On the occasion of Constitution Day, the original text of the Prime Minister's address in the Rajya Sabha during the discussion.

India Narendra Modi · Prime Minister of India

1 December 2015 · Discussion in the Rajya Sabha on Constitution Day · Rajya Sabha, India

Context
Modi addressed the Rajya Sabha on Constitution Day, December 1, 2015, during a discussion marking the 125th birth anniversary of Dr. B.R. Ambedkar.
Main themes
Constitution Day celebration, Dr. B.R. Ambedkar's 125th birth anniversary, Indian Constitution's significance, Constituent Assembly legacy, educating future generations on the Constitution, national unity, constitutional values, preamble, democratic governance, political inclusivity
Duration
~37 min
89th percentile
Words
4,494
89th percentile
Sentences
199
89th percentile
Readability
55
78th percentile
Grade
11.0
32nd percentile
Syntax
3.04
52nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
25th percentile

Translated from Hindi

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 47%46%
  • Social 25%25%
  • Ceremonial 19%18%
  • Economic 7%7%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

199 sentences in 34 paragraphs

I respectfully greet the House. About 50 honorable members have expressed their views in detail on this important subject. On the occasion of Baba Saheb Ambedkar's 125th birth anniversary, it was a good initiative, and when all the party leaders sat together before the House began, everyone welcomed it with one voice and approved it. However, we do not claim that this original idea was ours; there may be something beyond my knowledge, but in 2008, the Congress government in Maharashtra initiated this on November 26 as Constitution Day. And they did a good job by having children recite the preamble in schools. When I was in Gujarat, I found this experiment commendable because we celebrate August 15 and January 26. To some extent, on August 15, we remember the freedom fighters, the patriots; there are discussions on TV and in newspapers. On January 26, that does not happen as much; the focus is primarily on the parade. And in a democratic country like India, one thing is certain: if there is any place for guidance in our movement, it is our Constitution. If there is a path to move forward, it is the Constitution. Even in difficulties, to walk together, to unite, it is our Constitution. We should familiarize our future generations with the Constitution, and not only that, but we should also explain what the provisions of this Constitution are, in what context the Constitution was created, how various great personalities contributed, and how they could foresee the diverse challenges of this country, even during the period of colonialism, and how they attempted to address many new issues. Setting all this aside, the core essence of India, the fundamental thought process of India, had to develop a system to overcome the challenges that India faces today. How great this task was, it is not possible to name all the great personalities of the House; only then do we pay them respect. This program has been created to pay homage to all those sages who sat in the Constituent Assembly. It has been created to honor them, and if someone did not create it earlier, I do not believe they committed a sin. We had the thought, and we have done it, but the intention is to ensure that the great personalities who have worked to guide this nation for centuries are known to our future generations, so they understand. And therefore, if a member of my party is present, I should remember them; a country does not run like that. We cannot make decisions based on what ideas they had or which party they belonged to. This country is the result of everyone's positive contributions, and we must continue to connect with everyone's positive contributions; only then does the nation have sovereignty. And therefore, behind November 26, there is a vision that the country should not be confined to just the provisions but should also connect with the emotions of those who sat in the Constituent Assembly. And we have no doubt that many of those who sat there were associated with the Congress, but we have the courage to take pride in them. We have the courage; our values allow us to respect and honor them; these are our values.

We should take this positively, and suggestions are also needed that even if not many have come into this discussion, separately, because this is the House, there are greater expectations that here we should sometimes be impartial above the party and opposition. And how do we continue to familiarize our future generations with the core emotions of our Constitution, how do we strengthen their faith in the Constitution, even in times of despair, they should feel that yes, some people have come, there are disturbances, but this is a place from where the sun will shine someday. This sentiment needs to be instilled in our future generations continuously, and therefore, this effort for dialogue has been made, and if it happens here, then it can be percolated down quickly.

