Statement by President Lula at the opening of the 6th Meeting of the Pnae

Brazil Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva · President of Brazil

6 February 2025 · 6th Meeting of the Pnae

Context
Lula addressed the 6th Meeting of PNAE on February 6, 2025, celebrating public school excellence and advocating for greater investment in Brazilian education.
Main themes
Public school education, student achievement and inspiration, PNAE meeting, investment in education, cell phone ban in classrooms, Brazil's educational history, teacher respect and conditions, social inequality and education access, humanistic education values
Duration
~22 min
69th percentile
Words
2,601
69th percentile
Sentences
164
84th percentile
Readability
74
99th percentile
Grade
6.9
1st percentile
Syntax
2.73
15th percentile
Vocabulary
1.86
2nd percentile

Translated from Portuguese

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 70%66%
  • Ceremonial 12%11%
  • Institutional 9%9%
  • Economic 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

164 sentences in 47 paragraphs

First, Camilo [Santana, Minister of Education], I wanted to congratulate you on another education event. I want to apologize to you because I will not read the list of names. The list is extensive, almost the size of Camilo's speech. And I will... But I wanted… two new things that happened here.

First, I did not know that Janja [Janja Lula da Silva, First Lady of Brazil] had become an ambassador. So I will complain to Itamaraty that I need a title for myself. A woman is an ambassadress, what is a man? I will discuss here what my name will be in this.

The second thing, a tribute that you have already paid to a young figure who was invited by Camilo to be here because I insisted on giving her a hug, her mother, and showing you that it is always worth believing in public school. And here is a girl named Samille Malta, who is from Minas Gerais. Stand up, Samille.

This girl is from the interior of Minas Gerais, she was born in the United States. Her mother, like so many other people from Brazil, went to try her luck in the United States. She stayed there until she was seven years old, when her mother returned, working at everything you can imagine, from delivering newspapers to being a waitress [inaudible] and they returned. And this young woman went back to her hometown.

And this young woman was the only girl, or rather, young woman, from a public school who scored the highest grade on the Enem. She was the only young person. And more importantly, this young woman, in addition to scoring the highest grade on the Enem, has already been accepted into two important colleges, two universities.

She has already been accepted to Medicine at Unicamp, in Campinas, and has also been accepted to the Federal University of Minas Gerais for Medicine, which is the university she chose, because people from Minas speak very differently from everyone else. They say “ô trem, nóis”. So, she will study in Belo Horizonte.

And I asked Camilo to invite her because we see so many people speaking ill of public schools, we see so many criticisms of public schools, and people often do not realize how much a teacher in a public school earns. People often do not realize the conditions of education in public schools.

Many people do not know the suffering of the periphery of this country, the suffering that children sometimes go through at home and go to school, sometimes with the perspective of eating their meal. But children who sometimes suffer from all the violence that the periphery of this country faces, and who supports these children with great delicacy are teachers who are often disrespected by the public authorities themselves.

So, Samille is an example that, first, you have to study to succeed. If someone thinks they will go to school... Another important thing we did last week was to take away cell phones from children in the classroom. I said at the launch, at the announcement of the law, that it was extremely important that we formed, in our schools, humanistic people, people with heart, people who are supportive, fraternal people.

And we did not want to form algorithms, we wanted to form boys and girls, Brazilians and Brazilians, so that this country and the world become more human again. This is extremely important because you have to study.

This girl, to get where she got, studied almost 12 hours a day. I asked her: “how much time did you spend on your cell phone?” She said: “only two hours.” If we want to do the opposite, spend 12 hours on the cell phone and only two hours studying, no one will score a thousand. No one will be able to. I could not get there because I did not have a cell phone and did not study, so I could not get there. But she did.

So, I brought her here so that she can serve as an example, so that people believe. Public school depends on the respect that the public authorities have for it, it depends on the affection that teachers have for the students and on dedication. On dedication.

And that is why any investment we make in education is very little. Our historical debt with education is almost unpayable in a century. It is a huge debt we have with education.

If we take the history of Brazil, we will see that until the beginning of the last century, no one cared if children went to school. In fact, it was not mandatory to go to school. Girls could not go to school because they would learn to write letters to their boyfriends. Boys did not have to go to school because they had to work, go cut sugarcane, go weed, go do anything.

Studying was not a priority; that was the education we received in this country until the middle of the last century. That is why, Décio, this country only had its first university in 1920. Four hundred and twenty years after it was discovered, this country had its first university. Because the son of the rich went to Sorbonne, went to London, went to Harvard, went to Coimbra, went to Madrid, and the son of the poor went to the sugarcane field. This is our history.

And this also justifies when we invest in school meals because no one can study on an empty stomach, folks. No one. A child who leaves home without having breakfast. A child who did not have a decent dinner with the necessary calories and proteins at night. What will this child learn in school?

Only someone who has never seen a big worm growling to eat a smaller one thinks that a hungry child learns. Those who have never been hungry do not know what it is like to be unable to learn anything when we are hungry.

Because it is hard. It is hard not to have breakfast, not to have a bread with coffee and milk to drink, not to have a decent lunch, and not to have dinner; it is not possible to learn. Paulo Freire used to say: “When we eat, we become intelligent.”

The brain has time to learn, but when we do not eat, it only thinks about the damn food that never comes. So, when we make this investment, which is little, many people think, but spending R$5.5 billion on school meals is very little because there are 40 million people. Forty million people.

And when I entered the government in 2003, I had to give a raise because it had been more than 10 years without a raise, Camilo. Now I return again, and it had been a long time since there was a raise. Because it seems to me that the people who governed this country do not remember this.

From time to time, I see people talking about, for the first time in the history of Brazil, and I always said “for the first time in the history of Brazil,” sometimes it gives the impression: has this country never had a government? Lula, is he the only one who governed Brazil? Because they say this: “Lula thinks he is the only one who governed Brazil.”

