Speech by the President of the Government at the closing of the XXIX Meeting of the Circle of Economy

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

31 May 2013 · XXIX Meeting of the Circle of Economy

Context
Rajoy addressed the XXIX Circle of Economy annual meeting in Spain on May 31, 2013, discussing the country's economic crisis and recovery efforts.
Main themes
Spanish economic crisis, austerity and fiscal adjustment, economic recovery, public debt and deficit, European growth challenges, structural imbalances, deleveraging, unemployment, international financial crisis, institutional reform, global economic transformation, complexity of economic understanding
Duration
~41 min
91st percentile
Words
4,887
91st percentile
Sentences
191
88th percentile
Readability
43
42nd percentile
Grade
13.3
60th percentile
Syntax
3.21
74th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
42nd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 68%65%
  • Institutional 18%17%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 5%5%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

191 sentences in 80 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

In his famous novel "The Charterhouse of Parma," Stendhal tells the story of Fabricio del Dongo, who, in his adolescence, participates in the Battle of Waterloo. Fabricio has his first, and last, war experience going from one place to another, asking and wondering if he is really in a battle, because he never confronts the enemy even once. Even years later, as a mature man, he continues to question whether he truly took part in that historical event, which, as you all know, shaped the entire European history of the 19th century. He has only seen partial features of the battle, isolated events with no apparent significance, and he cannot explain how he could have been an actor in such a prominent occurrence without perceiving its importance.

Ladies and gentlemen,

It is not difficult to find today people who repeat the syndrome of Fabricio del Dongo in the face of the series of events we are experiencing. The accelerated pace of changes and our partial view of them sometimes make it difficult to see the phenomenon as a whole and, therefore, to have a complete understanding of reality.

It is logical. Just think, for a moment, about what the disappearance of the Soviet bloc, the emergence of China in the global economy, or the special impact of the revolution in communications, with the advent of the Internet as the most graphic example, has meant from an economic perspective over the last two decades.

The accelerated changes, the profound mutations in international trade and financial movements, and the emergence of new geographical areas with thriving economies have radically transformed the economic landscape. An impact of such nature generates uncertainties, because it is no longer possible to walk down well-trodden paths in advance. Almost everything is new, and, to paraphrase the poet, we make our way by walking.

A good example of this is found in some of the topics you have chosen for your sessions this year: "Deleveraging and growing?: is it possible? how?"; "Institutions are important, but how do we build good institutions?"; "The problem of European growth: if austerity does not work, what is the way out? Global risks in a multi-speed world economy." If such capable people as those gathered in this forum are raising these questions, imagine what is happening to the average citizen who has seen the certainties they had in economic matters crumble beneath their feet and who, perplexed, distrusts that we can successfully emerge from the current situation.

Ladies and gentlemen,

Complex problems require broad and detailed explanations that cannot fit into a communication dominated by headlines. That is why it is not surprising that many still wonder how it is possible that the number of unemployed in our country has grown by four million people in five and a half years; how it is possible that public accounts, which presented a surplus of two points over the Gross Domestic Product, went, in just twenty-four months, to a deficit of 11 percent; how it is possible that the debt of municipalities, autonomous communities, and the central state administration doubled in four years; how it is possible that the deficit of our balance with the outside world multiplied by four between 2003 and 2007, or how it is possible that the revenue collection of all public administrations decreased by 68 billion euros in two years.

You know as well as I do: due to the strong imbalances that occurred in the Spanish economy; imbalances whose origin is based on the existence of a huge availability of financing from abroad, and at low cost, which led to a considerable increase in consumption and investments in the residential housing sector. We had an economy based on massive indebtedness that allowed you to invest and consume far beyond your income.

This situation triggered a sharp increase in the external deficit and private debt, and, moreover, that "generous" financing was not channeled towards the sectors of exportable goods, which gives reason to those who claim that Spain lived for years beyond its means.

Now, after the international financial crisis, when it comes time to repay, both investment and consumption are, logically, below our income. And that, so painful, is not easy to understand or accept.

Well, with those reference parameters, we have been removing obstacles from the path of economic recovery and job creation for a year and a half. Sometimes, as if the difficulty were not enough, there are moments when it seems that a collective hysteria prevails that sees apocalyptic landscapes in the immediate future.

I propose an experiment: when you have a minute, now that it is no longer necessary to go to the archives, read what the media were saying exactly a year ago. In my speech at the Circle meeting exactly twelve months ago, I was forced to tell you the following, twelve months ago:

"The difficulties are very serious, no one can doubt it (...) However, if the difficulties are great, the echoes they trigger are even greater. We are witnessing these days a constant overflow of comments, alarms, and doomsday prophecies that seem to herald the end of times. It is as if all the sources of bad news had agreed to create the impression that something important is about to collapse, although they do not tell us exactly what it is.

