Press conference by Prime Minister of Republic of Turkey and President of the Spanish Government following High Level Turkey-Spain Meeting

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

10 February 2014 · High Level Turkey-Spain Meeting press conference

Context
Rajoy and Erdoğan addressed a joint press conference following a High Level Turkey-Spain Meeting in Ankara on 10 February 2014.
Main themes
Bilateral Turkey-Spain relations, trade and investment growth, infrastructure and transport projects, defense industry cooperation, Alliance of Civilizations, European Union accession support, Cyprus peace talks, counterterrorism cooperation, Mediterranean partnership, Syria conflict
Duration
~43 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,099
92nd percentile
Sentences
236
92nd percentile
Readability
59
85th percentile
Grade
10.4
25th percentile
Syntax
2.93
38th percentile
Vocabulary
1.98
8th percentile

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

236 sentences in 67 paragraphs

Mr. Erdogan.- My dear friend Mariano Rajoy; esteemed ministers, correspondents, members of the press; in the first place I would like to express my delight to see you all here together at this High Level Meeting.

This evening we have held talks with the President of the Government and his delegation, followed by what could almost be referred to as a cabinet meeting between the ministers of both countries represented here, concerning the military defence industry, culture and trade relations. We have held talks on many matters.

As you are all aware, Spain has always been a great ally of Turkey, above all in the process of joining the European Union, in which it has always expressed its support for us. And we were the founding members of the project known as the Alliance of Civilisations; indeed we are the architects of that project.

As two Mediterranean countries, we continue to work with determination. When we came to power, in the first year that we came to power, the volume of trade was very different from today, which currently exceeds the former trade figure. This level has risen to a very different position now. In 2003, our volume of trade amounted to 3.5 billion euros, but this volume of trade had risen to some 8.5 billion euros by the end of 2013. This continues to rise and I believe that in the short term we will reach a level of 10 billion euros which will then continue to rise.

I would like to quote you another figure: when we came to power, Spanish investment in Turkey amounted to 208 million euros, but this investment has now risen to 8 billion euros. That is a sign of confidence, a show of support because, at present, there are 90 Turkish companies in Spain and this process is continuing within our framework of collaboration.

During our talks with the President of the Government, when we dealt with our bilateral relations, we took steps on the Marmaray rail transport project. For example, Spanish companies are collaborating on the Ankara-Eskişehir and Ankara-Konya railway lines. Spanish companies are working on these projects. That is a very clear sign of Spanish-Turkish collaboration.

Tomorrow the Ankara metro will be inaugurated. This is a very important project and a symbolic milestone for us. We will inaugurate this new metro tomorrow with President of the Government Rajoy and hence Ankara, thanks to this line between Batikent and Sinçan, will undergo a profound change. I took part in a test drive and it is very good, really very good, and after these test drives we will set in motion the application of the metro line. We will inaugurate the metro line with the President of the Government tomorrow. This project was started by the Metropolitan Council of Ankara and was completed by the Ministry of Transport.

Other projects will continue to be undertaken within the framework of strategic investment. As regards the new Petkin refinery, the engineering works are being headed up by a Spanish company; I want to make that clear. Another significant step is that Turkey is currently involved in the construction of an aircraft carrier, in a landing vessel which is called "Juan", as a counterpart of the Spanish vessel "Juan Carlos". This agreement between the companies Navantia and SEDEF has now been completed and we will move on to the construction of the vessel, because this project is of great strategic importance to Turkey; yet another strategic step forward. Its manufacture will be carried out in the shipyards of Tuzla, in Turkey.

The political turmoil in our close geographical proximity was another matter discussed with Spain, our ally in Europe. We also touched on the matter of Syria but, as well as that we discussed the issue of the direct talks that started today in Cyprus. For example, the process that has now commenced has had very positive effects throughout the world and a joint text is guaranteed to be issued between the north and the south of the island. We hope that these talks continued to proceed in the right direction and reach a satisfactory conclusion, and that this problem that has persisted for decades can thus be resolved. As a guarantor country, Turkey will continue to provide all its support to Cyprus and we hope that Greece, as the other guarantor country, will support this process with a view to a satisfactory conclusion being reached. Just a little earlier today, an agreement was signed between the two countries.

For example, we are prepared to take steps in our foreign policy; but, first and foremost, Spain has a 50-year old problem, the problem of ETA, and we also have a problem, a process regarding a terrorist gang and we are determined to fight together to combat terrorism. We will support one another, evidenced by the Ministers for Home Affairs of Spain and Turkey defining a roadmap in the anti-terrorism struggle.