We in the government do not intend for such debates to happen every time, nor have we said so. The 125 years of Baba Saheb Ambedkar and his contributions cannot be underestimated. We have also seen a lot of neglect towards him; we have seen his ridicule, and we have also seen his forced acceptance. And here I speak in words, I do not speak in the language of you and me. There has been pressure from below that today this country cannot deny the great works of Baba Saheb Ambedkar. We must accept this truth, and therefore, the discussion on the 125th anniversary of the Constitution, on Baba Saheb Ambedkar, but at the same time, we pay homage to all the great personalities of the Constituent Assembly, we respect them, we pay homage to all, including Baba Saheb Ambedkar, and we want to move forward from this role.

One thing is true; this is also told in our families, it is also said in social life, it is also mentioned in folk tales, good things should be remembered repeatedly. It should be done in good times and in bad times. It is essential for social life. No matter how big a son becomes, when he goes from his village to the city, even if he has gone ten times, the mother will still say, "Son, do not get into a moving vehicle, do not look out of the window." The son has grown up, has gone before, but the mother feels the need to remind him to be careful. This has been our tradition, and for this, Dr. Karan Singh is sitting here; he will bring many Sanskrit verses before us because it has been said in our culture. But it has been said here:

"Through practice, the dull-witted become wise.

As the rope comes and goes, it leaves a mark on the stone."

The rope used to draw water from the well does not have the strength to fight against the stone, but the result of continuous practice is that new shapes are formed on that stone. And therefore, for us, the Constitution should be a celebration; the Constitution should be a festival; our respect and reverence for every emotion of the Constitution should continue for generations. These values, these legacies, are our responsibility. This country does not run on mere bickering; it runs when people come together, and therefore the Constitution is a power that can take us out of the language of you and me. The Constitution is a sentiment that gives us the strength to unite, and this House is such that it has the power to convey a message of impartiality above the party and opposition to Hindustan, and therefore I have great respect for this House.

We must respect values; we must strive for them. The height of our Constitution is the world's largest democracy, and we can still see the newspapers from the time when the Constituent Assembly was in session. There were many apprehensions about whether this vehicle would run, whether these people would be able to do it, and the British had an interest in emphasizing this point. And therefore, people did not believe it, but despite many obstacles, the years we have spent, our great personalities have given us such an excellent guiding Constitution that has continuously empowered us. And therefore, we sing its praises.

A famous American writer said about the Indian Constitution, Granville Austin... Granville Austin said, "Perhaps the greatest political venture since that which originated at Philadelphia in 1787." The political venture that originated in Philadelphia in 1787, perhaps the greatest political venture after that is the Constitution of India; this was said at that time. That is, we can say that sometimes we are here, our main work is to make laws. This is what people have sent us for, and we are experienced, knowledgeable, but we see how great the gap is among us, and we must introspect. And remembering the foresight and strength of the members of the Constituent Assembly, we will realize how much we need to rise.

The members of the Constituent Assembly thought about what would happen if a situation arose 50, 60, or 70 years later, and they were concerned about safeguards. We make laws today, and we have seen that their faults and their faults are not the issue. Our overall situation is that we make laws, and in the next session, we have to come back and say, "Hey, we made this last time, but these two words were left out; we need to amend it again." How many limitations we have, and the root cause of these limitations is not that God has not given us the ability; the root cause is that we do not continuously think about things in the light of the Constitution. Sometimes political situations overpower us, sometimes immediate gains take precedence, and because of that, we politicize problems and fail to approach the fundamental systems that would work for centuries. And therefore, we should think about the heights of the members of the Constituent Assembly, take inspiration from them, and remember how much they thought. What pressures must have come, what biases must have been there, what completely opposite views must have been expressed; everything must have happened. But a document was created by consensus that continues to inspire us today, and therefore, whatever provisions we make, it becomes our responsibility to carry out this work. And in this, I give special importance to the Rajya Sabha; I give special importance to this upper house because it is said in our scriptures:

"That assembly is not where the elders are not present,

The elders are not those who do not speak of dharma.

Dharma is where there is no untruth,

Truth is not that which is accompanied by deceit."

