Speech and subsequent discussion by the President of the Government to present the objectives of the Spanish Presidency of the European Union at an event organized by the Association of European Journalists.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

11 February 2009 · Event organized by the Association of European Journalists · Carlos de Amberes Foundation, Spain

Context
Zapatero addressed the Association of European Journalists in Madrid on February 11, 2009, to outline Spain's objectives for its upcoming 2010 EU Council Presidency.
Main themes
Spanish Presidency of the European Union, European leadership, global economic crisis, Treaty of Lisbon, European integration, multilateral international order, climate change, protectionism and nationalism, EU institutional reform, Millennium Development Goals, sustainable economic model
Duration
~71 min
97th percentile
Words
8,538
97th percentile
Sentences
332
96th percentile
Readability
41
39th percentile
Grade
13.7
64th percentile
Syntax
3.24
76th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
24th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 25%24%
  • Economic 24%23%
  • Institutional 23%22%
  • Social 18%17%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

332 sentences in 145 paragraphs

My gratitude, first of all, to the European Journalists Association and, in particular, to its President, Diego Carcedo, for his words, and to its Secretary General, Miguel Ángel Aguilar, as well as to the Carlos de Amberes Foundation that hosts us, for this invitation to speak to you about the projects for the Spanish Presidency of the European Union in the first half of 2010.

There are still a few months to go, but we already know that ours will have to be a demanding and committed Presidency. There are a few months left, and it is true that the Spanish Presidency of the European Union is not yet widely discussed, and I am convinced that the European Journalists Association, which has played a decisive role in our European commitment, will be a catalyst for the debate on the objectives and challenges of that Presidency.

There could be no other attitude from a European country like Spain. We will assume this Presidency at a complex and uncertain time like the one we are living in; so complex and so uncertain for the international community, for each of its States, and also for the Union, for its current reality and for its future.

We need, as rarely in the last few decades, a strong Europe that knows how to exercise its leadership. And, since such a thing is not guaranteed today, our commitment to that idea of Europe must be, if possible, greater at this moment.

Allow me, then, to begin this intervention by talking about Europe, about Europe today; that is, about Europe in the face of the serious global economic crisis we are suffering; about Europe in the face of the challenge of building a sustainable and balanced productive model; about Europe in the face of the pending challenge of its own political integration; about Europe, finally, in the undoubtedly desirable but not easy transition towards a multipolar system of international relations, because all this is what Europe has at stake now and in the coming months.

It is, therefore, on that reality, which can be viewed with hope but also with fear of frustration, on which Spain will exercise, with all the consequences, its committed and demanding Presidency.

I do not intend with these words, in case there is any doubt, to invite a theoretical reflection, always welcome by the way, on the European project; what I propose seems to me more pressing: it is to seek solutions and to accurately define the role of Europe, of the Union, of its institutions and of its actors for an immediate present and future surrounded by uncertainty.

I will try to express it with all clarity to reflect the intensity of my conviction: the European leadership in this time of crisis will largely determine when and how we, the member countries, will overcome it, and the leadership of Europe in this time of change will determine the structure of the new international financial system and the greater or lesser commitment to a just and balanced international order, to the fight against climate change, and to the achievement of the Millennium Development Goals.

All this does not depend solely on the leadership of Europe, on a responsible and active role of the Union, it is true, but without it, none of the aforementioned will be the same. And for Spain, for the majority position of Spanish citizens, it will be worse; undoubtedly, much worse. For Spain, the success of this approach will be key to its own success.

In short, and paraphrasing some well-known terms, Europe must be, in this imprecise constituent trance in which the world finds itself, an indispensable power. Indispensable, which is the opposite of dispensable.

In my opinion, the Union has shown positive attitudes, of leadership, in the reaction to the financial crash of September, but we cannot feel so satisfied with other behaviors that we are seeing in some corners of the Union these months. There are some disturbing symptoms of anti-European nationalism, of xenophobia, and the protectionist temptations are also visible. We have not always succeeded in this last period in modulating leadership within the Union, in combining the institutional leadership of the Council with that of some member countries, and in jointly promoting the more active role that apparently we all desire, and also the role that we must recognize for the Commission.

To achieve all these objectives, we need a strong Europe, which is what we began to design in the Treaty of Lisbon: the Europe of integration, of solidarity, of innovation, of competitiveness, of education and of citizenship, and the Europe with a single voice in the world in a definitive way.

For a stronger Europe, the Treaty of Lisbon creates strong institutions: a President of the European Council who must be a personality with political weight, an effective High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy, and an independent and dynamic European Commission, with a European Parliament that strengthens its powers.

If things go as expected, the implementation of the Treaty will essentially take place during the Spanish Presidency, but as of today, it depends on the Irish referendum. Ireland, by the way, is not the cause of our weakness, of the weakness of Europe, but rather its consequence.

