Press conference of the Prime Minister after the European Council meeting.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

22 November 2012 · European Council meeting

Context
Rajoy addressed press after an extraordinary European Council meeting in Brussels on 22 November 2012, reporting on EU budget framework negotiations for 2014-2020.
Main themes
EU Multiannual Financial Framework 2014-2020, Spain's negotiating position, European Council extraordinary meeting, bilateral meetings with EU leaders, transitional regions funding, Common Agricultural Policy, cohesion funds, EU budget negotiations, outermost regions, Ceuta and Melilla, political will for agreement
Duration
~31 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,724
83rd percentile
Sentences
159
83rd percentile
Readability
57
82nd percentile
Grade
10.7
28th percentile
Syntax
3.14
66th percentile
Vocabulary
1.88
2nd percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

159 sentences in 68 paragraphs

President.- Good afternoon and thank you very much for your attendance.

I appear before you to report on the results of the extraordinary European Council dedicated to the so-called Multiannual Financial Framework of the European Union for the period 2014-2020.

As you know, considerable progress has been made regarding the initial positions. Spain, which has participated, as always, with a constructive spirit in these negotiations, leaves this European Council with a better position than the one it entered with.

As I have said on other occasions, not reaching an agreement on the first attempt was to be expected, and I reminded you of this when I entered this very venue of the European Council yesterday. After all, it is usual for an agreement on this matter to require more than one round of negotiations to accommodate the interests of no less than twenty-seven countries. This happened in the negotiations of 1999, also in the negotiations of 2005, and therefore, this falls within the realm of predictability and normality.

Throughout yesterday and today, we have engaged in intense work, and I have held numerous bilateral meetings with the heads of state or government of allied countries. Specifically, I met with the German Chancellor, the British Prime Minister, the Italian Prime Minister, the President of the French Republic, the Portuguese Prime Minister, and also with the Presidents of the Commission and the European Council, Mr. Barroso and Mr. Van Rompuy.

I leave reasonably satisfied, not only for seeing Spain's initial position improved but, above all, for having observed a very constructive spirit on the part of our partners in the European Union. I believe this is good for Europe, and I have the feeling that things have been done well this time.

As you know, the Multiannual Financial Framework will take effect starting in 2014, so we have time, and, more importantly, I note that there is political will to continue working. In the coming weeks, we will continue with the negotiations, and I am convinced that we will soon achieve a satisfactory result.

Spain has defended, as is natural, its interests, and it has done so as what we are, a great country of the European Union; but it has also wanted to take into account, as is also natural, necessary, and reasonable in these cases, the interests and opinions of all others and, above all, those of the entire European Union.

From there, I am at your disposal for any questions you may have.

Q.- President, I would like to ask you about the transitional regions. Right now, is the last proposal from Van Rompuy still on the table?

President.- I have listened to you very attentively, and I am absolutely convinced that everyone present has as well; but, in any case, if you want to repeat the question, please do so.

Q.- I wanted to clarify. There are about 1.55 billion for the transitional regions, and I would like to know if that is still on the table and if it will continue to be studied according to that figure.

Second, regarding the common front for the CAP, I want to know what alliances you have made with other countries.

President.- Regarding the first question, the proposal that is on the table today is the one that Mr. Van Rompuy made yesterday, and you already know it because I have seen it published in various media, Mr. Van Rompuy. That is the proposal that exists.

From there, the different countries have made our proposals; now we have had a conversation, a meeting, since twelve noon, and it is expected that, from now on, a series of bilateral meetings will take place over the next few days, and Mr. Van Rompuy will make a proposal—I suppose it will be sometime in January—to try to close it afterwards.

Therefore, at this moment, there is what there was yesterday; but I insist, everyone has made their proposals on that, and logically, we will continue talking with the aim of reaching an agreement.

In yesterday's proposal, which Mr. Van Rompuy presented, there were things that were important to us: Ceuta; Melilla; better treatment for the outermost regions, which in our case is the Canary Islands; improvements for the situation of the regions, and above all, the creation of a fund that is in that initial proposal of 2.8 billion euros, which, logically, fully satisfies us.

