Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

13 May 2014 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to parliamentary questions during a government control session in the Spanish Congress on 13 May 2014, addressing press freedom concerns.
Main themes
Press freedom in Spain, media independence, democracy and free press, Freedom House ranking, self-censorship, media plurality, political interference in media, freedom of expression
Duration
~15 min
52nd percentile
Words
1,818
52nd percentile
Sentences
61
40th percentile
Readability
42
40th percentile
Grade
14.5
72nd percentile
Syntax
3.33
84th percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
35th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 35%31%
  • Economic 29%26%
  • Geopolitical 18%16%
  • Ceremonial 11%10%
  • Social 7%7%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 10%

61 sentences in 26 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Ms. Rosa Díez, of the Parliamentary Group Union, Progress and Democracy

Ms. Díez. - The clearest example of the existence of a depreciated democracy is often measured by the absence of a free and independent press. We have just learned of the world ranking on press freedom, conducted by Freedom House, which states that the lowest level of democracy in Spain, from the perspective of independent press, is occurring at this moment. The independence --says that report-- of journalists has been decreasing over the last decade to the level of Ghana, Suriname, or the Solomon Islands. We are about to stop being considered, from the press perspective, a free country and become a partially free country.

Since 2013 we have fallen from position number 39 to position number 52; since 2013, in just one year. Among the most restrictive countries, Spain scores twenty-eight out of one hundred points, of which fourteen are due to obstacles imposed by political power, six to legal limitations on the freedom to inform, and eight to economic conditions.

In recent years, we have been overtaken by countries that emerged from the Iron Curtain, Pacific islands, and South American countries. Portugal is ten points ahead of us; the Czech Republic, eight; Slovakia and Lithuania, four. Of the countries in the Union, only Berlusconi's Italy --only, Mr. President, Berlusconi's Italy-- and by a very small margin, is worse than Spain from the perspective of press freedom.

The director of this report says, among other things, about Spain that "we have seen how the media have laid off journalists, how there are fewer professionals and in worse conditions, how the media industry is declining and that makes journalists feel compelled to remain silent, worried about losing their jobs. In many cases, the situation leads to self-censorship, to not covering certain news." This will probably be one of the uncovered stories. And "at the same time, the diversity of opinion offered by the media is decreasing."

I ask you, Mr. President, in these circumstances and with this panorama, which is not stated by this political party, but by reputable reports like this one, do you believe that there can be democracy without press freedom, without an independent press?

President.- Good morning, Ms. Díez. Without a free and independent press, a democratic regime cannot exist. That is what I think, and I consider that the recognition of freedom of expression, academic freedom, and press freedom constitutes a key and essential piece of any democratic regime.

That said, you are very unfair to your country, I must tell you with absolute frankness. In Spain, there are more free television channels, both public and private, than anywhere else in the world; among public, private, national, and regional. There are a hundred newspaper titles, and in Madrid, there are four generalist newspapers. There are more economic newspapers than anywhere else in Europe, there are forty newspapers with more than one hundred thousand readers, there are ten newspapers with more than half a million readers, there are radio stations, there are digital newspapers, we have the internet... With absolute frankness, to say that there is no press freedom and freedom of expression in Spain seems to me an exaggeration, and that is why I have said: you are profoundly unfair to your country.

You have told us here a series of reports. The latest from Reporters Without Borders, which is not exactly a pro-government organization, places us in its ranking ahead of countries like the United States, France, or Italy in terms of press freedom. Therefore, I tell you, with absolute frankness, that in Spain there is freedom of expression recognized by the Constitution, and everyone exercises it regularly. I believe you should be more equitable, I say this to you with absolute frankness.

Ms. Díez. - I, equitable, and you, sincere.

Do not confuse quantity with quality, do not confuse quantity with freedom. Look, Mr. President, do not confuse public press with independent press. Here there is public press and concerted press, and that is a misfortune for democracy.

President.- I really do not have much to add to what I said in my first intervention; but I think it is an excess and an exaggeration on your part to say that there is no freedom of expression in Spain when all of us present here see every day what is written, what is said, and what is discussed on any topic, and the value judgments that are made in the exercise of freedom of expression and press by all citizens who have access to those media.

