Dialogue of the President of the Government at the closing of the XXIX Meeting of the Circle of Economy

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

31 May 2013 · Closing of the XXIX Meeting of the Circle of Economy

Context
Rajoy addressed the closing session of the XXIX Circle of Economy Meeting in May 2013, answering audience questions on Spain's economic priorities and R&D policy.
Main themes
Fiscal consolidation and deficit reduction, R&D investment and innovation policy, economic crisis management, sovereign debt crisis, Spain's productive model transformation, public spending cuts, support for science and technology, credibility and market trust, Catalonia, European Space Agency and CERN funding
Duration
~76 min
97th percentile
Words
9,101
97th percentile
Sentences
396
97th percentile
Readability
56
80th percentile
Grade
10.9
31st percentile
Syntax
3.06
56th percentile
Vocabulary
1.89
2nd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 45%42%
  • Institutional 39%37%
  • Geopolitical 8%7%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

396 sentences in 109 paragraphs

Mr. Piqué.- Let's start with some general topics and with --this is not a question, but rather an expression-- one that is identified as... The signature "Gerardo" and, since the other questions are not as accommodating, I will start with that one. What the card says is: "President, from Catalonia we support your management. That is the way. Gerardo."

President.- We will leave it there.

Mr. Piqué.- Continuing along that line, but with some nuance, there is another one that says: "President, congratulations because there are things that are indeed improving, but we cannot simplify the depth of the problem. You seem to be an honest man, with simple but clear ideas. How do you not realize that our business fabric is dying at a dizzying speed? Private banks are not lending at the level they should, especially not for R&D. And now you are 'killing the financial support system for R&D from the competitiveness and strategic plans of the Ministry of Industry by asking, for the first time, for bank guarantees for a certain percentage. Don’t you realize that with this we have destroyed the mechanism, as has already been pointed out by sectoral and business institutions? You and the president of the Circle of Economy have started by saying that in this situation we need to apply common sense, and I am sure that this also needs to be done."

On this issue of R&D, there are several questions, and that is why I wanted to link it to that one. For example, there is a question that raises the point that, with the official discourse of support for changing the economic and productive model towards greater added value, Spain has reduced its contribution to international agencies such as the European Space Agency (ESA) and CERN, which, by the way, has just received the Prince of Asturias Award along with two other researchers, with a direct effect on high-tech and qualified industry and employment, while other countries, like the United Kingdom, have increased theirs.

And there is another question that goes along those lines: "In order to accelerate Spain's exit from the crisis, do you not think it is important to reinforce investment in Science and Technology, and to configure an economic model with greater productivity? And do you not think that the opposite is being done?"

President.- Indeed, there are many issues that the Spanish economy currently has pending, but I would like to say one thing to all of you: in any facet of life, and when it comes to governing, I believe this is much more evident than in others, it is very important to set priorities.

Last year, when we came to government, we had a priority, which still is, and I hope it will be less so over time; we had a priority, and then, given what happened throughout 2012, I believe we were right. We went through a very serious financial crisis and then a very serious sovereign debt crisis, as everyone knows. Many times in life you have to choose, or almost always you have to choose, and when you govern, you also have to choose.

The first priority for us was, logically, the reduction of the public deficit. It was impossible to live with a public deficit of 9 percent. Spain had lost enormous credibility because Spain's commitment was to have a public deficit of 6 percent, and suddenly, in twenty-four hours, because it was in twenty-four hours --this was not prepared-- everyone, the markets, the European Commission, and all members of the European Council, saw how Spain, which was going to have a public deficit of 6 percent, because that was what was being communicated, ended up with a public deficit of 9 percent. Therefore, the government's first obligation was to proceed with the reduction of that public deficit.

A very important effort was made, and as I mentioned in my speech, and this is a very positive fact, it became a national objective, because all administrations were aware that it was decisive for Spain's economic future, to generate credibility and trust, to say: we take this seriously and this situation is going to end.

That forced us to many things that we can talk about later. It forced us to raise all taxes to collect only, as I mentioned in my speech, two billion euros more than the previous year, and it forced us to a reduction of absolutely all budget items. The reduction in spending for the ministries was, in two years, 2012 and 2013, 25 percent of the previous amount. There was no item that we did not touch, none, except for debt interest, over which we cannot make decisions, and except for unemployment benefits, although we did make a legal modification that implies lower remuneration and the obligation to pay social security contributions after six months of receiving it. I insist, except for the pensions item, we have had to reduce all other items.

I am fully aware that R&D is a capital issue. Logically, as soon as the government has the slightest possibility to make a decision and to send a clear message in this regard, you can be absolutely certain that we will do it, just as when we have the slightest possibility we will also lower taxes, as I have already pointed out on some other occasion.