It is natural that in circumstances like those we are going through, fears, suspicions, or anxieties arise. It is natural and reasonable. What is not reasonable is to feed fears and allow them to grow beyond reality, dragging them into the dangerous terrain of irrationality.

We are not on the brink of any precipice, ladies and gentlemen. That is not the reality. We are not walking down a path of roses, but we are also not witnessing the eve of the Apocalypse. (...)

(...) There are turbulences, but what matters is that we can withstand them and, later on, we will be able to overcome them successfully. And there are good reasons to be confident of that."

Well, ladies and gentlemen, twelve months later, now shielded against the often self-interested movements of panic, we must ask ourselves: are we worse off, the same, or better than we were then in our struggle to clear the obstacles that hinder economic growth and job creation?

A year ago, at the closing of this forum, I presented the five axes that articulated the economic policy of my Government. The first two depended exclusively on ourselves and were, as you know, fiscal consolidation and structural reforms. The other three axes corresponded to the European framework and referred to the structural reforms that should strengthen the internal market, the firm commitment to greater economic integration, and finally, the search for solutions to the problems of financing and liquidity of our economies.

I must tell you that throughout this year, the areas that depend exclusively on us and those that require actions from the entire Union have not developed at the same pace.

Regarding the first axis, fiscal consolidation, the results are evident: we have managed to halt the deterioration of public accounts. The deficit, which in 2011 was 8.96 percent of GDP, was reduced in 2012 to 6.98 percent, and that, in a context of a sharp decline in activity, is a true achievement. In total, the public deficit has been reduced by two percentage points of GDP, which is equivalent to 22 billion euros, of which 19.6 billion, that is, 89 percent, have been achieved through spending reduction measures and the rest by increasing revenues. All administrations, all --central, regional, and local-- have participated in this effort, thus disproving those who claimed that the lack of control of our autonomous communities would make it impossible to reduce public spending.

This reduction in the deficit has been achieved in a context of increased spending items that cannot be adjusted, such as interest on the debt, which constitutes a contractual expense that increased by 20 percent, and social benefits, which increased by 2.9 percent driven by unemployment expenses.

On the revenue side, it should be emphasized that for the fifth consecutive year, the taxable bases decreased in 2012. However, thanks to the regulatory measures approved, which affect the main tax figures, we managed to collect an additional 11.237 billion euros, thus avoiding a collapse in tax revenues.

To assess the fiscal consolidation exercise that Spain has carried out in 2012, reference must be made to what is called, in economic terms, the reduction of the structural primary deficit, which eliminates the effect produced by the increase in expenses and the fall in revenues derived from the crisis. Well, as recognized by the International Monetary Fund, Spain has reduced the structural primary deficit by 3.1 percentage points of GDP, very --I insist, very-- above the countries in our environment.

In the realm of the Central Administration, ministerial spending, for example, has been cut by 16.9 percent in 2012 and 8.9 percent in 2013. And for those who say that nothing has yet been done in the area of administrative reform, I will remind you that the number of public employees has been reduced by 375,000 people in the last year and a half.

I also want to tell you that reforms in the Administration will continue. We have been working for a few months on the one related to Local Administration, with the logical differences in criteria, but making progress. We will try to reach an understanding among all. And in June, that is, this month, it is my intention to present the important work that will serve as the basis for the reform of the Spanish Public Administrations pending for thirty years.

The second axis of national policy was that of structural reforms. First, the labor market reform, a key piece for an economic recovery that generates employment. This reform has been endorsed by all international organizations, and its effects, already perceptible, indicate that we are making progress in achieving the objectives we pursued: to halt the destruction of jobs and increase the competitiveness of Spanish companies.

As is known, and Mr. Piqué referred to this issue in his speech, unit labor costs are a clear indicator of the evolution of competitiveness. In the case of Spain, since the creation of the euro, unit labor costs had not been so low in relation to those of the Economic and Monetary Union. More has been achieved in 2012 than in the four previous years. Thanks to this, the loss of competitiveness in costs that had accumulated since 2004 has been corrected.

However, the greater speed in this adjustment has not been achieved at the cost of a more intense destruction of jobs, but rather, since the labor reform came into effect, there are signs of a change in the pattern of adjustment in the Spanish labor market. Indeed, a better evolution in employment behavior in relation to the economic cycle is observed. In this sense, more than half of the increase in unemployment (specifically, 53 percent) and the destruction of private employment (54 percent) in 2012 occurred in the first quarter, when the labor reform promoted by my Government had not yet come into effect.

