Speech by the President of the Government at the closing ceremony of the Conference on the Public Administration Reform in Europe
Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Rajoy addressed delegates at the closing ceremony of a European conference on public administration reform in Spain on February 9, 2014.
- Main themes
- Public administration reform, fiscal consolidation and deficit reduction, efficiency and modernization of government services, decentralization and bureaucratic overlap, public spending and GDP, structural economic reforms, competitiveness recovery, service quality improvement, Spanish economic crisis response
- Duration
- ~30 min
- Words
- 3,560
- Sentences
- 118
- Readability
- 37
- Grade
- 15.2
- Syntax
- 3.30
- Vocabulary
- 2.11
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other118 sentences in 51 paragraphs
Ladies and gentlemen,
In order to appreciate the dimension of this reform, it is necessary to understand the reality of the public administration in Spain. I would like to outline this briefly.
During the course of the last few decades, the bureaucratic machine in this country has been characterised by its smooth operation and for being established as a true driver of progress. In the transition of our country to an advanced democratic State with a model of far-reaching well-being, the public administration has played a leading role, developing as a reflection of the society it serves, with increasing functions and increasing complexities.
In this natural evolution, we have observed that our public administration services, while being good, are not perfect. And, of course, they have not been immune to the gradual appearance of inefficiencies, in many cases as a result of our very zeal in providing service to our citizens. Thus, in the decentralisation process, which exists in all our countries, to a greater or lesser extent, duplications and overlaps, and even loopholes in competencies, have emerged,
These errors in the cogs of the machine have unfortunately contributed to the creation of urban myths regarding our bureaucracy which must be refuted. The Spanish public administration is not over wieldy nor is it a major burden on the public purse. In fact, Spain is one of the Eurozone countries spending the least percentage of their GDP on public expenditure: 44% in 2012, or five percentage points less than the Eurozone average. Furthermore, almost two-thirds of our public expenditure goes on social spending and basic services; public, high quality and modern services, of which we can feel very proud.
We should thus ask ourselves: if the Spanish public administration is not so large but provides high quality services, why reform it? The answer is simple: today's society demands more services and better services, and we must be able to provide them without increasing the burden on our citizens. Achieving this goal requires that we do more with less, and that we do it better. And this must be an ongoing strategy and not merely a policy responding to a political situation.
An old political truism states that half of our mistakes derive from stopping thinking about one thing when this apparently raises no new challenges. But change doesn't stop because we stop and challenges don't stop emerging because we don't take them into account. Some people made the mistake over the last few years of stopping looking at the public administration, at how to improve it, and almost in how to sustain it and this resulted in increasing public spending disproportionally and without control.
Let me give you just a few figures to illustrate what I am talking about: firstly, between 2007 and 2011, public spending rose from 39.2% of GDP to 45.2% of GDP; and secondly, in the years of the crisis, when the private sector was shedding jobs by the million, the number of public workers increased by 280,000. These two figures are wholly incompatible, not only in the economic context, but in the very reality of our bureaucracy. Spain, we should remember, at the close of 2011, was one of the countries in the Eurozone with the lowest level of GDP revenue: 36.2%, nine points below the average.
Figures such as these help illustrate why it was unavoidable to undertake a reform of our public administration. However, I will say something else: the goal is not just to make a saving, but also to ensure that the Spanish public administration is as dynamic, effective and modern as the very society it seeks to serve. It is not only a question of streamlining, but also of becoming stronger, of creating a public administration at the service of our citizens and at the service of growth.
Ladies and gentlemen,
I must confess that the reform of the public administration in Spain had become an initiative that was forever being put off. It was the major reform of tomorrow and it would always be so. That is why the plan to reform the public administration was taken on board in certain circles with a degree of scepticism.
This doubt was a reaction to which some of us had already become accustomed when we started to speak about putting our accounts in order, when we started to speak about cleaning up our financial system and about applying a profound reformist agenda to recover the competitiveness of our economy. Faced with these doubts, and I want to place special emphasis on this: we reacted by stepping up our efforts and working with great determination.
