 percent of Gross Domestic Product. This will strengthen the pension system for our elders, both current and future.

In 2006 around 700,000 jobs will have been created, more than half occupied by women. In 2007 we expect to create more than 600,000 jobs and we foresee placing unemployment clearly below 8 percent, the minimum rate of the democratic period, the best unemployment rate of the entire democratic period.

Since the reform agreed upon with social interlocutors came into effect in July, there have been more than 1,200,000 new permanent contracts, 56 percent more than in the same period of 2005. In 2007, we will continue to transform temporary jobs into permanent ones, around half a million. And this is the result of a great agreement between employers, unions, and the Government, which I want to highlight today in this forum as one of the differential factors that allows Spain to grow economically with these figures.

Creating so many jobs and having a horizon of stability in our public accounts is due to the exemplary attitude of our unions and our employers, who responsibly contribute to collective well-being by reasonably defending their legitimate interests.

We ended the year with an inflation rate of 2.7 percent, one and a half points less than in 2005, reducing the differential with the European Union by almost a point, and we expect in 2007 to continue improving both parameters, inflation and differential; in this latter case to bring it to historical lows. We are in a position to reach in 2007 the historical minimum of the inflation differential with the European Union.

Since January 1, Spaniards who work and the companies that produce pay less taxes. 99.5 percent will benefit from the reforms of the Personal Income Tax. The January withholdings will already reflect an average decrease of 4.6 percent, more than 1,300,000 citizens with lower incomes will stop paying the Personal Income Tax, and the reduction for all employees will be greater the lower the income. The general average will be set at 6 percent.

The general rate of the Corporate Tax is reduced for the first time since 1983, almost a quarter of a century ago. Small and medium-sized enterprises will benefit from a five-point reduction in this Tax starting from this economic year.

To address the weak points of our economic model, which are productivity and competitiveness, in 2007 we will continue to invest intensively in people, through training; in modernity, through Research, Development, and Innovation; and in physical endowment and territorial balance, through infrastructure. In short, we will invest in the future.

I want to pause on this data and draw your attention to it: we will allocate 6.5 billion euros to Research, Development, and Innovation; a 34.3 percent increase over 2006, the largest increase in the Legislature and, attention, more than double, I repeat, more than double, what Spain invested in Research, Development, and Innovation in 2004. In just three years we have doubled our investment commitment for technical change, for the new economy, for innovation, and its effects, make no mistake, will be evident in the short and, of course, in the medium term.

In 2007 we will implement the State Pact reached at the Conference of Presidents on the strategy, objectives, and common monitoring mechanisms for Research, Development, and Innovation policy; the availability of our map of major scientific-technological infrastructures for the next fifteen years; the creation of the Euroingenio Fund, which will increase Spanish participation in European research programs; two new programs that will improve health and environmental research in cooperation with the Autonomous Communities and the joint promotion of the celebration of the Year of Science 2007.

I insist, a State Pact that we reached at the Conference of Presidents, combining the efforts of the central and regional administrations in the field of Research, Development, and Innovation, to reach the goal of investing 2 percent of our public spending by 2010. It was a great agreement and, without a doubt, the most relevant aspect of the Conference of Presidents, much more than some clandestine recording.

We will spend 28.4 percent more on education, 400 million more for scholarships, with resources to ensure the free provision of Early Childhood Education and to launch reinforcement and support programs to combat school failure in 1,200 schools across the country.

We will reform, with the new Law, the Universities, granting them more autonomy, more resources, modernizing studies, opening ourselves to the European Higher Education Area, and seeking greater cooperation between business and University.

Means will be made available to young people to promote English learning, the acquisition of computer equipment, more effective provision of Erasmus scholarships, and access to housing with nearly 16 percent more resources.

In 2007 we will invest 22 billion euros in railways, roads, ports, airports, air and maritime security, and water. This investment will allow the arrival of the AVE to Barcelona, Málaga, and Valladolid; 500 new kilometers put into service in 2007. We will begin construction on the Madrid-Extremadura and Medina-Ourense lines, and we will continue, of course, with those currently under development.

With this investment in 2007, we will also put into service 400 kilometers of new highways, the construction of another 640 kilometers will be announced, work will continue on another 920 kilometers, and 1,500 kilometers of the oldest or first-generation highways will be upgraded.

With this investment, we will continue the expansion of major airports in our country, such as Barcelona and Málaga. We will increase the operational capacity of the ports and, for the first time, we will address the bidding for the motorways of the sea.

In short, an ambitious infrastructure program, for modernization, for all territories, for all Communities, of our country.

In 2007, we will also intensify the supplementary support for the less fortunate. More than three million Spaniards will benefit from the increase in minimum pensions, which in this 2007 fiscal year will see a 25 percent increase since we came to power, and 600,000 Spaniards will benefit from the increase in the Minimum Interprofessional Wage, which has been recovering purchasing power each year of our Government, reaching the 600 euros of Minimum Interprofessional Wage that we have committed to by the end of the Legislature.

I can assure you that these two actions, the increase in pensions above the CPI, by 25 percent in three years, for three million pensioners, and the increase in the Minimum Interprofessional Wage, are the two measures of which the Government is most proud to have been able to implement, in line with its ideas.

Social policies are strengthened when they have continuity. The Government has increased social spending in each year of the Legislature above the average of the Budget and will continue to do so in 2007 by nearly 9 percent.