I would welcome my dear friend, President of the Government Rajoy and his whole delegation. I will now give him the floor.

President of the Government.- Good afternoon to you all. Thank you very much Mr Prime Minister.

I appear here before you, as you are aware, to take stock of the results of the High Level Spain-Turkey Meeting that has taken place, today, Tuesday 11 February 2014.

This is the fifth time that the Heads of Government of Spain and Turkey have met under this format and the almost annual frequency of this important meeting is due recognition of the privileged status and strategic nature of relations between our two countries.

On this occasion, the meeting has enjoyed the participation of the Ministers for Defence, Public Works and Home Affairs and the State Secretaries for Foreign Affairs and Trade, who have met with their Turkish counterparts to review the current state of bilateral relations in their respective areas.

The specific results of the High Level Meeting are set out in the Joint Statement that has been approved and I thus don't want to speak too much about them now. I refer you to the text of the Joint Statement so that you can review the details of the conversations held at today's meeting.

But I would like to stress, once again, that Spain and Turkey are two partners and allies, bound by ties of the most diverse nature: fluid political relations; clearly in tune on the main challenges facing international society and a fruitful collaboration within the international bodies that we form part of; close agreement in the matter of the fight against terrorism, as Prime Minister Erdogan reminded us; growing cooperation on cultural matters and education, and trade and investment relations that are increasingly dynamic, with a significant presence by Spanish companies in construction projects in infrastructure in Turkey.

Precisely tomorrow, as the Prime Minister reminded us in his speech, I will have the honour of accompanying him at the event to inaugurate the M3 Metro line in Ankara, which has been built by the company COMSA EMTE, a Catalan company, and hence a Spanish and European company. In the same way as countless other infrastructure companies that build bridges, metro lines and highways, COMSA EMTE has finalised a project that brings citizens closer together, reduces distances, facilitates co-existence, fosters exchange and allows borders and other natural barriers to be overcome.

During the course of this meeting, both the various ministers and state secretaries, and I myself, at my meeting with Prime Minister Erdogan, have had the opportunity to examine the aforesaid areas for collaboration and, once again we have seen the excellent health of relations between Spain and Turkey.

But allow me to pause to mention what probably constitutes the most important tie between Spain and Turkey - the European Union. As you are well aware, Spain has formed part of the European project since 1 January 1986, when we managed to join what was then the European Communities following long and complicated negotiations. More than a quarter of a century later, we consider that European integration has been a key element in the development and modernisation of our country.

Since December 1999, Turkey has held the status of candidate member of the European Union, and talks formally commenced in respect thereof in 2005. Since then, Spain has been and remains one of the main advocates of Turkey's European vocation, a natural bridge between Europe and Asia and a crucial country for stability in a key region for global security.

We are aware and have seen at first hand the complexities and frustrations which have frequently plagued these adhesion processes. For that reason, Spain would encourage Turkey to continue working on this adhesion process and complete the necessary reforms for the purpose of smoothing the way towards its membership of the Union.

I have said this on many occasions, but I would like to repeat it here today, before all of you: the construction of major common projects requires a high degree of political ambition, tenacity and sacrifice. Reforms are hardly ever easy, as Spain's recent experience has made clear, but their implementation constitutes an inescapable exercise in political responsibility for those in power who are committed to the development of their country and to the well-being of their people. Spain supports and will support Turkey's efforts towards this end.

Finally, the two countries share a strategic commitment, on various international forums, to all those issues that are of mutual interest in the Euro-Mediterranean region. Prime Minister Erdogan and I exchanged opinions on the important challenges facing the Mediterranean region, including the crisis in Syria, but also the talks with Iran and the Middle East peace process.

The point of view of our partner is particularly valuable to us, given that Turkey is a benchmark for many Arab and Muslim countries that are currently undergoing transition processes towards democracy. For this reason, I would like to reiterate to Prime Minister Erdogan that he can count on Spain to continue working together to foster democracy and prosperity throughout the Mediterranean.

Thank you very much for your attention and I would like to once again thank the prime minister and the whole delegation that has accompanied him at the working meetings for the way they have treated us, as always.

Q.- I wanted to know if one of the specific topics of conversation between you was the recent recommendations made by the European Commission to Turkey on the reforms pending on the General Council of the Judiciary so that a clear separation of powers can exist and these changes demanded on the controversial Internet Act. I would like to know if this was discussed and whether Mr Erdogan has something to say on this matter to us and to the European Union, and if this influences in any way Spain's support for Turkey's possible membership.

