Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

4 November 2013 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to parliamentary questions from MP Montilla during a government control session in Spain's Congress on 4 November 2013.
Main themes
Catalonia territorial issue, economic crisis recovery, dialogue and negotiation, constitutional framework, job creation, autonomous communities financing, infrastructure development, government priorities, political reform
Duration
~58 min
95th percentile
Words
6,926
95th percentile
Sentences
264
94th percentile
Readability
51
65th percentile
Grade
12.4
50th percentile
Syntax
3.37
88th percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
21st percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 41%39%
  • Economic 30%28%
  • Social 17%16%
  • Ceremonial 10%9%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

264 sentences in 95 paragraphs

Mr. President, what political initiatives will you and the Government you lead develop to address this problem?

President.- Thank you very much for your question, Mr. Montilla. This is not the first time you have asked me this question or another in very similar terms, and my answer will not be very different. In fact, you have already anticipated what I think, and it will not be very different from what I have said on previous occasions, and I believe that is good, because it does not seem reasonable for the president of the Government to change his criteria, especially when it comes to such an important issue as the one you are raising here.

The priority with which the party I lead presented itself in the elections and the priority of the Government I lead, expressed in the Investiture Debate, was exactly what you have stated here: to overcome the economic crisis, to grow and create jobs, because that is what will also allow us to increase revenue and, therefore, improve public services, and generate wealth and well-being.

With that objective, we have worked throughout this time. And it is true what you have said: we have made many decisions at the national level and we have also fought some battles at the European level. And it is true that you and others have disagreed with many of these decisions; but the fact is that this Government, if I may use the expression, has taken the bull by the horns, has tried to tackle the economic crisis, and we are beginning to see some positive effects. The idea is to continue with that policy, and therefore, the priority of the Government remains exactly the same.

In the case of Catalonia, there were also some very specific issues that were important: a high public debt, a high public deficit, a problem of non-payment to many suppliers of the Administrations, and the impossibility of financing in the markets. We have made decisions to try to address all those problems, and I believe that some steps have also been taken in the right direction. We have also tried, after completing two of the major infrastructures, the AVE and the El Prat Airport, to initiate a third: the Mediterranean Corridor, another of the most important infrastructures.

Therefore, all the initiatives that the Government has adopted over this time --some I understand may not please everyone, as is natural; but that is normal-- had one objective: to solve the most important problem that Spaniards have at this moment and that you and I share.

As for the rest, I will tell you the following: I ran for election with an electoral program in which I did not talk about reforming the Spanish Constitution, in which I did not talk about reforming the regulatory framework, and in which I did not talk about reforming the rules of the game, precisely for the reason that the priority was what you yourself have said today here in this Chamber. However, if there are other people who think differently, they have every right to do so.

There are instruments in the current legislation to propose reforms. My position will be the one you know, it will be a position of dialogue; but there are some issues on which I, as president of the Government, cannot be asked to yield in my proposals, because Article 1 and Article 2 of the Constitution, Spain and national sovereignty, for me are non-negotiable, and I am sure they are for you as well.

Mr. Montilla.- As you say, on previous occasions I have asked you similar questions and you have responded, I must say, correctly, constructively. You have spoken to me, as today, about these common objectives of Catalonia and the rest of Spain, such as overcoming the crisis, being able to generate employment… Also, referring to some of the instruments that have been created during this period, such as the Autonomous Liquidity Fund, to, among other things, solve the problem that the Communities currently have of not accessing the capital markets, as you know.

But, Mr. President, I am not only talking to you today about instruments that can be generalized to all Autonomous Communities; I am talking specifically about Catalonia. Is this not where we have the main territorial problem?

Has dialogue and negotiation with Catalonia been opened, Mr. President? I have read in recent days that this is the case, that dialogue has begun to take place. If that is so, and you will confirm it to me, I am sincerely glad. I am glad that you are willing to abandon passivity and that the president of the Generalitat has also abandoned or set aside his yielding attitude to the vocation of permanent dialogue as a prelude to the necessary and convenient pacts and agreements.

Mr. President, those who do not listen cannot speak, and those who do not speak cannot negotiate, agree, or come to an agreement; and those who do not agree do not serve their country or the general interests. You know that politics is, among other things, dialogue, pact, and agreement.

