Interview by President of the Government on programme "Herrera en COPE", on COPE radio station
Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Rajoy was interviewed on COPE radio by Carlos Herrera in January 2016, discussing Spain's unemployment figures and post-election government formation prospects.
- Main themes
- Unemployment and job creation, government formation after December 2016 elections, economic recovery trends, social security contributions, political stability, People's Party coalition options, Spain's constitutional parties, investment as Prime Minister
- Duration
- ~43 min
- Words
- 5,142
- Sentences
- 192
- Readability
- 57
- Grade
- 11.4
- Syntax
- 3.04
- Vocabulary
- 1.90
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
192 sentences in 69 paragraphs
President of the Government .- Very well, thank you very much. And a very good day to you Carlos.
C. Herrera .- After reading the unemployment figures, are you satisfied with these results?
President of the Government .- Well, I can never be completely satisfied with the results when the number of people out of work in Spain is still this high, but I am pleased with the shift in trend that has taken place over the course of this legislature.
When we came to power in December 2011, unemployment was rising at a rate of 7.9% per annum whereas now, four years on, unemployment is falling at a rate of 8% per annum. These figures are the same for the social security system: in 2011 these were falling at a rate of 2% per annum whereas now they are rising at a rate of 3.2%. So, the trend is very good. There are now more people contributing to the social security system and fewer people unemployed than at the start of our legislature but now what we must do is persevere and that is why, in recent months, and during the election campaign, I said that it was necessary to create - and that this could be achieved if things were done right - 2 million jobs over the course of the next four years.
C. Herrera .- How many of these 55,000 people who have left the unemployment queues do you think will return to the unemployment queues since they were fundamentally employed for the Christmas campaigns?
President of the Government .- January is a month in which the unemployment figures always rise, and in August. If you look at the figures for last year - 2015 - and for the year before - 2014 - you will see that unemployment fell in every month except January and August. In contrast, in the previous years - 2013 and 2012 - unemployment did not fall and there were several months in which unemployment rose. Hence, the month of January is always bad, as is August and that is why we must view these figures on a year-on-year basis; in other words, compare the unemployment figures in one year with the unemployment figures in the previous year. That is why I said that it is important to compare December 2015 with December 2014 and you can see that unemployment fell by 8%.
The issue is always the trend, you must look at things on a year-on-year basis. I believe that we are now enjoying a positive trend. In fact, over the two-year period 2014 and 2015 the number of National Insurance contributors has risen by 1,113,000, and that is what has led to our optimism if the same economic policy is maintained over the coming years, if stability is achieved at a governmental level and if certainty is offered to the economic and social stakeholders.
C. Herrera .- With your hand on your heart, what percentage of possibilities do you believe exist for you to be invested as President of the Government?
President of the Government .- It is impossible to answer that question, Carlos. There are three possibilities: a government, which is what I propose, supported by more than 210 MPs, with all those parties that believe in the Spanish Constitution and everything it represents, which believe in a certain way to combat terrorism, which are committed to Europe, to economic growth, to employment and to the unity of Spain. That is a viable government, headed up by the People's Party which won the elections. There is a second option, which is what some would seem to be seeking, which is a government made up of the Socialist Party, Podemos, the United Left and certain other nationalist forces, such as Esquerra Republicana. And there is a third option, to call for new elections.
That is what the results from 20 December have led us to. Quite sincerely, I believe that the best thing for Spain would be the first option: respecting the will of the Spanish people, allowing reforms with widespread support and sending out a message of stability regarding the country both within Spain and beyond our borders.
C. Herrera .- And how do you intend to receive this support or that, as a result of abstentions you are invested as President of the Government by someone that called you, something along the lines of dishonest or indecent just three weeks ago?
President of the Government .- There is not another political option. As a result of what happened in the ballot boxes, we must do two things: firstly, respect the results of the ballot boxes, and secondly, try to unite those political forces that are in agreement on the essential issues, however many or however important those things may be that divide us. But, of course, I believe that a government with Podemos, left-wing nationalist parties or extreme left-wing nationalist parties, the United Left and the PSOE [Spanish Socialist Workers' Party], in all sincerity, I believe that this would be very negative for Spain's interests; it would generate tremendous political instability and would offer little certainty. It would not be good for the Spanish economy or for the politics of our country.
