Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

4 March 2013 · Parliamentary control session (Spanish Congress of Deputies)

Context
Rajoy responded to parliamentary questions in the Spanish Congress in March 2013, defending the government's tax regularization decree against accusations of enabling money laundering.
Main themes
Tax regularization and amnesty, tax data confidentiality, money laundering concerns, underground economy, government compliance with tax law, deficit targets, tax evasion, corruption scandals, General Tax Law Article 95, revenue collection shortfall
Duration
~47 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,692
93rd percentile
Sentences
216
91st percentile
Readability
49
60th percentile
Grade
12.3
48th percentile
Syntax
3.29
81st percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
32nd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 59%53%
  • Institutional 28%25%
  • Ceremonial 13%12%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 9%

216 sentences in 85 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Jesús Enrique Iglesias Fernández, of the Mixed Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Iglesias Fernández.- Mr. Rajoy, the tax regularization contemplated in Royal Decree Law 12/2012 has all the signs of having become a gigantic money laundering machine. Does the Government you preside intend to inform Spanish society, without the mediation of judges, about the individuals and legal entities that have availed themselves of this tax regularization process?

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Iglesias. As you surely do not overlook, the Government must comply with the laws. The President of the Government cannot be asked to violate the law, and our tax legislation in this regard is very clear, and I am absolutely convinced that you are aware of it.

Article 95 of the General Tax Law states that "the data, reports, or background obtained by the Tax Administration in the performance of its functions are confidential and may only be used for the effective application of the taxes or resources for which it is responsible and for the imposition of the appropriate sanctions, without being able to be transferred or communicated to third parties." This general rule has its exceptions, which are outlined in Article 95 itself, and among these is collaboration with judicial bodies and the Public Prosecutor's Office in the investigation or prosecution of crimes, which is what you are surely referring to in your question.

This principle applies to all actions of the Tax Administration, and among these actions are also the tax regularization processes that, as you know, are not new either in Spain or in any country in the world.

Consequently, Your Honor, we are dealing with a law in force in Spain for more than thirty years, and you will understand that one of my obligations, the most important, is to comply with the law. And I want to tell you, moreover, that the confidentiality of tax data is a general principle of our tax system that protects all taxpayers, and this does not prevent these data from being used for the fulfillment of inspection purposes and for collaboration with judicial processes, which is what is happening at this moment.

Therefore, the President of the Government cannot be asked to violate so clearly, so distinctly, and so blatantly, as you intend, a law that has been in force, I insist, for more than thirty years.

Mr. Iglesias Fernández.- Nothing could be further from my intention than to ask the President to violate the law. I am content with him changing it, as he has changed more than thirty laws since he has presided over this Government through Royal Decree Laws or Projects. A few, even, have passed through this Chamber.

With the tax regularization, commonly known as amnesty, you took a very risky decision. You took a very risky decision with a dual purpose: on the one hand, for a part of the underground economy to emerge; on the other hand, to obtain revenues that would contribute to meeting the deficit target.

It was a risky decision, and you knew it, because it deals with the regularization of a figure that, first of all, is questioned by the technicians of the Tax Administration; secondly, it is disputed by international organizations such as the OECD, as it implies a message of impunity to society regarding those who fail to meet their tax obligations, and because, in any case, the result of a regularization is always unfair to the majority of society, to that vast majority of society that fulfills its tax obligations.

It is also risky because, although there were precedents, true, in our country of similar processes, the context was very different. We were in a context where we all knew of the existence of a very significant volume of opaque funds resulting from the successive bubbles, not only the real estate one, that have occurred in our country's economy.

And because we are experiencing an undeniable phenomenon, a proliferation of scandals related to corruption.

You set a modest target: to collect 2.5 billion euros; modest considering the fact that between 20 and 25 percent of the Gross Domestic Product is in the underground economy. But you did not even manage to achieve that modest target, even though the conditions were unbeatable: a 10 percent tax rate for tax evaders.

As things were not going well, that was not enough for you. Back in May, on May 31, you approved a Ministerial Order, 1182/2012, which further relaxed the conditions of the tax regularization and opened a hole, a real sieve, for the laundering of cash. Even with that, you did not reach 50 percent of collection. Why? Was there less underground economy? Was there less fraud? Obviously not, Mr. President. What there was was less credibility among tax evaders in the firm will of this Government to effectively combat tax fraud, despite the fact that the regularization was accompanied by other legislative reforms: those that toughened the phenomenon of tax fraud in the Penal Code. But that credibility was inevitably devalued, because simultaneously you were also toughening the fight against labor fraud and Social Security in the same reform.

