Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

9 May 2018 · Parliamentary control session · Madrid, Spain

Context
Rajoy responded to opposition questions during a parliamentary control session in Spain's Congress on 9 May 2018, addressing corruption and governance issues.
Main themes
Institutional deterioration in Madrid, corruption scandals, Popular Party governance, pension policy, budget debate, Community of Madrid economy and employment, political accountability, parliamentary oversight, Cifuentes resignation, Social Security records
Duration
~23 min
72nd percentile
Words
2,784
72nd percentile
Sentences
134
76th percentile
Readability
58
83rd percentile
Grade
9.9
20th percentile
Syntax
3.06
55th percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
14th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 65%65%
  • Ceremonial 20%20%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 5%4%
  • Economic 5%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

134 sentences in 49 paragraphs

Mr. Rajoy, the Community of Madrid has been governed by the Popular Party for more than twenty years. And it is evident, and everyone can see that it is subjected to enormous institutional deterioration. You, as President of the Government and president of this Party that is governing in the Community of Madrid, what are you going to do to stop this institutional deterioration?

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. President.

Well, Ms. Robles, as you know, Parliament is here to oversee the Executive, and you must be very satisfied with the actions of the Executive that I preside over, which does not ask me about its actions, but about other institutions. In any case, I am willing to answer your question.

In Madrid, what has happened is that the president of the Community resigned over matters that have nothing to do with her management. Now, the institutions are functioning; the procedures for a investiture session and to elect a new president have been initiated. I just hope it happens soon.

And, secondly, I will also tell you that Madrid is the Autonomous Community of Spain where the economy and employment have grown the most, and well-being in recent years, a very significant fact, without a doubt. The most significant, perhaps, is that in April of this year, Madrid achieved a record number of affiliates to Social Security.

Therefore, it is true that some events have occurred that none of us like, but it is also evident that in parallel, the Community of Madrid continued to grow, creating jobs and generating well-being like no other Community in the rest of Spain.

Thank you very much.

Ms. Robles.- Well, I see that as President of the Government you are not interested in anything that happens in the Community of Madrid. But look, I don’t know if you are familiar with the 'Lezo case', the 'Púnica case', the 'Gürtel case', private and public dossiers that go back and forth. Videos that are kept for seven years to be released at the right moment. Cross accusations, because you know, Ms. Cifuentes is the one who denounces the 'Canal case', the one who denounces the City of Justice, where is the City of Justice?, I ask you. And, also, it turns out that Ms. Cifuentes questions the public university of Madrid, the masters. But that doesn’t matter to you, that doesn’t matter to you, and you said that Ms. Cifuentes had given reasons about it, and, moreover, you said it in front of a colleague of yours, the Danish colleague, and said, well since she has given explanations, the Government Pact must continue.

Ah! That’s right, the day a video appeared with some creams you thought, that that day you were coming here, and that you were coming here, precisely, to the total debate, of the amendments to the Budgets, that your debate on the totality would not be disturbed.

By the way, in some amendments that you agreed with the Basque Nationalist Party, and that allowed pensioners, that which a month before you did not give them, then, to be able to take out. We see how much you care about pensioners. Your Secretary of State for Communication already said it. You used pensioners as a commodity to stay longer in Government, because that is what you want, to stay longer in Government. And you do not care about the public university of Madrid. You do not care about some creams, you have to continue in Government.

And, look, we citizens are a bit tired of your finger. Your finger that makes and unmakes, but worse than you are the party of Mr. Rivera. Mr. Rivera who has the audacity to come here to give lessons to the Socialist Party, and what he is doing with your support, what he is going to do with your support is some whitening creams for corruption in Madrid. That is what matters to him.

President.- Well, Mr. Speaker, as we are talking about the Government here, I am not going to make any reference to Autonomous Communities where you have been governing for forty years and have two presidents, who have been of the same, sitting in the dock. Therefore, I will not make any reference to that matter, simply to not lower myself to your level.

I would, however, like to make a comment on the situation of pensions. Pensions this year are going to rise, thanks to the Budget Project led by the Government, quite a bit more than what the Socialist Party had proposed in this same Chamber, and if you don’t like it, I’m very sorry, but I am very satisfied with the agreement we have reached.

