Speech by the President of the Government at the closing ceremony of the 29th Meeting of the Círculo de Economía

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

31 May 2013 · Closing ceremony of the 29th Meeting of the Círculo de Economía

Context
Rajoy addressed the closing ceremony of the 29th Círculo de Economía meeting in Barcelona on 31 May 2013, focusing on Spain's economic situation and political challenges.
Main themes
Spanish economic recovery, fiscal consolidation vs. growth debate, European economic challenges, austerity policies, structural reforms, political disaffection, civil society responsibility, Catalonia political situation, globalization and economic transformation, institutional reform
Duration
~48 min
94th percentile
Words
5,801
94th percentile
Sentences
221
91st percentile
Readability
45
49th percentile
Grade
13.1
58th percentile
Syntax
3.16
68th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
38th percentile
Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 67%66%
  • Institutional 15%15%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Social 7%7%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

221 sentences in 92 paragraphs

Dear friends of the Círculo de Economía,

Allow me to start with some brief acknowledgements. I would like to offer my sincere gratitude to the Círculo de Economía for inviting me once again to this forum. I would also like to thank Josep Piqué, its president, for his kind words of welcome and, of course, to all of you who have been kind enough to attend this event.

In his opening speech, the one you have just heard, the President of the Círculo de Economía, Josep Piqué, mentioned a number of unquestionably important issues; he mentioned the issues that most concern the people of Spain today and which are hugely important in themselves. My speech will basically focus on economic issues; but I would later like to touch on some other issues that have been brought up here, such as the Constitution, agreements, the general disaffection with politicians, the situation of the political parties and the Elections Act in Catalonia.

I obviously agree with one of the last statements made by the President of the Círculo de Economía in his speech on the need at this time for significant efforts to be made on streamlining, sensibility, common sense and foresight. For my own part, I will endeavour to ensure those concepts are present and I am absolutely convinced that the other actors will do the same; fundamentally the actors on the political stage but also other actors who are not so closely associated with politics and who are probably much more necessary than ever today - actors from what we have traditionally called 'civil society'.

Solving these problems is not only a government responsibility, nor a responsibility for the people who form part of a particular political party - whether they be in the opposition or supporting the government. Solving these problems is a responsibility for society as a whole and society must undoubtedly play a very important role, especially at the most complicated of times.

Therefore, I will first of all talk about the economy and certain issues that have been raised and then, either straight away or after further defining the issues a little, I will start tackling the issues that have not been included in the speech I have prepared for you right now.

Ladies and gentlemen,

In his famous novel entitled "The Charterhouse of Parma", Stendhal tells the story of Fabrice del Dongo who fought in the battle of Waterloo during his adolescence. Fabrice spends his first, and last, experience of war going from one place to another, asking and wondering whether he is in a battle or not because he never actually comes face to face with the enemy. Even years later, as a grown man, he continues to question whether or not he really did form part of that historical event, which, as you all know, shaped the entire history of 19th Century Europe. He saw only brief glimpses of the battle, isolated incidents of no apparent significance, and he cannot explain how it came to be that he was a player in such an important event without perceiving its significance.

Ladies and gentlemen,

It is not difficult to find people today experiencing the same turmoil as Fabrice del Dongo with the situation we are living through. The rapid pace of change and our partial vision of that change sometimes obscure an overall grasp of the phenomenon and, therefore, prevent full comprehension of the reality.

This is logical. Just think for a moment about the economic effects in the last two decades of the fallout from the collapse of the Soviet bloc, the emergence of China into the global economy or the special impact caused by the communications revolution - the rise of the Internet being the clearest example.

The accelerated pace of change, the sweeping changes in international trade and financial movements, and the appearance of new geographical regions with emerging economies have radically transformed the economic stage. Such an impact naturally generates shock waves and uncertainty because it is no longer possible to follow the well-trodden paths of before. Almost everything is new and, to paraphrase the poet, we are forging the way as we go.

A good example of this can be found in some of the topics chosen for your conferences this year: "Lower debt or grow? Is it possible? And how?"; "Institutions are important but how do we build good institutions"; "The European growth problem: if austerity fails, what is the answer? Global risks in a variable-speed world economy". If people as knowledgeable as those gathered for this forum are asking themselves these questions, just imagine how the average citizen feels as he sees the certainties he had in terms of the economy fall away beneath his feet and now, perplexed, has doubts regarding our ability to successfully recover from the current situation.

