"Variables such as depopulation must be taken into account when determining cohesion funds and the CAP."

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

28 March 2018 · Teruel

Context
Rajoy responded in writing to a questionnaire on rural depopulation following his visit to Teruel, Spain, in March 2018.
Main themes
Rural depopulation, demographic challenges, national strategy against depopulation, broadband connectivity, rural entrepreneurship, cohesion funds and CAP, housing policy, rural municipalities, aging population, digital infrastructure investment, regional policy, birth rate decline
Duration
~29 min
82nd percentile
Words
3,531
82nd percentile
Sentences
134
76th percentile
Readability
38
31st percentile
Grade
14.5
71st percentile
Syntax
3.24
76th percentile
Vocabulary
2.25
62nd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 50%43%
  • Social 26%22%
  • Institutional 14%12%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 4%3%
  • Environmental 2%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 16%

134 sentences in 41 paragraphs

This is affirmed in this interview, conducted through a broad and reasoned questionnaire sent to Moncloa, which has been summarized here, and to which he responded in writing after his visit to Teruel.

Question.- What do you understand by the problem of depopulation in rural areas?

President.- I am well aware of the problem, which affects Aragón, as well as Galicia and other regions of Spain. The truth is that demographic challenges have different faces, which in most aspects are common to European countries. We have demographic change, driven by the decline in birth rates in recent decades and the progressive aging, which in turn results from greater longevity and is further emphasized by the arrival at advanced ages of larger generations born during the so-called baby boom. And these demographic factors have a greater impact in areas with depopulation dynamics, because it is a specific problem that has been ongoing for decades, since the time of the most intense rural exodus with the process of industrialization. That is why we believe it deserves differentiated attention and solutions, and as such we are addressing it. With commitments and concrete actions that can help maintain and attract inhabitants to these areas.

Q.- How will the Government tackle rural depopulation and with what measures? Do you plan to include them in the state strategy and, above all, allocate money in the General State Budgets of 2018? Which ones will be included this year?

President.- We are already facing that challenge. For the first time, it has been included in the political agenda of the national Government. And we are working in this direction; we want to present our proposals within the framework of the National Strategy, with specific and differentiated measures to address depopulation. In fact, in recent weeks we are already anticipating significant strategic measures that are part of this approach. Thus, in the new Housing Plan, measures against depopulation are included for the first time, such as aid for the rehabilitation of single-family homes in rural areas, which increases by 25% when the beneficiaries are young people from municipalities with fewer than 5,000 inhabitants, or new aid for acquisition so that young people can settle in these municipalities. And, to facilitate this possibility, it is essential to have tools that make life and work easier. That is why, this week we have taken a very important step, with the 300x100 Plan, to ensure connectivity to next-generation networks for 100% of population centers by 2021. It is a Plan that involves a direct investment of 525 million euros, and it is being launched with an initial call endowed with 150 million euros, and logically each issue has its budgetary reflection. We believe that connectivity can be an important tool against depopulation, as it helps to address isolation and overcome gaps, facilitates access to services and products, makes businesses more profitable, or attracts business initiatives. New technologies help us live where we prefer.

Q.- Do you think there is still a solution for municipalities with fewer than 100 inhabitants, of which the province of Teruel holds records due to being a widespread reality, or will you be pragmatic and focus on those with larger populations?

President.- Our commitment in the fight against demographic challenges and depopulation is across the entire territory. Because it is a commitment as a country. We should not view villages as a remnant of the past, but rather promote opportunities for the future, and this is how we should approach this challenge, with future-oriented policies—such as the possibilities offered by technology—betting on cohesive development, but also valuing what villages and the rural world mean and contribute to the whole country.

Q.- Do you intend to adopt measures to support entrepreneurs in rural areas and the settlement of families? Do you consider among them fiscal measures through deductions and similar, and even introduce legislative changes as needed, which are the things that can be most effective and that are being requested by local institutions, and all kinds of organizations and groups involved in combating this problem?

