Words of the President of the Government on the 30th anniversary of the Constitution during an event organised by the Centre for Constitutional Studies

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

9 December 2008 · 30th anniversary of the Constitution, event organised by the Centre for Constitutional Studies · Centre for Constitutional Studies

Context
Zapatero addressed the Centre for Constitutional Studies on 9 December 2008 to mark the 30th anniversary of Spain's 1978 democratic Constitution.
Main themes
30th anniversary of Spanish Constitution, democratic transition, constitutional consensus, rule of law, civil rights and freedoms, social state, territorial diversity, Spain's European integration, constituent assembly legacy, historical modernization of Spain
Duration
~46 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,484
93rd percentile
Sentences
153
81st percentile
Readability
26
10th percentile
Grade
18.4
95th percentile
Syntax
3.49
94th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
43rd percentile
Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 76%76%
  • Social 11%11%
  • Economic 5%5%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

153 sentences in 79 paragraphs

Director of the Centre for Constitutional Studies, President of the Constitutional Court, President of the Supreme Court of Justice and of the General Council of the Judiciary, President of the Council of State and Master President of the Bar,

It is an honour for me to be at the Centre for Constitutional Studies. I feel very comfortable here. It reminds me of my beginning, of this professional experience in politics, an career that has always been related to the Constitution: first, as a student, then, as a teacher; later on, developing it as part of the Legislative Assembly and now, mainly, observing it, as President of the Government, for I think that this is the main approach the Government should implement from the point of view of its tasks: first of all, a Government should respect the Constitution and enforce it; and then implement its political programme.

I have said that I feel comfortable here because during the previous Legislature I also made a speech during the presentation of the Complete Works of Manuel Azaña, and I am here now to celebrate the thirtieth anniversary of our Constitution. And I am here to talk about Spain once more, about the democratic Spain, for these two terms are finally and happily together forever, for us and for the generations to come.

Curiously enough, it was in this very centre, 46 years ago, which by that time was the Centre for Political Studies, that Carl Schmitt received the Diploma and the Badge as Honorary Member of the Institute. Surely enough, he, the scholar who "defended the Constitution", and the Spanish personality in charge of making the "speech" that day - a person that would play an essential role both during Franco's rule and during the democracy, and I refer to Manuel Fraga, could not imagine then, in 1962, that today we would be celebrating the thirtieth anniversary of the Spanish democratic Constitution, a Constitution that has been "defended" through the very constitutional principles, through the full normality of its enforcement and application, and not through exceptional power or preventive exclusion.

Commemorating the thirtieth anniversary of the Constitution is commemorating three decades of respect for the sovereignty of citizens and of the Rule of Law; three decades during which civil rights and public freedom have been in force; three decades of progressive expansion of the Social State; three decades of territorial structuring and integration in Spain, from the recognition of its diversity; and three decades in which Spain has been characterised by freedom and progress and has become an active full member of the European Union, three decades during which Spain has lived its best moments .

Thirty years ago, just thirty years ago, Spanish citizens were only too aware of the historical need to bring their awful fate, fossilised intolerance, arbitrary impositions and inequality to an end. And in that generation of Spanish citizens, of lucid, reasonable Spanish citizens, Miguel Herrero, proved he was able to face that challenge and found the ideal legal-political formulae to contribute to the development of freedom among us.

The Transition towards democracy made it possible. Thus, let's say it again: in that context, the results were amazing.

When talking about the Transition we must refer to the idea of consensus, our proneness to establish a commitment and to set up agreements brings us closer to our fellow beings and to the reasons and expectations of the other.

We had to avoid the mistakes from the past. So far, our troubled constitutional history had been the history of a failure in the subsequent attempts to modernise our country. In 1978 we were able to fight that sort of spell, that incapacity to co-exist according to a set of rules accepted by all.

We had a Transition in Spain because we got to a consensus and we had a consensus because we had a Constitution, for this is how the genuine power of the Constituent Powers works and its results last in history.

Those who formed part of the Constituent Assembly were able to lay the foundations of our freedom and our social progress, be it from political compromise, from the unions, from the companies or from the mass media, from citizenship.

It was thanks to them that the generations who came afterwards have always lived in democracy in our country. In this Spain of ours, social welfare has progressively spread and increased, as well as equality and the respect for the rights of our fellow citizens.

