Joint press conference of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, Mr. Hans-Gert Pöttering, President of the European Parliament, and Mr. José Manuel Barroso, President of the European Commission, on the European response to the international financial crisis and its implications for economic coordination within the European Union, in Strasbourg on October 21, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

21 October 2008 · Joint press conference on the European response to the international financial crisis

Context
Sarkozy addressed a joint press conference with EU Parliament and Commission presidents in Strasbourg on October 21, 2008, discussing Europe's response to the global financial crisis.
Main themes
European economic coordination, financial crisis response, Eurozone governance, sovereign wealth funds, economic crisis management, ECB independence, automotive industry support, strategic asset protection, Lisbon strategy, European unity
Duration
~50 min
94th percentile
Words
5,985
94th percentile
Sentences
355
96th percentile
Readability
64
93rd percentile
Grade
8.4
7th percentile
Syntax
2.82
24th percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
10th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

355 sentences in 45 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT - Listen, regarding economic governance, are we in favor of economic governance or coordination of economic policies? It doesn't matter. Since when has Europe been able to provide a coordinated response to the unprecedented financial crisis? When we gathered, with President BARROSO, President JUNCKER, and President TRICHET, all the heads of state and government of the Eurogroup, it was, as everyone observes, a turning point in this crisis. Will it be a sufficient turning point? We will see in the days and weeks to come, but it was a turning point. Why? Because suddenly, all the countries of the Eurogroup adopted, in the beautiful expression of Mrs. MERKEL, the toolbox, which allowed us to move in the same direction. This financial crisis is leading us to an economic crisis, no one disputes that. In the face of this economic crisis, do we or do we not need coordination? I say coordination echoing what my friend Hans-Gert said, because, in any case, the situation of our countries is not exactly the same. But do we need economic coordination in the crisis as we needed economic coordination in the financial crisis? My answer is clearly yes. What worked with the meeting of the heads of state and government of the Eurozone for the financial crisis, can it work for the economic crisis? My answer is yes. In any case, would Europeans accept that after Europe demonstrated its unity in the financial crisis, it shows its disunity in the economic crisis?

Once again, this does not mean that everyone does the same thing. It does not mean opening the floodgates of spending but, at least, that we talk together, that is the question I wanted to raise. Moreover, speaking under the control of José-Manuel BARROSO, one of the most interesting moments of the Eurogroup was the high-quality discussion that occupied us, the President of the ECB, Mr. TRICHET, the heads of state and government, and the President of the Commission. It was fascinating. I want to pay tribute to Mr. TRICHET in this crisis, and I do not think that the fact that he discussed with the heads of state and government has, in the least, weakened the independence or legitimacy of the ECB, quite the contrary. It allowed us, heads of state and government, to better understand what was happening, why it was happening, how it was happening. You know, my astonishment is to know that it was the first time. I said to myself: but, after all, we have the same currency, we have the same bank, we had never met. So, if it worked, why not continue.

Now, regarding the sovereign fund, it is a proposal, it is an idea. What is happening today in Europe? Stock markets are falling, meaning that the value of a number of our companies is, for some of them, 30% of what it was six months ago. I was looking at one of the largest French companies among the most successful, EDF. It lost nearly 30% of its value in one day because a minister from a European government said that the rules of energy market regulation needed to be changed, it doesn't matter. But did EDF lose 30% of its value? It is absurd. And we have a number of large French and European groups whose value today, at market price, is a third of what it was six months ago. However, there are sovereign funds in the world with considerable means. Should we not reflect, during the crisis period, on the usefulness of establishing sovereign funds ourselves, which would allow us to defend national and European interests, by taking advantage, by the way, of cheap money, to acquire strategic assets that are themselves depreciated while the crisis passes, until prices return to a normal level and at that moment, we put back on the market the shares we would have acquired at a certain time? And, would what one country does not have even more strength if other countries did it? And, if other countries did it, would the coordination of the action of these funds on companies that are themselves European not be useful? And who could blame me for suggesting we think about this? I do not want to impose anything: it is an idea, there are many others.

The automotive industry, in France, with the dealers, represents 10% of the active population. Who could blame me for asking the question to the President of the Commission who is working on this? How, while respecting competition, respecting the market, respecting state aid, the regime of state aid, can we not ask the question: How to help our industrialists modernize to produce better, cleaner? Is this a national decision or is Europe concerned about this?

