Press conference of the Prime Minister and the Chancellor of the Republic of Austria.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

28 May 2013 · Press conference of the Prime Minister and the Chancellor of the Republic of Austria

Context
Rajoy addressed a joint press conference with Austrian Chancellor Werner Faymann in Madrid on May 28, 2013, ahead of the June European Council.
Main themes
EU economic crisis, banking union, fiscal consolidation, structural reforms, youth unemployment, SME financing, European integration, eurozone recession, bilateral relations Spain-Austria, European Council June 2013, European Investment Bank role, European Central Bank policy
Duration
~47 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,673
93rd percentile
Sentences
206
90th percentile
Readability
49
61st percentile
Grade
12.9
55th percentile
Syntax
3.27
79th percentile
Vocabulary
1.88
2nd percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

206 sentences in 78 paragraphs

President .- Ladies and gentlemen, good morning. Allow me to begin this address by welcoming the Chancellor of the Republic of Austria, Mr. Werner Faymann, on his first official visit to Spain since we both took office as heads of our respective governments.

We have had the opportunity, throughout the meeting we have just held, to review the good state of our bilateral relations, as well as to join efforts in preparation for the upcoming European Council in June, which is set to make very important decisions for our common future as Europeans. Please allow me to start this address with this last matter.

Austria and Spain share a common priority objective, which is for the European Union, and more specifically the eurozone, to overcome the difficulties it is currently facing. We believe that all countries in the European Union must work together on this. For this, and I have said it on other occasions, determined action is necessary, both at the national level and within the European Union.

I believe that at this moment the majority of countries in the Union, those that need to do so, are making an effort towards fiscal consolidation and reducing public deficit, and we are proposing -- you know the decisions that have been made in Spain -- a myriad of structural reforms aimed at improving the flexibility of our economy and its competitiveness.

Therefore, we both agree that national measures, particularly fiscal consolidation and structural reforms, are necessary and essential to overcome this crisis; but we also both agree that all of this must be accompanied by decisive action at the European level. First of all, to overcome the current economic crisis -- we have been in recession in the eurozone for eighteen months and Europe is the only region in the world that is not growing at this moment; I insist, the last one -- it is necessary to do these things and, at the same time, continue working on the final design of the European Union.

At the next European Council, there are some issues that we both consider important. I want to refer, fundamentally, to three or four matters.

First, the Banking Union. At the European Council in June of last year, President Van Rompuy, along with the other presidents, proposed what we could call a "roadmap": where Europe is headed, what we must do over the next few years. There, the need to advance in the Banking Union and in Fiscal Union was discussed, and to continue advancing in Economic Union, in order to eventually reach a Political Union.

We believe that at this European Council we must continue to advance in the Banking Union. An important decision has already been made, which is a single European banking supervisor, and what we want is for it to start functioning on the scheduled date, that is, March 1, 2014. But we also believe that we must advance, and do so this June, on two other matters, which are the Directive on direct recapitalization of financial entities and the Resolution Directive, so that by the end of the year we can work on another issue, which is the European Restructuring Mechanism, and finally, create a common Deposit Guarantee Fund at the level of the entire European Union.

But in addition to these matters, which fundamentally refer to greater European integration, there are two crucial issues at this moment on which we believe it is good to make decisions: the situation of small and medium-sized enterprises in many countries of the European Union and the difficulties they are currently facing, and youth unemployment. In the case of Austria, it is the country with the lowest youth unemployment in the entire European Union; in the case of Spain, it is a country with absolutely unacceptable youth unemployment rates, but we all want to work, as is natural, to solve this problem.

Regarding SMEs, we believe -- I will not get into technicalities -- that it is essential for the European Investment Bank to take on a more robust, clearer role in helping small and medium-sized enterprises and ensuring that they can fulfill their function, which, logically, apart from obtaining the profit that corresponds to anyone with an initiative, is a social function of creating jobs, especially in a country where 80 percent of people who have a job in the private sector work in a small or medium-sized enterprise.