Hence, I propose what I believe is best for my country in these circumstances in light of the results of the elections on 20 December.
C. Herrera .- And what about a government headed up by the People's Party, in other words, by you, with the abstention or an agreement with the MPs from the PSOE and from Ciudadanos? You would have to agree on certain things; in other words, there are things which you would not be able to do in contrast to when you governed alone. You would also need to share out the governmental powers among these political formations, in the event that they wanted this. What are your "red lines" in the event of agreeing to this?
President of the Government .- I don't have any "red lines". I believe that a government backed by more than 200 MPs would serve two purposes: firstly, to undertake reforms that are deemed necessary at this time, with widespread support from more than 200 MPs. If you take into account that these could be backed by more than 200 MPs, these would be reforms that would last for many years and which would be very important. And that would oblige us all to reach agreements, to give way on certain issues and to try to approve others. That would be very important.
And the second main objective would be to send out a message so that our economic recovery could be bedded down. At this time, Spain is enjoying growth, at a rate of more than 3%, and it is the country enjoying the fastest rate of growth of the main countries in the European Union; we are creating jobs - there is still a lot to do but the figures are already positive. Hence, that would offer stability, that would send out a good message to the markets, that would alleviate the situation of the risk premium, we would be able to continue receiving financing as we have to date and I believe that we would offer a good image, to investors as well, and a good image as a country.
Hence, that is what we would need to talk about. Everything else is secondary and, of course, it would be good for us to have a programme for a certain period of time and for this to be set out in the Investiture Debate.
C. Herrera .- The issue of Catalonia. Mr Mas has said that despite the "no" from CUP, he will not give up, he has five days left and he has said that he will oppose Madrid and I imagine that when he says "Madrid", he means you although you are from Pontevedra. Do you believe that in these five days he has any room to manoeuvre, perhaps to convince certain defectors or use certain artful wiles to finally be invested as President of the Regional Government of Catalonia?
President of the Government .- That is the last thing we need because after everything we have been through - a government hasn't been formed since 27 September, we have seen certain assemblies with some truly noteworthy results, such as the infamous 1,515 draw and we have seen what happened yesterday - I, quite sincerely, don't know what could be achieved in a period of five days after everything that has gone on.
Now, if you want my opinion, I believe that at this time the best thing would be for Mr Mas to abandon his pro-independence claims. Since I don't believe that will happen, I, who am against elections taking place every 30 minutes, believe that the second-best option would be for elections to be held if this does not happen. In all honesty, I cannot see another way out. I know that there have been elections in 2010, in 2012 and in 2015 and it would be ironic for others to be held in 2016, but that is the dynamic that some have introduced to the institutional functioning of Catalonia, and the very life and co-existence of the people of Catalonia. When things are done badly, they tend to turn out as such.
C. Herrera .- As regards these new elections, today certain political analysts are gambling that a new government will be formed by the left wing and the far left-wing, just think, CUP and even Esquerra Republicana de Cataluña would become the belle of the ball, just imagine. In other words, with a government of this nature, with a popular Catalan front governing after the elections, what problems could this bring to a government of Spain?
President of the Government .- It could have a great deal of them, but we have also had problems with the present Regional Government of Catalonia, and that was only comprised of one political force which hadn't said it would support self-determination and independence when it stood in the elections, nor any suchlike. However, this regional government conducted itself as it did but, in the end, it became clear that the State has sufficient means at its disposal to ensure that the law is upheld and that the law, the sovereignty of the Spanish people and national unity could not be done away with. Hence, this type of government, if things turn out like that, would be bad news, but in the present situation there isn't even a government; in other words, they are not capable of forming a government after more than three months since the elections.
That is why I say what common sense and reasonableness dictate. What I am sure a majority of citizens in Catalonia want is for this process that leads nowhere to be abandoned because, if not, there is no other alternative when a government cannot be formed. As I said, I would not like elections to be brought forward but I believe that there is no other option but for this to happen. At any event, we will find out in four or five days time. Now, stunts such as "let's take two MPs from one party and three from another"… That, in short, is taking something away from the normal functioning of democratic institutions and, of course, it is a slap in the face for the will of the people.
C. Herrera .- Mr Mas could always stand down and give way to Mr Junqueras, which is what he suggested to some extent yesterday - this has all the good intentions of all these guys from the CUP - and form a government, and from then on, maximum institutional tension, I imagine.
