Prime Minister Lars Løkke Rasmussen's speech at the Think Tank Europe conference on January 14, 2019.

Denmark Lars Løkke Rasmussen · Prime Minister of Denmark

14 January 2019 · Think Tank Europe conference

Context
Rasmussen addressed the Think Tank Europe conference in Denmark on January 14, 2019, one day before the UK Parliament's pivotal Brexit vote.
Main themes
Brexit and no-deal scenario, future of the EU, EU cooperation benefits, Danish public support for EU, UK parliamentary vote on withdrawal agreement, backstop negotiations, lessons from Danish Maastricht experience, international cooperation, refugee crisis, Russia-Crimea annexation, ISIL defeat
Duration
~30 min
82nd percentile
Words
3,592
82nd percentile
Sentences
265
94th percentile
Readability
64
94th percentile
Grade
7.4
2nd percentile
Syntax
2.60
7th percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
15th percentile

Translated from Danish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 35%33%
  • Institutional 28%26%
  • Economic 15%14%
  • Social 9%8%
  • Ceremonial 8%7%
  • Environmental 4%3%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Not in focus 6%

265 sentences in 110 paragraphs

Thank you very much for the floor.

And thank you to the Think Tank Europe for the initiative.

Now, one must look five years ahead.

Or perhaps just look five months ahead. It may very well be the last time one is here...

Well – five years from now. What will the EU look like?

That is a good question.

To find out how good a question it is, one can simply look five years back. And then one can ask oneself whether, five years ago, one would have been able to answer the question.

For could one have said five years ago: Russia will annex Crimea? Or could one have said five years ago that Europe would be facing a massive refugee crisis of unprecedented scale? Or could one have said five years ago: ISIL will take over Syria and Iraq – and will be defeated again? Or could one have said five years ago: The United Kingdom will leave the European Union?

I am not entirely sure. And that just shows that five years is a really long time.

And just as I stand here thinking, what will happen tomorrow?

I mean in just one day. Because tomorrow there will be a vote in the British Parliament.

And that could, in many ways, actually set the stage for what will happen in the next five years.

For there is no reason to sugarcoat it. Brexit is a tragedy. I truly believe that. For all of us.

But it would, if possible, be an even greater tragedy if we end up with a no-deal Brexit. That is, a situation where the United Kingdom – in just a few months – exits the EU without an exit agreement.

But that is a scenario that is getting closer and closer as time goes by. There are less than three months until the deadline.

And we are still waiting for clarification on whether the British House of Commons can approve the exit agreement that we negotiated with the British government after difficult negotiations in November last year.

And it is no secret – if it is, it is certainly not well-kept – that it looks difficult for Theresa May. To put it mildly.

Now, here today, yet another attempt has been made to create a platform of seriousness in a correspondence that has taken place between Theresa May, Juncker, and Tusk, which reaffirms the EU27’s willingness to avoid that this “backstop” ever becomes a reality. And a very strong indication that we are ready to roll up our sleeves the moment the exit agreement is approved by the British Parliament.

But whether such a reinforced foundation will create a different outcome for tomorrow’s vote, I will not judge.

Fundamentally, I unfortunately have the impression that something has moved in a positive direction since the vote was postponed before Christmas.

So what will happen if the House of Commons in London gives a thumbs down tomorrow? One can only speculate. It will initially be up to the British government to define a possible way forward that can find support. And that is where we Danes look a bit disappointed, because when we were in something that resembled a similar situation after the vote on Maastricht, one must at least give the generation of politicians before Margrethe and me that they took responsibility and laid out a compromise that made it very clear across the divides in Danish politics what was needed before we could move forward. And with that foundation, Uffe Ellemann-Jensen could travel around with clear demands for concessions. And that stands in stark contrast to what we are experiencing here. A British Prime Minister who has traveled around with a somewhat broader desire for us to be accommodating. And I believe we fundamentally want to be accommodating as well. But it would be easier if we knew what it was we were to accommodate...

I believe that Brexit has been an eye-opener for many people regarding the many advantages of EU cooperation, which, like many other things we have created in the wake of World War II, with a more regulated international order, have over time just been taken for granted. Something we have simply built upon.