Very recently we approved an Entrepreneurs' Law that represents a step in the right direction. We would have liked to go much further, but things are as they are and you cannot always make --almost never when you are governing-- decisions that please everyone, even the one making them; but I believe that we must act with full responsibility.

We have now adopted some important decisions in the Entrepreneurs' Law, whose objectives are to promote savings, investment, innovation, and employment. We have made important decisions regarding VAT, we have made important decisions regarding credit with "business angels," we have made important decisions such as the non-taxation of a part of the profits that are reinvested, and in that Law we have also made important decisions to support R&D.

I am absolutely convinced that a good part of our country's future lies in this direction; we wanted in this Entrepreneurs' Law to send a message that this is the government's desire and that this is on the government's agenda, and I hope, in this matter and in the issue of taxes, to be able to give good news to the people sooner rather than later, which will be good news for the whole of our country.

Mr. Piqué.- A question comes up that is very relevant after hearing you now, because the question is: "Do you remember what happened to George Bush Sr. when he promised 'read my lips, no new taxes'? He broke that promise and lost the elections?" If the initial situation is recovered, I believe there are still possibilities of winning them again.

President.- You have explained it very well. We have a mandate for four years, but I insist on what I just pointed out in response to the first question that was asked of me. Here it is about setting priorities, and the first priority that the Government of Spain had, the first, and I believe all of you will understand this, is not to enter into a procedure like the one that some countries in the European Union entered, and that is in the minds of all of you, which now have no possibility of doing any kind of economic policy because it is dictated to them.

Some say, "there are countries in the European Union...". For example, I will give something that is very well understood: Our neighbors have the hospitality VAT (restaurants and hotels), our Portuguese neighbors, at 23 percent. Spain has it at 10 percent. If we had not freed ourselves from that, from that threat that was real over the Spanish economy, we would now be in a radically different situation, and perhaps here the conference would be given by others, three together, and not just by me as I am doing at this moment.

For that reason, we have had to raise taxes. However, I am absolutely convinced, because I believe in this as well, that throughout this legislature we will lower taxes again. Now we have seen in the newspaper or in some media that the European Commission is asking Spain to raise VAT. It does not ask Spain to raise VAT, and we are not going to raise VAT. The increases in major taxes this year will not occur, and the government's objective, and we have communicated this in the Stability Plan that we sent to Brussels, and we have explained it, is to lower the Personal Income Tax at the latest --that is exactly the expression we have used-- in 2015, which means that at the latest in 2015.

I believe, on the other hand, that the reform, to which I just referred, of the Entrepreneurs' Law, which I already said I would have liked to go much further, explains where the government is headed. It is a reform whose objective is to promote savings, to promote investment, to promote innovation, and to promote employment. I believe that some things are pointed out there that I think are going in the right direction.

But, I insist, there are things that at certain moments cannot be done and that at other moments can be done. Therefore, I will not have the same fate as George Bush Sr.

Mr. Piqué.- We are glad to hear that, President. To conclude the economic block, and I am aware that we are a bit pressed for time, I will group a few specific questions on economic topics and we will move on to a more political block.

One is: why is the reduction of public entities so slow, and we are very far from the set objective? Another says that the Treasury has one hundred thousand cases in the courts because it does not put its experts to close agreements with taxpayers and to collect cash, and also to offer discounts for tax prepayment. Another is, and I believe you have already mentioned it in your speech, whether it is necessary and desirable to mutualize public debts in Europe, but the specific question is: are movements expected in this regard after the German elections? Another, linked to the fiscal issue as well, is: given such an efficient tax information system, how is it possible that we also have such high levels of tax evasion and fraud? Another raises something that we all know, which is that credit does not flow to companies, and the little that arrives is expensive because, in the end, there is a rate between the ICO, the banks, and the Euribor of 7 percent, while Europe finances at 2 percent; in some places, supposedly. How are we going to be competitive with such a difference?

And one that could be a bit of a closing question for all these issues: "Mr. Rajoy, is a good summary of your speech that the government has done and is doing everything it has to do, and, on the other hand, it is Europe that is not doing what it should do?"

President.- The first question refers to the reduction of public entities. I have given a figure here, which is likely to have surprised some of you, about the reduction of public employment in the Administration, which I believe is a very significant figure. You can consult the Active Population Survey, because in the years 2008, 2009, 2010, and 2011, the increase in unemployment in Spain was 3.4 million people, but with a very significant increase in public employment. Now, in recent times, it has been lower, but with a very significant increase in unemployment in public employment. That is to say, it is not exactly the same situation.

I also spoke to you in my speech about the reform of the Administration. We decided approximately in October --I believe it was in October-- to do what is so often talked about and that is so difficult to define, because do not think it is easy to do this, which is to make a serious reform of public administrations in Spain. There is already a reform of Local Administration that has been approved by the Council of Ministers; now it needs to be debated, discussed, and talked about, but I believe it is very important. And in June, as I also mentioned in my speech, we will hold a presentation event for that work where we will address many issues.

