Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

27 October 2014 · Parliamentary control session (Spanish Congress of Deputies)

Context
Rajoy addressed the Spanish Parliament on October 27, 2014, responding to questions on social inequality and corruption scandals during a parliamentary control session.
Main themes
Political corruption and accountability, social inequality and poverty, unemployment and economic crisis, anti-corruption reforms, rule of law, economic recovery, political party integrity, child poverty, youth emigration, parliamentary oversight
Duration
~54 min
95th percentile
Words
6,492
95th percentile
Sentences
245
93rd percentile
Readability
46
51st percentile
Grade
13.0
56th percentile
Syntax
3.20
73rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
41st percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 53%52%
  • Economic 14%14%
  • Social 12%12%
  • Geopolitical 12%11%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

245 sentences in 88 paragraphs

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Ms. María Victoria Chivite, of the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Ms. Chivite.- Mr. Rajoy, since you have been governing in Spain, there are two and a half million people at risk of social exclusion, three out of ten children are at risk of poverty, 200,000 people with disabilities receive no assistance, 740,000 Spanish households have no income, three million unemployed have no type of benefit, and 400,000 young people have left Spain because they had no opportunity. In light of this, Mr. Rajoy, does your Government plan to take any measures to address the inequality, the social gap that exists between Spanish citizens?

President.- Ms. Chivite, before addressing the issue you raise, allow me to make a reference to the corruption matters that have come to light in recent days. I want to say three things about this to the entire Chamber and to all Spaniards.

First, I fully understand and share the indignation of so many Spaniards at the accumulation of scandals. The latest one we have learned about, with the information we have so far, seems to respond to the personal greed of the public officials involved and not to the political organizations to which they belong or belonged. As for the individuals who are part of my party, they are already suspended from membership, and if the charges are confirmed, they will be expelled. But, in any case, I deeply regret the situation created and on behalf of the Popular Party, I want to apologize to all Spaniards for having placed in positions unworthy of them those who have apparently abused them.

Secondly, I not only perfectly understand the justified anger of citizens, but I also share their indignation and their weariness. These behaviors are particularly hurtful when Spaniards have had to face so many sacrifices and make so many efforts to pull our country out of the crisis. Moreover, these behaviors cast a shadow of widespread suspicion over the actions of all politicians, and while I understand this, I want to once again say here that this stain unjustly tarnishes the image and reputation of the majority of people from all parties who are in politics to serve others and not to serve themselves.

Thirdly, I want, as President of the Government, to say that it is not only my duty to condemn these facts but also to act to prevent them. In this regard, I remind you of some of the reforms we have already promoted that are unprecedented in Spain: we have mandated the publication of all salaries, subsidies, and contracts of the Administration, as well as requiring all high-ranking officials to declare their assets and property at the beginning and end of their term; we have proposed prohibiting donations from companies to political parties and allowing banks to forgive the debts of political formations; and we have proposed to toughen penalties for prevarication and expand the cases for the crime of influence peddling.

We will continue to expand the range of anti-corruption measures until we ensure that any public official in this country thinks twice before succumbing to the temptation to corrupt themselves.

Democracy cannot allow anyone to play with the trust that citizens place in those who administer them. That is why we have been negotiating with the opposition two important legislative projects to combat corruption: the Statute of High Officials and the Law on the Control of the Economic and Financial Activity of Political Parties. Of course, we will not delay for a single minute the approval of this package of reforms. I announce to you that, if it is with the agreement of the opposition, better, and if not, we will push these measures forward with the votes of the Popular Party.

I would like to add a final consideration: if these cases of corruption are being investigated, pursued, and judged, it is because the rule of law works; because the Tax Agency, the State Security Forces, and the Prosecutor's Office work, and also because an independent judiciary works. I ask everyone to trust in that rule of law and to be assured that our commitment to the cleanliness of public life is total.

Thank you very much.

Ms. Chivite, we have already taken many measures and we intend to continue doing so in the future. The objective of this Legislature has always been, and continues to be, to overcome the crisis and combat its consequences. That is why growth, job creation, and correcting inequalities are basic priorities of all our policies.