It is just incredibly unfortunate that it takes such a fateful and – in my eyes – wrong decision for people to seriously begin to articulate these advantages.

But if one is to find comfort in the old saying that there is nothing bad without it being good for something, then it must be that in the wake of the Brexit vote, there has been a very clear reaction also in Denmark. Namely that Brexit is not an example to follow.

On the contrary, the Danes are supporting EU cooperation even more than before. A new poll – and I fundamentally subscribe to the viewpoint that all polls should be taken with great caution (...) depending on what they show, of course... But a new poll shows – and it is significant and outside the statistical uncertainty – that two out of three Danes would vote to remain in the EU if there were a referendum today.

And that is good. And it is a sign of a healthy attitude. We should not turn our backs on international cooperation and conventions. On the contrary, we should get involved. Participate actively. Make the cooperation better.

***

This requires that Denmark sets ambitions for the EU. And that the EU sets ambitions for the future.

No more airy visions. But concrete solutions that are rooted in realism. And in an understanding of citizens' concerns. And in an analysis of what Europe needs.

That is the course I wish for. And in several areas, I would also assert that Europe is well on its way.

Also based on the fact that the Commission we have now is a far better Commission than many we have had in the past. A Commission that has been mindful that we need to be strong on the big issues and a bit less on the small issues. That has been positive.

And we can see it all around. In the digital area. Where Margrethe, our strong Danish Commissioner, has taken the lead with demands on the big tech giants for fair business models and better data protection. Which has made Europe a leading region. A region that even Marc Zuckerberg can see the vision in.

We can see it in the climate area. Where the EU has contributed to bringing the great powers to the negotiating table. Even when we negotiated the climate agreement in Paris. One great power has since withdrawn. But the main line in the EU is that we continue undeterred. And it is now being set up that what has been a Danish ambition for years will now also be a European ambition, namely that we will pursue the goal of becoming independent of fossil fuels by 2050.

We can see it in the environmental area. For example, when it comes to plastic, which far too often ends up on our beaches, in nature, in the oceans... Before Christmas, we in the EU agreed on a European ban on the sale of single-use plastics. If we want to reduce the amount of plastic and set strict requirements for recycling, it really only matters if we do it together. And here, the EU is the first large community we can see besides our own that can help raise standards. Which can also set itself globally over time.

We can also look at the migration area, where the EU – after some time, and in my own temperament, also too many twists around the distribution of refugees among countries, before we try to bring the numbers down – has, after all, gone into “action mode,” among other things with the EU-Turkey agreement. Where in 2015 nearly 900,000 migrants arrived in Europe via Turkey and Greece, the number in 2018 was just 46,000. That is a reduction of 95%! It is quite noticeable. And it is an example of what can be achieved when acting together.

So the EU delivers.

And then there are all the economic benefits of the EU:

“Frictionless trade.” That is the British main appetite at the moment. That is the slogan. “We want frictionless trade.” ...

Yes... but that is essentially what we have. For that is the core of EU cooperation. The free and open trade between markets.

It is frictionless trade that has made Denmark richer and richer. And it can be expressed in many ways, but it can be calculated to correspond to 5% of our Gross National Product. It can be established that real wages for Danes today are about 10% higher than they would have been if we had not had access to this frictionless trade in the internal market.

Here – in the building, presumably a few floors higher up, in Dansk Industri – it is estimated that half a million Danish jobs depend on the internal market.

If we did not have the internal market in Europe, we would have to invent it.

***

All in all, there are many good and concrete benefits associated with EU cooperation.

We sometimes forget to remind citizens of that. They certainly did in the United Kingdom. Where the political class for 40 years told the Brits what the EU did not do for them.

In that way, it is actually a bit of a miracle that 48% of the British population still voted to remain.

I sense that Danes have become more aware of the concrete benefits of the EU in recent years.

And that is important. For the great debate – peace in our time. Building peace and cooperation on the ruins of World War II with the Coal and Steel Community has, for many, been a foundational narrative and perhaps also a sufficient narrative in itself. But that is hardly enough for future generations.