President.- There are different proposals and approaches, and, of course, we believe it is important to work on generating opportunities, because after all, employment is the key to livelihood and, with it, to the settlement of population. That is why we consider it essential to promote entrepreneurial initiatives, which can contribute to economic development, job creation, and demographic recovery in these areas. Our commitment to broadband will greatly help those who want to start a business without having to move to a big city, because today the Internet opens up all kinds of options without the need to be physically where it was previously necessary. And, beyond the advances brought by new technologies, we are evaluating other measures that can contribute to the launch and development of entrepreneurial projects, also from the perspective of regulatory simplification.

"It is very easy to blame the Government for everything and look the other way when solutions are proposed."

Q.- How far is the Government willing to go to prevent the closure of the Andorra thermal power plant and the disappearance of coal mining in the province of Teruel? Are there any alternatives being considered to address this very serious situation?

President.- In the particular case of the coal-fired power plants, the fundamental problem is that many political groups have demanded the closure of the plants for ideological reasons without taking into account any technical or economic considerations. This makes their continuity very difficult. However, the Government believes that decisions regarding Spain's energy mix must be compatible with three basic objectives: supply security, sustainability, and competitiveness. Spain is meeting its environmental objectives, and keep in mind that we burn much less coal than neighboring countries like Germany. Given this, the Government's position is that as long as thermal power plants like Andorra contribute to making energy more affordable, they should continue to operate and not be closed for ideological reasons. For this reason, shortly the Popular parliamentary group will present a bill in Congress precisely so that when approving or not the closure of a plant, its impact on competitiveness and electricity prices is evaluated. This analysis is fundamental, especially in plants like Andorra that have provided price stability to the system in recent years. Now we will have to see what position the other political groups take because it is evident that the PP does not have a sufficient majority to pass this law, and in the past it was not possible to count on support from other parties to process this law. Regarding the Miner funds, a few days ago Minister Nadal signed a framework agreement with the president of Aragón to promote new projects that improve infrastructure and degraded areas. And it should be noted that the money dedicated to coal mining is used for projects selected by the autonomous community itself and affected municipalities, and those aids are awarded in a very strict manner with thorough monitoring and control. Now the specific projects will arrive.

Q.- Are you in favor of moving towards a CAP model that favors the most disadvantaged agricultural areas at this time, that prevents their future disappearance and that promotes the incorporation of young farmers? The Government of Aragón has made a proposal; do you consider it appropriate and how do you think Europe should advance in that direction so that the CAP is an effective instrument in the fight against depopulation?

President.- In this matter, first, we must again advocate for technology as a determining factor for the future for young farmers. The Ministry of Agriculture is developing an Agenda for the Digitalization of Rural Areas that I believe will be very useful to encourage young people to dedicate themselves to such a necessary and vital profession for all as agriculture. At the same time, and digitalization surely helps, we must increase the competitiveness of the agricultural sector and provide this sector with an environment that allows it to grow more and better. I add here that the Ministry of Agriculture has taken important measures in this regard, such as investment in innovative projects and the creation of digital transformation offices for the agricultural sector. Regarding the CAP, I will tell you that the current one, negotiated by this Government, guarantees stability for the sector until 2020. We have secured 47 billion euros for the Spanish countryside. The CAP guarantees more than a quarter of the incomes of Aragonese farmers and ranchers, and the reform of this policy will allow Aragón to maintain a level of aid similar to that of the previous period, around 3.5 billion euros, during the 2014-2020 period. I believe that common policies like this must be viewed with a global approach for the entire sector across Spain, but I am sure that the CAP continues to contribute to mitigating the effects of depopulation. Certainly more than if it did not exist. But we must work in more directions, as I have said.

"Variables such as depopulation must be considered when determining cohesion funds and the CAP."

Q.- Apart from the extension of the much-demanded broadband to the entire territory, which is so necessary today as infrastructure for communication, what other investment forecasts does your Government have in terms of road communications to be made immediately and with sufficient budget allocation?

President.- As I already mentioned during the event at the former headquarters of the Bank of Spain in Teruel, the study orders for the Teruel-Villastar and Villastar-Ademuz sections of the N-330 have already been issued. The investment for both sections is over 105 million euros. Additionally, in the coming months, the work to improve the N-232 road between Rafales and the border of the province of Castellón will be completed with an investment of 65.5 million euros. These are two good pieces of news, and we continue to work to provide more news of this type as soon as possible. Investment in infrastructure is a fundamental element of cohesion for the country and for provinces that have been more disconnected from the main routes until now.