In fact, the policies that have been implemented this Legislature are beginning to yield results: Spain has been growing for five consecutive quarters, after many years of negative growth; net employment is being created in Spain, specifically in this last year unemployment has been reduced by more than five hundred thousand people, and for the first time in many years, the indicators used by international organizations to measure inequality and poverty are beginning to decline for the first time in 2013, already signaling the start of a change in trend.

Mr. Chivite.- Mr. Rajoy, you have rejected eight requests for appearances in Congress. Today we have asked for another appearance; you have the opportunity to go next week, to appear in Congress and provide explanations, and to provide explanations about the envelopes, and to provide explanations about the messages you sent to Bárcenas, and to provide explanations about the B financing of your party, and to provide explanations to all Spaniards about how many high-ranking officials of your party will again parade through the courts with accounts in Switzerland. That is what you must explain in the Congress of Deputies.

And to the point. You, Mr. Rajoy, instead of combating inequality, consolidate it, and you consolidate it in each of your political actions, and you consolidate it Budget after Budget and Law after Law, and you are bringing many Spanish citizens to the brink of the abyss. You are the political version of the type with the stamp, because you are consolidating the lie as a way of doing politics. You have deceived all the groups in Spain.

By the way, regarding the data: today Cáritas warns that only 34 percent of the population is not affected by social exclusion; the number of poor children has increased by eight hundred thousand in Spain, Spanish families are taking a great leap backward of ten years. These are the data, Mr. Rajoy, these are the data.

You have deceived pensioners, impoverishing them with copayments; you have deceived the unemployed, taking away any type of benefit from three million unemployed; you have deceived all Spanish citizens by saying that you would protect our healthcare and you have cut 7.5 billion from our healthcare, and you have deceived all Spaniards on the issue of taxes. Do you remember when you collected signatures against the VAT increase? Well, that is how you have deceived Spaniards.

In the face of the serious situation that Spain is experiencing, Mr. Rajoy offers more inequality, more unemployment, and more poverty in your Budgets for the year 2015, where, far from solving the problems of Spaniards, you favor 10 percent of the population and forget about 90 percent of the population.

We socialists have proposed solutions to you, Mr. President. We have proposed a financial rescue for families and for the self-employed; we have proposed to rescue five hundred thousand Spanish families; we have proposed a plan for the reindustrialization of Spain; we have proposed a pact against child poverty; we have proposed to tackle unemployment with active employment policies; we have proposed to raise the Minimum Interprofessional Wage and we have proposed a Law on Equal Pay, because that is how inequality is tackled, Mr. President. But you prefer to look at your navel and tell us about those vigorous roots and cruising speed, and here the only thing that is taking root is unemployment, because you are not creating jobs, you are fragmenting employment. Because here the only thing that is taking root is labor poverty, that new social class of working poor. What is taking root is social exclusion.

And the only thing that is gaining cruising speed, Mr. President, are the police and judicial investigations that are cornering you and your party. You owe too many explanations already. You owe too many explanations, Mr. Rajoy, to the young people who have had to leave this country because they had no opportunities; to the evicted people; to the self-employed and to working families to whom you raise the VAT, the IBI, take away their aid, take away their scholarships, impose payments and copayments, and to those who need to go to court and cannot pay the fees.

You are a president of a disintegrating Government, who is neither here nor expected; who has a Minister of Health who we do not know how she remains at the head of the Ministry; who has a Minister of Finance who grants amnesty to Mr. Granados and to tax evaders and squeezes the rest of us; who has a Minister of Employment who says that young people emigrate because they want to, with that of external mobility, and who has a Minister of the Interior who cuts our rights and freedoms. And I could go through all the ministers of your Government; a Government, Mr. President, that Spaniards are very fed up with.

And I want to end my speech by referring to the inheritance, but to an inheritance, Mr. Rajoy, that you never talk about: it is the inheritance that more than two million children in this country will receive, which is the poverty they will inherit from their parents.

Rousseau stated that the first source of evil is inequality. So, Mr. Rajoy, you should start combating inequality, because it is your responsibility. Do not sidestep, take responsibility and face it, because in democracy, as in life, one must face it, because problems are not solved by sidestepping. So, Mr. Rajoy, wake up. There is a country to move forward. Get your act together or step aside.

