Speech and subsequent discussion by the President of the Government at the business roundtable organized by "The Economist."

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

24 November 2008 · Business roundtable organized by "The Economist"

Context
Zapatero addressed The Economist's business roundtable in November 2008, discussing Spain's response to the global financial crisis and coordinated government action.
Main themes
Global financial crisis, government coordination and cooperation, economic stimulus and reactivation, European Union leadership, public investment, fiscal policy, Stability Pact flexibility, market stabilization, Lisbon Strategy, transatlantic cooperation, emerging economies
Duration
~83 min
98th percentile
Words
9,939
98th percentile
Sentences
287
95th percentile
Readability
32
19th percentile
Grade
17.1
90th percentile
Syntax
3.54
95th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
20th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 65%64%
  • Geopolitical 12%12%
  • Social 10%10%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Institutional 4%3%
  • Environmental 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

287 sentences in 131 paragraphs

President.- Good morning. I would like to thank, first of all, "The Economist" for this new invitation to these sessions in which I have become a regular, where I have demonstrated my loyalty because this is the fourth occasion on which I appear before this prestigious forum, which always has such an impact and such success.

It is true that practically since the summer, since the month of August, every week seems decisive and significant for the economic situation, for expectations, and for the future. Every piece of news has a great impact; the markets show notable hypersensitivity, and we have witnessed and are witnessing phenomena that were hardly imaginable just a year ago when we shared this room to discuss the economic situation, especially with what has happened in the international financial system, particularly in the North American financial system.

Today, the news was published that the Federal Reserve has committed to capitalizing financial entities in the United States of America with an amount that amounts to 119 billion dollars. Surely, if this had been told to us a year ago in this room, we would have had a profound act of disbelief, and no one would have assumed that this was likely, but it has happened.

It has happened, and it is important that today we have the most accurate snapshot of the situation, starting from that data, from the unpredictability of the events we have experienced, and from an effort surely not seen since World War II on the part of governments, on the part of states, to tackle, to govern, and to manage a situation that could have been certainly grave, as we were practically in the last days of September and the first days of October in a genuine collapse of the financial system, which is the precursor to a collapse of the economic system, although, logically, the damages that have occurred will have effects, have effects, and will have effects for a certain time.

I said that the reaction that governments have had to adopt in response to the consequences that became most evident and caused their most harmful effects with the fall of Lehman Brothers has been an unprecedented reaction.

I would attribute two characteristics to that reaction of the governments. The first is that there has been a real willingness for collaboration and coordination: a real willingness for collaboration and cooperation, certainly very intense in the context of the European Union, of the Eurogroup; a transatlantic cooperation, with the difficulties and particularities of each area, and a cooperation and coordination that has been extended practically to all regions of the world, and that has also encompassed, perhaps even with less intensity, what we know as economically developed countries with emerging countries, where, in my opinion, a good part of the future of a scenario of stability, of a return to normality, and of order in the markets and in economic activity is at stake.

I want to emphasize that, from my perspective, the attitude and action of governments are not intended to replace the markets, because that would be an absolutely dangerous and harmful temptation, but to restore order in the markets, to ensure that the markets function again with the principles that should characterize them. I believe this is a fundamental principle position, and except for some very minority positions of the governments of the countries that count, this is the principle that has governed the entire conception and reaction that the governments have developed.

It was said that this week was going to be an important week because the European Commission is going to put on the table an action plan to reactivate the economy, which is affected by a scenario of recession for practically all developed countries as a consequence of the financial system crisis.

The position that the Government of Spain maintains in this regard is based on two principles: first, it is advisable that there is maximum possible coordination and that this coordination has the leadership of the European Union; second, the task of economic reactivation must meet two characteristics: the first, a stimulus to demand, through one of the two possible levers: either fiscal stimulus or an increase in investment. If it is about increasing investment, we must focus that increase in public investment on the central points, on the knots, that the Lisbon Strategy develops, that is, innovation, productivity, energy, infrastructure, and education.

This is what, from my point of view, underpins the possibility of an increase in public investment, an increase that, logically, is at the forefront of what could be a flexible interpretation scenario of the Stability Pact. If the Stability Pact states that the deficit of 3 percent can be exceeded in situations of exceptionalism, it seems quite evident that it will surely be very difficult for at least all of us here to experience a situation of exceptionalism like the one that has occurred and that, therefore, fits into what the Stability Pact is an exceptional situation that must have, from my point of view, a temporary character and a commitment, for those countries that need that demand effort, of a dimension and nature that have a productive imprint, that is temporary and that responds to the fundamental objectives.

As you also know, next Thursday afternoon I will present in Parliament, for debate with the different Parliamentary Groups, what is the Spanish plan for economic activation, in which I will summarize all the measures in progress that the Government of Spain has and all those that we are going to implement, fundamentally, in the line of stimulating demand through increased investment. It is a two-year plan, 2009-2010. Some of the measures are already approved, but the objective for it to produce effects and for its impact on the real economy, on the entire productive fabric, is fundamentally designed for 2009 and 2010.

I want to make a brief reminder of the measures we have been taking that, perhaps because they are already quite a number approaching eighty measures, may sometimes go unnoticed or even fall into a certain oblivion, particularly when they, logically, have their implementation time.