As you know, the Irish government has committed to holding a new referendum on the Treaty of Lisbon before the end of the current European Commission's mandate, that is, before the next November 1. I trust that the Irish people will appreciate the effort that the European Council has made, as far as it could, clarifying the scope of the issues that the Irish government conveyed to them; that they will value that and, above all, their interest in supporting the Treaty to build that stronger Europe, which could well seem more pressing in the eyes of the Irish in these times of acute crisis that affects us all.

Spain strongly wishes for that support to occur. For the Spanish Presidency, it will undoubtedly be easier to work in favor of the strength of Europe by launching the new institutional framework; but we will pursue this objective in any case, with or without a new Treaty, and we have planned for both scenarios.

Moreover, in a way, we are going to anticipate Lisbon by doing something truly innovative, which is to prepare a Presidency in coordination, as is natural, with the previous Presidency, Sweden in this case, and also in a trio with the two subsequent ones, Belgium and Hungary, which will provide greater continuity to the process and will be beneficial for all Europeans, in what the State Secretariat for European Affairs, with the Minister at the helm, has been working on in recent months and which culminated in an agreement precisely last night.

Ladies and gentlemen,

Fifty years ago, Europe was built on economic and energy development, with agriculture, with the common market, and with what Schuman called "de facto solidarities."

For the Government of Spain, today, in a globalized world, the strength of Europe must be based on two great principles: the capacity to generate innovation in all areas, the transformative will, and the promotion of equality in its various manifestations, both within the Union and outside of Europe. All the actions of our Presidency will be guided by these two cross-cutting driving ideas.

We understand innovation not only as technological but also as economic, institutional, and political. Innovation is a sine qua non condition for Europeans to emerge well from the crisis, with the real possibility of generating new jobs and better jobs. There is nothing more opposed to this great objective than to become a sort of great museum without weight in the world.

The second idea is that of equality. Europe has led the fight for equal opportunities and for solidarity among social groups, among regions and States; also externally, having become the world's leading donor of development aid; and for gender equality. The world we are now building needs to deepen equality, solidarity, and cohesion. Europe's leadership at this moment lies in asserting this hallmark of identity.

Innovation and equality will give meaning and will permeate the three priorities of our Presidency:

The European dimension has been present from the outset in the measures we have taken in response to the crisis. There has been European coordination not only among States but also with the institutions, within the Council and through the leadership of the Commission, to launch a stimulus of two hundred billion euros, 1.5 percent of the community GDP.

Already at the G-20 Summit in Washington, we opted for a coordinated exit from the crisis. Now, at the beginning of April, in London, we must complete the task by participating in the design of the new financial system, which cannot wait too long. Prior to that, preparatory meetings will be held among the 27 and the European governments that will attend London to harmonize our positions. The European Union must go to London prepared to speak with one voice and lead a meeting that goes beyond joint statements and makes decisions in the short and also medium term, through a task that will extend over time.

I do not need to remind you at this moment what it means for Spain to participate in this global constitutive project, having joined the group of countries that lead it. For unfortunate and well-known historical reasons, we were absent from Bretton Woods, San Francisco, and even Rome. This time we have regained the place that corresponds to us as a country.

The real possibility of asserting the position of the European Union would not have been possible without what is today one of our main assets: the euro. The role of the European Central Bank, to provide liquidity to the financial system and facilitate the reduction of interest rates, is proving decisive and will prove decisive for the exit from the situation.

To the doomsayers of the euro - there are always doomsayers about almost everything, who sow the idea that the Monetary Union, which has just turned ten years old, is in danger - I would reply that the single currency has constituted and constitutes a bastion of stability that, above all, is the most valuable and decisive asset in times of such uncertainty as we are living. It is not by chance, therefore, that there is now a long waiting list to join the Monetary Union.

Creating the most dynamic and economically competitive area in the world was the goal we set when we adopted the so-called "Lisbon Strategy" also ten years ago, when the euro was launched. This innovative path has yielded positive results, but below initial aspirations. We need a reinforced European economic strategy, equipped with new instruments to build the Europe of innovation and employment. We cannot wait another ten years to achieve it.

Therefore, during the Spanish Presidency, we will promote a thorough review, which means a review to address the roots, of the Lisbon Strategy. For this, coordination will not be enough. In the medium and long term, we must think of more advanced strategies. After the experience of this crisis, we must take bold and daring steps that will truly allow us to achieve that the European Union quickly becomes the most dynamic economic area in the world.

To ensure that Europe transforms into the engine of the global economy and moves towards political union, we must also progress in a common energy policy. And it is, again, during our Presidency that the II Triannual Energy Action Plan 2010-2012 must be implemented. We must also advance the plan for major infrastructures in Europe.