We also believe it is good for the European Central Bank, whose president Draghi announced on May 2 that there was a significant problem in Europe, that there was financing for SMEs that varied greatly from country to country and that this needed to be resolved... He said he was willing to explore solutions. We believe it is good to take a step in the right direction, a step in the direction of the measure he himself announced.

Regarding youth employment, as you know, we have made two proposals for now, without prejudice to the fact that we believe more needs to be done in the future. The first is that the six billion euros agreed upon in the penultimate Council, in February, when the budgets for 2014-2020 were approved, can be used immediately and that it should not be six billion for seven years, because that makes little sense. This is a figure that will need to be considered for expansion or not; but, in any case, it should be usable now, and therefore, there should be speed, there should be an acceleration in the use of these funds. And then, Spain has also proposed that the social security contributions for hiring young people should not be penalized in the excessive deficit procedure.

On these matters, we have exchanged opinions. We believe it is good for all countries in the European Union to improve. This is good for everyone, not only for the countries individually, but for the whole. Austria is a country that exports a lot to other countries in the European Union and, therefore, it is a net exporting country. It is in its interest that other countries do well, and the same can happen to other national states in the Union. And I have also stated that I believe it is good for countries that can do so, due to being in a better macroeconomic situation, to adopt more expansive policies than those of us who cannot do so due to the level of public and private debt we are in.

As I mentioned at the beginning, we have also evaluated our bilateral relations. We have intense relations at all levels and the Chancellor and I have committed to strengthening them.

And I will conclude. I want to thank the Chancellor for his visit to our country. He is very welcome, as he has always been, and, if possible, in the future he will be even better received -- I don't know if that is possible -- like all Austrians who visit us, and there are many, at certain times of each year in our country.

Thank you very much.

Mr. Faymann .- Dear Mr. President of the Government, thank you very much. I want to thank you for the warm welcome and also thank you for being able to speak openly about the pending issues we have in the European Union.

I am fully convinced that it is important for the various countries of the European Union to do well, because that way we will achieve a good common future for Europe, because purchasing power in Europe is a decisive factor for our economic development and for well-being.

Exports from the European Union outside of Europe are desirable, but, in light of the figures, we realize that the export share of exporting countries is very strong within the European Union, that is, within Europe; therefore, we cannot be indifferent to what happens in other countries. Furthermore, all of this is added to the good friendly relationship, the good political relationship, and the good historical cooperation between Austria and Spain, and among the other countries of Europe.

We have human reasons and we have reasons for the future, for a peaceful future, and these are reasons that do not allow us to overlook a country that has such high unemployment and such high youth unemployment. That is why I have said that the six billion euros that are planned in the Financial Framework are only a very small amount in the program of measures to combat youth unemployment. This amount would need to be available annually, but not over seven years, because we need to create models, such as the Dual Vocational Training model, which works very well in our country.

People are trained in the company, work in the company, and then also visit, let’s say, the vocational school. They learn in practice. We have a training guarantee for young people aged sixteen to nineteen, so that they do not end up on the streets. No one looking for a job should be left on the streets; but among young people, it is very important to be able to demonstrate one’s personality, to be able to develop as a person. That is why it is so important that this training guarantee exists throughout Europe.

We in Austria favor social partnership. It is a very important factor in creating the necessary framework conditions for a competitive economy. Without competitiveness and without being able to compete positively, we will not be able to maintain freedom and democracy against other countries outside of Europe.

We want to maintain high social systems, high welfare systems. Compared to other countries, we have very high standards, and that is why we need to intensify cooperation and coordination in Europe. There we need to consider issues such as amortization funds, etc. We need to take advantage of everything to generate a margin of maneuver that allows for investment, because only investments can guarantee greater economic growth. And without economic growth, we can talk about programs, but without economic growth, even with good training, we cannot create the jobs we need.

That is why I believe it would be good for all of us to try to resolve the tasks that have not been addressed when introducing the euro. Many generations before us saw that the European Union is a magnificent guarantee of a peaceful future; but the framework conditions for a Monetary Union, for high growth and high employment, must be created by us. And we have many tasks ahead of us.