Then I would like to ask the President of the Spanish Government for his assessment of the document that German business leaders have signed regarding Catalonia, and whether or not he intends to meet with Artur Mas or if that is possible in the event of not withdrawing the referendum for 9 November.

President of the Government .- I understand that you have asked me two questions: firstly, regarding our position. In reality, I have answered this in my initial speech, but allow me to clarify a couple more points.

The first thing I would like to reiterate is that Spain is a great friend and partner of Turkey. We are both members of NATO; we have wonderful bilateral relations; our trade relations are growing constantly; Spanish companies invest in Turkey; Turkish companies invest in Spain; Spanish companies take part in public tenders and make bids… And precisely tomorrow, as I have said here on various occasions, we are going to inaugurate a new metro line.

We have supported Turkey's membership of the European Union right from the outset; we continue to support it and to urge its government to implement the necessary reforms to achieve this objective and make progress on implementing improvements to pave this way to integration, as we have all done.

I should say that we have not spoken about any domestic matter in relation to Turkey or to Spain; but I would like to reiterate that Prime Minister Erdogan has offered guarantees to the EU authorities that the changes will respect the Rule of Law, judicial independence and the separation of powers, and I am absolutely convinced that this will be the case. For this reason, as I said, Spain will be, as has always been the case, on the front line supporting Turkey's membership of the European Union.

As regards the second matter, the first point is that in order for there to be dialogue, it is necessary for the party interested in talking to request this, something which, for the time being, I haven't been asked to do.

I would like to make a reflection now: a referendum has been announced, and in addition to announcing a referendum, the date has been set for this referendum, and moreover, Spanish public opinion has been informed of the questions to be posed in the referendum. And we have all been made aware of this via the same medium - through the media. Do you think dialogue is possible given this? I will leave you to be the judge of that.

Having said that, I would like to say that I am prepared to speak about anything; as I have always been. I believe that speaking is good, and that listening is better still, rather than taking unilateral decisions and not putting others in an impossible situation. And we can talk about many things; for example, about the work being done by Catalan companies, such as the company that we have just finished speaking about now and which has just built the metro line here, in Ankara. And we can talk about trade relations and the situation of difficulties in the markets, and we can speak about the supplier payment plan and the autonomous region liquidity fund (Spanish acronym: FLA).

We can speak about whatever you want. The only thing that the President of the Government of Spain, or of any other country for that matter, cannot speak about is about impinging on national sovereignty. I cannot speak about that because it doesn't fall upon me to do so; this falls within the remit of the Spanish people as a whole. Aside from that, I am ready to speak about anything.

Now, having said that, judge for yourselves whether it is good protocol to hype up the announcement of a referendum, announce the two questions and the date. You will appreciate that this puts everyone else in an extremely complicated situation.

I will repeat one thing: I am prepared to talk. That has been my way my whole life and it will continue to be so in the future, and of course, to listen as well. What I am not prepared to do, because I cannot and I must not do - and moreover it is what I believe in - is to play with our national sovereignty. I am not prepared to do that, nor do I believe is any other president of the government of any other democratic country.

Mr. Erdogan.- Dear friends, I want to answer the part of the question just posed that falls to me.

Above all, I want our European friends and the Turkish media to be aware of the following, although, in reality, I already said this in my speech to the Parliamentary group: when we came to power, the Internet was only used in Turkey by 20,000 people, whereas this figure now stands at 34 million people. The point we have now reached is the following: a government that was against the Internet would probably not have increased this figure from 20,000 to 34 million. That is where we have got to after 11 years. And while the Internet is spreading, so are the tablets that are being used a great deal in our schools.

Here there is a reality relating to the right to privacy of the individual and the family. This is a case of a measure in this respect. If the Telecommunications Authority has a deadline of five days to respond, there is no privacy at all. What we are trying to approve is that the Telecommunications Authority responds in 24 hours. The following is an important matter: during this process the right to lodge a legal appeal is reserved. If the court confirms the decision adopted by the Telecommunications Authority, then the process continues, but if the legal ruling brings the proceedings to a halt, then so be it.

The regulation being drafted is like this, but, of course, this is currently being interpreted in another way, because, regrettably, during this current lapse of five days, illegal taps, environmental taps are taking place, which is a serious threat. Aside from that, what is at stake in reality is the use of the Internet as an instrument to create a parallel structure within the State, which has forced us to draw up this regulation. We have never interfered in the spread of the use of the Internet; we have always supported this and we will continue supporting it.