There are four parts; one of them is administrative simplification. The objective of administrative simplification is to make a much more efficient Administration. Some important decisions have already been made in some municipalities, and to open a business in some municipalities it is enough to simply present a sworn declaration of compliance with all the requirements established in the laws, and then the inspection will come from the municipality, the autonomous community, or the government to see if it has been complied with or not.

There is a very important part of administrative simplification, and there is another very important part that has as its fundamental objective to avoid duplicities between administrations, which make life very complex and difficult for citizens. There is a Law of Market Unity, which we currently have in the Cortes and about which we also want to talk, which is very important, and there is a Law on the suppression of autonomous organizations and public entities.

The Government has made a significant reduction, and many Autonomous Communities have also made a significant reduction. You can have total and absolute certainty, and you will see it this June, that we will make the greatest effort we are capable of. We need to have the autonomous bodies and public entities that are necessary, and we should not have autonomous bodies and public entities that are not necessary for the fulfillment of the function for which they are supposed to exist.

One hundred thousand cases in the Courts. It is true that there are many cases in the Courts, and on many occasions those cases are in the Courts, and that is no criticism of anyone, because logically those who go to the Courts, and their lawyers and clients, also have an interest in being in the Courts and being there for as long as possible. Of course, what is posed to me is that the tax administration reaches an understanding with the taxpayer in question. This is fundamentally a technical criterion, and, evidently, there can be instructions that can be given; but I believe that on many occasions tax administrations reach agreements with taxpayers. The problem arises when it is not possible, and that is what leads to things ending up in the Courts. I am aware of this because there are amounts here that would be very important to resolve a good part of the problems that the Administrations have at this moment.

Regarding the mutualization of debt in Europe, I agree, but this is not something that will be addressed in this Council. This takes time. First, it will be necessary for all of us to make our efforts in terms of deficit and public debt; but I believe this would be important. Moreover, there are many formulas, all studied. We have proposed one up to 60 percent, and this is a topic that will eventually be addressed. I have no doubt about it, because it is part of this great process of European construction that I referred to earlier and of which we continue to discuss.

I have here the level of tax evasion. Why is there so much tax evasion? I will give you a fact: Spain is the country of the 27 — now Croatia will enter on July 1, but of the current twenty-seven in the European Union; I am no longer referring to the eurozone — that collects the least Value Added Tax in proportion to Gross Domestic Product. The one that collects the least of the 27 in the Union; including all, therefore. And in total tax revenues, it is fourth from the bottom, meaning there are three countries that have less tax revenue in proportion to GDP.

Last year, within the endless structural reforms that we have launched, there was indeed a law that will make the State Tax Agency much more operational against tax fraud. There is also a very important law to prevent the underground economy and VAT defaults. And the effects are being felt, and a lot, in revenue collection. There is also a decisive action on unemployment insurance, and there have been infinitely superior actions to those that occurred in previous years.

This is one of the Government's great priorities. Recently, the Government asked tax residents in Spain to report their assets abroad, and assets were declared, although some may have already been declared, amounting to 89 billion euros; that is, assets of tax residents in Spain abroad. All are steps we are taking in the right direction, and this is a great objective.

Is it true that the summary of my intervention could be that things are being done well in Spain but Europe does what it does? No. I am not in favor of black or white. I believe that... I said here, and forgive me for reiterating it, a year ago that five points were the summary of our economic policy; I said it a year ago: the first point, fiscal consolidation; the second, reforms in Spain; the third, reforms in Europe; the fourth, liquidity problems in Europe; and the fifth, greater European integration.

In Spain, in terms of fiscal consolidation, we have made progress, but we still have a deficit this year of practically 7 percent. Therefore, if you ask me if I am satisfied, I am not satisfied. It is evident that the great objective, in the end, is to grow, because that is also the way to fight against the deficit; but we must continue to adjust public spending. It is fundamental if we want to move forward and be able to grow in a stable and sustained manner.

Mr. Piqué referred in his intervention to the increase in public debt. We have had to implement a Suppliers' Plan, indeed, because it is intolerable that there are twenty-seven billion euros that are not paid by the Public Administrations to people who have provided their services. This is absolutely unacceptable, unworthy of a serious country. We will do more this year, and the great objective is that all Public Administrations pay within thirty days. I know it is a very difficult goal, but if one does not set clear, understandable, and ambitious objectives, one will never achieve anything.

Secondly, in structural reforms, have we done things? Yes, in Spain we have done many things; I will not recount any. The important thing is that many imbalances have been corrected. I know that this does not reach the people, but that is the prologue to growth and employment.

And then in the three European lines, what has happened? Economic reforms at the European level are progressing more slowly than I would like. I previously referred to the last European Council where we talked about energy. Well, I want the connections, for example, with France — I am just giving an example — to be made much more quickly, and that is not functioning well at this moment, and we must continue to insist on that.