Thank you very much, especially for the good cooperation we have at all levels. If the Ministers of Labor, the Ministers of Economy, the responsible parties cooperate intensively, then something can be achieved. We need to see what the models of good practices are, especially if good framework conditions can be created for the future. And there we should take advantage of it, as you have said, Mr. President of the Government. If we are able to intensify the good cooperation we already have, then, of course, we can see that we can develop in a solidary direction to address the tasks of the future.

Q.- I have a question for the President of the Government. The Chancellor has mentioned the Dual Vocational Training system and, probably, he has made the offer to send fifty experts to Spain, who could help in the creation of this Dual Training. A few weeks ago, the German government made the proposal that five thousand apprentices go to Germany to participate in German vocational training. Would you like Spaniards to also be trained in Austria, or would it be better for Austrian trainers and experts to come to Spain and for Spaniards to stay here?

President .- I believe that all proposals are good, right? However, the best is the reality that means the existence of Dual Vocational Training, which is something I included in the electoral program with which I ran in the last elections because, indeed, I know about the good functioning, especially in Austria and Germany, of Vocational Training.

It involves students who are studying, but at the same time have a job, logically, which ultimately also becomes part of their studies. This has the enormous advantage that people are already focused on the needs of the labor market. Therefore, while studying, they are being trained in practical matters and have many possibilities later to access a job in that same company.

I want to say that in Spain there are already some companies that are doing Dual Vocational Training, because it is already allowed; but, of course, they are, above all and fundamentally, large companies, in many cases multinationals, and it really works to full satisfaction.

I, of course, want this to be a system that becomes widespread in our country, because I have seen that it has worked very well, particularly in Austria and Germany. Any of the formulas are good: having people come here to help those who can then develop that knowledge is very interesting, and also going there. But, I insist, what matters most to me is the concept. I believe that Dual Vocational Training is something very positive that Austria has the fortune of having introduced into its tradition a long time ago. And, probably, this, along with other decisions made in the past, says a lot and has a lot to do with the macroeconomic figures and the standard of living that Austria has at this moment.

Q.- I wanted to ask two questions, one for both and another for the President of the Government of Spain.

For both. Today, the OECD has released forecasts that are indeed not good for the European Union, nor for Spain. I would like to know if, in light of these forecasts, you do not think it would be necessary to make a radical shift in the economic policy being pursued by the European Union, which is excessively focused on austerity, in order to try to emerge, as the OECD says, from the "clutches of recession."

To the President of the Spanish Government, I would like to raise the issue of the European Commission, which is today studying the Reform Plan that Spain has presented and its forecasts for next year. It has already indicated that it will demand an urgent reform of the pension system, a deepening of labor reform, and a review of the tax system because, despite the tax increases that have occurred, it seems that the revenue from all tax figures is falling. So, I would like to know if you are willing to advance in these three areas, especially in the last one, by easing, for example, the personal income tax in exchange for raising or changing the VAT brackets.

President.- These are two distinct and very interesting questions.

Regarding the OECD forecasts, there is one piece of data that is very positive and on which all forecasts agree: this will be a year in which we will have already hit bottom. We have already hit bottom, really, haven’t we? This year there will still be negative growth, but next year there will be positive growth, and that is a very relevant piece of information. They always agree, plus or minus a tenth, with the forecasts we made, as you know, not long ago; the government’s forecast: negative growth this year of -1.3 percent and already positive growth for next year.

But, just as I tell you that, I also tell you something I have pointed out on some occasions: the key is to work to exceed the forecasts. Regarding the forecasts, you see, this year the twenty-seven countries of the Union have changed their forecasts, and the Commission and the International Monetary Fund have changed the forecasts for almost all the countries of the European Union. The key, and that is the objective, is to improve those forecasts. Just as this year we had made forecasts of -0.5 percent and moved to -1.3 percent, we should try to exceed that -1.3 percent, improving it, and next year grow more than we have projected.

Of course, that leads to two types of decisions: some, the national ones, where we will continue to work in the same direction, that is, reducing the public deficit and implementing structural reforms; and others, the European decisions to which you also referred in your question.