Over these last two years, Spain has managed to spectacularly reduce its deficit, the greatest reduction of any G-20 Member State, which has enabled us to recover confidence. We have proceeded to clean up and restructure our financial sector, and the programme of European assistance has been successfully terminated. And our competitiveness, thanks to far-reaching structural reform, is back to the same levels as in 1999. Reforms such as the labour reform, the market unity reform, the Entrepreneur Act, the integration of our regulatory bodies, the de-indexing of the economy, have all contributed to making the operation of our economy more flexible, to making the foreign trade sector the new driver of growth and they will be key to our economic recovery being both stable and lasting, which will finally translate from major macro-economic figures into small domestic economies.
Well, you will appreciate that with these precedents, we were able to maintain our determination to reform the public administration; a reform initiated in the first few months of our term of office, with the General Law on Budgetary Stability and Financial Sustainability, with a reduction in spending by ministerial departments as never seen before, a restructuring of government to limit the number of executive posts and a raft of structural measures relating to the civil service, including a zero rate of staff replacement, apart from certain exceptions.
All these measures have contributed to an extraordinary effort towards making savings, with results already emerging in 2012. Despite the difficult economic situation, the proportion of GDP spending fell by 1.27 points in contrast to an average increase of 0.4 points in the Eurozone.
I have highlighted these figures to emphasise the reformist spirit as regards the public administration set in motion at the very start of this legislature and which we won't let up on during the rest of this term of office.
I also wanted to say, and I give this great importance and would thank the tremendous work done by our civil servants, who are the ones who have achieved this, that, since little more than half a year ago, we have also been able to count on a procedural guide, which is the Report by the Commission for the Reform of the Public Administration (Spanish acronym: CORA), a report which includes a detailed overview of the public administration, headed up by the Vice-President of the Government, with the participation of trade unions and employers' associations, universities and other institutions in our civil society, and of our citizens, who, through a specially designed electronic mailbox, have contributed more than 2,000 proposals.
This diagnosis led to a raft of more than 200 measures being proposed. Thanks to the intensive legislative and governmental activity, all of these measures are being implemented and more than 23 % of them have already been fully complied with.
These will perhaps disappoint those who thought we would cave in to the enormity of the task we had set ourselves, but you will agree with me now that the reform of the Spanish public administration is progressing at an unstoppable rate.
The structural reform of the public administration undertaken by the government on matters of public employment, the restructuring of public bodies, improvements in efficiency and in the management of public resources, as well as in removing duplication and in administrative simplification, have already resulted in savings of 7.38 billion euros. And we are yet to see the results from the reform of the local authorities, which has just been approved, and the centralised procurement of major administrative contracts, among other important measures taken.
Consequently, and only as a result of the measures already implemented, what we have already done but not including what is still to be done, the Spanish public administration will make savings of more than 28.9 billion euros by the end of 2015. To that we should add the efforts being made by the autonomous regions and local authorities, which are very significant and which have the major objective of ensuring budgetary stability and of making life easier, more comfortable and simpler for our citizens. I would like to recall that a saving of 4.04 billion euros was made merely by reducing the number of regional public companies and bodies. Ladies and gentlemen,
It makes me especially proud to see this progress in light of the speech I had the occasion to make upon presenting the report I mentioned earlier. The vast majority of the measures I outlined then by way of example are now a reality or are about to be so.
Just think, for example, about such important measures as that to do away with late payments by the public sector, which is now in force, the Constitutional Law to Control Commercial Debt in the Public Sector, which incorporated commercial debt under the principle of financial stability, and the Law to Promote Electronic Invoicing, whereby suppliers register their invoices electronically to avoid them being lost, forgotten or remaining unpaid, which happened here for many years, as I will refer to later.