This has demanded an effort; it has been necessary to overcome difficulties and certain threats, of course, but we have geared our ship in a specific direction with a strong collective determination.

Thus, now that we are commemorating the thirtieth anniversary of our Constitution as a period of greater freedom and welfare in the history of contemporary Spain, we are also celebrating the success of the constituent assembly, but also something more, for were it not for their success we would not be here now. Professor Rubio Llorente stated it, as a sort of premonition, back in 1979: "approving of a constitutional text turns it into nothing more than a hypothetical Constitution. The Constitution will become a living reality when it is turned into an efficient reality."

Thus, today, we are also celebrating the constant, faithful work of several generations in Spain, generations that from the institutions or in their daily life have been able to observe this Constitution and have been faithful to it, behaving according to its values, to its principles and to its rules, because loyalty to the constitutional consensus involves loyalty to principles such as freedom, justice, equality and political pluralism; it involves loyal to the principles of the Social Democratic Rule of Law and to the model of the State of Autonomies.

And, now that we are mentioning the constitutional principles, namely, freedom, justice and equality, I would also like to refer to another anniversary: we are celebrating the thirtieth anniversary of our Constitution but also the sixtieth anniversary of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which, as you all know, the Constitution mentions explicitly as the canon to interpret our fundamental rights.

These two texts have many things in common: these are texts of reconciliation which look forward to the future, soothing the pain of the wounds from the past, and these are texts that make us become part of Spain, part of the world, part of a community with shared principles.

Ladies and gentlemen,

Democratic Constitutions are in fact a programme for co-existence in the long term. The Constituent Assembly mentioned in the Preamble to our Constitution a primitive shared desire: "establishing justice, freedom and safety and promoting the common welfare".

Thus, our Constitution is mainly an essential desire of peaceful co-existence that materialises in a vast agreement concerning the basics of the political community and that is developed through the Law. The dream becomes an impulse of willingness; willingness becomes power and this power is organised according to the rules set by the Law in order to guarantee that it does not belong to a single person, for it must belong to everyone.

Unlike other agreements sanctioned and regulated well-documented in Law, the Constitution is not just an agreement between the parties involved, it is not related to a specific moment in time and it does not concern just those parties. The constitutional agreement does not involve any parties or authors of a given norm, other than those who are to observe it, both in the present and in the future. This is what characterises a Constitution and this is also the main principle of its special legitimacy.

His Majesty the King expressed this very idea, he worded it in such a way that it is difficult to reword it now, for on 27 December 1978 he said before the Parliament that the Constitution he had just sanctioned belonged "to everyone and was intended for everyone". And as the word "everyone" is not linked to a specific moment and, thus, the Constitution belongs to its addressees and the addressees are the subsequent living generations of Spanish citizens, and, therefore, the King has said, thirty years later, that our Supreme Law is "the essential nucleus of our present and the best instrument for the future".

The Spanish Constitution forms part of a specific legal, political culture based upon two fundamental achievements: the objective reaffirmation of the dignity of human beings and the principle that states that the organisation and the exertion of power can only be justified in the will of those who accept it.

Thus, fundamental rights and democracy are integral part of the contents of our Constitution. We could now say that without rights and democracy, as the so frequently quoted article 16 of the French Declaration of 1789 goes, there is no Constitution and, thus, in order to guarantee its enforcement, the Constitution is endowed with normative supremacy.

Democracy and the fundamental rights open the Constitution to the future with the same strength it had when it was promulgated. There will always be room to enrich and strengthen the protection of dignity and the living generations will be able to explore new paths through the democratic procedures.

It is not possible to promote the common welfare if the Constitution is kept hidden away. We cannot place the Constitution on an altar, as if it was a piece of dead material. It needs to feel the pulse of live. The Constitution has not been written to be contemplated, but to be felt and also lived by subsequent generations that share the simple, yet important willingness to live together and make a common project come true.

Weiler stressed the fact that the concept of political community and citizens' support should not be understood from the romantic idea of homogenous historical identity, but from the republican idea of shared acceptance of common values; an idea that is in the basis of constitutional patriotism, that is far more open and inclusive, that is especially useful in a globalised world and in Spain, a country in which citizens of different nationalities co-exist.