On the other hand, the decreases in registered unemployment and the increases in affiliation to Social Security in the months of March, April, and May of this year are also encouraging in the sense that, despite the context of economic recession, the labor market is performing better than in previous years.

As you know, I am very reluctant, and I have been criticized for it, to "green shoots" or "turnarounds of the crisis just around the corner." Therefore, no bells ringing; but next Tuesday, the 4th, I recommend that you pay attention to the unemployment and Social Security contributor figures that will be made public by the Ministry of Employment. They will be, if the observed trends are confirmed, clearly hopeful.

In short, the reform has provided a new framework for labor relations, which is beneficial for companies and for workers. We are achieving, as the data indicates, that wage moderation and measures of internal flexibility are, at last, a practicable path and an effective alternative to job destruction.

Another major reform is the financial one.

The Government firmly addressed the complete cleaning of the financial system and its recapitalization. This pending task was key to ensuring that credit could reach families and businesses.

Last year, the problems of part of this sector were about to knock the Spanish economy down for the count. To restore confidence in the health of our banks, an independent evaluation exercise was carried out, and banks were required to provision their portfolios for a value of 82 billion euros.

As you know, the Government requested --as Mr. Piqué just reminded us in his speech-- European funds to recapitalize those entities that were not capable of reaching the required solvency levels on their own. The restructured and recapitalized entities have regained their strength and the confidence of the markets. Proof of this is, for example, that between December 2012 and February 2013 they secured external financing amounting to 30.5 billion euros, after almost two years during which no foreign funds were entering to invest in our financial system. The foundations are being laid --just that, but they are being laid-- for credit to flow.

In the meantime, the Government has focused much of its efforts on improving access to credit for companies, particularly SMEs, addressing the various existing financing avenues: banking, non-banking, and through the markets.

The initial measures have consisted of a considerable injection of public funds: 22 billion euros in ICO mediation lines and 28.46 billion euros disbursed in the two phases of the Supplier Payment Plan.

I will not detail them, but we have approved a myriad of regulations of different ranks with a great objective: to facilitate and promote alternative, non-banking financing, especially for SMEs, an area in which our country, and I am fully aware, still has a long way to go.

The Draft Law on Support for Entrepreneurs and Their Internationalization includes new measures to favor business financing, such as internationalization bonds and the improvement of refinancing agreements within the framework of the Bankruptcy Law. Additionally, tax incentives have been approved, such as cash VAT, incentives for the investment of profits, those aimed at promoting the quality of growth through business innovation, and finally, tax incentives for investments from business angels.

To these two major reforms, we must add those aimed at improving competitiveness and flexibility. Among these, it is worth highlighting, first, the Draft Law on Guaranteeing the Single Market, which seeks the free establishment and free movement of operators throughout the national territory, and which is being processed in Parliament on an urgent basis.

Secondly, the Draft Law on Support for Entrepreneurs and Their Internationalization, which I just referred to, which, in addition to the tax measures and support for financing, promotes entrepreneurial initiative from the educational sphere and facilitates the start of economic activities through the creation of the Limited Liability Entrepreneur figure or the Limited Liability Company of Successive Formation, with no minimum capital.

I do not want to go into details, but the Law facilitates the growth of business projects, simplifies administrative requirements, reduces burdens, eliminates obstacles to public contracting, supports financing, and protects the leap to the international market.

At this moment, we are also drafting a Law on De-indexation, which seeks to eliminate the harmful effects of automatic linkage to the CPI in the setting of prices and costs. The objective is to avoid second-round effects on inflation, which will contribute to a gain in price competitiveness compared to the rest of the world and a boost to exports in our economy.

Well, these are the main actions we are working on, but they are not the only ones, as we are also adopting sectoral reforms, including measures aimed at promoting the rental market; the rehabilitation of buildings and urban regeneration and renewal; measures to improve the functioning of the food chain, as well as promoting the integration of cooperatives and other associative entities of an agri-food nature, or actions aimed at the regulation of transport or the reform of the energy sector.

Up to this point, dear friends, what has been done so far --I have summarized it as briefly as possible, but I know I have not been very brief-- but I want to now ask myself what the results have been:

Well, these achievements did not seem possible, but they have been reached. Spain is correcting its economic imbalances at a very rapid pace, despite the difficult economic context we find ourselves in: we are advancing in the consolidation of public accounts in a credible and realistic manner, we have restructured our financial system, and our economy is becoming increasingly flexible and competitive.