You say: does Europe need to change its economic policy? I believe there are data that demonstrate that Europe is changing. Very recently, the deficit target for this year in Spain was -4.5 percent, and now a significantly higher deficit target is being discussed. In any case, I can already tell you that the deficit must be met. Look, Austria has a magnificent deficit figure, and that deficit figure, along with other things, is what leads to its economic situation being one of the best in the entire European Union today.

Therefore, there has been a change in Europe regarding the path of the public deficit, which I believe is positive; but we must continue to do everything possible to reduce that public deficit.

Then there is something that I believe Europe is also doing, but in which we must work intensively. I believe my first European Council was in January 2012. At that time, only austerity and public deficit were discussed, and now we are already talking about European integration, we are talking about youth employment, and we are talking about what we can do to help small and medium-sized enterprises. Therefore, the discourse has changed, which is what many of us were advocating at that time.

Thus, in that line, I hope that this European Council we are holding now will take steps in the direction of integration and in resolving some specific problems; I am referring, fundamentally, to credit for SMEs and the issue of youth unemployment, which are, in Europe, but especially and particularly in Spain, a major objective.

Now you are talking to me — this is the second question — about today’s meeting of the European Commission. The European Commission will review today the Stability Plan of all the countries in the eurozone and also the accounts of the countries that are not part of the eurozone, and then the National Reform Plans of all the countries. And it will make recommendations, as it has always done, to the twenty-seven countries and, in the case of the eurozone, to all those that are part of it.

We do not know what they are, but in the case of the three issues you have referred to, they are: first, the sustainability of pensions. It is not that they will make recommendations; it is that this is included in the National Reform Plan that we have submitted to the Commission, so what I suppose they will say, because I do not know yet, is that they find it acceptable. In fact, as you know, we have already tasked a group of independent experts to begin working on this issue to bring it to the Toledo Pact and, from there, make decisions.

This is a crucial issue. It is about working in the medium and long term with the basic objective of maintaining what is a great achievement, such as the public pension system we have in our country. But, I insist, we are working on that issue.

Regarding the labor market, we do not know exactly what they will tell us. Probably, that we should evaluate the results of the labor market reform. We are doing that; it is something we started doing two months ago. I believe that the structural reform of the labor market has been one of the decisions that many people I am aware of did not like, but it is one of the best that has been made to improve the competitiveness of the Spanish economy and to end the only option many companies had, which was to lay off people.

Now, with greater flexibility, there are more alternatives to layoffs, and I think that is very positive. A flexible and competitive economy will always be better for people and better for the country as a whole.

As for the tax system, we do not know if they will tell us what you have pointed out; but I have already stated on some occasions that we want to lower the Personal Income Tax. Frankly, I do not want to raise the Value Added Tax. No one wants to raise taxes if things are going well. If we have made this decision, it has been because we believe we had no alternative and because there was a priority, which was to overcome a very serious crisis that we had in Spain, the two major crises we had in Spain last year: the financial system — we are already restructuring the financial system — and then the sovereign debt crisis.

Last year at this time, and in the following months, we were only talking about whether there would be a rescue or not, or what you were going to do, what you were not going to do. Fortunately, now we are no longer talking about the rescue, but we are talking about when we are going to lower, which we are going to lower, the Personal Income Tax or what we are going to do with the labor market reform.

Therefore, I believe that is a significant advance. I am satisfied with how the European Commission has been acting in recent times. On the 5th, that is, next Wednesday, I will have the opportunity to meet with the entire College of Commissioners, accompanied by several members of my Government; then I will also be with Mr. Van Rompuy, and, of course, we will talk about all these issues. And, of course, the European Council, which, I insist, is very important for everyone.

Mr. Faymann.- I believe that competitiveness and structural reforms serve to prepare us for the future, because with cuts we cannot maintain purchasing power, and the purchasing power of the population has two advantages: of course, it boosts the economy itself through consumption, and then it also generates greater social acceptance of reforms and thus also a social acceptance of a common Europe.

