Press conference of the Prime Minister after the European Council meeting.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

23 October 2014 · Press conference after the European Council meeting

Context
Rajoy addressed press after the October 2014 European Council meeting, outlining decisions on climate targets and Spain's energy interconnection gains.
Main themes
EU climate and energy framework 2030, energy interconnections for Spain and Portugal, European Commission appointment, greenhouse gas emission reduction targets, renewable energy targets, energy efficiency targets, Iberian Peninsula energy isolation, EU leadership on climate change, Lima and Paris climate conferences, internal energy market, Jean-Claude Juncker Commission
Duration
~36 min
88th percentile
Words
4,366
88th percentile
Sentences
172
85th percentile
Readability
44
46th percentile
Grade
13.1
58th percentile
Syntax
3.24
76th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
27th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

172 sentences in 70 paragraphs

President.- Ladies and gentlemen, good afternoon and thank you very much for your attendance at this meeting.

As you know, this European Council in October has been the last in which Herman Van Rompuy and José Manuel Durão Barroso have participated as Presidents of the Council and the Commission, respectively. I want to begin this speech by thanking both for their work during their mandate. In very difficult times, they have managed to navigate obstacles and face the challenges that have occupied the European agenda in recent years. Under their leadership, the European Union has made very significant progress in its integration process. Both have been great friends of Spain, and I wish them all the best.

We have proceeded, as stipulated by the Treaties of the European Union, to appoint the new European Commission following the approval vote by the European Parliament last Wednesday. This Commission is born with reinforced democratic legitimacy. For the first time, its President had to be proposed in accordance with the democratic outcome of the elections to the European Parliament. This Parliament has ratified it, approving the new Commission by a wide majority: 423 in favor, 209 against, and 67 abstentions. It has also received the agreement of the two main European political groups: the People's Party and the Socialist Party.

Welcome, then, to the new Commission and its President Jean-Claude Juncker. He has a very important responsibility ahead, but he has surrounded himself with an excellent team, to which Spain, by the way, has contributed an excellent Commissioner for Climate Action and Energy, two of the most important challenges of the present and future for Spain, for Europe, and for the world. I wish them good luck, and they can count on my Government's support from now on.

In line with this new political cycle, this European Council constitutes a first political step of great importance, as it sets the strategic lines that the new Commission must follow starting on November 1. Indeed, the main outcome of this European Council has been the decisions made regarding the framework for energy and climate action until 2030.

First, this European Council has established the position of the European Union for the upcoming Conferences in Lima and Paris, organized by the United Nations for Climate Change, where an agreement on greenhouse gas emission reductions is sought. Specifically, we have agreed on a European target for 2030 of reducing emissions by at least 40 percent compared to 2005 levels; a European target for renewable energy participation of at least 27 percent, mandatory at the level of the European Union; and a European target for improving energy efficiency of at least 27 percent. This target is indicative.

With these decisions, Europe assumes clear global leadership in climate change and sustainable growth ahead of the upcoming international meetings. Spain is satisfied with these objectives.

Secondly, and this is very important, this European Council has also made very positive decisions, particularly for Spain. When this debate began for this European Council in June of this year, only climate issues were raised. Spain sent a high-level delegation and highlighted that the issue of interconnections was crucial for satisfactorily resolving these issues. It was achieved that this topic became the central element of the discussion on the Internal Energy Market, and all of this is reflected in the decisions made, which I will now comment on.

First decision: this Council, for the first time, has recognized that the most isolated areas of the internal energy market, such as the Iberian Peninsula, face additional difficulties in meeting environmental objectives. Therefore, the conclusions recognize that to meet the Union's renewable objectives, member states may set their planning based on their degree of interconnection. This is the first time that this relationship between interconnection and environmental ambition has been established in the conclusions of a European Council.

Second decision: Spain receives compensation to address the differential costs due to low interconnection. This compensation will be made effective through a greater allocation of emission rights.