Probably, if you had joined the agreement, you could explain to the citizens what it is for. That is, what is the utility of your party, because I believe that in the Budget Debate, the only utility of the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party will be to say no to a Budget with a growth of 2.7, with a forecast of job creation of 475,000 jobs, with a salary increase for civil servants, after an agreement with the unions for three years, with a salary increase, equating them, in a first step already, to the State Security Forces and Corps with the regional police, with an increase of more than four billion euros for the Autonomous Communities, and, therefore, for Health and Education, and you are going to be left with absolutely nothing. Absolutely irrelevant.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Pablo Iglesias Turrión, of the Parliamentary Group Confederal of Unidos Podemos, En Comú Podem, En Marea

Mr. Iglesias.- Thank you, Mr. President.

Does the President of the Government think that the corruption cases affecting his party can still be considered isolated cases? Thank you.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. President.

Well, as in any aspect of life, Mr. Iglesias, a certain moderation is also advisable in this matter. I neither minimize nor magnify any irregular action. I reject them all, of course, including those of your party. And those that affect mine, I try to address them realistically and I try to make fair decisions. And, above all, I work to prevent such actions from happening again in the future, which is the most important thing.

Thank you very much.

Mr. Iglesias.- Mr. Rajoy, I appreciate that you address with moderation, with realism the corruption cases affecting your party. I truly wish I didn’t have to ask you about this so many times, but it is that every week your party brings us a new news story about corruption. I have to remind you that our parliamentary spokesperson from this podium spent two minutes enumerating corruption cases from your party to the shame of you and the citizens.

In recent weeks, Madrid has become the topic of conversation because of your party, and that affects you. Allow me to recap. "As Esperanza Aguirre was tainted by corruption, you appointed Ignacio González", "As Ignacio González was tainted by corruption", you appointed Cristina Cifuentes". "As Cristina Cifuentes was tainted by corruption", you have appointed Mr. Garrido, who was an advisor to Cifuentes and Aguirre, what could go wrong?, Mr. Mariano Rajoy.

Look, you have been able to use the Ministry of Justice, yes, Mr. Catalá, to protect corrupt individuals. You have been able to make tax amnesties, yes, Mr. Montoro, to protect fraudsters and they have been declared unconstitutional by the Constitutional Court.

In recent weeks, you have humiliated the dignity of Spanish public universities. In this country, there are many people who have to strive for their children to go to university. In this country, there are many students who know what it is to do a master's degree, and know what it is to do a doctorate, and who, however, have had to emigrate from Spain. You are the greatest threat to the public, Mr. Mariano Rajoy, because corruption is the greatest threat to the public. And now you bring us the solution, you tell us that the solution is to present clean candidates with clean curricula.

I ask you a very simple question and I hope you answer me. Can you guarantee that the candidates you are going to present are at least as clean as you?

Thank you very much.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. President.

Indeed, Mr. Iglesias, you always ask me the same thing, you repeat yourself without any rest. And one of two, either you have lost imagination and freshness or the Government that I preside over is doing very well, and, therefore, you have to ask me about what others do.

I stick with this hypothesis, so you do not lose either imagination or freshness, but you do recognize that the Government I preside over is doing very well, and, therefore, you have to ask me about other things.

Of course, it may also happen that you intend with your questions that I talk about the intern who was paid without appearing at the university, whom you have then imposed as a candidate for the Presidency of the Community of Madrid. I have not imposed anyone, you are the one who imposes them. Or about the deputies of your party here, or the boss you have out there, who did not pay Social Security, or about the deputy from my town, my town is Galicia, and from your party, which, as you know, is Podemos, who dedicated her well-deserved moments of leisure to breaking rearview mirrors of people who had the audacity to park their car on the street where she walked. We have seen it all in the vineyard of the Lord, and that they have only been two years, Mr. Iglesias.

But, well, Mr. Speaker, I am not going to talk to you about that either. Nor am I going to talk to you about the lady deputy who sits two seats above yours and who has had the audacity to break the traditional harmony that exists in your party. I am not going to talk to you about that either. And do you know why I am not going to talk to you about that? Because I believe that all of that harms you. And even if you don’t believe it, I do not want to harm you.

Thank you very much.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Albert Rivera Díaz, of the Parliamentary Group Ciudadanos

Mr. Rivera.- Thank you, Mr. President.