Secondly, liquidity in Europe. Has there been progress? Certainly, not all that I wanted. I have now made a proposal following Draghi's latest statements on credit to SMEs; but, in any case, Draghi has sent good messages to the markets, and we are all aware of that. Before, that did not exist. In other words, decisions have been made. And now we are going to debate the European Investment Bank and we will see the new decisions, if they occur, from the European Central Bank.

In terms of European integration, progress has been made. I attended the first European Council... The first one I attended was in January 2012, and there was only talk of austerity, fiscal consolidation, fiscal deficit, that we had not met our objectives, that we were a country that generated I don’t know what. Well, look, now there is talk of Banking Union, there is talk of Fiscal Union, there is talk of more economic integration, and there is talk of Political Union. And there it is said whether there should be a European Parliament with functions like those of national Parliaments and with, therefore, much greater functions than those that exist now, and there is talk of giving democratic legitimacy, which is very important, to European institutions.

Are we making slow progress on these issues? Yes, but we are making progress. But the European process has always been a process of slow advances. Of course, the Treaty of Rome is from 1957, and the euro took ten years from when it started to be discussed, when we had to meet the requirements, the Treaties were approved, etc., etc.

I believe that we will have to reform the Treaties of the Union again, not today, but yes when we give a little serenity and stability to all this. But, of course, to address Political Union, the European Treaties will have to be reformed, and that will indeed be a decisive moment in the history of Europe.

I have one question left, which is about credit: It is true. Look at all the priorities and all the concerns that I may have, and if someone were to ask me "tell me one": credit. That is what matters most to me at this moment, and believe me, I have had conversations with all the affected sectors: those who give or should give credit and those who receive or should receive credit.

The Entrepreneurs' Law says many things about this issue. A little while before, we had approved a Royal Decree Law, which I announced in the Debate on the State of the Nation in February. Everything we are going to try now in the European Council in June regarding the European Investment Bank is related to credit. I know that there are Spanish companies that are bidding abroad, and sometimes they are not even accepted with the guarantee of a large Spanish bank. All of that is absurd and makes little sense. This is the great concern, and this is undoubtedly a major challenge for the future.

Now, what has happened in Spain in recent years? Forgive me for extending this, because this is a capital issue. We have an external debt that is almost the GDP. This is unsustainable. The net external debt of Spain is almost the GDP. Here, for a long time, everyone was asking for credit, and everyone was given credit. The bad thing is that it was not much for productive investment; it was for housing, plasma televisions — I do not put them on the same level — trips to the Caribbean… Banks were giving a lot of credit, and the regulator should have warned that so much credit could not be given. Meanwhile, the ECB was conducting an economic policy that did not suit us, and German banks were lending to Spanish banks. Now all of that has to be repaid, and therefore, those who need to deleverage must deleverage.

Here the problem is that there are people who have opportunities to invest, who have done things right, and who are harmed by all this. Of course, we are aware that this is the case, but we must also be aware that the origin of the crisis in Spain is a brutal indebtedness, and now, as so many times in life, we must act distinguishing between one and the other.

However, this is the most important challenge, I insist, that the Government has now, and I insist, many of the measures in the Entrepreneurs' Law aim to ensure that credit returns to small and medium-sized enterprises.

I believe I have answered almost all, right?

Mr. Piqué.- There are two questions that are not really questions; they are complaints regarding the support policy for Spanish emigrants and another regarding the conditions of official protected housing. I believe that, as they do not raise specific issues but rather, let’s say, complaints, I would move on to the political block and divide it, if you agree, into two or two and a half parts. I will explain why now.

There is a part that is very linked — both are linked — to some of the contents of the note that we made public at the Círculo de Economía a few days ago, last Monday, and that emphasizes, some, whether it is possible, again, a great pact similar to the one made during the Transition, both at the political level and at the social and business level, to explain what the situation is and to row together. That insistence on the importance of exploring possible pacts is also present in two or three additional questions.

There is another aspect that is also recurrent, and that is the concern that the emergence, the succession, of episodes of political corruption is demoralizing society and also reduces the capacity to face our problems.

There is another that touches on communication and gives a specific example: in a Council of Ministers, a very realistic/pessimistic forecast of growth and unemployment is made; but then, the next day or two days later, the President of the Government communicates his conviction that we are going to improve it. It seems that this type of "incoherence" also provokes a certain distrust.

To conclude this block, there is a question that recognizes the value of the Government in addressing the necessary reforms — here there has been an almost exhaustive mention of them — but says that it is very difficult to see a strategic project, both in the economy and in politics, for the whole country.

President.- I have understood, first, possible pacts; second, the situation of institutions and corruption; third, communication after the Council of Ministers on April 26 when we sent our Stability Program and our National Reform Plan, and then, a strategic project for the country.

