Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

18 February 2014 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to parliamentary questions on Spain's financial system restructuring, tax policy, and calls for an investigative commission during a February 2014 congressional control session.
Main themes
Financial system restructuring, tax increases and fiscal policy, tax reform proposals, parliamentary accountability, unemployment and economic recovery, SME policy, savings and consumption, investigative commission demands, Eurogroup program exit, middle class protection
Duration
~16 min
55th percentile
Words
1,903
55th percentile
Sentences
66
43rd percentile
Readability
50
63rd percentile
Grade
13.3
59th percentile
Syntax
3.20
73rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
29th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 40%38%
  • Social 31%29%
  • Institutional 19%18%
  • Ceremonial 10%9%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

66 sentences in 30 paragraphs

Mr. Rajoy, you should push for the investigative commission because if you refuse today, you become a political accomplice to the greatest fraud in democracy.

President.- Look, Mr. Lara, one of the most important problems that this Government had to face was the situation in which our financial system found itself, and you know that without a financial system, there is no functioning economy, neither the Spanish nor any other in the world.

At this point, I can tell you that the Government has taken care of what it needed to take care of: first, guaranteeing the deposits, investment funds, and pension plans of all Spanish savers, and fortunately, that has been achieved, which has not happened in other countries very close to ours. Secondly, I must say that we have already proceeded with the restructuring of our financial system and we have exited the European Union program with the support and approval of the Eurogroup and all our partners in the Union. And finally, I want to tell you that the prosecutor has acted, that the courts are dealing with the cases you are interested in, that there are already many investigations open in Spanish courts, and there are constant news reports appearing in the media.

Therefore, in Spain, the institutions work, the courts work, and let us allow them to do their job while the Government and Parliament take care of theirs.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Josep Sánchez Llibre, from the Catalan Parliamentary Group of Convergència i Unió

Mr. Sánchez Llibre.- Mr. Rajoy, I do not know if you are aware that you are the President of the Spanish Government of our young democracy who has raised taxes the most on families, self-employed individuals, citizens, and the middle classes in general, despite the fact that you promised to lower them in your recent electoral campaign.

As of today, Mr. President, you hold the title of champion in the tax ranking of tax increases among Presidents who have proposed tax hikes to Spaniards. And you have implemented, in our view, a confiscatory fiscal policy that greatly harms families, the middle classes, and low incomes. You have raised personal income tax, you have raised VAT, you have raised excise taxes, you have raised corporate tax, and you have raised and created new taxes on lotteries and energy products.

Spain, Mr. President, and you know this perfectly well, has a 26 percent unemployment rate, and those who work as employees or self-employed individuals are being crushed by taxes. They are left practically dry with no disposable income to save or consume. For this reason, from Convergència i Unió, we ask you for a radical change in your tax policy. We are calling for a radical change in your fiscal and tax policy, and that is why we ask you, Mr. President, when will there be a reduction in personal income tax, when will there be a reduction in cultural VAT from 21 percent to 10 percent, when will there be a fiscal policy of savings and protection for families, when will you consider SMEs as an instrument for generating wealth and employment instead of viewing them merely as passive taxpayers to the Treasury.

Mr. President, from Convergència i Unió, we say, with the utmost clarity and strength, now is the time to lower taxes. I repeat, now is the time to lower taxes. Without this tax reduction, there will be no recovery, there will be no consumption, there will be no incentive for savings, there will be no job creation, and, what is more serious, the middle classes will disappear.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Sánchez Llibre.

Indeed, I have raised many taxes, those to which you referred in your question; but no one found the country in a situation like the one I found myself in. I want to tell you, moreover, that I avoided raising others. You talk about the increase in VAT, but there were those who intended, and not precisely with little power, to raise the VAT on restaurants and hospitality to 21 percent, and that did not happen. I must also tell you that we have not raised taxes on entrepreneurs or self-employed individuals; yes, some others, but in this case, we have lowered them on some occasions.

I must also tell you that I agree with you that now is the time to proceed with a tax reduction, and that is why the Council of Ministers already in July of last year, 2013, approved an Agreement to establish a commission of experts for the reform of the Spanish tax system. This commission will analyze the system and formulate proposals. At the end of this month of February, the commission will deliver the report to the Government, the Government will conduct an analysis, an assessment, and will present a Bill here, in the Cortes.

This is the situation we are in at this moment. That new Law will come into effect on January 1, 2015, and that is when the tax reduction will begin, which was indeed what I had committed to the Spanish people.