I believe that the crisis is an opportunity to rethink our way of building Europe to be more effective. This does not mean emptying the coffers, some of which, by the way, are not very full. This does not mean stimulating the economy by distributing money that we do not have. But the Lisbon strategy was to invest in research, in investment, in strategic areas. Does this not deserve at least that we talk about it among ourselves? While leaving the responsibility of each in their country to build a coordinated response, if not a global one. There you go, sorry, I have been too long, but this is really what I have in mind.

I think, to conclude, and that is why I am quite optimistic about the future of Europe, that after this crisis, Europe will be different and that is a good thing. And I do not believe that we will be able to govern, lead, embody Europe after the crisis as we did before. In any case, I will not be one of those who will allow bad habits to return. In Europe, we have become accustomed to ambition and unity, to determination. I hope that this continues.

Mr. BARROSO - The question of economic coordination is an old question. And we, the European Commission, have long sought to support the idea of coordinating economic policy. You remember when there was the debate on Lisbon, particularly the revision of Lisbon, after the KOK report. There was very strong opposition from some member states to any kind of collective exercises. At that time, we had a great discussion: whether it was possible or not to even have a binding system for the coordination of economic policies under Lisbon. Clearly, the member states were not prepared for that. We have made some important progress. I believe it is the first time in economic history that 27 countries have agreed to present national reform programs. There is a certain collective exercise of accompaniment, so there are already some mechanisms of articulation, and here, I also agree with President SARKOZY, it is really very little, compared to the scale of the challenges we have now.

It is true that for these debates on economic coordination, I am, as always, very frank, I like the frankness, the policy of President SARKOZY. Very often, the rhetoric on economic governance was perceived, perhaps wrongly, as an idea to put the Central Bank in the pocket. That is not the case now. You all heard the very clear statements of President SARKOZY again today, in the plenary session, on the independence of the Central Bank, and there, I believe it is fundamental to guarantee this aspect. But, of course, nothing prevents the Central Bank from discussing not only with finance ministers, as it does in the Eurogroup, but also with heads of state and government when there is a meeting, like the one - it was a great success - in Paris.

So, let’s be clear, I speak to you on behalf of the European Commission. We are in favor of strengthening all mechanisms for coordinating the economic policies of Europe, of European states. At the same time, I believe we should not create the illusion that would be, in my opinion, very dangerous, of giving instructions to the Central Bank or questioning the independence of the Central Bank, also questioning the acquis communautaire, the Treaty of Rome, and all our achievements.

And there, that is the answer to the second question. We need the internal market, it is not a question of dogma of the Commission, a doctrine, it is in our idea. Why? Because our great strength in Europe is precisely that a small business, in France, Germany, Portugal, Ireland, Poland, has access to the entire market. Therefore, the Commission, the message on which it insists a lot - it is a very interesting point in the debate in Paris with the European Central Bank, with heads of state and government - the Commission is, in principle, in favor of all measures to support industry, the economy, employment, growth, if these measures are not discriminatory, if they do not undermine the internal market. And not because we are dogmatists of competition, not at all, but because we are convinced Europeans. We must not undermine this system that we have, and that is the problem. Sometimes, we must see how to find concrete solutions. The question of sovereign funds is very interesting, the opinion, the idea of President SARKOZY. But look, I just saw that today, Italy announced some measures to restrict investment, but Spain has made a call for investments from Arab sovereign funds for Spanish public debt funds. It is very curious, isn’t it? There are now European countries that are asking non-European sovereign funds to invest, and the truth is that we know that there are several banks that are now in difficulty asking these sovereign funds to invest. That is why this is an extremely complex subject where I call for a discussion between the member states and the Commission, of course, and all European institutions, the Parliament, on this issue. We already know this debate.

Excuse me for being a bit long, but it is a really very difficult question with a technical part. In the energy internal market package, you have undoubtedly noticed that the Commission proposed a clause that we called the Gazprom clause. But it was not against Gazprom; it was a clause that was a reciprocity clause, meaning that we would have the right to refuse investments coming from third countries if those third countries did not accept the same investment rules for European companies. And you saw how the debate was. Very curiously, some who were originally behind this idea ended up being against it. And the truth is that this clause was very nuanced in the debate, and we have already obtained an agreement at the Council level on this energy internal market package. So, it is a very complicated subject, and we cannot give the impression that we are, in principle, against sovereign funds. There are sovereign funds that may also be interesting. At the same time, I am absolutely sensitive to the argument that President SARKOZY just presented and that some heads of state and government have already posed to me. What do we do if, now, there are attacks - let’s say predators - on our economies? I believe that at least we could agree that we do not have agreements with investments that are determined by reasons other than economic or commercial. Because that could also happen, but we need to find some rules, if possible common ones, because if there are no common rules, what is the risk? There is the risk precisely, as President SARKOZY said earlier in the plenary session, that capital flows seek the best places. There will be the introduction of competitive disadvantages within the single market itself, and that is a problem.