To achieve investments, better coordination at the European level is needed. If financial markets open a very significant gap for us and if the interest rate differential were as high as last year, now the situation has improved a bit.

Countries had an interest rate differential last year between our country, 1-2 percent in the long term, and other countries had to pay 7-8 percent, so a common strategy is needed; not necessarily a redemption fund, but a common strategy because, if money is used to pay interest rates, then there will be no money to invest.

I believe that in Europe there are many who think that, apart from the necessary structural reforms, we need to create a margin of maneuver that allows for investment because, if not, we would lose an entire generation, because we have young people unemployed, who are unemployed for a year, then two, then four years, and if measures take too long to arrive, they will practically never integrate into the labor market. That would be very bad for those affected, but also for the future development of Europe; a serious mistake.

Q.- Mr. President of the Government, we are talking about Dual Vocational Training and the successful model of Austria is the so-called social partnership, the partnership between social agents. Your Government has tried to make a reform in this regard, but it is difficult to achieve. Spain and other countries have had the need for reforms for a long time, but they have not been made; that is, they have been made because of the crisis. Why does Spain have so many difficulties in achieving this kind of social partnership so that it becomes anchored as a foundation in society?

President.- You have said something that is enormously true: that Spain and other countries could have made more structural reforms and did not do so. We have made many structural reforms throughout our history, then there were times when we did not make structural reforms, and in the Government that I preside over, in the nearly year and a half that we have been in charge of the Government, we have made structural reforms of great significance, starting with a Budget Stability and Public Accounts Sustainability Law. I always say that this is probably the most important structural reform we have made, and its objective is to achieve budgetary balance and reach zero deficit.

We have made a labor reform, which has certainly been very controversial for many people, but which makes the Spanish economy much more competitive; we have initiated the restructuring of the financial system; we have already made decisions regarding pensions to try to bring the real retirement age closer to the legal age; we have made very important decisions in energy matters, and we must continue to make them, because we had a tariff deficit that exceeded twenty billion euros; we have a Market Unity Law underway; we have a reform of Public Administrations underway, and I have already mentioned the sustainability model of pensions.

In a very short time, we have made — I would have liked them to be done already — some structural reforms, which we do not do because Europe says we have to do them, which is also true; but we do them, above all, because we believe in them and because it is good for sustained and stable growth, and to prevent a situation like the one we have experienced from happening again.

It is evident that when the financial crisis occurred worldwide, those who were better prepared fared better than those who were less prepared.

The issue of Dual Vocational Training is undoubtedly a matter of enormous importance, it has a high budgetary cost, and what we cannot do is achieve it in twenty-four hours. But the fundamental thing is to take steps in the right direction.

I like the model, I tell you. I ran for election with Dual Vocational Training. I believe I launched this idea in the summer of 2011; I don’t even know if it was in the summer of 2010, I don’t remember exactly. And the Minister of Labor of my Government met with the Austrian official to also explore the possibilities of this. I believe in it, we are going to do it, but, logically, we will do it gradually.

I truly believe that a Government should never lose its reformist spirit; I think it is a huge mistake. Society is constantly changing, times are different, new realities arise, and a Government that falls behind does a disservice to its country. Therefore, the reformist spirit should be the hallmark of any Government.

Now we have been forced during this time to make, I insist, structural reforms of great significance. Two weeks ago we presented an Education Law, a week ago we presented an Entrepreneurs Law, and that will be the tone throughout this entire Legislature.

P.- My questions are for President Rajoy. First of all, I would like to ask if you can confirm a piece of information that has appeared today, according to which you met, I believe this Monday, with Mr. Adelson to talk about Eurovegas. Specifically, and above all, we would like to know if the Government has already decided whether exceptions will be introduced in the Anti-Tobacco Law so that smoking can be allowed in Eurovegas.

Another question. After your meeting here at La Moncloa with Mr. Felipe González and the good rapport that, apparently, we have seen this morning in the session of government control with the leader of the opposition, I would like to know if you are considering calling La Moncloa to meet again with Mr. Rubalcaba, with whom I believe you have not officially met for over a year, and if, in that way, it will be possible to work towards a great employment pact, especially for youth employment, as all social organizations are somewhat demanding.