And third decision, and this is very important because it unlocks a situation that has been stagnant since 2002: for the first time, concrete steps are being taken to resolve the lack of interconnection of isolated member states, specifically mentioning Spain and Portugal. These steps are:

1. The European institutions are directly involved, as it is recognized that isolation is a European problem and not a bilateral one. Specifically, the Commission will take urgent measures to ensure a minimum interconnection of 10 percent by 2020 and will oversee the process. Additionally, it will regularly inform the European Council with the aim of reaching 15 percent interconnection by 2030.

2. Concrete interconnection projects for the Iberian Peninsula are being promoted.

- Maximum priority is given to projects already underway to be completed by 2020 at the latest, including two projects between Spain and France, one for gas and one for electricity.

- The strategy agreed upon by the transmission network managers to develop the interconnection of the Peninsula is adopted and its execution is urged. This strategy includes three new electrical interconnection projects.

- Additional projects necessary to achieve the 10 percent interconnection will be prioritized and executed quickly.

- And, above all, the Commission is involved in the monitoring and implementation of these projects to achieve the set objective.

3. Regarding financing, we have asked the Commission to present concrete proposals to the European Council to ensure the financing of these projects.

All these decisions and steps that I have just outlined place interconnection between member states, particularly of the Iberian Peninsula, at the center of European energy policy. Likewise, they make interconnections a priority issue for achieving the Internal Energy Market. This is the first time this has happened, and therefore, I leave satisfied.

I now turn to economic issues. In addition to the 2030 framework, at this European Council, and subsequently at the eurozone leaders' meeting, we have discussed the economic situation in Europe and how to intensify growth and job creation.

Spain, after a very difficult period, which you are all well aware of, and after significant reforms in its economy, is growing and creating jobs. The latest data corroborates this. The EPA for the third quarter confirms the trend of the last year of job creation and reduction of unemployment. The largest drop in unemployment in a third quarter since statistics have been kept has occurred: 195,200 people. In the last year, unemployment has fallen by more than half a million people: exactly 517,500. The job creation figure is also very good: the number of employed has increased, and in the last year, it has risen by 274,000 people.

And yesterday, the Bank of Spain also anticipated that growth for the third quarter of this year would be 0.5 percent, in line with the Government's forecasts. Thus, the fifth consecutive quarter of economic growth is confirmed.

That said, you also know that growth in the European Union, our main trading partner, is weakening, and that is not good; it is not good for them, but it is also not good for Spain. Therefore, at this Council, we have promoted measures that stimulate employment, growth, and competitiveness, in line with the Strategic Agenda we agreed upon in June and with the leadership of the new Commission. Specifically, we have supported the initiative of the new President, Mr. Juncker, to mobilize three hundred billion euros in public and private investments over the next three years, and we have also supported the concrete steps that are already being taken to identify projects by December of this year.

Spain is already working to define its projects; an interministerial working group is already underway for this. Additionally, as you will recall, we approved in June of this year a plan of measures for growth, competitiveness, and efficiency that made the most of the available resources, especially European funds. The objective of this plan was precisely to intensify the recovery through public and private investment initiatives, and therefore, these are measures that fit into the Juncker initiative. Furthermore, we want to leverage this initiative to finance energy interconnections in line with the results of this Council.

I now turn to international matters. Discussions on these issues have focused on two matters: the Ebola crisis and the situation in Ukraine.

Regarding Ebola, I want to remind you that this issue was already introduced into the agenda of the European Council in August, at Spain's initiative. The Ebola epidemic represents a first-order health emergency, affecting the health of thousands of people and having a direct impact on the politics, economy, and security of our African neighbors.

To address the current crisis, in addition to taking appropriate measures in each of our countries and at the European level, it is essential to tackle the problem on the ground in the countries directly affected. Under the leadership of the United Nations, at this European Council, we have agreed to strengthen our coordination and increase our financial and health efforts. In this regard, we have appointed the Commissioner for Humanitarian Aid and Crisis Management, Christos Stylianides, as the European coordinator for Ebola.

On the financial front, the European Union and its member states had already committed around six hundred million euros, and we have now agreed to increase our effort to one billion.