So, it is a whole subject, a fascinating subject, and we, at the Commission, are ready to discuss it very constructively with, of course, the French Presidency but also with all the member states, showing you that our problem and our goal are to guarantee in all these adaptations that we must make, the preservation of the acquis communautaire so as not to undermine everything that is really the achievement of the internal market, which is truly an extraordinary source of growth and wealth. That said, we are convinced by our own analysis that the rules, as they are, allow, if there is flexibility, if there is common sense, the necessary level of elasticity to integrate many of these ideas into a perspective, that which interests us, the defense of European interest.

QUESTION - By emphasizing the need for an initiative on sovereign funds, are you not abandoning the idea that we need to protect ourselves against foreign sovereign funds? Because the initial idea was rather that sovereign funds are a threat and that we need to protect ourselves. Do you still consider sovereign funds to be a threat and that we need to protect ourselves from them? Regarding the economic governance of the euro area, you mentioned that the format of the finance ministers' meetings was not sufficient and that perhaps we should move to another format and renew the exercise you conducted in Paris two weeks ago? Are you considering institutionalizing this type of meeting and, if so, organizing it once a year at what frequency?

THE PRESIDENT - First of all, I do not consider sovereign funds to be a threat, and secondly, my vision of Europe is not a defensive one. And finally, I think it is difficult to distinguish between those who come for economic reasons and those who come for political reasons because very few will say, "We are coming for political reasons." They will all put forward an economic interest. And why not? I am in favor of free trade, I support the flow of investments, but I want a Europe that is not simply defensive. It is not about establishing a Maginot Line. It is about taking into account a pragmatic situation. Markets are depressed. The stock market does not have much significance today; it is erratic, as they say. Should we draw conclusions from this or not, especially if it were to persist? My answer is yes. What is the best way to prepare for the future? I have already done it—not in the form of a sovereign fund, but what I did with Alstom in 2004, after a famous discussion with Mr. MONTI, was what if not to have the State play its role as a regulator at a certain moment? And then, the State sold. We had bought back 20% of Alstom for 800 million; the government sold those same 20% for 2.5 billion two years later. This means that good deals can be made, even when one is a finance minister. It is not forbidden. So why not do it? Why not discuss it? Why, today, should we not ask this question of offensive strategy?

Regarding the Eurogroup: frankly, a meeting every 8 years was reasonable; it does not tire one too much! Should we then move to a meeting once a year? I do not know. I am in favor of a more pragmatic solution. I think it all depends on the analysis we make of the severity of the economic crisis. The heads of state and government of the euro area have analyzed the financial crisis as serious. They said to themselves, "It is serious; we must therefore take care of it; we must step up." By the way, who thinks that only finance ministers could mobilize 1.8 trillion euros? If we think that the economic crisis is not serious, that it will sort itself out, that we do not need to take care of it, there is no need for a new Eurogroup meeting with heads of state and government. If, on the contrary, we think that after the financial crisis, or during the financial crisis, we have a strong economic crisis, it is rather interesting that we talk, if only to do some benchmarking. What are you doing at home? What am I doing at home? How can we harmonize things when we are all so integrated into the European economy? But what a strange idea, nonetheless, to think that we can have a single central bank, a single currency, a single market, and that talking about economic policy is not good? Honestly, it is still a curious idea. All of this with a European skepticism that must be fought. But not by saying that it is not good to be for Europe; it must be fought by drawing conclusions from this skepticism to act differently, and I believe that Europeans, at this moment, understand that Europe matters. But we must draw the consequences. And I think that is extremely important.

I mentioned it earlier regarding competition. I am very attached to competition and free trade. It is not an end in itself. Competition is a means, a means to create wealth, to lower prices, to benefit the consumer. It is not a religion. I add that all these rules must also be discussed by the legitimate authorities of the States. It is not because one is elected that one should not have ideas. I believe that being elected does not deprive one of having ideas and convictions. I have always been in favor of the independence of national central banks and the European Central Bank. But I say that the debate is useful, very useful.

