Speech by Néstor Kirchner on changing the method of appointing judges

Argentina Néstor Kirchner · President of Argentina

16 June 2003

Context
Kirchner addressed Argentine officials and jurists on June 16, 2003, announcing a new transparent process for appointing Supreme Court justices.
Main themes
Supreme Court reform, institutional quality, judicial independence, reconciliation of politics and society, transparency in judicial appointments, democracy and rule of law, human rights commitment, republican values, social justice, state reform
Duration
~16 min
55th percentile
Words
1,921
55th percentile
Sentences
71
47th percentile
Readability
38
31st percentile
Grade
14.5
71st percentile
Syntax
3.19
71st percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
35th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 85%85%
  • Social 10%10%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

71 sentences in 43 paragraphs

Mr. Vice President of the Nation; Mr. President of the Honorable Chamber of Deputies of the Nation; Mr. Governor of the Province of Buenos Aires; Mr. Head of Government of the Autonomous City of Buenos Aires; Ministers of the National Executive Power; Secretaries and Undersecretaries; Legislators; Jurists and representatives of the Bar Association and academic entities, NGOs; ladies and gentlemen; citizens: we have maintained since the initial moment of our mandate that it is necessary in our Homeland to reconcile politics, institutions, and government with society.

We want to recover the values of solidarity and social justice that allow us to move towards a more balanced, more mature, more just society.

We have made a strong personal commitment to achieve an increase in institutional quality and thus forge a reconciliation between institutions and society. Institutional quality begins with each individual's adherence to the rules and the fulfillment of their roles by the institutions.

We want profound changes. We want to put an end to a way of managing the State and a way of doing politics. We want change, and we do not want that change to be reduced to the functional. We seek a deep and conceptual change.

Article 99, section 4 of the Constitution of the Argentine Nation grants the President of the Nation the authority to appoint the justices of the Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation, with the agreement of the Senate by two-thirds of the votes of its present members. Like the Constitution of other states, the system of our Constitution has opted to invest the President with such important political powers, leaving their exercise to their exclusive discretion, holding them politically accountable only to their people and ethically, to their own conscience.

This is an important political power that the popular origin of their election confers upon the President. It is also a great responsibility.

Since the then-President, General Bartolomé Mitre, established the first Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation in 1863, all Presidents have exercised that power personally. It has rightly been said that none of them shied away from the need to place judges identified with their political creed in it.

In the middle of the last century, the circumstance was added that each de facto institutional change and the subsequent lawful governments that replaced them shaped their Supreme Courts in their own way, adding to those constitutional powers the circumstance of producing the complete renewal of their members.

It is verifiable that at any point in our history, the Court has served as a political support element for the sitting president, so it has been maintained that in most cases, here and in other latitudes, the judges of the Court have remained loyal to those who appointed them.

Surely the sum of those practices and those constant interruptions of institutional life have much to do with the state of citizen perception regarding the Court.

We have said that our ideal is to provide a justice service close to the citizen from the State, with standards of performance, efficiency, and equity that guarantee real legal security for all the inhabitants of our Homeland, regardless of their economic and social condition.

Due to its role as a power of the State, due to its character as the governing body of Federal Justice, due to its function as the judicial branch of government, due to being the final interpreter of the Constitution, and due to its important role as a court of constitutional guarantees, the Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation needs to earn the trust of society for the solidity of its decisions.

There is no serious country where judicial decisions are not respected by the authority of the judges.

We are aware that choosing who should occupy a vacant position in the Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation, at a historical moment like the current one where change is essential, means something more than just trying to set a course for that institution of the Nation.

In circumstances like the current ones, it will imply a signal that will reach even the most hidden folds of the Republic, impacting multiple aspects of institutional and social life.

In the increase of institutional quality that we seek, the modality we choose to select the new members of the highest Court will play an important role.

That is why the old practices do not serve us. That is why it is necessary not to take into account the accustomed precedents at this point. It is necessary to open a new path that brings light to republican life and clears the relationships of institutions with society from distrust.

We have said and repeat that we are not interested in forming a subservient Supreme Court. We want to add that the only commitment we will require will be to the country. Commitment to the State. Commitment to Democracy. Commitment to the defense of human rights. Commitment to the Republic. Commitment to the Constitution.

And the way to be faithful to those words is to self-limit our own constitutional authority, always within the parameters of the Constitution itself and in a way that is not contrary to what it establishes.