Regarding Ukraine, the European Council has reiterated that the key is to reach a political solution based on respect for Ukraine's territorial integrity and sovereignty. The national legislative elections next Sunday are a relevant milestone in the necessary process of political and economic reforms that must be undertaken in Ukraine without fail.

Likewise, the member states have made it crystal clear that the electoral call by the self-proclaimed authorities of Donetsk and Lugansk has no value and that its result will not be recognized, as it is illegal.

In summary, I leave this Council very satisfied. We have managed to make the issue of interconnections a priority for the European Union and concrete commitments to resolve this issue that has been blocked for too long. This not only addresses a just claim from Spain and Portugal but also lays the foundations for an energy union in Europe, which will provide safer, cleaner, and more affordable energy for citizens and businesses.

Thank you very much for your attention. I am at your disposal.

Q.- President, you had a long conversation with Mr. Draghi, and I wanted to ask what Mr. Draghi has asked of you. What position has the Spanish Government maintained regarding the economic situation, and what can the European Central Bank do? Do you already know if there is any Spanish bank that will fail the "stress tests"?

On national issues, in the same week, Mr. Rato has left the party, Mr. Acebes has been indicted, a new ruling has come out regarding a supposed off-the-books payment at the PP headquarters of 1.7 million euros... I wanted to ask you, in addition to the respect for Justice that you always promote and to which you are obliged, what do you say to citizens who may be overwhelmed by this wave of news?

President.- Indeed, as President of the Government, I must be especially prudent and express my respect for the decisions that Justice may take. What we are currently doing is taking all measures to prevent these events from occurring in the future, and I hope that they never happen again, through the package we have presented in the Cortes of legislative reforms and, in addition, taking all those decisions so that all these things that have happened are known and to help Justice act, punishing the guilty and recognizing those who are innocent.

Regarding the "stress tests," as you know, we will not have knowledge of what has happened until next Sunday, but I firmly believe that all the decisions the Government has made to restructure our financial system have been effective and useful, and therefore, the Spanish financial system is sound. I do not know if there will be any problems with any entity or not, but until Sunday... I certainly do not have any data at this moment.

As you know, it was not easy. We have been in Government for nearly three years, and the financial system, in a very substantial part, was literally broken. We were forced to request a loan from the European Union and had to nationalize three banks; but I believe that this effort, which has involved a restructuring like never before in our Spanish financial system, is very useful. You cannot have an economy that grows and creates jobs without a financial system that is sound and provides credit, and I believe we have already taken many steps in the right direction.

Regarding my position on economic policy, I have stated, first, that Spain, and I believe that other European countries that need to do so should also continue with their process of fiscal consolidation. One cannot live permanently and indefinitely spending more than one earns, because that ultimately leads to the bankruptcy of a family, a company, or a state, as we have unfortunately seen in the European Union in recent times.

Secondly, I have pointed out the need for structural reforms. Spain has made many structural reforms, and everyone recognizes this. And I believe that if today we can talk about an Active Population Survey like the one we saw yesterday or if today Spain is at the forefront of growth in the European Union, it is fundamentally due to the structural reforms we have made and the effort of acceptance that the Spanish people have made, knowing the very difficult situation from which we started.

Thirdly, I have indicated in my speech that the reforms must also be European and that Europe needs an Internal Energy Market, a single energy market, and that is why I have talked about interconnections; a single digital market and a single market in services.

Fourthly, I have spoken about the process of European integration, which must be expedited. We have made significant progress in Banking Union, but Fiscal Union and Political Union are still pending.

Finally, which is the fifth point of the economic policy we have maintained since the beginning of the Legislature, I have said that inflation at this moment in the European Union is 0.3 percent and that the inflation target set by the European Union is 2 percent or a little below 2 percent. I have said that I am absolutely convinced that the European Central Bank will know what to do to keep that inflation between 1.5 and 2 percent, which I believe is where it should be, and I think that would also help growth and employment. But the European Bank is independent; it is the one that has to make the decisions; it has made some very good ones in recent times, and for inflation to be in a situation of normality, it knows better than anyone—the Central Bank, I mean—what it has to do in the future.