Q.- Why will the Zaragoza-Teruel-Sagunto line not receive the same treatment of double electrified track as the rest of the Cantabrian-Mediterranean corridor from Zaragoza to the Basque Country and northern Spain? Are you considering reconsidering that decision so that the section passing through Teruel is also of double electrified track and high capacity instead of single electrified track as currently planned?

President.- The Cantabrian-Mediterranean corridor is an infrastructure to which we are dedicating special attention. That is why we have managed to reduce travel time for passenger trains on the Valencia-Teruel-Zaragoza route, and that is why the number of freight trains has increased from 3 trains a week to 30 trains a week. Improvements on the line between Teruel and Sagunto will soon be awarded. We must continue to do things to improve these infrastructures, but we are improving it, and that will benefit all the people of Teruel.

"The FITE does not replace investments, but complements them. They are different mechanisms."

Q.- Does the Government intend, as several autonomous communities have already requested, for the new model of autonomous financing to take into account depopulation to guarantee the same quality of services in depopulated areas, instead of relying solely on criteria based on the number of inhabitants, or will priority continue to be given to more populated territories to the detriment of depopulated ones?

President.- From the Conference of Presidents that I convened in January 2017, the need to establish a debate on a new model of autonomous financing emerged. From that need, a working group of experts was created that has presented a report on possible solutions, and now it is up to the Treasury and the autonomous communities to see, based on the opinions of those experts, what model to build. At this point, the PSOE plays a very important role, as it governs in 7 autonomous communities, and we need a constructive and serious role from them, as a State, so that we can reach an agreement that allows us to have a financing model that meets the aspirations of the communities as much as possible and that does not break the fundamental requirement of solidarity among all Spaniards that has worked wonderfully for us until now.

Q.- What does the Government plan to do to alleviate the sense of insecurity in rural areas that has been left among the population after the triple crime in Andorra? Do you think that action should have been taken differently? Will the vacancies in the police force that have arisen in the province in recent years be filled in a proportion much higher than the rest of Spain?

President.- The first thing I want to do is express my solidarity and support to the families of the two Civil Guard officers and the farmer who were brutally murdered. They paid with their lives for the vile act of a ruthless murderer, but they also managed to apprehend a very dangerous individual and thus saved many lives. Security is one of the fundamental priorities of a government, and we are always working to improve it, so that events like this do not occur. But they do happen, here and in Madrid and in Barcelona. In fact, according to data from the Ministry of the Interior, the number of criminal offenses per thousand inhabitants in the province of Teruel is the lowest in Spain. Security in rural areas has improved significantly in recent years, and perhaps one of the reasons for this has been the implementation by this government of 106 specialized teams for rural thefts. We are now going to call for new positions for police officers and Civil Guard officers, and I hope to have the support of the opposition parties to formalize this through the budgets. Because, of course, it is very easy to blame the government for everything but then look the other way when solutions are proposed. Those parties now have the opportunity to support us in calling for these positions and to ensure that we equip our agents with adequate salaries.

Q.- Do you believe that the Teruel Investment Fund (Fite) should be given a new orientation so that it truly serves as a development fund for the province instead of replacing the investments that the State and the autonomous community should undertake in their ordinary budgets?

President.- The Fite has been a good instrument of assistance to make the principle of inter-territorial solidarity effective for this province, which, given the income level of the autonomous community, is deprived of access to territorial compensation funds. It has been and is a useful instrument, which since 2012 has accumulated a state investment of 180 million euros. In December, we already activated the mechanism so that this year's spending could be committed with the extended budget. But this does not replace investments; rather, it complements them. They are different mechanisms.

Q.- Is there an intention to return to the province of Teruel the uninvested Fite money that belongs to the people of Teruel?

President.- We are working with the Treasury to find a way to reach an agreement on this issue that is satisfactory for all.

Q.- What actions is the Government of Spain taking in Europe to ensure that depopulated areas are addressed regarding their problems, in line with Article 174 of the Lisbon Treaty, which urges states to promote territorial cohesion?