First of all, I want to remind you that the Government, with regulatory measures adopted in 2007 and 2008, has returned fiscally to families and companies, in what goes of this year 2008, an amount that rises to 14.9 billion euros and that, therefore, as November and December remain to be estimated, will surely approach 16.5 billion euros. This is a consequence of regulatory measures for tax reduction, for tax refunds in personal income tax and corporate tax, and some other complementary regulatory measure, such as the birth aid, which this year will import a fiscal benefit for those parents who have had the fortune of having a child of nine hundred million euros.

But, I repeat, tax reduction for families and companies, in what goes of the year, 14.9 billion euros and by the end of the year, at the end of 2008, it will reach 16 billion euros. This represents 1.6 points of Gross Domestic Product, it also represents, logically, a stimulus to demand through fiscal means and it also means that we are going to cut the tax burden in relation to GDP and with the latest data that had been known. But I wanted to highlight that, perhaps, we have been the country in the European Union that has taken the most measures for tax reduction.

I want to tell you that there is a pending regulatory transfer and approval for 2009, which is the elimination of the Wealth Tax, a tax that is certainly obsolete, which acted almost as a relic in the European order, which taxes in part what is also income and which will mean a new fiscal refund for families, in 2009, of 1.8 billion euros, as a new fiscal stimulus.

Therefore, the extent to which we are going to find ourselves in terms of tax relief or fiscal refund, any concept can be useful, is situated at eighteen billion euros between 2008 and 2009, which is a very considerable amount, as we are approaching almost two points of Gross Domestic Product.

As you know, in addition, the Government has been approving measures to increase the traditional lines of support for financing companies through the ICO. Specifically, we have approved a novel measure, which is being implemented, novel because it is very exceptional, which is a line of financing for the working capital of SMEs for a value of ten billion euros. We are convinced that, as soon as it is effectively in force, it can help a very large number of small and medium-sized enterprises in what they represent the difficulties they face regarding credit.

But, at the same time that we were implementing a tax reduction policy, and therefore more income capacity in favor of families and greater financial availability for companies, we were also strengthening social cohesion during this period, maintaining some of the fundamental objectives that have characterized our Government in that direction of increasing social cohesion. Why? Because the 2009 Budget maintains the effort to increase the lowest incomes in our country, which are the minimum pensions, which will rise by 6 percent, because the Budget for 2009 maintains the increase of 6 percent for scholarships to facilitate maximum equality in Education, and because the Budget we have approved maintains housing assistance for the most needy families.

In addition to this, we have taken a specific measure in favor of the unemployed, which is to facilitate the reduction of the mortgage payment for those unemployed who have a commitment to acquire housing and are financing it; to facilitate the reduction of the monthly housing payment by 50 percent, which is deferred for a period of two years and is backed by the State.

In short, we have made an effort undoubtedly, in quantitative terms, the greatest effort so far that has been made by a European government of fiscal measures to stimulate demand and improve the disposable income of families and companies, while strengthening social cohesion and addressing the great challenge of the financial system crisis.

I will not dwell on the measures in favor of the financial system. They are known, they were approved in the Eurogroup, they were approved by the European Union, and they were approved in the Parliament of Spain through two Royal Decree Laws practically unanimously, negotiated and agreed upon by the Popular Party. There are two measures, basically: a Fund for the acquisition of assets for financial entities, to facilitate their financing, for an amount of fifty billion euros, through the auction mechanism; the first has been held, new auctions will be held soon, and we are convinced that it is a good support mechanism. And, in addition, the mechanism to guarantee the debt issued by financial entities for an amount of up to one hundred billion euros in 2008 and another one hundred billion euros in 2009.

Along with this, the Government considers that the financial system, in addition to this support in which all states have brought out all the armada we have to sustain it, it is essential to work quickly on the reform of the financial system.

We have had the G-20 Washington Summit, where a plan of action for the reform of the financial system has been launched and approved by a broad consensus, unanimously. In March, a new meeting is scheduled, but in the interest, in the objective, and in the priority of the Government of Spain is that the European Union and, of course, the main actors who have shaped that Washington Summit carry out as quickly as possible the tasks aimed at ensuring transparency, a new model of supervision, fighting against tax havens, establishing more guarantees, and rethinking some financial products; to return, ultimately, to a financial system that provides security: security to investors, security to savers, security to depositors, and, why not say it, security to governments, because you can already imagine that all this earthquake that has been experienced in the financial system has also put governments in a compromised situation, from the point of view of the general security of the economy.

Security is the great objective. Secure markets are those that have clear and transparent rules, where it is known what can be done and where it is known who has to oversee what can be done. Supervising is not intervening; supervising is ensuring the proper functioning of things and, therefore, the lesson we must learn is that good supervision is a guarantee for all.

Financial reform measures cannot wait, and therefore we should not lose the momentum that was gained at the Washington Summit to achieve that objective.

You know that Spain worked to be at that Summit, which, from my perspective, the International Community and a country like Spain needed, that the eighth largest economic power in the world, which is the seventh power in the financial system and which has demonstrated to have a strong and solid model of supervision and regulation, as Spain has, fortunately now recognized practically by the whole world, should be present and participate in the architecture of the new international order, the new financial order, and also the new economic order. We have been at that Summit, we have participated, and, of course, our objective will continue to be to be part of that group of countries that have something to say for what they represent and for the ideas they are willing to put on the table.

Financial measures, therefore, to support the system so that normality returns, a normality that will return progressively, little by little; measures for economic reactivation and measures for economic modernization, which seem to me as important as those aimed at stimulating demand. I want to make a very specific reference to Spain and to what, within that economic reactivation plan for our country, we want to incorporate as priorities, some priorities that are already underway and some that we want to accelerate and intensify.