And now we know, from what you say, that you yourselves were committing fraud against Social Security, labor fraud. How could there be credibility among tax evaders that there was political will to effectively fight from now on?

Furthermore, and I find this the most serious of all, because in that regularization, in that reform, in Royal Decree Law 12/2012, a kind of permanent regularization or amnesty process was established. The first final provision modifies Article 180 of the General Tax Law, establishing that those who regularize their situation before the start of verification or investigation actions will be exempt from criminal liability even if they have committed tax crimes, and neither the Public Prosecutor's Office nor the judicial authority will be informed.

Like light passing through glass without leaving a stain, you transfer to Tax Law the dogma of the Immaculate Conception, and since the great tax evaders have no connections and there has never been any kind of leak in this country, you can imagine how uneasy they must have felt reading this provision.

Moreover, it was inevitable that the risks would end up yielding the results they have yielded. To this day, there is no major ongoing corruption judicial process in which judges are not asking the Tax Agency to disclose who appears on that list of beneficiaries of the tax regularization or amnesty: from the "Bárcenas-Gürtel case" to the "Noos case," including some that have emerged in Catalonia: alleged availing of the tax regularization.

The Professional Association of State Tax Inspectors denounces that the regularization allegedly served for the laundering of illicitly obtained capital; that not even a declaration about the origin of those capitals was requested, and much less were control mechanisms established for the files. That is why they are now asking to be informed.

Change the law, you can change it by Royal Decree Law. It would not be a punitive measure and, therefore, it could perfectly have retroactive effects. Let Spanish society know who truly did not pay taxes. Not those that Mr. Montoso provocatively insinuates did not pay taxes, but those who did. And if you do not do it, the rest of us will have to do what we must: Chamber Regulations, twenty-five senators --Article 59.1-- from different Groups can promote the establishment of a Commission of Inquiry. Here are two already ready to sign, we need 23 more.

President.- Thank you very much for your words, Mr. Iglesias. I am glad that you do not ask me to violate the law because, as you will understand, the President of the Government could not do so.

I want to say a few things regarding everything you have said in your speech; first of all, about the regularization itself, which you have questioned.

I want to tell you that this is not the first regularization that has been carried out in this country, as you have rightly recognized. This country is also not the only one that does it, because countries in our environment, such as, for example, the United States, the United Kingdom, Italy, or Germany, following the recommendations of the OECD, have also introduced this type of processes.

This is an extraordinary, exceptional regularization, limited in time, to respond to an extraordinary and unsustainable situation of public accounts, to broaden the tax bases and to increase revenue, and it is a useful instrument in the fight against fraud. Because I suppose that, like me, you are concerned about the revenues we fail to collect that should go to finance our public services. Therefore, the objective was, as you have rightly said, to bring the underground economy to light and to identify new tax bases to solidly increase revenue.

I am going to give you some data that I think you should take into account to make a well-founded value judgment. It is not the first time that a Government has approved a program for the regularization of hidden assets: it was done in 1977, in 1984, and in 1991.

The regularization, in this case, requires the identification of the real owner of the regularized assets and rights, which did not happen in previous regularizations. The regularization is transparent in terms of access by public officials of the Tax Agency. The staff of the Tax Inspection has access to this information to fulfill their functions; this had never been done before. The regularization neither erases, nor cleans, nor conceals crimes committed, because no person who has an open process, whether in the administrative or judicial route, can use this procedure to avoid the consequences of these processes. The program serves for undeclared income obtained before October 31, 2012, whose origin is lawful. No individual or legal entity can benefit from the submission of the tax declaration if they have initiated a tax regularization procedure in the administrative or judicial route. And the income revealed in these cases is taxed at a rate of 10 percent, while previously it was taxed at a rate of zero.

In summary, just as with the rest of the tax declarations, this regularization is compatible with the Law on the Prevention of Money Laundering as it allows for the determination and punishment of these crimes.