The European Union must remain at the forefront in the fight against global warming and its effects. The results of the Climate Change Summit in Copenhagen next December, which must lay the foundations for a post-Kyoto agreement, will depend greatly on our unity and clear objectives. The attitude of the new Obama Administration is very encouraging regarding the policy change that the United States will advocate.

Therefore, the first priority of the Spanish Presidency: to continue the fight to leave the crisis behind and to raise a new economic model that is more competitive and, above all, more innovative and more sustainable, in a radical defense of sustainability as the main axis of the most advanced and innovative economies in the medium term.

The second priority is the deepening of social Europe, of social rights, and of effective equality between European women and men. In summary, it is about recovering and enhancing the concept and practice of European citizenship in its social dimension.

Against the projected, interested, and persistent suspicion for several years by neoconservative currents of thought, the model of the European social economy has become the model to follow to overcome this crisis.

We must update and strengthen the policy of economic and social cohesion, which has yielded such good results in Spain, among other countries, and which can now be extended to the countries and regions that have entered the European Union with more delay. For this reason, we aim to promote a new statute on the Outermost Regions.

I also intend to advance in the establishment of a European civil society definitively anchored in gender equality, opening up the public and private spaces that still resist it, and to make the fight against gender-based violence a European objective enriched with the best contributions from some of the member States.

Perhaps one of the programs that has contributed the most over time to building Europe from its very foundations has been "Erasmus," the scholarship program for students. I will propose to expand this type of program to other areas of professional life.

We will also take advantage of the Spanish Presidency to continue shaping a genuine European immigration policy. We hope to make significant progress in the full integration of immigrants into our societies, in creating a framework for smooth dialogue and cooperation with the countries of origin and transit of immigration, and in establishing new systems for controlling our external borders.

In particular, Spain has developed a national immigration policy. We have achieved this without xenophobic outbursts in Spain like those we see and have seen in other places. We have managed to convey our vision to the European Union and, together with the other Member States, begin to build a common policy.

Our fundamental objective must be to strengthen the values of freedom, human dignity, security, and justice, that is, the defining and therefore non-negotiable traits of the Europe in which we believe.

A new dimension for our Presidency: 2010 will be the European Year for the Fight against Poverty and Social Exclusion, which is tantamount to proclaiming the year of solidarity, both within and beyond the borders of the Union.

We will insist in London, and of course during our Presidency, that in these moments of financial crisis and global economic slowdown, there must be a special effort to prevent developing countries from seeing a decrease in the channels and flows of financing necessary to achieve their development goals.

My Government remains committed to allocating 0.7 percent of Gross Domestic Product to Official Development Assistance by the end of the current Legislature. The fight against hunger and poverty must continue to be a priority objective in Spanish cooperation policy and European cooperation.

Europe's leadership in the future will largely depend, in my opinion, on its growing commitment to development cooperation policy; a policy, a commitment, let us not forget, that has a double value: an indisputable and urgent moral value, on the one hand; and a value in preventing conflicts that fuel extreme poverty, on the other.

European cooperation for the development of peoples allows us to renew European ideals. The founding idea of Europe was peace. Peace remains Europe's destiny, but peace for all can no longer be conceived without solidarity.

Consequently, we want the Spanish Presidency to be judged also by the progress made in the European social model, in effective equality between men and women, in common immigration policy, and in development cooperation. I cannot and do not want to forget the defense of human rights, which is one of the fundamental pillars of European construction and its projection abroad. Unfortunately, there has been a loss of weight of Europe in this area, which we must recover.

And so, I turn to address, finally, our third priority.

A multipolar world offers Europe new opportunities for leadership, but we must know how to seize them. We are the world's leading trading power, the largest donor of foreign aid, and the second in military capacity. If we want to assert these attributes on the international stage, it is essential to advance in the integration of Foreign and Security Policy. Both the current open situation and the Treaty of Lisbon provide us with an excellent opportunity to do so.

First of all, I intend for the Spanish Presidency to give a boost to Croatia within the European Union and to Turkey's aspirations to join the Union. That great country has been waiting too long at our doors.

I want the Spanish Presidency to be distinguished as "Euro-American," in the broadest sense of the term.

Of course, we must give central importance to the relationship between the European Union and Latin America and the Caribbean, working intensively to strengthen this bi-regional strategic partnership that we have been building in recent years.

In this regard, we will make every effort to ensure that the VI Summit Europe-Latin America and the Caribbean constitutes a qualitative leap in strengthening the essential relationship between two regions of the world that share strong historical, social, cultural, and economic ties; and, definitively, also democratic values and principles and a commitment to peace, human rights, and multilateralism.

We aspire to see the signing of the Association Agreement between the Union and Central America materialize, the first of the Agreements between both regional blocs.