I am also glad to have read, and you will confirm it, that you have decided to lower the tension and that, finally, you have ordered verbal moderation and discretion in the approaches.

Mr. President, do not let yourself be influenced by those who believe that the passage of time will solve this problem, but even less by those who advise confrontation and a hard hand. The cost would be to deepen, perhaps irreversibly, the existing fissures between Catalonia and the rest of Spain, also favoring the growing fracture within Catalan society.

There are those who speak, you know, of demographic and electoral calculations saying that you and your party are already interested in the tension, the confrontation, with the Catalan issue in the background, as it re-groups your electorate and disperses that of the alternative. I do not know if I am naive, but I do not believe you are capable of that. I want to believe that the medium and long-term interests of all Spaniards are above short-term electoral maneuvers.

You must govern keeping in mind the Constitution and the defense of the Rule of Law; but this does not obligate you, in any way, to ensure that the only messages, accompanied by actions that we perceive from Catalonia, have been political initiatives characterized by the majority of Catalan political formations as weakening self-government and undermining their competences. The LOMCE, the best example.

The Catalan issue is not resolved with the passage of time, but from action; it is not resolved, obviously, by raising walls, but by opening doors, building bridges, and it is not resolved by speculating or provoking errors from the supposed adversary. The Catalan issue, Mr. President, when it rots, is not better; it is worse, much worse. Start taking steps in the right direction; the first, in attitude and tone, I hope, seeking environmental moderation to open an opportunity for dialogue. That is what I have perceived.

But to dialogue without moving, to dialogue from immobility, can only increase frustration and deterioration as well. What are you willing to do to resolve the Catalan issue? A few days ago you dismissed the so-called "third way," but will yours be capable of resolving the underlying and formal problems? The problem will be if your way is one-way and Mr. Mas's is a dead end. We need other paths to walk, to meet, to resolve the problems. Start with words and then accompany them with actions. Do not give more arguments to those who want to leave, who bet on independence.

The president of the Generalitat has committed, as you know, to hold a consultation next year. You know that by the end of the year he may present the explicit question that the Government of Catalonia wants to ask and the date on which it wants to hold it. It is not the best way to approach a negotiation, I admit; but the outcome could be worse, as you know: a unilateral declaration of independence. If that were to happen, it would be a failure for Catalonia, but also for Spain.

I am not an independentist. I do not believe that secession of a territory is possible today in Europe unless it is through a process agreed upon with the State, as is the case in Scotland; but the political and institutional crisis and the emotional rift it would provoke would negatively affect us all for years.

You, Mr. President, are obliged to avoid that crisis because you are the president of the Government and you have the majority to do so. Dialogue with the Government of Catalonia and dialogue with the Socialist Party, with all those of us who want to be together, but better.

We expect from you, Mr. President --and with this I conclude-- not only good words but gestures and initiatives that accompany them in the line of giving the impression that you are aware of the problem and, moreover, that you want to resolve it. Are you willing to express, within the framework of respect for the Rule of Law, initiatives that could allow for a better fit of Catalonia in Spain?

The Constitution, and with this I do conclude, is not an immutable text. It can be changed if a broad majority wishes so, if it is the best way to guarantee coexistence, Mr. President. There are political formations that have proposed this. Do not close this door. Say it here with responsibility and you will have taken a more important initial step to open other paths, the inclusive ones for coexistence and agreement. Spain deserves it, and so does Catalonia, and you are the President. Do not shirk responsibility. We are listening to you, Mr. President.

President.- Thank you very much for your intervention, Mr. Montilla. I explained to you in my first intervention what the Government's initiatives are, and I explained that all of them are aimed at the same objective: to face the crisis, to get out of the situation, to grow and create jobs. I believe this is the main concern of all Spaniards.

Now I would like to add something more. I want Catalonia to definitively overcome the crisis; I want it to continue being the engine of our country, in economic matters and in other areas as well; I want it to recover that dynamism and its strength; I want us to live together, as always; I want us to work to strengthen the emotional, family, commercial, and historical ties that unite us, those that unite those who have always lived together; and I want us to combine efforts to be strong in an open, global world, with fewer borders and much more competitive. And because I want all this, I did not propose in the electoral program with which we presented ourselves for the elections any reform of the current legal framework.