The first objective in the modernization effort of the Spanish economy is the reforms in the services sector, as well as in certain strategic sectors, such as transport, energy, and telecommunications.

In the transport sector, we have committed to introducing measures to improve the transport of goods by rail; a new model of airport management, which will include the privatization of part of the airport management of AENA, and a new economic regime and service provision for ports to improve their efficiency.

In the field of energy and climate change, the Government is focusing its efforts on reducing our dependence on oil and ensuring supply security. We have reached a good agreement with France to double our capacity to import and export electricity through France, and we have underway a Plan for the Activation of Savings and Energy Efficiency, which is an absolutely priority national objective. We must reduce our oil imports, we must save energy, and we must be much more efficient in energy consumption.

In telecommunications and the information society, we will continue to reduce the barriers that limit a more efficient use of the radio spectrum and we will approve a Telecommunications User Rights Charter with the aim of strengthening consumer protection.

And, without a doubt, the most ambitious effort in modernization that we are committed to is the demanding and rapid transposition of the European Services Directive, which will undoubtedly have a great impact on our legal framework and is intended to avoid any unnecessary obstacles or requirements that restrict the provision of services in our country. I insist, a priority objective and a task of great impact that will require a broad deployment of regulatory modification and coordination with the Autonomous Communities.

In that effort to modernize economic activity in our country, the Government is committed to carrying out a significant reduction of excessive and unjustified administrative burdens in our country. We have approved a plan to reduce them by 30 percent before the end of the Legislature, with which we are convinced that we will increase our growth capacity in the coming years.

The Spanish economy, as you well know, has experienced extraordinary growth in recent years. It may be the example of a developed economy that has grown the most, that has gained the most convergence in per capita income with the European Union, where we have already surpassed the average and even surpassed Italy. This growth has been supported by a strong boost in domestic demand, despite being a very open economy, and by a strong presence of the residential construction sector.

The economic situation we are going through will naturally determine us, and also by the effort of all the actors in the system, driven by the Government; it will lead us to an improvement and a reform of the growth model that we will have as soon as the international situation returns to normal.

I believe that the horizon we have, beyond overcoming this situation with the stimulus and the response that I have just briefly referred to, is that the Spanish economy gains in export capacity, is already gaining in export capacity, and the data for this year is encouraging and, therefore, that this is a reflection of the increase in productivity, of innovative growth, and of our country's expansion to be present in economic areas where it was practically absent until now and that are of great importance, especially Asia.

The horizon of the Spanish economy is also to significantly improve its external deficit, which will logically be a positive and reassuring factor, and the horizon of the Spanish economy lies in its improvement in the field of education.

We have a strong capacity for physical capitalization in our country. We are, surely, a country that, with the effort we are currently making in terms of physical capital infrastructure, transport infrastructure, will place us at the forefront of European countries in infrastructure modernization; we will recover the lost time in what represents the effort in research, development, and innovation, and, without a doubt, the great objective for that economic horizon of growth and job creation that the Spanish economy has demonstrated, for which it has great capacity, is education and, specifically, raising the educational level of those young people who leave school too soon, who leave school with compulsory education, is the great objective of the country.

The productivity we need to incorporate and the employability we need to increase in our country are centered on the effort we make in education in a very clear and prioritized manner.

I have told you, and with this I will conclude, that we had made a great fiscal effort to stimulate demand. We will increase it with the measures I will announce on Thursday. Fundamentally, they will be aimed at combating the unemployment that has grown and is growing in a very worrying manner, and which has its origin, basically, in the halt, in the strong reduction of the residential construction sector.

We are convinced that the process, in my opinion, consolidated in the short and medium term, of reducing inflation will lead us to an inflation rate of 2.5 percent for this month of November, which is a very positive figure; it will be lower in December and, logically, the entire outlook for 2009 will also be lower compared to what it was in 2008, and a monetary policy from the European Central Bank, which can only be thought of as a demand-stimulating policy in the coming times, will facilitate, from the point of view of the availability of income for families, a reasonable recovery of consumption that is extraordinarily conditioned by this magic word, which in economics almost no one is able to decipher, called "confidence," and which has a fundamental basis in the horizon and in the predictability that all economic actors, including governments, can offer to citizens.

With that data, which will alleviate the financial tensions of families, businesses, and also of states, the most negative forecasts for 2009, just as the forecasts made six months ago had a much more optimistic horizon and outlook… If that trend, which I estimate is a trend that will consolidate; if governments get it right in the demand-stimulating measures; if the new American administration consolidates, as I hope and wish, certainty and security, it is not only desirable but probable that the most pessimistic forecasts for 2009 can be improved.

This is the objective with which the Government is working, this is the objective with which the entire European Union must work, which, I insist, is willing to coordinate, and this is the objective that, from my point of view, the business world must also have.

The world economy has experienced a period of growth unknown until almost a year ago; it has been years of great vigor in the world economy, with good foundations in that growth and with a significant contribution from emerging countries. And there are more reasons to think that, to the extent that sufficient principles of trust and security are established in the financial system, the capacity to return to a growth path, which must prioritize central issues such as meeting the Millennium Development Goals or combating climate change, can be maintained for a reasonable time.

