Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

29 October 2013 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy addressed the Spanish parliament on October 29, 2013, responding to questions from opposition MPs during a parliamentary control session on economic policy.
Main themes
Economic recovery, austerity policy, social inequality, unemployment, welfare state, tax evasion, credit access, public sector wages, poverty, government economic reforms, pensions, parliamentary accountability
Duration
~15 min
53rd percentile
Words
1,848
53rd percentile
Sentences
66
43rd percentile
Readability
53
72nd percentile
Grade
12.2
47th percentile
Syntax
3.10
60th percentile
Vocabulary
1.95
6th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 49%48%
  • Social 34%33%
  • Ceremonial 17%17%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Institutional 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

66 sentences in 27 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Ms. Rosa Díez, of the Parliamentary Group of Unión Progreso y Democracia

Ms. Díez.- Here I am again, Mr. President of the Government. Over the past two years, and under the justification of the crisis, let’s say, instead of using the excuse, we could say that your policies have been generous when it comes to suppressing citizens' rights and austere when it comes to suppressing privileges. What has really happened in these years, as a consequence of the Government's policy, has been a very generous distribution of suffering among those who most need the protection of the State. That is why today I ask you what measures the Government intends to adopt so that those who are suffering the most from the crisis can benefit immediately from the end of the recession.

President.- I will start by saying that I am very glad to see you here again, in the same place.

I want to tell you that the Government intends to maintain the same economic policy. We started from a very difficult situation. There were very large imbalances in the economy. This has forced us to make decisions and to implement reforms, and I believe that now we are beginning to see the light at the end of the tunnel.

There have already been positive data regarding growth; prices are, as I said before, at -0.1 percent, and the risk premium, and therefore the financing of the economy, is in a better situation today than it was a year ago. We are exporting, and that is good because it means we are producing; therefore, there are people who are working. Foreign investment is already double that of last year; that is a good figure. And we are seeing something, just something—I say again, deeply unsatisfactory, but something is being seen—in terms of unemployment.

Logically, all of this is what will ultimately lead to economic growth, employment, and therefore we will be able to collect more revenue. Then we will be able to allocate more money to pensions, to social policies, and we will be able to unfreeze the situation of civil servants. I am aware: they have had their salaries frozen for five years, and even in one year, they were reduced.

Therefore, we are in a good situation, and as we grow and create jobs, we will be able to make decisions that will also help improve the welfare level of the people.

Ms. Díez.- Doing the same thing when the situation is different is usually a mistake. Mr. President, I would ask you to loosen the knot through your policies, that knot that tightens those who have sacrificed the most during the bad times: those affected by healthcare co-payments; those who have lost purchasing power in their pensions and continue to lose it; public employees, whose salaries have been frozen; policies for dependency, for healthcare, for education...

I tell you to "loosen the knot" for all of them and to tighten it on those who benefit from the low taxes of the Sicav, for example, which are increasingly numerous; to tighten it on tax evaders; to end the obscene tax amnesty; to pursue, as I say, tax evaders by giving more powers and more tools to the Tax Agency; to implement measures to ensure credit flows to families and businesses—notice that banks are now boasting about all their profits, even a bank that is now public, like Bankia;—to tighten it there so that credit flows, and to combat extreme poverty: more than three million people in Spain are in a situation of extreme poverty. The gap between those who have the most and those who have the least is widening.

In short, act on the price of basic foodstuffs to prevent cases of malnutrition, and a report has recently come out that is devastating; and change labor policy so that precariousness is no longer the norm for new contracts.

In short, Mr. President, loosen the knot on those who suffer and tighten it on those who take advantage of the crisis and the exit from the crisis.

President.- I believe that the Government has asked many efforts from the Spanish people, but we have wanted to be equitable. The first tax increase we made was the Personal Income Tax, and there were people, those who received the least amounts, who did not see any increase; others saw an increase of 0.5 percent, and some saw an increase of seven points. We have made very important decisions—I would like you to study them thoroughly—in the electricity sector and also in the salaries of the banking sector. We have also made an effort in terms of fraud, and I believe we must continue in that direction.