Q.- Mr. President, yesterday you offered Spain as a platform for the redistribution of gas in Europe and to help reduce the dependence of Eastern countries on Russian gas. Do you think that with the measures approved today or with the projects that will be promoted, this objective can be achieved? Has this proposal been well received among the other partners or in the East?

President.- This is a topic on which I will not deviate from what I believe I must do, which is to provide you with the most objective information. This is a crucial issue. That is to say, if Europe is working, and has been doing so for a long time, towards the creation of a single market, it is evident that at this moment we cannot talk about a single market in energy, plain and simple, because Spain and Portugal are energy islands. Therefore, out of respect for what the European Union itself is or one of its great objectives—the free movement of goods, people, capital, and services—it is evident that we must advance in this.

Secondly, a political situation has now arisen, which is the issue of gas. If there were electricity interconnections, but in this case, I also speak of gas, it is evident that Europe would have more possibilities and more places to go to buy gas. At this moment, approximately 25 percent of gas comes from Russia and another 25 percent comes from Norway, which are the largest gas suppliers in the European space. We do not receive gas, as you know, from Norway or Russia; we receive it from Algeria.

I believe it would be very important to advance in this. But I think that would also be very positive for the African continent because, if we could have good gas and electricity interconnections, logically that would be good for Algeria; but it would be good for Algeria, for Morocco, or for Tunisia, because important investments could be made there in solar thermal and photovoltaic energy, and then sent to Europe through the interconnections.

Therefore, I believe this is an operation that is good for everyone: it is good, of course, for Spain, which is, logically, what I should be most concerned about; it is good for Portugal, with whom we have worked hand in hand, who have also made a great effort in this Council in this whole project, and I must thank them for their commitment to make this happen and the mutual support we have given each other; but it is also good for the whole of the European Union and for the African continent.

This is a step in the right direction. There is something very important, which is that for the first time the Commission is involved. Previously, this was a bilateral issue; now it is not. The Commission has a mandate to take care of and be concerned about this matter, and the Energy Commissioner, appointed by Mr. Juncker, is a commissioner who knows the issues well and I am absolutely convinced that, in defense of European interests, he will fight this battle.

Q.- I wanted to revisit a previous question. I wanted to ask you what feeling you are left with when, I don’t know if it has been in ten days, bank cards, a son of Pujol detained, and Mr. Acebes, also a member of your previous Government and a strong man of the Popular Party, indicted… I don’t know if you can tell us what feeling you are left with.

Then, regarding the works at the headquarters of the Popular Party, I don’t know if you can tell us more about what happened there.

President.- Look, the only feeling I have is a firm will to make all the decisions to prevent these events from occurring in the future, and that is why I have presented a package of laws in Parliament; and, secondly, I have another feeling, which is to help Justice to bring these issues to light, punish the guilty, and recognize the innocent.

Q.- Mr. President, I wanted to know your assessment of the latest steps taken by the president of the Generalitat to hold a consultation on November 9; specifically, regarding the information campaign that he has now also called for that consultation.

I also wanted to know if the Government can guarantee that on that day, November 9, there will not be a consultation with ballot boxes and questions about the independence of Catalonia.

President.- As you and all of you know, the basic obligation of the Government, not just the Government of Spain but any Government anywhere in the world, is to ensure respect for the rule of law and compliance with the law. A territory where the rule of law is not respected and where the law is violated, especially by the authorities, is evidently not a healthy democracy, as we want our country to be.

For that reason, we have appealed to the Constitutional Court regarding the Consultation Law of the Parliament of Catalonia and the decree of convocation, and the Constitutional Court, which is the one that determines whether that law or that decree complies with legality, ordered the suspension of the consultation.