Ladies and gentlemen,

On January 1, the Law on Attention to Persons in Situations of Dependency came into force, a law with broad parliamentary support and broad social backing. We have begun to write a new chapter in our country in protection and welfare policies. While other countries are tearing pages from their protection systems, Spain can face the task of writing a new page in its social welfare model and in its protection system.

We are going to start addressing the needs of many currently unattended individuals, and many of their family members, who are currently unable to maintain a possibility for themselves as they dedicate their lives to caring for their closest loved ones in a situation of incapacity to fend for themselves. Thus, we are moving towards a more supportive, fairer, and safer society for all, for all citizens today, but also for all citizens in the future.

Next spring, Spaniards will be more equal. The Equality Law is already in the Senate. Its very imminent entry into force will promote active policies against discrimination of women in the workplace, in salary, in the home, in business leadership, and in institutional and political representation. It will be another of the decisive advances that will consolidate a country with a future, because a country with a future is one where there are all possibilities for all its citizens. Where the values of equality are more deeply rooted, there innovation, positive will, and therefore progress and well-being grow better.

In 2007, we will have better instruments to channel a rigorous immigration policy. We have made progress in the Conference of Presidents and there is still an important path ahead; we have advanced in the European dimension, although there is still an evident area for the application of European policy on immigration, and we have advanced, through bilateral agreements, with many countries that are sources or transit points for immigration. But there is still an important path to travel.

We are putting more resources in the Budgets. In 2007, we will increase to 190 million, a 30 percent increase, the fund for the reception and integration of immigrants and educational reinforcement, which we have multiplied by 23 times since we have been in Government.

Ladies and gentlemen,

In 2007, Spaniards will be more and better protected, with stronger public security and more resources for security. We will dedicate 8.1 billion euros to this in 2007, a 12 percent increase over 2006. A significant portion will be allocated to having more police and civil guards, better trained, better paid, in line with the latest Agreement of the Council of Ministers that has resulted in a pay increase, which had not occurred for many years, for our Police and our Civil Guard of nearly 7 percent, and therefore, with greater overall capacity to ensure better security in Spain.

We will also have better Armed Forces, because the increasing application of the regulations on troops and sailors, and the new Military Career Law, will ensure this.

In 2007, we all have to contribute to continuing the fight against one of our most painful problems, the reduction of deaths on the road. Since the introduction of the points-based driving license, 306 fewer people have died than in the same period of 2005.

Advanced societies demand not only effectiveness in service delivery but also efficiency in resource utilization. In 2007, we will have a novel instrument to improve the management of the Administration: the State Agency for the Evaluation of Public Policies and the Quality of Services will be established, which aims to independently and autonomously evaluate plans, programs, and the allocation of funds, public resources that are the resources of citizens, and subject them to a permanent quality control, because the public enterprise that represents a country must also meet the highest requirements and demands when spending public money.

In 2007, we will continue to advance in territorial cohesion, which is the tone and result that emerges from the State of Autonomies. Thirty years after launching the State of Autonomies, our country today has more territorial cohesion. We will allocate 1.8 billion to specific plans for Soria, Teruel, Jaén, the Northwest of our country, and Extremadura.

Furthermore, looking beyond our borders, I want to highlight that Spanish society, through the Government, has just shown the world its commitment to solidarity. We have just contributed 528 million to the Spain-UNDP Fund for the achievement of the Millennium Goals. In 2007, this commitment will grow, a vital commitment for the Government of Spain, because Official Development Assistance will increase by nearly 40 percent compared to 2006, doubling the resources available in 2004, when we came to power, and its action will expand to the most depressed areas of the planet.

Spain will be in a few years at the forefront of development aid in the world, at the forefront of solidarity, and this goal represents a fundamental hallmark of our Government in foreign policy and in commitment to a just, equitable vision with greater opportunities for many places in the world.

I want to insist on an idea that seems evident to me: our future well-being as a country, like that of many other countries, will depend on the degree of discomfort in other countries and other latitudes of the world. Contributing to the improvement, progress, and development in so many societies with inequalities and poverty is not only, and primarily, an ethical imperative, but it is also fundamental for a reasonable order of society.

From the normality that is now accepted, we are strengthening all of Spain by strengthening each of its parts, brought together through cooperation and solidarity. I know that this is a debatable and discussed idea, and that for some, despite the experience of the State of Autonomies, it is difficult to internalize; but it is perfectly possible, and Spain is the best demonstration, that as the parts grow, the whole grows; as the parts grow, there are more global opportunities, more solidarity, and fewer differences between Communities or between regions in per capita income, infrastructure, and development. This is one of the great contributions that our constitutional model, our model of territorial coexistence, has made at this historical moment.

I would like to emphasize that committing the Autonomous Communities, as the Government is doing, to the development of the National Dependency System, to integrate the general Administration and Autonomous Administrations into a common policy in Research, Development, and Innovation, and to mobilize jointly and coordinately the resources of all for the integration policy of immigrants, is neither easy nor traditional in our country, and we are clearly advancing in this direction.

The examples are abundant: we have held for the first time in history three Conferences of Autonomous Presidents with the President of the Government, and I believe I can affirm that I am the President of the Government who has had the most meetings and encounters with the various Autonomous Presidents, of all political colors, because today governing Spain well requires that the Government of Spain govern with the Autonomous Communities, not with its back to the Autonomous Communities and, even less, without counting on or against the Autonomous Communities.