Now I will talk about Europe, because this affects, and a lot, our economy as well.

At the end of April this year --very recently; specifically, on Friday, April 26-- we sent the European Commission the two documents that all member states must present in spring: the Stability Program and the National Reform Plan, which you already know. The Commission's assessment of both has been favorable. Specifically, it is noted that the Reform Program --I will not go into details because otherwise I would never finish-- proposed is comprehensive and is heading in the right direction.

Regarding fiscal consolidation, the Commission has confirmed that Spain will not have to reach a deficit below 3 percent until the year 2016, that is, two additional years than initially planned. That is to say, there is a greater adaptation to reality in the Commission's documents, because it gives more importance to the need to grow than, exclusively, to consolidate, regardless of growth.

These changes in stance are not a product of chance. If Spain has seen its deficit revised for this year from 4.5 percent to 6.5 percent, it is due to the endorsement that the effort already made offers us and the correct design of our consolidation policies. To highlight the importance of this fact, I ask you to imagine what a reduction of the deficit of an additional 21 billion euros for this year would have represented. Take a moment to think about it.

Ladies and gentlemen,

We care a lot about how things are going in the European Union because, despite all that we are doing, we are not growing. And we are not growing because Europe is not growing. And when Europe does not grow, experience tells us that Spain does not either.

As I said in this forum a year ago, the task of recovering growth and job creation does not fall solely on national governments. It requires European decisions, that is, decisions that must be made and implemented by the members and institutions of the Union; we, among them.

It is fair to point out that in the last year important steps have been taken. Things have improved and the monetary storms have calmed. No one doubts the irreversibility of the euro. The worst of the crisis is already behind us.

However, Europe is the only region in the world that continues to not grow. It has been in recession for six quarters, and it is normal for citizens to wonder what we are doing wrong. The answer, in my opinion, is clear: Europe must do more, better, and faster, and it must do so in the three areas I already pointed out here a year ago: structural reforms in the Union to strengthen the internal market, liquidity for our economy, and advances in integration, that is, more banking and fiscal integration.

I will start by referring to structural reforms, what I call Economic Union. The more integrated our markets are and the more open our economies are, the less likely imbalances will arise, and if they do, it will be easier to solve them. To achieve this goal, we need greater integration in many key sectors, such as retail banking, services, transport, telecommunications, or energy. The recent European Council in May on energy and other issues, but on energy, for example, could have gone further in making decisive decisions.

But we also need to advance in integration in other areas. I specifically refer to advancing in the creation of a true Banking Union and Fiscal Union, and later, and this is a very important challenge, in Political Union. To do this, the first thing we need is to comply with and apply what has already been agreed and decided. I ask for nothing but something very basic: that decisions be transformed into actions.

Almost a year ago, the Euro Summit in June made groundbreaking decisions in this area and also agreed to strengthen liquidity provision mechanisms to reduce financial fragmentation in the euro area, and to take measures to break the vicious circle between financial institutions and sovereign debts. The objective of greater integration was reflected in the document that the President of the Council, van Rompuy, and the other three presidents of the Commission, the Central Bank, and the Eurogroup presented last year: the so-called "roadmap." Spain made very notable contributions that were reflected in the final document: more Economic Union, Banking Union, Fiscal Union, and Political Union.

Well, a year later from that June meeting, I must say that we have made some progress, especially in Banking Union, but we need to do much more because, while it is true that we have a single supervisor, it is still not operational. And regarding the Directive on the resolution of credit institutions, and the possibility of directly recapitalizing banks by the European Stability Mechanism, we are committed to reaching an agreement at the European Council at the end of this month.

We have made some progress, therefore, but it is not enough. The next European Council will be crucial to show that the European Union fulfills what has been agreed and is capable of executing it effectively, because the "roadmap" I mentioned covers a much broader spectrum.

We need to advance even further towards Banking Union. In addition to what I have previously mentioned, before the end of the year we must agree on the Single Resolution Mechanism, and it is my wish, shared by many others, to agree on the foundations and dates of a future common European deposit guarantee system. This is very important to avoid destabilizing cases like the one we experienced in Cyprus. With Banking Union, we would not have talked about the problems we have known in Cyprus.

Regarding Fiscal Union, progress has been excessively timid. We have hardly advanced anything proposed in the "roadmap." We need continental coverage systems, including some type of common European debt.