No. It is for the first time because they never governed for the poorest people in this country. They never cared. So, the poorest are forgotten. They are forgotten until there is no more way.

When Camilo says that 68% of our population did not complete elementary school, it shows that if we had invested more in education, we would have much more international competitiveness, the quality of our products would be infinitely better, our education would be much better, but this was not invested in. So, what we are doing is trying to recover lost time.

This lost time cannot be recovered in 10 years, or in a day; it will take a long time. When we made an agreement with the mayors, all the mayors agreed with us that literacy at the right time is necessary. An agreement was made with 100% participation from the mayors.

Now it is necessary to monitor to see if it will be fulfilled because many times it is not fulfilled. Just as we want at least 80% of children, by 2030, we did not even set 100%, we set 80%, to be literate. When this happens, you will see the miracle that will happen in this country.

And then, one important thing is that we, Camilo, need to learn a lesson. When a child does not want to go to school, it is because something is happening to them. So, we also have to see if the quality of education is motivating for children to go to school.

In other words, school has to become a pleasure, a desire, a necessity, an urgency for children to run to school, to get up in the morning and want to go to school. And then the school has to be of quality. And then, Camilo, we still need to make the community take care of its school.

It is not from Brasília that the president will take care of the school. Who will take care of the school and its quality is the community that has its children in the school, and we need to create conditions for them to monitor these schools. For example, a full-time school, Camilo, a full-time school, many schools, at least in São Paulo, are almost like a matchbox.

They are schools that do not have space for children to have fun. No one has ever thought about children practicing sports in the same school. What exists is a court that serves for basketball, serves for futsal, serves for a lot of things, just one court.

When we need to think, we need to create new things, alternatives, and every time a mayor, a governor, a president of the Republic puts money, for God's sake, do not be miserly, do not think of it as an expense: “I will spend, I will spend.” You will invest, you will not spend.

You will form better quality men and women, with more learning. It is this country that we need to build. And not the country of lies, the country of nonsense, the country of fake news, the country of irresponsibility.

That is why, comrades, every time I come to launch something in education, I think: it was worth it. It was worth it for us to bet because when I go to a Mathematics Olympiad, and I see students receiving gold medals, I think: it was worth it.

Because when we launched, Camilo, people thought that public school students would not accept participating in mathematics because they were not prepared. And public school students excelled. In the first registration, there were 10 million, then 14 million, then 16 million, then 18 million; when I left the presidency, there were 19 million children registering.

And then I learned that mathematics is not difficult. Mathematics, when you manage to grasp the thread of the cocoon, you learn it is the most enjoyable subject in school. It is like Portuguese; people are not good at writing, they are not good at writing; people need to learn.

They have to learn in school. And I wanted to end by saying to you: we have two more years of government, and you have learned a lesson. Building takes decades. Destroying, it only takes a crazy person to win the elections, and he destroys in four years what we did in 20 or 30. You know how it is. We spend hours and hours, months and months building something. A guy comes in, and with a decree, he destroys everything.

Because it is better to create CAC [Collector, Sports Shooter, and Hunter] for people to learn to shoot than to create schools for children to learn to study. That’s it. So, comrades, we have not yet finished everything we have to do for education. We are halfway there. And there is still a lot to do.

That is why I want to thank the lunch ladies. Because it is a job that is often not observed with care by those who have never been in a kitchen. There are these women who dedicate their whole day to ensure that our children can eat. They deserve, they deserve much more than respect; they deserve to have a decent salary, with the pride we have for their profession.

In the same way, the respect we have to have for the people who take care of what we call nutritionists. In the same way. Also, the respect we have for the people who, not being teachers in the school, are concerned about participating in institutions that take care of the issue of school meals.

And we also have here, I don’t know if there are rural workers here, we have the obligation… We created, still in my first term, the responsibility that 30% of school meals, at that time it was called school meals, it was not food. We have evolved so much that even the name has changed. So, that 30% had to be purchased from family farming.

I don’t know if it happened, if everyone bought. But the concrete data is that the cheapest way to multiply the quality of food, the quality of life, and the income of people who work in the field to help the people who eat in the city.

It is a whole difficult process, folks. It is a whole difficult process because it requires a lot of meetings, a lot of discussion, it takes a lot of patience. And many times there are people who do not like it. Do you think that any president who has no relationship with the people will be concerned about having meetings?

He will be concerned about listening to the companions who make the food? He is concerned about knowing if the specialists will deal with this? He is concerned about talking to our dear Minister of Education, with our dear Wellington [Wellington Dias, Minister of Development and Social Assistance], with our dear Paulo Teixeira [Minister of Agrarian Development]? He will not.

It is as follows: you have money, go buy at the supermarket. If you don’t have it, don’t eat. That is the logic. Why waste time with healthy food if I can buy American canned food and everyone eats it, and will get fat? Because when we are skinny from hunger, we think that getting fat is healthy. It is natural. You are skinny, it is like Jeca Tatu.

Jeca Tatu is a character from Brazilian folklore, skinny, sick, eats nothing, does not even eat cassava. Then you give him food, a Biotônico Fontoura, the guy gets strong, fat, and thinks it is beautiful. Look how beautiful I am, skinny.

Look at how I am. Let's be frank. I am better than... Let's be frank. So, the food has to be healthy. Healthy and tasty, right? Healthy and tasty, because it has to be healthy, of quality, and still cheap. Is that okay, folks?

Therefore, my dear companions, I am compelled to conclude this by saying that it is worth it for us to govern a country that has people of your quality who commit, sometimes without earning anything, to do what many who earn so much do not do.

May God bless you all. Congratulations.