In 2007, the Government will strongly bet on a preferred line, which is the defense of the environment and the challenge posed by climate change; in short, for sustainable development because today, increasingly, it is evident that if our development is not sustainable, it will surely not last long.

To this end, we will promote a new environmental regulatory block already in processing or that we will present in the next legislative session. Among the first, the Law regulating the rights of access to information and public participation in environmental matters, the Law on the assessment of the specific effects of certain plans and programs on the environment, the National Parks Law, or the Land Law stand out. Among the second, those that we will present in this legislative session, the Air Quality and Atmospheric Protection Law, the Draft Law on the defense of natural heritage and biodiversity, the Draft Law on environmental responsibility for attacks on the environment, and the Draft Law on the reform of the Water Law, along with the Law on the sustainable development of rural areas.

And, as you know, the Conference of Presidents next year will have as its main theme the fight, the policies, against climate change.

I am finishing. In 2007, we will intensify the process of modernization of our public services: as of January 1, it is no longer required to present a photocopy of the ID card in any procedure of the State Administration; before 2008, more than twenty million paper documents currently required for various procedures will be eliminated; before 2008, three million Spaniards will have the new electronic ID card, and before 2008, we will reduce the time for issuing university degrees by half.

In the period we are now starting, the Government will approve a set of regulations, which I would like to see approved by the end of the Legislature, in addition to the 35 that are currently in the Congress and eight in the Senate in various stages of the legislative process. Among them, I quickly list the Law on the processing of international adoptions, where Spain is a world leader; the Law on measures in Social Security, resulting from the agreement on Social Security; the Law regulating the Reserve Fund of Social Security, to make the Fund more profitable, which currently stands at around 40 billion euros; the Law on the Statute of non-university teaching staff; the Law for the protection of health and the prevention of alcohol consumption by minors; the Film Law, which will be of great relevance to our industry in this sector; the Law on the sustainable development of rural areas, which I referred to earlier, or the Law of solidarity with the victims of terrorism.

In short, these are the most important plans, programs, and reforms that the Government wants to carry out in this year that is now beginning; but it has very clear objectives in what represents political action: one of them, a priority, in the strict field of politics: to ensure that we all position ourselves close on the same side, as we have always needed to be, in the fight against terrorism; to convey confidence and security to Spanish society at a time when the best opportunities in our modern history are available to position ourselves where the most advanced are and even surpass some of them, and to exercise leadership in areas where we can undoubtedly do so.

We are putting this into practice in economic growth and job creation; we are exercising it with social protection and equality policies; we are exercising it in the recognition of new rights and freedoms, and we can do it in many other fields.

All of this provides solid reasons and objectives for confidence in our future; they are reasons for optimism typical of a society that, since the recovery of democracy, has always, always, made the right fundamental decisions and oriented its efforts correctly.

Thank you very much.

Dialogue with the President of the Government

-----------------------------------------------------------------

Moderator.- There are hundreds of questions, but imagine that we are in León, where we have met frequently, and, first of all, I was going to ask you, with personal affection, how you are doing.

President.- I am reasonably well and, like all Spaniards, still in mourning for the loss of two human lives as a result of the attack on December 30.

Moderator.- There are many questions, and I will try to summarize them. If you find it appropriate, Mr. President, let us start with the most current issue, the issue of the breakdown of the truce.

How can the anti-terrorist pact and the great consensus of all be made compatible? Do you support the appropriateness of the Political Parties Law? Do you maintain that Batasuna will not be able to run in the elections? What is your opinion on the "litmus test" proposed by the PP, the illegalization of the Communist Party of the Basque Lands? What would be the Government's demands on ETA to initiate a new negotiation process? Do you share the view expressed by Rubalcaba that there will never be a credible truce from ETA, never again a negotiation with ETA?

President.- I will address the most relevant issue, which is what we must do in the immediate future together, and that is to achieve an agreement, a consensus, a unity among all democrats, among all democratic political parties. This is what the Spanish citizens overwhelmingly want, who are always full of common sense, and who have once again responded with calmness and citizenship, and who cannot understand why so much passion is put into confrontation on a matter such as the fight against terrorism; they cannot understand it. Consequently, the objective of the Government must be to unite everyone.

The question asks what the requirements are from both sides. What do the Spanish people expect? What is done when one is going to dialogue to reach an agreement? To go without any limits or prior conditions, to go to listen, to dialogue, and to seek a common point of agreement. That is the attitude one has when one truly wants to reach an agreement. When one wants to get to another place, before sitting down, one already sets limits and conditions, or, when going to a meeting or a debate, before listening to the other, one has already decided and written what one is going to respond.

The Spanish people want to see us with the will to share this task, to unite and to add up. That is what the Government is going to do, and I also believe that the Spanish people, with great common sense, know that the direction of anti-terrorist policy corresponds to the Government by constitutional mandate and by mandate of the citizens, and that, therefore, from that principle, all democratic political parties must unite their efforts around the Government. The Government will listen to everyone, integrate positions, but around the Government, around the State, the Rule of Law, because in anti-terrorist matters, in this matter, there is no political color of Governments.