That is a very important fact, and I always tell you: let’s go for the big one. The big one is that the referendum announced on December 12, 2013, will not be held, and it will not be held because the Constitutional Court has said so after the Government fulfilled its duty. The Government could not have done anything other than ensure that this is truly a rule of law and that the law is complied with.

From there, since that referendum cannot be held, they intend to hold a participation process—which is what they call it, and that is why I use that expression—without any democratic guarantees. It is something that has no precedent in our country. If you analyze the history of our country, there is no precedent for wanting to hold a process without any democratic guarantees: without a prior census and in which the supporters of one position provide the ballots, collect them, count them, and safeguard them. That is to say, they intend to replace an illegal procedure with an even more undemocratic procedure. Furthermore, to evade their responsibility, they shift it onto the officials and citizens, to whom they refuse to give written instructions.

Well, since the Government of Spain has to ensure that the law is complied with and since the Government of Spain has to comply with the law, we also have another obligation, which is to safeguard the rights of citizens in any circumstance and, in this case, to safeguard the rights of the citizens of Catalonia. That is why I have instructed the legal services of the State to analyze in depth each and every one of the actions of the Generalitat for the implementation of this consultation.

And you can be absolutely certain that, as I did when the illegal referendum was prevented, if there is the slightest violation of the law, we will go to the courts and, even, we will go back to the Constitutional Court.

But, I insist, there are no precedents in the democratic history of our country where an attempt is made to organize a process of these characteristics without any guarantees, undemocratic. The presidents of the electoral tables, if they can be called that, are people appointed by those who want to and are organizing a referendum illegally. There is no census, it is not known what will happen with the ballots, it is not known what guarantees there are for the result… Frankly, I believe that the Catalan citizens and all Spaniards do not deserve this.

Above all, it is certainly a drama that, when I have been here for two days hearing about more Banking Union, more European integration, moving towards a single budget, that we need to be big and that we need to be strong and that the European Union must occupy a place in the world…; it is certainly ironic that in some place in Europe there are some who are trying to provoke a process of exit from Europe and a journey back to the Middle Ages. Really, it is unacceptable, and the citizens of Catalonia and the rest of Spain do not deserve that.

Q.- Mr. President, following up on this response, I would like to know: in the event that this participatory process ultimately leads, more than to a consultation as such, to a mobilization, to a concentration, do you also believe that it can be declared illegal? That is to say, to what extent do you separate the line between what is a consultation, a participation process, or a mobilization, as there have been others, or a demonstration, so to speak, if it ultimately ends up becoming that?

President.- I will tell you one thing: when the holding of the referendum was announced, I was often asked: what will happen if…? What will happen in the event of what…? All I said, on the same day, December 12, 2013, was: this referendum will not be held. And that referendum was not held.

You can be absolutely certain that Spain is a country in which the law is complied with, and the duty of the president of the Government, his obligation, is to guarantee that it is complied with.

Q.- In your response about Catalonia, you said that the Catalans do not deserve this, but there have been large demonstrations by Catalans asking for a referendum. At what point would the Spanish Government be willing to discuss the possibility of a referendum that could have a census, as you requested, democracy, and democratic guarantees?

President.- When the law is complied with, exactly at that moment. That is to say, when a project for constitutional reform is presented by whoever wants to do so, stating "we want sovereignty not to belong to the Spanish people" and the Spanish people as a whole say whether they want sovereignty not to belong to them or not.

That is to say, the law and compliance with the law, and the procedures established by the law, is something that in advanced democracies, like ours, cannot be disregarded in any way. We, in 1978, all Spaniards established rules of the game and norms of coexistence, and everyone voted on them. And one of the key issues was the recognition of national sovereignty. That is to say, what Spain is, is decided by all Spaniards.

I am from Santiago de Compostela, and I believe that what Santiago de Compostela is should be decided by all Spaniards, not just the neighbors of that area. That is national sovereignty, a basic principle of political law and, if you allow me, of common sense. That is what gives meaning to all the nations that exist today. That is what is attempted to be concealed from all the citizens of Catalonia.

The right to decide what a country is belongs to all those who live in that country.

Thank you very much.