On the issue of pacts and agreements, I am in favor, like any reasonable and sensible person. I do not know anyone who is not in favor of pacts or agreements, but, as so often happens in life, what matters is the content of those pacts or agreements. That is to say, what cannot be done in any way is to pursue an economic policy similar to the one that has been pursued in recent years in Spain, among other things, because that is what has brought us to this situation. I can reach an understanding, which is one of the great debates out there, on how the objectives of public deficit are distributed; but, of course, that I have to reduce the public deficit — I do not, Spain as a whole — is something that is indisputable.

In the General Courts, there are many people who tell me that this is nonsense, that the public deficit must be increased… Of course, they will have to go to the markets and explain it, right? Because in that case… The labor reform: the Government has faced two general strikes over the labor reform. Of course, if we want labor legislation like the one we had before, it is very difficult to reach understandings and agreements. That is one of the requests made to me by those who are offering agreements at this moment. The Budgetary Stability Law has been voted against, the labor reform has been voted against, and the restructuring of the financial system has been voted against.

So, of course, if the program that we, as the Government, believe Spain needs is not liked by others, what we can do is follow what others say; but I believe this is not good for Spain and, certainly, it is questionably democratic.

In any case, can agreements be reached? Yes. There is one issue on which there is practically an agreement, and moreover, it is crucial, among all political forces, and I see it in my conversations with various political leaders and in my own debates in Parliament. It is the European issue. What I have said here about Europe generally raises a very broad consensus among all political forces, and this is extremely important, because today Europe is a fundamental part of the decisions that affect us. There is a majority of political forces and of the country that advocates for greater European integration, there is a majority that wants reforms in Europe, and, of course, there is a majority that wants the European Central Bank to make life, at least, pleasant for all European citizens. That is to say, there are many people with whom there is agreement on many of these issues.

We recently approved a Transparency Law with a fairly broad agreement in Congress, which is one of the major reforms that have been made. And now we have a huge opportunity, because we are going to debate -- of course, talking about structural reforms -- a crucial issue such as the sustainability of pensions. Look, this is indeed a first-order structural reform. We are going to bring the issue to the Toledo Pact, there is a group of experts working on it, that will go to the Toledo Pact and consultations have been made with other forces about which people could be part of that committee of experts. We have the reform of the Administration, which is a topic that we can undoubtedly discuss. And there is a crucial issue such as solving the problems of the energy sector and our tariff deficit.

So, there are things where it is easier to reach an understanding than in others, but in any case, what we must never forget is how democracy works. The Government must assume its own responsibilities. It is very difficult for us to gain support for extremely unpopular decisions that the Government often has to make, and I understand that. The opposition often, when it is said "look, you are making -- as is sometimes said -- cuts," does not want to support it.

But at least in the major structural reforms and in essential issues we can do it, and I believe that on these issues I have just referred to -- sustainability of pensions; de-indexation, which is an enormously important issue; reform of the Administration, electricity sector, and all credit issues -- I think there can be understandings among all. And there is a good relationship, especially, with the main leader of the opposition, who was here yesterday.

Then there is the institutional issue, the issue of disaffection, and, well, all these matters such as the issue of corruption. Let's see.

I am going to give you my opinion on this matter: We have been in a very tough economic crisis for five years, and, logically, that is by no means the best environment for people to be happy. People are worried and, moreover, it is logical that they are worried, and they care about the future, and they care about what may happen to their children, and they care about their business, or they care about the lack of credit, or they care about the difficulties they may have in exporting. For those who lose their jobs, it matters a lot. How can those things not matter to them? And, logically, it does not create, without a doubt, a good atmosphere.

Now, it is true that issues of corruption have appeared, and the newspapers report them profusely -- they inform much more about these things than about others, as everyone knows -- and there have been some. We have to make an effort to do everything in our power to overcome it. In the last State of the Nation Debate, as I have announced here, I spoke about some very important laws. The most important is the Transparency Law. The Transparency Law, which was debated this Thursday in the Cortes, is a structural reform of enormous significance. The thing is that I do not see that it is given the attention it deserves. Of enormous significance and it is a law that has not faced much rejection from many people in the Cortes.

We have announced four more laws, which we are trying to agree upon with all political forces. We are going to do everything in our power to make it difficult for public managers to do things that should not be done, which are clearly contrary to the law and to morality. We are going to do it.

Now, having said this, I do want to say one thing: it is profoundly unfair to generalize about the political class by saying that all the people who engage in this noble activity that is politics are suspicious people or people one cannot trust.

I have been in politics for many years and I have known many people -- moreover, I started as a councilor -- who dedicate hours and hours to this activity, and councilors… There is talk of salaries and there are thousands and thousands of councilors. I have heard on some occasions that there are five hundred thousand politicians in Spain being paid. That is absurd, it is ridiculous and it is not true. The vast majority of councilors in Spain earn zero; the vast majority. Therefore, I would ask for fairness when dealing with these matters.