President of the Government .- Aside from that, we don't know exactly what a government backed by the CUP, Esquerra Republicana and the other political forces would do. I, of course, believe that nothing good for Catalonia and nothing good for Spain. But, I repeat, they have already tried to hold a referendum that was illegal and a violation of the Constitution and they have already tried certain other manoeuvres as well. The Constitutional Court rose to the occasion and I believe that the Government of Spain also did what it needed to do. So, those who try to break the law or violate the Constitution, which is their intention, must know, here in the 21st Century, that they cannot do this and that they won't be able to do this and that we are not going to allow this. And they must know that national sovereignty will not be renounced and national sovereignty means that whatever Spain is to be will be decided on by the Spanish people, whoever they may be, wherever they may live, however they may think; in other words that they have the right to voice their opinions on their country in its entirety. And not just a part of the country can decide what Spain is to be.
C. Herrera .- Under no circumstance would you stand down from your position as President of the Government to facilitate this pact to form a government and carry out reforms with 250 MPs?
President of the Government .- That is not what is being proposed. If we start to do… No political force has made this type of proposal, a proposal which is barely democratic in nature. We must get used to the fact that democracy is many things, but one of them, and this is very important, is respecting the will of the people. The People's Party stood at the elections following an extremely tough term of office, it chose its own candidate through the procedures established in its Articles of Association and it won the elections. It obtained 1.7 million votes more than the second political force, 33 more seats and won by a difference of almost seven points. That is a very significant difference. With this same difference, in fact a little less, Mr Cameron, under the British electoral system, had an absolute majority.
So, I will always continue to defend maximum respect for the will of our people and then ensure that solutions are adapted to common sense, to finding a balance which offer certainty and security to the people.
Ignacio Camacho .- A very good day to you, Mr President of the Government. It's nice to see you and a Happy New Year.
President of the Government .- Good day to you, Ignacio, and the same to you. Happy New Year.
I. Camacho .- Before the end of last year, you announced your intention to stand again as the head of the PP at the next party congress. My question is if you still maintain this intention in the event that you are not re-invested as President of the Government.
President of the Government .- In reality, it doesn't make much sense to get ahead of events. What we are trying to achieve at this time is to form a government, which is our obligation to the whole of the Spanish people. Parliament will be constituted on 13 January and then an investiture session will be held. So the obligation now on any responsible person, which is what I endeavour to be, is to work on the priority issues, and what is a priority for Spain is to have a government in the near future.
Aside from that, my idea was, and remains, to stand again as the party president, whatever may happen.
Mayte Alcaraz .- Good day to you, Mr Rajoy.
President of the Government .- Good day, Mayte.
M. Alcaraz .- You said that Parliament will be constituted on 13 January. By the way, a small query before asking you a question. Will you support Patxi López's candidature as Speaker of the Lower House of Parliament? Do you feel he would be a good Speaker of the Lower House?
President of the Government .- I don't feel one way or the other, but we definitely won't be backing him. We believe that the People's Party should put forward the Speaker of the House. I remember my first conversation with Pedro Sánchez. In short, it is not a question of anything now, but, of course, it is a question of a party that has 90 seats and 1.7 million votes less than the winning party trying to put forward the President of the Government and the Speaker of the Lower House. That seems neither acceptable nor serious to me.
Hence, the People's Party will present its candidate for the Speaker of the Lower House, because since 1977 whoever has won the elections in Spain has appointed the Speaker of the Lower House and headed up the government and now, in 2015 or 2016, where we are today, I have the feeling that people want to throw everything away including, among other things, the normal functioning of the rule book. So, under no circumstance are we going to support a candidate who is not from the People's Party to be the Speaker of the Lower House, because we have very clearly won the elections.
M. Alcaraz .- Once Parliament is constituted with the Speaker that you propose or the one decided by Parliament in plenary session, I understand that the King, which is logical, will commission you with forming a government and with trying to obtain sufficient support to be invested. Will you take part in the vote for the investiture in the event that you don't have a 100% guarantee in the voting or at least the guarantee that the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party will abstain? I know that in the first round of voting things obviously won't be like that, you will only receive the votes from your party, but there will then be a second round and there may even be a third round. Will you persist even if you don't have these votes guaranteed?
