Press conference by the President of the French Republic and the President of the Government of Spain

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

25 March 2013 · Joint press conference with the President of the Government of Spain

Context
Rajoy held a joint press conference with French President Hollande in Paris on March 25, 2013, following bilateral talks on Europe, Mali, and infrastructure.
Main themes
Franco-Spanish bilateral relations, European banking union, Cyprus crisis, economic growth and fiscal consolidation, Mali intervention, infrastructure projects, unemployment, European Council cooperation, financial stability mechanisms
Duration
~35 min
87th percentile
Words
4,168
87th percentile
Sentences
166
84th percentile
Readability
49
59th percentile
Grade
12.6
53rd percentile
Syntax
3.13
64th percentile
Vocabulary
1.98
8th percentile
Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 43%42%
  • Ceremonial 22%22%
  • Institutional 18%17%
  • Geopolitical 14%14%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

166 sentences in 59 paragraphs

One word describes our bilateral relations: excellent. They are excellent not only in terms of political and personal relations, but they are also excellent because we have been able in recent months to carry out a certain number of infrastructure works, both on the gas pipeline (in fact there was an opening today) and in the area of electricity power lines and the future high-speed railway line between Perpignan and Barcelona, which we plan to open in the upcoming months, perhaps in the summer for the France-Spain summit.

We also tackled political and diplomatic relations. I thanked Mr Rajoy for the support Spain has given to France in the intervention in Mali: for its presence in the training of the Mali forces, but also for its participation in the security of the European forces deployed on Mali soil, and whose number will be more important over the coming months, as we ourselves are going to see our presence reduced. Our aim for Mali, I remind you, is for there to be a Resolution by the Security Council to decide a peacekeeping operation. This Resolution could arrive in April.

We also exchanged opinions on the situation in Europe. Since June, Spain and France have worked with the same purpose we showed at the European Council meeting in June: to ensure that the growth objectives succeed, but that financial stability does as well. It was a very important European Council meeting, and we still note its effects today. Our responsibility is to transfer what we decided at the Council meeting so that there is significant change in Europe's financial situation. That is what we did at the Council meetings that followed up on the one in June, and that is the reason why we put so much value on both banking union and the resolution mechanisms, the supervision mechanisms and the recapitalisation mechanisms, with a guarantee for deposits, which must be an absolute and irrevocable principle.

We want to make progress in this banking union according to the timetable that was planned and we have seen its use in the solution to the problem of Cyprus. If this banking union had existed, we would not have experienced the Cyprus situation. We thus have to analyse the agreement between Cyprus and the Troika as if it were a section introduced into the process of banking union, with rules that must be adjusted to it as much as possible, even though the situation of Cyprus is specific, unique and exceptional.

With respect to the other goal we were trying to achieve together, as we reduce our deficits and continue along the path that takes us towards healthier public accounts, we have a determination to create growth. Europe has to be stimulated so that there can be prospects for a return to growth, even in the year 2013. A balance has to be found between the part reserved for fiscal consolidation and the part that must be reserved for a return to growth. If the part of fiscal consolidation is too high, there will be no return to growth; but if there is no fiscal consolidation, there will be no confidence for growth.

That is therefore the path we have to find and it is different for each country. In Spain, very important measures have been taken; in France we are not in the same situation, but the spirit is the same. We know that the unemployment rates are very high in Spain, but in France they are high too: the number of unemployed has risen by one million over the last five years.

So we therefore have an obligation to do everything we can to return to growth. That will be the goal of the discussion that we will have with our colleagues at the European Council, and for each of our countries individually, with the European Commission.

So that is essentially the outcome of our meeting: excellent bilateral relations, a common political stance, as we have just seen, on Mali, and finally, a vision of Europe that must have rules, that must have principles, mechanisms for resolving the crisis - banking union, the stability mechanisms - and a Europe that proposes growth with the same conviction as it does finding a balance in our public accounts.

Thank you, Mariano.

President of the Government. Thank you very much, Mr President.

Ladies and gentlemen, a very good afternoon to you.

As President Hollande has said, this is the third time that I have come to Paris to meet with him. On each of the three occasions, the reception, the welcome, has been extraordinary, and so once again I would like to thank him here for his kindliness.

President Hollande also visited Madrid, as you know, last year, and we have had the opportunity to meet on various occasions at the European Council meetings and at various international meetings. I believe that we have managed to establish a fluid relationship of confidence and cooperation between us, and I believe that this is very important for the bilateral relations between Spain and France, but also for promoting a joint exit from the crisis that the European Union is currently undergoing.

