Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

21 January 2014 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to parliamentary questions on abortion law reform and the Basque Y high-speed rail project during a January 2014 congressional control session in Spain.
Main themes
Abortion law reform, constitutional doctrine and reproductive rights, Basque Y high-speed rail project, infrastructure investment and budget constraints, parliamentary accountability, government commitments and broken promises, Basque regional infrastructure priorities, budgetary restrictions
Duration
~16 min
56th percentile
Words
1,972
56th percentile
Sentences
91
58th percentile
Readability
56
79th percentile
Grade
10.5
27th percentile
Syntax
2.96
42nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
42nd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 39%38%
  • Social 36%35%
  • Institutional 16%15%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

91 sentences in 37 paragraphs

Mr. Ruiz-Gallardón, the only thing we women are victims of is intolerant and fundamentalist ideologies, and we want to be responsible for our actions. We do not want you to liberate us from being people. We want to be people with all rights.

Ladies and gentlemen, this Law, the current Law, recognizes the first fourteen weeks as a gestation period for abortion. The ruling even recognizes up to the moment of the unborn...

President.- Thank you very much, Madam Deputy. As you know, this Government committed to the Spanish people at the polls to modify a law enacted by the socialist Government in 2010, deviating from the doctrine of the Constitutional Court and acting unilaterally. Therefore, this is the first reason why we are proposing this Draft Law.

There are some points that are undoubtedly controversial. This is a Draft that will be submitted to debate. There are different views in society; it is an enormously sensitive issue, and I believe it should be treated with that sensitivity and delicacy.

It is not about seeking legislation that aligns with the personal or individual principles of any person or sector, nor imposing a personal option, but rather that it is in accordance with constitutional doctrine, respectful of the rights of all, and applicable to the majority of society. That is the Government's will, sir.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Aitor Esteban, from the Basque Parliamentary Group EAJ-PNV

Mr. Esteban.- Mr. President, I read directly from the Senate's Journal of Sessions of March 5. You, in response to a question from our spokesperson in that Chamber, said literally: "we are firmly committed to the development of the Basque Y as a priority project. Our intention is to maintain the work pace so that its commissioning is a reality within the planned deadlines. It is true that this year 2013 the budget allocation has been reduced, but it can be stated that this allocation is sufficient to continue with the ongoing platform works, to begin the works of the Atxondo-Abadiño section, and to initiate the bidding for the sections corresponding to the Bergara knot. Therefore, it can be done, and I want it to be done. In the case of the line between Burgos and Vitoria, the allocation provided in the General State Budgets is 130 million euros."

Well, Mr. President, you have neither tendered anything for the Bergara knot nor for the Atxondo-Abadiño section. What have you done? Because you have also done nothing for the section between Burgos and Vitoria. And, of course, you have therefore failed to keep your promise. We are already in 2014.

The Bergara knot is fundamental because we run a serious risk of the Gipuzkoan arm of the Basque Y becoming isolated and those works not being connected and deteriorating over time.

There is a lack of commitment from your Government. We see it this way, Mr. President, because you do not even execute the already small budget that has existed this last year 2013. And we are talking about a priority axis of connection with Europe. Even the City Council of Valladolid, your own party members, are telling you that this is a priority axis and that we must insist and prioritize this line.

Therefore, are you going to keep your word, even if it is late?

President.- It is not a problem of commitment, Mr. Esteban; it is a problem of budgetary resources.

In any case, I want to say that I maintain my commitment to the development of the Basque Y as a priority project. I want to remind you that the investments executed between 2012 and 2013, in a context of budgetary restriction, as you know, amount to 1.106 billion euros, and this represents nearly 50 percent of the total invested since the work began. In fact, the average investment in 2012 and 2013 triples that of the period 2006-2011. Likewise, we must continue to advance our goal of providing High-Speed access to the three Basque capitals, and in this regard, we are reaching agreements based on technically and economically viable solutions.

Regarding the section corresponding to the Bergara knot, it has a project that has already been, as you know, approved and is pending bidding. As soon as we have the slightest possibility of doing so, you can be absolutely certain that we will do it.

Mr. Esteban.- Mr. President, you said that there was already money in 2013 to do it, and you have not done it, nor the Atxondo section either. Less and less money in the Budgets, and you do not have a firm commitment to move forward on this issue. You are pushing forward some lines without any type of connection and without any type of priority, which will, frankly, provide very little benefit to the citizens, while this priority axis is completely abandoned. Money, investments, and not words, Mr. President. That will be necessary for you to demonstrate this year, and if not, all that touted commitment of your political party and your Government will amount to absolutely nothing.

President.- What do you understand by the expression "nothing"? I will tell you, since you are left with "nothing," what is "nothing" for you.