Ladies and gentlemen,

Complex problems require broader and more detailed explanations that have no place in communication where the headline is all. For that reason, it is no wonder that many people are still asking themselves how it is possible that the number of unemployed in Spain has risen by four million in five and a half years; how it is possible that the public accounts, which posted a surplus of 2% of the gross domestic product, have slipped in only 24 months to a deficit of 11%; how it is possible that the debt held by local councils, regional governments and the central government could have doubled in four years; how it is possible that the deficit in our trade balance could have multiplied four-fold between 2003 and 2007; or how it is possible that tax revenue for all the public administration services could have fallen by 68 billion euros in two years.

You know the answers as well as I do: because of the serious imbalances that arose in the Spanish economy; imbalances whose origin can be found in the existence of an enormous availability of financing from overseas at a low cost that led to a considerable increase in consumption and investment in the residential property sector. We had an economy based on massive indebtedness that let people invest and consume far beyond their income level.

This situation led to a sudden increase in the foreign trade deficit and private debt. Furthermore, that "generous" financing was not channelled towards sectors producing exportable goods, thus lending truth to statements from those who say that Spain was living beyond its means for a time.

Now, that the time to repay has arrived, following the international financial crisis, both investment and consumption are, naturally, at a level below our revenue. That painful fact is not easy to understand or swallow.

So, with that in mind and for a year and a half, we have been removing obstacles from the path to economic recovery and job creation. Sometimes, as if the situation was not already difficult enough, there are moments at which a collective hysteria seems to arise and people only see apocalyptic scenarios for the immediate future.

Allow me to propose an experiment: when you have a minute, now that newspaper archives have become obsolete, read what the media were saying precisely one year ago. In my speech at the meeting of the Círculo de Economía exactly 12 months ago, I was forced to tell you the following:

"The difficulties are very serious, nobody can question that (...). That said, if the difficulties are large, the ripples they produce further down the line are much larger. We have been bombarded recently by a constant barrage of comments, warnings and apocalyptic prophecies that seem to preclude the end of days. It is as if all the sources of bad news have reached an agreement to create the impression that something important is about to happen, although without saying exactly what.

It is only natural that fears, suspicions and concerns abound in a situation such as the one we are experiencing at the moment. Natural and reasonable. What is not reasonable is to feed those fears and enable them to grow out of all proportion, dragging them into the dangerous territory of irrationality.

We are not on the edge of a precipice, ladies and gentlemen. That is not the reality. We are not walking through a field of roses but neither are we witnessing the dawn of the Apocalypse. (...)

(...) We do have problems, but the important thing is that we can deal with them and, in the future, successfully overcome them. And there are well-grounded reasons to be sure of that."

Now, ladies and gentlemen, 12 months on, now protected against the often controlled movements towards panic, we should ask ourselves this: Are we worse off, the same or better off than we were then in our efforts to remove the obstacles preventing economic growth and job creation?

A year ago, at the closing ceremony of this forum, I presented the five core areas supporting the economic policy of my government. The first two depended exclusively on us and were, as you know, fiscal consolidation and structural reforms. The other three corresponded to the European framework and related to the structural reforms needed to strengthen the internal market, the firm commitment to greater economic integration and, finally, the search for solutions to the problems of financing and liquidity in our economies.

I must tell you that, over the course of this year, the issues that depend exclusively on us and those that require action from the EU as a whole have not developed at the same pace.

As regards the first core area - fiscal consolidation - the results are obvious: we have managed to slow down the pace of deterioration in the public accounts. The deficit, which stood at 8.96% of GDP in 2011, was reduced to 6.98% in 2012 - and that, against a backdrop of strong decline in activity, is a real achievement. In total, the public deficit has been reduced by two percentage points of GDP. This equates to 22 billion euros, of which 19.6 billion euros or 89% was achieved with cut-backs and the rest was achieved by increasing revenue. All tiers of government, every one - central, regional and local - have made a contribution to that effort, thus refuting those who said that a lack of control in our regional governments would make a public expenditure reduction impossible.

This deficit reduction was achieved against a backdrop of increased spending under those headings it was not possible to adjust, such as servicing debt - which constitute a contractual expense and increased by 20% - and social benefits - which increased by 2.9% because of the large amount of unemployment benefits needed by the people.