In short, the Spanish economy will overcome this moment of generalized recession and the Spanish economy has strengths in its public accounts, in its financial system, in the great capitalization in infrastructure that we have achieved, and a growth of the active population like no other country. It is true that this raises our unemployment rate, but it is a great asset for the future of economic activity and for demand for the sustainability of public accounts. There is no country in the European Union where its active population grows by nearly 3 percent.

Therefore, it is a young country; it is a country that incorporates many people into the workforce, where there are more and more people willing and eager to work, especially women, as a result of the great transformation that our society has undergone in favor of equality; and it is a country, like the vast majority, that has to make reforms and improvements. I have clearly identified them: reforming services to introduce more competition and reforming the sectors of transport, energy, and education to improve our potential.

Spain is today a country that responds in the functioning of the economy to principles that can convey trust and security. As you well know, I belong to a social-democratic political affiliation, but I have seen that during this time there have been and are in conservative political thought political leaders and governments with much more interventionist drive than mine. I believe that in the economy, intervention should be just enough to guarantee the security of economic actors.

Our country will continue to be an open country. I disbelieve in protectionism, which I believe is a retrogressive element for the progress and development of peoples. Our country will continue to be a country with a strong European vocation. The European Union has demonstrated that it is perhaps the greatest advance in governance of the common affairs that we have experienced since World War II, considered continent by continent, and that strengthening the European Union is strengthening the possibilities of our stability and security in all areas and, of course, also in the economic.

Spain will continue to be a very attractive country for foreign investment; it is being so in this complicated 2008, and, of course, we have the objective and the possibility of continuing to maintain, deepen, and develop a solid and efficient Welfare State, because a solid and efficient Welfare State is also good policy in favor of wealth creation. Guaranteeing education and good access to education, having a health system and a dependency care system, and a solvent pension system, as the Spanish economy has, generates social cohesion, and social cohesion is also a good fuel for wealth creation.

I therefore encourage economic actors, companies, and investors to keep alive the conviction that this moment of general crisis is long-lasting and difficult, and that it will recover. We will overcome the crisis. Fortunately, the economy, progress, and well-being of recent decades have shown how things can be done.

To the extent that more actors are convinced that this crisis will be overcome and will be overcome well, coming out of it well, we will advance all the possibilities we have today to ensure that the most difficult period lasts as little as possible, being aware of the magnitude of what we have ahead. President Obama said, I believe yesterday, that it was a historic crisis; but the degree of development of democracies and the development of the growing talent capacity that societies have demonstrated should give us security and confidence.

I hope, therefore, that the worst forecasts of international organizations in economic matters do not come true and that governments, citizens, and companies demonstrate how to face this situation and how to recover a path of growth.

In any case, I thank "The Economist" for this opportunity to convey these considerations that respond to a very deep conviction and a similarly deep assurance that we will win the crisis, that we will overcome this situation, and that, together, Europe and, of course, the United States, which is fundamental, will see growth and well-being again in a reasonable period of time.

What we have now is to draw lessons from the things that have been done wrong in order to put in place sufficient barriers so that we do not fall into the same mistakes again, although, looking at the history of Humanity, surely in fifteen or twenty years new mistakes will arise that will again need to be corrected. But, in any case, twenty years from now is not the topic of today's debate.

Thank you very much.

COLLOQUIUM WITH THE PRIME MINISTER

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Q.- Hearing the Prime Minister say that he will ensure that social spending remains there gives us a lot of peace of mind.

There are indicators that we have seen in recent months showing how Spain, for example, after being in a favorable position regarding waiting lists in the healthcare service, today finds itself in a somewhat less favorable position. That is why it is important to ensure that we continue working to increase the efficiency of our healthcare system to reduce those waiting lists that bring so many difficulties to the average Spaniard.

Johnson & Johnson made the decision a few months ago to be a leading sponsor of this event, to help with the commitment to the development of Spain and the commitment to the development of the entire world. We have a large operation worldwide with around 120,000 employees; in Spain, we are around two thousand and we remain, despite economic difficulties and challenges, committed to being part of the solution. And it is not by coincidence: our company philosophy is very clear that our priority is the patients, nurses, doctors, parents of those who use our products; our employees, the communities where we operate, and finally, the shareholders.

After 122 years of existence, those priorities have been there. As a large corporation, we went through the Great Depression of the 1930s. Our company philosophy was written during World War II and the priorities were clear: first, the patient; first, society; and lastly, the shareholders. Meeting those priorities has ensured that shareholders have done quite well, thank God. That is why it is important to highlight this today, here.

Through 120 years of existence, we have made very significant investments in R&D. That is why I am very interested in the alignment we have with the Spanish Government. Last year, we made around seven billion dollars in R&D investment worldwide. That represents around 10 percent of our revenue. This year, it will possibly be more than 10 percent of our revenue. Johnson & Johnson's commitment is serious and what do those investments bring? They bring more accurate diagnostics in healthcare, less invasive treatments, faster return to work, shorter hospital stays, fewer or less likely medical errors, and fewer side effects from pharmaceuticals.

Finally, we are interested in quality of life and economic growth being one of our main objectives.

To conclude, I just wanted to put the proposal on the table for all actors, as the Prime Minister rightly said, not only in the healthcare sector but in the entire industrial and economic fabric, to look at this crisis with optimism, to be conservative in projections and aggressive in investments to achieve the goal that the Government has for us to do better than we think. This is the philosophy that Johnson & Johnson has, and the invitation we want to make here today to the industrial and economic fabric.

