Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

20 July 2010 · Parliamentary control session (Sesión de control al Gobierno)

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions from UPN's Carlos Salvador regarding the government's fulfillment of a motion on renewable energy policy, during a July 2010 congressional control session.
Main themes
Renewable energy policy, Energy Pact negotiations, energy sector regulation, remuneration framework for renewables, solar and wind energy, energy mix and infrastructure, energy savings and efficiency, Navarra's energy model, parliamentary motions and political consensus, climate change commitments
Duration
~20 min
66th percentile
Words
2,421
66th percentile
Sentences
68
45th percentile
Readability
37
30th percentile
Grade
16.5
87th percentile
Syntax
3.46
92nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
27th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 55%47%
  • Institutional 22%19%
  • Social 16%13%
  • Ceremonial 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 2%1%
  • Environmental 2%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 15%

68 sentences in 40 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Carlos Salvador, from the Mixed Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Salvador.- Mr. President, at least ten resolution proposals addressed the issue of energy yesterday. This means that, with differences, we are all aware of the importance of the topic and also of the opportunity that getting the strategic objectives we set in energy right represents for the development of industry and the economy of Spain.

It is true that we live in an increasingly complicated world and that any change generates instability, an instability that quickly affects the markets and also the markets linked by energy: raw materials, transport, distribution, and generation. Therefore, I do not risk much, Mr. President, if I assert that there is a widespread political consensus in seeking formulas that take advantage of clean, cheap, and renewable indigenous sources of generation.

In Navarra, as you well know, we have made a significant commitment to renewable energies for years, which has also meant bearing a significant learning curve. But it has not been a party commitment; it has been a commitment of an entire Community. We have developed an industrial model linked to clean energies, which has been successful in Spain and abroad, and, obviously, we want to continue promoting it with the same determination.

My party, UPN, has promoted several parliamentary initiatives in this Chamber, which were also approved yesterday in defense of renewable energies; but --you know it, you are aware of it-- at this moment the sector is very concerned about its future. That is why I pose the question that appears on the agenda: how do you plan to fulfill the motion resulting from the urgent interpellation regarding the energy sector, especially renewables, presented by Unión del Pueblo Navarro and approved by the Plenary of this Chamber on June 22?

President.- Mr. Salvador, I agree with you on the importance that energy has for the economy and the future of our country.

The Government, in response to the question you pose, is fulfilling the motion that was approved in this Chamber at the initiative of your Group and is doing so within the framework of the dialogue on the Energy Pact, as well as in the Subcommittee for the analysis of the energy strategy, of which you are a part.

There is a coincidence between the Government's strategy and your Group's motion. Specifically, there are six major topics that are the subject of dialogue and negotiation: energy mix, infrastructures and interconnections, liberalization, energy savings and efficiency, review of regulated costs, and nuclear safety and waste management. We hope to reach a common position before the end of this month of July.

Regarding renewables, Your Excellency, you know that their development and implementation has had strategic value for the Government since 2004 and will continue to have it. Renewables already covered 25 percent of the total electricity generation in Spain last year, a very relevant percentage, higher in Navarra, where it reaches 42 percent, as a result of a special effort made there.

We need to clarify the remuneration framework for renewable energies so that it can reconcile fair profitability of investments with the economic sustainability of the entire system. That review is one of the points subject to debate within the framework of the Energy Pact, and we are, Your Excellency, on the right track. As Your Excellency knows, an agreement has already been reached with the wind and solar thermal sectors, and this very morning a meeting is taking place with representatives of the photovoltaic sector to reach an agreement in this last area of renewable energies.

So, in short, Your Excellency, we are not only fulfilling the motion presented by your party, but we are also working intensively to move towards a State Pact on energy matters, and I am convinced that we have your party's good disposition in this matter, and, of course, I hope that of all Parliamentary Groups.

Mr. Salvador.- We, from UPN, want to tell you, Mr. President, that indeed, we want to support a pact on energy; but we do not wish it to be at the expense of small solar energy producers who have fulfilled their obligations, as has been the case in Navarra, where you know this problem affects more than ten thousand people.

In Navarra, Mr. President, what we also need is a greater commitment that guarantees the companies in the wind sector can maintain their research centers in Navarra or in Spain and do not relocate their R&D, which is what ultimately gives substance to the industrial sector of renewables.

In any case, Mr. President, if we want to fulfill the political commitments that Spain has made and, at the same time, combat climate change, from my party, from UPN, we believe --and you have said it; I hope it is so and we will be vigilant-- that we must continue to bet on renewables in a reasoned manner, but also in a sustainable manner.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, from the Popular Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President of the Government, you have repeatedly said things like this: "we are going to win this fight by maintaining social rights and social spending" and "we are going to get out of the crisis by protecting those who have the most difficulties, the most disadvantaged." You have also said: "an antisocial exit from the crisis would be an unjust exit." Well, all this reality has shown to be false, because you have lowered the salaries of public employees, eliminated the baby check, raised taxes that affect everyone, cut aid to dependents, and, above all, made two especially unjust decisions: the freezing of pensions and the cut in aid for dependent children under three years old.

You have said that in the budget debate you would ask for new efforts from the Spanish people. We would like to know what those efforts are that you are going to ask of the Spanish people.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, not only are your assertions unfounded, but I must remind you, as I already told you in the State of the Nation Debate, that the Government I preside has made a great effort to improve social policy in this country, which is reflected in the fact that spending has increased by 50 percent, improving pensions, improving scholarships, improving the Minimum Interprofessional Wage, improving Early Childhood Education… all social policies.