In the new multipolar world that is emerging, Europe and the United States must continue to be essential allies and partners. We have a wonderful opportunity to strengthen the transatlantic relationship with the new American Administration, but Europe must also be capable of responding to those expectations, of being up to the circumstances. And what must apply to the fight against climate change and to trade negotiations to finally close the Doha Round must also apply to taking on more responsibilities in maintaining international peace and security, especially in our closest environment, and also in the distant one, when world peace is at risk.

In 2010, it will be fifteen years since Spain, during a previous Presidency under another socialist government, promoted what came to be called the New Transatlantic Agenda to improve relations between the European Union and the United States. Well, we aim for the EU-U.S. Summit, which we will hold in the spring of 2010, to approve a Renewed Transatlantic Agenda.

The neighborhood policy will also occupy a relevant space in our Presidency, whether with the Union for the Mediterranean (Euromed), whose Summit we hope to hold when we also celebrate fifteen years of the Barcelona Process, and with Morocco, with which we hope to deepen the Advanced Statute of association already achieved.

Likewise, the Spanish Presidency will look to Africa, a continent that is becoming increasingly important to us day by day. In this case, our relations are based on two pillars: the Global Political Dialogue between the European Union and Africa and the Joint Strategy between the European Union and Africa approved at the last Lisbon Summit.

Regarding Russia, we must integrate it into the building Euro-Atlantic space. The attitude of both the current Russian leaders and the Obama Administration opens a window of opportunity that we must seize, which we cannot under any circumstances renounce.

We will also develop extensive external activity in other parts of the world, promoting relations with Asia. Specifically, I highlight the relationship and the Summit with Japan, and we will promote relations, already quite consolidated, with China and India. The rebirth of China spoke of rebirth because in 1820 China represented 33 percent of the world's GDP, alongside India, which is one of the great changes in our world in this century.

And, of course, there is the Middle East and the efforts that Europeans must dedicate to achieving regional stability and peace that starts from a new beginning that first consolidates the ceasefire and subsequently allows for the resumption of a peace process between Israelis and Palestinians.

We will decisively promote the European Common Security and Defense Policy. Naturally, in this area, whether or not the Treaty of Lisbon comes into force will not be indifferent at all.

We will seek to promote the development of the revised European Security Strategy, setting strategic objectives in relation to operations, capabilities, and partnerships. Previously, because it is closely linked to this, we intend to develop a National Security Strategy, which I believe will be very useful for the work of the Administration, but also for citizens' understanding of the challenges we face.

Subsequently, we will pay special attention to the relations between the European Union and NATO, and we will study the possibility of proposing the creation of a specific formation of the Council in the format of Defense Ministers.

In particular, I wish for the Presidency to allow progress in the effort to achieve an effective moratorium on the death penalty by 2015.

Ladies and gentlemen,

As you can see, we are preparing a Spanish Presidency with a very ambitious agenda. Our diplomacy is working at full capacity. I am aware of this, as I am also aware, and we have the recent experience of the French Presidency, that unforeseen issues may arise that condition the execution of that agenda and force us to adjust priorities. But the starting point must be ambitious.

The Presidency is a great opportunity for Spain, and it is at this decisive moment for Europe because it is for the world.

At this point, I can tell you that we have made a detailed planning of all the scheduled meetings and the agendas of those meetings, from the European Councils to the working groups that will meet over the six months.

The Spanish Presidency constitutes a challenge that transcends the governmental sphere and presents itself as the paradigm of a state issue, above party interests and aimed at achieving a great national project.

Therefore, we will make a special effort to reach a consensus on the Presidency's program with parliamentary forces, first of all, and with the Autonomous Communities. My aim, in this regard, is to soon initiate a consultation process with everyone to inform them about the planned plans and gather their ideas and support to complete and improve them. And we will subsequently present the program, as is logical, in Parliament, in the Congress of Deputies.

This is undoubtedly a central event of the Legislature and the coming years for Spain, which must be shared openly and transparently with society as a whole, with those citizens, the Spaniards, who have always felt so European and pro-European. This is the reason for my presence in this Association, to do so before civil society and before a large group of people, of Spanish pro-Europeans, such as this Association, who have contributed and can contribute in this period in a very decisive way to the success and achievement of the objectives of the Spanish Presidency.

It so happens that in a few months they will all have the opportunity to participate in the elections to the European Parliament and, therefore, to become aware of the importance, which the various political forces should be able to convey, of the Union and its future.

As you know, these upcoming elections will inevitably have to be held according to the rules of Nice, so we will elect fifty deputies in Spain, four fewer than we would be entitled to with the Treaty of Lisbon already in force. However, I want to remind you that the European Council has heeded our request and we will recover those four seats when that entry into force occurs.

Ladies and gentlemen, I conclude.