QUESTION - Can you give us concrete examples of the overhaul of the financial architecture on a global basis, concrete examples? And then, if China and India participate in this global summit, would these countries be partners on an equal footing or merely guests?

THE PRESIDENT - You know that I have long thought that the G8 format is insufficient. I advocate for a G13, and who can think that we can invite China and India, two billion three hundred million inhabitants, without giving them the right to speak, with a folding chair? China and India! I think they must be invited as essential and indispensable partners of the international summit that, together with President BARROSO, we have called for. It is so obvious! China is today a monetary power, a capital power in terms of the availability of its funds, an economic power. As for India, in 30 years it will be the most populous country in the world. It is normal to associate them with the rebuilding of the system.

Three very quick examples: the remuneration of operators in trading rooms. This remuneration, made through bonuses, has pushed a number of these operators to take reckless risks. Can we imagine a reflection on how operators in trading rooms are compensated? Secondly, tax havens. Would it be normal for a bank that benefits from the guarantee of a State or from the equity of a State to continue working with a tax haven? Who could accept that? Thirdly, hedge funds that have raised billions of dollars in recent years are not subject to any supervisory rules, no control, no prudential rules. Can we continue like this? Because they, when they made a lot of money, when they made fortunes, did not ask us to share. Now that they have led us, among other things, to catastrophe, we would not have the right to ask questions? These are three examples among others. There are many others that I could present before you, and I am sure that on these points—this is what we defended with President BARROSO and President BUSH—we can reach a consensus.

QUESTION - Excuse me for returning to the format. In Paris, there was indeed Mr. BROWN who attended this meeting. I would like to know if this can become a norm during the crisis. If so, when should the Eurogroup meet a second time, or a third, or a fourth, or was this an exceptional exception? And, still on the same subject, I would like to know if your proposal on the G8 expanded to the G5 can also include exceptions given that the Spanish Prime Minister had specifically requested to be present and that Mr. BROWN had supported him? Do you exclude this possibility?

THE PRESIDENT - Regarding the Eurogroup, I will not prolong the discussion. As President of the Council, I must convene the 27. But, after all, there is a specificity for those who share the same currency. We cannot blame them for that. So, we will see, for example, how we should prepare for the international summit. Should we prepare it by having just the four Europeans, members of the G8, by having the euro area, or by having the 27? We will discuss it. I think everyone has a say.

Regarding Spain. Spain has played a significant role, and Mr. ZAPATERO first, since he was the one who proposed the Eurogroup meeting at a lunch in Paris. A meeting, of course, that Mr. BARROSO and I accepted.

Now, it is not me who decides the members of the G8. It is not by my merit that France is in the G8. I found this situation there. Regarding the G8, concerning Spain's place, which has made significant progress this year, we can indeed hope that in the long term, Spain, which is a great nation, a great economy, takes its rightful place. But it is not solely up to me to decide. You know that perfectly well. Then, there would be the problem of Poland and its 38 million inhabitants... It is not about redoing everything that exists; it is simply about finding the most suitable forums. I add that with President BARROSO, we proposed that the Secretary-General of the United Nations, Mr. BAN KI-MOON, that the President of the World Bank, and that the Managing Director of the IMF be present.

Depending on the number of summits we will hold—because we have agreed that there will be several, particularly one on global governance—it will be a matter of seeing how to expand the circle because it is, of course, about starting from monetary and financial regulation, perhaps even fiscal, to move towards a new global governance. At that moment, the more numerous we are, the more legitimacy we will have to decide. What was important was to launch the process.

QUESTION - You wish to rely on the Eurogroup for European economic governance. It happens that the Eurogroup has been chaired for many years—indeed, it has been renewed—by Jean-Claude JUNCKER. There was an important meeting in Paris this morning on tax havens. Luxembourg did not wish to attend this meeting. Is there not a problem? Is there not, more broadly, a problem surrounding Luxembourg or perhaps Mr. JUNCKER?

THE PRESIDENT - I cannot speak ill of Mr. JUNCKER. First, because I do not think so. Secondly, because at the time when I was Minister of Finance, in 2004, Mr. PÖTTERING, as Mr. BARROSO certainly remembers, we decided to elect a President of the Eurogroup finance ministers for 2 and a half years. We could do this because the Eurogroup, not being an institution in the sense that it is not provided for in the Treaties, had more flexibility to adapt its organization.