As for measures to promote liquidity in economies that find it more difficult to access markets, some progress has also been made. The Conclusions of the Euro Summit last June enabled the announcement of the OMT operations --that is what they were called-- of the European Central Bank, which have had a calming effect on the markets. This has facilitated things for both the Spanish Treasury and large companies in their search for financing in international markets. As Josep Piqué recalled, if you compare the Spanish risk premium from yesterday with that of nine months ago, you will see that it has reduced by 55 percent, from 638 basis points to 292 points today.

The situation, however, as Piqué also recalled, is not normalized in the financial markets. SMEs in countries like Spain have difficulties accessing credit and competing on equal terms with their counterparts in other European countries. Resolving this situation of difficulty in accessing financing is essential for growth and job creation.

The most important of these actions has an immediate objective of supporting small and medium-sized enterprises. In Europe, there are twenty-four million unemployed, but there are also twenty-four million SMEs. The best way to tackle unemployment is to facilitate the financing of projects from these companies. For this, I believe that the European Investment Bank can play a fundamental role. A year ago, we agreed, in the already so often cited European Council of June, to recapitalize the European Investment Bank by ten billion euros. This is already materializing, but it is necessary to make good use of it.

I believe that support for small businesses can be channeled through three avenues, something I will propose at this month's Council:

On its part, and I give importance to this issue, the European Central Bank has announced that it will study ways to facilitate the flow of credit to small businesses, which is stalled due to the fragmentation of financial markets. With full respect for its independence, I firmly believe that the European Central Bank can and should do more. On May 2, President Draghi announced his desire to initiate an inter-institutional dialogue to address this issue. This dialogue, in my opinion, and I encourage it, should start now.

The other measures I propose for the Council specifically relate to youth employment. All my colleagues in the Union and I --for obvious reasons, more than anyone-- are very concerned about youth unemployment. We want to adopt effective actions. Two are the ones that, in my opinion, can have the most impact and achieve the objectives sooner.

The most relevant point is, to put it simply, that the aid I wish to provide for youth employment should not penalize us in the deficit. What I am asking for is a mechanism so that the expenses incurred in subsidizing social security contributions for the hiring of young people are not taken into account when assessing compliance with fiscal consolidation obligations in the Excessive Deficit Procedure. With this action, we would allow, and it is already within reach, a strong and immediate action, with a real capacity to incentivize hiring.

The other measure I am calling for is that we quickly utilize the resources that are already available. Last February, in the European Union's Financial Framework, we approved the creation of a fund to boost youth employment endowed with six billion. Spain has been one of the driving forces behind this initiative, whose approval I am particularly pleased with. Now we must ensure that the funds reach their recipients as soon as possible, so that they can be used rapidly as soon as 2014 begins.

I conclude this part by reaffirming the great importance that the upcoming Summit on the 26th and 27th of this month can have. It is evident that there are many more things to do in the area of European integration, it is evident that this Summit will not discuss Fiscal Union, and it is evident that this Summit will also not discuss Political Union, which is undoubtedly one of the topics we must address in the future; but there is one positive thing, which is that there is already a "roadmap": we are already talking about more Economic Union, we are talking about Banking Union, we are talking about Fiscal Union, and we are also talking about Political Union.

It is very important to send positive signals to the markets, to the general public, and to European citizens that there is a firm will to build a European Union in which there is democratic control, in which there is a functioning Parliament, in which there is joint banking supervision, a deposit guarantee fund, a kind of European debt, and in which there is something similar to what happens in other parts of the world with composite states.

And I will conclude now, ladies and gentlemen.

We are making very difficult decisions in a very short time. Some are very painful, but they are unavoidable, because they are essential requirements to recover growth and secure our future.

The efforts, as we have seen, are yielding results, and today we can say that the worst is over, and that the most critical moments are behind us; but we cannot afford a moment of rest. I insist, not a minute; we must continue working in the same direction. The situation of unemployment for millions of people reminds us every day that the fundamental objective of our policy—economic growth and job creation—has not yet been achieved, not by a long shot.

That is why we must all strive, both inside and outside of Spain. To succeed, to grow, and to create jobs, it is not enough for Spaniards to work diligently; we need a more vigorous push, as I have said, within the European framework. The direction that Europe has set, as I have just pointed out, is the correct one. What my Government intends is for the decisions made in the Union to be applied swiftly.

Honestly, I must tell you that I believe we will achieve both things, I believe it. I believe that we will succeed in removing all the obstacles that were blocking the path to prosperity in Spain, as we are doing, and at the same time, I am absolutely convinced that we will achieve that things are done correctly in Europe, so that we can leave the recession behind as soon as possible for the benefit of all.

Nothing more, and thank you very much for your attention.