Speech by the President of the Government at the inauguration ceremony of the President of the Council of State.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

21 April 2004 · Inauguration ceremony of the President of the Council of State

Context
Zapatero addressed the inauguration ceremony of Francisco Rubio Llorente as President of Spain's Council of State on April 21, 2004, outlining institutional reforms.
Main themes
Council of State inauguration, Francisco Rubio Llorente appointment, constitutional reform proposals, institutional reform, advisory bodies, former presidents as permanent members, Center for Political and Constitutional Studies, Spanish Constitution of 1978, independence and prestige in public institutions
Duration
~12 min
41st percentile
Words
1,390
41st percentile
Sentences
36
22nd percentile
Readability
22
6th percentile
Grade
19.7
97th percentile
Syntax
3.60
96th percentile
Vocabulary
2.26
65th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 83%83%
  • Ceremonial 14%14%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

36 sentences in 21 paragraphs

Esteemed gentlemen, ladies and gentlemen,

The event we are attending today is full of symbolic connotations, not only because of the symbolic nature of this multi-centennial institution that has provided so many, so repeated, and so permanent services to the State, that is, to the entirety of Spanish society.

In this brief, but by no means ritual intervention, I would like to refer, first of all, to the person who will preside over the work of this House from today; then, to the changes that will soon occur in the composition, structure, and functions of this body, to finally emphasize the specific and novel work that I intend to assign to him, which will occupy a good part of the Council's dedication in the immediate future, and undoubtedly the most delicate and sensitive.

I begin, then, with the person. I announced in my recent investiture speech that the Government intended to appoint a President of the Council of State who met the requirements of having recognized prestige and proven independence. We will all agree that the intellectual trajectory and the extensive exercise of public functions carried out by Francisco Rubio Llorente attest to a very high possession of both qualities; essential, moreover, to lead an institution that bases its prestige on the serenity of its analysis, the rigor of its judgments, the flexibility of its proposals, the foundation of its critical positions, and the timeliness of its advice.

To preside over it, a high level of "authoritas" was required, and Francisco Rubio has accumulated it throughout a long intellectual career and through a broad exercise of public functions. A recognized constitutionalist both within and outside our borders, he has contributed, through teaching, to the formation of generations of students and young and mature professors spread today across the Spanish university landscape.

As a Legal Advisor to the Cortes Generales, his astute advice has influenced not a few of the basic norms that today make up our legal system; but, above all, he has left a less visible, yet recognized, imprint on the work of the Constitutional and Public Liberties Commission of the Congress of Deputies that ruled on the draft of the Spanish Constitution of 1978. It could almost be said that behind the scenes, Francisco Rubio is, in reality, a sort of added father of our current constitutional text.

As a Magistrate of the Constitutional Court and as its Vice President, he has notably contributed to interpreting that text, to shaping its true meaning, for it is well known that the Constitution says what the Constitutional Court says it says.

Regarding his independence, Francisco Rubio has defended it with vehemence and tenacity in all circumstances in which he has performed his function. I can underline two traits of his personality that do not require further development: his reflections or judgments have never been comfortable for power, and on occasions, he has bravely shown the most irreducible of independences: that of accepting to correct his own positions if he has come to the conviction that there were reasons or arguments to support others different from those previously expressed by himself, even if he had done so explicitly and publicly.

Referring now to the Institution, I must point out that I also announced in my investiture speech that my Government would soon submit to Parliament a Bill that would allow for the incorporation of those who have held the position of Presidents of the Government as permanent and native members of this Council. I find this incorporation advisable, not only because of the relevance of all those who have preceded me in my function, but because, in my opinion, the best way for society to benefit from their experience is to put it at the service of the State in that place where experience transforms into advice, in the Institution that the Spanish Constitution itself defines as the "supreme consultative body of the Government."

I am fully convinced that with this incorporation, this house emerges strengthened, not in its relevance, which it already has to the highest degree, but in its capacity to serve the community.

I also announced that for the work I am going to request regarding the proposals for constitutional reform, to which I will later refer, the Council will be able to count on the support of the Center for Political and Constitutional Studies, which will be assigned to it, leaving the strict orbit of the Government. I am sure that this will smoothly and mutually integrate the accumulated capacity of those who are part of that center, as well as the qualified reflection that it is capable of mobilizing internally and externally, taking advantage of the multiple intellectual and analytical resources that the Spanish constitutionalist and political science community possesses today.

I now pause on the important and very sensitive work that, in addition to the ordinary work it carries out, I intend to request from the Council of State.

In the Government program that I intend to develop, I have incorporated the proposal to proceed with reforms in specific, yet significant, points of our Constitution. I have delineated the scope of these reforms, which would affect the composition and functions of the Senate, so that it can develop the identity of a territorial Chamber that the Constitution itself confers upon it; the regulation of succession in the Crown, to adapt its norms to the principle of non-discrimination against women; the incorporation of the official designation of the Autonomous Communities and the two Autonomous Cities; and, finally, the incorporation of a reference to the future European Constitution.

The four reforms have one essential point in common: they respond to the convenience, if not the necessity, of adapting our constitutional text to the transformations that Spanish society has experienced since 1978: transformations in its territorial structure and in the decentralization of political power, with the formation of a complex State that requires for its normal functioning the development and strengthening of the space for dialogue, cooperation, and institutional coordination, whose logical center at the highest level can be none other than the Senate; transformation in its values, due to the progress of the conquests against all discrimination, starting with that which affects women; and transformation in our membership in a supranational entity of which we are part, but above all actors.

Francisco Rubio has written that the Constitution is the form of power, specifying that this means giving shape to power, creating it. If we want to address the transformations of that power to which I have referred, which are already part of social reality, the convenience of addressing the necessary reforms for it is explained.

But I have pointed out, at least with the same emphasis, that these reforms cannot be imposed by any majority, not even if it had the instruments and votes sufficient to successfully activate the complex mechanisms necessary for it. These are reforms that require serene dialogue, consensus, but above all, social conviction of their convenience and timeliness.

That is why I have stated that, in order to reach a great agreement, the Government will submit to the Council, for its prior report, the initiative it takes regarding constitutional reform.

This Institution is the house of consultation, of advice, which is tantamount to saying the seat of thoughtful reflection. I now ask it to also be the place for serene debate in the search for appropriate formulas that can be shared by the vast majority of Spanish society and by the overwhelming majority of political forces.

No formula is better than the greatest consensus, no consensus arises without prior participation in its definition, no successful definition precedes dialogue and the mutual exposition of criteria and convictions. Only in this way is a conviction founded, extended, and shared.

I ask this Institution and its President to activate the debate, the dialogue, the participation, and to finally present us with the heart of the consensus. Let it do so slowly, trying to avoid the dictates of the immediate. It starts from a good position, for its President from today is fully aware of that risk from which we must protect ourselves. He has also written that the tendency to forget the important in favor of the urgent is a permanent trait of the human condition with which we must confront.

Thank you very much.