The fight for life against death, the fight for freedom against threat, has no political color. An anti-terrorist policy belongs to democracy, not to a Government of one political sign or another. I understood this from the very first day I became the leader of the opposition, from the very first day. That is why I arrived at La Moncloa and told Mr. Aznar: "Nothing would give me more satisfaction than to see the end of terrorism with you as President of the Government and me as leader of the opposition. And know that from today you have all my support, every day, in every initiative you take and in every proposal you make." And in the nearly four years I led the opposition in this country against the Government of the Popular Party, one will not find any critical statement, not a single one, against the Aznar Government in anti-terrorist policy, but rather all statements saying "I support the Government" in any circumstance, serious attacks that occurred, new laws or initiatives that were produced.

For that to be the case, for the Government to have that conviction that my word, as I always try, is a word that I keep, I said: "Let us sign an agreement, the Pact for Liberties and against Terrorism." It is now frequently invoked by many sectors. It is curious what happens sometimes in life. It is invoked against this Government and against me, when I was, allow me to remember, although the Popular Party never acknowledges it, the one who proposed it, who thought of it, and who designed it. At first, when that happened, the reaction was one of coldness from the Popular Party in the Government at that time, a bit dismissive; they have not changed in this regard either; but in the end, we did it.

Do you know what the essence of the Pact is? The essence of the Pact is spoken by the one who proposed it and who thought of it, and therefore I believe I have an authoritative voice; I could speak of a certain authentic interpretation, since there are distinguished jurists here, of the Pact is that the Government feels as strong as possible to carry out the fight against terrorism, to end violence; that it feels strong and the terrorists, weak. That is the essence of the Pact and that there be not a single confrontation, not a single one, when it comes to reasoning against terrorism, when it comes to combating terrorism or when it comes to fighting for the end of terrorism, because I want to remind you that the best anti-terrorist policy is the one that seeks the end of terrorism and violence. That is the best. The most difficult, without a doubt, but the one that the citizens deserve.

Therefore, unity, consensus, and clear will, and the citizens will see each of us in our attitude. One cannot go to a consensus with prior conditions, even before having sat down to talk. This requires talking and, by the way, talking quite a bit, with discretion and absolute sincerity. That is what I propose, because it is what the Spanish people want and it is my duty as President of the Government.

Moderator.- Mr. President, many of the attendees have sent us notes and questions indicating that you have left open channels or certain possibilities for agreement with ETA in your words. They ask you if this is not turning the other cheek.

President.- In my speech today and in my speech in the Plenary, I clearly stated that the dialogue process, the so-called peace process, was broken, that it had come to an end, that there is no dialogue with violence and that ETA does not have two options: violence or dialogue. There are not those two options. And I ended my speech in Parliament with a phrase, more or less textual, that said: the Government has done, is doing, and will do everything possible to seek the paths that lead to a definitive peace. It is a responsible, necessary statement that is part of the entire democratic tradition.

And I add more: that phrase is not mine; that phrase is from President Aznar on the day he broke the truce of 1998 with the terrorist group ETA, and I incorporated it, and today I repeat it here, explicitly. I repeat it: the Government has done, is doing, and will do everything possible to seek the paths that lead us to a definitive peace. Aznar said it while being President of the Government on the day the truce with ETA was broken. I have incorporated it as a doctrine that seems reasonable to me, that is part of the democratic heritage; but surely before one could speak of a peace process and now there are certain sectors that rise up when one speaks of a peace process.

Well, in that statement, President Aznar on the day the truce with ETA was broken spoke six times about peace, six times. Therefore, let us apply common sense.

There is no one who contemplates a scenario, after what happened on December 30, of dialogue with the ETA band. We have told them actively and passively: their only destiny is the end. But in anti-terrorist policy, the Government has, as it has always done and as all democratic and responsible Governments must do, I emphasize, all, to take initiatives that can help seek paths that lead us to a definitive peace.

Of course, I share that statement. I have made it my own. Although it may have surprised some, it was from President Aznar. Such is life.

Moderator.- Mr. President, what role, what predominance or not, can the PNV have in the unity pact you propose?

President.- The PNV and everyone, because beyond the Popular Party and the Socialist Party, there is a significant number of political groups that have parliamentary representation, that represent Spaniards. Convergència i Unió, Coalición Canaria, Partido Nacionalista Vasco, Bloque Nacionalista Gallego, Esquerra Republicana de Cataluña; all expressed in the Plenary the other day a strong attitude against terrorism, against ETA and against what has been a breakdown of dialogue by the ETA band, and all have been demanding in the conditions against ETA.

I want to emphasize what I found to be a very well-constructed intervention, which was that of Izquierda Unida, by the spokesperson of Izquierda Unida, Gaspar Llamazares. After having listened to that in the Plenary, and believe me, I listened attentively to all the spokespersons, can an agreement be reached by all? Yes. If one takes the interventions, there may be some elements that can be considered to be in different positions, but an agreement could be reached if there is will, because no political group desires more than to see the end of terrorism and to combat terrorism.

To be specific regarding the PNV, of course, I wish for the PNV to be in the best, in the great, democratic agreement against terrorism. It is not difficult to understand given what the Basque Nationalist Party represents in Basque society and what Basque society represents in the fight against and the end of terrorism.

In this matter, as in other important matters for the State, such as territorial cohesion, the development of Spain and its territorial coexistence, we cannot forget that there are four Communities where there are parties with a strong presence and vote that are not of state scope, such as Catalonia, Euskadi, Galicia, and the Canary Islands. And I believe that now with our candidate, Juan Fernando, that will be much less.