I am going to give you some data. You have pointed them out, and I will give them to you in more detail: the revenues for the public coffers are 1.193 billion euros; you may find that little, but I believe it is a very considerable amount. There have been a total of 31,529 declarations, and 98 percent of the declarations submitted are from individuals. And, most importantly, the measure has allowed for the emergence of assets worth 40 billion euros; that is, an amount equivalent to 4 percent of nominal GDP.

You speak of the fight against tax fraud. We have presented two laws: the Anti-Fraud Law and the reform of the Penal Code. In addition, the Inspection last year, 2012, collected 12 percent more than it collected in 2011, and I am convinced that this year these figures will be much better.

Finally, I would like to respond to your proposal to modify the law. These things cannot be done lightly. This law has been in force in Spain for more than thirty years, with a practically unanimous agreement from all political forces. What I tell you is that at this moment the Government is thinking, and is aware of the relevance it has, of communicating tax offenders as an additional instrument in this fight. For this, we are studying possible regulatory modifications, so that the most relevant tax non-compliances can be subject to publication, always respecting the right to protection of the affected taxpayers.

It is a delicate issue, we are studying it in depth, and do not have the slightest doubt that any intelligent and interesting contribution you can make will be taken into account.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Marcelino Iglesias, of the Socialist Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Iglesias.- Mr. President of the Government, it has been more than fifteen months since you committed during the electoral campaign to get us out of the crisis without bothering anyone; you would do it with a kind of general anesthesia. The problem of Spain for you at that moment was the Government of José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero, and you were the solution. People were not displeased with your electoral proposals, they supported them, and you then achieved an absolute majority.

In these fifteen months, they have completely forgotten their commitments, they have cut Education, they have cut Healthcare and dependency, they have made layoffs easier and cheaper, and they have raised taxes. They have gone from collecting signatures in the streets against the VAT increase to the largest tax increase, Mr. Rajoy, in democracy. Throughout this year, their bet has been the deficit, and all policies, all other policies, have been subordinated to this objective of the public deficit.

Last week, you announced to us, with great applause from your Group, that the deficit would be 6.7 percent, but the next day the Commission, in its winter report, told us that the deficit would be 10.2 percent. Mr. President, I ask you about this discrepancy with the European Commission, because I believe that, no matter what they do with the makeup, no matter what their spokespersons do, no matter how they try to spin it, this deficit figure is the evident demonstration of the most resounding failure of your economic policy. It is the demonstration that the horse adjustment not only does not improve but severely worsens our situation.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Iglesias. As you very well recalled, the European Commission published its winter forecasts for the years 2013 and 2014 some time ago, and also for the closure of the year 2012. The Commission makes a forecast of growth, deficit, unemployment, and the economic situation in general of the different countries of the European Union, and also of other countries.

You are interested in a specific issue, and I will respond to that. It is about the forecast of the European Commission that places the deficit for Spain in the past year 2012 at 10.25 percent of the Gross Domestic Product, and you ask me for my assessment of that forecast. It is a question of interest because, without a doubt, the issue is important.

My answer is as follows: the public deficit of last year in Spain was 6.74 percent, compared to 8.96 percent from the previous year. This figure, Mr. Iglesias, is not a forecast; it is not; it is a data from the General Intervention of the State, and this is a very positive data because it means that we have managed to reduce our public deficit by more than two percentage points of GDP, that is, 24.5 billion euros. This means two things: that in 2012 we borrowed 24.5 billion euros less than in 2011, which, among many other things, saves us interest on debt payments; and, secondly, that we are advancing in the credibility of Spanish public accounts and in the recovery of confidence. We have done this, moreover, in the worst of circumstances -- recession and very difficult and expensive financing -- and this has been highly valued, as you will have had the opportunity to verify, by various international organizations.

The objective now must continue to be the reduction of the public deficit so as not to live on borrowed money, which, moreover, today is very difficult and very expensive. We are facing something that is crucial for economic growth and the recovery of employment to come to Spain.

Finally, a comment: the figure of 10.2 percent from the Commission's forecast is the result of a forecast, which the Commission says is 7 percent -- the General Intervention of the State does not make a forecast, but provides data, and it is 6.7 percent --, with the inclusion of an additional public deficit of 3.25 percent that is not part of the excessive deficit procedure, which is for one time only and is due to extraordinary circumstances in the financial sector. What happens here is the same as what happened in 2011: the deficit of 2011, and I have said this many times in this Chamber, was 8.96 percent, but since there was 0.5 points for bank recapitalization, the real figure was 9.4 percent. But for the purposes of the Commission, for the purposes of its demands and for the purposes of financing needs, the figure that counts and to which the Commission refers is the 6.7 percent that I have given you and which the Commission expects to be 7 percent.