Over the last thirty years, the Constitution of 1978 has proved that it was with us. It brought about democracy and it has developed with democracy. It guaranteed freedom and safety and it has guided us in moments of tension and conflict. It confirmed our innate diversity and it has made it possible for us to admit and regulate its scope. It opened up our country to Europe and to an international order based upon human rights, and we have been able to get fully integrated in the European Union and to play an active Role in the International Community.

The Constitution of 1978 is, therefore, part of our lives; it lives and evolves with us. And this is its greatest virtue: it has come to form part of the Spanish society.

Even the constitutionality of the acts of power is something citizens have learnt to appreciate naturally. Talking about the constitutionality of a Law, of someone's words, of a decision issued by a court or of the behaviour of a public institution or an individual has come to form part of the democratic behaviour of Spanish citizens now. Beyond the technical-legal analysis, "constitutional" facts refer to whatever is considered socially adequate and fair for the political progress of the community, while "unconstitutional" facts refer to whatever must be rejected precisely because it produces the contrary effect.

Thanks to this "democratization" of the Constitution, it now has more interpreters. And this is a good thing, for when a Constitution is discussed and mentioned it is alive and able to remind us o our condition of free men and women every day. As Konrad Hesse put it, "the normative strength of Constitution is conditioned by the constant willingness of those that take part in the constitutional process of implementing its contents" and "therefore, that willingness becomes essential, since, in its turn, it is based upon the basic consensus that guarantees the firm stability of the legal structures… The stronger the 'Constitutional willingness, the more comprehensive the limits of the possibilities of implementation of the Constitution will be".

Still, the Constitution is a legal norm, the highest one and the strongest one, and the possibilities to adapt it to the ever-changing social reality depend to a great extent of whatever its main interpreter, the Constitutional Court, may establish.

The Court is an essential, delicate component of the Rule of Law. We shouldn't forget this. We shouldn't forget the responsibility that the political representatives have, either in the Government or in the opposition, and it has to do with its institutional prestige and good operation: for they are responsible for facilitating its renewal, according to the constitutional provisions, they are responsible for respecting its daily work and they are responsible for commenting on its decisions and, if necessary, criticising them, freely but with prudence.

This is the responsibility of the Government in the first place, but also of all the rest, including the Constitutional Court and all its members. Thus, I think it is rather contradictory to see that those who, being in public relevant positions, claim that they subscribe the Constitution, and then they do not respect it, and then they do not contribute to its enforcement or they do not facilitate the task of the Constitutional Court.

There is no normative Constitution without a constitutional frame, without a constitutional power exerted with independence, responsibility and capacity of persuasion.

Over the last thirty years - twenty eight in fact -, the Constitutional Court has carried out a praiseworthy task, a necessary task in order to define the contents and the protection of rights, in order to solve the conflicts concerning the competences of our complex State and to eliminate unconstitutional norms. Spanish democracy and our Constitution need the Court to keep working like this in the future, with the same institutional orientation and with the same technical quality implemented over nearly three decades, the last three decades.

Apart from the constitutional interpretation, it is democratic legislators that must be in charge of developing and adapting the Constitution to the new times and realities.

The Constitution of 1978 has made it possible to change Government and to change with stability; and it has also made it possible to govern and legislate at different paces, with different approaches and priorities.

My Government and the parliamentary majority that supports it have seen our actions backed by the Constitution - and I will be prudent, for there are members of the Constitutional Court here - when trying to extend the scope of protection of certain rights, namely, those that have to do with equality de facto between men and women, rights that involve new duties for the public authorities and, in some cases, for the individuals too; when trying to recognise new rights, such as the right of same-sex couples to marry according to the specifications contemplated in our civil legal frame, or the rights of Spanish citizens abroad, or the new social right to attention in the case of dependent people…

The comprehensive demand contemplated in article 9.2 of the Constitution is intended for the public authorities "to promote the conditions so that freedom and equality, either in the case of individuals and in the case of groups, may exist de facto", to "remove the obstacles that prevent or hinder their full integration" and to "facilitate the participation of all citizens in the political, economic, cultural and social life"; and this is surely enough a firm basis for an ambitious programme of reforms.