Whoever does not have this perspective will not govern in an integrative manner for Spain; whoever is not aware of that objective fact, of what is the fruit of the will of the citizens, will not make good cohesion and integration policy, which is at the base of what the constitutional pact was and at the base of what our territorial model represents. Therefore, it is unquestionable. If you ask the Spaniards, in response to the question of a PSOE-PP pact or a pact among all, more than 80 percent will answer a pact of all, and perhaps no more than 15 percent will respond that a pact only between PSOE and PP.

If there is a will, it can be achieved, and I want to remind you that at this moment all parliamentary parties, except one, all support the Government. They supported the Government before the truce, during the truce, with the attack, and after the attack. All, except one. But I am willing to do everything possible to ensure that that one is with everyone.

Moderator.- Mr. President, to conclude this topic, Justice continues its processes. On the 31st of this month, Lehendakari Ibarretxe has to testify before a judge regarding his conversations with HB, and later Otegi has another important appointment. How do you see these processes?

They also ask you if you categorically rule out the participation of Batasuna in the upcoming municipal elections.

President.- I always see Justice with respect, with respect for its independence. I believe that throughout my political career, and particularly since I have been President of the Government, I have never made a statement regarding a judicial resolution or a judicial action. I will not do so. I may have my opinion, but I believe that the President of the Government must be profoundly respectful. We have an independent judiciary, which acts as such, as it should in a Rule of Law, and that is a value we must preserve above any other circumstance.

The Government has its area of competencies, which is very broad; among other things, it has a power that is legislative initiative and the parliamentary majority to change laws. That is its area of responsibility, and Justice should act independently and, of course, thinking of the general interests, as it does.

Batasuna? We are in a Rule of Law. It is a question in which the President of the Government has an objective limitation when it comes to answering whether one political formation or another can be in an electoral process. What the Law says, the contents of the Law, the spirit and the letter of the Law. That will not depend, obviously, on what the President of the Government says. That said, after the statements that Batasuna, the illegalized Batasuna, the abertzale left, has been making, I cannot see how with the Political Parties Law they will be able to participate in an electoral competition.

My wish, what is it? That the so-called abertzale left takes a step further every day, which is essential for us to achieve this objective that we all desire to see the end of violence sooner rather than later, in the separation from the violent, in the condemnation, in the rejection of what can be violence. I consider it fundamental, and all of us, from the democratic authority, and the democratic authority also represents the capacity for generosity for the future, because only those who have democratic authority, that is, the people, the citizens, can be generous, we must demand of the abertzale left that they separate from violence and condemn violence. That would undoubtedly be a very important step.

There have been some statements in recent days that I believe should not go unnoticed, although all precautions must be present on our part.

Moderator.- Josu Jon Imaz has just stated that Batasuna could become the party that disarms ETA.

President.- I have great respect for the opinions, the career, and the attitude of Josu Jon Imaz, with whom I hope to meet in the coming days. Of course, it is a reflection that I wish were so and I hope it comes to fruition.

Moderator.- If you agree, let us delve into some issues regarding territorial politics. The Constitutional Court's ruling on the appeals presented by the Ombudsman and the Popular Party regarding the Statute of Catalonia is pending. If this ruling occurs before the upcoming regional and municipal elections, could it potentially alter that very process?

President.- From my point of view, no. The Constitutional Court will issue its resolution, its ruling, on the Statute of Catalonia, as it does with all laws that are questioned regarding their constitutionality, and that should not affect any electoral process.

From my perspective, the process of statutory reforms we have experienced, which was passionate regarding the Statute of Catalonia and very positive in the overall context of statutory reforms, because all of them imply the consensus of the two major political parties, will be a positive process and, from my point of view, and we have defended it as such in this case, I can reaffirm it and it should not be interpreted as any position against the free, independent, and autonomous deliberation that the Constitutional Court must have; from our point of view, from the perspective of the Socialist Party and the Government, the reform of the Statute is a reform that fits within the Constitution.

But, if you allow me, to conclude I will make a reflection. All the reforms of the Statutes will have an agreement between the PP and the PSOE, except for Catalonia, and perhaps the PP has not been there because it does not share and, from my point of view, because it does not understand the reflection I made a moment ago: that to govern Spain with that integrative strength, one cannot lose sight of the fact that there are Autonomous Communities that have a significant social, electoral presence of political forces that are not state-based. The PP understood this during the Legislature from 1996 to 2000. In those four years, it understood this, and by the way, it did not fare badly, and now it seems to have forgotten this fundamental aspect of our political territorial Constitution.

Therefore, I believe it is enormously important that these statutory reforms are consolidated and consolidate what, from our point of view, is practically the culmination of the development of the territorial model in normative and competential aspects, because we need to calmly address the reform of the autonomous financing model. We will approach it with the same serenity and tranquility that characterizes the economic Vice President throughout the Government's actions.

In other words, we are not in an imminent or urgent situation to address that model of financing reform, which will not be the last, because all politically decentralized states, all composite states, whether federal, regional, autonomous, or whatever we want to call them, all have periodic debates and reforms regarding financing between the central power and the territorial powers, because economic realities change, income types change, and financing needs change.

That debate is always open. There are usually pendular trends; sometimes there is a trend to reduce financing to central powers and give more to territorial powers, and sometimes there is a trend in the opposite direction. It is true that in Spain, so far, there has only been one trend, which has been the tendency for territorial powers or Autonomous Communities to have more spending capacity and the central power to have less. But I must say, as of today, that the State maintains a significant volume of resources, financial capacity, and the ability to establish and determine tax authority, which is essential, and that we can make a reform that is reasonable for both the Autonomous Communities and the State, although, given the topic, it will require time, much negotiation, and a lot of dialogue, as always in democracy.