In the Constituent Assembly, there cannot be a discussion in which there are no elders, where there is no dharma among the elders, where there is no truth; this is that assembly. And therefore, I believe the Rajya Sabha has its own significance. It has a special role, and I want to quote what Gopalaswami Ayyangar said in the debates of the Constituent Assembly: "Wherever there is any significant federal system in the world, the practical necessity of a second house has been felt. Overall, we are considering this to know whether everyone is a useful worker or not? Our expectation from the second house is perhaps only that it should conduct dignified debates on important issues and perhaps keep pending any law that arises as a result of momentary emotional outbursts until that emotion calms down and peaceful consideration is given to the measures that come before the legislature, and while making this provision in the Constitution, we must keep in mind that whenever there is a dispute between the Lok Sabha and the Rajya Sabha on any important issue, especially financial matters, the opinion of the Lok Sabha will be valid. Therefore, in the presence of this second house, we only obtain the means to delay that action which may have been initiated in haste and perhaps we want to give that experienced person an opportunity who may not be involved in deep political disputes but wants to participate in that debate with knowledge and significance, which we generally do not associate with the Lok Sabha. All these points are related to the second house. I believe that overall, after considering this, most people are in favor of creating such a house and ensuring that it does not become an obstacle in the way of law or administration," this is what Gopalaswami Ayyangar said in the Constituent Assembly. I believe there cannot be a greater guiding principle for the people of this House than this.

And Pandit Nehru made a very important point while expressing his views. He said, "The successful implementation of our Constitution, like any democratic structure, depends on mutual cooperation between the two houses, and therefore it becomes essential for us to figure out how we can work together to take this forward." And as I have already said in the scriptures, it is not an assembly in which experienced people are not included, and it is not the elders who do not speak of dharma, and it is not dharma in which truth is not spoken, and it is not truth that is accompanied by deceit and fraud. I believe this is extremely necessary for us.

In the same way, the country looks towards us. It is true that over time, we know what our condition is, what the condition of our community is. But it is also true that we still have some responsibilities, and fulfilling those responsibilities as a member, a lot has been said in our Constitution, but what our scriptures have said is equally important for us.

"Whatever the superior does, the common people follow that as a standard."

The conduct of superior people is followed by all. Whatever standards they set, people follow those standards.

Ambedkar ji quoted Edmund Burke in 1946, saying, "It is easy to give power; it is difficult to give wisdom." And I will read the entire translation. "It is easy to take power in hand; it is much harder to gain wisdom and prudence as a heritage. Let us prove through our conduct that if this assembly has given itself some universal powers, then the proper use of those powers will also be with wisdom and prudence. Only in this way can we move forward together. This is the only way to walk in the direction of unity."

Honorable Chairperson, our Constitution makers thought so much, but one thing they did not feel the need to think about, and what happened that we had to walk that path. It was not their fault. They had faith in us, and therefore they did not think in this direction, and then this House, whether it is the upper house or the Lok Sabha, we had to create an Ethics Committee. The members of the Constituent Assembly may not have felt it necessary to create an Ethics Committee. This House had to create an Ethics Committee. And I believe I am not criticizing anyone in this regard. We in politics also convey a message of our responsibilities. When some members here made minor mistakes, it is the courage of this House that they upheld the dignity of the House, but this is necessary. Chairperson, I will urge that it is necessary for all our members to be reminded repeatedly of the principles of the Ethics Committee that have been established; we must keep informing them because it is our responsibility that none of us make mistakes. But regarding this, I would like to say...

On August 14, 1947, Dr. Radhakrishnan said something that I believe is our responsibility. Dr. Radhakrishnan stated, "From the next morning after tonight, we cannot blame the British; we will be responsible for whatever we do. Free India will be judged by how the interests of the common man are fulfilled in matters related to food, clothing, housing, and social services. Until we eliminate the existing corruption at high positions, uproot nepotism, the desire for power, profiteering, and black marketing that has tarnished the image of this great country during times of defeat, we will not be able to enhance efficiency in administration, production, and the distribution of goods related to life." This is not a speech from December 1, 2015; this was Dr. Radhakrishnan's foresight on August 14, 1947, regarding the crises we would face. Therefore, it is essential for us to remember these great men and reflect on what has happened and what has been overlooked. We must remember again, resolve again, and move forward; it is not too late. In a country of 1.25 billion, with a population of 800 million under the age of 65, there is no reason for despair. We have the legacy of such great men and the potential of our youth. We need to look ahead to how we can combine both.