President.- Ms. Chivite, I am not going to talk to you about the judicial investigations in the Supreme Court of deputies and senators from your party, nor about the more than one hundred indicted in the EREs of Andalusia; I am not going to talk to you about that. I prefer to build, look to the future, and offer you, as I have done here this afternoon, an agreement. If you do not want it, we will approve the anti-corruption regulations alone.

I do want, however, to say something. Ms. Chivite, what increases inequality the most is unemployment and, therefore, the most effective policies against inequality are those that create jobs. In the Legislature 2008-2011, unemployment in Spain increased by 3,400,000 people, and you did not rescue them either, and tax revenue fell by 70 billion euros. There lies the origin of everything. Fortunately, things have begun to change and now in Spain we are growing --the country that has grown the most in the eurozone--, we are beginning to create net jobs and the data from the EPA, Social Security, and INEM are increasingly better. And as they are better, they are also reflected in the indices approved by the European Union on poverty and inequality.

According to Eurostat, the AROPE rate, which in the previous Legislature the poverty rate grew by 4.5 points, in 2012 it only grew by half a point and in 2013, for the first time in six years, there has been the first reduction, as a consequence of the policies of the Popular Party. The same has happened with the Gini Index, which between 2007 and 2011 indicates that social inequality increased by 8 percent; in 2012, a minimal increase of 0.3 percent and in 2013 it has already been reduced for the first time. And the same with the 80-20 Indicator, which grew in 2007 and 2011, and has already begun to decrease in 2013.

What is happening in the Spanish economy? There is a change in trend in growth, in employment, and in inequality; we were coming out of a cave that you put us in and, fortunately, we are now about to emerge definitively.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Jesús Enrique Iglesias, of the Mixed Parliamentary Group

Mr. Iglesias.- Mr. President, since you have opened the floor, allow me also a preamble. It is not at all respectful of the rule of law, to which you have just referred, to turn the control session of the Government into a framework for reading a press release without questions, because the rest of us cannot change the question.

Going to that question, Mr. President, you have turned respect for the law into a kind of motto of your Government's action and have ratified that no one can ask the Government to violate the law, and that its obligation is to enforce it. Why then --and this is the question-- does your Government violate the law at our borders every day and force the Security Forces to violate it with the practice of hot returns in Ceuta and Melilla?

President.- Mr. Iglesias, as a first premise, I would like to clarify that we are dealing with a matter of enormous sensitivity and that, therefore, we must treat it with the utmost responsibility. It is a matter in which we must weigh an irrenounceable obligation, which is the control of our borders, and the harshness and drama that irregular immigration entails, which is the result, unfortunately, of the activity of criminal organizations that traffic in human beings. A matter that we must therefore face as a state policy and, from this perspective, I will try to explain to you what we are talking about.

As you know, we have the obligation, like any country, to safeguard our borders in accordance with the terms imposed by the Schengen Borders Code and our internal regulations, including the Organic Law on the Bodies and Forces of State Security. This Code establishes that the main objective of border surveillance is to prevent unauthorized crossing of the border, and the Law on the Bodies and Forces of State Security of 1986 assigns the Civil Guard the mission of guarding coasts and borders in order to prevent the illegal entry of persons.

These are the legal frameworks that we cannot and must not ignore or circumvent. And these obligations must, of course, be reconciled with respect for the fundamental rights that are compromised in migratory flows, even when attempts at entry occur through illegal means.

In this regard, our immigration regulations adequately address the situations arising from irregular entry or irregular stay and residence in Spain, regulating the procedures that you are very familiar with.

But, ladies and gentlemen, the borders of Ceuta and Melilla have unique characteristics that are not found at other border crossings. Firstly, they have been subjected to intense migratory pressure for years, and I do not need to remind you of the continuous episodes of mass entry attempts and assaults that both border perimeters endure. On the other hand, they are the only external borders of the European Union with the African continent.

Well, in the face of a specific and complex situation, it is necessary to articulate policies that offer balanced solutions; it is necessary to address both the humanitarian dimension of the problem and the responsibility undertaken by Spain, as a sovereign state and member of the Union, to protect its borders. Failing to properly address the problem would be tantamount to admitting illegality in such an important matter as the delimitation of territory.