All this issue of disaffection that is here is not a matter that corresponds solely to the Government or to political parties, which can do things and must do things, and they certainly have to set an example. It also corresponds to those who write, to those who express opinions. It is very important. This is an absolutely collective task.

And then I want to say another thing: in Spain there are institutions, and they work. Look at what the prosecutors are doing or what the judges are doing. And there is control from Parliament. All those things are functioning. Will they work later, will they be slow? It may be, and the ideal is that they work faster.

Therefore, I summarize on this issue: first, it is true that the situation of our economy does not help; it is true that there have been behaviors that are clearly reprehensible; it is true that the Government and political parties have to do things and I believe we are doing them; but it is also true that we must be measured, sensible, and place ourselves in the right terms when making value judgments. And I tell you, and I repeat it: I have been in this for many years and there are many people who work many hours doing, or at least trying to do, things well and serving the citizen, and I believe that in this they have many more possibilities of creating a favorable environment than we ourselves because, after all, they will say that we say this because we are interested.

More things. The Council of Ministers on April 26. On April 26 -- I will try not to extend too much -- there were, fundamentally, two major decisions: one, to send our Stability Plan to Brussels, which is something that all countries in the eurozone do, and have been doing for many years, fundamentally, public deficit and public debt; and another, to send our National Reform Plan to Brussels.

That day we reviewed our growth forecasts. We had said at a certain moment that the growth forecast for this year 2013 would be -0.5 percent and that day we said: "no, it will not be 0.5 percent, it will be -1.3 percent." Then, many people said: "well, they are revising their growth forecasts! What is this?" And, upon reviewing those, we also revised the deficit and unemployment forecasts.

I will tell you one thing: of the twenty-seven countries in the European Union, all twenty-seven revised their growth forecasts for the year 2013, that is, one hundred percent. For example, the United Kingdom had made a growth forecast of 1.6 percent and left it at 0.4 percent; Germany had made a growth forecast and lowered it by 1.2 percent, and France had made a growth forecast of 0.8 percent and left it at zero. That is to say, everyone lowered their growth forecasts, including the European Commission and the International Monetary Fund, for the eurozone.

I think it is much better to tell the truth, because in 2012, when we made the forecasts, the Government said -1.7 percent and, in the end, it was -1.4 percent. That is to say, the forecasts improved. But there are recent data in Spanish history, from the last five years, where the unemployment forecast was one hundred thousand more unemployed and then, at the end of the year, it was 1,100,000 more unemployed. I can also make forecasts like that, but I think we would lose all credibility and all trust.

So, what is the challenge now, which is the question I am asked? "And you said you were going to try to overcome them? Well, of course. What I want is for those growth forecasts to be better, for reality to be better than the forecasts. That is what I want. And is that impossible? No. And why is it not? Because, just as we have all had to revise the growth forecasts downwards, perhaps in a few months we will have to revise our growth forecasts upwards. That is the challenge and for that, the important thing is the policies.

Now, what cannot be asked of me… Sometimes, when political criticisms are made by some who are mistaken -- I have told them in Parliament -- about a million job losses, I certainly will not do that. I will always try to make forecasts adjusted to what we believe will happen and, in any case, erring on the side of caution.

Mr. Piqué. - The issue of the territorial problem. There is a block of questions related to what has now been called the asymmetric distribution of the deficit and how we are going to take advantage, in addition, of the small margin that has been communicated to us from the European Commission for the present year. Some argue that, in the end, the most social services and the more rigid parts of public spending correspond to the autonomous communities, such as health or education.

Then, there are also some questions related to fiscal balances, in the sense of why there cannot be greater transparency and thus avoid that only one version always comes out.

Linked to this last point, there are also questions related to the current political process in Catalonia and we have had the opportunity to hear the views of both the president of the Generalitat and the leader of the opposition the day before yesterday and yesterday, respectively. And the questions, basically, I can summarize by saying: What is the Government's attitude towards the political proposal being made from the Government and Parliament of Catalonia and if the response, in the event of any unilateral decision, could be to suspend autonomy or, if that is not the case, if there is a possibility of agreement to make a call.

President. - I will try not to extend too much. First, it is the distribution of the deficit, health and education, and then it is the reform of the Constitution and all this matter that we are raising.

The issue of the public deficit. I would like to say something about the public deficit… Of course, sometimes, special emphasis is placed or a magnifying glass is put on a very specific issue, which is what is happening now: one wants the deficit to be symmetric, asymmetric, I don’t know what… Well, there are opinions for all tastes.

But I want to say something about the public deficit and I do not want to repeat what I have pointed out before: everyone lowered the public deficit, and this is a very positive fact, which has sent a very important message as a country, because there are many people who say: "this is ungovernable, everyone is going their own way." No; look, no. Everyone has lowered the public deficit and everyone has made a great effort. The Government of Spain has made a great effort, but the Generalitat of Catalonia has also made a great effort, and many others.