It is not about evading the responsibility of proposing an appointment to the Senate of the Nation. It is not about diluting that responsibility in a collective responsibility.

It is about keeping in mind, when exercising that constitutional authority, not only the circumstances related to the composition of the current Body in terms of gender diversity, professional specialties, and regional and federal sense, but also, and centrally, the requirements related to moral integrity and technical suitability as well as the commitment to democracy and human rights.

We want to adopt a selection mechanism that, in its exercise, through its transparency and the participation of the citizen, of society, produces a certain increase in institutional quality to positively impact the credibility of the institution to which the magistrate must join.

We want that as presidential discretion decreases, the rights of citizens grow. We want to energize society's help to improve, to avoid mistakes, to set an example of how the future can be changed with everyone's commitment.

We self-limit our discretion to end the widespread practice of governments that, to obtain governability, need to forge subservient courts or fall into cryptic negotiations. We want to improve the selection system with the participation of citizens to try to enhance the Supreme Court as an institution.

We believe that with this first step taken towards improving institutional quality, others will take as many steps that will ultimately put those of us with institutional responsibilities in a position to offer the society we represent a better future.

The longest journey begins with a first step. Today we take this important step, knowing that we are starting a long irreversible journey as long as it is understood by society and the rest of those who can help to traverse it with the least possible trauma.

The transparency of the method we offer, the social control we want to be exercised regarding the exercise of this function that the Constitution entrusts to us, must culminate in the pre-selection of the one who best expresses these aspirations so that once in office and from their place of action, they can help achieve a result that approaches the serious country that the vast majority of society expects.

The repetition of this process as many times as vacancies occur in the Supreme Court must have the effect that society demands: institutions with the necessary degree of credibility to adequately fulfill the role that the Constitution of the Argentine Nation reserves for them.

This is how we want this gesture to be understood, devoid of any kind of grandiloquence, as important and simple is the contribution we intend. We are fully aware that this is no small matter. We know that at this point, the changes that must be made are not exhausted. It is a good beginning.

In the framework of preserving the good name and honor of those proposed, we seek to implement a mechanism that allows us to make a prudent assessment of their moral aptitudes, their technical and legal suitability, their trajectory, and their commitment to the defense of human rights and democratic values that make them worthy of such an important function.

To that end, within a maximum period of thirty days after a vacancy occurs, the name and curricular background of the person or persons decided to be put forward for consideration for the position will be published in the Official Gazette and in two national newspapers for three days and simultaneously on the website of the Ministry of Justice, Security, and Human Rights.

The proposed candidates must comply with the declaration required by the Law of Ethics of Public Function and another in which they will have the duty to express data that allows evaluating any type of commitment that may affect the impartiality of their judgment, as well as the probable existence of incompatibilities and conflicts of interest.

In a subsequent period of fifteen days, citizens in general, non-governmental organizations, professional associations, academic and human rights entities, may submit their positions, observations, or data they consider of interest in writing and in a reasoned and documented manner.

Of course, only imprudent or irrelevant objections to the pursued purpose, as well as those that imply any type of discrimination, will not be taken into account.

Without prejudice to the presentations made spontaneously, the Ministry may request opinions from relevant organizations in the professional, judicial, academic, social, political, and human rights fields to enrich the evaluation.

Additionally, the Federal Administration of Public Revenues will be required, observing the formalities and confidentiality that the law requires, regarding the compliance with tax obligations of the candidates.

After a period that cannot exceed another fifteen days, and taking into account the reasons that support the decision made, if it is positive, the respective appointment will be submitted to the Honorable Senate of the Nation along with the proceedings.

This is the simple and practical way we want to put into effect the principles in which we believe. It is along this path that we require the help and commitment of all citizens of the Argentine Republic.

This is how we seek to energize citizen participation to build the new institutional quality on which we want to lay the foundation for our future.

We know that it is the opening to profound moral change, which goes far beyond a simple instrumental change. We know that in its simplicity, it presents us with the challenge of altering deep structures of our collective behavior.

We trust in the capacity of the different social actors to act responsibly when the mechanism is put in place, with everyone helping to achieve the common goal of acting within the framework of our competencies to achieve a justice service like the one we need.

I thank you all for accepting our invitation today, as we are grateful to those who understand the profound meaning of the change we want to generate and to the society that, in its vast majority, we know will understand and support this change.

This is one of the dreams we want to propose to you. The dream of a different Argentina. The dream of a normal Argentina. A serious country awaits us at the end of the path we begin with this step we announce today. God will help us to make it happen.