In a world of uncertainties, with the collapse we have experienced of the great models inherited from the last century, we need a model and a great commitment from governments and societies to emerge from the crisis. That model is Europe, because Europe is, above all, the "European peace" and because European peace is coexistence, rights, well-being, creativity, and freedom. It is the guarantee to guide us in a multipolar world, which bases its stability on achieving sustainable and solidarity-based development.

European peace will be supported by equality and innovation as the two great values of the present and the future.

European peace is, as we have known for three decades, the best way for Spain to defend, from our condition as Europeans, its principles and interests.

At a time when European and global efforts will converge to recover an agenda that allows us to overcome the confusion and uncertainty of the present, and at a time when we will receive proposals for a future agenda for the European Union from the Reflection Group chaired by Felipe González, I believe that the only alternative for Spain will be to exercise a transformative Presidency and not a managerial one. I believe that the only alternative for Europe will be to strengthen its institutions, before Europeans and in the world. Salvador de Madariaga already said that "Europe will not be a reality until it is in the consciousness of the people."

Today I want to end by expressing my conviction that Europe, with a Spanish Presidency, will know how to rise to that historical demand, consolidating and transforming policies so that the Union becomes increasingly perfect; the objectives, more shared; and the institutions, more agile and sensitive to the will and aspirations of citizens.

Thank you very much.

P.- Mr. President, you mentioned that one of the objectives for the Presidency will be to encourage competitiveness. In Spain, we had a speech yesterday from the Governor of the Bank of Spain saying that it is essential that we encourage competitiveness with a labor reform here in Spain, and if we do not do so, economic growth could drop to the European average or even lower. I would like your assessment of that forecast from the Governor.

The Governor also said that he did not rule out the possibility of a government intervention in some banking entity in the future. Can you comment on this?

President.- I think we started with few European questions and rather national ones. I have made every effort for the speech to be suggestive enough so that we could delve into the substantive issues of Europe, but I see that we are sticking to concrete matters.

Fortunately, there are diverse opinions regarding the most pressing needs to recover competitiveness and productivity in Europe and also, in this case, in Spain. There are some things that the Governor said that I share, and others that I do not. That, on the other hand, I believe demonstrates a good sign of democratic health. Normally, I try to appoint those responsible for these institutions, not so much for their loyalties, but for their qualities, and the Governor of the Bank of Spain has them well accredited.

What do we need to boost our competitiveness? Two things, basically. Improving the education extension ratios for young people beyond compulsory education is the first objective, the first need, to improve the competitiveness of the Spanish economy. Why? Because we need as many workers as possible, especially young people, to have the best training, with a higher level of education. We are ten to fifteen points behind the European average in this regard.

In the thirty years of extraordinary democracy, we have made a significant leap in the extension of education. When our education data is sometimes discussed, it is forgotten where we come from and what the data was on higher or secondary education for many families at the dawn of democracy, which is a conditioning factor for the education of children.

This is the first objective: to extend education, and logically the quality of it, as much as possible. The second objective is to increase our investment in Research and Development. In recent years, we have made a great leap and have approached, according to 2006 data, 1.30% of GDP, but we are below a target as reasonable as 2% of GDP in research between the public and private sectors. The public sector has almost tripled its investment, and some of the effects of this tripling of investment in Research and Development are now taking effect.

We always have a problem with European data, which is that the data, usually from Eurostat and sometimes from the Commission, has a certain delay. However, from our perspective, it can be verified that 2007 and 2008 have represented a strong increase in Spain's innovative and research potential.

These are the two basic conditions, the most important ones.

In which sectors should we prioritize the improvement, the transformation, of the economic model in Spain and also in Europe? Where is, from my point of view, the great window of opportunity to generate a more competitive and innovative economy, and also more stable employment? Without a doubt, and this will be the Government's bet, it has been so, but now we are going to reinforce it just to prepare for the exit from the economic crisis, it is in the sector, the broad sector, that today constitutes environmental sustainability: priority for renewable energies, but also energy reuse, energy savings, treatment and management of our wealth in water resources, everything that represents preservation in the rural area, reforestation, etc. We must be a great power in this sector, and we already have the best conditions because, in research and in high-tech companies, in some of these areas we are very strong.

This will be Spain's great bet. In my opinion, it is a winning bet, a bet with great export potential, a bet with great potential for creating stable employment, and a bet that will also require or allow the readjustment of part of the construction sector, where we have a high level of competitiveness. We talked about housing construction, and we must remember that there are many things that serve to build houses that are the result of innovation and have created wealth, which can be perfectly readjusted to what the entire sustainability sector is.

These are, in my opinion, the great lines.