And, if you allow me, a last-minute issue has arisen, just before this press conference began. The Constitutional Court has accepted the appeal against the elimination of the extra pay for civil servants from last Christmas. I would like you to tell us a bit about the Government's position on this issue and if you fear that there may be a judicial setback against one of the main savings measures that have been implemented in the last year.

President.- There are several questions. Regarding the first one, yes, I have met with Mr. Adelson, just as I have met with Mr. González and also with Mr. Aznar, which is one of the topics that, apparently, has generated interest over the last few days. This is part of the meetings that the President of the Government regularly has, and he has them because they are people who, each in their current activity—one for business reasons and the other for their knowledge and history in this country—can contribute things that are useful for the better governance of Spain.

Listening, hearing, and talking to people is something to which I dedicate a very important part of my agenda.

Regarding Mr. Adelson, no decision has been made on that matter you referred to; but we do believe it is a good project because it will generate a lot of jobs in our country.

The meeting with Mr. González has nothing to do with what happened this morning in Congress. What happened this morning in Congress is nothing but the continuation of the positions that the Socialist Party, the Popular Party, and the Government of Spain have maintained regarding the European issue. This is not one of the topics that have generated controversies.

You know that the Socialist Group has not supported many of the structural reforms I have referred to. They have not supported the labor reform, nor the Budgetary Stability Law, nor the Restructuring of the Financial System; but they have supported us on the general lines of the European debate.

From time to time, it is worth recalling history, even if it is recent history, because I have been telling you for a long time what the Government's European policy is. You will remember that I always tell you five points: first point, fiscal consolidation, but with a reasonable path, and now there is fiscal consolidation with a reasonable path; second point, national structural reforms: we have done them and continue to do them; third point, European integration, and look at what I have talked to you about regarding Banking Union, Fiscal Union, and remember the European Council of June last year; fourth point, structural reforms in Europe, the big debates on Economic Union and the internal market, and fifth point, liquidity issues: here is the EIB and here is everything that the European Central Bank does and can do in the future.

That has been my position since I arrived in the Government; it has always been the same. I now see, and I am happy about it, that everything is being talked about. We are no longer only talking about the first point, which is fiscal consolidation; we are talking about everything. And I believe that on this matter, the position, I think of the majority of the Chamber, is similar.

As for not having seen Mr. Rubalcaba for a year, no, no. What is the difference between officially and unofficially? I don’t know, but I talk to him often, which, on the other hand, should not surprise anyone and is normal. I talk to him; on many things we agree and on others we do not agree; but on these European issues we agree, and it is good that we all agree because, moreover, these are matters of quite a bit of common sense.

Regarding the last-minute issue, I did not know; I thank you for giving me this information. Whenever we make decisions, we believe they are in accordance with the Spanish Constitution, as is natural; if not, we would not make them, as is perfectly understandable. I hope we are proven right. I hope never to have to take away the extra pay from anyone again, but if we did, it was because at that moment there was no other choice, just as I have said the same regarding the increase in personal income tax.

A leader often has to make decisions that many people do not like, but if we do so, it is because we believe it is absolutely essential for the general interest of Spain. I do not like having had to raise the Personal Income Tax; I do not like it, and, as I have already said, I will lower it as soon as I can. But all these decisions we are making in Spain have no other objective than to lead to economic growth, to create jobs, and therefore to achieve revenues for the Administration that will then allow us to lower taxes and even improve people's purchasing power. That is exactly how things are.

What I cannot do is make decisions that create... I can be right or wrong, like anyone; but what I will never do is make decisions that I believe are bad for the general interests of all citizens.

I am absolutely convinced that everything that is being done will ultimately produce positive effects for Spaniards, and I am absolutely convinced that many people who are now, and rightly so, critical of the Government's decisions will then recognize that they should not have been so critical. I am sure many will do so; not all, but many will do so, and that is good. It is a sign that we are a just country when it comes to expressing opinions.

Thank you. Thank you very much.