This Internet network is being introduced in all our schools. This week we will distribute 100,000 tablets in schools and in the coming weeks, more than 600,000 tablets will be distributed to schools. The Internet now exists in all our schools. Thanks to this network, our children and our students will have the opportunity to be in contact with the rest of the world. Can a government that takes this kind of step be accused of being against the Internet? This is nothing more than black propaganda by those who cannot see any form of future for themselves at the polls. This is the result of black propaganda and nothing more.

Q.- My question is addressed to the President of the Government of my country. As regards the Infanta, I wanted to know if you have had the chance to speak with the King about this matter and, since it seems that the prosecutor is going to ask for up to 19 years for the Infanta's husband, don't you think that the Crown ought to separate this marriage from what we consider to be part of the Royal Family?

If you will allow me one more question. Do you believe there could be a party split in the PP in Andalusia, given that it seems that there may be more than one candidate, even two candidates? And do you now have a candidate for the European elections? And, of course, if you are able tell us about this.

President of the Government.- I have a regular audience with the King. It is my obligation as President of the Government and, moreover, the King likes to be regularly informed of what is taking place in his country. But, as you well know, the President of the Government must not make public the content of his meetings with the Head of State. This has never happened and you will appreciate that I am not going to start to do this now.

Aside from that, I am unaware of whether the prosecutor is going to ask for what you have referred to. I am unaware of whether this is the case and, hence, the prosecutor will act in the exercise of his independence, as he sees fit and appropriate, and I, as President of the Government, will have nothing to add.

I do have little to add on this matter to what I said at the time. In other words, the Infanta has, like any other citizen, a presumption of innocence, and she does not have a presumption of guilt simply because she is the Infanta. She has one of innocence, like all our citizens. Aside from that, we all have to follow the rulings handed down by the courts of justice, because Spain enjoys the Rule of Law, and this must be respected.

As regards the PP in Andalusia, the fact that there is… I don't know how many candidates there will be, but the fact that there may be two or more candidates does not mean there is a party split. What does that mean? Is there a party split in the Socialist Party when there are two candidates or a split in other parties when there are three candidates? When there is only one, you say one thing, when there are two, you say another thing and none of them is good. No, just look, I believe that if there are two, it is because there are two people who aspire to the post, and it will be the militants in Andalusia who take the decision that they see fit and appropriate. I am absolutely convinced that they will make the right choice, as they have almost always done.

As regards the candidate for the European elections, in principle we will not take a decision and, of course, we won't take it before the European People's Party Congress that will take place in Dublin, I believe, in the first week of March, the 6, 7 and 8 March. Under no circumstances prior to this date. Aside from that, what I can assure you of is that we will take a decision prior to the date set by law for nominating a candidate.

Q.- Mr Prime Minister, following the raid on the "Mavi Marmara" flotilla, one of the three conditions imposed by Turkey was the payment of compensation. Talks have been going on now for a very long time. The Israeli media, in particular, has been reporting that an agreement is almost upon us. What point are you at in the talks? Has a figure being agreed on in respect of compensation? Will Turkey withdraw the legal claims it has lodged?

Mr. Erdogan.- These talks still haven't reached their final conclusion. In other words, it was not only a question of an apology, which was possible only thanks to intervention from Mr Obama, but also of compensation. Talks have been held on this matter and I know that they have reached a certain level, but not the final level, as I am very much in favour of the final level being contained in a protocol. In other words, this should not only be done verbally, but also in a protocol.

As you are aware, there is a third aspect relating to lifting the embargo. Until the embargo is lifted this third aspect won't be possible because for the embargo to be lifted this must be set out in a written protocol. Just look, tonight I saw on television a Palestinian boy, who was handcuffed and shot in the foot, and they made him get into a vehicle. He was a child, a young man, who I believe was 15 or 16 years old.

This is the panorama and it remains that way. Now, any good intentions must be clear. Until such time as there are good intentions, we have no right to say "yes" to a final solution because, as you are aware, no-one on board the vessel "Marmara" was armed. However, the armed Israeli soldiers and police fired indiscriminately in international waters on these people who were transporting humanitarian aid. Perhaps they were all activists but they only carried humanitarian aid. Nine of our citizens were killed, whom we consider to be martyrs. One of the victims was a young man of 19 years of age of American nationality, and this young man was shot a point blank range. According to the medical examiner's report, he was shot both in the back and between the eyes with five bullets. He was an American citizen. The United States has done nothing about the death of this citizen. I showed them the photos of this young man and I showed them to Mr Obama.