As regards revenue, it should be stressed that the tax bases fell for the fifth consecutive year in 2012. However, thanks to the approved regulatory measures affecting the main taxes, it was possible to collect an additional 11.24 billion euros and thus avoid a collapse in tax revenue figures.

In order to assess the exercise in fiscal consolidation undertaken by Spain in 2012, I must refer to what is called in economic jargon the reduction in the primary structural deficit, which eliminates the effect caused by the increase in spending and the decrease in revenue derived from the crisis. Now, as recognised by the International Monetary Fund, Spain has lowered its primary structural deficit by 3.1% of GDP - a great deal more than the other countries in our peer group.

In terms of spending by central government, for example, ministerial expenditure was cut by 16.9% in 2012 and by 8.9% in 2013. And to those who say that nothing has yet been done in terms of reforming the public administration services, I would remind them that the number of civil servants has been reduced by 375,000 in the last year and a half.

I must also say that the reforms in the public administration services will continue. We have been working on the reform of the local authorities for a number of months, with the expected differences in criteria, but progress is being made. We will try to reach an understanding between all concerned. And in June, this month in other words, it is my intention to present the important project that will serve as a basis for the reform of the public administration services in Spain, which has been necessary for the last 30 years.

The second core area of domestic policy related to structural reforms. First of all, the reform of the labour market - a key piece of the jig-saw for economic recovery capable of creating jobs. This reform has been backed by all the international organisations and its effects, which can already be seen, show we are heading towards compliance with our targets: to slow the pace of job losses; and to increase the competitiveness of Spanish companies.

As is well known, and Mr. Piqué also mentioned this in his speech, unit labour costs are a clear indicator of the trend in competitiveness. In the case of Spain, since the launch of the Euro, since then, unit labour costs had not been at such low levels when compared with those of the Economic and Monetary Union. More was achieved in 2012 than in the four previous years. Thanks to this, the loss in cost competitiveness accumulated since 2004 has been corrected.

However, the increased speed of this adjustment was not achieved in exchange for faster job losses but rather, since the entry into force of the labour reform, we have seen signs of a change in the pattern of adjustment in the Spanish labour market. In fact, we are seeing a better development in employment trends in relation to the economic cycle. In this regard, more than half of the unemployment growth (53% to be precise) and of the private job losses (54%) in 2012 took place in the first quarter, when the labour reform promoted by my government had not yet come into effect.

Furthermore, the fall in recorded unemployment and the increasing number of people registered with the Social Security system in March, April and May this year are encouraging in the sense that, in spite of a context of economic recession, the labour market is posting better results than in previous years.

As you know, I am rather averse - and I have been criticised for this - to mentioning the "green shoots" or the "exit from the crisis being just around the corner". Therefore, I will avoid making a song and dance of this but I recommend you pay attention to the unemployment and national insurance figures that will be released on Tuesday, 4 June, by the Ministry of Employment. If the latest trends are confirmed, they will be clearly encouraging.

In short, the reform has given our labour relations a new framework, which is beneficial for companies and beneficial for workers. As the figures indicate, we are ensuring that wage moderation and the internal flexibility measures can finally become a feasible solution and an effective alternative to job losses. The financial reform is another big one.

The Government of Spain took strong action to completely reorganise and recapitalise the financial system. This had been a long time coming and was essential for re-opening the flow of credit to families and companies again.

Last year, the problems in a part of this sector were on the verge of bringing down the Spanish economy. In order to restore confidence in the health of our banks, we commissioned an independent assessment and the banks were required to provision their portfolios for a value of 82 billion euros.

As you know, the Government of Spain asked - Mr. Piqué just reminded us of this in his speech - for European funds to recapitalise those entities that were unable of achieving the required solvency levels on their own. The reorganised and recapitalised entities have regained their strength and market confidence. Proof of that can be seen, for example, in the fact that, between December 2012 and February 2013, they have obtained external financing to the sum of 30.5 billion euros. And that after almost two years in which no foreign funds were entering Spain for investment in our financial system. The foundations are being created - only the foundations but it's a good start - to restart the flow of credit.

Meanwhile, the Government of Spain has focused a large part of its efforts on improving access to credit for companies, and SMEs in particular, by tackling the various financing channels that already exist: bank financing, non-bank financing and via the markets.

The first measures consisted of a sizeable injection of public money: 22 billion euros through ICO credit lines and 28.46 billion euros paid out during the two stages of the Supplier Payment Plan.