As a result of the Supplier Payment Plan, more than eight million invoices have been paid - just imagine, we owed more than eight million invoices - to more than 230,000 businesses and independent contractors. The marker has been reset at zero and, henceforth, each public administration must pay on time and in a manner, which, to put it another way, is reasonable, not only because the law says so, but because not doing this destroys the very credibility of our institutions and seriously prejudices our companies, particularly SMEs and independent contractors, who are the ones driving the very growth of this country, and those who will be called on to do so in the future.
That is why the CORA Report has made a great effort to uncover the various burdens that prejudiced the creation and development of business initiatives. Hence, the Entrepreneur Act has extended the use of declarations of liability to replace the preliminary licenses that delayed the opening of thousands of businesses - this is a very important reform - which has reduced the requirements that prevented SMEs from gaining access to public sector contracts.
Furthermore, major projects have been set in motion on administrative simplification in important sectors such as communications and infrastructure, removing environmental and regulatory requirements that could result in removing the incentive to invest. One example, the average time to process an environmental evaluation case has been reduced from 3.4 years to four months.
Other more modest projects, in their conception, have an important impact, in reality, on the daily lives of our citizens. I refer, for example, to prior appointments for employment services or, more recently, with the Directorate General for Traffic, which has led to time not being wasted in queues for more than 460,000 citizens and a saving of 40 million euros for the public administration services.
Taking advantage of the resources offered by new technologies can allow us to save time and opportunity and economic costs for both our citizens and for companies. I am convinced that the replacement of notifications and postal communications by electronic notifications is a true revolution, which not only allows for faster relations with our citizens but also increased legal certainty and savings, both for our citizens (estimated at 1.13 billion euros over three years) and for the State (469 million euros).
This project will be completed by the implementation of a Single Edict Notice Board, the regulation for which has been submitted to Parliament, which will enable citizens to consult notifications that affect them from all our public administration services through a single web site. Furthermore, through an à la carte Official State Gazette, citizens can receive a message when their name appears or simply when a regulation of interest is published. In other words neither citizens nor companies will need to constantly review the Gazette, wasting time and energy that they wish to invest in other things. Setting a common deadline for the entry into force of the regulations for companies will be the next step to be taken.
And understanding legislation can become one of the main headaches for business owners:
- Firstly, because in certain important areas, there has been a real profusion of laws enacted which have been subject to repeated amendments, to the point of even incurring in contradictions. The CORA has identified 17 of these areas and it has submitted to Parliament a bill that allows the government to draft eight consolidated texts to put this morass of regulations in order.
- Secondly, because the regulatory differences that exist in our country have translated into an obstacle for the operation of companies. For that reason, the Law to Guarantee Market Unity ensures that any product or service produced under the scope of a regional regulation, any whatsoever, can be commercialised throughout the country on the basis of principles that inspire the single European market: a single licence and legislation of origin. We are also developing a project to streamline regulations in order to adapt all State and regional legislation to these principles.
From this same perspective, a law has also been passed that regulates the characteristics of the single healthcare card, that will enable the clinical records of any patient to be accessed and allow electronic prescriptions to be issued anywhere in Spain. We also intend for birth certificates to be handled electronically at health centres without having to go to other offices with the additional effort that this involves. These are just simple examples of what can be achieved for our citizens when the public administration services collaborate and coordinate with each other.
Ladies and gentlemen,
Improving and finding solutions is a joint effort, which means involving Central Government and the autonomous regions. The Central Government is prepared to drive as many initiatives as necessary to make progress on this target, and there are many initiatives in the proposals contained in the CORA Report to ensure greater coordination, integrated registers and shared data bases. This is a question of common sense and administrative streamlining, because of the 39 Sector Conferences, only 21 met on a regular basis during the last three years; others have never even been set up.
But this has been changing since the publication of the report: the Annual Plan on Employment Policies has been approved which establishes - and this is very important - joint planning of technologies in the field of the administration of justice - something truly worthy of mention that did not exist before, with the problems that this caused - and the Sector Conference has been set up on matters of traffic and road safety. Moreover, various autonomous regions have signed up to the Framework Agreement on Humanitarian Aid, such that, if a new disaster unfortunately takes place, the Spanish response will be, as always, one of support, but henceforth, a joint and more effective response.