Sometimes, when we remember Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar, I want to say a few things about the Constitution, and it is true that our Constitution is not limited to just a legal framework. It is also a social document, and just as we appreciate its legal strength, we must also appreciate the power of its social document and demonstrate it in our lives; this is our duty.

The Constitution given to us by Babasaheb contains a legal framework that upholds the principle of equality, advocates for social justice, and discusses social justice. However, if we get stuck within the confines of the Constitution, equality may be achieved, but if society is not ready to change, if society does not resolve to free itself from centuries of evils, if we and our future generations do not prepare to atone for the sins committed by our ancestors, then the responsibility of fulfilling the power of social justice and equality, as envisioned by Babasaheb Ambedkar, will also fall upon us as a society.

Therefore, if the Constitution gives us the power of equality, the cultural river of society gives us the power of compassion. If equality is derived from the inherent powers of the Constitution, then society must also be prepared that just as equality is essential, so is compassion in society, and the country will progress where there is both equality and compassion; where there is both equality and empathy. The son born from the womb of a Dalit mother in this country of 1.25 billion is also my brother. The power that God has given me, the Supreme Being has given him the same power. I have had opportunities, but he has not. It is our duty to ensure he gets opportunities, and therefore, it is not just about the limits of the Constitution; societal awareness is equally essential. We need to move forward with the resolve of "No Hindu shall be downtrodden," and this should be raised in this house; this should reach the house. Even today, if someone faces such atrocities in society, it is a stain on us, a stain as a society, a stain as a nation. We must feel this pain and strive to awaken the sensitivity of society to this pain.

It is true that when we remember Sardar Patel, it is associated with the unity of India. But if we get stuck on the fact that Sardar Patel united the country, the conversation will not progress. The mantra of unity should be centered in a country like India. There can be many excuses for division, but it is our duty to seek opportunities for unity. Therefore, while there will be excuses for division, in a country of 1.25 billion, connections can be made from any corner. However, there are some people whose responsibility it is to find opportunities for unity even amidst excuses for division, to inspire people, and to empower them to unite; this is our duty. For the unity and integrity of the country, and this is what our ancestors said, "Rashtriyam Jagriyam Vyam." Eternal vigilance is the price of liberty. This is ingrained in our veins, and therefore, we must continuously promote the mantra of unity and integrity of the country.

I have a program in mind. I hope that those of you who think and have time will also provide some new ideas to make it better. "One India, Great India," this vision is running in my mind. I am leaving such thoughts; I have not yet designed anything. We have fought a lot in our country. The people in the south feel that Hindi is being imposed on them. And I have seen that it comes up in speeches here and there. But there is another way to understand the country, to know it, to move forward, and I mentioned this a little on October 31, the birth anniversary of Sardar Patel. Can we inspire the states? It will be urged that, for example, the state of Chhattisgarh decides that in 2016, we will celebrate Kerala Festival, and in the state of Chhattisgarh, children will be introduced to the Malayalam language's alphabets. 100 sentences, not more than that. How can we make it easy for children in schools, casually over tea... it will continue in a light-hearted manner, and they will learn. Why not have a Malayalam film festival in Chhattisgarh? Why not bring the cuisine, the people, and the drama from there here for people to see? Similarly, any other state can connect with another state for a year. The children who go as tourists from here that year will go to that state. If slowly all the states of India start celebrating one state every year and not more than one to five songs. Now see, we are all familiar with "Vaishnav Jan To Tene Kahiye." We are all familiar with it. When we hear and sing "Vaishnav Jan To Tene Kahiye," it does not feel foreign to us. We never remember in which language it was written. It has become so much a part of us. Why not instill the habit of singing four or five good songs from all the languages of our country in the new generation? We need to enhance our cultural values, and I believe that respecting the spirit of the Constitution, we should do this.