Some made a greater effort than others. Some started from one starting point and others from another starting point. That is to say, there are Autonomous Communities that have managed to lower the deficit by 6.31 percent and the average reduction of the deficit was -- look at the effort made by the Autonomous Communities -- from 3.31 to 1.76 percent; they lowered it by 1.55 percent. Now, there were those who lowered it by 6.31 percent and those who lowered it by 0.21 percent. Curiously, those who lowered it by 0.21 percent lowered it less because they were already doing very well; the starting point also counts.

In our Budget project, which we later, as I have just explained here, reformed, we had said: Autonomous Communities -- not in the Budget project, in the Council of Fiscal Policy -- the Government's objective, 0.7 percent. Now we have distributed the deficit target, fundamentally, among Autonomous Communities and Social Security. That is to say, the State, well, what is the Government that I preside over, we have put it in an even worse situation; but, of course, the bulk is taken by Social Security, because Social Security has had three years of deficit and, for that reason, we are going to do everything I have said about the sustainability of pensions.

That is to say, Social Security has a very large deficit throughout Spain and also here, in Catalonia. In 2012, approximately, about 2.7 billion euros. Of course, pensions have to be paid, those of everyone, as everyone understands.

Now there is a debate. What are we going to do about this matter? As Piqué said, sensibility, common sense, dialogue, and discussion. We are going to reach an agreement. Now, criteria? Some say everyone should be treated exactly the same. That may be one opinion. There are other criteria: compliance with the stability objective in 2012 --look at all the criteria I have--; reduction of the average payment period to suppliers; using the regulatory instruments approved by the State to reduce the public deficit --that is, those who have made significant progress in health and education will be treated better--; reduction, the issue I was asked about here, of the public business or foundational sector, that is, those who have made a great effort to reduce entities will be treated better; fiscal effort in 2012, that is, to reward those who have reduced the deficit the most in 2012…

There are many opinions on this, just as there are when the debate about regional financing arises. Everyone has their reasons and arguments. The only thing I can tell you is that we will address this issue once the European Council in June has stated, because it must be approved by the European Council, what the deficit objective for Spain is and that, of course, the Government will do everything in its power to reach an agreement among all. And I believe that this agreement will be achieved among all, but allow me not to say at this moment whether it will be symmetrical or asymmetrical, because I am the President of the Government and it seems much more reasonable to me that the Autonomous Communities have the corresponding debate on this matter in the Council of Fiscal and Financial Policy.

But, in the end, the important thing about all this is that we are all aware that we must continue working on reducing that public deficit and that I recognize the efforts that everyone has made, which have been very complicated, and that some started from a really complicated situation.

I also want to say that the Government has helped the Autonomous Communities and will continue to help them. We have lived, and we are still living, a very complicated situation. There are many Public Administrations that cannot finance themselves in the markets. Last year, even the companies in the Ibex 35 could not finance themselves in the markets; not even they could. Now the Government is already financing itself and, as I said before, foreign investors are already entering foreign portfolios.

All these things are happening, but we are now with the Autonomous Liquidity Fund helping the Autonomous Communities; but it is not that I do not want to help them, it is that I want them not to need help because everyone has debt and deficit figures that allow them to access the markets with absolute normality. That is the great objective and this is the great operation in which we are all now, each from different political approaches.

The next issue is health and education. Obviously, health and education are the great fundamental public services and, as I said before, the largest expenditure in all of Spain is pensions. Pensions account for more than 25 percent of all total public expenditure in Spain, including health, education, unemployment, debt interest, municipalities… That is to say, this is the great issue and this issue will be much more important in the future because, fortunately, people are living many more years and those who are now entering the system to collect their pension have higher pensions because they have contributed more and for more amounts of money than the people who are passing away. This is more than 25 percent.

Pensions are paid throughout Spain and there are places where pensions are deficit; that is, there are more pensioners than contributors, and there are places where the contributor pays much more than what they receive in pensions in that same area. This is indeed a first-order instrument of solidarity.

The issue of the Constitution and the debate we have here. I want to say the following about the reform of the Constitution: first, the Constitution can be reformed. The Constitution has already been reformed. The Spanish Constitution has been reformed twice: once, for the right of active and passive suffrage of foreigners in European Parliament and municipal elections, not regional or national --there are foreign mayors in Spain, let's say, citizens of the Community itself--; and, another, recently, on the occasion of the decision made in Europe regarding the fiscal pact, the need for budgetary balance of the public accounts of all Administrations. Therefore, it can be reformed.

Next issue, to reform the Constitution --now I am not talking about the specific issue of today-- three things are needed, at least in my opinion: first, a clear objective. When we reformed the Constitution for the fiscal pact, we knew what we wanted to do and, when we reformed it so that community citizens could vote in Spain, or be elected mayors, we knew what we wanted to do. Therefore, first, a clear objective.