Therefore, I cannot share your statements, I do not share your opinion, and I affirm that this is a country where there is freedom of expression, as everyone who is listening to us at this moment knows.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Alfredo Pérez Rubalcaba, of the Parliamentary Group Socialist

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.- Mr. Rajoy, how do you assess the effect of your policies on Spanish citizens?

President.- The great objective of this Legislature, as you know, Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba, is to grow and create jobs, because in the four years prior to the moment we assumed the responsibility of governing, Spain was not growing and unemployment had increased by 3,400,000 people. To achieve this, we have had to correct the imbalances in the Spanish economy, the public deficit, restructure the financial system, and recover lost competitiveness through structural reforms. Difficult decisions had to be made, reforms had to be implemented, and we tried to do so equitably. We have raised taxes and reduced some expenses; but always trying to distribute among all, trying to be fair and maintaining the great pillars of the Welfare State: pension system, healthcare, education, and social services.

Today, as a result of those measures, we are much better than two years ago, this year we will already have economic growth, and next year more economic growth. This year, net job creation is already happening in Spain, the number of Social Security affiliates has been increasing for several consecutive months, and therefore, I believe that all these reforms will gradually produce results that are increasingly appreciable to the entire Spanish population.

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.- Mr. Rajoy, you know that I deeply disagree with the policies your Government has followed, which have led to more unemployment in Spain today than when you arrived, fewer social rights, fewer labor rights, and, above all, much more inequality. And you know that your forecasts, those of your Government, those made by Brussels, and those made by the OECD say something terrible, which is that this Legislature is a lost legislature for employment, which will end with fewer Spaniards working than when it began, and that your model of growth, which is based on low wages and social cuts, will not generate significant employment in the next two years.

But today, among other reasons because we are close to European elections, I think it is good to bring some reflections that I have made in this Chamber regarding Europe in the debates we have had here - debates, by the way, intense and extensive -- about Europe and that have to do precisely with how to change these negative forecasts for our country.

I have said, and I repeat today here, that the problems of the European Union, of Europe, are resolved with more Europe; that we socialists want there to be more Banking Union, among other things, so that citizens never again pay for what their managers, the managers of the banks, do wrong; that we want more Fiscal Union so that companies pay where they have their profits; that, above all, we want more Social Union, so that Europeans never again see that spectacle of a Europe skimping fifteen billion euros to combat youth unemployment; and that we want more Political Union so that Europeans know who decides and, above all, to whom those who decide are accountable.

These are the first European general elections that are held, which are key to getting out of the crisis and which are key to, among other things, getting out of the prostration in which Europe is: Europe that is demoralized, Europe in which these misguided policies have led to a breeding ground in which selfishness, xenophobia, racism… have grown, that Europe that must emerge or has to emerge from the crisis after these elections.

And let these words serve to remind Europeans that also in these elections one can say no precisely to that: to xenophobia, to racism, and to selfishness; one can say no to those who want to rule in Europe without believing in Europe, who want to govern Europe without believing in Europe and, above all, without believing in the values that gave rise to this Europe that we all want. All this is decided in these elections, and I believe…

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba. You have spoken about many things, and I will try to respond.

I am substantially in agreement, and we have seen it in the various debates that have taken place here on European matters, about what we should do in the future. I am in favor of Banking Union, I am also in favor of Fiscal Union, and of course, I am in favor of fighting against youth unemployment. It was Spain, and the Government I preside over, that proposed the initiative that was later concretized; in my opinion, with fewer resources than we would have liked, but certainly, it was useful. I am in favor of Political Union and, therefore, I am in favor of more Europe.

I believe that, fortunately, the process is irreversible, I believe that the serious euro crisis we experienced in recent years has been overcome, and from that perspective, what I believe we must continue to do is work for the future.

But one thing is what we do in Europe and another is what we do in our country, and I want to reiterate what I have also told you on some occasion in this same Chamber: today things are better than they were two years ago. That is evident. Denying reality makes no sense. We see that there are good data in Social Security: there are already more affiliates today than a year ago. The latest data from the European Union indicates that 38 percent of the number of unemployed less in all of Europe today are Spaniards; it is a positive figure. The risk premium is good, we can finance ourselves, foreign investment, tourism, and consumption have returned, and therefore, there are data that indicate that things are going in the right direction, and, as I pointed out earlier, in 2014 and 2015 there will be growth and job creation in our country.