I will tell you something more, and understand that I am going to say it because I value your attitude and your intervention. You are not naive: nothing moves me more when making decisions than the general interest of Spaniards. What is the point of entering into my position on moderation, dialogue, or confrontation? I believe that, as president of the Government, I must act with the balance, sensibility, and common sense with which the president of this country must act, regardless of the party and whatever it is called.

Mr. Montilla, I do not dismiss any path, nor do I despise, nor will I ever despise, any opinion. But I will tell you one thing in which I deeply believe: from what I see and from what I think, I am much closer to you --look at what I am telling you-- than some people from your party. The essential and what is being debated here is Article 1 and Article 2 of the Constitution. I am not in favor of changing it; I believe, as I have said, in national unity and I believe that sovereignty belongs to all Spaniards. And I am absolutely convinced that you do not either, which reassures and comforts me.

From there, if someone wants to do it, let them do it, following the procedures established in the laws that we have all approved at the time.

Mr. Montilla, I am not against reforming the Constitution just for the sake of it. In fact, I have supported the two reforms of the Constitution that were proposed in this country, in Spain; as I have said on some occasions, the last one proposed by the former president of the Government, José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero. However, I want to tell you one thing: when we talk about reforming the Constitution, we are not talking about reforming the rate of the Personal Income Tax; we are talking about the rules of the game, the norms of coexistence, and it is very important to know what we want to change, it is very important to have it very clear, and it is very important to achieve, and to have, the maximum possible consensus, and it is very important to choose the right moment.

With all due respect, I will tell you one thing, and I do it from the respect I have for you: I have the impression that proposing a reform of the Constitution to satisfy someone who will not feel satisfied with that reform of the Constitution is a huge mistake. I, for my part, will not do it.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Narvay Quintero, of the Mixed Parliamentary Group

Mr. Quintero.- We are approaching the halfway point of the Legislature and I would like us to take stock of your commitments, both in your electoral campaign and in the Investiture Debate. I will remind you of some of them.

You said that your commitment to the Economic and Fiscal Regime of the Canary Islands would be total, full, and absolute; you guaranteed that you would maintain the same policy in the rehabilitation of the tourist spaces of the Canary Islands; you assured that the POSEI was very important and your commitment to Canary agriculture was clear.

He said that he agreed with the extension of the air fare bonuses and informed us that the policy in this area at the Canary Islands airports would be different from that of the rest of the territory, and that the Canary Islands airports would also have the Fifth Freedom.

He also said that he would subsidize the transport of bananas so that they could compete on equal terms with plantains, that is, up to 70 percent of the transport, as you well know, supported by the European Union.

He also mentioned that he would carry out an Infrastructure Plan, a Coast Plan, a Road Plan, and a specific Employment Plan for the Canary region.

And he said, during your visit to the island of El Hierro, that if he were the President of the Government of Spain, which he is, he would expand the Los Cangrejos airport, the airport of the Island of Hierro, the runway; he would lower flight costs and improve our connections.

That is why, Mr. President, I ask you: do you believe that you have fulfilled your commitments to a territory, according to you, in response to a question I asked you just over a year ago, one of the most affected by the crisis and that would need special attention to alleviate the disadvantages of remoteness, insularity, and outermost regions, and that did not have those great highways and communication networks, as the continental territories do?

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Quintero. Just as it happens to you, my time is limited; it is what it is; but I will try to respond to what I believe is most essential and to what I think are the problems we must try to resolve in the Canary Islands as urgently as possible.

In my opinion, the first problem in the Canary Islands at this moment is unemployment and, within unemployment, youth unemployment. The objective of the Government, and I made this explicit in the Investiture Debate, was to grow, and to grow and create jobs, because that, as I pointed out in response to the previous question, is what allows for more public income and, therefore, improves services. This applies to the Canary Islands and, naturally, to all of Spain. And all the policies we have carried out, both at the national level and at the European level, have that objective: we are going to grow and we are going to create jobs.

Furthermore, in the Investiture Debate, I also committed to a shock plan for youth employment and we have made some decisions that have been positive: first, the labor reform; then, dual vocational education; then came the Youth Entrepreneurship and Employment Strategy, and then, the Entrepreneurs Law.

Therefore, there is a general policy to combat youth unemployment and there is also a specific policy that pursues the same objective. And the key is that little by little we are achieving results. I believe, I insist, that this is the most important issue for the Canary Islands.