In this sense, in Ceuta and Melilla, situations arise that precede immigration regulations, their principles, and procedures. Therefore, there is a need to provide greater legal certainty to the actions of border surveillance and rejection that the State Security Forces carry out in Ceuta and Melilla, precisely by virtue of that geographical uniqueness.

In short, what we intend to do is improve the legal coverage of a situation and an action that precede the application of the procedures of the Immigration Law and that we must not ignore, because this is the key issue, which constitutes illegal entry attempts that often occur violently or clandestinely, violating the security devices of the border perimeter. This reform that we have proposed will be complemented by the Ministry of the Interior with a comprehensive action protocol to complete the legal regulation, and it will be done, I repeat, weighing two goods worthy of protection: the security of our borders — we cannot be the only country in the world that does not guarantee security at our borders, unless you say so — and the humanitarian principles that necessarily inspire national and community legality.

Mr. Iglesias.- Mr. President, in a way, you have acknowledged that this reform responds to the fact that until now they have operated in absolute illegality. But we will talk about that reform when it arrives in this Chamber, because that reform will not resolve those legality issues either, because there are matters determined by treaties and international agreements, of which our country is a part, above which that legislative reform you refer to will not stand.

So far, in that clear and open illegality, you have operated with pseudo-legal concepts, with shortcuts in this matter: border rejection, which is not contemplated in the Immigration Law or in the Regulation, and the operational concept of the border.

Border rejection, I insist, is not contemplated in the Immigration Law, which you will not be able to create specifically for a zone of Spain, for a specific border, I insist, due to the international commitments I will refer to later.

The Law today regulates expulsions, which require an administrative file and a reasoned resolution. The Law today provides for the denial of entry, which also requires a reasoned resolution and possibilities for appeal. The Law today provides for returns that involve transfer to the police station beforehand and a resolution from the sub-delegate of the Government, and require legal and interpreter assistance. None of this is being done today in Ceuta and Melilla with hot returns.

The other concept, the operational concept of the border. I must acknowledge that this demonstrates truly commendable ingenuity. Borders are not those determined by the Government; borders are those that, internationally, through treaties, through usages, are delineated, and you are also playing with fire by moving the borders in a historically disputed territory.

We have seen images of expulsions after crossing the third fence, on the road, and we have seen expulsions of people who were in Spain's internal waters. All of this is a clear violation of that Law that you say must be complied with.

They also violate the Immigration Law and the Asylum and Subsidiary Protection Law, which enshrines the right to asylum, which cannot be requested because hot expulsion prevents it. And they violate those international laws that will condition the normative capacity of the Government and these Chambers, unless we denounce the treaties that bind us. They violate the Constitution itself, which in its article 10 states that norms relating to fundamental rights must be interpreted in accordance with the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. And they violate international treaties, such as the Geneva Convention of July 28, 1951 and the Protocol of January 31 on the Status of Refugees, and article 18 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union, which also prohibits collective expulsions, and hot returns are collective expulsions.

Do you know, Mr. President, that just a few days ago, on October 21, the European Court of Human Rights condemned Italy and Greece for collective expulsions that violate that norm? They violate the European Convention on Human Rights and the Return Directive with their decisions.

These practices have been condemned in our country by NGOs, by the General Council of the Bar, by Amnesty International, by the Ombudsman since 2005 — in the last report of 2013 reiterates that denunciation — by the legal report prepared by fifteen professors and university lecturers of Constitutional and International Law, which was made public last June. And outside our borders, by Human Rights Watch, by UNHCR, by the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, and by the Commissioner for Home Affairs of the European Union, who has just warned that she will take measures if violations of European Union regulations continue, which is what is being violated with such practices.

Now you intend to change that Law, I insist, without having the margin to provide coverage for practices that will remain illegal after that Law. And with this, you are not only facing a political responsibility, but there are also criminal responsibilities. So far we have a colonel of the Civil Guard who has been charged by a judge in Melilla; but those criminal responsibilities do not have to end, in any case, with those who execute the orders received, because one thing is political responsibilities and another is criminal ones. But nowhere is it written that one cannot have both criminal legal responsibilities and political responsibilities at the same time.