Spain and France are neighbours, friends and allies: we defend the same values and are working together to ensure a strong, prosperous and more cohesive European Union.

Today I have once more noted the central importance that both countries grant to our bilateral relations. And these relations are, as President Hollande said, excellent and increasingly close. We demonstrated that at the last France-Spain summit in October, which is now beginning to bring results.

As you know, not very long ago we opened the Spanish section of the first high-speed rail line between our two countries, from Barcelona to Figueras, and I hope, as President Hollande also said just now, that soon the high-speed line will link Perpignan, Barcelona and the rest of Spain. And I think that we can all be very happy about that.

I would also like to say - and we have talked about this issue - that, before the summer, we will make delivery in Seville of the first Airbus 400 that has been acquired by the French Armed Forces.

These are two signs of what is a very important collaboration, as is the support given by the French government and President of the Republic to our government and our country in the fight against ETA; and I thank them for it once more.

This year we are holding another bilateral summit in the autumn, and thus recover the annual frequency that had been neglected in recent years. We are already working to ensure that this summit can produce real results in areas such as energy and transport interconnections, political and legal cooperation, and many other matters covered in our relations.

Our cooperation is also very important on the European front, above all and in particular, in the European Council meetings that took place last year and this year, in 2013. Together we defended the Growth Pact in June 2012, and more recently, a realistic Financial Framework for the European Union with sufficient political resources for policies such as the Common Agricultural Policy, where we had common positions that I believe have been useful for both the French and Spanish agricultural sectors. And we have also worked to create a fund that promotes youth employment, one of the most important problems that some of the countries in the European Union have, above all Spain.

I would like to make a brief comment, and the President of the Republic referred to this matter in his speech, with respect to what is happening in the European Union and what has happened in Cyprus.

I want to say that the agreement reached in Cyprus appears good to us, to Spain. I believe it is very important that there should be a programme that helps the Cyprus economy move forward and I also believe that it is very important that the deposits of all those people with amounts below 100,000 euros should have been respected. We consider this is very important and I think that maintaining this position means sending out a message of confidence.

But I also want to say that the problem of the Cyprus banking sector is a problem that is different from that of any other country in the European Union. That is why the decision adopted, as included in the Eurogroup minutes, is an extraordinary and unique decision, and that is why it has been applied, in extraordinary fashion, only to Cyprus. That is very important. I would like to make this very clear, as has already been done by others over the last few hours.

And I would also like to say that to maintain confidence not only should we take decisions and be consistent, but when it comes to making declarations, we should be prudent, act with precision and with care; and without a doubt, we should always comply with the agreements made by the different European institutions.

With respect to the European Union, and taking up something that President Hollande has just said, it has to be said that if banking union was already a fact, a reality, we would not have experienced this problem we have lived through over the last few hours.

In this sense, I would like to say that the European Council meeting last June, was a very important Council meeting, because it set a goal and a path forward. The goal it set was banking union, fiscal union, economic union and political union… As you know, things take their time and we have to make an effort to reach an agreement between all of us on subjects that are far from minor; that are very important, because they affect, and greatly, people's lives; but a timetable was also agreed and then ratified in the European Council meeting in December. That is why I would like to say that Spain will defend the idea that next June there should be approval of the system for the European recapitalisation of financial institutions, and that in December we should already discuss and approve a system of deposit guarantees and a single resolution mechanism.

That, I insist, is very important. I believe that the steps that have been already taken to ensure that we can talk about banking union in Europe, which could have avoided many problems, must continue. They must be taken with determination, conviction and courage. I insist that this is very important and will represent a substantial advance in European construction. And then I would also like to talk about fiscal union, economic union and political union.

So I would like to say that the Government of Spain, as it has already done and as the rest of the European governments did over 2012, continues with its commitment to increasingly closer European integration that will undoubtedly bring nothing but prosperity, welfare and wealth to all to the people of Europe.

Finally, I want to ratify Spain's commitment in the actions and decisions adopted with respect to Mali. The situation there is very complex. We have supported the French government's decision from the start. We have provided it with political support and also with material and human resources, and we will continue to work with it so that the situation is resolved as quickly as possible and Mali, and the whole region in general, becomes what we all want: an area of stability where there can be progress and welfare for all those who live there.