This year marks 30 years since the Berlin Wall fell. I remember it. I went down and saw it myself. But for today’s youth, it is history.

Therefore, I believe that when we look five years ahead, we must be aware that the relevance of EU cooperation does not lie in historical achievements, but in the future ability to tackle real, cross-border challenges.

That will be a task, and it will certainly also be a task when we now have to create new budgets. Where we must – even though it will be difficult – insist that we modernize the budgets and steer them towards the future: Migration. Partnerships with our neighboring areas, so we avoid having migration pressure on us. Investments in innovation and development. Digitalization. All that Europe must live off in the future. And then invest somewhat less in structural funds and agriculture.

It will not be simple. But that is the foundation from which Denmark will enter the negotiations.

I believe it is important that we keep in mind that the task is to further develop cooperation so that we can continue to deliver concrete results and solutions to the challenges that citizens experience in their daily lives.

But just as it is in the concrete that citizens and our businesses see and appreciate the benefits of EU cooperation, it is also in the concrete that we from time to time experience an EU that sometimes seems unreasonable.

This applies, for example, when we have to send a full Danish child benefit to a child in a country where it is worth three times as much...

Or when the internal market is abused as a shortcut for employing Filipino labor. As we saw in Padborg. Where people lived and worked under conditions that are completely, completely, completely unacceptable...

That is not fair. And we need to find solutions to that in the EU.

For such stories – no matter how much they fill up against the normal picture, and no matter how much child benefit is sent abroad compared to what we otherwise spend on child benefits, it undermines support for EU cooperation if we neglect it. Downplay it. Do not take it seriously.

In some areas, we are fortunately well on our way. This applies, for example, when we talk about more orderly conditions on the roads. Member states agreed just before Christmas to introduce much stricter requirements for the road transport sector. So it will be easier to control that the common rules are followed.

In other areas, one must honestly say that we are more challenged. This applies, for example, when the European Parliament recently proposed that just one day of work is enough to achieve a real connection to the Danish labor market. That after one day of residence in Denmark, one can receive Danish unemployment benefits – if one has had at least a year of unemployment insurance in the country one comes from. I think, to put it bluntly, that is simply not fair. And it must change if we are to maintain popular support for the project.

But even though we are challenged, we are also moving the debate. This applies, for example, when it comes to the possibility of indexing child benefits to the cost of living in the country where the children live. We received a response, which unfortunately for us was tied to a British yes in a referendum. But then it would have been there. It was not. But we stood completely alone. And can today note that several other countries – both large and small – actually support the Danish fairness agenda. And we just need to keep standing up for that. And it should not translate into EU skepticism or anything else. On the contrary. It is actually born out of an ambition that we need to clean up what pushes people away.

But I will not fool anyone into thinking that it is an easy task. For there are also strong feelings about these issues. Which do not always align with our views. But it is an important agenda.

***

This year is a European election year. This year a new European Parliament will be elected. A new Commission. A new President of the European Council will be appointed.

This year – in fact, here in the spring – the balls for the next five years of the European political agenda will be cast. And we have, from the Danish side, wholeheartedly thrown ourselves into the fight to shape the future of Europe as much as possible in our direction.

And I have tried here to hint at how.

European cooperation must be further developed to match the societies of the future. We must ensure that the internal market continues to deliver prosperity and growth to Denmark and the rest of Europe. It is about seizing new technological opportunities. And reflecting that in our budget priorities. It is about safeguarding the value of free trade, while at the same time demanding respect for fundamental rules of the game.

Some of the key words for the future EU will be digitalization and sustainable transition. Here, Denmark – wearing a digital leadership jersey, and known as a long-standing frontrunner in the green area – has particularly special conditions to make a noticeable difference.

And we will – as a strong priority – work for a fairer Europe, not least when it comes to free movement.

We must do more to ensure that existing rules are followed. And more to avoid circumvention and abuse of the rules. In my view, this is one of the main tasks for the new Commission.

Therefore, I will work to ensure that the next Commission places greater political focus on implementation. On enforcement. That is, not just developing new policies, but also putting more energy into ensuring that what we have agreed is actually implemented. So we ensure that all member states implement common rules in a timely and correct manner.