On another note, the integrated registers and data bases are making progress on including information from the different public administration services. For example, the State register for public benefits already contains information from 11 different autonomous regions.
I would like to say that the autonomous regions are participating in the reform process of the public administration in a very active manner and they are implementing major projects to streamline their structures. The net reduction of 751 public bodies, amounting to 31.75% of the total, and the reorganisation of 228 other bodies, are a clear example of this.
To this we should add the contribution from Central Government in this matter, with a net reduction that will amount to more than 90 public companies and foundations, or 39% of those that existed before. And the adjustments don't stop there: the new Law on the Legal System Governing the Public Administration Services will impose periodic revisions of all those bodies, their targets, their structures and their results and, when their existence is unjustified, they will be dissolved.
Ladies and gentlemen,
There is room for improvement in all the public administration services, as in all facets of life. We have seen this first hand in Central Government. For example, through adopting measures for centralised procurement, which has translated into a saving of more than 100 million euros. Remember that, when I appeared here to present the first CORA Report, I found out, because I wasn't aware beforehand - I found out that day - that the Central Government had more than 4,000 bank accounts. That number will now be reduced to 0.01 of those 4,000 bank accounts. And with centralised procurement, we have achieved in a very short time and in the few places where we have been able to make progress a saving of more than 100 million euros.
These savings have been made solely by centralising procurement within each ministerial department and monitoring what is purchased, because no ministerial department can now purchase an IT system of computer without the unit managing new technologies authorising said purchase, which involves there being no other system or computer belonging to the public administration than can be used to said end that is compatible with those existing; it must be necessary and the price must be valid.
And this is just the beginning. In 2014, for the first time, joint telecommunications, energy and cleaning public tenders will be issued for various ministerial departments which will result in even greater savings. If we need to put out a tender in the telecommunications sector, you can imagine that putting out just one rather than 575 will be cheaper. And the same is true for energy or many other services that appear under the heading of running costs of the public administration services.
At any event, I would like to say to you that we will reduce costs, but under no circumstances will we reduce the quality of the services provided by the public administration, because this is the whole crux of the reform: to ensure that the public administration is a driver of growth and that it operates at an optimum level in order to benefit companies and citizens.
I will conclude now, and I will do so by inviting you to take part in this key reform that we are making. Experience has taught us that all suggestions are welcome and enriching, both those from within, which is why we created the Office for the Implementation of the Reform of the Public Administration, and also those from outside; for example, those that may come from conferences such as the one that has gathered us here and which enables us to see what is being done in other countries.
Our intention, through this, is to take a giant leap towards modernity. As I have said during the course of this speech, the reform of the public administration is not an easy task; it is something that has been spoken about since time immemorial. Previously I remarked that it is a reform that will continue into the future, since it was a reform that was pending. We have taken it seriously. That has not been easy, as you are all aware. This is complicated to explain, but it is very important, and not simply because of the savings to be made, which will be made, but rather, and above all, because the main and essential goal is to make life easier for our citizens and for Spanish small- and medium-sized enterprises as well as for our major corporations.
That is the main goal. I believe it is a worthy goal and I believe that it is a reform which will be in force forever, well into the future, because no-one will put the brakes on something which is good, works well and which everyone applauds.
That is why I wish to reiterate, once again, to all the civil servants that are working so hard and putting in so much effort, and without their hard work this task would be impossible to bring to fruition… I would like to express my very special thanks to them.
I am aware of how complicated this is. This work must be done very meticulously and the regulations must be studied one by one, but, in the end, this will result in satisfaction; satisfaction for our citizens as a whole and, above all, the greatest satisfaction, the satisfaction of a job well done; of having contributed to doing something that is good and useful for your country.
And to all of you, Madam Vice-President of the Government and ministers, thank you very much. I was the Minister for the Public Administration Services sometime back. I didn't reform them back then but I have returned to do so now.
Thank you very much.