Q. I would like to ask a question to the President of the Government Rajoy. Today the Bank of Spain has published forecasts that put the fall of GDP at 1.5% and the unemployment rate at 27%. You already said that you would review these forecasts, and I would like to know if you are going to do that. What opinion do you have of the recommendation made by the Bank of Spain to use labour reform to lower wages?

And, if you will allow me, we have just received news of a statement by ETA that announces "negative consequences" after the Government broke off dialogue, and that also criticises the Government's inflexibility. I would like you to comment on this statement.

President of the Government. Yes, I am aware of the forecasts of the Bank of Spain, and of course they have to be taken into account. There have been many other forecasts by the International Monetary Fund, and also forecasts from the European Commission, and of course from many research services of different Spanish and international organisations.

When we presented the Budget, it was accompanied by a macroeconomic table, with forecasts for 2013, and as I announced in Parliament, when we submitted our Stability and Growth Plan for next year to the European Council, we included a review of these forecasts, as, I repeat, I pointed out at the time. I am not going to tell you now whether or not they are in line with what the Bank of Spain says; what I will tell you is that we are going to revise our economic forecasts.

With respect to the labour reform, I believe that there was a very important agreement at the start of last year between the trade unions and employers' organisations on the subject of wages. I believe that the labour reform has been a very significant step forward, and that is why the competitiveness of the Spanish economy has improved a great deal over these months. Even the data related to unit labour costs are very important if compared, above all, with other countries in the European Union. That is very important, because it affects the competitiveness of the Spanish economy, and when we talk about competitiveness, what we are talking about is progress, welfare and employment.

That is why this is an agreement that should be reached by the employers' organisations and trade unions, workers and employers, and of course the Government has to respect it and to set it within a framework, which is the labour reform we have implemented.

With respect to the statement you refer to, I would like to be positive about it. I do not want to talk about negative consequences. I want to talk about positive consequences and the best positive consequences for all, I repeat, for all the people of Spain will come when ETA announces for good its dissolution and disappearance as a terrorist organisation. That will be a positive consequence that will bring nothing but good to all, starting with, and above all, as the human beings we are, the individual rights of each person.

Q. The European Commission indicated today that deposits greater than 100,000 euros could be used within the framework of future resolutions of banking crises. I would like to know if you are opposed to these deposits being used in the future and I wanted to know if you think that Jeroen Dijsselbloem is a good President of the Eurogroup.

President of the Government. Yes. I believe that the bank recapitalisation plans must be carried out, as I have always said, and I hope that things move in that direction, using the ESM. That is my position and I will not be in favour of a Directive that says that the recapitalisation plans of the banks should be carried out using people's deposits. That is not my opinion, it is not my criterion, and that is certainly the position I will defend when the time comes.

With respect to the second question, I have nothing more to add to what I have already said. We must all act above all by complying with the agreements that are adopted. I think that is the best thing to do, what generates greatest stability, calm and confidence.

Mr Hollande. What is banking union? It is what allows us greater oversight, what we call supervision, of banks; it is what allows us to have a clear resolve when there is a crisis and it is a guarantee of deposits, with a recapitalisation that in the final analysis will come via the ESM, as Mariano Rajoy has just described. In other words, it is a solidarity fund at European level. Thus there are two essential principles in banking union, beyond the oversight and supervision and oversight. The two essential principles are: the guarantee of deposits, in other words people who put money in banks in the Eurozone have a guarantee with respect to the funds they have deposited. That is a principle that has to be respected, because it is a principle that gives confidence and is the foundation of banking union. When there is a crisis, which can happen, and it has not been addressed with sufficient speed, it is the ESM mechanisms that bring a solution via recapitalisation.

I have no more comments to make about the statements that may have been made, because what is most important with respect to Cyprus is the agreement that has needed time to be concluded, because it was not simple given the special nature of Cyprus, with a hypertrophied banking system with respect to the real economy and with deposit holders who were not only European depositors from the Eurozone. So the way the situation was handled had to be exceptional, specific, unique; but it had to be done and was done precisely so that holders of deposits of under 100,000 euros did not have any cuts made to their accounts.

Q. For Mr President of the Government Rajoy. I would like to ask him about the latest events that have occurred with respect to the movement of victims of eviction in Spain. The government delegate in Madrid has related these movements with pro-ETA movements or ETA supporters. It also appears that the opposition has said today that these movements are being criminalised. I would like to know your opinion… and there have also been complaints by members of parliament.