Babasaheb Ambedkar's economic thought had its characteristics, and he was in favor of industrialization. The most important thing he said was that I would like the house to understand my sentiment; I will not speak at length. Babasaheb Ambedkar used to say that industrialization is necessary in India, and he said that Dalits do not own land; they are not landowners. If we want to provide them with employment, where will those who do not have land go? Industrialization should also happen to create employment opportunities for the Dalits, the oppressed, the exploited, and the marginalized in society. Therefore, Babasaheb Ambedkar's thoughts may surprise some people today. What he said through economic thought, and I believe that the debates we have today will be guided by what Babasaheb thought at that time. Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar said, "It is the responsibility of the state to create an economic plan for the people that leads to high productivity, but in doing so, it should not close off other opportunities. Additionally, it should provide enterprises and ensure that whatever benefits are gained are distributed equally among all."

Dr. Babasaheb said, "Productivity in agriculture can be increased, but this will require an increase in capital and machinery, along with a reduction in labor in the agricultural sector, so that the productivity of land and labor can be enhanced. By placing excess labor in non-agricultural productive sectors, the pressure on the agricultural sector will be significantly reduced, and the excessive pressure on the available land in India will also be eliminated. Furthermore, when these workers are engaged in productive activities in agriculture and industry, they will not only earn their livelihood but will also produce more, and more production means more capital. In short, however strange it may seem, industrialization is the most effective remedy for India's agricultural problems." Babasaheb Ambedkar also said elsewhere that "India is caught between the two blades of a pair of tweezers. One blade is the growing pressure of the population, and the other blade is the limited availability of land compared to its needs. The result is that at the end of every decade, we face a negative balance of population and production, leading to a decline in the standard of living and an increase in poverty. The growing population is also resulting in a vast number of landless and fragmented families. Apart from launching a serious campaign in favor of industrialization, the possibilities of making agriculture profitable are negligible." Babasaheb Ambedkar presented to us 60 years ago the problems we would face, the struggles we would have to endure, and what our economic thought should be.

It is true that no one can doubt the patriotism of any of us, nor is there any reason to doubt the patriotism of 1.25 billion countrymen, and no one should have to provide evidence of their patriotism morning and evening. Society, we are all bound by the Constitution of India. We are all bound by the great values and traditions of India. How the world viewed us and how the world praised India, today when we think of those great men who created the Constitution, what kind of atmosphere must have prevailed for them to take such steps. I will conclude my remarks with a final word.

Honorable Chairman, I would like to quote Max Muller today; what did he say? Max Muller says, "If I were to look around the whole world for a country where nature has spread her wealth, power, and beauty in the most abundant measure, I would point to India as the real paradise on earth. If I were asked under which sky the human mind has developed some of its favorite gifts most completely, has deeply pondered the greatest problems of life, and has found solutions to some of them that would attract the attention of those who have read Plato and Kant, my answer would again point to India. If I were to ask myself from which literature, here in Europe, those who have been nurtured almost entirely on Greek and Roman, and Jewish thoughts can identify the true essence that is necessary for improving, expanding, and becoming a true human being, not only for this life but for this transformed and immortal life, my answer would again point to India."

This is what Max Muller said. We are rich in this great heritage. And that wealth of heritage is the strength of all of us. Let us celebrate it and resolve that in the light of the Constitution and the sacrifices and penance of our great men, we will move forward with what is best. What is temporal is not accepted by time; only what is eternal and new is accepted. With that eternal newness, we will all contribute to the building of a great nation.

Once again, I express my heartfelt gratitude to all the honorable members. Chairman, I also thank you, and in the light of the excellent points that have emerged from this discussion on the Constitution, we will build laws, conduct ourselves in Parliament, lead society, and strive to move society forward, carrying those same thoughts with the belief that I once again extend my heartfelt greetings to all the honorable members who have enriched this house with their excellent discourses. I pay my respects to Babasaheb Ambedkar and all those great individuals who worked alongside that great man.

Thank you very much.