Last year, at this time, we were talking about the rescue of Spain, the premium, and the euro. Now we are talking about something else, and this year we have made a slightly better budget: pensions increase by 4.9 percent; unemployment insurance increases by 10 percent; the scholarship allocation increases by 10.6 percent, and the employment promotion allocation increases by 7.9 percent. We intend to continue doing this in the future, but for that it is essential to maintain the economic policy we are carrying out because, if not, there will be no employment, and if there is no employment, there are no economic resources in Spain to carry out those policies.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Alfredo Pérez Rubalcaba, of the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.- Mr. Rajoy, do you believe that an educational reform can be made by reducing spending on education?

President.- Let’s see. Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba, the issue is as follows: we have an educational model that you have approved and which I believe can function much better. So, in that situation, we can do two things: nothing, leave it as it is and resign ourselves, or make some changes.

Look, the rates of early school leaving double the OECD average; the current model leaves one in four students by the wayside, especially those with fewer economic possibilities; PISA says that our educational results are among the poorest; the latest PISA study for adults says that in the last twenty years the acquisition of basic competencies in mathematics and reading comprehension has stagnated, and we are in the second-to-last and last place among the twenty-three countries in that study. And what you want is for everything to remain the same.

You must understand that I cannot share your position, and I have the obligation to say so, and that is why I have proposed the reform of the Education Law in the hope that it will undoubtedly lead to an improvement in these results that we cannot afford because we are Spain.

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.- Mr. President, there are changes that make things worse. You seem to give change a necessarily good meaning, and I tell you that it is not. And, secondly, I ask you, please, to break down those data by Autonomous Communities to see if the problem is really of the general structure or of specific educational policies.

That said, I bring the question here because it was your Minister of Education who said, "if my reform works, it will cost a lot." And one looks at the Government's economic forecasts... Yes, your minister, in a national newspaper. He looked scared, and I don’t blame him.

If one looks at the educational policies and the budgetary policies of your Government, one comes to the conclusion that the Budgets will keep going down, and down, and down, and therefore there is no choice but to end up saying: even Mr. Wert does not believe that his reform will come into effect. It is true, because it will not, because the entirety of the Groups in this Chamber disagree with a reform that, I repeat, will be worse for the educational system, especially for the public sector, for public schools, which will be sidelined because you have made laws thinking basically of the private or concerted sector. This is the issue.

And I will tell you: behind this, there is something more. There is, as I have been explaining to you, a model of growth because if you abandon education, if you cut spending on R&D, if you forget about digital policy, because in Spain credits have also fallen, and you only rely on wage cuts, things will not go well. If you think that Spain will get out of the crisis by lowering wages and cutting social rights, healthcare, education, and now pensions, I tell you that things will not go well; that is an unsustainable and indefensible model. It is unsustainable over time because, as I have been telling you, there will always be someone who competes cheaper, who pays less; and it is socially indefensible.

That is why we disagree, and that is the point I want to discuss with you. Change your policy because if you change it, we will come out faster and, above all, in a fairer way, without so many imbalances and without the insecurity that you are transferring to many citizens, fundamentally, you know, those: those who need security the most, those who have the least; precisely those who use those social services that your Autonomous Communities, by the way, are putting at risk one after another.

President.- Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba, since you have made one of those general-type interventions, you have asked me to increase the budget for Education, R&D, policies that generate employment, social services, Education, Healthcare, or everything. But, of course, what you should have said is how you left this when you came to Government, which is what has forced us to make the decisions to be able to do it in the future.

In any case, Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba, I will explain to you very clearly: public spending per student—OECD data—in the European Union is higher in Spain than in those countries; the student/teacher ratio is higher in Spain than the OECD and European Union average; we spend 15 percent more than the OECD and European Union average per student. These are indeed the data from the OECD and the European Union. And yet, the results are much worse than in those countries that spend much less money than we do.

Look, something has to be done. You have to think that what you did, and you have been doing for twenty years in Spain, must have some defect. You say: no, we are not immobilists. More than 80 percent of the amendments you presented to the reform of the Education Law are for suppression; that is, all you want is for everything to remain as it is. And I cannot accept that because it is unfair to the Spanish people and because in education we are playing with the future.

Therefore, we must change in educational matters for a better educational system than yours, which should have been modified long ago...