Today we have had data that is encouraging. Both the registered unemployment data and the Social Security affiliation data are encouraging. They are clearly insufficient, of course, but we are no longer going down; we have already started to rise. Specifically, youth unemployment for people under twenty-five years old today is 7 percent less than a year ago; that is a positive data point. And since the Youth Employment and Entrepreneurship Strategy was approved, more than one hundred thousand young people (100,910) have found a job opportunity, either as self-employed or wage earners; they have secured a job, which represents that 420 young people a day have found employment.

Also in the Canary Islands, in the last six months, unemployment has decreased by 3.9 percent and Social Security affiliation has also increased. Clearly insufficient, I can already tell you, but I believe this is the most important problem and where we must concentrate. We have already managed to overcome the most difficult and complicated phase, and I hope that from now on we will receive all, especially the Canarians, very good news.

From there, you speak to me about many issues. I do not know how much time I will have to respond to you.

Regarding the Economic and Fiscal Regime of the Canary Islands, you do not have to convince me; do not make an effort. I am absolutely in favor of the Economic and Fiscal Regime of the Canary Islands. At this moment we are processing the request and notification for the extension, until June 30, 2014, and next year we will address the various issues that are requested regarding the new Regime, which will cover from 2014 to 2020, and which, as I already indicated in the Investiture Debate, and I reaffirm now, will allow us to fulfill all those aspects of the REF that are not currently being met and to update those that can be improved.

From there, we have tried to make an effort, in a difficult budgetary situation, in terms of infrastructure. I believe that in tourism the Government is doing a good job; we are also making efforts in transportation and also in agriculture, and also, if you allow me, in energy matters.

All of these, which are the same ones you have referred to, are the commitments I mentioned in the Investiture Debate and, honestly, when not even half of the Legislature has passed, I believe I can tell you that we are on track to fulfill them and, above all, to successfully address the most important one, which is youth employment and job creation.

Mr. Quintero.- Mr. President, I obviously completely agree with you that the most serious problem, not only in the Canary Islands but in all of Spain, is unemployment. But allow me to say that I do not agree with you, not in your words, which I do, but not in the actions of your Government, and allow me to explain why.

I believe that of the commitments you have made, almost none have been fulfilled; on the contrary, some have almost ceased to exist, others have disappeared — and I will now explain which ones — and others have gone in the opposite direction to what you committed to.

In the Economic and Fiscal Regime of the Canary Islands, which you have mentioned, far from currently fulfilling its objectives and promises, your Government has widened the gap of average investment per inhabitant in the Canary Islands compared to the average investment of the State. You eliminated outright the fifty million euros of the third year of the Tourism Rehabilitation Plan without any justification; a tourism sector that, as you well know, is one of the most important engines of the Canary economy. The aids, both economic and political agreements with third countries, currently leave the primary sector, the most sensitive part of our economy, in a very delicate and uncertain situation. The aid for the transport of bananas, which we spoke about earlier, instead of being at 70 percent, in these 2014 Budgets does not even reach 26 percent.

A few days after your investiture, your Government did not extend the bonuses for air fares, which you had promised and which some members of your Government defined as "Bolshevik policies, perverse, bread for today and hunger for tomorrow." Fortunately, it is wise to correct, and your Government, not long ago, after two years, made a 180-degree turn and reinstated the bonuses on air fares; that yes, for all airports. But let me tell you that it was forced by the crisis at Barajas airport and not by the demand, both from the Canary Islands and from the Balearic Islands, which we have been demanding for two years. And the Fifth Freedom that you promised, Mr. President, for Canary airports has not been heard of since.

The special plans for the Canary Islands, for roads, for infrastructure, and for coasts, are almost non-existent. Let me tell you that only in the road plan in its three budgetary exercises, it has been reduced by nothing less than 462 million. And the most important one, the employment plan, which you have spoken about, and I agree with you, the Specific Employment Plan for the Canary Islands in these 2014 Budgets has completely disappeared. But, as I see that you agree with me that the greatest need of the Canary Islands and Spain is employment, you still have time to rectify it. Amend it and reinstate the Specific Employment Plan for the Canary Islands with the budgets we had, because your Government has withdrawn it, Mr. President.