President of the Government .- Absolutely yes. If the King commissions me with trying to form a government, I will fulfil my duty and I will try to do this, firstly because I owe this to the 7.3 million Spaniards who voted for the People's Party in very difficult circumstances - I owe this to them, it is my duty - and then, secondly, because I owe this to the normal functioning of the Spanish democratic institutions.
The People's Party has been the most voted-for party in Spain and it has won the elections. Hence, under no circumstance can it renounce trying to form a government, because that would not then be the way in which the institutions function normally. Here, although some people believe that anything can be done, I don't believe so. I believe it is good for the rule book and the election results to be respected by everyone.
Jorge Bustos .- Happy New Year, President of the Government, although it doesn't look like it is going to be a very happy one, but anyway …
President of the Government .- Happy New Year, Jorge. Yes, let's all be positive because one's approach in life can help greatly, even in resolving problems.
J. Bustos .- You are going to receive Pedro Sánchez again. On the first occasion there almost wasn't even time to exchange small talk, but on this second occasion, and given the serious situation and the need for a clear vision that I believe is being asked for by the electorate from the parties in order to reach an agreement, what are you going to propose to Pedro Sánchez to facilitate his abstention or even to integrate him in a coalition government? And you are aware that the Socialist Party will find it very complicated, given that for 30 years two parties have been alternating in power, to justify supporting you or abstaining, or facilitating the formation of a government, including if you are the most voted-for party, given that there was very little difference in the final vote count this time.
President of the Government .- Traditionally in Spain, the party that wins the elections does so by considerable margin, except, possibly back in 1996, when we beat the Socialist Party by 300,000 votes. Isn't that right? However, when we won by only 300,000 votes, we managed to form a government, on that occasion with support from Convergència i Unió, the PNV [Basque Nationalist Party] and Coalición Canaria [Canary Islands Coalition]. We have won by considerably more this time - by 1.7 million votes; but new parties have emerged and it is more difficult to forge alliances.
There are coalition government in the majority of countries in Europe at this time. Whilst there is a majority in the United Kingdom this time round, in the previous legislature there was a coalition government, as there is in Belgium between four parties, as there is in the Netherlands, in Finland, in Germany - a major coalition - and even in Austria, also between the Socialist Party and the People's Party. In other words, this is the case in most countries.
So, in Spain, although this has not been the case to date, we must start to get used to things changing and perhaps in the future there will not only be two parties, or maybe we will return to that situation. Who knows? What is true is that a responsible politician is under an obligation, after citizens have spoken, to try to put together something that is reasonable and what I am going to say is that these three political forces, which hold more than 200 seats, are united by the fundamental issues and are united by certain things that do not unite these political forces with others. We are united by national unity, we are united by national sovereignty, we are united by the principle of the equality of the Spanish people, we are united by our membership of the European Union and European policy, we are united by the foreign policy we are implementing, we are united by our defence policy and we are united, albeit with certain differences, in the main objective of forging economic growth and creating jobs. We may then disagree on the type of reforms to be undertaken, but there are many more things that unite us than separate us.
And at this time we must turn need into a virtue. With this result we may be able to undertake some of the important reforms that Spain needs with widespread support so that they can last for a long time. And as I said at the beginning, this, moreover, would be very positive for continuing to maintain the rhythm of economic growth and job creation, which is what Spain truly needs for the years to come and which remains the main national goal.
I. Camacho .- President of the Government, when you speak about lasting reforms and the suchlike, are you clearly including the reform of the Constitution in that?
President of the Government .- I am not closed to anything. It is clear that I am not closed to anything; but my position in that regard is well-known: the reform of the Constitution requires widespread support. With more than 200 MPs, we can undertake a reform of the Constitution; with 300 we could design a totally new and absolutely different Constitution that many of us couldn't support. But important institutional reforms could be undertaken and we could leave many problems resolved for many years to come. That is why I stress that this is a great opportunity and that we are all under an obligation to make pacts, reach agreements and have a period of balance in our country.
C. Herrera .- If Susana Díaz headed up the PSOE, do you believe that it would be easier to reach some form of agreement? In addition, has she been in touch with you at any time during this process?