In Denmark, during this election period, we have had good experiences establishing an implementation council and a special ministerial committee. To constantly benchmark ourselves against other countries. I believe it is an instrument that could be adopted in Europe. For it is central that we follow the rules to the letter, and ensure that there is a "level playing field."

We must help each other to monitor that rules are followed across borders. We must inform each other when someone discovers loopholes and unintended consequences. And we must ensure that incomprehensible rules and practices are addressed.

If we do not address conditions that seem unreasonable and create unequal competitive conditions, we risk giving space to those who would rather see us dismantle than maintain European cooperation. To those – and there are some, both at home and abroad – who would like to sell simple and short-term solutions to difficult and complex problems.

We have seen plenty of that lately.

***

Where will we be in five years?

I wish I knew.

One thing is for sure: The world, Europe, and Denmark are not standing still.

And it is rarely the case that past solutions fit future challenges.

This applies not only in Europe. It also applies here at home.

Last year, the Danish opt-outs celebrated their silver anniversary. 25 years.

And that could serve as inspiration – in terms of process – for how to handle the situation that the United Kingdom is in at the moment. But otherwise, I do not know how much inspiration they can provide.

It has been 25 years. 1993. That is a long time ago. A very long time ago.

Back then, Sweden, Austria, and Finland were not members of the EU.

The Tamil case had not yet reached a conclusion. If anyone remembers that.

Boris Yeltsin was the great new hope from the east.

I was myself the chairman of the Children and Culture Committee in Græsted-Gilleleje.

A lot has happened since then.

The world in which our opt-outs were born no longer exists.

The fear that the opt-outs were an insurance against...

And every now and then, it might be worth – and I do not edit newspapers – but it could be fun to create a little magazine that uncovered who said what, why they said it, and what happened?

Because what was the fear?

It was the fear that the beetroot-colored Danish passport would be replaced by an EU passport.

That foreign police would patrol our streets.

Denmark would be forced into an EU army.

Bound into a common currency, which it was believed would not be in Denmark's economic interest. Since then, we have chosen to tie ourselves to it unconditionally. I mean – we call it something else – but we have tied ourselves to it.

But that was the fear on which the opt-outs were based.

And one can discuss whether the fear, which has persistently been proven wrong for 25 years, still makes sense. Or whether that fear might actually risk making past insurances a kind of straitjacket for us in the future.

I will not sugarcoat that.

I believe we should get rid of the defense opt-out. It does not serve Denmark's interests. Time has run out on it.

And especially at a time when an American president alternately turns his back and faces us, demanding greater European engagement in its own security. It would suit us to get rid of it. It would be in our interest.

That cannot obviously happen without a referendum. And such a referendum is not just around the corner, nor will it happen on this side of an election. Already for the reason that there is no majority in the Folketing to remove the opt-out. There apparently is in the population. Quite massively, in fact, if you ask. But if you count votes in Christiansborg – Mette Frederiksen will come later – the situation is the opposite.

So it is not just around the corner.

However, I hope that by keeping the debate alive – also without setting a deadline that makes everything end up black and white. And with scare tactics. We can help create the conditions for us to eventually be able to address this question. That is, not a yes/no, black/white debate, but a nuanced debate.

A free debate – about this, but in general about the EU – where we also talk about what sovereignty means in the world we live in.

One does not become more sovereign by standing outside influence when the rules are to be made – only to then conform to what others have decided. That is the situation that countries on the periphery of Europe often find themselves in.

If you are not at the table, you risk becoming part of the menu. Eaten by the others.

With that, I have tried to provide a perspective on what I think we should focus on. Both in the EU: Moving from traditional policy areas into future growth areas. Both in budgetary and political focus. More focus on implementation. More focus on picking up the small discrepancies that risk causing "a small tuft to topple a large load" and undermine public support. And at home, an appeal for us to stand tall. Acknowledge that many actually demand our societal model and our solution model. And perhaps use that as a support to have enough confidence to – on certain points – commit ourselves more fully than we have done to date.

Thank you for the word.