I am not going to ask you about creams, nor about rearview mirrors, I am going to ask you about something that seems more serious and more grave to me. We have suffered a coup d'état in Catalonia. We have defended democracy together, Mr. Rajoy. We supported you to apply Article 155 of the Constitution. We supported you in your Investiture, when no one else in the Chamber supported you, and you know it. We have supported the Budgets in difficult times and, therefore, with all authority and legitimacy, I ask you: Why, Mr. Rajoy, have you decided not to appeal to the Constitutional Court the delegated vote of two fugitives from Justice, Mr. Comín, and Mr. Puigdemont? It makes no sense, in my opinion, and in the opinion of our Group, that two gentlemen who are fugitives from Justice, who staged a coup d'état, have a privilege that a deputy in this Chamber does not have. Because recently we voted, for example, on the Budgets here, imagine that a vote, a deputy cannot vote, could not delegate the vote, and can a fugitive from Justice do it?

Mr. Rajoy, act and appeal to the Constitutional Court, and if not, explain to us why you do not intend to do so. If you do, you have our support. If you do not, you cannot count on our support to apply the Constitution in Catalonia.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. President.

Thank you very much, Mr. Rivera. Look Mr. Rivera, I am the President of the Government, as you know, and I try to fulfill my obligations. I have activated Article 155 of the Constitution; I have tried to do it with prudence and moderation, and at the same time, with firmness. That had never happened in Spain, because as you well know it is a decision that is not precisely easy, but in addition to making that decision I have presented 25 appeals to the Constitutional Court, Mr. Speaker, 25 appeals for actions related to the so-called "process".

Today, I have convened an extraordinary Council of Ministers for eleven in the morning, with the aim of appealing again a decision of the Parliament of Catalonia, which intended that there would be an investiture of a person fugitive from Justice, who does not live in Spain, and that, moreover, the Government of the Generalitat could hold meetings in Spain, which is obviously absurd.

And the only reason why I have not raised that appeal to which you have referred is because the legal services of the State consider that that appeal cannot be raised by the Government of Spain due to lack of legitimacy and because there are precedents in the Constitutional Court that advise us not to do so. So, I cannot act capriciously, just because it occurs to me, but I have to heed what my services tell me. And I insist, I believe that the fact of having applied Article 155 and presenting 25 appeals, honestly, does not make me suspicious of anything, at least, in that matter, Mr. Rivera.

Thank you very much.

Mr. Rivera.- Yes, Mr. Rajoy, as you have done nothing in this matter, we have done it and the appeal for protection of 36 deputies from Ciudadanos has been admitted for processing. If the Constitutional Court has admitted it for processing, Mr. Rajoy, it will not be so strange. Therefore, do not shelter yourself in that argument, because the Constitutional Court this very week has admitted for processing an appeal for protection from Ciudadanos. So, why don’t you do it? You will have to explain it to us.

But I tell you one thing, speaking of suspicions. First, this is not about kilos, it is not about the number of appeals, it is about getting it right. And we ask you to do it. We have supported you in everything, Mr. Rajoy, in everything. No Group in this Chamber has supported you as much as Ciudadanos and that is why we ask you.

And secondly, Mr. Rajoy. Today we have learned that the Prosecutor's Office confirms that money from the FLA, which you said here was not allocated even a euro, was used for the 9N, not just for October 1, but for November 9, Mr. Rajoy. This is a joke. It cannot be that you do not monitor public money. It cannot be that with invoices charged to the money of all Spaniards, those who stage a coup take us for fools.

Therefore, Mr. Rajoy, I ask you to monitor the money, and if not, hold someone accountable. You cannot look the other way while they stage a coup.

And Mr. Rajoy, we have supported you until now, but we will only support you if you closely monitor what the separatists are doing in Catalonia; otherwise, you cannot count on our support.

President.- Look, Your Honor, the deputies of the Popular Party have also sought refuge in the Constitutional Court. But the Government of Spain does not have active legitimacy to do so; however, the deputies of the Parliament of Catalonia do. If not, I would have gone, because you will understand that after having presented 25 appeals, it makes no sense not to present the 26th, unless it was to allow you to ask a question here in this Chamber.

But I will tell you one thing. I believe we have a shared objective. And I think staging a supposed disagreement really has no interest. And I do not think it is good to dedicate your energies to criticizing the Government on matters of state, Mr. Rivera. And I believe this does not earn you a vote. This could make you lose votes and cause many people not to take you seriously, because they see you as "opportunistic" on an important issue. And I ask you to behave with the same loyalty that the Socialist Party is demonstrating; I do not know if I am harming you with this statement. Simply, behave as the Socialist Party is behaving on the issue of Catalonia, and, honestly, we would be much better off.

Thank you very much.