Statement by the Prime Minister on the situation in Israel and Gaza, prior to the debate on the European Council.

Netherlands Mark Rutte · Prime Minister of the Netherlands

24 October 2023 · Debate on the European Council

Context
Rutte addressed the Dutch parliament on October 24, 2023, reporting on his visit to Israel and the West Bank amid the ongoing Israel-Hamas war following the October 7 attacks.
Main themes
Israel-Hamas conflict, humanitarian crisis in Gaza, two-state solution, civilian protection, hostages, humanitarian aid corridors, diplomatic visits and mediation, international cooperation, Palestinian rights, restraint and humanitarian law, regional escalation prevention
Duration
~8 min
27th percentile
Words
944
27th percentile
Sentences
72
47th percentile
Readability
61
89th percentile
Grade
7.9
4th percentile
Syntax
2.55
5th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from Dutch

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 53%53%
  • Social 35%35%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Institutional 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

72 sentences in 28 paragraphs

Madam Chair, thank you for giving me the opportunity to briefly reflect on my visit to Israel and the West Bank yesterday and on the situation that has arisen since October 7.

We are now 2.5 weeks after the horrific massacres in Israel. 2.5 weeks of destruction and violence. Of deep human suffering. Of intense sorrow and also of great concern.

How does this continue? How does this end? What is needed to silence the weapons again? That is the question that occupies everyone.

We in the Netherlands, people around the world, mourn the victims of the atrocities committed by Hamas. We mourn the death of our 33-year-old compatriot Islam al-Ashqar and all the injured and dead in Gaza. And we mourn the uncertain fate of the Israeli hostages, including 18-year-old Ofir Engel, whose family I spoke to yesterday – it was heartbreaking.

Every victim is one too many. Every human life is equally valuable. There is no gradation between grief and loss.

Madam Chair, I say this clearly because after the attacks by Hamas on Israel, some have come to believe that the cabinet supports Israel blindly in everything that is happening now. I want to say the following about that.

The atrocities of Saturday, October 7, can in no way be justified and can only be condemned in the strongest terms. And yes, Israel has every right to defend itself against the terrorist violence of Hamas, within the bounds of humanitarian law.

Is that the whole story? No, it is not.

The tragedy of this war is that the thinking about it is often black and white – for or against. Even in our country. While the reality is that so many things are true at the same time.

It is true that October 7 shows that Israel cannot exist safely if it does not act against Hamas. The ability of Hamas to carry out attacks must be eliminated. Hamas must be stopped.

At the same time, it is also true that innocent people in Gaza must not become victims of this.

It is true that both Israel and the Palestinian people have the right to their own independent state, which provides security. A future perspective.

And it is also true that a two-state solution is ultimately the only way out. All these truths coexist.

Yesterday, I spoke on the West Bank with Palestinians who have family in Gaza. They live in fear every day now that their family members have nowhere to go. A woman I spoke to yesterday lost 5 loved ones in one bombing.

In Israel, I spoke with people who told me how they have to flee to shelters three times a day during yet another air raid. Hundreds of thousands of people in Israel have been displaced from their homes.

A girl told me about her grandfather, the only Holocaust survivor in his family, and how afraid she is that it could happen again. This morning, I met with families of Israeli hostages, some of whom saw their relatives being murdered or abducted on their phones on October 7. A moment they have relived over and over since then. In fear for the fate of their loved ones. Barbaric – there is no other word for it.

And this afternoon, I spoke with Palestinian Dutch citizens, who sometimes have not heard from their families for days. Who are afraid of every message, every phone call, that could bring terrible news.

These people have almost lost hope for peace and an end to the violence. Those are conversations that leave you speechless. Emotional.

And you realize once again how important it is that humanity ultimately prevails again. How we must hold on to hope for that.

Madam Chair, yesterday I had an open and honest conversation with Prime Minister Netanyahu. I reaffirmed that Israel's military deterrence against acts of terrorism, from any quarter, must be restored.

I also emphasized that innocent civilians must be protected as much as possible from the conflict against Hamas. I advocated for allowing aid and essential goods into Gaza. So water, food, medicine, and also fuel. And not just one convoy of trucks, but a well-organized and sustainable corridor.

I called for humanitarian pauses to ensure that aid can arrive safely. And I called for restraint in the use of violence.

With President Abbas, I discussed that the terrorist acts of Hamas do nothing positive for the future of the Palestinians. We completely agreed on that. It was good to hear from him that he also condemns the actions of Hamas.

It is now crucial to prevent the violence from spilling over into the West Bank. And rightly, President Abbas drew attention to illegal settlements and the violence of settlers. That must also stop, and I had urged Prime Minister Netanyahu on that earlier in the day.

Madam Chair, we must be realistic: the Dutch influence is limited, but we do what we can. All of us. And we do this in close cooperation with other EU member states, with the United States, and with countries in the region: Egypt, Qatar, Jordan, and the United Arab Emirates.

The more united the international community is, the greater the chance that regional escalation can be prevented. The greater also the chance that the humanitarian situation in Gaza can improve somewhat. And the sooner the hostages can be released – which must happen! – and that the Dutch present there and other people from other countries can leave Gaza.

For that, we must do everything we can. And that will of course also be our commitment during the European Council on Thursday and Friday.

Thank you.