I will avoid going into excessive detail at this time, but we have approved a long list of regulations at various levels with one main objective: to facilitate and promote an alternative form of financing - non-banking finance - for SMEs especially, an issue on which a lot of work still needs to be done in Spain, something I am fully aware of that.

The Draft Bill on Support for Entrepreneurs and their Internationalisation includes new measures to foster corporate financing, such as internationalisation covered bonds and the improvement of refinancing agreements within the framework of the Insolvency Act. In addition, a number of fiscal incentives have been approved, such as the cash-based VAT system, the incentives to invest profits, those aimed at fostering quality of growth through corporate innovation and, finally, tax breaks for investments by business angels.

To these two major reforms can be added the other reforms aimed at improving competitiveness and flexibility. They include, firstly, the Draft Law on Guaranteeing Market Unity, which seeks the free establishment and free circulation of operators throughout the country, is being fast-tracked through Parliament.

Secondly, the Draft Bill to Support Entrepreneurs and their Internationalisation, which I just mentioned and which, as well as the fiscal measures and those to support financing, fosters entrepreneurial initiative through education and makes it easier to launch economic activity by creating the status of limited liability entrepreneur and the limited liability capital growth company, with no minimum capital amount.

I do not want to take up your time with too many details but the law makes it easier for business projects to grow, simplifies administrative requirements, reduces burdens, eliminates obstacles to public contracting, supports financing and protects the leap into the international market.

We are currently working on a draft De-indexing Act, which seeks to eliminate the harmful effects associated with automatically linking prices and costs to the CPI. The goal is to avoid second-round effects on inflation, which will contribute to a competitiveness-price gain when compared with the rest of the world and a driving force behind exports in our economy.

Now, these are the main steps we are working on at the moment - although they are not the only ones because we are also adopting sectoral reforms, which include the measures aimed at promoting the rental market; the rehabilitation of buildings, and urban regeneration and renovation; the measures to improve how the food chain operates, as well as promoting the integration of cooperatives and other associative entities in the agri-food sector and the steps aimed at reorganising transport and reforming the energy sector.

Up to now, dear friends, I have only spoken about what we have done so far. I have provided as brief a summary as possible - although I know it was not that brief. However, I would now like to talk about the results:

• Our inflation is at an all-time low and will fall to 1% this year.

• We are swiftly gaining competitiveness: the Spanish export sectors have already recovered the labour competitiveness they had lost since the launch of the Economic and Monetary Union.

• We have gone from an unsustainable foreign trade deficit of more than 10% of GDP only a few years ago to a surplus this year that, as Mr. Piqué said in his speech, will be approximately 2.5%; a surplus. In fact, we have had a foreign trade surplus since the summer of 2012 and, in March 2013, we obtained the first trade surplus since 1971 thanks to the sustained growth in our exports.

• In spite of the high unemployment - a real challenge, as was mentioned earlier - the labour reform has managed something that we cannot ignore: salary containment that is helping to maintain competitiveness and will mean we create jobs faster when growth returns.

Now, these achievements did not seem possible but they have been achieved. Spain is correcting its economic imbalances at a very fast pace in spite of the difficult economic context in which we find ourselves: we are making progress on the consolidation of public accounts in a credible and realistic manner, we have restructured our financial system and our economy is increasingly more flexible and competitive.

Now I will talk about Europe because Europe has a significant effect on our economy.

At the end of April this year - a very short time ago, on Friday 26 April, to be precise - we provided the European Commission with the two documents that every Member State has to present in the spring: the Stability Programme and the National Reform Plan, which you have already seen. The Commission issued a favourable assessment on both. To be more precise, it was said that the Programme of Reforms - I won't go into detail because I will never finish otherwise - proposed by Spain is complete and is moving in the right direction.

As regards fiscal consolidation, the Commission confirmed that Spain will not need to achieve a deficit of less than 3% until 2016, in other words, we have been given an extra two years than initially planned. The documents from the Commission are showing themselves to be more adapted to reality because more importance is being given to the need to grow than simply to consolidate regardless of growth.

This change in posture has not happened by chance. If Spain has had its deficit for this year revised from 4.5% to 6.5%, that is due to the guarantee offered by the efforts already made and the correct design of our consolidation policies. To underline the importance of this fact, I ask that you imagine what a deficit reduction of an additional 21 billion euros would have meant for this year. Stop a moment and think about that.