Therefore, Mr. Rajoy, even with a crisis as severe as this one, we have made the effort to increase unemployment protection, because those who lose their jobs are the ones who suffer the most during crises. Even in a serious crisis like this one, we have maintained the scholarship policy and, with the effort of the entire Chamber, we have also established and maintained the Law that constitutes the fourth pillar of the Social State, such as the Dependency Law, which attends to the most disadvantaged and humble people, whom you did not remember at any time during your years in Government.

And yes, we have asked for efforts from citizens, especially from a part of the citizens, to meet the objectives of austerity and savings that the Spanish economy requires to get out of the crisis: austerity and reforms. Those will be the objectives of the Budgets that, as you know, will reduce the total volume of spending by 7.7 percent; but with the principle of maintaining social cohesion, which we have extended, expanded, and developed, especially in favor of the most vulnerable, despite your absolutely unsustainable demagoguery.

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, everything you say is very well, but your social policy is summarized in that when you came to power, the unemployment rate in Spain was 10 percent and today it is double, and 4.6 million Spaniards cannot work. That is the summary of your social policy.

But I have asked you and I have posed a question. I have the right to do so as a deputy, and the Spanish people have the right to know what those efforts are that you are going to ask of them, because you, in the State of the Nation Debate, said "I am going to go down that path, no matter the cost to me" and, given your track record, it is logical that people are concerned and it is logical that I ask you that question: what more are you going to ask of the Spanish people?

And I ask you another question, because yesterday, here, with your vote, a resolution was approved stating that the Government had to comply with the Resolutions of this Chamber. That was approved with your vote, and yesterday two Resolutions were approved here: one, that pensions would not be frozen next year, and the second, that there should be no cut in aid for dependent children for people earning less than eight hundred euros a month, who received five hundred euros a year and you have reduced it to 291 euros. Those two Resolutions were approved here yesterday and you should reverse them.

And I ask: are you going to comply with the Resolutions and will you reverse them, and what more efforts are you going to ask of the Spanish people? And I ask you to respond to me, because it is your duty as President of the Government to respond to what the opposition asks you.

President.- If new efforts need to be asked of the Spanish people, I will do so; if they need to be asked, in the Budgets. And the Government, as the Vice President explained yesterday, will present the Budgets and they will contain that.

The Government's idea is that those new efforts will be for those who have a high economic capacity. I anticipate that and I hope to count on your support for that.

Finally, I wanted to tell you, and I know that for you this is an unknown language, that for you what is important is that nothing costs you anything; not doing anything that costs you anything. But I have a different vision of politics: if efforts have to cost me to get out of the crisis, something will cost me.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josep Sánchez Llibre, from the Catalan Parliamentary Group of Convergència i Unió

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Sánchez Llibre.- Mr. President of the Government, does the Government foresee making any significant reform to the Corporate Tax?

President.- Mr. Sánchez Llibre, I must remind you that the Government has made decisions regarding the Corporate Tax: in 2007, a reduction of the Tax by five points for all companies: from 35 to 30 percent for large companies and from 30 to 25 percent for SMEs; a five-point reduction in the tax rate for SMEs that create or maintain jobs: Budget Law of 2010; extension to 2011 and 2012 of the freedom of amortization for companies that maintain their employment level: Royal Decree Law 6/2010; creation of a favorable regime for investment companies in real estate assets intended for rent, whose tax rate is set at 19 percent, and I remind you that in the Sustainable Economy Bill being processed in this Chamber, the percentage of deduction for technological innovation activities is increased from the current 8 percent to 12 percent.

In addition, regarding R&D and Information and Communication Technologies, it raises the minimum deduction limit, which goes from 50 percent to 60 percent, and extends, indefinitely, the environmental deduction, while raising it to 8 percent from the 2 percent of 2010.

In short, Mr. Sánchez Llibre, you are aware that all these measures we have promoted from the Government have had the collaboration of your Group and that, consequently, we have had several years of support, improvement, and tax reduction for companies through the Corporate Tax. That is what the Government has done to promote economic activity, and that is the intention that the Government maintains: to support companies fiscally so that they generate economic activity, maintain, and create jobs. And I hope that, for your part, there will be recognition of what I have said, of all that we have done in favor of the Corporate Tax, because it has been the period of the most fiscal support to companies via Corporate Tax, and also that we continue in the attitude of collaboration for the future.

Mr. Sánchez Llibre.- I have listened attentively to the response of the President of the Government, from which we draw a first conclusion, which is that the Government does not intend to modify the Corporate Tax, nor does it intend to limit the deductions currently provided for in the Corporate Tax, which means, in our opinion, that the Government does not intend to increase the Corporate Tax, which is good news that has been perfectly clarified as a result of our question.

Secondly, we would also like to make two or three considerations. We agree, as you have said and expressed, that Convergència i Unió was, to some extent, a driving force, together with the Government, for the substantial reductions in the Corporate Tax that have taken place over the last six years, which I would say are very well appreciated by the productive economy of Spain.

But we would also like to raise other considerations that we believe are not beneficial for the productive economy of Spain: First, these trial balloons that the Government sometimes puts forward, hinting at an increase in tax pressure, I sincerely believe are not good for the economy and what they create is insecurity and distrust regarding future investments that may come. Therefore, I think it would be good if in the future no trial balloons were floated in the direction of a tax increase.

Secondly, we also understand that it would be good for the Government to take fiscal policy as a basis for the potential growth of our economy and not as a basis for increasing resources for tax collection. We understand that it is good not to raise the Corporate Tax, but perhaps it should be lowered, I would say selectively, for certain matters such as for those companies that create jobs or for those companies...

President.- Mr. Sánchez Llibre, I confirm that the Government does not plan to increase the tax pressure on Corporate Tax, but it must be recognized that the effective Corporate Tax rate is at 20 percent in our country...