Moderator.- Today, the President of the Xunta de Galicia, Pérez Touriño; the Vice President Quintana, from the Bloc, and Alberto Núñez, from the Popular Party of Galicia, are meeting to unblock the negotiation process for the new Statute of Autonomy of Galicia. You have made, I wanted to understand, a forecast that the PP could also do what it has done in Andalusia and lend its support there. Would you accept a Galician Statute similar to the Catalan one?

And they also ask you from Galicia what your Government's plans are for a Community that bears a significant historical debt.

President.- I wish, and I know that the Socialist Party of Galicia and Emilio Pérez Touriño will make every effort, that there is a reform of the Statute with the Popular Party and the Galician Nationalist Bloc. The Socialist Party has established a series of guidelines for all statutory reforms that will logically also be present in the Statute of Galicia, but taking into account, which is the essence of autonomy, that Statutes have and will have particularities. It is the essence of autonomy. It would make no sense for the Statutes to be like drops of water. They must have particularities. Why? To respond to the singular territorial interest of each Autonomous Community. And I mention the territorial interest because it is the constitutional expression. The Autonomous Communities, above all, have one obligation: to defend the territorial interest.

We sometimes forget, when we see that the Autonomous Communities are always claiming, defending, demanding, that it is a constitutional mandate. It is a constitutional mandate, just as the Government of Spain has the obligation to defend the general interest. And we also forget that the Autonomous Communities are part of the State constitutionally. That is to say, when President Chaves or the President of the Community of Madrid are managing public health centers, or hospitals, or public schools, they do so in the name of the State; in Andalusia, in Madrid, yes, but they are the State. Of course, just like President Iglesias in Aragon, who, by the way, does it very well, as everyone knows.

Moderator.- According to the polls, the PSOE and the PP are in the most equal electoral situation, they say. This paradox occurs when the country is experiencing a prolonged period of economic growth and when the Government is introducing a series of social improvements, such as, for example, the integration process of immigrants. Does your future as President, they ask, depend on how terrorism is resolved?

President.- Pepe Blanco would tell me that this is not what the polls say; but I have to say that polls have two characteristics: one, that they have more value as they approach electoral processes, of course; and, secondly, that we already have a proven experience of having certain polls and then the elections come and what happened, right?

If above the polls is common sense… It is that the common sense of the people, of the citizens, has demonstrated it so many times and will continue to demonstrate it in the upcoming elections. It is not the day, nor do I want or should I make a forecast, but I can assure you that citizens do not have the anxiety that some seem to have; they do not have it. They have demonstrated it, even, in the hard days we lived with the attack on December 30.

The country has very positive conditions. It is a vital country, it is a country eager to work, it is a country that, above all, is every day winning the future and has demonstrated that under no circumstances, and we have had very difficult circumstances… Of course, it has never lost hope in the face of any attack or any bomb; hope and self-confidence as a country and, of course, the hope and confidence of seeing the end of violence.

Today is not the time for us to be looking at what citizens think in the polls, no; it is the time to show citizens what each one represents and thinks.

Look. Today a poll comes out about yesterday's debate, about who won and who did not win, in a media outlet; it comes out there in a little box. The last thing someone can take to a counter-terrorism political debate is to know whether they are going to win or lose against the leader of the opposition or any other leader. Perhaps the result of the debate is explained because someone has not understood that those debates are not about winning or losing, because who has to win is Spain and who has to lose are the terrorists.

Moderator.- An easy question, President. In Madrid, who is going to win the Mayor's office?

President.- My friend José Luis always seeks the sensitive points. The other day I heard Gallardón say that it was going to be one of my last political battles. I have respect for Alberto Ruíz-Gallardón, but he always has that air of great self-confidence, of great security. It would be nice to hear him say that he has made a mistake or to say "I made a mistake, I acknowledge it; I rectify." We know that this is not common. But I would tell or advise him, because he is a person with whom I have a friendly relationship, to think about what Miguel Sebastián is going to do and what he can do.

One must have great respect for the rival, one must be humble even if one has won one, two, or three elections. The citizenry does not forgive arrogance, because no one who is voted for by the citizens has the right to show arrogance. The citizenry demands humility.

The citizenry must verify that each ruler, I do not care if they are a Mayor, Minister, or President, is there by the vote of the citizens and only for that, even if some find it hard to understand; but only for that. When you are given that, which is the most precious thing a person has in their condition as a citizen, a vote, it is given to you so that you respect them. And, among other things, respect is to show oneself politely, not to think that anyone is more than anyone else in democracy; to think that we are all equal, because it usually happens that those who boast the most are the weakest, deep down.

I believe that politics, for it to be credible, close to the people, for what we feel when we do it, and we feel that what we do is true and we feel that our ideas are what move us, must be credible to the people. There is no one, not a single politician, who does not make mistakes sometimes; we make mistakes, we commit errors, and when we can, we acknowledge them.

I always have great respect for rivals and I believe it is good for the Mayor of Madrid to have it for Miguel Sebastián. In this Forum that is here, everyone knows him and everyone knows the qualities that Miguel Sebastián has, both political and human. I can predict that it will be an interesting contest and that, moreover, knowing Miguel Sebastián, it will be elegant in the contest and brilliant in everything that can be the process to reach the Mayor's office of Madrid. Look, he is going to demonstrate that, above all, even being a man with enormous intellectual qualities, he can and can be Mayor, because above all he is a great citizen.

