Is a good life a perfect life? Protestant Lecture by Prime Minister Mark Rutte

Netherlands Mark Rutte · Prime Minister of the Netherlands

30 October 2020 · Protestant Lecture · Kloosterkerk, The Hague, Netherlands

Context
Rutte delivered the annual Protestant Lecture at the Kloosterkerk in The Hague on Reformation Day 2020, reflecting on faith, community, and the good life during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Main themes
Community and togetherness, faith and Christianity, COVID-19 pandemic, the good life vs. perfect life, Protestant tradition, volunteer spirit and mutual aid, loneliness and mental health, hope and comfort in crisis, role of churches in society, Dutch society and values
Duration
~17 min
58th percentile
Words
2,033
58th percentile
Sentences
126
74th percentile
Readability
65
94th percentile
Grade
8.2
6th percentile
Syntax
2.84
27th percentile
Vocabulary
1.91
3rd percentile

Translated from Dutch

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 83%83%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Economic 3%3%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Institutional 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

126 sentences in 32 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

If I were given the impossible task of describing what the church means to me personally in one word, I would probably say: 'Community'. Because in the church, people come together, as a congregation. In person, with each other.

And how alienating it is to have to address you from this beautiful, yet almost empty Kloosterkerk in The Hague via the camera. We know why this is necessary. We know what we are doing it for. But we also feel how much we need that sense of community, especially now.

That is immediately the main reason why I gladly said yes to the request to deliver the annual Protestant Lecture on this Reformation Day. Adjusted in form and scope due to the circumstances, but hopefully not in meaning and reception. Because today I want to emphasize that necessity of community and thereby also the important role that faith, the churches, and especially the people who together form the church, play in it.

We cannot ignore it: the coronavirus is taking an incredibly heavy toll on our society. On everyone who has to miss a loved one due to corona. On people who are very ill from it now, or who are struggling with the physical and mental aftermath of the virus. On young and old alike who, due to all the social restrictions, are facing tensions behind closed doors, with loneliness and depressive feelings. Or on all those entrepreneurs whose businesses are on the brink and on the people who are at risk of losing their jobs.

In short, corona is more than a virus, more than just an illness. It is also mourning, it is loss, it is disruption.

But I am convinced that the tradition in which we stand helps us get through this difficult period. Each of us individually and our country as a whole. That tradition is certainly not exclusively Christian, but it is largely so. And it works very directly and personally, because those who believe in God may have hope, and that brings enormous comfort. That is how it works for me, at least.

And it also works collectively, because of that well-known Bible verse: love your neighbor as yourself. For me, that means: look out for each other, help each other, comfort each other. Exactly what we immediately saw happening during that first wave of corona. And just recently, dozens of churches and Christian organizations from various denominations sent a letter to the cabinet offering to help during the second wave of corona, for example in combating loneliness. So faith also makes us stronger together, in a societal sense.

And of course, we see the tension among people increasing in this second wave, but underlying it all, the Netherlands remains a country of volunteers and mutual aid. A country of doing groceries for each other and a pot of soup for the sick neighbor. Even during this second wave, there are still more people with patience and compassion than with a short fuse. We read little about that goodness and patience in society in the newspapers and we also do not hear much about it at the various talk show tables, but that does not make it any less of a reality.

In this time, we are being confronted with the facts, whether we like it or not. Achievements that we always took for granted suddenly turned out to be less self-evident than we thought this spring. Suddenly, we are living under restrictions that were hardly imaginable until recently.

That raises the question: what really matters in a person's life? Or to put it in the form of the question I was asked to reflect on today: is a good life a perfect life?

The short answer is, of course: no, thankfully not. Because perfection is a standard that very few people can meet.

Moreover, what is perfect? That differs from person to person, it seems to me. For one, it is a brilliant career with much prestige and wealth. For another, it is an attractive appearance or a sporting achievement. And for yet another, it is a harmonious family life or the satisfaction of volunteer work.

So a definitive answer cannot be given. For me personally, perfect is also another word for boring. Just imagine: a perfect life and nothing more to wish for? I honestly don't want to think about it!

The question remains: what is a good life then? There is, of course, no right or wrong answer to that either. But what the corona crisis teaches us anyway is that life, when it comes down to it, is not about more, more, more, and certainly not about more me, me, me, but about togetherness, about responsibility, and about attention for the people around you. We all know that saying that no one on their deathbed says they should have spent more time at work or gathered more possessions. In 2020, we might also have to add the number of followers on Instagram or Facebook to that. But life is not about cash or consumption; it is about contact. About real human contact. That is ultimately all that matters, not wealth or appearances, but what you have done with and for another.