As for the rest, I refer you to the answer I gave to Mr. GOEBBELS, a socialist, himself Luxembourgish, who called on me not to remain in plumbing and to do architecture. He himself being well placed to know that there can be, in Europe, countries more or less willing to ensure transparency and impose regulation. In any case, I completely agree with what Ms. DE SARNEZ said. We will have no credibility if we ask others, outside of Europe, to respect rules that we would not be willing to respect in Europe. That goes without saying. But there is no reason to believe that Mr. JUNCKER would be against this evolution. It is not possible. We cannot demand transparency from others and not apply it to ourselves. So we must be clear that these rules will apply to us. And I have understood that now we are associated: the French State, the Luxembourg State, and the Belgian State—we have this pleasure. This will be an opportunity to discuss all of this, and I look forward to it.

QUESTION - A short question to the President of the Commission, José Manuel BARROSO. You love frankness. Tell us really if for Commissioner MAC GREEVY, who we see less and less, who has always been a proponent of self-regulation by banks, who has always refused any regulation for hedge funds—still not very long ago, it seems to me, three weeks ago—you think he is still credible today to lead the internal market of financial sectors, or is it rather Commissioner ALMUNIA who is most often seen on this subject and who seems the most suitable? And, if I may, a small question for President SARKOZY. The Eurogroup meeting chaired by JUNCKER in March 2009, is that the next one at the level of heads of state?

MR. BARROSO - Regarding the question you are asking me, frankly, if you want a scapegoat! To say that the responsibility for this crisis lies with one commissioner. Listen, don’t count on me. Frankly, I find that it is neither politically nor intellectually honest. This crisis was born in the United States. There were very serious structural problems. It is true that in Europe we also have some regulatory failures. In any case, already in this Commission we have presented 32 legislative measures that have been adopted either by co-decision or by comitology in the area of financial services. All of this only since the beginning of this Commission. So, by the end of 2004, among these initiatives, 19 were approved by co-decision. It is true that one can always criticize. We are not perfect. I am not saying that we have done everything or that all the members of the Commission have done everything. I am not saying that. It would not be honest of me. Sometimes, I too discuss with my commissioners: what more can we do? Is that true?

That said, I find that some criticisms directed at Commissioner MAC GREEVY are absolutely exaggerated. It is true that he is not the most popular in the European Parliament, I know that well. But I believe that if we want to conduct a truly honest review, then we must ask the member states what they have done and the different governments.

I said it earlier, perhaps you were already in the press room. But I said it in the plenary session. A few months ago, I myself asked the member states: are you ready for regulation of credit rating agencies? The answer: "no." It was not possible; the commissioner was not the problem.

Even a few weeks ago, the change in accounting rules, and President SARKOZY knows this well. Some member states did not even want to hear about it. It was not the commissioner.

For many other initiatives, I find that in this area we must move forward together. But, listen, the right of initiative belongs to the Commission. That is true, but financial services are not like other areas. In financial services, I fear that there is what is called an empty announcement effect. I believe that this is bad.

If, in the midst of a crisis, the Commission were to come forward with certain proposals knowing that some of the member states, among the most important in financial and economic terms, would immediately say no, do you think it would be good for Europe to have this fracture? That is why we must see the right moments to act. I can tell you, in any case, that the Commission, as a whole - of course, you understand that I must defend the Commission as a whole - is always in favor of a European approach and included in the areas of financial services regulation.

But it must be done with an agreement with the member states. Otherwise, it does not work. This is very important. I can tell you again, at the beginning of this crisis I wrote an article that I published in several European countries. In France, it was not your newspaper but Le Figaro. In Germany, Handelsblatt, in Spain, El País, in Italy, La Repubblica, you saw it. I called for a European dimension. I can tell you that some governments said: "But why are you advocating for a European approach? Each can solve the problem for themselves. A European approach is not necessary." That is the question.

That is why I told the European Parliament earlier that now we have a crisis that has opened minds. There is now a potential change; let us use it fully. And there, I am completely supportive of President SARKOZY's efforts. But frankly, I do not believe it is honest to - even if sometimes we may agree or not with him - hold a commissioner responsible for this crisis who, by the way, I will tell you is not an ideologue, he is a pragmatic man, perhaps too pragmatic, you might say. But he is a pragmatic man. I believe we must work. My duty, as President of the Commission, is to work with all the commissioners, with the college of commissioners. Understanding, of course, that the commissioner and the college represent a large coalition. We have socialists, liberals, Christian democrats, conservatives. And we must find a consensus. I believe I can say, and I say that the problem was not the Commission. The Commission, especially in this crisis, is proud of the work it has done. Of course, I want to say it is not the Commission that can deliver the states, that can make the states. That is why we need a strong Presidency of the Council. I do not say this to be courteous to President SARKOZY, for whom, you know, I have great admiration, a sincere friendship.