President of the Government .- Those are two questions and the answer to the second question is "no". I have not spoken with Susana Díaz during this process. The only person I have spoken with during this process from the Socialist Party has been Mr Sánchez. Here, we either all respect each other or we will end up having a problem, and my counterpart is Mr Sánchez, because he is the General Secretary of the Socialist Party, and I will continue to speak with him alone. If I have to speak with the Socialist Party I will speak with whoever they designate. In the same way as if I speak with Ciudadanos or with Podemos, or with any other political force, I speak with those designated by them because, if we do not respect this we are going to have even greater problems than we have at this time.
C. Herrera .- But wouldn't it be easier?
President of the Government .- I don't know, and moreover, nor should I get involved in the different ways of approaching things by some or others, because that is not my job nor is it my place to do so, and nor would I like it if others did that in my own party.
C. Herrera .- Are those who in some way have suggested that you should take a step backwards in the near future the same as those who said that back in 2008?
President of the Government .- In reality, these things always happen. I have been hearing these things about me since I arrived on the scene, and hence, they don't concern me greatly. I received a very resounding majority at the last meeting of the Executive Committee, and I sincerely thank my party colleagues for that. But, I repeat, I don't believe that this is the issue at hand, in all sincerity; I believe that the issue and the battle we are facing is whether we will be able to do something that has never been done before in our country. That would be a major change.
What concerns me is for us to enjoy political stability here in Spain and that the efforts made by the Spanish people over the course of the last four years, and that allow us today to speak about the unemployment figures we have mentioned, are not in vain because if a government now comes to power that is going to throw out all the reforms that have been undertaken - they don't like the labour reform or the Budget Stability Act or anything else - we run a serious risk of suffering another relapse and that would be truly sad after all we have gone through over the course of recent years.
M. Alcaraz .- Carlos asked you before, Mr President of the Government, whether you had spoken with Susana Díaz. There is another very important person in the Socialist Party, Felipe González, whom we gather is very concerned by the current situation. Have you spoken with him from a sense of corporatism of Presidents of the Government? Have you spoken about the situation being proposed in Spain following these elections?
President of the Government .- No, I haven't. As I said, the only member of the Socialist Party that I have spoken with is Pedro Sánchez. I have not spoken with any other leader from the Socialist Party.
J. Bustos .- President of the Government, if the situation in Catalonia is cleared up and a regional president is finally invested that re-launches the pro-independence process, although the government is a caretaker government, are you not concerned, given the support from the forces that have already visited Moncloa Palace and have confirmed they are in agreement with you on this…? Could Article 155 be invoked if a so-called "disconnection process" is initiated even though this is a caretaker government, because it would seem this could be the case for some time?
President of the Government .- I don't want to get ahead of events. What I should say is that I am the President of the Government and hence, while I am President of the Government of Spain, and I am sure that this will apply to whoever holds this position in the future as well, no attack will be made on our national sovereignty nor on the unity of Spain that is not responded in accordance with the law and in a proportionate manner. This is not going to happen ever.
C. Herrera .- To what extent are you prepared to give ground to reach an agreement with the PSOE?
President of the Government .- I don't believe it is a question of giving ground; it is a question of seeing what can be done together over the course of the next four years, although the most important thing for me, I repeat, is to have an economic policy that generates confidence, credibility and stability. That is the most important thing for me. Aside from that, we will need to talk. It is clear that there are many things I am not going to give ground on, but nor is the PSOE going to do so, and that includes the unity of Spain, national sovereignty, the equality of the Spanish people… Neither of us is going to give ground on these issues because it is impossible to do so, because this forms part of our DNA as a party, unless someone goes insane, which is highly unlikely.
C. Herrera .-Look, if the PSOE makes a pact with Podemos, and indeed it has done so in some local authorities and regional governments, it would seem that there is only one issue that concerns them both, which is the issue of a referendum in Catalonia. This is my last question. This pact could take place if they put aside this issue for a period of time. It would seem that the PSOE doesn't view the rest of the Podemos manifesto so badly.
President of the Government .- That is what can be deduced from the statements made by certain leaders of the Socialist Party, but what I do know about this is exactly the same as you have stated, which is true. But, in short, I believe that there are many very important things.
C. Herrera .- Mr Rajoy Brey, we have some busy days ahead of us, do we not?
President of the Government .- Without a doubt, but maybe things will be resolved sooner than some think. Let's hope so. That would be the best thing for Spain.
C. Herrera .- Mr acting President of the Government, thank you very much for coming here. It has been very kind of you.
President of the Government .- Thank very much to you Carlos, and to your team.