Labor market? I do not want to evade it. The United States has the most flexible labor market in the world and is destroying jobs with figures not seen in thirty years. What creates jobs is economic activity, and a society with workers with rights, with increasingly better wages, and with a solid Welfare State is a more competitive society. Social rights and social welfare create wealth because the more citizens we have with better education conditions and better support for work-life balance, the more economic potential we will have.

The other represents theses that we have seen are within the catalog of recipes included in neoconservative postulates: no regulation, no intervention, slimming down the Welfare State... The results are not satisfactory, and we certainly should not go down that path.

P.- Mr. President, my question relates to the speech you just delivered. You said that in the coming days or dates you plan to meet or call political parties and Autonomous Communities to reach a consensus for that important date of the Legislature, which is the European Presidency. I would like to know if you believe that at this moment, in this political moment we are living, the Popular Party will be willing to accept your call, considering that yesterday they broke relations with the Ministry of Justice or that they accused you of...

A second part was that, as you were accused yesterday of being the Government that was using public institutions the worst or that was using them the most, whether you still have no doubt about that meeting.

President.- This answer is very quick: I have no doubt that yes, of course. Moreover, we have already spoken with the Popular Party and will talk in more depth as the months approach the European Presidency.

P.- Mr. President, I had two questions about your speech. You said that Europe must take on more responsibilities and maintain international peace and security. I wanted to know what you mean exactly, considering that you have said that if we are asked for more resources for Afghanistan, the answer would be "no."

I also wanted to ask you if, given that when Spain assumes the rotating Presidency there will still not be a permanent Presidency of the European Union, you would be willing to assume or if you think it would be good to assume such a personalistic Presidency as the one Sarkozy had.

President.- Regarding the first question, fortunately, global responsibilities in favor of peace and security are not only military responsibilities. We must achieve that Europe, with the International Community and especially with the United States, conquers more peace scenarios through politics. I am confident that politics is a path that also leads to peace, to conflict resolution, and to providing stability to certain areas where there is currently more insecurity, more uncertainty, and more concern.

Moreover, I am convinced that this reflection is part of what will be the new strategy of the North American Administration and that Europe must share it and commit actively, because the opportunity that has opened up with the change of Administration in the United States to widen political, diplomatic, and agreement avenues to reduce conflicts cannot be wasted.

The second question is quite simple. For me, Mr. Sarkozy had a very good French Presidency of the European Union. He set the bar very high. We will try to do our best, but the bar has been set very high.

P.- One of the problems that Italy and Spain share is the illegal immigration of "undocumented" individuals. I believe you are very close to this problem. What solution should Europe provide for the undocumented? Is Frontex viable or not?

President.- The problem of illegal immigration must be combated on two fronts. The first is the internal front, the front of the borders. And I believe that the development of Frontex, certainly in the case of Spain, has been positive and useful. Among others, we have had collaboration from countries like Italy to prevent the departure of illegal immigrants from the coasts of sub-Saharan Africa.

That is necessary, but the most decisive factor is that immigrants, who are people we call illegal, can have a work opportunity and a life expectation in their countries. For this, it is absolutely essential that all the major European countries, the European Union, the United States, and developed countries fulfill the Millennium Development Goals set by the United Nations, and facilitate financing for a productive structure in the countries where this outflow dictated by extreme poverty is occurring, so that they have another new opportunity.

In my opinion, this second policy is absolutely essential and a priority. And I believe that we have a path to travel here. We can put more resources into Frontex, we can tighten legislation, or we can contain illegal immigration; but the underlying problem is of a magnitude that has much more to do with what happens there than with what happens here, on our coasts and in our streets. I think Miguel Ángel Aguilar put it very well: unless we export prosperity to many areas of the world, our well-being will end up being affected.

P.- The return of France to NATO's integrated military structure, will it have any reflection, will it be compensated in some way, or will it activate any mechanism of European defense? Will there be any counter-performance?

President.- I believe that these are paths that run parallel, but there does not necessarily have to be an impact or a consequence. European defense policy must advance, and NATO cannot be an excuse or a brake to develop and consolidate a much stronger European defense policy. It will be much more useful for Europe, but also for the perspective of Atlantic security.

We know that this always produces some friction problems, but in this I must say that Spain and France are perhaps the countries with the most will and determination to develop an increasingly integrated and stronger European defense policy.

P.- At the beginning of your speech, you said that Europeans cannot feel so satisfied with behaviors that we are seeing in the Union these months and cited worrying symptoms of anti-European nationalism, xenophobia, and protectionist temptations. I would like to know, Mr. President, if you can name names and surnames of those who have these symptoms.

President.- Well! One is in the newspapers, and certainly, it seems that it is good manners not to point fingers and not to put any group, let alone a country, in a somewhat complicated position. We have all seen it. They are minority, but I believe that Europe of freedoms, the Europe of rights, must always give a strong response to any expression of this nature, even if it is minority and temporary, which, in my opinion, are the two characteristics of the phenomena we see on some occasions, as in recent weeks or months.