Ladies and gentlemen,

We have a great interest in how things are going in the European Union because, in spite of all our efforts, we are not growing. And we're not growing because Europe isn't growing. And when Europe doesn't grow, experience tells us that Spain doesn't grow either.

As I said at this forum a year ago, the task of returning to growth and job creation does not solely fall on national governments. It requires European decisions, in other words, decisions that must be taken and implemented by the members and institutions of the Union; Spain included.

It should be stressed that important steps have been taken in the last year. The situation has improved and the monetary storms have eased. Nobody is questioning the future existence of the Euro. The worst of the crisis has now passed.

However, Europe is the only region of the world that is still not growing. It has been in recession for the last six quarters and it is only normal that the people of Europe are asking what we are doing wrong. I think the answer is clear: Europe must do more, better and faster, and must do so in the three areas I highlighted here a year ago: structural reforms in the EU to strengthen the internal market; liquidity for our economy; and progress on integration, in other words, greater banking and fiscal integration.

I will start by mentioning the structural reforms; that which I call Economic Union. The more integrated our markets become and the more open our economies are, the less likely it will be that imbalances emerge and, if they do, the easier it will be to resolve them. In order to achieve that target, greater integration is needed in numerous key sectors, such as retail banking, services, transport, telecommunications and energy. The recent May European Council on energy and other issues, but on energy, for example, could have gone further in terms of taking firm decisions.

But we also need to make progress on integration in other areas. I am specifically referring to progress on the creation of real Banking Union and Fiscal Union, and later on, and this is a very important challenge, on Political Union. For that, we must first comply with and apply what has already been agreed and decided on. I ask for nothing but the most elementary of concepts - that decisions be transformed into actions.

Almost one year ago, the June Euro Summit adopted decisions of vital importance in this area and also agreed to strengthen the liquidity provision mechanisms to reduce the financial fragmentation of the Eurozone, and to adopt measures to break the vicious circle linking financial institutions and sovereign debt. The goal of greater integration was reflected in the document presented last year by the President of the Council, Mr. Van Rompuy, and the other three presidents of the Commission, the Central Bank and the Eurogroup: the so-called "roadmap". Spain made a number of very noteworthy contributions that were included in the final document: more Economic Union, Banking Union, Fiscal Union and Political Union.

Now, one year after that meeting in June, I must say that we have made some progress, especially on Banking Union, but we still need to do much more because, although it is true we have a single supervisor, it is not yet operating. And as regards the Directive on winding up credit entities and the possibility of recapitalising banks directly from the European Stability Mechanism, we have a commitment to reach an agreement at the European Council meeting to be held at the end of this month.

So, some progress has been made but it is not enough. The next European Council meeting will be crucial for showing that the European Union follows through on agreements and is capable of taking effective action, because the "roadmap" I mentioned tackles a far broader spectrum.

We need to make even more progress on Banking Union. In addition to what I said before, we must agree on the Single Resolution Mechanisms before the end of the year, and it is my wish - a wish I share with many others - to agree on the foundations and dates for a future common European deposit guarantee system. This is very important for avoiding such destabilising situations as those we saw in Cyprus. With Banking Union, we would not have had to deal with problems like those we saw in Cyprus.

As regards Fiscal Union, our steps have been far too timid. We have made practically no progress whatsoever on the content of the "roadmap". We need coverage systems of a continental nature, including some form of common European debt.

As regards the measures needed to support liquidity in those economies experiencing the most difficulty in accessing the markets, some progress has also been made. The Conclusions from the June Euro Summit in 2012 made it possible to announce the WTO operations - that was what they were called - by the European Central Bank, which appeased the markets. This made the situation easier for both the Spanish Treasury and large enterprises in their search for financing from the international markets. As Josep Piqué said in his speech, if you compare the Spanish risk premium from yesterday with the figure from nine months ago, you will see it has fallen by 55%; from 638 basis points to 292 points today.

However, as Mr. Piqué also said, the situation in the financial markets has not returned to normal. The SMEs in countries such as Spain still have difficulty in accessing credit and competing on a level playing field with their colleagues in other European countries. It is essential that this situation of difficult access to credit be solved in order to grow and create jobs.