This tax system will have four characteristics: first, simplicity; it must be simpler than the one we currently have; second, sufficiency, to be able to exercise the powers that the laws attribute to public authorities; third, it aims to promote economic development: the great objective is economic growth, job creation, and the internationalization of our companies; and finally, social development: to protect families, people with disabilities, and to stimulate savings.

I can give you some more data. First, we want a tax system that does not harm hiring but rather stimulates and favors it; second, a tax system that improves competitiveness in line with what we have done in the Entrepreneurs' Law, where there is a reduced corporate tax rate of 15 percent for newly created companies, a 20 percent reduction in net income for self-employed individuals starting economic activities, and complete exemption for self-employed individuals in personal income tax for unemployment benefits and similar ones.

The third major objective of the reform will be to improve collection. In Spain, 70 billion euros were lost in two years, fifteen times more in collection than the European Union, in the years 2008 and 2009. We have not achieved that; therefore, we need to create a system that is more equitable, more neutral, and improve inspection.

And finally, support for families, stimulation of savings...

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Alfredo Pérez Rubalcaba, from the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.- Mr. Rajoy, do you consider that the Draft Bill your Government has prepared to modify the Abortion Law respects women's freedom to decide about their own motherhood?

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba. The current Law was approved by you, as you know, in 2010. It was not in your electoral program, and you modified the 1985 Law that had been in force for twenty-five years and that you also approved, which had been ratified by the Constitutional Court, and which we, although it was not our law, chose not to modify in the interest of consensus. Now, as we had committed in the electoral program, we are going to propose a reform of the Law that, in substance, means a return to the 1985 Law, the one that was in force for twenty-five years with almost general consensus.

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba, you were in Government for many years during the validity of the 1985 Law. You approved it, and you were very comfortable with it because in twenty-five years you never expressed the slightest intention to change it. So I ask you: why was that Law good in 1985 and afterwards, when you were in Government, and now that we are doing it, it is bad? It seems to me that you have a rather strange measuring stick.

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.- Mr. Rajoy, as you know, in matters of pregnancy termination, there are two models: deadlines and assumptions. The difference between the two is who decides: in the deadlines, the woman decides, and in the assumptions, someone decides for the woman.

In Spain, there has been a deadline law for four years that has aligned us with Europe, which has not posed any social difficulties and with which, by the way, abortions in Spain have decreased. You now want to go back further, to a more restrictive law, the one from 1985, which is true that we approved, without your votes, you are right, and which functioned at the time; it was an advance, but we changed it. Do you know why? To give freedom or legal security to women, to adapt the Law to the social change in Spain, because Spanish society has changed a lot, and finally, to incorporate some suggestions, for example, from the World Health Organization.

You now want to separate us from Europe. It is true that not for everyone, eh! There are women whom you will bring closer to Europe: those who have the resources to move to European countries and continue using a deadline law.

In summary, if you have money, deadlines; if you do not have it, assumptions. If you have money, you decide, freedom, and if you do not have it, someone decides for you. And if they tell you no, you have to deal with an unwanted pregnancy or go underground and risk it.

This is the reality, Mr. Rajoy. That is why I ask you: do not deprive Spanish women of the freedom to decide about their own pregnancy; do not establish a contradiction, a discrimination, between women who have resources, who will have freedom in European countries, and those who do not, who will not have it in Spain; do not impose the morality of some on the entire citizenry of Spain and do not sacrifice the freedom of women for a handful of votes from the far right. Neither for that, nor for anything, Mr. Rajoy.

President.- Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba, this is a very difficult and complex issue, and it is advisable not to believe oneself to be in possession of the truth. In fact, you have had two truths: the truth you defended with the 1985 Law for twenty-five years, which is the law of assumptions, and the truth you have defended since 2010, which is a different law, the law of deadlines, so I understand that all the reproaches you have made to me for approving the 1985 Law, you have also made to yourself for twenty-five years.

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba, this Law is the 1985 Law, which is exactly the one you approved and maintained in force for twenty-five years, with some modifications: the woman will never have criminal reproach; a minor will have to have the knowledge of her parents to make this decision and not do it alone; and, thirdly, the need to offer social and clinical counseling to women about alternatives and their consequences is established, which, in my opinion, is quite positive.

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba, I am willing to dialogue with you, to talk and to agree. What I am not willing to do is to let you try to prohibit this Parliamentary Group, legitimized by the ballot boxes, from presenting a Bill here, which seems to be the thesis you are defending.

Thank you very much.