But I insist, until there is an agreement, all there are are proposals, which can be modified. At this moment, the proposal that is in force is that one, and at the appropriate time, there will be an agreement after the conversations that take place.

Regarding the CAP, in principle, the proposal has been made jointly by the President of the French Republic, Mr. Hollande, and myself; the Irish President has joined, and then what I have tried to do is talk with those countries that might have a lesser interest. And I have had a conversation on this matter with the British Prime Minister and the Dutch Prime Minister, who have received it sympathetically. From there, the conversations will continue.

As you know, for us, agricultural policy is very important. Agriculture has great economic importance, but it also has enormous social significance. Agriculture, the environment, keeps the population in rural areas, it is our towns, it is our history… It has great value, and moreover, today the agri-food industry is growing a lot, and exports are increasing significantly. As you know, Spain has been improving its exports recently. In fact, the trade deficit is now positive with the eurozone, something that has never happened before, and the Spanish agri-food industry plays a major role in that.

Therefore, this issue matters to us; it also matters to France, as everyone knows, and the goal is to gather friends for the cause.

Q.- President, I wanted to ask you about figures. In yesterday's proposal from Mr. Van Rompuy, it seems that there is a smaller cut in agriculture and in cohesion funds. Right now, what is Spain's new proposal with that common front with France and Ireland?

President.- Mr. Van Rompuy's proposal is the one that is on the table. It is true that yesterday's proposal is better than the one that was before, and on that basis, we will continue discussing.

Q.- President, I don't know if you are the only one who leaves satisfied, if your satisfaction is shared by your colleagues, and if you have been able to notice it at the end of the meeting.

What I would also like to know is if you are concerned that there are so many countries, basically those that pay more than they receive, that demand cuts of nearly thirty billion.

President.- In general, yes; and, in fact, a statement has been agreed upon, which I suppose is the statement that the President of the European Council, Mr. Van Rompuy, has made known to the public, where everyone praised the constructive spirit with which everyone acted and the fact that there have been approaches in positions.

Really, I tell you this with absolute frankness because, moreover, there was no reason for it not to happen: just think, twenty-seven countries negotiating over euros, you will understand that it is certainly not an easy thing, and I said: after some things we know, this is going to be a very complicated matter. I have been pleasantly surprised, and if you want me to tell you more, I will say that I am very happy to have been pleasantly surprised.

From there, you say that there are some countries that are net contributors who want the budget to be reduced. They have said that, and it is their position, but there are others who have other positions, and here the goal is for the approaches to continue.

I tell you, I am optimistic that the details are being polished, which are what ultimately lead to a paper that we all accept; but there are positions… Just think, among twenty-seven, what would be truly remarkable is if we all thought the same. But this is negotiation. What is negotiation? It is talking, dialoguing, listening, attending to the other, seeing what their reasons are, their arguments, being firm in principles and prioritizing, but also being flexible. That is negotiation.

Everything I have told you is pure common sense, but believe me, it is like that; at least, I see it that way.

Q.- President, today you should be in Catalonia for the end of the electoral campaign, and I apologize if you don't mind me asking about that. Today the report has finally been published by the Police on which the information from "El Mundo" was based. What is your opinion on that? It is a report that the Ministry of the Interior had not disclosed until now, and yet it has now been made public.

President.- I do not… Please do not take it as a discourtesy; I beg you, because it is not; but I will no longer contribute to this spectacle. Allow me not to contribute any further to this. We are here with very important issues, talking about the general interests of Spaniards, and allow me not to enter into this matter.

Q.- President, I know it is very difficult to talk about figures because everything is very open; but we entered here with a threat of losing twenty billion euros in aid. You have said that we are leaving better than we came. Has the Government made calculations on where the figures would stand right now?

President.- As you have very well said, it is very difficult to talk about figures. Put yourself in my place: if it is very difficult for everyone, for me, who must be more prudent, it is much more difficult.

Keep that idea that you have expressed very well and that reflects what has happened, and my good impression derives in part from that.

Q.- President, I would like to know, in the battle of yesterday and today, where the real big problems have been; if they have been the United Kingdom and the "British cheque," if it has been that common front of the northern countries that wanted more cuts, and if this last proposal from Van Rompuy is one that Spain would have signed or if it remains unacceptable, like the first one he made for Spain.