In other words, this happened before the eyes of the whole world and yet there has been no reaction whatsoever. When it is a question of Israel, it's back to business. Do rights only exist for Israel? Don't they exist for others? Can't we claim our rights? I think that the main obligation, particularly ours, that of politicians, is to oppose cruelty, whoever the victim may be, and to be on the side of the oppressed.

Hence, it is not possible to consider this conflict as concluded without a certain protocol existing, or expect a return to normal relations. Firstly, the protocol needs to be drawn up, and then the necessary steps need to be taken. And that is what we have conveyed to the relevant counterparts in the matter.

Q- I have questions for both the Prime Minister and the President of the Government. The first is for the guest President of the Government, Mr Rajoy. You just said that nobody is privileged in the eyes of the law, if we understood correctly. In this respect, there was recently an anti-corruption operation at the headquarters of your party. Could you also analyse this please.

Mr Prime Minister, my second question is for you, if you will allow me, on domestic policy. In the last few days, certain recordings have emerged within the framework of legal wiretaps. I wanted to ask you about three allegations directly related to you: firstly, it is alleged that during the demonstrations in Gezi Park, you called the television station "Haberturk" from Morocco and made them remove some banners belonging to Devlet Bahceli; secondly, it is alleged that you have put aside a pool (fund) of money from certain business leaders that won public tenders thanks to your intervention and that with the money from this fund you have acquired the daily paper "Sabah" and the television channel ATV, and, in this way, these media changed owner; thirdly, it is alleged that in Urla (Esmirna), houses were built on land located in an area subject to first degree special protection and that you were informed of this, and you even, according to the allegations, have a house there. How do you respond to these allegations?

President of the Government.- As regards the question you asked me, I will only say what I said earlier, and I have nothing more to add. We will abide by the ruling handed down by the courts of justice for all cases that may affect any political party or indeed anyone else. That is the Rule of Law. The Executive has certain functions, the Legislative is entrusted with overseeing the Executive and approving laws, and the Judiciary oversees compliance with the law and imposes penalties on those who break the law. And that's it. That is my position. I believe that this is very clear and absolutely understandable.

Mr. Erdogan.- Firstly, let's put aside the expression "it is alleged" and let's say "we allege", because behind all these allegations are their bosses and behind all these allegations there is a place on which you all depend overseas. You are acting in accordance with the orders from the place on which you depend overseas.

I will start at the end. You are talking about the case of Urla. Above all, this case has nothing to do with me. There is a legal premise, learn it! He who alleges must prove his case. Who is making these allegations? It is the media to which he belongs. Firstly this newspaper is obliged to prove what it alleges. The place referred to is a place built 35 years ago. Why isn't the question addressed to the interested party, who is involved in legal proceedings, instead of addressing it to me? Ask his bosses first. This has nothing to do with me. It is a place that belongs to a very dear friend of mine, which I have visited for three to five days each year for the last five years. This land doesn't belong to the treasury. It is his land. I want you to be aware of that. Tell that to your bosses as well. But, unfortunately, your bosses are used to not telling the truth but to acting with the mentality of slandering people of trust in this country since, although they don't get it right, at least they can besmirch their good name.

These people have owned these properties for the last 35 years; the houses belong to them and were built 35 years ago; it is their village. It is said that it is an area of special protection of the first degree, or of the third degree. That is a legal process under way.

You cannot belittle the prime minister with this matter. To do so, you need more power and more evidence. This has nothing to do with me.

As regards the other matter, yes I called by phone from Morocco. That is very clear and very evident. I simply gave them a reminder that this was a speech in which he insulted a prime minister who was on a trip overseas. They did what they had to do. In other words, my colleagues and I have also called the heads of the newspapers in the past, and called your bosses as well, when there were instances of insults of this nature. I am not sure if this is a mistake, but the insults were not acceptable.

You had a third question. Firstly, you used an expression which is "pool" (fund). That aroused my curiosity and I asked about it. You are the ones to have invented this expression. Which "pool" are you referring to? The company that is taking this step in not any old company. The owner of this subsidiary company transferred his shares to his paternal uncle, he sold them.

On another note, in relation to the third airport, he sold his shares to those who belong to the "pool" as you call it, and that is how he joined the media. That is what he did. "Is that the "pool"? Please tell your bosses all this, but I know you don't intend to do so. Although you may tell them this, you won't achieve anything, because at the end of the day a world has been created based on slander and we see how they ask their supporters to repeat their messages on Twitter. Since you have also received the same instruction, follow it!

Thank you very much.