You must comply with the Law and not hide behind the mafias, which exist; the first being the corruption in the Moroccan regime, which, despite what we have in our country, in the corruption ranking, there are forty states behind us more corrupt before reaching Morocco. Because those who push people to jump the fence are not the mafias; they may help, but what pushes them is hunger and desperation. Let us focus on solving those problems and not dedicate 32 times more resources to stopping them at the borders than, for example, to helping refugees.

President.- Thank you very much for your intervention, Mr. Iglesias. I regret to say that I do not share anything of what you have stated.

I must say that all the actions being carried out by the State Security Forces at the borders of Ceuta and Melilla fully comply with the Law, and I must say that the modification of the same proposed by the Government fully complies with all international legislation.

I could ask you a question, but first I will make the exposition of motives for the question. We are talking, and we see it very often on television, about illegal entries of people that in most cases occur violently or clandestinely, violating the security devices of the border perimeter. And you say that we should not talk about the mafias, even though you are aware that it is the mafias that organize this. Come on! How can I not talk about the mafias, who are precisely the ones organizing these violent and clandestine entries?

So, in a situation of this nature, we can do two things: the first is to open the borders and let anyone who deems it appropriate and convenient enter, because why should we prevent it? We can do that, which seems to be what you propose with your interventions. From now on, here, at the European border, the only land border with Africa, anyone can enter, and I will have to explain that in the European Union and I will have to explain to all Spaniards that, because someone comes up with the idea, the Spanish border will be opened for anyone to enter, with or without mafias, violently or peacefully. I cannot accept that, and therefore, I will not accept it, and we will continue with the reform.

I do agree with you on one of the statements you made. Obviously, the medium- and long-term solution to the problem that arises very frequently, unfortunately, in Ceuta and Melilla is to try to work with the countries of origin. And undoubtedly, this should be, and I have proposed it on some occasions, and I will continue to insist on it in the future, a European policy: agreements with these countries, trying to help them out of poverty, building institutions and trying to affirm democratic institutions there. Undoubtedly, that is the medium- and long-term system, because it is evident that if people cannot live with dignity in their country, they will seek a living elsewhere.

But that has nothing to do with Spain, or the whole of the European Union — and this policy, of course, has been supported by all countries in the European Union — making decisions to prevent our borders from ceasing to be borders and becoming something else.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. José Montilla, of the Parliamentary Group Entesa pel Progrès de Catalunya

Mr. Montilla.- Mr. President, over the last two years I have asked you similar questions in this Plenary, the last time in February of this year, always expressing the same concern about the deterioration of a matter that concerns Catalan policy but that directly affects Spanish policy. Today I insist with a very firm conviction: it is urgent that you and your Government change your behavior and move from a passive mode to a proactive attitude.

On October 14, you expressed your satisfaction — "it is excellent news," you said — with President Mas's decision to suspend the known consultation, previously suspended by the Constitutional Court. You accompanied that comment with the assertion, often reiterated throughout this year, of your willingness to engage in dialogue.

On November 9, there will indeed not be a referendum in Catalonia under the terms promoted by the Government of the Generalitat, nor a democratic consultation that meets the requirements to be considered as such. There will surely be a large mobilization that, in my opinion, will not bring any significant novelty to the already known landscape, even if you appeal that alternative consultation, as it seems you will.

Whatever the effect of that mobilization, after the 9th, the 10th will come. The problems raised will be the same, and the need and urgency to address them intelligently will also remain. And it cannot be only by appealing to the rule of law and constitutional legality, which you know I also defend.

Mr. President, do you believe we are facing a serious situation? Do you not think that the integration of Catalonia into Spain constitutes one of the most important problems that your Government must face, along with others, certainly? Do you think that the passage of time will resolve that situation? Do you intend to propose a solution or do you believe that requesting reports from the Council of State and suspensions from the Constitutional Court is sufficient?

President.- Mr. Montilla, as you recalled at the beginning of your intervention, it is true that this is not the first occasion on which you have posed this question to me. As you can well imagine, my response will not be very different from the one I gave you on previous occasions. In fact, your question is not different either.

The priority of the Government throughout this Legislature, as I have said on numerous occasions, is economic growth and job creation, because it is the improvement of the well-being and wealth of all citizens. Fortunately, I believe that things have been improving over recent times, and I am convinced that they will continue to do so in this year 2014 and also in the year 2015. This is the change that has occurred in Spain in recent times: before, every quarter, negative growth, and now, every quarter, positive growth; before unemployment was rising, and now, fortunately, employment is growing.