Regarding the commitment to the island of El Hierro, which you have not mentioned, and which I represent in the Senate, unfortunately, the expansion of the airport is neither seen nor expected from your Government. And instead of lowering the price of plane tickets and improving connections, we have lost more than ten weekly connections for an island like El Hierro, which only has two on some days. We can leave or enter at eight in the morning and return at six in the evening, and there are no more connections from the island of El Hierro to any island. Apart from that, we have increased the price by 14 percent in the last two years.

Mr. President, you, and any Spaniard and foreigner, can travel from Madrid to Segovia, round trip, thirty minutes of travel, for eighteen euros. We, the Canarians, from Tenerife to El Hierro, thirty minutes also of flight, have to pay 170 euros. Is this the equality of opportunity you speak of or is this the territorial cohesion you refer to? I believe we are not on equal terms, Mr. President.

You may say that it is a collective effort, and you have said so, and I agree with you. You may even blame the Government of the Canary Islands, and, evidently, the Government of the Canary Islands has also made many mistakes; but the Canary Islands have very different geographical singularities from other territories. For this reason, the "coffee for all" approach does not work for us, Mr. President. We need different policies and solutions for different territories. "The equality of Spaniards means treating unequally those who are unequal." This phrase should sound familiar to you, Mr. President, because it is yours and I fully share it; but your policies do not reflect the same.

Mr. President of the Government, you are leading our Canary land and Spain to massive impoverishment and selective enrichment, where the only green shoots, unfortunately, are only seen by the companies listed on the IBEX and the great fortunes. The middle class of Spain and the Canary Islands is disappearing.

And I will conclude. If there is any possibility, however small, of giving meaning to this Chamber, since your electoral commitments have not been fulfilled, execute the initiatives that are approved in this Chamber; even more so, if only those that are supported by the party that supports the Government, the majority party, are approved. On June 5, 2012, I presented an initiative with five specific measures for the island of El Hierro to recover its economy, approved in this Chamber, and your Government has not executed any of them.

Mr. President, if you value this Chamber, at least take that motion and execute it, and give meaning to a Chamber that is very devalued in the eyes of citizens. I hope, Mr. President, that you understand what I am asking and that you assume the consequences. You still have time to fulfill your commitments. Let us hope, Mr. President, that it is not too late.

President.- Thank you very much for your words, Mr. Quintero. I understand them, believe me, I understand them. And I cannot share much of the assertions you have made.

Since the General State Budgets were presented, I find myself in a strange situation: several deputies from different Spanish territorial constituencies have told me how poorly the State Budgets treat their constituency. Someone will have to say one day who, then, are the beneficiaries of the decisions made by the Government. We try to make decisions in defense of the general interests of all of Spain, and that is what we have also done on this occasion.

I will respond to two or three issues. Just recently, the spokesperson for Convergència i Unió told me how poorly the General State Budgets treat Catalonia; last week, in Congress, I had to respond to the mistreatment by the Government, because there was a deputy from Navarra, to the constituency of Navarra. This happens regularly. I am already used to it; it is my duty to respond to what you have pointed out, but I wanted to preface it with this introduction that you have just heard.

I will talk to you about Employment Plans. There were Employment Plans for the Canary Islands and there were Employment Plans for Andalusia, and for Galicia, and for Castilla-La Mancha, and for Extremadura, and for many regions of Spain. The problem is that the Employment Plans were not useful. What they served for was to increase unemployment in all regions of Spain in recent years. And now we are going to change the policies that have been shown not to have worked; we are now going to agree among all, in the Sectoral Conference, and be more effective. Precisely, this Friday the Council of Ministers will approve the allocations of the Employment Plan which, in the case of the Canary Islands, amount to 76 million euros.

But, I insist, the most important thing in employment is not a plan for a region nor is it a specific plan for a municipality; the most important thing is the large general policies, which are the ones that must provoke economic activity and, therefore, growth and employment in our country.

You have said that we must treat unequally those who are unequal, quoting me. I agree, as is natural, with myself and I also agree with what you quote me on; but, of course, you say this to me while talking about the Economic and Fiscal Regime of the Canary Islands. The Economic and Fiscal Regime of the Canary Islands is unique and exclusively for the Canary Islands, and it is so for the reasons that you and I know perfectly well. I have always defended it and I will continue to do so in the future, and, as I said, we are going to request an extension now and we will negotiate in the first half of next year.

You can make whatever criticism you deem appropriate and convenient regarding tourism; you have every right to do so; but this is the best tourist year in many years in the Canary Islands and in other places in Spain. Therefore, perhaps the timing of your comments has not been the most appropriate on your part.