A second question. Have you thought about or decided whether you will attend Oslo to collect the Nobel Peace Prize, since Durao Barroso has invited all heads of state?

President.- The second is the easiest to answer: yes, I will be there, God willing, on the 10th in Oslo to collect the Nobel Peace Prize. I believe it is good for the largest number of leaders and political leaders of the Union to be there because I also believe that it is a rightly awarded prize. The European Union signs its Treaty of Rome, although, as you know very well, there were precedents in 1957, and I always say: compare the 55 years following 1957 and the 55 years before. That is why we always say: when we entered Europe, we entered a space of peace, first, and then of democratic coexistence, prosperity, and progress. Therefore, I will be there in Oslo.

Regarding the problems and the unacceptable… as I said before, it is better. I believe this proposal is better.

Where are the problems? You know very well because you publish them regularly: there are those who want the budget to be higher, there are those who want it to be lower; there are those who want their cheque, there are those who want not to have it; there are more supporters of cohesion policies, others more in agriculture… All the policies of the Union seem better to some and less good to others, and everyone has their priorities.

So, the goal is to make a policy that serves the general interest and reflects everyone. Although it is very difficult to be absolutely objective, since all heads of government, logically, have their own national interests, as is natural, from there we can build positively for the benefit of all.

All attitudes have been good. There has been no word or statement out of tone in any of the meetings. It has been very constructive, believe me when I say this, and it is true.

Q.- President, has there been any specific point where the debate has stalled and that has caused the postponement to a new Summit, which, in addition, I would like to know if it already has a date: if it will be at the end of January or in February?

President.- It does not have a date, but the dates will be those you just referred to, although there is no set day. And there has been no specific point that has led to that blockage.

Think about how things developed yesterday and today. Yesterday, the President of the Council, Mr. Van Rompuy, along with the President of the Commission, had twenty-seven bilateral meetings; that is, he met with all the heads of government and state who were here at the meeting. From there, he prepared a new document, and that new document was subject to a very general analysis in the meeting we had today. Apart from that, each country has submitted in writing, through the procedures it deemed appropriate and convenient, its opinions.

Today a general approach has been given. I believe there has been an approach of positions, and that is seen, above all, in the bilateral meetings; but those processes of rapprochement must continue. And then there are also the details. Think that it is very difficult because each country may have some specific, small issues. Of course, we are twenty-seven. It is very difficult, even, to put a new paper on the table after the one that was put yesterday.

P.- Mr. President, the Eurogroup will meet tomorrow and on Monday to discuss another issue that is important for Spain, which is reaching an agreement to finance Greece. I wanted to know what the Government's position is on the possibility of reducing interest rates on loans to Greece, whether Spain will ask for compensation, whether the rates would be lower than those with which it is financed, and whether you believe there will be an agreement.

President.- I agree with what you say, that this is important for Spain; but, if you allow me, it is more important for Europe than for Spain. Therefore, what Spain wants is for the issue of Greece to be resolved as quickly as possible, that is, next week.

Greece has fulfilled all its commitments, and the "troika" has certified this. People have suffered a lot in Greece over these months, the Government is making a great effort, and, of course, I am in favor of resolving this issue this week.

As for the formula that will be used, whether it is a reduction in the interest rates that Greece owes to the other countries of the European Union or something else, that is still not settled. The only thing I can say is that Spain's position is to help Greece, because we believe in a European project, we believe in the euro, and we believe that Greece is a country that is making a great effort and, therefore, deserves that we all give it a chance. Helping Greece is an unequivocal demonstration of our commitment to the European project, and Spain will certainly do so.

P.- Mr. President, I don't know if you have already decided whether pensions will be updated based on inflation and how you think the European Commission would react to an increase in spending at this time.

President.- The European Commission, in its latest report, which, as you very well know, was presented by the Commissioner for Economic Affairs, Mr. Rehn, a few days ago, has said that Spain is doing well in meeting its public deficit targets and, therefore, has no recommendations to make, neither for 2012 nor for 2013.