P.- Mr. President, in the general context of your speech, you spoke of your hopes placed, after the G-20 in November, in the next meeting in April. I would like to know what your optimism is based on if the "roadmap" and the objectives set at the G-20 in November have practically not been fulfilled. The same European leaders already complained that, upon returning, each one dedicated themselves to their own. What can your hopes be based on if the economic situation is even worse than in November?

Secondly, regarding protectionism, shall we forget about the 150 euros? I mean the 150 euros to spend only on Spanish products.

President.- I believe that the Washington Summit had two commitments, adopted two commitments, from all the countries that were there. The first commitment established a work program for the reform of the international financial system, a work program that will need, at least, after the London Summit, still a few months for its implementation, because, as everyone knows, it is extraordinarily complex. That work program contained principles, a "roadmap," that the G-20 countries have been working on and on which documents will be seen at the London Summit.

There is no doubt that the sooner we reform the International Monetary Fund, the World Bank, the rules of supervision, and the coordination of the rules of supervision in the financial system, the sooner we will give more confidence to the international financial system. But this is a large-scale agenda. Why? Because the reform of the international financial system involves a reform of the power relations and entails an agreement on the new power relations that have been established for more than fifty years.

Everyone must understand that this will be a deep negotiating process. The weight of some regions and others, the weight of emerging countries and the new rules of the financial system for the International Monetary Fund, all of this will take time.

The second commitment made in Washington: in the face of the prospect of a global recession or in much of the world, certainly in the vast majority or in the immense majority of developed economies, to bet on demand stimulation through a commitment to public spending, a fiscal investment stimulus, set at 1.5 percent of GDP or 2 percent. At that time it was not specified, but that is where it has been positioned. Europe adopted that commitment, and all countries have adopted that commitment.

Therefore, if there was a result in the actions of governments, when will we see the result in the evolution of the economy? Inevitably, in the face of a severe recession like the one we are experiencing and a collapse of the international financial system that has no precedent in history, we will have to endure a few difficult months—let's hope not more than a year—to be able to have positive signs.

But I must say one thing: the financial system, on which the entire economy depends and which finances the economy, was on the brink of collapse and, therefore, on the verge of a global catastrophe in the economy at the end of September and the beginning of October. If the European Union, in its Eurogroup framework and in coordination with the European Union, the United States, and other powerful economies in the world, had not come to the rescue of the financial system and the Central Bank had not made its decisions, the situation today would be much worse, much worse, because we would have seen a greater number of financial entities collapsing than we have seen, and there would have been a halt to the economy or an even deeper recession.

I understand that it is difficult to convey this, because in September to October we still did not have a perception of the reality, in the streets, of what the dimension of the problem of the financial system was; but the dimension was very serious. We put up a dam, but that does not mean that the effects that the lack of normal functioning of the financial system had already generated would not have drained into the entire global economy to provoke the recession. And that negative drainage that the financial system produced for months has to run its course and must necessarily follow its path until we can again see recovery once everything that was stifled in the economy as a consequence of the financial system crisis has been drained.

Therefore, the Washington Summit had its objectives: first, the fact that it took place was positive; a spirit of coordination; second, a willingness to reform the financial system; and third, a boost to demand. And I am convinced that the London Summit will have a more decisive than programmatic component, as was the Washington Summit.

Q.- I could try to disguise this question as a European question, but I prefer to ask it directly. I would like to know, Mr. President, if you think it is ethical for your Minister of Justice to have gone hunting with the judge who is overseeing a corruption case involving the Popular Party and if you also consider that this is sufficient reason for this party to question the judge.

Miguel Ángel Aguilar.- Thank you very much for the question. I have said that journalists have many opportunities to be with the President; now, in the streets, when he goes out. We will reserve this space for questions related to his intervention, that is, to his European program.

Q.- I wanted to ask the President. I see that the moderator is making tremendous efforts to ensure that the discussion stays focused on European issues. What I wonder is who will make those efforts to ensure that in the upcoming European elections we talk about European issues and not domestic issues.

For example, it would surely be a good way to motivate society to talk about European issues in the European elections if we could know in advance, for example, if the Socialist Party wins at the European level, who will be the President of the European Council and, if the Popular Party and its counterparts win, who will it be; that is, if we are not going to vote and then we will find that the governments will make a decision outside of the citizens. I know there is a timing issue with the Irish referendum, but it would surely be good for citizens to know what it means to vote socialist or vote popular, regardless of whether it is in Spain, Germany, or the United Kingdom.