But we also need a strong Presidency. That is why I think this crisis has highlighted the need, once again, for the Lisbon Treaty to have a stable Presidency. But do not ask the Commission; the Commission cannot give. The Commission does its work, honestly, certainly not perfectly, but there must also be a minimum of willingness from the member states, from our governments, to move forward on certain projects.

THE PRESIDENT - What has surprised me since I became President of the Council? It is not the difficulty of getting support because, after all, we have it much more easily than we think. What has surprised me is a system that has become so rigid in its way of thinking that any new idea is, a priori, labeled as controversial. While the world is changing. We have changed centuries. That the crisis does not resemble any of the crises we have known and that the continents that will emerge from it are the continents that will show youth of spirit, imagination, innovation, research, and novelty. And, as soon as we say something, really, it’s everyone to the shelters!

I want to say that, from the beginning with President BARROSO, we have worked hand in hand and I want to sincerely pay tribute to him because he has, each time, beyond the responsibilities that are his, wanted to accompany, to help, this movement of renewal. Look: the Union for the Mediterranean: when I think that to create such a beautiful idea, it took so much effort... It’s extravagant, it’s extraordinary! I was accused of wanting to undermine Europe because I wanted a Union for the Mediterranean. One wonders where such ideas come from! You told President BARROSO that he hated jargon; you could have told me that. But we worked together and it was a success.

The same goes for Georgia and Russia: all the community habits should have led us to stay quietly there, to have a nice little European Council but respecting tradition. We do not meet in August! It is not done. Really, there is an unwritten rule and it is all the more serious because it is not written! On the grand tableau of great Europeans, there is no meeting in August. Why no meeting in August? One really wonders... On the financial crisis, when I proposed the meeting with four Europeans from the G8: a crime of lèse-majesté! Is this man really European who thinks that Germany, in financial matters, counts more than... I forgot which other European country... and that, perhaps, it will be easier to agree at 27 if the four largest have already started the discussion.

All the ideas I propose, everything we try to do with José Manuel, is not to impose a truth, not for France to show arrogance or to give lessons to anyone; it is because when you are President of the European Council for six months, it is an honor, it is a responsibility: we must move the system, we must advance it. We must try to find the answers for tomorrow, not the answers from yesterday.

I think, like José Manuel, that it is not good to choose a scapegoat. But it is also not good that those who could be scapegoats do not understand that we have changed worlds. I deeply believe this; I have always thought so, and I find it very unfair sometimes that it is said: he is for a European policy, therefore he is for the deficit. He is for an economic government, therefore he is against the independence of the Central Bank. I tell you, I tell my German friends: I am deeply convinced of the necessity of the independence of the Central Bank. I am deeply convinced that deficits will bring nothing, and I see all the progress we have to make in France. But I deeply believe in a European ideal that cannot be expressed as it was expressed 50 years ago. It is not possible.

Would Jean-Claude make a good President of the Eurogroup? Of course! Why not? We will have to elect him. Since the President of the Eurogroup, of which I have been a part, is the President of the Finance Ministers. Will it be necessary, sooner or later, to express this at the level of heads of state and government? It is up to them to decide.

I think we cannot continue for another eight years without meeting the Eurogroup at the level of heads of government and heads of state. I think that is not reasonable. So then, is there a need for a President or not? It doesn’t matter. Jean-Claude JUNCKER could very well do both. He is a man of great quality for whom I have a lot of respect and friendship. But I will tell you one thing: I have tried to create, with José Manuel BARROSO, the unity of Europe. I will not let that be undone. I have tried to promote a Europe - and, with Hans-Gert, we have talked a lot about this, we have made a path towards each other sometimes to be in agreement - I claim his term of social market economy. But I will not let the ambition of a proactive Europe be rolled back. Because that, I can be reproached for many things, but not for not having been a President of the Council who wanted to promote the unity of Europe and the ambition of Europe. I assure you: I believe that this crisis is the opportunity to change behaviors. And then, in eight months we have European elections. We need a Europe that protects, a Europe that embodies something. And I think that Europe is reconciling with Europeans in this crisis because Europeans see well that, together, we are stronger than alone.

Thank you all.