From there, this is a matter that, as soon as the time comes, when we know exactly what the CPI figure is, at the end of November or in the first half of December, we will make a decision. In any case, as you also know, next year pensions will be the only item in the Budget that will increase; moreover, unfortunately, debt interest will also rise. These will be the only two items that will increase, and, of course, within the economic difficulties and the control of the deficit, and we have always said this, the priority is to defend those who are least able to defend themselves, precisely because of the circumstances that are inherent and well-known to a pensioner.

P.- Mr. President, regarding today's negotiation, I believe that, above all, Cameron has persistently requested a reduction in the salaries of Brussels officials. There are even those who have pointed to you as an example of a president who earns much less or the same as many Brussels officials. I wanted to know what you think about that.

President.- There have been... Yes, these things happen. I, of course, believe that a public official is a person who performs a very important function, I also believe that there are magnificent officials, and, as in any aspect of life, there will be all kinds, just as there are among politicians, members of the Popular Party, or you, the journalists. There will be all kinds, right?

From there, I am not going to go into details because, whatever I say, it will be used against me.

P.- You seemed to assume that Mr. Van Rompuy's latest proposal is the one on the table. Some believe that until there is an agreement on everything, there is no agreement on anything. Mr. Van Rompuy himself has suggested in his speech that there could be a review of the spending ceiling proposed at this Council to reach an agreement, which would obviously imply reducing certain items.

I wanted to ask you if you trust that this latest offer will be maintained. We know that there has been a very clear offer regarding the Cohesion Fund, and we do not know what response has been given to the proposal made by Mr. Hollande and yourself regarding agricultural aid funds, and if, really, as you were asked earlier, you would have signed today if that had been maintained.

And, if you allow me, just to finish, there are elections in Catalonia on Sunday. Let's hope to give you time to reach the end of the campaign. In any case, these elections are being framed as a plebiscite on President Mas's sovereignty proposal. I wanted to know if you share this diagnosis and what interpretation you think should be made of the results that occur in Catalonia on Sunday.

President.- You are asking me, which is the classic question, what would happen in the event that an event occurred or did not occur. You will understand that I am not here to make analyses; I am here to set positions on issues.

It is true, everyone knows it, and they have made it public, that there are people who want the total amount of the Budget to be reduced and others who want to improve agricultural items. That is to say, the positions are there and are known.

But what I can tell you, reiterating what I pointed out earlier, is that there are approaches. I see that there are approaches; I see it, especially in bilateral meetings, and that seems important to me. And I believe that what is now lacking is for those approaches to occur with increasing intensity and, then, those small details that are typical of the end of any negotiation.

Whether I would have signed or not signed... As you very well pointed out, until everything is on the table, nothing is approved. Spain's positions are more or less known, but, of course, I cannot go into a negotiation or a meeting saying: if you do not give me this, then I will veto. That is not reasonable because, if another person tells me exactly the opposite and also vetoes, then the agreement is already impossible. Negotiation is still an art, and therefore, one must try to do it in the best possible way.

Regarding the issue of Catalonia, my position is also known. I have always said that it made no sense to hold these elections, because there were still two years left until the end of the mandate. I believe that the priority at this moment, in Catalonia and in Spain, is to fight against the crisis, to work to create jobs and generate economic growth, and I think that is what a majority of people think. What does not make sense is to bring elections forward by two years, to waste time that could be very important for working towards economic recovery, to create a great division, and, in the end, I do not know what all this will serve.

My position, on the other hand, is clear: we live in a global world. Look, now we are here, in Europe, talking about budgets that affect Spaniards. There are large organizations all over the world, and in the European Union, we are there for many reasons, and one of them is because Europe is a large and important actor in the world. The larger we are in the European Union and the larger Spain is, the better it will be for us and the better we will defend our positions. Therefore, I believe that these processes are processes from other times in history and that the world no longer goes that way.

From there, we have done many things together throughout our history, we are united by ties of all kinds, but of all kinds, even of people who went there from other places in Spain, people who left and people who returned, and all this seems to me to make very little sense.

However, what do I hope? That common sense and reason return because, if not, things are going to be very complicated.

Ladies and gentlemen, I have to go. Thank you very much.