This also happens in the area of civil rights, for instance, with article 10.1, which states that "the dignity of individuals" and the "free development of their personality" are "the basis of the political order", and the same goes for the explicit comment against discrimination in article 14.

If we take a look at those principles the Constitution defines as "ruling principles of social and economic policies", which are sometimes forgotten, perhaps we should think of the duty of public authorities to "guarantee the social, economic and legal protection of families" (article 39); their duty to "contribute to a regime that may guarantee the existence of sufficient social aids to face situations of need, in particular in the case of unemployment" (article 41); their duty to "promote the necessary conditions and establish the corresponding norms to turn the right to have a house into a reality and to regulate the use of land according to the general interest and to avoid speculation" (article 47); the duty to "implement prevision, treatment, restoration and integration policies" as far as people with disabilities are concerned (article 49), or the duty to "guarantee economic independence to the elderly" (article 50).

Even more in the case of a reality that the Constituent Assembly couldn't even imagine, the reality of climatic change and the fact that the measures to fight its consequences are also backed by a constitutional precept, the one that defends the "right to an adequate environment" (article 45), whereby it is established that public authorities must "see to it that all the natural resources are used in a reasonable way, in order to protect and improve life quality and to defend and 'restore' the environment, with the support of the 'necessary' collective solidarity", and it orders the legislator "to create penal or administrative sanctions and to establish the 'obligation to make up' for the damage caused".

These normative prescriptions cannot be disregarded, as some have said, these norms and social rights are more precise and direct than we think from the point of view of their constitutional regulation, they are specific mandates for the public authorities and they endow them explicitly with the capacity to impose duties on third parties in order to guarantee social protection, which is particularly valuable, let me say so, in difficult situations such as the one we are facing at present.

Thus, the Constitution of 1978 has proved its capacity to cover different legislative programmes and governing over the last thirty years, and also to adapt to an ever-changing social reality, something that the axiological scope of some of its precepts already observe.

Thus, it has proved its capacity to adapt from the point of view of our territorial model, to a great extent, because this was what the Constituent Assembly wanted in fact. And do not forget this, this issued from the Constitution. And, thus, it is an unprecedented model both in Spain and outside our borders. This is the subtle result of a rational use of experience, desires and balance.

This model recognises the right to autonomy, yet, it does not impose homogeneity among the different Autonomous Regions; and, thus, it contains and guarantees a rather precise set of State competences and also the principles of solidarity, cooperation and the existence of several official languages.

Still, our work is not over, because we must seek for the specific plans in the norms that complete the constitutional structure, the guidelines that influence considerably the final results.

That very constitutional model states, explicitly, that it is the Autonomous Regions and their own Parliaments that must put forward the initiative to reform their own Statutes of Autonomy; an initiative that combines with the capacity of the Spanish Parliament to amend and approve of the final text, in some cases before the ratification of the reform by the electing body of the Autonomous Regions.

This dialogue between the different Parliaments, with the final decision of the Spanish Parliament, that represents us all, is aimed at seeking balance between the needs and demands of the Autonomous Regions and the necessary defence of general interest and of the need to guarantee the harmonic operation of the whole system. Therefore, the Parliament plays an essential role, not to monitor or direct the reforms, but to channel the territorial pluralism guaranteeing the unity of the State.

This is the constitutional context that must be guaranteed by the Constitutional Court, for it must guarantee the implementation of the accepted freedom for constitutional development within the limits set by the Constitution.

Complex States are based upon a delicate balance, upon instability. Moreover, in our case there are added factors that result in a greater complexity, factors that have to do with the very process of creation of Spain and with the historical difficulty to organise diversity and to articulate difference within diversity as part of the unity of the State, a difficulty that has increased due to the emotional filters, on many an occasion. Still, it has been the Constitution in force, the Constitution of 1978, that has provided the viable legal context to guarantee that territorial balance for the first time, because democracy involves the recognition of territorial pluralism and territorial pluralism can only be preserved from a common democratic project.

The constitutional context is based upon the idea of balance and it is this balance that we must enhance and guarantee day by day; through the norms and through the reforms, but also through a responsible political attitude.