That is the serious matter, and that is, Mr. Iglesias, the truth.

Mr. Iglesias.- Mr. President of the Government, I do not know what Europe will ultimately say about the deficit. What is certain is that the Spanish State is the one that has received, and therefore has to repay, the 40 billion euros in bank bailouts, that is what is certain, and that this amount places the deficit one point above what you inherited from the previous government, and that you have used that figure of 9 percent as an excuse to fail to comply with your electoral program and to justify your ruthless cuts and more cuts policies.

You have compromised your electoral commitments, you have compromised your program, to control the deficit, and you have neither fulfilled the program nor controlled the deficit.

Today the country, Mr. President, is worse off than a year ago; it is much worse. A year ago we had a deep economic crisis; during this time, the crisis has generalized and infected all of society. Today we have more than seven hundred thousand more unemployed. The economy has gone from growing a little, by 0.4 percent, to shrinking by 1.4 points, and with this negative growth of 1.4 points, you told us the other day that we already had our heads above water.

A year ago we had the problem of private debt; today we have, apart from the problem of private debt, the record figure of public debt in a hundred years: we have grown this year by more than twenty points in public debt. In one year, the risk premium, Mr. President, has exceeded 600 points; in one year, youth unemployment has increased by more than ten points; in Social Security, in one year we have lost three hundred thousand affiliates. Mr. President, wage incomes have fallen by 8.5 percent this year.

This is the tremendous reality of our country during these almost fifteen months of your Government after the elections.

The situation has indeed worsened day by day; the crisis has infected our entire society. A year after your Government, everything in Spain is in crisis. Where is that confidence that your Government was going to generate in the markets?

Mr. President, this is a parliamentary control session; I understand it to be a control of compliance with your electoral program. A year ago, citizens gave you their trust, but they gave it to you to carry out an electoral program. This trust and this electoral program are what fundamentally justifies your Government and what gave you an absolute majority. But you immediately renounced that contract with the citizens; the contract is what legitimized you to govern, and your policy has been: cuts, unemployment, economic recession, and more taxes; and, finally, Mr. President, scandals. Every morning a new chapter of the exploits of that nameless genius of finance who gives us all the finger. This is, Mr. President, an explosive mix.

Yes, here you have an absolute majority, a majority that cheers you on and applauds you, applauds you even before you speak, even when you arrive -- by the way, a new modality that we could call preventive applause; but in society, in this society, you and your Government have lost confidence in a very short time. You have broken the record for losing confidence in a very short time; you are blocked, and, in my opinion, you are disqualified from asking the Spanish people for any new effort.

A year later, Mr. Rajoy, a year after the elections, since you have been governing, undoubtedly, this is the most difficult moment Spain has faced since the democratic transition.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Iglesias. I will stick to your question. The first point of the electoral program with which we presented ourselves for the elections was to reduce the public deficit, because it is a sine qua non requirement -- more things need to be done, but it is a sine qua non requirement -- to achieve economic growth and employment. Now, fixing some things that are left to you is not easy, and they cannot be done in half an hour.

I insist on what I said: the public deficit this year, according to the General Intervention of the State, is 6.7 percent of GDP; a very positive figure, because we came from 8.96 percent of GDP, although the commitment was to be at 6 percent, as you know. This figure represented a substantial reduction of the deficit in 2012, as I told you before, of 24.5 billion euros, and this figure improves the credibility of the Spanish economy and also the confidence in it.

What accounts for the figure of 10.2 percent of GDP? It is due to actions in the financial sector, which I will explain to you and to anyone who wants to hear me in this Chamber. In 2008, many countries in the European Union injected very significant amounts of public money into their financial institutions, amounting to one trillion five hundred billion euros. Here, it was not wanted to do so in 2008, when the rest of the countries in the world did, and it was said that we lived in the best financial system in the world. I have nothing to say about that decision, and what I do say is that then the patches began: Spanish public money began to be injected, up to twenty-one billion euros, dedicated to covering losses, of which fourteen billion have already impacted or will impact the public deficit. That is lost Spanish money, Mr. Iglesias.