Second, a broad consensus on the objective. That is, the Spanish Constitution, as Josep Piqué recalled in his speech, was the product of a great agreement. It resolved many issues and some things may have been susceptible to different interpretations later; but for that, a Constitutional Court was also established to interpret it.

Therefore, clear objective, consensus, and then, the moment. The moment is very important in life, not only in politics but in any aspect of life. Things that at a certain moment are difficult, later, perhaps, after some time, even seem normal. Therefore, the moment and the setting of priorities are very important. A ruler has two things to be very clear about: first, knowing what their priorities are and, second, knowing what their timing is. That is the most important thing.

Having said that. I have heard, and moreover, this is a topic I like and I have read a lot, opinions for all tastes: from professors, from people, from presidents, from intellectuals, etc., etc. There are many very different opinions on this matter.

And recently we had a Debate on the State of the Nation, in February; we had a debate in the Cortes. I want to tell you one thing: I am the President of the Government and, therefore, I have, just for that, an added responsibility. I cannot express opinions as many others might, and you are fully aware of that. Moreover, I am the president of the most important party in Spain, at least today, because it has the most votes in the Congress of Deputies.

The position of my party, the traditional one, the one that has always been, is: the model of the State is the one in our Constitution, which is a very decentralized model, with a lot of self-government. At this moment, if we set aside Social Security, regional spending is 50 percent, the spending of the Government of Spain is 30 percent --I refer to the total public spending in Spain-- and 20 percent are Local Corporations. Therefore, it is a model that can be perfected, that can be improved and in which we can collaborate; but that is the model of the State that my party has traditionally defended.

For example, the main opposition party now says it is going for a federal model. Very well. I am willing, but we must tell others what that federal model consists of because, of course, which federal model? The German one? It is much less decentralized than ours today; much less decentralized. And, above all, let us stop talking about words and tell me what you intend; that is, what it consists of.

I am willing to consider it and to listen; but what I believe is that acting opportunistically on this issue is of the utmost irresponsibility and I, of course, cannot afford that. I believe that no one can; but I, of course, cannot afford that.

There are others --this was a very important debate that took place in the Cortes-- who proposed that the State assume a series of competencies, among others, education and health, which are held by the Autonomous Communities. This was proposed by a parliamentary group in the debate that took place there. There are others who are proposing a republic similar to what some used to call real socialism and there are others who are now proposing different things like what we have heard about the right to decide and, therefore, the article on national sovereignty would no longer exist.

That is to say, this is the panorama we have today, this is how things are at this moment. So, all this must be taken into account. I do not refuse to talk. I have never refused to talk about this matter and, moreover, I have not refused that it can be reformed; but I have the obligation to be especially responsible.

And then, there are the moments. We must face an economic crisis of the first magnitude. We must try to face it all together. We have very serious financing problems and we are talking today… I am going to Brussels to defend that there should be a single supervisor for all European banks, that there should be a single restructuring for all banks, that there should be a single Deposit Guarantee Fund for all, that there should be a kind of Minister of Finance for all of Europe, that there should be a European budget, that there should be a common European debt, that there should be a European political union… That is what we are defending now. I cannot be in a different position here. I am not going to be. I believe that in that sense I am not saying anything new. My position is known. The great reform that is being made now is the European one, that is indeed a constitutional reform of the highest order.

From there, my position is known. I am Spanish and I am Galician, and as a Galician, I feel Spanish and I am very honored that it is so. I believe in the Spanish Constitution; I believe in the State of Autonomies, which many criticize now; I believe that in this crisis we have shown that together we are capable of setting objectives and fighting for the same thing, and I believe that there are many things, without a doubt, that can be improved and we can talk about, and we can talk about financing, and discuss.

But I believe that we now have many more things that unite us. It is that our history unites us, personal relationships unite us, those who have come here, those who have left, those who have married, commercial relationships unite us. Our own constitutional text unites us, because under its protection we have lived the best period in the history of Spain, the best, in terms of freedoms, human rights, self-government, progress… The best. And we are now united in a battle to face an economic crisis and we are also united in a battle to achieve more Europe, because more Europe is absolutely necessary and essential if we want to exist in the world.

And today we need to be great. In the world we are in, we need to be great. We need to be in Europe, but to be in Europe with strength we need to be great. The small do not count, they do not count at all.

Therefore, my position on this matter is known. I am willing to talk about everything, but I am the one most obliged to address these issues with the utmost responsibility possible. And that is what I will do.

Mr. Piqué.- Thank you very much, President, for your generosity in time, also for your generosity and the position in your arguments, not only from the point of view of their political content but also based on reasons and data. From this moment, we invite you to the next session of the Circle of Economy Meeting.