In spite of the controversy that took place during the previous Legislature, the different statutory reforms have attained a wide consensus both at the Regional Parliaments and at the Spanish Parliament; all but one, the reform of the Statute of Catalonia, which was modified for the first time ever since it was promulgated back in 1979 although it had the support of the four main political forces of that Autonomous Region.

It wasn't an easy political process, but constitutional logics were respected, the dialogue between the Parliaments was respected and the role of the Spanish Parliament as a deciding body was respected. Now, as in the case of the rest of the Statutes, and regardless of whatever might be decided by the Constitutional Court, it must be developed with faithfulness and with a sense of balance.

In spite of this controversy, during the previous Legislature we also attained the historical minimum rates of jurisdictional conflict between the State and the Autonomous Regions, it is rather paradoxical, but it is true; a more intense and frequent institutional dialogue between the State institutions and the representatives of the Autonomous Regions, the reactivation of the Sector Conferences and the creation of a new body we intend to consolidate and regulate during this Legislature, linking it with the Senate: the Conference of Presidents.

Thus, I would like to repeat this: our Constitution has a great capacity to adapt and a great capacity to keep moving on with the Spanish society and to keep helping to solve present and future challenges.

But, it is true, this capacity, the flexibility of our Constitution has a limit. Constitutional interpretation and democratic legislators do not have unlimited powers. And this raises a question that seems necessary now we are celebrating this anniversary: the possible convenience to reform the Constitution. We say convenience, a real convenience, and this limits the area of analysis, because we are referring to specific aspects. According to the different opinions, there might be more or less aspects to go through, but they are specific and they refer to organic or procedural questions rather than to its contents; that is to say, we are leaving aside the greatest options (that is, the form of the State, the form of Government, the declaration of fundamental rights, the electoral system, the constitutional jurisdiction…) which were already established by the Constituent Assembly.

As you all know, the Socialist Party presented its candidature to the election in 2004 with an electoral programme that intended to approach four specific constitutional reforms, which were also mentioned during the investiture speech. During this Legislature we have been working so that a prestigious institution, namely, the State Council, would analyse the legal viability of those reforms. Once the report was made and published, the Government explored the political possibilities to start the reform process and we soon reached a conclusion, and I can guarantee this, that the necessary conditions to carry them out were not met.

Now, and thinking of this new period we are facing, I have had the chance to express this opinion once more.

I am sure that our Constitution can be improved and I am sure that this possibility is proved by the constitutional experience and by certain changes that have taken place in the Spanish society. Still, although I am aware of this, although I am aware that it might be useful to undertake those specific reforms, I am also aware that it would only be prudent, adequate and viable to do so with an initial consensus; a consensus including, of course, the two main parties, but not only.

In my opinion, and beyond the mathematical issues required by the constitution, it would be very convenient to attain a similar consensus to the consensus attained when the text of the Constitution was approved of, because one of the main tasks of a Constitution is enhancing political integration and we must always try to preserve and even increase the degree of integration we attained when it was created and not otherwise.

Thus, in my opinion, right now there is not an adequate political context - and I hope this situation may change - in order to open up an important reform process in order to reform the Constitution. This does not mean that our efforts over the last few years have been completely useless. The debate about the reform has become part of our constitutional culture, the mass media have paid attention to it too and, surely enough, this progressive social spread of the reform might propitiate the necessary political conditions to approach this reform with enough guarantees to reach a consensus and also with enough doses of normality.

As Elster put it: reforms are a mechanism of acceptance of Constitution itself. It is difficult to exaggerate their integrating function in this sense, because this makes it possible even for those who do not share some of the values included in the constitutional text or who consider that the text renounces to some specific aspects to accept and assume the system in force and to try to modify it from within.

Ladies and gentlemen,

Assessing the contemporary vitality of a Constitution demands paying attention to its functionality because if the Constitution belongs only to citizens, it is citizens it must serve. In order to asses this, I think that we must take into account two aspects: the capacity of the Constitution to keep enhancing and articulating pluralism in our society, in the first place, and, then, the fact that it serves to organise power, for it serves to limit power but also to provide it with the necessary means to carry out an efficient action. As to ideological and political pluralism, I would like to remind you of the fact that it is based upon an epistemological premise that states that truth is always an unattainable project and that fallibility principle pointed out by Karl Popper is precisely what takes us to political freedom. And precisely because no one knows the whole truth, we need enough room for the different truths and to create, with the necessary autonomy, our own vision of reality.