And, as "The Economist" requests, I will end with a question for the Prime Minister, which is: having clarity after hearing your words about how the healthcare sector constitutes a fundamental element for the development of the country and if we agree on the importance of investing in healthcare technology, what is the Government's commitment in the next twenty-four months, which will be difficult, to improve the efficiency of our healthcare system?

Prime Minister.- I want to congratulate Johnson & Johnson, first of all, for their work and, secondly, for how well they explain it and the defense they make of their mission and business objectives. Furthermore, I want to thank that there is this general agreement on an idea, which is often discussed from certain perspectives, that has to do with the goodness of social cohesion and social policies, not only for balance, justice, and an aspiration for equality of opportunities that must exist in a society, but also for that society to be more effective, more productive, and more competitive.

To get down to specifics, there are two aspects that are decisive for increasing productivity: one of them I have referred to, it is structural and indispensable, and that is education, the improvement of education; the other has to do with social conditions, with social support policies for families and the population in two specific points: one, the reconciliation of work and family life, and the possibilities that public administrations offer for this purpose; and, two, the development and application of the Dependency Law, which, by the way, is a great generator of employment.

I want to say that since the Dependency Law has been implemented, seventy thousand jobs have been created in the sector. It is one of the sectoral areas that, despite the bleak employment outlook we have at the moment, continues to create jobs at a good pace, just like, by the way, the education sector. Therefore, among the measures that we are going to incorporate to strongly boost productive and social investment that I will present on Thursday, there will also be an important chapter for these two social anchors that are so decisive in improving productivity and, therefore, the economy.

Secondly, our healthcare system and healthcare spending have been yielding very satisfactory results, in comparative terms. The reputation of our National Health System is high and spending, investment, in healthcare has been increasing and will continue to grow in our country. This is the natural evolution.

As is known, the management of healthcare is in the hands of the Autonomous Communities and, as is known, we have ahead of us a reform of the financing of the Autonomous Communities, whose impact, as everyone can imagine, will be that the Autonomous Communities will have more capacity for public resources at their disposal, fundamentally for healthcare and education, which are the two major areas managed by regional governments and the two major areas of expenditure.

Our country offers, in certain areas, very interesting results in what concerns research in the health sector, in healthcare, and also in new technologies. Certainly, our capacity for computerization in hospital centers is known and valued, and this specific sector, that is, technological research in the healthcare field and the development of the entire adjacent field such as biotechnology, is undoubtedly identified as one of the priority investment areas of our National Plan for Research, Development, and Innovation, and will also receive an investment boost in the measures to meet demand.

Therefore, this is what I want to say and, of course, I thank you for the last words of confidence that, without a doubt, when they come from the business sector, carry as much or more weight than from governments, because we are almost assumed to have the obligation to convey that confidence and have an optimistic view of the economy and the future of our country; which, moreover, those who know me know is not strange or difficult for me to feel this way and to convey it this way, because I have confidence and I am optimistic about the future of the economy, well-being, and development of Spain.

Q.- I must also confess that in the opportunities I have had to speak with the Prime Minister, I have always admired, indeed, that always optimistic and creative stance of looking ahead, which has not only been here, but I must confess that he has always carried it. And I want to share that optimism with him in the medium and long term for our country.

I believe that our country has had great development, which has not only been about construction, and proof of that are the large Spanish companies in the telecommunications, financial, services, energy, and tourism sectors… That is to say, I believe that our country has experienced very significant growth in recent years based on the reduction of the cost of capital, based on a very orthodox fiscal policy, on a serious and professional administration that we have, also on a great business drive that are long-term movements that continue in our country, and on a great creation of active population.

Of the two major problems we had and still have, one of them is liquidity, and I believe that the Government has reacted seriously, in depth, and clearly by taking measures against that tough problem we had to face. Now it is necessary for that liquidity to reach companies, which will undoubtedly happen, and for us to continue in the productive process and job creation.

Then, in the PEAE, the Spanish Economic Activation Plan, which I believe will be a kind of "New Deal" and which we truly need in this economic adjustment we have as a change of cycle that our economy is undergoing, I believe there are very interesting measures. I fully agree with the Prime Minister that in terms of investments, a country is ultimately what its people are, their training, and the infrastructures. That is what attracts companies. Ultimately, for a country to create jobs, it has to be competitive. Competitiveness is the fundamental issue and competition is perhaps the most important lever of modernity. There, indeed, infrastructures, training, and innovation are three basic axes of growth.

But I would like to simply put four topics on the table, Mr. Prime Minister, that are also very important for companies, for job creation, so that we are more competitive in the international environment in which we find ourselves.

One of them is cheap energy and security in its supply. This is also a fundamental issue for business.

Another fundamental issue is to try to recover market unity as much as we can: to homogenize regulations, to homogenize… Having critical mass is very important for Spanish companies to remain competitive in all areas, and if we can incorporate something in the sense of recovering the single market, I believe it will be very important.

Another topic is income policies, which I do not know if it is contemplated in that plan: prudent and flexible income policies. I believe that is also another issue for entrepreneurs, for business it is fundamental.

There is a topic that I know the Prime Minister is concerned about and that he personally supports, which is support for Spanish companies abroad. Many times, there is still a lack of support from our embassies and even in our internal organization, in our internal administration. I know that the Prime Minister has dedicated time to this and, moreover, takes it as a personal issue; but that is very important, because Spanish companies going abroad ultimately create innovation, create wealth, create jobs, exports, etc.