Moderator.- Surely, you are going to help him by personally participating in the campaign, because many see or want to see that the candidate is really you.

President.- That is something Gallardón has said many times, but the truth is that I do not understand what the subconscious motive is that leads him to that. Gallardón can only face me if he is a candidate for President of the Government, if my party gives me the confidence to be again the candidate for President of the Government. If my party gives me the confidence, eh!, because this is not a matter of mine; it is of my party, to which I have the utmost respect and affection for the support it gives me. But, if he wants to… I cannot think otherwise.

I do not know what he is thinking, nor do I know what Mariano Rajoy will think about what he may be thinking, but things are as they are. I can assure you that I am not running for the Mayor's office of Madrid; I can assure you and, moreover, that I am very happy with the candidate who is running for the Mayor's office of Madrid and for the Community of Madrid, where a certain closeness to the people and a bit of humility would do well for a people as supportive as the people of Madrid.

Moderator.- By the way, Mr. Simancas is also among us.

I regret that we are running so short on time. You can tell me that we started late due to traffic, and you are right, because he could not get here earlier…

President.- The traffic was not that bad. What happens is that there were many cars here and it was difficult in the last phase.

Moderator.- Naturally, I ask you for a little more time from you and the attendees, and I will conclude with a small round of questions regarding economic issues.

The Vice President of the CEOE and President of the Chamber of Commerce of Madrid and of CEIM, Gerardo Díaz Ferrán, sends me a note in which he wants to congratulate you on the magnificent presentation and convey an optimism that he shares. He thanks you for mentioning the commitment and contribution of entrepreneurs and unions, whose General Secretaries are here with us, Mr. Fidalgo and Mr. Méndez, through a constructive dialogue that will certainly continue with the efforts of entrepreneurs and unions.

He says that the Spanish company is losing competitiveness with its European environment. The reduction of the Corporate Tax from 35 to 30 percent is commendable, but it is insufficient. In fact, the French President has just made a proposal to lower the tax rate in France to curb the wave of relocations and ensure attractiveness for the French economy. They also say that it is necessary to lower the Corporate Tax to 20 percent in order to compete, attract investments, and avoid relocations. What do you think about these aspects, which summarize a bit the thoughts of business leaders?

President.- I want to thank the President of CEIM for his words regarding my statements about business leaders and trade unions, but I must say this with absolute sincerity. My experience as President of the Government, and I want Spaniards to know this, is that we have exemplary entrepreneurs, business organizations, and trade union organizations. The only thing I have noticed so far is a willingness to help the Government in every challenge, plan, program, or action we have undertaken; otherwise, the country would not be in such a good economic state nor creating the jobs it has. In the end, a country is indeed a collective enterprise of all.

To improve competitiveness, we must act on three clear lines. The first is a reduction in Corporate Taxes. We have just implemented it, for the first time since 1983, and it is now in effect. I believe it is an effort. I understand that business leaders want a new reform of the Corporate Tax now.

I mentioned in my speech that, fortunately, we are doing so well in public deficit that we have a surplus, which we will be able to maintain; we are doing very well in debt and, indeed, we may even exceed forecasts, and that will undoubtedly allow us to continue a trend of tax reduction in the future. But we have just had a reduction in the Corporate Tax, which I believe will help companies to capitalize, to save, and therefore to create jobs and innovate.

The second essential line is prices. Achieving the goal I mentioned of having an inflation differential that places us in a more competitive position with our European partners.

And the third line is innovation, which may be the most important; innovation and ensuring that this innovation has a clear application in the company. That is R&D&I. The latest data from 2005 puts us at 1.13 percent of spending on R&D&I; in 2006 we will see a significant leap. The data we have on penetration and change in the Information Society, in new technologies, shows that we are making very, very significant strides in recent years, and that is where we need to make more effort. We need to have a much stronger research system, we need to have companies much more linked to research, and we need to have companies that apply innovation more.

But I am convinced, just as we have managed to have the most solvent and best financial institutions in the world, and just as we have leading companies in technological sectors such as construction and the environment, that we will achieve that our business fabric will definitely turn towards innovation and that we will have a solid research system and universities that are more like companies and companies that are more like universities, following some of the brilliant doctrines that some important business leaders have put into operation.

These are the three lines: continued tax reduction, prices, and R&D&I.

Moderator.- Mr. President, 70 percent of our country's energy supply depends on partners that are, let’s say, a bit unusual, and our compatriot Javier Solana has stated that Europe will not have a truly strong, common foreign policy until it has an energy policy with a sufficient level of self-sufficiency. Do you not think it is time to start thinking about nuclear energy?

President.- It is a recurring question and surely the easiest answer to energy problems. But nuclear energy still poses a serious problem, which is nuclear waste, for which there is no effective response, and I do not know if there will be one in the future. From my point of view, we must continue to bet on many more renewable, alternative energies, and, of course, to have a European policy on energy.

It is not in the Government's plans to resume a program for the development or increase of nuclear energy; it is not in the Government's programs. We remain faithful to the electoral program although, logically, in the run-up to the 2008 elections, the party's electoral program will have to be pronounced.