In the 2012 fiscal year, in a moment of budgetary restriction, 307 million euros were dedicated to this project, plus the 347 million euros executed by the Basque Government charged to the Quota and, therefore, financed by the State. That is why we talk about 655 million euros for the Basque Y in 2012.

It is true that this has been reduced in 2013, but of the twenty sections of the Basque Y whose execution corresponds to ADIF, eight sections have the platform works completed or nearly completed, and six sections are in the construction phase.

And in the 2014 Budgets, 190 million have been allocated for the Basque Y, and additionally, other amounts for the sections of Valladolid-Venta de Baños-Burgos-Vitoria, which means we are talking about a total of 377 million euros.

Look, this is not the word "nothing" that you referred to. It is evident that we are in a moment of budgetary difficulty; but it is evident that we have the commitment to do it, and a good proof that we have the commitment to do it are the figures we are allocating to this infrastructure. Furthermore, we have held the Monitoring and Coordination Commission of the Agreement for the Construction of the Basque Y, which had not been convened since 2006, and it will meet again now, in 2014. Additionally, a week ago, the Minister of Development met with the Basque Minister, and we are going to work in a coordinated manner to try to expedite this with the budgetary resources we have.

Therefore, I insist, I maintain the commitment...

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Alfredo Pérez Rubalcaba, from the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.- Mr. President, do you believe that your Government guarantees the right to health protection for citizens?

President.- Yes.

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.- Mr. President, you started by taking away the right to public healthcare from irregular immigrants, a clumsy decision and, if I may, I would call it cruel; so much so that no Autonomous Community applies it, although some have to sneak immigrants in through the back door of hospitals.

Then you imposed the pharmaceutical copayment. Could you explain to me why the pharmaceutical copayment for pensioners has increased by 1.47 percent, when the CPI has risen by 0.3 percent and pensions by 0.25 percent?

Could you tell me in this Chamber why you have not reviewed the reference prices of drugs in the public health system? Do you know that the State has lost more money by not making that review, that is, it has given more money to the pharmaceutical industries than it has collected, than it has received, from the pharmaceutical copayment from pensioners?

Then, you wanted to impose copayment on ambulances, and you had to withdraw it because the Council of State reminded you that people do not take ambulances for tourism.

After that, you imposed hospital copayment, which is another clumsy and cruel measure, which does not collect money and means that people who need to take medications to survive have to pay for it. Look, no one is going to apply it because no one can apply it after your general secretary, president of the Community of Castilla-La Mancha, has said that she is not going to do it. Who is going to do it if even Mrs. Cospedal does not apply it?

And then, what you have done is take away the health card from people who are more than three months outside of Spain. Another cruelty. People who go to look for work are left without a health card after three months. Five Communities have said that they are not going to apply it, which means that in the end, no one is going to apply it, Mr. Rajoy.

Look, I know you do not like to anticipate events. I am not going to ask you for that; I am going to ask you the opposite: to review it, to withdraw some things. I am going to ask you to restore healthcare to irregular immigrants, to return the health card to Spanish emigrants who have had it taken away, to withdraw hospital copayment, and to put the reference prices into effect so that you can eliminate pharmaceutical copayment for pensioners. And I will tell you more: it costs nothing; it costs nothing, Mr. Rajoy. Do you know what it saves? Suffering for many Spaniards.

President.- It costs nothing, Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba, if it is not paid. When we came to Government, the debt of the National Health System was 16 billion euros, pharmaceutical suppliers were being paid in 525 days, pharmaceutical spending was the highest in all of Europe, 3,700 tons of expired medications were thrown away each year, and healthcare tourism cost one billion euros.

Now, transfers to the Autonomous Communities have increased by 7.4 percent, the bulk of which is dedicated to healthcare spending. In the Supplier Payment Plan, we have paid 18.5 billion euros. The FLA dedicates 60 percent of the resources that it does not allocate to meet debt maturities to healthcare.

I will tell you two or three things. Look, when you were in power, there was copayment, and certainly, long-term unemployed people had to pay 40 percent before, and now, with the decisions of the Government I lead, they pay nothing. So, do not demagogue on this issue.

And I will tell you another thing about the withdrawal of the health card after three months; I will explain it to you: all students who go abroad have the Spanish health card; all those who go to work, all, after ninety days have the health card of the country in question, and when they come to Spain, they use it, and if they return to Spain, they get the health card again. But I will tell you another thing, which is the most important: we have done this because this is included in a European Directive that was approved when you were in the Government of Spain. This is the issue. Therefore, I ask you not to demagogue.

As for illegal immigrants, they have healthcare attention for all minors... I know you do not like to hear these things, but it is not possible to continuously demagogue on this issue.

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba, healthcare in Spain, fortunately, is public, universal, free, and today also sustainable, and, in addition, there is a pact that has been made with all healthcare professionals in the sector, something that you never did when you were in the Government of Spain.