President.- What we are clear about is that we defend the involvement of the European Union in addressing demographic challenges and depopulation, because we understand that these are problems that are often common to the Member States. In defining the new Multiannual Financial Framework of the European Union post-2020, variables like these must be taken into account when determining the amount of funds to be distributed both in cohesion policy and in the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP). Our goal is to achieve a good outcome for Spain in this negotiation, which involves defending the allocations that Spain receives both in CAP and in cohesion policy, and in this sense, it is especially relevant to consider challenges such as the demographic challenge.

"In Teruel, the average retirement pension is almost 20 percent higher than at the end of 2011."

Q.- Do you think that the situation in Teruel due to depopulation is not as serious as that in the territories of the Blue ITIs, Cádiz, and the Mar Menor, so as not to receive the same financial treatment? Do you think this will be rectified in the next Partnership Agreement?

President.- I believe that the situation in Teruel is what it is, just as Cádiz has its particularities and other regions of Spain have theirs. What the government is trying to do is balance the aid and financing so that we all have, regardless of where we live, the best services and the highest possible quality of life. This involves EU funds, common policies, investment funds like the Fite, the General State Budgets, and of course, autonomous financing. If we soon have these last two, something that fundamentally requires the concurrence of other political parties, we will be able to see how investments grow or how financing improves, among other things.

Q.- How do you plan to address the much-demanded revaluation of pensions, in addition to being able to guarantee them in the future?

President.- The main guarantee for pensions is employment. Since we took office, we have already done something fundamental to guarantee them: create two million jobs and ensure that where previously three contributors exited for every pensioner entering the system, now six new contributors enter for each pensioner. The key to pensions is to create more and better jobs. When I arrived in government, one of the few things I was clear about that could not be touched in the adjustment policy was pensions. And I did so, unlike my predecessors who now demand pension increases but at that time froze them. Since I have been president of the government, pensions have always increased as much as possible. This debate must be approached responsibly and without deceiving people with promises that cannot be fulfilled. Pensions account for more than 40% of the budget, 139 billion last year. In Spain, the average pension represents 72.3 percent of the salary prior to retirement, twenty points above the OECD average. As I said in Congress, in the 2018 budget project, I will propose concentrating tax aid in personal income tax for pensioners and families, as well as improving minimum pensions and widow's pensions. And we will continue to promote employment policies, which is what ensures a clear future for pensions. In Teruel, where the number of unemployed decreased by almost 13 percent last year, the average retirement pension is almost 20 percent higher than at the end of 2011, around 1,012 euros.

"Believe me, the people of Teruel will benefit from budgets that also provide stability."

Q.- How will the province of Teruel be addressed in the upcoming General State Budgets of 2018? Will investment increase, and, above all, will this be reflected in its execution given the very low budget execution each year?

President.- The upcoming General State Budgets, which we will present to an extraordinary Council of Ministers on March 27, are fundamental for everyone. With them, we can update state spending for areas such as autonomous financing and the public services that depend on it, public employment offers, salary improvements for civil servants, equalization of salaries for police and Civil Guard, the pensions we just talked about, investments in infrastructure… I cannot go into detail because we still have to negotiate and work a lot, but believe me, the people of Teruel will benefit from budgets that also provide stability.

Q.- The people of Teruel believe that they are not attended to because they have little political weight, which translates into few seats in the Cortes Generales, something that is always argued against by the central government with the data on budgeted investment -not executed investment- by the number of inhabitants and not by the area of the territory that the province of Teruel represents. What do you have to say about this?

President.- Well, here you mix several very different things. First, with the parliamentary representation that comes from the current electoral law and that is the system we have, which in fact seeks a more realistic representation for all territories than the proposals made by some to prioritize large cities over rural areas. The PP will continue to defend an electoral model that gives visibility to all the towns of Spain and to the rural population, which is a group we owe a lot to and that we must value. The two deputies that my party has for the province are two excellent representatives for Teruel, judging by their deep knowledge of the reality of Teruel and the activity they carry out in Congress. The people of Teruel know that this government and the party that supports it care about them and will continue to do so always.

NOTE: Interview published with the authorization of "Diario de Teruel."