I am sure that today our Constitution serves to enhance the construction and defence of different, contradictory political and ideological ideas and positions. The real strength of our system of fundamental rights is the best of proofs.

The Spanish Constitution of 1978 is also useful as far as a second important aspect is concerned: it allows the State to carry out a legitimate, efficient action. Certain challenges we are now facing may serve as an example of this, namely, the international economic recession we are facing.

There is an ongoing debate in America about the existence of a state of emergency as far as economy is concerned. I think that, from the legal point of view, there are no grounds for such an approach in our country, as has been proved with the recent Royal Decrees, which are useful instruments used by the Government to react fast and intensely and fight an exceptionally fast, intense economic crisis. The Constitution offers those reaction mechanisms within the pre-established legal frame. The political control is decided during the process implemented to validate the Royal Decrees; and any existing legal limits are dealt with at the Constitutional Court.

But the current economic crisis has also proved the need, the usefulness and the contribution of the State, of the public institutions, although this is a different question.

Neither does the Government feel it is doing something outside the Constitution with regards to the measures that are being adopted. On the contrary, the Constitution - which is intended to organise our social life as a whole and, thus, our economy too - recognises the right to private property and, at the same time, it sets forth its limits considering its social function; it defends market economy but also productivity and, even, planning; and it guarantees both corporate freedom and the freedom of unions, collective negotiation and the right to go on strike. And I have already mentioned the considerable pre-eminence it gives to social rights.

Thus, the Social State becomes an equation that makes it possible to satisfy the material needs of human beings, either through the market either through active social policies. That is to say, it makes up for those needs in a complementary way, rather than in a dialectic way. Without social policies there is no place for the market and without the market it is not possible to implement a social policy. The central issue in this parallelism is the question of the efficiency and legitimacy of the actions carried out by the State, which now, when 2008 is coming to an end, must face the challenge to bring a bit more dignity to our lives once more and with a special sense of responsibility.

The functionality of the Constitution in the creation of a legitimate, efficient action on the side of the State also shows in the fight against terrorism. If the Constitution does not provide the legitimate authorities with the necessary means to defend its precepts against its enemies would be useless. As everyone knows, this question brought about a reflection at a worldwide level after 11 September, but this is not something new for the Spanish constitutional feeling, which has had to face terrorism ever since the Constitution was approved of back in 1978.

Does the Constitution provide us with efficient instruments to fight terrorism and bring violence to an end? I think so, of course, and I think so considering my years at the Government, more than four now; it surely offers us all the necessary instruments, combining legitimacy and efficiency. The constitutional frame set forth by articles 17 and 55.2, the legal coverage, the operational capacity of the State Security Forces and the control of the Judiciary form part of a normative network that guarantees efficiency and legitimacy in the fight against terrorism.

In fact, the Constitution has also allowed us to draw a clear line between legal political action and cooperation with terrorism, with the essential support of the Constitutional Court and of the Supreme Court of Justice. This is not a political defence of the Constitution, but a matter of preventing political parties from collaborating with terrorism. So far, our Constitution endows the State with sufficient power so as to avoid this contradiction; sufficient, legitimate power, precisely because there are limits to it, limits that should never be ignored. We must remove the cancer cells that prey on our body but we must be careful not to damage the heart of pluralism.

To conclude, our Constitution is as alive as ever, just as thirty years ago, because it lives and evolves with us, because it belongs to Spanish citizens, because it is the most valuable instrument for the integration of our political community and because it allows us to face the challenges we are facing now and those we might have to face in the future.

Since our Transition to democracy, Spanish citizens have been able to find the way together, and we have found and we will keep finding difficulties on our way, but we won't recoil. This is a road we are crossing together in order to defend and expand on our freedom, so as to make it more efficient and so as to strengthen co-existence and welfare. The Constitution of 1978 is still the safest guide to keep on moving on.

As Francisco Tomás y Valiente said twenty five years ago, and I quote him, "it is under this symbiosis of legal ethics, utopia and expertise, it is under this Constitution, which is the supreme legal norm, that our people can and want to live in peace here and now".

Thank you very much.