Next I would like to ask you if you could give us another opinion on the cases of corruption from which your party is suffering on all fronts. You have not talked to the Spanish press on this subject since December and the party is not meeting, the party hierarchy has not met for weeks. The system for funding the party has been under suspicion and under investigation for many years. Today Mr Sanchís has been charged; Mr Bárcenas has, or had, a considerable amount of money in Switzerland...

There are many questions, but did you never suspect at all that these people were acting badly for all these years? Have you not considered that your silence increases people's suspicions instead of easing them and that it would be a good idea to give rather more unambiguous explanations?

President of the Government. With respect to the second question, I stated my position in public a few days after some news appeared to which you refer, and it was an open announcement that was followed by everyone who wanted to do so. That is my position and I have made it perfectly clear.

So having said that, the political party I head, the People's Party (Partido Popular, PP), has delivered all its accounts to the courts, we have carried out an internal audit, we have made it known to the public. And having done that, we are prepared to accept what the courts say, as is the case in any democratic state that operates under the rule of law such as ours.

With respect to what is occurring, I have to say that it is not democratic, nor is it just or appropriate for a serious country, that people should be harassed and intimidated in their homes, and that their homes should be pasted with posters depicting their faces. I believe that this is antidemocratic and I believe that everyone who feels a democrat should say so and state it clearly, because respect for others is a basic value in a democratic system, even if they do not think like you, and although they do things you don't like; because if everyone acted as some people do, you have to understand that the country could not function. So it appears profoundly undemocratic and it is my obligation to say so and act in accordance.

Second, I would like to say that we are aware of the existing problem, but I would also like to say that this Government is the first that has taken decisions on this matter. In other words, it is not the first: it is the only government that has taken decisions on this matter. And we have to reconcile the difficult situation that many people are experiencing, of which we are aware, with legal security, with the rules we have established between all of us and that were not approved yesterday, but that have been in force for a long time and have also allowed many people to have mortgage loans and thus to own their own home in Spain.

So we have a good system, but it can be perfected. It is true that at the present time we are in a very complex and difficult situation due to the economic crisis we are suffering from, but it is also true that we have to search for balanced solutions. I believe that we have taken steps in the right direction. We are now debating in Parliament the Bill presented by this Government, and which is also a popular initiative, and there we can take decisions. But I repeat, they have to be balanced decisions, because we also have to preserve legal security and the interests of a very great number of Spanish citizens, very many, who deposit money in financial institutions that is then lent out, and it is important that this should also be known.

Q. Another question about unemployment. The unemployment rate in France, which was released this afternoon, is close to the all-time high of 1997 and in Spain, as my Spanish colleague has said, it could hit 27% this year. Does this justify for you the adoption of exceptional measures? President Hollande, do you still think the unemployment curve will be reversed at the end of this year?

And as we are talking about forecasts, a question about football. Could you give us your forecasts for the results of the match you are going to see?

Mr Hollande. With respect to unemployment, you have recalled the Spanish figures and you could cite the figures of Italy and Portugal; and you have, very reasonably, mentioned the figures of France.

For five years now, for the last 60 months, there have been 52 months of rises and 8 months of falls. Unemployment has increased by one million. Among the reasons are zero growth, which leads to this continuous increase in jobseekers. With respect to the February figure, 18,400 people, I would say that it is lower, also that it is lower than in January, twice as low. But it is too much, too high with respect to what our citizens are living through: precariousness, doubt and uncertainty.

The growth figures were mentioned a little while ago: for Spain there is a recession of 1.5% in 2013 and for Portugal and Italy, 2%. In France we do not want to play at optimism, and we have just over 0.1%. That is little, too little.

So to reduce unemployment we need growth: growth in France and growth in Europe, because we need growth in Europe. The core of our trade is with the European market, and when Europe is in recession, France cannot expand, nor can any other country, and that goes too for the country that appears to be performing best, and that will only experience a growth of barely 0.8% in 2013.

You ask me if I am still convinced that we will reverse the unemployment curve. It is not a question of conviction, it is not simply a belief; it is a determination, it is an objective and I will continue with the measures we have taken over recent months and which will produce their effects. But this reversal, which will not occur until the end of the year - and that is the commitment I have adopted - has to be fuelled by growth if it is to be lasting. That is the reason for the battle that I am waging at national, but also European level, for a return to growth.

With respect to the football match, this forecast is completely different to the one I have just outlined. Here, for many reasons, both friendly and sporting, a draw would be the best result for France.

President of the Government. With your permission, I cannot agree on that. I believe the best result is a victory for Spain.

Mr Hollande. And on that note of discord we will leave it. Thank you very much.