If I may also return to the issue of xenophobia that was raised earlier, I have seen that your response to me has been optimistic when you said that they are very minor outbreaks, and I have also seen that in your speech you felt proud that there have not yet been reactions of that type in Spain. I wonder if the Spanish government and the European governments should not take measures to prevent this from happening, because perhaps if nothing is done, that phenomenon will increase instead of recede.

President.- Regarding the first question, I must say that I think it is an idea to consider that I do not know if in these elections, perhaps it is a bit premature, in the future we may see in the elections to the European Parliament a definition of options with clear, individualized faces. It could be a good idea.

In my experience in the European Council, I must say that the European Union is, above all, a union of countries and citizens. Therefore, the references of ideological alternatives or ideological projects do not situate themselves as they might in the logic of each country, the national logic. That is extraordinarily nuanced, and for that reason, sometimes those situations arise that are more difficult to explain to the citizenry. It seems to me that it is a reasonable model. It is not that ideologies do not occupy their space, but the will to unite is stronger than the will to carry forward your ideological political project. That is how I would summarize what I have experienced in Europe, and I think it is quite reasonable.

As for the other issue, so far they have been minor outbreaks, globally, and certainly in our country as well. There have been some, but very minor. Are we going to do something to prevent? No, we have been doing a lot for a long time to prevent. And the best way to prevent any situation of this type is, on the one hand, the integration of immigration, an active dialogue with the social organizations representing immigrants, and a dialogue at the local level, which is fundamental. We have very good examples of municipalities that manage diversity and that manage the presence of a very high percentage of immigrants in many of their neighborhoods, with participation councils, with cooperation councils, or with mediators, and that yield very good results. For this, as is known, the State has been allocating a fund of economic resources for immigration.

And, more generally, preventing outbreaks of xenophobia means educating, educating in citizenship.

Q.- As has been mentioned several times, how do you imagine a President with broad powers and a true Minister of Foreign Affairs being appointed? What is your idea? How should this be done?

President.- Yes, I imagine it and I am convinced that what we will experience will come. For this, what must we do? I believe there are two fundamental conditions. The first is that the governments of the states do not feel that part of their political responsibility is decided or determined by the role they play within the European institutions, by what they demand from the Commission or by what they achieve in a European Council. This culture needs to change.

What is the requirement to change it? The requirement is a requirement, in this case, of agreements among major parties. Why? Because the oppositions... It does not matter the political color, eh! Where there is a popular or conservative government, the social democratic opposition is always waiting to see and to judge its role in Europe, and where there is a socialist or social democratic government, the same happens with the popular or conservative oppositions. This dynamic needs to be broken, and this can only be broken with a party agreement.

At the moment that the governments of each state do not feel so compelled to achieve things and to criticize the Commission, which is an easy and favorite sport of many governments, we will make the unique, united institutions of Europe have more strength, more projection, and more representativeness, and that the dialectic of European political control is in the European Parliament and not in the twenty-seven national parliaments.

M.A. Aguilar.- Mr. President, if you allow me, the other thing that is lacking is media that are truly European, that have a representative, relevant dissemination across all European territories. And that lack of questioning political powers from a European perspective also produces poor results. The deficit of Europe, more than democratic, is a media deficit. We have studied this very well here, in the Association.

I see that you have decided, Mr. President, to let me... I had already made a bad impression with Tele 5, but now you want to recover that, to look good, and I commend you for it.

President.- More than anything, I do it for the Association.

I want to say that it is part of the best European spirit, which is a spirit shaped by democratic values, the prudence in public debate. The evident exaggeration does not correspond with what the usual rules of democracy are, of how political dueling is in democracy.

Therefore, what I ask for is a bit of moderation in some of the statements that have been made and in some of the assessments about events that have occurred. Moderation and calm, for one reason: because what interests me most, which is what citizens should know, is that, fortunately, the rule of law works well in this country and, logically, the law is for everyone in what it represents in having to be accountable, in their case, and also in the guarantees of defense.

Secondly, we have learned something in the democracy of our country, and that is that it is usually not useful to attack others to try to solve one's own problems. One's own problems must be resolved, and almost nothing is achieved by attacking others. This should serve as a lesson. I understand that there are always circumstances or every so often each party has some problem, more or less significant, and it must be resolved. What should others do? Logically, be patient and wait for it to be resolved.

But it has been proven: when someone has to resolve something that is fundamentally theirs, do it in that direction, because attacking others does not help. Therefore, as I believe that this is part of the good democratic functioning, I will understand that the things that have been said are simply the result of the moment or of exaggeration and we will not respond. We hope that things will calmly return to their course.

M.A. Aguilar.- Thank you very much, Mr. President. The crisis is darkness, but the electrical experts already said that light problems are resolved in the dark. And I believe that the problems of the crisis will also be resolved.

Thank you very much for coming here to present these anticipations about the program for the European Presidency.

President.- Thank you very much.