Specifically, in 2011, four billion euros went to the public deficit; those that give rise to the difference between 8.9 and 9.4 percent. And this year we have to include in the public deficit, in that of 2012, seven billion euros that you injected into the banks.

But, as all that was not enough, to fix the problems in 2012 we requested a loan from the European Union with ten years of grace and 0.5 percent interest to cover the losses that had been generated before. That is what gives rise to 26.269 billion euros that come from previous times and that go to the public deficit of 2012.

In any case, whether they are from your time, as they are, or from now, as I told you before, this does not influence the public deficit, it does not affect the excessive deficit procedure, because it is for one time only and is due to extraordinary circumstances.

Look at what the Commission's report says that you referred to: "it is expected that the deficit will be reduced to around 7 percent of GDP from the 8.9 percent recorded in 2011, excluding in both cases the bank recapitalization." Therefore, I would ask you for good faith on this issue of the deficit and on all others. You committed to 6 percent and left it at 8.9 percent; we committed to 6.3 percent and left it at 6.7 percent. And all the rating agencies and international organizations have said: the Spanish Government, in this matter, has fulfilled its duties.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Jokin Bildarratz, from the Basque Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Bildarratz.- Mr. President of the Government, first of all, in this my first intervention in a session of control of the Government, I would like, of course, to offer all that collaboration, our collaboration, in everything that we can share in the future.

And referring to the question, we are talking about the High-Speed Line Vitoria-Bilbao-San Sebastián, that is, the Atlantic branch of the Priority Project number 3 of the European Union which, as all Your Lordships know, consists of two branches: both the Atlantic branch and the Mediterranean branch.

We are talking, Mr. President, about the most important infrastructure that is currently being built in Euskadi and that, probably, has never been built; a line that should have been completed by 2010; later, this schedule was postponed to 2013, except for the Guipuzcoan section, which was aimed for 2015 or 2016.

My perception, and that of many Basques, is that neither the Government you preside over nor previous Governments have considered it necessary to adapt to the priority criteria expressed by the European Union. Let us remember that the beginnings of this project date back to 1989, that is, no more and no less than the staggering twenty-four years ago. If you want, to put it another way, the priority posed by the European Union is not being responded to. Keep in mind that, among many other reasons, the importance of this infrastructure lies in the fact that the Atlantic Arc concentrates between 30 and 40 percent of the GDP of the euro area.

What is the current situation? That in 2013 the works are delayed, and not only that, but in both the Alava and Biscay sections, the works are beginning to be paralyzed, which, of course, and you will understand, is concerning. Not to mention the Burgos-Vitoria section, where the same thing is happening.

At the same time, we must remember that some sections have aid from the European Union. These works will be monitored for compliance. What are you going to do? Lose European Union aid? Have sections yet to start and others completed?

The question and the issue would be the following: how does your Government plan to address this situation and what are the deadlines within which the Executive is moving for the completion of the works?

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Bildarratz. I appreciate your kind words and your offer of collaboration in this your first intervention in the control session, as you have recalled.

I want to tell you that the Government and the President of the Government are firmly committed to the development of the Basque Y as a priority project, and our intention is to maintain the pace of work so that its commissioning becomes a reality within the planned deadlines. Our commitment is to continue advancing the access of High Speed to the three Basque capitals, in coordination with local and regional public administrations, to improve connectivity and boost our communications. In this regard, we hope to reach agreements that will allow us to optimize solutions from both an economic and functional perspective in the three cities.

That all of this must be done within the framework of the current policy of cost rationalization in High-Speed Lines and respecting the budgetary policy is a necessity that I am absolutely convinced you are aware of. But, despite that framework of austerity, in which we unfortunately live, the Government maintains a firm commitment to its infrastructure policy and has a strong political will to decisively promote a project that serves territorial cohesion and our economic development. It is a project that the Government believes in, was conceived by an Executive of the Popular Party, and you are right to emphasize its importance; but know that I am also convinced of it.

Mr. Bildarratz.- I am pleased with the response you give us. In any case, I imagine you are also aware that at this moment ADIF is issuing the order to slow down the works, and in that sense, I am going to provide a series of examples to at least cast doubt on whether the positive message you are conveying may be in contradiction with the facts that are being carried out. I will provide that series of examples.