I myself am the product of a not too heavy Reformed upbringing, so I always have to be a bit careful with references to or interpretations of the Bible. But is what I just said not also a common thread in that beautiful book? For example, in that parable of the rich man for whom it is harder to enter the Kingdom of God than for a camel to go through the eye of a needle? It seems to me a clear message: possessions are ballast that you leave behind in the end.

Or for example where Jesus says: 'So always treat others as you would want them to treat you.' That is a nice positive reversal of: 'What you do not want done to you…' And in this, there is also a crystal-clear message: think of others in everything you want and do.

The answer to the question of what a good life is is perhaps nowhere more clearly formulated in the Bible than in Romans 12, in one of Paul's letters of instruction. He writes there unequivocally that a good life is a life in service of the will of God. In the New Bible Translation, it literally says: 'Do not conform to the pattern of this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your mind, so that you may test and approve what God’s will is—his good, pleasing and perfect will.'

I hear in that the echo of one of the core values that I received from my parents: always think for yourself, take responsibility for your own actions, and do not blindly follow the herd. Just as Luther did on that very first Reformation Day in Wittenberg, 503 years ago, when he, like Paul, also addressed Rome with his theses. Think, choose, and accept the consequences.

And so, in that text from Romans 12, there is much of the faith of my youth, of the church in which I grew up—the Nieuwe Badkapel in Scheveningen. A church that attracted people from all walks of life, from ministers and top civil servants to fishermen from Scheveningen. As a child, I felt at home there.

Paul strongly emphasizes in his letter to the Romans that people have different gifts and that there is no hierarchy in that. 'We have different gifts, according to the grace given to us,' it says. And he then compares that to a body, of which each part has its own function.

That appeals to me enormously. It means that everyone can do good in their life, thus leading a good and meaningful life, and that the sum of everyone’s contribution is more than the sum of the parts.

I like to call that, following Frits Bolkestein, the inspiring connection in society, the strength and energy that resides in people, which keeps us together and makes us stronger as a whole. Everyone's contribution counts. No one is more important than another. Or as I learned from my parents: you do not look up to the professor and you do not look down on the garbage collector. Everyone contributes according to their ability.

In that context, I learned early on that it is better to keep your own role in perspective, that you should not always take yourself too seriously. Just keep walking on the small stones, that was what we called it at home. And Paul also calls us to this in Romans 12. He writes: '(…) do not think of yourself more highly than you ought, but rather think of yourself with sober judgment.' And, another quote: '(…) honor one another above yourselves.' And for those who still do not understand, there is also this very literal call: '(…) do not be proud, but be willing to associate with people of low position.'

In short, Paul's answer to the question of what a good life is contains a kind of Droste effect. A good life is a life that has meaning in the lives of others. We do not exist without another. And what I find most appealing about that conclusion is that Paul also implicitly answers the question of what a failed life is. Or better: the question of whether there is such a thing as a failed life. I tell you honestly: everything in me resists that. As a believing person and as a liberal. Because it would mean that we write people off, and that does not fit into the society we have.

Of course, there are people who have bad luck in life, who are affected by illness, an accident, or other misfortune. People who find it difficult to keep up in the digital information society that demands more and more from us. People who, for whatever reason, need help, and who fortunately receive that help in our country. But that says nothing about what they mean in the lives of their parents, children, friends, neighbors, colleagues. With few exceptions, everyone is something to someone. Everyone is someone who is loved. So everyone’s life matters. I am deeply convinced of that.

And what I also want to say today is this. Now that the coronavirus confronts us with our own smallness and vulnerability, the important role of the churches becomes even clearer.

And then I return to that word community that I spoke about at the beginning. This period reminds me of the plaque that John F. Kennedy had on his desk in the Oval Office. It bore this line from an old Breton fishermen's prayer: 'O God, thy sea is so great and my boat is so small.' The original can still be admired in the Kennedy Presidential Library in Boston. That vague feeling of that great sea will be recognizable to many during the corona crisis. Because where does this end? Churches can provide clarity on that. In the church, we feel: we are not alone in that small boat; we are in it together, and we have faced hotter fires in history. So we will also overcome this period. And I believe we cannot hear that message often enough in this time.

Ladies and gentlemen,

I fear that I will remain indebted to you for the definitive answer to the question of what a good life is. But hopefully, you did not expect to receive that answer. From what I have said, it should be clear that for me it revolves around equality and community. Around the inspiring connection in society, which resides in us people, all of whom contribute in a way that makes the whole more than the sum of the parts.

A good life is therefore not necessarily a believing life. That would be enormously presumptuous and also far too simplistic. But speaking for myself, I dare to say that faith makes my own painting larger and deeper. It simply helps me to see a little further and—hopefully—to do as much good as possible in my own life.

Thank you.