I believe that in terms of transportation, as you have said, we have made decisions. Certainly, all the commitments I stated in my investiture speech are now in effect. You have asked whether we have rectified or not. I do not have data at this moment, but what you have said, and I believe you, is what I had committed to in the Investiture Debate.

Therefore, Mr. Quintero, I understand your position; you are right to defend the interests of the constituency you have chosen; but you should also acknowledge that the Government of Spain is addressing the most important issues, which are those that affect the Canary Islands and all citizens, and that we are already beginning to see some positive things, although some do not want to share this because it seems that they do not like it very much. This is not your case.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Marcelino Iglesias, of the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Mr. Iglesias.- Mr. President of the Government, as it appears on the screens, I ask you today about the Education Law. But I believe that all of Spain needs an answer on an education issue: Mr. President, what are you going to do with the Erasmus scholarships?

President.- I understand that you are asking me two questions, one more specific, referring to the Erasmus scholarships, and the other question refers to education, to the modification of the Law that is currently still not definitively approved in the General Courts.

Regarding what we are going to do with the Erasmus scholarships, we are going to do exactly the same thing we did last year, as the Minister of Education has just told the media, which, it seems, you have not been aware of. But, in any case, I can do it here at this moment. I hope to have your full and total support for the announcement I have just made; I expect that, Mr. Iglesias. Thank you very much for your attention.

The purpose of the reform of the Education Law, Mr. Iglesias, is to improve the quality of education; that is the objective. Our educational system has achieved important milestones; we all know that; but we cannot deny that there are things that do not work, and that translates into fewer opportunities for new generations in the future. And this is the issue: to guarantee opportunities for the future.

I do not want to overwhelm you with data, which, on the other hand, you are well aware of; but the dropout and school failure rates in Spain are almost double the OECD average, which means that one in four students, one in four young Spaniards, do not finish their studies and, therefore, have very few opportunities, due to their low qualifications, to find work in the future.

I want to remind you of the international results of the PISA reports, which are published periodically: Spain is very low; we need to be much better. The PISA report for adults, which we learned about not long ago, is not something we can be proud of, precisely. One in four, 40 percent, to be exact, of students under fifteen years old have already repeated a grade, and there are few vocational training students.

I believe there are things that need to be improved, and this is especially evident because Spain spends 15 percent more on education than the OECD and European Union average. Between 2000 and 2009, we doubled spending on education. Well, Your Honor, something is happening; something is going on: we spend more than others, and the results are worse. And in this situation, there are two things to do: one, do nothing, which is what you want, and the other, make reasonable changes, which is what we propose, which is not an absolute change in the Law. It is not an entirely new law, no; it is a reform of the current legislation.

For thirty years in Spain, socialist legislation has been applied, and the results are improvable. Look, let us improve the system and do not ask me, being fully aware and having the total and absolute conviction that this is the case, not to do anything on one of the most important issues for the future of our children, of the children and of the Spaniards. I will not remain inactive.

Mr. Iglesias.- Mr. President of the Government, it is true that I have listened to the minister; but the minister said one thing on the 29th, another thing yesterday, and another thing today, and you are the one who has to bring order to the Government. I do not know if the minister, because he was not in the Senate at that moment, went up to the press conference to say: "since I messed up, I rectify and I leave." I do not know if he said that, but that is what I believe a reasonable minister should have done, because the shock he has caused with the Erasmus scholarships has been magnificent.

Look, first we send students to Europe; first, the students and their families organize to spend a year in Europe, almost forty thousand students, and once they are there, they have found accommodation, they have found an apartment, and they have settled in, we tell them that they will not receive assistance. Of course, that is madness, Mr. President, and that is why I would like to know your opinion as President of the Government, because the minister's press conference is one thing, the decree is another, and what the newspapers announced yesterday is something completely different.

Mr. President, if the minister has rectified, I ask you to rectify as well with the Law, to rectify with a law that nobody supports: that the school community does not support, that the Autonomous Communities do not support, and that the teachers do not support. It is the first time in the history of Spain that we have two strikes and nobody supporting an Education Law.

Look, an Education Law should have stability. I am not saying that everything that has been done so far is right. Minister Gabilondo spent a year trying to negotiate with you a reform of the Education Law, and it was not negotiated because the elections came, and someone did not want the political opponent to use that victory. That is the reality.