Finally, it would be very important to incorporate regional and local bodies into a process like this, in a plan of this magnitude, perhaps giving them the necessary funding to carry out investments; fundamentally, funding for investments, again, to create the infrastructure capable of generating wealth in the future.

Once again, congratulations, Prime Minister, and I want to participate in that medium and long-term optimism, because our country has many assets, and very important ones, that can be valued and that transcend difficult and hard economic cycles, in which a significant adjustment is required, but that, without a doubt, we will know how to carry out.

Prime Minister.- All the topics you have raised are of great interest, in addition to your introductory words, which are logically very satisfying for the work we do; therefore, they deserve my most sincere gratitude.

I am fully convinced that the demand and need we have, as a country, and which I expressed earlier in my speech, to have a policy of savings and energy efficiency constitute the best source for our energy security. First, it is to save; secondly, it is to decisively bet on renewable energies, which are the future not only of the European Union but also of the new American Administration's program, it is extraordinarily valuable for improving our external deficit, for guaranteeing maximum security, and for contributing to the fight against climate change.

I am certain that the innovative capacity, from a technological point of view, will continue to improve costs in the entire renewable energy sector; but I must remind you that our companies and our researchers are at the global forefront in this field. Therefore, it seems reasonable that the country's strategy is a strategy of a decisive commitment to renewable energies and that we join all efforts, commitments, and plans that are in this direction at the European and international levels.

Supply security is an unrenounceable objective for a government, which does not have any alarm signals on the horizon. Therefore, we must always be attentive and have confidence and tranquility in this regard. To this end, we are implementing a strategic policy that also unfolds in different areas of interconnections, and that has our growing presence in various markets and what represents a capacity for dialogue with many countries that are fortunate enough to be the true energy producers.

I fully agree with what concerns the unity of the market. On the occasion of this process we are undertaking to transpose the Services Directive, we have certified that a very high percentage of the regulations that are impacted, from the perspective of promoting this improvement and liberalization, are regional regulations. The task will need to be done in a coordinated manner to be effective.

I am convinced that this is a matter that should be the subject of reflection and analysis by the major political forces; but there are sensitive aspects of regulation from the Autonomous Communities, which also have their regulation at the state level, that are worth considering to strengthen what can be a good functioning of the market, greater incentives for companies, and to avoid problems that certainly arise under certain circumstances.

I am going to make an act of trust in entrepreneurs and unions in this country. They have demonstrated their contribution to social peace, stability, and the governability of the economy and social issues. I am convinced that they will also know how to contribute their part in this moment of crisis, especially with such a serious impact on unemployment as we have, and that this process of negotiating income policies will be a reasonable process that adjusts to the circumstances we are living and that decisively bets on employment. I am confident that this will be the case, and I am sure that the CEOE, on one hand, and Comisiones and UGT will rise to the occasion that the economy and Spanish society require.

We are multiplying our efforts to support Spanish companies abroad, which is one of the major strategic lines we need as a country; but I mentioned it in passing and I reiterate now that the export data is very encouraging. Even in this moment of economic crisis, where there is a decline in global demand, our exports are growing and doing very well. I believe that the data we will have for the month of September is very positive, and it is encouraging how our deficit is being reduced and how our companies are conquering more and more markets. We had practically saturated our export capacity in what is the European Union, especially the eurozone, and now we are expanding with annual growth of 20 and 30 percent in many of the so-called emerging countries.

As is known, ICEX does a good job; in the 2009 Budget, we have substantially increased the investment allocated to export support, and it is true, but this happens, I believe, in many countries, that our diplomatic service, which is a very good diplomatic service, needs to incorporate into its priority activities what represents support for companies and being close to our export activity. To this end, we are working, within the slowness that you know is how things work in certain areas of the State Administration, on a reform of the Foreign Service that incorporates, as a priority element, in the training both of the career and of the post-training once a diplomatic position is obtained, the economic aspect, business promotion, and country promotion, as one of the essential aspects. I hope we achieve this.

Finally, undoubtedly, this new effort that we are going to launch for a substantial increase in investment will have infrastructure as its main protagonist. I know that this is good news for certain business areas because, in addition, it will respond to maximum efficiency and agility; but investing in infrastructure is always investing in the future.

I said in my speech that we should link infrastructure to the Lisbon Objectives, that is, infrastructure for energy savings and for water savings, infrastructure to facilitate transport in those areas where there are more possibilities for economic development and social infrastructure. That will undoubtedly be the commitment and the conviction that in that field and in local areas there is a possibility, a great lever, to, first, promote demand and, second, substantially reduce what is the loss of employment in the traditional residential construction sector.

I am very pleased that Mr. Falcones has highlighted everything that is the economy of this country, which is not, evidently, that 8 or 9 percent only of residential construction, because it is a bit, sometimes, incomprehensible that an image is wanted to be given that the Spanish economy is the economy of bricks, no. That is eight and a half or nine percent; the rest is an economy with productive, industrial, and technological sectors that are demonstrating leadership in the world; certainly, in renewable energies and, of course, in biotechnology and engineering, because we always talk about construction companies, because out of the ten largest construction companies in the world, six are Spanish...

When we say "construction company," it seems that we are also saying something linked to cement. No, they are engineering firms and, therefore, with great added value and a significant technological component. And it is a sign, from my point of view, of little knowledge not to value that.