From there, there are many more things in which we can collaborate with the Autonomous Communities and, of course, also with Catalonia. We have collaborated, and the Government of the Generalitat with its decisions has also contributed to fiscal consolidation in Spain. It has supported some structural reforms that, in my opinion, were very positive. We have reached an agreement on a key issue, such as the Autonomous Liquidity Fund and the Payment Plan to Suppliers, which have allowed many people to be paid for services rendered to the Administration. We have been able to meet financial debt payments, saving approximately seven billion in interest. I believe this is a demonstration of loyal and effective collaboration between Public Administrations.

My position on the referendum is known; it is the same as yours. I believe that in a democratic and rule-of-law state, like ours, all rulers must be subject to the Law, and it was the Constitutional Court that determined what was law and what was not law. And that is why I found, and indeed qualified as "excellent," the response of Mr. Mas at that time.

That said, you say that I always make appeals for dialogue. It is true. I can talk about anything except, as I have said, if it involves violating the Law, because I believe it must be upheld. However, from there, if someone wants to change it, there are procedures in our legislation to do so. It is true that there are some things that I will never accept, because I believe in them and have a legitimate right to defend them, such as that Spaniards decide what they want their country to be, that is, the principle of national sovereignty; the principle of equality among Spaniards and the freedom and individual rights of people.

From there, I would also like to find a solution to this situation, but you say: "make a proposal." What does that mean? That I have to make a proposal to anyone who intends to call a referendum against what the Constitution itself says? Do I have to give something in return? Because, in the end, Mr. Montilla, what we are talking about is that: do I have to give something in return? Do I have to make a proposal? What needs to be given? The fiscal pact? Do you have any idea? What would you give? Don't talk to me about the federal system, because it doesn't suit you.

Therefore, let us stop talking about things that mean nothing, about slogans and words, which are fine, and you present things well, and let us get to the heart of the matter: what would you do?

Mr. Montilla.- Mr. President, what I would not do is be a mere spectator of the situation, which is what you are.

Mr. President, you consider that the fight against the crisis is the first of the priorities and you affirm it on every occasion you can. We have, it is true, a different opinion on the necessary policies to correct the economic situation in Spain; but I recognize your tenacity regarding that priority and the adoption of structural reforms that, in your opinion, in your judgment, are necessary. Often, we have adopted a critical attitude towards some of these reforms, but I appreciate your and your Group's willingness to promote them, because you do so thinking that, in the face of the serious problem of the economic crisis, the lack of growth in our economy, and the weak job creation, we must take the initiative.

Do you believe that the Catalan crisis should not also be a priority? Why do you not adopt positive measures to restore the situation? These measures are necessary, Mr. Rajoy, and urgent to address the citizens of Catalonia, and to channel the growing political tension that is occurring there; a tension that has underlying reasons, and you know it, that does not end on November 9 and that, unfortunately, is systematically fed by decisions from both sides, which seem more aimed at stoking the fire than at pacifying the situation.

Resolving the Catalan problem, which is a problem for Spain, is a social and political urgency, but also an economic necessity. Spain cannot afford to have one of its most dynamic economies in a situation of instability and future risk. I know you will tell me, and you have told me, that the Government attends to the needs of Catalonia, and has referred to the FLA and some relevant investments; but that is not enough, Mr. President. Proposing solutions is your responsibility, and waiting for time to pass is not a solution.

You may believe that time, combined with firmness in defending the rule of law, contributes to weakening the positions of sovereignty. Do not be so sure. And if that is the calculation, Mr. President, it would be a strictly tactical, short-term calculation, because just as corruption, which must be fought without respite, fuels populism, your immobility on the Catalan issue fuels independence. It may weaken and restrict the maneuvering margin of those who support an independence process in Catalonia, but time also has negative effects in a situation that is rotting and can become entrenched.

The time of blockage can also burn opportunities to solve underlying problems. The time of paralysis can add new difficulties to the search for solutions, because there are things that, once broken, are very difficult to reassemble.