But we are not stuck in that improvements cannot be made, Mr. President. However, what we do not agree on is demonizing a public education system that has worked well; a system that, when you compare it to Finland, which is possibly one of the best education systems in the world, the Minister forgets a small detail: a hundred years ago in Finland, there was a 5 percent illiteracy rate, and thirty years ago in Spain, a 25 percent. With those data, in Spain, with a 25 percent illiteracy rate when the Constitution was approved, it has been achieved that 40 percent of our young people are higher education graduates. Is that a failure? That is a reality; that is the reality of our country.

I believe that the educational system we have created together has been a successful system, which can undoubtedly be improved. But look at what I have told you: you have campaigned saying that if the PISA report, etc., etc. With the same laws, there are Autonomous Communities that have results superior to Finland, and with the same Law, there are Autonomous Communities that have results that are much lower, which means that it is not, Mr. President, a problem of the Law. Here we have other problems.

School failure, from my point of view, during the growth period has much more to do with the young people who left school and went into construction or services than with problems in the Education Law.

Mr. President, allow me to tell you a little story, and I hope the President of the Chamber gives me time. A hundred years ago, Ramón y Cajal, Mr. Santiago Ramón y Cajal, won the Nobel Prize in Medicine; a little over a hundred years ago, in 1906, he was awarded the Nobel Prize. Ramón y Cajal, when he was a child, was an impossible child. His father, from a modest family, wanted him to be a doctor; he insisted that he become a doctor and took him to the Escolapios, the best school in the area. They expelled him from the Escolapios; he was an impossible child; a rebellious, seditious, and incorrigible child; an impossible child, a child of school failure, Mr. Minister. They expelled him from school, and not only that: at ten or twelve years old, he spent several days in the local jail. That is how complicated Ramón y Cajal was.

In the end, his father decided that he should learn a trade, to learn to be a barber and a tooth extractor, and he did. But his father regretted it and said: let’s try again. He tried again and made a deal with the boy that he would return to school. He would behave well, return to school, and let him draw, which is what he wanted to do. He returned to school, passed his Baccalaureate, and graduated in Medicine, and in 1906 he was awarded the Nobel Prize. He had written one of the reference texts for neuroscience: "The Structure of the Nervous System of Man and Vertebrates." Even today, scientists refer to that book by Mr. Santiago Ramón y Cajal.

Mr. Santiago Ramón y Cajal, Mr. Minister and Mr. President, with your Law of itineraries, of Darwinian selection, and of revalidas would have been a magnificent barber-tooth extractor, but he would never have been a Nobel Prize winner.

President.- Mr. Iglesias, with the permission of the President, I would like to inform part of this Chamber, because the rest of this Chamber already knows it: when Mr. Santiago Ramón y Cajal studied, the socialist model was not the model with which one studied in Spain.

Mr. Iglesias, living with your back to reality does not solve problems, and saying that our educational system does not need reforms is not understanding what is happening. And, of course, I think it is not bad to remember that there are many things that can be improved.

Look, with the problems of youth unemployment we have here, with the problems of training, with the problems we have with qualifications, with school dropout and with school failure, as President of the Government, you can ask me for whatever you want; but the only thing you cannot ask me is to do nothing and not to have the ambition to try to make things better. I cannot accept that request.

What we intend is an educational model that provides opportunities for our young people in an increasingly difficult and competitive world.

You like to talk a lot about public education. Look, I studied part of my university career, actually all of it, but part of my Baccalaureate in public education and part in private education. And I will tell you one thing very clearly: the best defense that can be made of public education, the best, is to solve its problems, and the greatest attack that can be made on public education is not to resolve the serious problems it has. This is said by someone who studied in public education.

You like to talk a lot, and you always do when you talk about education, about ideological reforms. The worst ideology is to insist on leaving things as they are when things are not well and can be improved. I will never have such prejudices, and when something, whether I have done it or you have done it, or anyone, believes it can be improved, I will take my responsibility, which is to try to do so. In the meantime, if you want, you can stay with your immobility.

You believe that because you have made some laws, which undoubtedly have some positive aspects and have served, they cannot be improved; you are mistaken. I, for my part, will not remain still because I would be irresponsible to the entire Spanish society.

Thank you very much.