Spanish engineering is very good and brilliant, as it is demonstrating. We have an accredited prestige. In my role as President of the Government and in my relations with other governments, whenever we talk about how our engineering constructs things, I do not always talk about our construction companies; one always feels the satisfaction of receiving great praise, just like from our energy sector, just like from our sector in biotechnology and in certain areas of the most advanced, also technologically, in which we are leaders.

It is true that, at times, we struggle with this imprint of confidence in what is the economy, but this is the economy of Spain and it is what has also favored growth, and not only bricks, not only residential construction. Proof of this is all the business potential that we have been able to deploy around the world and that, of course, are not residential construction companies or real estate developers that are dedicated to the residential sector, because their fundamental task has been in Spain.

It is logical that we live a process of adjustment in the residential construction sector, but that we continue to see the vigor and creation of new and more competitive companies in many other sectors where we have demonstrated leadership, know-how, and, of course, a volume, a number, of entrepreneurs in this country who provide or give us enough tranquility for the future.

Therefore, I greatly appreciate that consideration you have made, not to mention other assets we have, which now appear very evidently, such as our brilliant capacity to manage financial services that is being demonstrated with banks that in the world are giving the best image of leadership and effectiveness in management.

Q.- Mr. President, it is true that we are in a global crisis, but here, in Spain, we have our own battlefield with enemies, some of them very fierce, some structural, others not so much, and that, in principle, are those that the Government should confront most directly, in my opinion, and where it has the most ground. I believe we have all agreed on the identification of these, some of which are not easy to solve and, in particular, some require medicines that may be bitter. I am convinced that those measures, those medicines, only succeed or can succeed when there is a determined support from the President of the Government in particular.

Specifically, I am referring to measures such as those related to reducing public spending in its state aspect, to employment flexibility, or to immigration regulation in the interest of greater productivity. So, my question refers to whether you are determined to support measures that are aimed in that direction.

Q.- We represent a sector, the automobile, which accounts for 10 percent of GDP, 10 percent of employment, and 20 percent of exports; therefore, equally as important as construction or tourism. I am surprised that you have not commented on the plan for the automobile that Mr. Sebastián briefly mentioned to us yesterday, especially in terms of energy savings as he mentioned, the strong support plan from the Government towards electric vehicles. For example, if 20 percent of the Spanish car fleet were electric, we could save six billion euros on the energy bill. I am surprised that you have not mentioned anything about the automobile.

Q.- President, congratulations on the presentation, congratulations on the success at the G-21, and congratulations also on the results of November 4 and for having a President who shares another 4, this one in August, which is the birthday of the elected President and of you. My question is, as a representative of U.S. investments, how is productivity going to be improved in Spain, which will undoubtedly be the element that needs to be improved and adapted once this period of financial turbulence passes.

President.- All the questions have their substance.

Regarding the first, austerity in spending, in what is current spending or non-productive spending, all. There we are making the necessary effort. But the opinion of all experts and all governments at this moment, also the opinion of the Government of Spain, is that to give an injection of activity to the economy it is necessary to make a fiscal effort to stimulate demand, which has an orientation and that this temporary, circumstantial spending, which we are going to increase -- all governments are going to do it, will have an impact on an increase in the productivity of the country. I believe I have previously outlined the two objectives of that productivity: one, productivity linked to the major issues of the Lisbon Strategy; two, productivity linked to social investment that generates productivity in line with what we were talking about: reconciliation and the Dependency Law.

The labor market is often discussed. I believe that the labor market in our country has unique characteristics. With a percentage of temporality around 30 percent, it is, without a doubt, a space of flexibility in that labor market. The most evident proof is that job destruction occurs, predominantly, in what are temporary contracts.

Two, the agreement, the understanding, between employers and unions, the spirit of social dialogue is one of the great contributions to the Spanish economy; we must preserve it. Of course, there are issues that can be improved and deepened in terms of productivity, in income policies, and in linking everything that involves activity in a situation like this and the difficulties, to the agreements between employers and unions themselves.

But, of course, the Government will not be the one to take a unilateral initiative to call into question the basic foundations of the labor market in Spain. I know this is a recurring element. It is the element, if you allow me, the easiest to make in the discourse: in the face of difficulties, resorting to flexibilizing the labor market. I believe that what we need to do is not to flexibilize the labor market, but to strengthen the training of workers, their education, and to strengthen the innovative capacity of companies. This is much more useful in the medium and long term, because it guarantees social consensus between employers and unions.

Automobile sector. If I talk about all the things, of course, next Thursday I would be very limited in making any news, although it is evident that the proximity of this parliamentary debate with this act obliges me to give some hint. But it is in the action of the Government and in the planning of the Government to provide support. As the President of Renault well knows, tomorrow the Commission will release its Action Plan, and I know that the automobile, as a basic sector within the industry in the European Union, will have special consideration. So, I am waiting to know exactly the literalness of the European Commission's Action Plan to, from there, incorporate what will be our support actions for the automobile sector.

I want, in this sense, to convey a certain tranquility; but we must do it in coordination with the European Union. I think this is fundamental. I believe that this is what would give it effectiveness, especially in a sector like the automobile. I am very aware of the importance it has in exports and that it is one of our export strongholds, and I can assure you that we will do everything we can legally to maintain the strength and that stronghold of export and technological innovation in many fields that is the automobile sector.