Moderator.- The merger between Autostrade and Abertis has been canceled, at least for now, with accusations from the Italian company against the Prodi Government for the obstacles placed on this operation. Do you not think that these difficulties, Mr. President, show that each country is going its own way and, let’s say, doing its own thing? Do you not think that perhaps Spain could be accused of the same, for example, in the case of Endesa?

President.- I think we need to view these situations with a bit of perspective. The economic and monetary European Union works; it works generally with what represents the construction of a common market, the free movement of capital in all sectors, and it works quite well, and we can all say that it has been, and is, a great success. The economic union and the monetary union, of course; not only in the political realm but in the economic realm.

Sometimes it is true that there are policies specific to each country regarding its industrial strength, its business strength. That is normal, and there are situations where different positions and interests meet. What, in my opinion, should happen is that the European Union has a clear authority on these issues and that, moreover, that authority has equal decision-making power for all in each circumstance and at each moment, taking into account, because you have indirectly mentioned it, that the energy sector poses evident particularities, because regulations are very different from one country to another and because in many countries there is a presence of public capital, from the public sector, and in Spain, for example, there is not.

Therefore, the perspective and the criteria, in my opinion, must be different.

Moderator.- The takeover bids for Endesa are already a step away from the market. What outcome does the Government desire?

President.- The market. That the market decides in favor of the shareholders and, of course, with the guarantee of the energy interests of our country.

I had almost forgotten about the takeover bid after so much time and so many vicissitudes.

Moderator.- How do you see the situation in Latin America? It seems that the Bolivarian stain is spreading. Are you concerned about this change in trend?

President.- No. We have two positive data points in Ibero-America, in Latin America. The first is that it has sustained economic growth, as it is growing above 5 percent. That should open up a perspective that the social gap, which is the great problem of Latin America… The great problem of Latin America is not the color or profile of one or another leader; it is the glaring social inequality and the poverty that exists in many countries, which are fundamentally the cause of many government instabilities and many situations we have experienced.

In the last year, a little over a year, there has been an intense process of elections: renewal of electoral mandates, new Presidents… What is Spain's obligation? Spain's obligation is to have a positive relationship with all Ibero-American countries; first, for geopolitical reasons. It is our regional area where we have the most influence, where we can more easily align interests with Spain.

Second, for economic reasons, because we have a wide business presence, where the Government works day by day, shoulder to shoulder, with all companies to defend our interests in Latin America. Moreover, it does so from Moncloa, where we have an observatory for Latin America with the companies that are in Latin America to carry out strategies together.

Third, everything that the Government of Spain does to strengthen democracies, of course, systems that respect the rule of law, guarantees, what could and should be a stable party system, with ideologies comparable to what the major European ideological currents are; everything it does will be an absolutely essential task.

But let us respect, whether we like it or not, and everyone can have their opinion; sometimes I am placed as a friend of several leaders in Latin America, even Fidel Castro, whom I have never met in my life; I have never had the opportunity to shake his hand; but above all, let us respect the peoples of Latin America and what they vote.

I would like to tell some to also respect what is voted here.

Moderator.- Two questions for brief answers, unless you want otherwise.

Are you going to maintain the date of the elections, more or less? Are you going to exhaust the Legislature?

President.- Yes, yes; I am going to exhaust the Legislature, yes. This is a question that has been asked of me since the first year. I do not know if it is because some leader of the PP said: "he will not last the legislature, it will be short." But, in my conception of what political action and government action is, there is a first essential element for the mandate to be fulfilled, which is what the Constitution establishes in principle: that the Government has parliamentary support, sufficient backing, and objectively the Government has that parliamentary support to carry out its program; a program that is ambitious in what it has been and in what remains of the Legislature, of reforms, of changes in laws, of a new perspective on territorial Spain. The second condition is the evolution of the country, the economic, employment, and social evolution being very positive.

Therefore, I will say that the Government has almost the obligation to continue taking advantage of the opportunity it has left in this legislature to consolidate, even to strengthen, some of the policies that are being so successful economically and to begin to develop the social commitments we have initiated.

I believe there is a certain world, which is, in my opinion, quite small, where, as political anxiety prevails, I do not know if desperation, but certainly anxiety, they believe that this is the situation of what citizens think, and it is not true. It is not true. Citizens appreciate that the four-year electoral mandate is fulfilled, because that is, in part, fulfilling your task.

Of course, even if I had the guarantee of having a magnificent result in six months, I will do everything in my power to fulfill the four-year mandate and not call for early elections.

Moderator.- Mr. President, do you have a date for an interview with President Bush or, at this point, do you not care?

President.- I have to say one thing: everyone can understand, moreover, I believe that citizens understand very well that it will not be easy for me to have an interview with President Bush. It will not be easy because we have had a very intense disagreement regarding my decision to withdraw troops from Iraq, which is a decision made by the Spanish people, not by the President of the Government. The President of the Government has only fulfilled what the Spanish people voted overwhelmingly and clearly desired, which was to withdraw from Iraq. That is the essence of democracy.

President Bush has the right to receive and meet with whomever he wants, but relations between the United States and Spain are not affected by that. It would only be lacking for them to depend on what President Bush may want or the conditions that may exist for an interview. We have a very significant increase in American investment in Spain, and the relationship between administrations works. We have not had any conflict, except for what is evident, which is that he did not share my decision at all. But between fulfilling the will of the citizens and never having a meeting with President Bush, because that seems to be what he wants, I am very clear: fulfilling the will of the Spaniards.

Thank you very much.