At this moment, the Ministry of Development, based on the 2013 Budgets, is going to invest 3.302 billion in High Speed. For Euskadi, and as you have said, and being a priority project, only 190 million; of the 3.302 billion, 190 million for Euskadi. Obviously, we are aware of the economic situation we are in, but let’s see what happens with the Basque Y.

At this moment, the Ministry of Development has three main Corridors as its most important investments; it has more investments, but the main focus is on three Corridors: two of them fall within the priority of the European Union, as previously mentioned. Well, the Northwest Corridor maintains 88.64% of the budget in 2013 compared to 2012, the Mediterranean Corridor maintains 94.34% of the budget compared to 2012, and the North and High-Speed Corridor, which, as I have pointed out, corresponds to the Atlantic Axis where the Basque Y is located, only receives 50% of the budget in 2013 compared to 2012; that is to say, we are coming down to half.

That is the only project that, if we qualify it as a priority, is cut in half, so do you really consider this project to be a priority? In that sense, two conclusions: first, we are seeing that the work is being abandoned, with companies being forced to stop because ADIF is making them work at 15% of their capacity, at 15%. And not only that. Last week, a meeting took place in the Basque Government with some of the awarded companies in which they were asked not to certify work done in 2012; that is to say, these companies will not yet be able to collect what has been done, what has been executed.

Second conclusion: in 2013, as we have said, 190 million out of 3.302 billion investment in High Speed; that is to say, 5.75% of your budgets. A clearly insufficient figure for the commitments already made. The conclusion, obviously, is clear: they are prioritizing other infrastructures, which means that the connection with Europe through Irún is being relegated.

Mr. President, I will conclude. As always, with an outstretched hand, seeking solutions to the problems, and here, in my opinion, we need to seek an agreement. We need to seek an agreement because Euskadi needs this infrastructure and Euskadi needs to make a commitment to the Basque Y. Let us extend, for example, the management assignment of the Guipuzkoan section to the sections of Biscay and Álava, and negotiate the conditions. For the Basques, it is the most important infrastructure we have at hand, and I am sure, sure, that we will manage it well.

And I conclude. The integration of Euskadi with Europe is at stake, and our economic development is also at stake. We will work together with Basque society to successfully complete an infrastructure that has caused us much suffering, because it has also made us suffer; but I am sure it will be worth it, I am sure. But this can only be done in a joint manner and by making a true commitment to it. Let’s do it.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Bildarratz. I want to, as I said in my first intervention, reiterate our commitment to the Basque Y project and to the infrastructures in the Basque Country.

The General State Administration has already invested more than one billion euros just in the Y, 1.135 billion, plus the corresponding part, which the General State Administration also pays, although in a different way, in the Guipuzkoan area: 789 million euros.

In 2012, which was a very tough year, as some other senator recalled in one of their interventions, the project was allocated 314 million euros in the Budgets. It is true that this year, 2013, the budget allocation has been reduced; but it can be stated that this allocation is sufficient to continue with the ongoing platform works, to begin the works of the Atxondo-Abadiño section, and to initiate the bidding for the sections corresponding to the Bergara knot. Therefore, it can be done, and I certainly want it to be done.

In the case of the line between Burgos and Vitoria, to which you also referred in your intervention, it is a competence of the General State Administration, and our purpose is to continue working on the ongoing actions and to be able to advance towards solutions that enhance the infrastructure as the actions are completed. The allocation provided in the General State Budgets is 130 million euros, sufficient to continue with the ongoing works.

Your Excellency, the economic context in which we operate has not caused the Government to waver in its commitment to continue the development of the High-Speed network in Spain. You can be absolutely certain that High Speed in the Basque Country will be completed. We believe that this is one of the main elements that integrates the territory, effective and of high quality.

Obviously, the actions are carried out based on the potential for demand capture and their economic and social profitability, the current degree of execution, the improvement of the functionality of the network, and the receipt of European funds; but I want to tell you that rationalizing costs in a situation that is what it is does not mean postponing or forgetting the commitments made. The Government is committed to that infrastructure and to the planned commissioning schedule. I know there are problems, I will not take that away from you; but I can tell you that I will do everything in my power. I have listened to you attentively, I will try to accommodate you and talk with the Basque Government.

Thank you very much.