We cannot do it alone, and we cannot do it outside the lines set by the European Union. We must be very clear about that. But from there, we will fully commit to that task. This has been one of the most debated elements in recent weeks within the European Union. I am sure that at this hour it is still being discussed by the various Commissioners to see how far and in what way that support for the automotive industry can reach. Tomorrow we will see the light, and from there we will apply, adapt, whatever our possible aid policy is within that framework; but, without a doubt, the automobile will be there.

Finally, improving productivity. The first thing to say is that productivity is improving. I believe that when we came to government, productivity was at 0.3 or 0.4 percent, growing at that rate, and now I think there is a cyclical moment that we must take with a certain prudence. But until we had the moment of deep deceleration, it was already growing above 1 percent. It is a substantial change in four years of government.

My opinion is that the trend will continue to be one of productivity growth in our country, and to achieve this, we must act on four fundamental fronts: one front that affects public administrations in their management, which has to do with the Services Directive and with the reduction of administrative burdens, which in some cases have been absolutely exorbitant in our country; two, it has to do with the training of workers, and for this reason, I have insisted so much on education, especially in extending the percentage of young people in our country who pursue higher education beyond compulsory education. This is the gap we have in relation to other European countries.

The goal for 2010 is to reach 85 percent of young people in the European Union who, starting at the age of sixteen, continue studying and therefore continue acquiring a qualification in the various possibilities. However, this is where Spain is clearly in unacceptable positions, because the percentage of young people who continue studying and training beyond compulsory education is around fifteen or eighteen points below the European average.

This is the great challenge, and allow me, it is a great challenge, especially to a large extent, for the Autonomous Communities that have competencies in education, training, and employment.

The third element to strengthen productivity is to improve social conditions in the aspects I mentioned earlier: reconciliation, more prominently.

And finally, to increase our spending on R&D&I. According to the data, this increase must come more from the private sector today, because the public sector has significantly increased spending on R&D&I in recent years, and the private sector, which needs incentives and support, has ahead of it the necessity to grow in R&D&I to get closer to what could be the European average.

For me, those are the three basic factors: a more effective management of public administration; less regulation for business activity, with reform and competition in the services sector; training and education after the age of sixteen, increasing that percentage; and, fourth, improving social conditions, especially reconciliation.

Q.- One last brief question using my privilege as president. As you mentioned, Spain is the eighth largest economy in the world and, however, it has not had an automatic place in the G-20. It has had to resort to special arrangements to be present there. Naturally, Spain should be present. What are you doing to institutionalize Spain's presence at the main decision-making table in the world, so that Spain, so to speak, can be present in the creation of any new global government that may arise from this crisis?

President.- It is true that it was an original G-20, because we were twenty-one; but it is no less true that the Three Musketeers were four. Therefore, these things happen sometimes.

I said that we have made a diplomatic and political effort to recognize that Spain was the eighth economic power in the world, that it had a very important financial system and that it should be at the table where the future of the financial system and the international economic order is discussed.

The formats that have worked so far have been different: the G-8, the G-20... It was decided that the G-20 would initiate the almost constitutional process around what will be a new financial system and, fundamentally, a new economic order, and we have been there.

What I must say is that the recognition has been a very broad recognition of what Spain is and can contribute, starting with our European partners, who have shown that they are partners and friends. This has great value in what it is and represents for the European Union, because the four big ones of the European Union, who have normally always occupied the highest decision-making positions internationally on behalf of Europe or as Europeans, have helped and have considered that Spain is there... In relation to the four big ones, we have somewhat fewer inhabitants, as most are in the fifty-something million range and Germany in the eighty-something, and our GDP, logically, is somewhat smaller than that of the four big ones. However, the European idea and the idea of recognition of Spain have functioned very clearly, just as in other countries around the world.

Our goal is to be among the group of countries that will mark the decisions in the financial order, in the economic order, and that, logically, have an impact on everything that is the international geopolitical order.

We have a strategy and an action plan that we have been working on even before we consolidated our presence at the Washington Summit. For this, we have, I insist, good friends, fundamentally in the European sphere; but you will understand that the last thing that can be done is to disclose a strategy. I can assure you that I would love to, because it would logically have a lot of informative interest and also for you; but, of course, if we disclose the strategy, we have undermined the strategy. This is always the case. I imagine it is the same in the business world; it is certainly so in the political world and it is also so in the diplomatic world when you have to go out to achieve.

What I can express are two ideas: first, we are heading in the right direction to achieve the objective, which undoubtedly everyone shares, that Spain is and is stably where it needs to be; second, it has great importance for our country. It is to take a definitive step in this process of growth and modernization that we have all carried out in the last twenty-five or thirty years, which a good part of governments, countries, and their citizens recognize and admire, and have admired in recent years.

It is common in international activity for people to say, "You have to see how Spain has improved, how Spain has changed; when one comes to Spain, the change that has occurred is impressive." This is usual. What we lacked was for that recognition to invite us to the table and to feel not just what we have changed, but what we are and what we have to contribute from that change we have achieved.

For the confidence of the country in ourselves and for the confidence of business and the economy, consolidating that position has great significance, because surely due to our past, not the recent one, but the past of the last two centuries, doubts sometimes return to the national debate about what we are, what we have achieved, what we are capable of doing, and what we represent in the world.

This will be a formula to forever dispel the doubts about what Spain means today, about its strength, its value, and its influence in the world. Therefore, I have a clear commitment, not only because it will benefit our economy and our dialogue, but because, as a country, it will be the moment when we leave behind forever the doubts about what we have all done together.

Thank you.