The most important step is aimed at small- and medium-sized enterprises in the short term. There are 24 million people out of work in Europe but there are also 24 million SMEs. The best way to tackle unemployment is to facilitate the financing of projects by these companies. To do so, I think that the European Investment Bank can play a vital role. At the June meeting of the European Council last year that I have mentioned so often now, we agreed on recapitalisation funds from the European Investment Bank of 10 billion euros. This is taking shape now but we must take full advantage of this opportunity.

I believe that the help for small enterprises can be channelled in three ways - something I will propose to the Council this month:

• Firstly: triple the annual volume of finance available from the current 10 billion euros to 30 billion euros, and thus achieve a significant impact at a European scale.

• Secondly: increase the powers of the European Investment Bank to issue solid guarantees on the portfolio of new loans to small enterprises.

• Thirdly: develop a programme of support for business that can enable access by European companies to international tender processes and facilitate credit for export activity; something that, by the way, we Europeans helped take place beyond Europe through our contributions to the development banks but that we did not implement in our own countries.

In turn, and I think this is important, the European Central Bank has announced it will study ways to facilitate the flow of credit to small enterprises, now stagnant due to the fragmentation of the financial markets. While fully respecting their independence, I firmly believe that the European Central Bank can and must do more. On 2 May, President Draghi announced his desire to open inter-institutional dialogue on this topic. In my opinion, this dialogue must start now and I will encourage such action to take place.

The other measures I am proposing for the Council specifically relate to youth employment. All my EU colleagues and I - for obvious reasons - are highly concerned by the youth unemployment situation. We want to take effective steps. In my opinion, two of those steps have the potential to generate a greater impact and achieve the desired results sooner.

The most important is, to put it simply, to remove any deficit penalties for the support I want to offer for the hiring of young people. What I am asking for is a mechanism whereby the expenditure made on discounting National Insurance contributions for the hiring of young people is not taken into consideration when assessing compliance with fiscal consolidation obligations in the Excessive Deficit Procedure. Through such a step, we would enable resounding and immediate action to be taken with a real capacity to encourage new hirings.

The other measure I am calling for is swift action in the use of resources already available to us. In February, in the European Union Financial Framework, we approved the creation of a fund to promote youth employment. Six billion euros was earmarked for that fund. Spain was one of the supporters of this initiative, the approval of which I was particularly pleased by. We must now ensure that the funds reach their targets as soon as possible so they can quickly start to be used when we enter 2014.

I will now conclude this part by reaffirming how important the next Summit on 26 and 27 of this month could be. It is clear there are many things to be done in terms of European integration, it is clear that there will be no talk of Fiscal Union at this Summit and it is clear that neither will there be talk of Political Union at this Summit, which is unquestionably one of the topics we must discuss in the future. However, there is one positive issue and that is the existence of a "roadmap": we are now talking about Economic Union, we are talking about Banking Union; we are talking about Fiscal Union and we are also talking about Political Union.

It is very important to send positive signals to the markets, to public opinion as a whole and to the people of Europe regarding the existence of a firm desire to build a European Union in which there can be democratic control, where there can be a Parliament that works, where there can be joint banking supervision, a deposit guarantee fund, a kind of European debt and where there can be something similar to what is happening in other regions of the world with a combination of States.

I am reaching the end now, ladies and gentlemen,

We are taking very difficult decisions in a very short period of time. Some of them are very painful, yet inevitable, because they are essential requirements for recovery and to guarantee our future.

As we have seen, the efforts are producing results and we can say today that the worst is behind us and that the most critical moments have passed; but we cannot allow ourselves to relax even for a moment. I repeat, not even a moment; we must continue working in the same direction. The unemployment situation with millions of people out of work reminds us every day that the fundamental objective for our policy - economic growth and job creation - is still a long way off.

That is why we must all make an effort, both within Spain and beyond. In order to achieve success, grow and create jobs, it is not enough for the people of Spain to diligently do everything we can. We need more dynamic support, as I said earlier, within the European framework. The course set by Europe, as I have just explained, is the right one. What my government wants is for the decisions taken by the European Union to be applied swiftly.

I must tell you that I believe we are going to achieve both things, I sincerely do. I believe that we will manage to remove all the obstacles in Spain that were blocking our path to prosperity, as we are doing right now, and, at the same time, I am absolutely convinced that we will manage to get things done in Europe so we can leave the recession behind and make life better for everyone.

That is all. Thank you very much for your attention.