Mr. President, you know that I am not an independentist. I respect those who believe that this is the best solution for the economic and social problems of Catalonia. However, I sincerely believe that a hypothetical secession of Catalonia would be detrimental to the interests of Catalans.

I still think that Catalonia should adopt a leadership position in Spain and work on a shared project, but the conditions for that to happen today are deteriorated. Recognizing this fact is the first condition to find solutions that must commit us all. We must create the conditions for a new pact that seduces both Catalans and all Spaniards.

You are the president of the Government, the president of all Spaniards, including Catalans. You cannot remain indifferent to the course of events without taking a positive initiative. Last Wednesday, your Minister of Foreign Affairs stated that the Government is not, in any way, closed to reforming the Constitution and reiterated that the decision on the appropriate moment is in your hands. I believe that the voices proposing federal solutions and advocating for reforming the Constitution to deepen the constitutional pact are becoming increasingly numerous.

I conclude. I understand that you express caution regarding the constitutional reform process. That is a delicate operation that must be done seeking the highest degree of consensus. It is true that it is not an easy objective, but it is not impossible. If we achieved it in 1978, why should we not achieve it now? It requires time, tenacity, a sense of state, generosity, and loyalty. A difficult challenge, but believe me, Mr. President, necessary and urgent.

You must assume, Mr. President, your responsibility; take the initiative, history, Catalans, and Spaniards will thank you or demand it. It depends on you.

President.- I thank you, Mr. Montilla, for your intervention, which, as usual, has been measured, sensible, and from which I can indeed share many things.

There is only one thing to which you have not responded: is something to be given for announcing the call for an illegal referendum? And what is it that needs to be given? That is the issue, Mr. Montilla; that is the question I have been asking for a long time.

I am not a spectator. I have made the decisions that I am obliged to make as President of the Government to prevent a referendum from being held in Spain that violates the Law and the Constitution. That is taking action, fulfilling one's obligation.

From there, Mr. Montilla, just two comments to conclude this intervention. What am I going to do in the future? Well, look, I am going to talk about a country, which is Spain, and I will say that it is a country with centuries of history, and I will say that it is the first to achieve its unity, the oldest in all of Europe. A country united for many centuries by all kinds of ties: family, personal, emotional, and commercial. A country whose Constitution we made together among all Spaniards; it is not owned by anyone, but it was made for the sake of agreement and the common good, with a Constitution that guarantees our fundamental rights and freedoms, for example, the right to vote legally. A Constitution that established the greatest decentralization in the history of Spain and makes our country today the most decentralized country in the world; a country with infrastructures that almost no one else in the world has; a country with a Welfare State like the one we have in Spain; a country that in the last fifty years has been among the top four in the world that has grown the most; a country that is participating in the process of European integration, which is the largest political operation that has been carried out in centuries; a country that has just entered the United Nations Security Council; a country that has overcome a serious economic crisis and is already seeing light at the end of the tunnel.

That is the country I offer to all Spaniards; a country that some do not want to speak well of, but others do want to speak well of.

Certainly, what I cannot offer to the people, because it would go against what I believe, is a small country, outside of Europe, impoverished, without the euro, because today, as the world is, in the process of globalization we are experiencing, what exists are processes of union and integration, and what does not work, because it is nonsense and leads directly to impoverishment, is division.

Indeed, you say that I have made decisions about Catalonia and that you think the FLA is good. Yes, it is the Government's obligation to prevent some people from suffering. We did it with Catalonia and with other Autonomous Communities, and also with the Payment Plan to Suppliers, and also with infrastructures, and in a situation of enormous difficulty.

Yes, I know, everything is debatable and everything is open to opinion, but there is only one thing that I will never renounce, which is convictions, like those I mentioned earlier, which are held by the vast majority of Spaniards: national sovereignty, freedom, and the individual rights of citizens.

With absolute frankness, Mr. Montilla, what can be offered..? Tell me, because that was the only thing you did not tell me. What can be offered to someone who calls for an illegal referendum, who does it unilaterally and who tells me: "either there is this referendum or I will do what I deem appropriate and convenient." I can only offer you the Constitution and the Law. And from there, we will talk whenever you want, but always within the Law. And you too, and I am sure you have much to contribute to this great national project; you.

Thank you very much.